All Episodes

April 14, 2026 16 mins

After 5 days in Bahamian police custody, 58-year-old Brian Hooker is a free man. His wife, Lynette remains missing after he claims she fell overboard from their 8 foot dinghy in rough seas. News outlets have revealed text messages where Lynette described a rocky relationship, saying she “can’t be out there with him” referring to boating with Brian. Despite suggestions of foul play from Lynette’s daughter and friends of the couple, authorities say they don’t have enough evidence for charges, however, Brian Hooker remains a suspect as the search continues for Lynette.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Listen
Watch
Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
Hey, folks, it is Tuesday, April fourteenth, and he said
his wife fell off their boat more than a week ago.

Speaker 2 (00:11):
She's been missing ever since.

Speaker 1 (00:14):
He has been held by police for the past several days,
but he is sticking to his story and for right now,
police don't have another story to go with, and that's
why he has walked out of jail.

Speaker 2 (00:27):
Now.

Speaker 1 (00:27):
With that, welcome to this episode of Amy and TJ.
With the clock was ticking, deadline was approaching, they had
to either charge Brian Hooker or release him. And Brian
Hooker has been released now rose by Behaman authorities without
chargers in the disappearance of his wife.

Speaker 3 (00:42):
That's correct. He was detained for a full five days
since last Wednesday. He was questioned for more than three
hours on Friday, and his attorney said he was questioned
again on Monday the same line of questionings. But Brian
Hooker is sticking with his story and there is no
evidence proving otherwise, according to his attorney, and that is

(01:04):
why police were forced to release him. They kept pushing
the goalpost. First it was forty eight hours. Then they
said we're going to extend it to I believe ninety
six hours. But by law, they had to release him
if they couldn't charge him, and so they claim he
is still a suspect, but he is out of custody.

Speaker 1 (01:26):
This is one of those cases, Robes. It doesn't matter
how bad it might look into the public. It doesn't
matter how many much the headlines are working against you.
It does not matter how much people are talking about
you on social media and thinking you are behind the
disappearance of your wife. It does not matter if they
can't prove it. And Robes, we talked about this from
the very beginning. What can they prove if they do

(01:46):
not have this woman's body. All they have is his
story she fell out, They robes clearly at this point
can't prove anything otherwise. Are we only waiting to see
if they recover her body and that's the only chance
of charges here?

Speaker 3 (02:02):
It seems like that is a possibility, because yes, they
still have not found the body of Lynnette Hooker despite
massive aerial and water searches. She is nowhere to be found.
He claims he wants her body to found to be found.
He claims he wants that for his own closure as well.
He didn't respond, by the way, to reporters questions, says

(02:23):
he was leaving the police station. Of course, can you
imagine the scene We've been there as reporters shouting at him.
He didn't say a word. His attorney did come back
and tell reporters that her client was very emotional and
that he needed time to de stress from this horrible experience.
That's the only word we heard directly from his attorney

(02:44):
upon his release last night. But you can only imagine
the folks who are going to be clamoring to get
to speak to him. I'm sure they know where he's staying.
His hell is still, he's in the midst of it.

Speaker 1 (02:58):
This isn't over for him to be quiet for a while,
because they are still looking at the possibility of charging
him with something if they can't. The official statement we
got from Behamian authorities yesterday did not say much, but
they did let us.

Speaker 2 (03:10):
Know he was being released. They were letting us know
why enrolled.

Speaker 1 (03:13):
I guess we get an indication of this search not
necessarily is over. It is a search and recovery. But
until in otherwise they find her body, don't know how
they can move forward. But this was the official statement
we did get from Behamian authorities about the release of
Brian Hooker.

Speaker 3 (03:27):
Yes, the decision to release the individual was made following
consultation with the Department of Public Prosecutions, which recommended that
no charges be filed at this time, pending the outcome
of further investigations, and the police commissioner specifically told the
press that Brian Hooker remains a suspect in this case.

(03:49):
The investigation is ongoing, and look, yes, they need or
at least they're hoping to find Lynnette Hooker's body, but
they also did take some items from their boat, and
it looks like it didn't prove to be fruitful. So
they had a search warrant looking at his video recorders,
digital tablets, cell phones, related accessories, and they were hoping

(04:13):
that it could be evidence to point maybe to premeditation
or some sort of direction as to how why if
he planned it. Nothing. Obviously, if anything had come from
those devices, they would have been able to hold him
and actually charge him. So that is of note that
so far, at least nothing found on those devices led

(04:35):
police to be able to charge him. But there are
some text messages that we're hearing about, and these are
from Lynette with her friend and they were from January
of twenty twenty four to February of twenty twenty four,
and this speaks to what we have been hearing a
lot about their relationship before leading up to her disappearance.

(04:59):
And so we have some of those text messages where
she was talking with a friend that they met through
sailing about their marriage being over. She said, I guess
it was just too much closeness. We decided to call
it quits. I'm not going back, she said. She was heartbroken,
considering I quit my awesome career, sold my house and
gave away everything I owned to cruise. Slapping my head stupid.

(05:23):
Here's the really interesting text that Lynette sent her friend.
We were married twenty one years, our marriage lasted six
weeks cruising, and when her friend asked her if there
was any possible way they could reconcile, not at this time.
It was real bad. I can't be out there with him.

(05:43):
That last sentence, I can't be out there with them
is certainly haunting given the fact that now Lynette Hooker
is missing.

Speaker 2 (05:53):
I mean, it could be completely irrelevant.

Speaker 1 (05:54):
Anybody in a relationship, a long term one and maybe
their second or whatever marriage, they will go through all
kinds of strife. Now you're taking that into context of
her being missing. Now, yes, that can mean a lot,
But I get it, and I get why those things
are out there. I get why CBS is reporting that,
But that to me, if she were not missing, wouldn't
raise alarm bells. That if she were not missing sounds

(06:17):
like a couple doing there back and forth. I understand
just in how that language sounds. I can't be out
there with him. It sounded like these two people got
along just fine, but forever reason they their personalities clashed
when it came to voting to being out on the
water together. And don't know exactly why, but yeah, I
see why people would take that and maybe want to

(06:38):
run with it.

Speaker 3 (06:38):
You make a good point. I mean, think about how
many marriages could handle being in those types of close
quarters where there's a lot of stress about making sure
when you're voting. That's a high stress environment. So now
you've got two people, even if you've been married for
twenty one years, if y'all were used to having separate careers,
separate lives, now all of a sudden boom, you're up

(07:00):
on each other twenty four hours a day, seven days
a week in a fairly stressful situation that could question
or challenge a lot of people's marriages. So yes, you
could look at it through that lens as well.

Speaker 1 (07:11):
Well well yeah, but people are wanting to and I
get it, And look we are here because I guess
we're ten days removed from this incident, and the story
being that they were out on their dinghy this April fourth.
It wasn't quite sundown, it wasn't quite dark, but he
just claims thore we some bumpy seas and she bumped
and bounced, I believe is the word right off of

(07:32):
that dinghy on April fourth. And this is where robes
this from that beginning where the story gets a little questionable,
and we're not the ones questioning it is Lynnette's daughter
and also Brian's friends who are questioning his account. But
why is it she goes into the water and has
the key in her pocket. Nobody can make sense of that.
How does she get separated from him so quickly that

(07:54):
he couldn't reach out to get her. He had an
or which he could paddle back to shore, but you
couldn't paddle the direction of your wife who had just
gone into the water. She was a good swimmer, so
you're telling me she can't manage for just a moment
to get back onto this boat. His claim is also
that she started swimming towards their yacht and not back
towards the dinghy. That doesn't make sense. But if she

(08:14):
could go towards the yacht, why wouldn't he go towards
the yacht. None of this makes sense. That is the story.
But Rose, you can't. It's always just a matter of
what you can prove. And we're sitting here now talking
about text messages and all. This really started bubbling and
rose to the level because the daughter robes. I don't
think if the daughter had not come out and spoke
as strongly as she had in questioning she stopped just

(08:37):
short of calling her stepdad a killer, but she went
a long way, and I think probably Behamian authorities listened
to her and it raised a bunch of alarm bells,
and she might have pushed this whole story forward.

Speaker 3 (08:51):
Oh absolutely. She made an impassioned plea not only to
police but to the members of the media, asking for
an investigation. And that is what it looks like the
Behamian authorities did. And by the way. The US Coast
Guard heavily involved in this investigation as well, so they
were assisting the Behamian police. And look, I say assisting
as if it's over, it's not over. That's a really

(09:12):
important point. And the officials when announcing Brian Hooker's release,
made it very clear that this investigation is not over,
that it continues. They just weren't able to hold him
any longer. Not sure yet if there are any restrictions
about whether or not he can leave the Bahamas. His
attorney hasn't given any details as of that yet, but
certainly I did.

Speaker 2 (09:33):
See that, Oh you did.

Speaker 1 (09:33):
Okay, the attorney said, he's free to look, believe my goodness,
free to go. That's at least what is attorney flat
out told the reporters. He is a at this point,
a free man, free to do whatever the hell.

Speaker 3 (09:45):
He wants to do, my goodness, So.

Speaker 2 (09:47):
Yeah, he leaves, how they going to get him back?
And who's handling this investigation?

Speaker 3 (09:53):
The US Coast Guard is holding So that is my question.
Can they still charge him even if he's back in Florida,
back in the States. But as he had pointed out
so tearfully and certainly said to his friends, and we've
heard him before he stopped talking to the press, saying
that all he wanted to do even when he was
in custody. His attorney told reporters all he wanted to
do was assist in the search for his wife. So

(10:15):
if he were to head back to the States, probably
not a good look. But we were saying regardless, even
if charges are never brought against this man, this is
somebody who is always going to have the shadow of,
or at least the suspicion of being involved in his
wife's disappearance.

Speaker 1 (10:32):
Any might have had absolutely nothing to do with it,
and this was the accident that he describes. But I
will listen to his daughter. I will listen to his
friend who suggests, as people who know him and know
that relationship, that this is not right and this something
is wrong, not just from their history, but in the
actual story that.

Speaker 2 (10:54):
Is being told. They said this, none of this adds up.

Speaker 3 (10:57):
That's correct, But in the story that he's told. When
we come back, we're going to tell you what Brian
Hooker sent to his friends and to fellow voters that
he claims will back up his story of what happened
that night when his wife fell Overboord and welcome back

(11:26):
everyone to this episode of Amy and TJ. Brian Hooker
the man who has been held, been questioned for hours
and been in custody for five days surrounding the disappearance
of his wife, Lynette, who he claims fell overboard in
rough seas in the Bahamas. He is now a freeman.
He was released last night. It was the Behamian law.

(11:50):
They could only hold him for a certain amount of
time and unless they were able to charge him with
murder charges, they were forced to release him. And it's
interesting because we heard his attorney even just the day prior,
given the questioning he was facing, she actually told reporters
she felt like her client was likely going to be

(12:10):
facing murder charges. So this was look But as the
hours ticked on and the days went on and no
charges were brought, it seemed pretty obvious that authorities just
didn't have the proof. They didn't have the evidence they
needed to actually formally charge Brian Hooker. And they certainly

(12:32):
went through what you would imagine police would do. They
they got evidence, they went through hours of exhaustive interrogations.
But if he's denying it, there's no evidence showing anything else.
They don't have the body of Lynnette Hooker and there
were no other witnesses. What can they do? What options
did they have?

Speaker 2 (12:52):
Yeah?

Speaker 1 (12:52):
Let me I guess I don't know how heated and
how dedicated they're going to be to the search moving forward,
But I guess that's just going to be key. That
might be it whether or not he faces charges as
whether or not they find her body, and even if
they find her body, is said mean there is evidence
of wrongdoing?

Speaker 3 (13:09):
Yes, And that is the big question now. Brian Hooker,
before he was taken into custody, sent out some maps
that he rendered and he sent this to his friends,
he said to Feller voters, and there were screenshots from
his GPS and he marked the route where he says
his dinghy went and he marked where Lynette went overboard,

(13:32):
and he said he made them to aid in the
search and rescue. But a lot of folks are looking
at this that. Yes, he's getting very specific and very
detailed about what happened and if evidence if they find
her body when they looked at the boat, if anything,
if there's anything that isn't reconciled with what he very
clearly marks that could be used against him. He's hoping

(13:52):
it bolsters the story that he says, this is exactly
what happened. But he shows that he traveled four miles
before he landed on the shore of another island seven
hours later. And it's just as you point out, questionable
why he wouldn't have made his way if he could paddle, yes, slowly,
but if he could paddle, why couldn't he paddle to

(14:14):
the boat? Why couldn't he paddle towards the same direction
his own wife, he says, was floating. If the current
was taking her there, why couldn't it have taken the
boat there as well? With the paddle. It's very puzzling
that his boat went in the opposite direction of his
wife and the opposite direction of their sailboat.

Speaker 1 (14:36):
And that's why he won't do any interviews because somebody's
going to ask him all those questions and it's going
to be difficult to answer. So bottom line for him,
if he's not going to be charged, I mean, he's
going to go on with his life and I don't
expect to see him. I mean, what's the right thing
to do. Get in front of cameras and say, help
me find my wife. That's not We're not in a

(14:59):
situation where the he can call for the public's help.
So the only reason to get in front of a
camera is to improve his own standing in the public,
and that's going to backfire.

Speaker 3 (15:09):
Yeah, you feel for Lynette Hooker's a daughter, for her
family members, for her friends, because obviously people just want answers,
They want to know what happened. And look, we even
heard and I think this is really important from Brian
Hooker's stepdaughter. From Lynette Hooker's daughter, she has said it often.
She hopes this was just a tragic accident. She wants

(15:30):
to believe that her stepdad had nothing to do with this,
and so without without finding Lynette, without getting some of
those answers, then not knowing will most likely be the
hardest part, not just for Lynette's daughter, but if Brian
Hooker had nothing to do with this, he'll never probably
escape the suspicion of it, and so this is going
to be a tough story going forward if there aren't

(15:52):
any answers. Of course, we'll continue to follow any of
the developments that come out of the Bahamas, but for now,
Brian Hooker is a free man and Lynette Hooker's whereabouts
is still unknown and without everyone. Thank you for joining us.
We always appreciate you listening to us. We've got morning
run coming up in just a bit, so look for that.
But in the meantime, thank you as always. I made

(16:14):
me Robock alongside TJ. Holmes. We'll talk to you soon.
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

Stuff You Should Know
Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Crime Junkie

Crime Junkie

Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by Audiochuck Media Company.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2026 iHeartMedia, Inc.

  • Help
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • AdChoicesAd Choices