All Episodes

January 11, 2026 19 mins

Police have charged actor and director Timothy Busfield with two counts of criminal sexual conduct with a minor.  Police say the abuse happened on the set of “The Cleaning Lady” when the boys were just 7 and 8 years old.  Busfield is married to actress Melissa Gilbert who has recently spoken out about child sex abuse on sets.  Busfield is known for his roles in “Thirtysomething” and “The West Wing” and has suggested the allegations are revenge for the boys being replaced on the show. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:10):
Hey there, folks. It is Sunday, January eleventh, and a
director and Emmy Award winning actor is facing charges of
child sex abuse, accused by two child actors who once
worked for him. And with that, welcome to this episode
of Amy and TJ. Roves. This is one of those

(00:32):
Casesn't fair to say the actor here is a name
that's not immediately familiar, but you see the face and
you go, oh.

Speaker 2 (00:40):
Him, Yes, exactly one of those cases. Yes, his name
is Timothy Bussfield. That would not have rung any bells
for me. For a lot of you, it may have,
but when you see his face, you'll say, oh, that guy,
that guy who starred in thirty something, that guy who
starred in West Wing, that guy who won won an
Emmy and has seven hundred and fifty professional credits to

(01:01):
his name.

Speaker 1 (01:02):
And also you had to remind me also who he's
married to. Yes, that I didn't register me at all.

Speaker 2 (01:08):
I had forgotten that this had happened. It seemed like
a very happy third marriage for both of them, and
maybe it still is. But he is married to Melissa
Gilbert aka Laura Ingalls from Little House on the Prairie.
She is and was probably one of my childhood just obsessions.
I love Melissa Gilbert. She was on GMA three with us,

(01:30):
a lovely woman and actually has recently spoken out against
child sexual abusers. So this is a very disturbing story.

Speaker 1 (01:41):
Now, is it fair to say that, even if you
didn't know his name, when you hear her name, did
you know immediately who she was married to?

Speaker 2 (01:49):
Not necessarily, No, because this is a third marriage for both.
So this is something. This is love they found later
in life. They've been together I believe for about ten
years now, and I went back and there were a
lot of articles at actually in the last few years
of their love story how they found love again, how
third times a charmed So no, I didn't necessarily connect
the two of them.

Speaker 1 (02:08):
Together, all right, So Timothy Bussfield is the name, and
we assure you you will know his face. He has
been around for decades in this business now, A lot
of like you said, thirty something that was the nineties,
was it not that that show was out and he
had multiple I think Emmy nominations for that, but actually
did win an Emmy for that show. Of course, he

(02:28):
was on West Wing, a hit show as well. He
played a very very prominent character. He was a reporter
for the Washington Post. I was just very much into
that and remember his romance with Alison Jenny Jenny, yes,
character on that show. So a lot of people will
remember that. But he has been also very involved in
producing and directing over the past several years as well.
And it is in that capacity as a director that

(02:49):
he was working on a show called The Cleaning Lady.
Now a lot of people might remember because it was
a It did have at least four seasons, I think,
but it had a pretty big promotional push and a
LOADI Young I believe is her name, the one who
was the lead on that. You've seen her around enough
and enough high profile things. But he was director on

(03:09):
that show. Directed two boys on the show at the
age of seven and eight. They were brothers. That is
where the accusations are coming from. Two boys on the show.
And now Tim bussfil has been charged with two counts
of criminal sexual contact with a minor. And this is
coming out of an arrestaurant in Albuquerque. Now we're going

(03:30):
to get into some more details, but Robes I thought
it was the best way to sum up what we're
dealing with here. The affidavit, the arrest report from the
officer who was investigating. He goes through the affidavit, goes
through and gives all the details, evidence, interviews, he's done.
But then at the bottom he gives his conclusion. And
it's the conclusion he gave based on his experience that

(03:51):
he wrote in there that kind of sums up. I thought,
Robes and I thought this was a good way to
kind of introduce or let the listeners know what we're
talking about her.

Speaker 2 (04:00):
Yes, as we were researching the story, you said, Babe,
if you read anything, read the conclusion to the affidavit,
because boy does it say a lot. And here is
how it reads. In my training and experience, pedophiles often
infiltrate families under a trusted role, like Timothy, who, as
a producer, exploited the hectic film sets to tickle and

(04:21):
touch victim on his penis and buttocks, making it masking
it as play. He would invite the family to offset gatherings,
his wife buying Christmas gifts to foster closeness, making the
victim feel special and dependent. Classic grooming to erode boundaries,
isolate the victim and silent suspicions by blending abuse into normalcy.

(04:46):
This dual tactic, charming parents while secretly violating the child,
builds a web of complicity that is hard to unravel,
delaying detection as families trust the abuser's facade.

Speaker 1 (05:00):
It is his conclusion again, this is an investigator, and
after all he put together and all he investigated in
all his interviews, this is the conclusion he had, now, Robes,
I read through the affidavit before getting to that conclusion,
and I was trying to piece it together and what
the story is when that landed, he is flat out

(05:20):
making an accusation here, or is of the belief that
this wasn't just horseplay, this wasn't just an isolated incident.
He is accusing at least this officer of his belief
that this was more than a moment or two, that
this guy is a pedophile.

Speaker 2 (05:37):
He makes no bones about it, and he talks about
the strategy, the premeditation, and the function which he chose
to do what police say he did to these boys.
And that's what the boys and the boys the way
they told it, it didn't all come out at once.
It was a classic situation where they first just kind

(05:57):
of talked about how he tickled them, right, So he
did grow closer to the boys. He was in charge
of making sure he was directing them, So that was
not anything out of the ordinary for him to have
contact with them, to be talking to them, to be
having private moments with them, perhaps to direct them. But

(06:18):
when the parents found out correct that he had reports
of being perhaps inappropriate with women, they decided to ask
their children about their relationship with him, and they actually
asked him, have you, as anybody ever touched you inappropriately?
And their response was pretty chilling, You mean, like uncle Tim.

(06:42):
That is frightening as a parent to hear. And so
they followed up and they had an interview with the
police and that's when the boys just said, hey, he
would tickle us on our stomach and legs, and that's
as far as they went. And so that was back
in twenty twenty four, correct in November, and police made
the decision at that point that it did not meet

(07:04):
the standards to charge him, so they let it go.
They didn't pursue further investigation. They didn't pursue what he
charges until recently when the boys finally did admit they
said that they were sexually abused and.

Speaker 1 (07:18):
Again, what the what it's supposed to happen at least
a couple of things on set. We understand is that
when you have kids this young, they're supposed to have
constant supervision. Constant supervision means not just adults around, but
someone is assigned to them. They have what they called
a teacher that's supposed to be with the kids. But
the teacher that is assigned to be on set admitted

(07:39):
in this affidavit that at times with the hectic set,
that no, they weren't always they didn't always have eyes
on the boys, they weren't always with the boys. And sometimes, yes,
the kids could have alone moments with someone else, And
they said, it's not odd for a director to have
a one on one moment with an actor. They set
this up in the affidavit at least I read robes

(07:59):
suggesting that there were times, there were moments, there were opportunities,
even on a busy set, for a man to find
a way to be alone with a child is what
the affidavit reads. It was also this issue they brought
up of iPads on set, that parents, it's a closed set,
nobody's supposed to see anything, but when they're kids involved

(08:20):
parents are allowed to have an iPads to which they
could essentially keep an eye on their kids. The affidavit
suggests that this was a practice that was done away
with by Timothy Bussfield when he joined and became a
director on the set. What that could mean, I don't know,
but it was relevant enough that the officer thought he
should put that in the report. Now, of course Timothy
Bussville was spoken to. They did talk to him as

(08:43):
well as a part of this. And Roves, I don't
know how to necessarily characterize the I guess the back
and forth between police and Buzsfield. He was open and
he talked to them on the phone. But then some
of his answers were a bit confusing. But the quotes,
particularly and specifically, I should say, are in the affidavit.

Speaker 2 (09:03):
The quotes are actually quite alarming, would you not agree?
I mean, when I read them, it was actually shocking
to me what he said and how he said it.

Speaker 1 (09:12):
Again, we're trying to piece something together, and you when
somebody says to you you're accused of touching a child inappropriately,
you would think the answer would be pretty forceful.

Speaker 2 (09:24):
Oh hell no, I never turned the table.

Speaker 1 (09:26):
Over screaming and yelling, who the hell said this, Let's
get to the bott let's get this worked out right now.
And it wasn't exactly what he said, all.

Speaker 2 (09:32):
Right, So they asked Timothy what the protocol was for
touching children, picking them up, just touching them just in
general on this set. He asked if that was allowed,
And here's what Timothy told police. Initially, It's not allowed
at all. There is no there's no protocol. I mean,
I'm always around people, right, it would be it would be,

(09:56):
you know, in front of the parents. There would never
be a weird mo mom about it. I don't really
remember picking those boys up. I remember picking up the
boy who followed them. I'd pick him up and he'd
be giggling and that would sort of get him ready
to act. Then Timothy said this, I don't remember those boys. No,

(10:18):
I don't. I don't actually, I don't remember it. If
it happened. I don't remember overly tickling the boys ever,
but it wouldn't be uncommon for me. I don't know.

Speaker 1 (10:31):
He's trying to piece it together. Is this the phone
call where he was his wife was on as well.

Speaker 2 (10:35):
Yes, I believe that was all happening.

Speaker 1 (10:37):
They described the officer at least of saying that Timothy
Busfelt was on speakerphone with his wife's say your name
it Melissa, Melissa gil Gilbert was on the phone at
the time, and that was the answer that he gave it.
It's confusing, it's you don't want I don't know how
to get into his mind and try to understand or
interpret what might have been going on on set and
how it could have been misinterpreted by someone else. But

(11:01):
to your point earlier ropes, this wasn't a thing where
one incident was misinterpreter or two people saw one incident
and it was you know, this was the boys were asked.
This came from therapists, This came from other people on
set seeing things over time as well with the parents.
So this wasn't a one off so that they said

(11:22):
it happened multiple times. All the boys were seven and
eight years old on set multiple times, and there was
also a situation in there they'd described in the Affidavid,
I think it was the teacher or someone on set
that followed one of the boys that was a sign
to him said something happened. He went from being thrilled

(11:43):
and excited and jumping around on that set every day
to flat out not wanting to be there at all.
She's described it as a stark and disturbing change that
was inexplicable.

Speaker 2 (11:56):
Wow. Wow, and just that do you mean Uncle Tim?
He wanted the boys to call him Uncle Tim? He
said that was part of it. And look that in
and of itself isn't anything unusual necessarily, but just to
have your kids, I'm just imagining that moment when you
say has anyone ever touched you inappropriately? And your children?

(12:17):
Your child immediately says, like, Uncle Tim, that's That's just
a horrific moment when maybe all of your suspicions, some
of the weirdness you're sensing, the energy, you're feeling, your kids,
changing their disposition, changing how they acted and reacted about
wanting to go to the set and about wanting to
come home, all of that just falls into line when

(12:38):
you hear that sentence from your child.

Speaker 1 (12:40):
And as of this moment, do I have right ropes
that we haven't gott an official statement response, even from
a lawyer from a bustfelt right.

Speaker 2 (12:47):
There's nothing from the bus Field camp. In fact, we
don't even know right now whether or not. He is
currently in custody. We know there is a warrant issued
for his arrest. The last I saw, I believe they
lived in upstate New York. They might have a home
in New York City as well. So this is in
New Mexico. So it's unclear what's happening right there in
the legal process.

Speaker 1 (13:05):
All right, Well, we mentioned Ellidi Young is the woman's
name who was the lead on the Cleaning Lady. Well,
police reached out to her as well, and they did,
in fact set up an interview with her. That interview, however,
did not happen. Stay here. We'll explain the voicemail the
officer said he got from the star of the show

(13:26):
that made clear she wanted nothing to do with this.
We'll also tell you what Warner Brothers had to say.
Stay here, all right, We continue here on Amy and TJ.
Timothy Bussfil a name of an actor you might not know,

(13:47):
but you certainly know his name. You know his excuse me,
know his face, and you know his work over the
past several decades, from thirty Something where he won an Emmy,
to West Wing where he played a prominent role, and
his life now again, she is one of I mean,
she is a what do you put her in pop culture?

Speaker 2 (14:06):
She's an icon. She's an icon from the seventies and eighties,
playing half pint, playing Lori Ingles Wilder in Little House
in the Prairie and so interesting, babe, because just a
couple of weeks ago, she wrote a whole op ed
and actually weighed in on child sex abuse on movie sets,

(14:26):
on television sets, on production sets, because she said she
was forced to have a romantic experience with we It
was Almanda Almlonzo. Yes, I forgot her love interest in
the show was like a full ten something years older
than her, and she was in her like early teens,
like fourteen fifteen, and she talked about how that was inappropriate.
So it's so I mean, ironic is, for lack of

(14:50):
a better word, that she just was outspoken about this
issue about what happens on sex on sets and how
there isn't enough protection for younger actors on sets in
these types of situations. And so to now have her
husband be at the center of a criminal investigation and
have charges now filed against him is not I mean,

(15:12):
irony is the only word to use.

Speaker 1 (15:15):
And of course the cleaning lady were talking about. He
was directing on set there. This was a Warner Brother set.
They did put out a statement simply saying that they
take of course, this is stuff you're used to hearing,
but they did acknowledge that they are aware of the
charges against mister buss Phil and they will continue to
cooperate with law enforcement. They also did their own investigation,

(15:37):
which nothing came of that. Correct, So here we are now.
Elidi Young. Did you know her face? The actress from
the cleaning lanbe I know.

Speaker 2 (15:46):
Her face, Yes, I didn't know her name. Same kind
of situation as Timothy bussefelt.

Speaker 1 (15:50):
Yeah, but a French actress that's been making her way
and doing more here in the US. I remember her
in particularly if you've seen The Hitman's Bodyguard with Ryan
Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson. I've been trying to get
you to watch this movie for a while. It is
hilarious action fact and it's just those two dudes. It's fun.
But she plays a very prominent role and a memorable one.

(16:10):
She's the ex girlfriend of Ryan Reynolds. Oh, and she
matches his you know how he is and his scenes.
She matches his fire and energy in the first time
I'd ever seen her, and I was impressed with her.
But she got the lead on this show, The Cleaning Lady,
and so they reached out to her to ask about
the investigation and what she might know, and she said, sure,

(16:32):
I'll talk to you. They set up an interview that
was supposed to take place on one day. The day before,
they got a call said I changed my mind. The
way the officer put it, said, Leddie left me a
voicemail declining to speak with me and said that she
does not want to be involved with the investigation and
that she would not have any information that could assist
in this case. And that was it. That was at

(16:55):
least for me. The Affidavid says, called, She's sure, whatever
you need, here's a time, here's a place, let's meet.
And then she had a change of heart pretty quickly
and the day before said nope, I want nothing to
do with it. Got nothing the same.

Speaker 2 (17:13):
That's interesting, and we also did hear at least in
some of the reporting that Timothy Bussfield has suggested that
perhaps the parents are doing this again. They are upset
that their children were essentially written out of the script
and were no longer a part of the show. And

(17:33):
so the one thing we have heard from him through
some of the affidavits and what they've released in terms
of the investigation, his point of view is that this
is retribution for those kids no longer being a part
of the storyline.

Speaker 1 (17:51):
Yes, and that is a part of the Affidavid, So
that is him giving a defense without officially coming out.
But he was defending himself at least as terms of
this AffA day. It says the officer thought it was
important enough. He has listed two previous allegations against him
Busville from nineteen ninety four and twenty twelve, one involving

(18:11):
a twenty eight year old woman, the other involving a
seventeen year old who was an extra on Little Big League. Now,
nothing came, no charges were filed in either one of them,
we should say, but the officer at least thought it
was important enough to mention it in the affidavit and
included it in there.

Speaker 2 (18:28):
And perhaps the parents finding out about those allegations prompted
them to ask their children a few questions. So right
now a lot of people pointing fingers. We don't know
exactly obviously what comes next, but we do know that
Timothy Bussfield will be at least at some point taken
into custody. There will have to be some sort of

(18:49):
hearing where there will be some sort of bond hearing,
and we'll figure out where he is, if he has
to remain behind bars, if he's able to post bail
and see his day in the court. But we will
certainly continue to follow this story. We appreciate you as
always listening to us. Thank you so much. I'm Amy
Roeboch alongside T. J. Holmes. People talk to you
Advertise With Us

Hosts And Creators

Amy Robach

Amy Robach

T.J. Holmes

T.J. Holmes

Popular Podcasts

Two Guys, Five Rings: Matt, Bowen & The Olympics

Two Guys, Five Rings: Matt, Bowen & The Olympics

Two Guys (Bowen Yang and Matt Rogers). Five Rings (you know, from the Olympics logo). One essential podcast for the 2026 Milan-Cortina Winter Olympics. Bowen Yang (SNL, Wicked) and Matt Rogers (Palm Royale, No Good Deed) of Las Culturistas are back for a second season of Two Guys, Five Rings, a collaboration with NBC Sports and iHeartRadio. In this 15-episode event, Bowen and Matt discuss the top storylines, obsess over Italian culture, and find out what really goes on in the Olympic Village.

iHeartOlympics: The Latest

iHeartOlympics: The Latest

Listen to the latest news from the 2026 Winter Olympics.

Milan Cortina Winter Olympics

Milan Cortina Winter Olympics

The 2026 Winter Olympics in Milan Cortina are here and have everyone talking. iHeartPodcasts is buzzing with content in honor of the XXV Winter Olympics We’re bringing you episodes from a variety of iHeartPodcast shows to help you keep up with the action. Follow Milan Cortina Winter Olympics so you don’t miss any coverage of the 2026 Winter Olympics, and if you like what you hear, be sure to follow each Podcast in the feed for more great content from iHeartPodcasts.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2026 iHeartMedia, Inc.