April 19, 2023 • 27 mins
Philodendron Spiritus-Sancti is one of the rarest plants in the world. Many call it the “Holy Grail of Philodendrons.” In May 2020, the San Diego Botanic Garden had one of these plants as their centerpiece. But in the dead of night, it was stolen.
In this episode of Bad Seeds, a look inside a booming craze for houseplants and how a cultural obsession might be killing the things we love the most.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:08):
School of humans.
Speaker 2 (00:27):
Deep in the mountainous rainforests of southeastern Brazil, not far
from the village of Domingos Marchings, grows a plant. Its
stalks are long and narrow, a crown of dangling green.
It grows out of the mist below the canopy, slowly
creeping up the trunks of trees. As it matures. It
(00:49):
hangs above the ground like a chandelier. The blades of
each leaf splayed like the wings of an angel. The
plant's name is philodendron. Spirit is sancty Latin for holy ghost.
It is one of the rarest plants in the world.
Only a few specimens grow in the wild. To plant collectors,
(01:13):
the words spirit is sancty illicit goosebumps. The plant's name
is spoken with hushed religious reverence. Many call it the
holy Grail of philodendrons.
Speaker 3 (01:30):
It's only found in the wild in one small town
in Brazil at this point, as far.
Speaker 2 (01:33):
As we know, that's doctor Arinovi. He's the president and
CEO of the San Diego Botanic Garden.
Speaker 3 (01:40):
A big part about why it has such value to
collectors is it has very beautiful long leaves. It looks
fantastic and it's incredibly hard to propagate.
Speaker 2 (01:48):
A botched cutting, for example, could kill the entire plant,
and that's why captive Spirit of Sancty specimens are best
handled by professionals, people like doctor Novi and the folks
at the garden in San Diego.
Speaker 3 (02:01):
We have about five thousand a little over five thousand
individual plant taxa or species that are represented within our collections.
It is an ungodly diversity of plants.
Speaker 2 (02:12):
This collection includes rare and endangered species like the Hawaiian
Hibiscus aka Hibiscus rosa sinensis, the Bastard quivertree or Alliodendron pilancie,
and of course the Holy Relic of southern Brazil. For years,
(02:33):
the Spirit of Sancty was one of San Diego's centerpieces.
It hangs high above the ground, delicately suspended from the
greenhouse's ceiling, far out of reach of passers by. At
least that's what they thought. One morning in May twenty twenty,
(02:53):
a garden employee stepped into the greenhouse, peered up and
witnessed a blasphemy.
Speaker 3 (03:00):
Our director of porta Culture at the time was in
the garden and he felt like that basket looked a
little less who eventually got out a ladder and climbed
up and saw that this plant had been kind of
hacked off.
Speaker 2 (03:23):
It became clear what had happened, and the dead of
night somebody had broken into the garden, grabbed a pole
saw or a long pair of lappers, and hacked off
pieces of the treasured plant. The heist seemed meticulously planned.
Speaker 4 (03:38):
There were no signs of breaking or entering.
Speaker 3 (03:40):
There are other valuable plants in that space that they
were not targeted, but it certainly seems like somebody was
aware of our habits, you know, somebody was, for lack
of a better term, kind of tasting the joint.
Speaker 4 (03:49):
For a while.
Speaker 2 (03:50):
The reason they targeted the spiritus money.
Speaker 3 (03:53):
That was probably the single highest value plant in the
collection of the Botanic Garden in terms of what you
could get for resale value. This plant could sell for
between ten and fifteen thousand dollars on the open market.
Speaker 2 (04:05):
Fifteen thousand dollars. A Spirit of Sancty is more than
a plant. It's a status symbol, an investment, a limited
edition Rolex that knows photosynthesis, and that price tag has
done much more than simply drained the pockets of rich
plant lovers it's fueled a spree of crime and lies
(04:29):
and deceit. I'm Summer rain Oaks. On this episode, a
look inside a booming craze for house plans and how
a cultural obsession and the human instinct to keep up
with the joneses might be killing the things we love
the most. From School of Humans and iHeart Podcasts. This
(04:49):
is Bad Seeds. It's twenty twelve and a small crowd
is gathered for the International Alloyd Society Fall Show and
Sale in Florida. It's an annual banquet and this year
doctor Tom Crowet of the Missouri Botanical Garden and Tom Moore,
(05:13):
founder of the Tropical Fern and Exotic Plant Society, are
holding a plant they call the Piece de Resistance.
Speaker 4 (05:20):
Mortgage your house, Tell your children on this plant. It's
been a little stock market.
Speaker 2 (05:29):
It's a spiritus sancty, a small one, but a spirit
is nonetheless. And then the bidding begins.
Speaker 4 (05:35):
World works your money tonight.
Speaker 5 (05:37):
You have fifty dollars opening bed. Come.
Speaker 1 (05:42):
I got two hundred, three hundred three, I got four hundred,
I got four hundred back.
Speaker 4 (05:49):
I got four hundred back.
Speaker 5 (05:50):
You're gonna let this go for four hundred.
Speaker 2 (05:51):
Dollars, of course not. The bids keep rising. Five hundred
seven hundred, nine hundred nine.
Speaker 6 (05:58):
Fifty I got nine fifty nine seventy seven to got money.
Speaker 7 (06:03):
I got what.
Speaker 1 (06:07):
I'm gonna go.
Speaker 4 (06:09):
One thousand, once, one thousand, twice.
Speaker 7 (06:12):
So.
Speaker 2 (06:16):
One thousand dollars for a potted plant with just six leaves.
This again, was twenty twelve, just over a decade later.
That price seems quaint now. I remember when I first
learned about the Spirit of Sancty. It was five years
ago and I was doing a tour with a popular
arroid grower, end A Falter. During that tour, I got
(06:40):
to see the plant for the first time.
Speaker 6 (06:43):
This is the awesome Spirit of Sancty, one of the
most rare philodendrons in the world. It's not in a
lot of collections, and it's hard to get a hold
of one.
Speaker 2 (06:53):
Actually, she tried to convey just how rare this plant was,
but to be honest, I didn't really grasp it at
the time.
Speaker 6 (07:02):
Well, they're first, they're expensive, and they're hard to get.
There's only a few people that even wouldever have one
to sell.
Speaker 2 (07:07):
You've got few would ever loan you at cutting either.
That scarcity however, drives an aggressive market for the rare plants.
It keeps prices high. In fact, if you bought and
held onto that plant auctioned off in Florida, its value
would have yielded an annual rate of return of about
twenty eight percent, beating out gold. Prices have been turbocharged
(07:31):
in the past few years, so much so that it's
taken experts like doctor Arinovi by surprise.
Speaker 3 (07:38):
We knew that that plant prices were going up, and
that during the pandemic, you know, people were getting more
enthusiastic about house plants and even some rare plants, which
mostly we looked at as a wonderful thing. But you know,
we started looking at eBay and other things and being like,
oh my god. We didn't realize that the same plant
that you used to be able to buy for fifteen
dollars at home depot now goes for.
Speaker 4 (07:57):
Three four hundred dollars.
Speaker 2 (07:59):
Driving this boom is classic supply and demand. There aren't
many plants, but there are a ton of people who
want them, so prices go up. In fact, one online
plant store in Britain saw sales surge five hundred percent
during lockdown. But who are these people driving up prices.
If you read the headlines, it seems pretty obvious.
Speaker 3 (08:21):
California hipster plants at the center of smuggling crisis.
Speaker 4 (08:25):
What is it with millennials and cactuses?
Speaker 1 (08:28):
If only hipsters had stuck to their handlebar, mustaches and
craft beer, this never would have happened.
Speaker 2 (08:34):
Yep, the same people who got blamed for killing the
napkin industry, mayonnaise, the nine to five workday, and lately,
well pretty much everything else. Millennials.
Speaker 3 (08:44):
We saw a whole generation of young people who previously
weren't that engaged in house plans get excited about it,
and again, that is ninety nine percent awesome. The only
thing about it that's not awesome is that it did
lead to a market that encouraged theft den poachings.
Speaker 2 (08:58):
The pandemic, of course, deserves a lot of blame too.
Millions of us, trapped inside and craving something to do,
began transforming our homes into sanctuaries, and it wasn't long
before viral posts on TikTok began touting the plant mom
and plant dad lifestyle. But the question I keep coming
back to is is that the real reason this plant
(09:20):
craze is happening? Or is there something about human nature,
something dark, that just makes us crazy for plants. Here's
the thing about our recent plant obsession. It's nothing new.
(09:44):
Just ask Charles Mackay. In the eighteen forties, Mackay, a
Scottish journalist, became fascinated with herd behavior, how certain interests
or beliefs grew to overtake entire cultures. So in eighteen
forty one, Mackay published the first volume of his book
Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, witch Hunts, Alchemy,
(10:07):
the Crusades. The book plum the Darkest Recesses of the
Human Mind, and in it Mackay concluded that these trends
and obsessions are just part of a cultural cycle.
Speaker 5 (10:18):
Millions of people become simultaneously impressed with one delusion and
drawn after it till their tension is caughked by some
new folly more captivating.
Speaker 4 (10:27):
Than the first.
Speaker 2 (10:30):
One. Such folly, he wrote, was an irrational mania for plants,
specifically tulips. It's the sixteen thirties, Holland. New trade routes
just opened to the Ottoman Empire, leading the Dutch to
quote unquote discover new foods, new spices, new ideas, and
(10:52):
of course new plants. It's an exciting time and people
are positively enchanted with everything coming out of the Far East,
including a vibrant flower native to the lush valleys of
my China and Afghanistan, the tulip. Within years, everybody in
Holland wanted to get their hands on some tulips. According
(11:15):
to Mackay, speculators began buying up bulbs, not with the
intent of planting them, but in the hopes of just
reselling them for a profit. And this rich scheme it worked.
The cost of tulip skyrocketed, with some bulbs fetching more
than a single year's wage. One bulb was valued to
(11:36):
cost as much as twelve acres of corn. But then
the craze stopped. People came to their senses the bubble burst,
Speculators panicked and prices, according to some estimates, collapsed as
much as ninety nine percent, and some people lost everything.
(12:00):
Now it's important to note that Mackay had a habit
of bending the truth a bit. His reports that this
tulip mania plunged Holland into economic ruin are exaggerated, but
the obsession was very real, as was another plant madness
growing right outside Mackay's front door. This time it was ferns.
(12:21):
In nineteenth century Britain, ferns were inescapable botanic gardens overflowed
with fern specimens. Readers gobbled up literature on the subject
and turned niche fern collecting books into best sellers. People
subscribed to fern magazines and joined fern societies, with fern
loving propagandists arguing that owning ferns was proof of intelligence
(12:44):
that improved virility and mental health. But beyond all that,
they were just another way to show off well to do.
Collectors hired explorers to trot around Panama, Honduras and Tasmania
to find rare ferns. Meanwhile, the middle class trekked towards
(13:04):
coastal hillsides and dug up the plants themselves. It was
like a treasure hunt, and it wasn't always fun in games.
According to the September eighteen sixty seven Floral World and
Garden Guide, one British woman, Miss Jane Myers, plunged off
a cliff one hundred and seventy feet to her death
(13:25):
while trying to pick a fern like tulips. The price
of foreign ferns exploded, with some selling for more than
one thousand dollars in today's money. Crook's cut wind pretty fast.
Knowing they could earn an easy shilling, they started poaching ferns.
(13:45):
It got so bad that botanists started to worry about
the plant's survival. In his book The Flora of Cornwall,
the botanist H. Davy wrote, it's.
Speaker 6 (13:54):
A shameful plundering has gone on that I now hesitate
to speak or write about localities where the royal fern grows.
Speaker 2 (14:01):
As the naturalist Peter da Boyd tells us, it wasn't epidemic,
with careless poachers catering to the demand of fern enthusiasts.
Speaker 5 (14:10):
The search for wild species led to the plundering of
woodlands and hillsides, stream sides and whole woodlands would be
effectively destroyed as regards their ferns by collecting literally tons
of fern plants where unscrupulous collectors didn't think about what
(14:32):
effect it might have on the environment. For most of
the nineteenth century, there was no law against collecting ferns, but.
Speaker 2 (14:41):
That changed in February eighteen ninety six, a periodical called
The Gardener's Chronicle documented the punishment for a pair of
fern thieves.
Speaker 8 (14:50):
Fern stealers William Moby and Charles Williams of Bexley, Kent,
were engaged with the horse and cart and the wholesale
removal of ferns. Moby was sentenced to six weeks hard
labor and Williams to one month.
Speaker 2 (15:04):
The wholesale plunder of ferns would turn the whole British
countryside into one big crime scene, and that sparked the
conservation movement.
Speaker 5 (15:13):
Such damage led to the first legal plant protection in Britain.
Speaker 2 (15:21):
Some of those laws, however, would arrive too late. The
Killarney fern or Trichomani's speciosum, admired for its lacy, almost
translucent leaves, nearly went extinct in Scotland. And that brings
us back to the present day and our pandemic induced
(15:42):
plant mania. It reminds me of something that doctor Arinovi
told us.
Speaker 3 (15:47):
But you buy it illegal plants, you may be financing
the destruction of an irreplaceable ecosystem that cannot come back.
So the stakes are kind of high, and like I said,
we unfortunately now have evidence that this big plant craze
during the pandemic may have wiped out several species around
the world just just from poaching.
Speaker 4 (16:04):
So it's it's not trivial.
Speaker 2 (16:06):
But who is really to blame? Is that boom and
prices and the surgeon poaching really driven by millennials. To
find the answer, we had to go to the coastal
cliffs of northern California. High above crashing waves and not
far from the meandering curves of Highway One, rose Dudleya Farinosa,
(16:29):
a small cliff dwelling succulent nicknamed bluff lettuce. Around twenty eighteen,
succulent poachers started plaguing these coasts, plucking thousands of Dudleya
from the cliff side. Many of the people who were
caught were Korean. One stole six hundred thousand dollars worth
(16:49):
of succulents. Headline writers pounced. Soon news agencies were claiming
that these thieves were motivated by quote, housewives and hipsters,
people who are willing to pay hundreds of dollars for
a single succulent. You might remember our friend doctor Jared
margolis So.
Speaker 7 (17:10):
The obvious sort of narratives emerged that every housewife and
hipster in South Korea wanted one of these Dudleia, and
that there was this succulent mania happening in East Asia
that was driving this trade, and that people just saw
an opportunity to steal the plants and make a huge
profit off of it.
Speaker 2 (17:27):
In other words, the madness of crowds was just working
its magic again. But something about that narrative didn't sit
right with doctor Margulis, Like, why would somebody steal Dudleya.
Speaker 7 (17:42):
These plants were legally available for purchase from a variety
of outlets in California, and they sort of looked like
a commonplace succulent, you know, they have a nice, pretty
rosette shape, and they put out a lovely sort of
inflorescence in flower. They're not a rare species, and so
people were pretty confused why suddenly it looked like people
were stealing them by the thousands from their habitat.
Speaker 2 (18:03):
Not to mention that bluff lettuce, it's not a beginner's plant.
Speaker 7 (18:07):
Dudley As are really hard to grow as houseplants, and
they really require an enormous amount of specialized care to
keep them alive outside of their native habitat. On the
West coast of California. So these were not plants that
were being bought and sold by our typical succulent consumer.
Speaker 2 (18:24):
This didn't sound like the madness of crowds at work.
This sounded like something else. Doctor Margulis needed to know more.
Speaker 7 (18:32):
I decided I had to go spend some time in
South Korea to try to really understand and do my
best to analyze these narratives and what was really happening
in the trade there.
Speaker 2 (18:45):
So Margoulis flew to Korea. He visited nurseries and garden
centers and talked to shop owners about dudley A sales.
He discovered they were not a widely popular succulent plant
amongst mainstream consumers in Seoul. Margulis popped into three of
the city's largest succulent markets. Only one was selling the
(19:06):
California Succulent. The vendor complained about a lack of demand.
This didn't fit the narrative played out back home.
Speaker 7 (19:15):
These plants are really were only being sought by highly
specialized collectors with a typically with a lot of skill
and capacity to care for them, owning and maintaining either
professional greenhouses or renting space in someone else's greenhouse in
order to keep them alive. This was not sort of
being driven by mainstream consumer culture.
Speaker 2 (19:35):
One plant dealer told Markulla's point blank, this isn't about
Chinese collectors, or Japanese collectors or Korean collectors. This is
about individual collectors and what they want. Millennial plant moms
and plant dads weren't driving the crime spree in California.
It was a small group of collectors, hardcore hobbyists, demanding
(19:57):
that the plant be ripped from the ground, and as
it turns out, they'd do just about anything to have it.
(20:18):
You can hear the pain in doctor Novi's voice when
he thinks back to the spirit of sancty heist.
Speaker 3 (20:24):
It would almost have been better if, like somebody was
trying to steal our computers and like ruin the plants incidentally,
because you know, you should have understand petty theft. But
this is like premeditated, Let's find the rarest plant around
here and steal it, taking it away from public usage.
Speaker 2 (20:45):
After the initial shock of the robbery, the botanic Garden
notified police, who at first didn't really understand the magnitude
of the crime.
Speaker 3 (20:53):
Probably the first second we were talking to law enforcement
they probably were like, you know, this is some person
in a neighborhood, and like, you know, some neighbors stole
their prizes. But like, you know, as soon as we
said here's who we are, this plant could sell for
between ten and fifteen thousand dollars on the open market.
Like they're like, oh, and I think they treated it
like any object you know of that level value, if
you know, if somebody called up and said, you know,
(21:14):
someone stole my car.
Speaker 2 (21:15):
But the Botanic Garden was already at a disadvantage when
it comes to high level plant crimes. Most local law
enforcement officers are extremely inexperienced.
Speaker 3 (21:25):
Back in the nineteen nineties, when the Garden did have
the theft of psychic heads, the garden benefited from the
fact that the Sheriff's office in San Diego had an
Agricultural Crimes division.
Speaker 2 (21:33):
That's right, an entire unit dedicated to plant crimes, which
is not super common, especially these days.
Speaker 3 (21:40):
So there are no longer, to our knowledge, detectives within
the San Diego law enforcement community that are specifically trained
on and or daily dealing with agricultural, plant and animal theft.
Speaker 4 (21:51):
Law enforcement doesn't get to practice it as much.
Speaker 3 (21:54):
It means a certain kind of expertise is not present
when it does happen.
Speaker 2 (21:58):
So to say the least, the police did not turn
up many promising leads. At one point, they suggested the
possibility of an inside job. The idea had merit. One
prominent plant influencer online bragged that whenever he volunteered at
botanic gardens, he'd steal rare clippings. The practice called proplifting,
(22:20):
a portmanteau of propagate and shoplifting, is increasingly common. A
Reddit page dedicated to legal and I Stress legal proplifting
has more than two hundred thousand members. But in San Diego,
the theft of the Spirit of Sancty went beyond simple proplifting.
This was the work of an obsessive who knew what
(22:42):
they were doing, and it would only be solved with
the help of other obsessives. And that is when the
gardens started getting tips from other plant lovers. People began
trawling forums and social media looking for somebody, anybody trying
to sell the famed plant.
Speaker 3 (23:04):
We started to get from the online aroid community saying, hey,
we're seeing some chatter, you know, in some of the
you know, blogs and social media. So that there might
be a plant for sale that sounds like it might
potentially be yours. The timing is right, the size and
this and that.
Speaker 2 (23:21):
Pictures of the plant in question began turning up in
the San Diego botanist inbox. One of them caught Novi's eye.
Speaker 3 (23:28):
Plant people are like dog people, and you know, we
look at the plants in the same way that dog
people or other pet owners, you know, or pet parents,
you know, look at their pets. And so, you know,
we know how many leaves that were on that one,
We know the color differences between young leaves and old leaves,
and so we told law enforcement and others that the
plant in question looked a heck of a lot like
(23:49):
our plant.
Speaker 2 (23:50):
So the police did their investigation.
Speaker 3 (23:52):
Law enforcement actually went to see one of the individuals
who some people in the community thought either may have
stolen it or somehow acquired it, you know, maybe they
thought it was legal and was reselling it. Law enforcement
told us that the person had an all buy or
just there wasn't enough evidence.
Speaker 4 (24:07):
They couldn't move any further.
Speaker 2 (24:12):
So the investigation stalled, and Novena's colleagues resigned themselves to
the fact that the plant was probably lost forever.
Speaker 3 (24:21):
I would put money on the fact that this plant died.
I mean, this thing was so hacked up, like you know,
they're very hard to root. I think somebody sold this
plant for fifteen thousand dollars and the person who bought
it didn't really know what they're doing, and.
Speaker 4 (24:33):
I think it died.
Speaker 5 (24:35):
You know.
Speaker 3 (24:35):
That's like for us, you know, and when you've cared
for that plant for ten or more years and it's
it's pretty devastating, you know. But I think, like everything else,
you know, you try to build resilience from tragedy.
Speaker 2 (24:48):
But that's tough. Because the theft at the San Diego
Botanic Garden, it's not uncommon. The list of thefts from
institutions to community gardens stretches from Jerusalem to Sydney to
Penang Church, New Zealand. A single plant where three thousand
(25:08):
New Zealand dollars was pilford in Coral Gables, Florida, robbers
ran off with two thousand dollars worth of greenery in
Brooklyn five thousand dollars and because of these thieves, the
public has lost priceless bonzize, rare orchids, and the world's
smallest water lily. The basic fact is, if you know
(25:32):
a botanic garden, somebody has probably stolen from.
Speaker 3 (25:36):
This is not someone's stealing a loaf of bread because
they're hungry, right, I mean, this is somebody very clearly
taking something that's not theirs, that's being maintained by a public,
nonprofit institution to benefit the public and posterity, and deciding
to try to create personal value and wealth gain out
of that theft.
Speaker 4 (25:53):
So, I mean, I.
Speaker 3 (25:54):
Don't think we have to dance around whether or not
it's evil. Is it, you know, evil on a high level.
That's a different.
Speaker 2 (25:59):
Question, and it's a question we're going to grapple with
for the rest of this show because rhymes like this
go far beyond questions of whether it's right or wrong
to steal. It shows how a passionate hobby or obsession
could put the planet end people's lives at risk. Next episode,
(26:21):
we dive deeper into the shadows following a team of
poachers and join the detectives who are hot on their tail.
Speaker 9 (26:28):
Ended up going to this really kind of sketchy pot
of just flown cattail knocker territory in Mexico. I'm just
gone met us on the side of the highway on
his Marta black and he was departure.
Speaker 2 (26:41):
I'm Summer rain Oaks. Join us again next time for
Bad Seeds. Bad Seeds is a production of School of
Humans and iHeart Podcasts. I'm your Host Summer rain Oaks.
Lucas Riley is our writer, Gabby Watts is our producer,
and Amelia Brock is our senior producer. Fact Checking is
(27:02):
by Savannah Hugely and Zoe Farrow. Music is by Claire Campbell.
Sound design and score is by Jesse Niswanger. Development was
by Brian Lavin and Jacob Selzer. Special thanks to our
voice actors Etily's Perez, Frank Swain, Reuben wu and Paul Feiffe.
Executive producers are Brian Lavin, Elsie Crowley, Brandon Barr, Virginia
(27:25):
Prescott and Jacob Selzer.
Speaker 1 (27:40):
School of Humans
School of humans.
Speaker 2 (00:27):
Deep in the mountainous rainforests of southeastern Brazil, not far
from the village of Domingos Marchings, grows a plant. Its
stalks are long and narrow, a crown of dangling green.
It grows out of the mist below the canopy, slowly
creeping up the trunks of trees. As it matures. It
(00:49):
hangs above the ground like a chandelier. The blades of
each leaf splayed like the wings of an angel. The
plant's name is philodendron. Spirit is sancty Latin for holy ghost.
It is one of the rarest plants in the world.
Only a few specimens grow in the wild. To plant collectors,
(01:13):
the words spirit is sancty illicit goosebumps. The plant's name
is spoken with hushed religious reverence. Many call it the
holy Grail of philodendrons.
Speaker 3 (01:30):
It's only found in the wild in one small town
in Brazil at this point, as far.
Speaker 2 (01:33):
As we know, that's doctor Arinovi. He's the president and
CEO of the San Diego Botanic Garden.
Speaker 3 (01:40):
A big part about why it has such value to
collectors is it has very beautiful long leaves. It looks
fantastic and it's incredibly hard to propagate.
Speaker 2 (01:48):
A botched cutting, for example, could kill the entire plant,
and that's why captive Spirit of Sancty specimens are best
handled by professionals, people like doctor Novi and the folks
at the garden in San Diego.
Speaker 3 (02:01):
We have about five thousand a little over five thousand
individual plant taxa or species that are represented within our collections.
It is an ungodly diversity of plants.
Speaker 2 (02:12):
This collection includes rare and endangered species like the Hawaiian
Hibiscus aka Hibiscus rosa sinensis, the Bastard quivertree or Alliodendron pilancie,
and of course the Holy Relic of southern Brazil. For years,
(02:33):
the Spirit of Sancty was one of San Diego's centerpieces.
It hangs high above the ground, delicately suspended from the
greenhouse's ceiling, far out of reach of passers by. At
least that's what they thought. One morning in May twenty twenty,
(02:53):
a garden employee stepped into the greenhouse, peered up and
witnessed a blasphemy.
Speaker 3 (03:00):
Our director of porta Culture at the time was in
the garden and he felt like that basket looked a
little less who eventually got out a ladder and climbed
up and saw that this plant had been kind of
hacked off.
Speaker 2 (03:23):
It became clear what had happened, and the dead of
night somebody had broken into the garden, grabbed a pole
saw or a long pair of lappers, and hacked off
pieces of the treasured plant. The heist seemed meticulously planned.
Speaker 4 (03:38):
There were no signs of breaking or entering.
Speaker 3 (03:40):
There are other valuable plants in that space that they
were not targeted, but it certainly seems like somebody was
aware of our habits, you know, somebody was, for lack
of a better term, kind of tasting the joint.
Speaker 4 (03:49):
For a while.
Speaker 2 (03:50):
The reason they targeted the spiritus money.
Speaker 3 (03:53):
That was probably the single highest value plant in the
collection of the Botanic Garden in terms of what you
could get for resale value. This plant could sell for
between ten and fifteen thousand dollars on the open market.
Speaker 2 (04:05):
Fifteen thousand dollars. A Spirit of Sancty is more than
a plant. It's a status symbol, an investment, a limited
edition Rolex that knows photosynthesis, and that price tag has
done much more than simply drained the pockets of rich
plant lovers it's fueled a spree of crime and lies
(04:29):
and deceit. I'm Summer rain Oaks. On this episode, a
look inside a booming craze for house plans and how
a cultural obsession and the human instinct to keep up
with the joneses might be killing the things we love
the most. From School of Humans and iHeart Podcasts. This
(04:49):
is Bad Seeds. It's twenty twelve and a small crowd
is gathered for the International Alloyd Society Fall Show and
Sale in Florida. It's an annual banquet and this year
doctor Tom Crowet of the Missouri Botanical Garden and Tom Moore,
(05:13):
founder of the Tropical Fern and Exotic Plant Society, are
holding a plant they call the Piece de Resistance.
Speaker 4 (05:20):
Mortgage your house, Tell your children on this plant. It's
been a little stock market.
Speaker 2 (05:29):
It's a spiritus sancty, a small one, but a spirit
is nonetheless. And then the bidding begins.
Speaker 4 (05:35):
World works your money tonight.
Speaker 5 (05:37):
You have fifty dollars opening bed. Come.
Speaker 1 (05:42):
I got two hundred, three hundred three, I got four hundred,
I got four hundred back.
Speaker 4 (05:49):
I got four hundred back.
Speaker 5 (05:50):
You're gonna let this go for four hundred.
Speaker 2 (05:51):
Dollars, of course not. The bids keep rising. Five hundred
seven hundred, nine hundred nine.
Speaker 6 (05:58):
Fifty I got nine fifty nine seventy seven to got money.
Speaker 7 (06:03):
I got what.
Speaker 1 (06:07):
I'm gonna go.
Speaker 4 (06:09):
One thousand, once, one thousand, twice.
Speaker 7 (06:12):
So.
Speaker 2 (06:16):
One thousand dollars for a potted plant with just six leaves.
This again, was twenty twelve, just over a decade later.
That price seems quaint now. I remember when I first
learned about the Spirit of Sancty. It was five years
ago and I was doing a tour with a popular
arroid grower, end A Falter. During that tour, I got
(06:40):
to see the plant for the first time.
Speaker 6 (06:43):
This is the awesome Spirit of Sancty, one of the
most rare philodendrons in the world. It's not in a
lot of collections, and it's hard to get a hold
of one.
Speaker 2 (06:53):
Actually, she tried to convey just how rare this plant was,
but to be honest, I didn't really grasp it at
the time.
Speaker 6 (07:02):
Well, they're first, they're expensive, and they're hard to get.
There's only a few people that even wouldever have one
to sell.
Speaker 2 (07:07):
You've got few would ever loan you at cutting either.
That scarcity however, drives an aggressive market for the rare plants.
It keeps prices high. In fact, if you bought and
held onto that plant auctioned off in Florida, its value
would have yielded an annual rate of return of about
twenty eight percent, beating out gold. Prices have been turbocharged
(07:31):
in the past few years, so much so that it's
taken experts like doctor Arinovi by surprise.
Speaker 3 (07:38):
We knew that that plant prices were going up, and
that during the pandemic, you know, people were getting more
enthusiastic about house plants and even some rare plants, which
mostly we looked at as a wonderful thing. But you know,
we started looking at eBay and other things and being like,
oh my god. We didn't realize that the same plant
that you used to be able to buy for fifteen
dollars at home depot now goes for.
Speaker 4 (07:57):
Three four hundred dollars.
Speaker 2 (07:59):
Driving this boom is classic supply and demand. There aren't
many plants, but there are a ton of people who
want them, so prices go up. In fact, one online
plant store in Britain saw sales surge five hundred percent
during lockdown. But who are these people driving up prices.
If you read the headlines, it seems pretty obvious.
Speaker 3 (08:21):
California hipster plants at the center of smuggling crisis.
Speaker 4 (08:25):
What is it with millennials and cactuses?
Speaker 1 (08:28):
If only hipsters had stuck to their handlebar, mustaches and
craft beer, this never would have happened.
Speaker 2 (08:34):
Yep, the same people who got blamed for killing the
napkin industry, mayonnaise, the nine to five workday, and lately,
well pretty much everything else. Millennials.
Speaker 3 (08:44):
We saw a whole generation of young people who previously
weren't that engaged in house plans get excited about it,
and again, that is ninety nine percent awesome. The only
thing about it that's not awesome is that it did
lead to a market that encouraged theft den poachings.
Speaker 2 (08:58):
The pandemic, of course, deserves a lot of blame too.
Millions of us, trapped inside and craving something to do,
began transforming our homes into sanctuaries, and it wasn't long
before viral posts on TikTok began touting the plant mom
and plant dad lifestyle. But the question I keep coming
back to is is that the real reason this plant
(09:20):
craze is happening? Or is there something about human nature,
something dark, that just makes us crazy for plants. Here's
the thing about our recent plant obsession. It's nothing new.
(09:44):
Just ask Charles Mackay. In the eighteen forties, Mackay, a
Scottish journalist, became fascinated with herd behavior, how certain interests
or beliefs grew to overtake entire cultures. So in eighteen
forty one, Mackay published the first volume of his book
Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, witch Hunts, Alchemy,
(10:07):
the Crusades. The book plum the Darkest Recesses of the
Human Mind, and in it Mackay concluded that these trends
and obsessions are just part of a cultural cycle.
Speaker 5 (10:18):
Millions of people become simultaneously impressed with one delusion and
drawn after it till their tension is caughked by some
new folly more captivating.
Speaker 4 (10:27):
Than the first.
Speaker 2 (10:30):
One. Such folly, he wrote, was an irrational mania for plants,
specifically tulips. It's the sixteen thirties, Holland. New trade routes
just opened to the Ottoman Empire, leading the Dutch to
quote unquote discover new foods, new spices, new ideas, and
(10:52):
of course new plants. It's an exciting time and people
are positively enchanted with everything coming out of the Far East,
including a vibrant flower native to the lush valleys of
my China and Afghanistan, the tulip. Within years, everybody in
Holland wanted to get their hands on some tulips. According
(11:15):
to Mackay, speculators began buying up bulbs, not with the
intent of planting them, but in the hopes of just
reselling them for a profit. And this rich scheme it worked.
The cost of tulip skyrocketed, with some bulbs fetching more
than a single year's wage. One bulb was valued to
(11:36):
cost as much as twelve acres of corn. But then
the craze stopped. People came to their senses the bubble burst,
Speculators panicked and prices, according to some estimates, collapsed as
much as ninety nine percent, and some people lost everything.
(12:00):
Now it's important to note that Mackay had a habit
of bending the truth a bit. His reports that this
tulip mania plunged Holland into economic ruin are exaggerated, but
the obsession was very real, as was another plant madness
growing right outside Mackay's front door. This time it was ferns.
(12:21):
In nineteenth century Britain, ferns were inescapable botanic gardens overflowed
with fern specimens. Readers gobbled up literature on the subject
and turned niche fern collecting books into best sellers. People
subscribed to fern magazines and joined fern societies, with fern
loving propagandists arguing that owning ferns was proof of intelligence
(12:44):
that improved virility and mental health. But beyond all that,
they were just another way to show off well to do.
Collectors hired explorers to trot around Panama, Honduras and Tasmania
to find rare ferns. Meanwhile, the middle class trekked towards
(13:04):
coastal hillsides and dug up the plants themselves. It was
like a treasure hunt, and it wasn't always fun in games.
According to the September eighteen sixty seven Floral World and
Garden Guide, one British woman, Miss Jane Myers, plunged off
a cliff one hundred and seventy feet to her death
(13:25):
while trying to pick a fern like tulips. The price
of foreign ferns exploded, with some selling for more than
one thousand dollars in today's money. Crook's cut wind pretty fast.
Knowing they could earn an easy shilling, they started poaching ferns.
(13:45):
It got so bad that botanists started to worry about
the plant's survival. In his book The Flora of Cornwall,
the botanist H. Davy wrote, it's.
Speaker 6 (13:54):
A shameful plundering has gone on that I now hesitate
to speak or write about localities where the royal fern grows.
Speaker 2 (14:01):
As the naturalist Peter da Boyd tells us, it wasn't epidemic,
with careless poachers catering to the demand of fern enthusiasts.
Speaker 5 (14:10):
The search for wild species led to the plundering of
woodlands and hillsides, stream sides and whole woodlands would be
effectively destroyed as regards their ferns by collecting literally tons
of fern plants where unscrupulous collectors didn't think about what
(14:32):
effect it might have on the environment. For most of
the nineteenth century, there was no law against collecting ferns, but.
Speaker 2 (14:41):
That changed in February eighteen ninety six, a periodical called
The Gardener's Chronicle documented the punishment for a pair of
fern thieves.
Speaker 8 (14:50):
Fern stealers William Moby and Charles Williams of Bexley, Kent,
were engaged with the horse and cart and the wholesale
removal of ferns. Moby was sentenced to six weeks hard
labor and Williams to one month.
Speaker 2 (15:04):
The wholesale plunder of ferns would turn the whole British
countryside into one big crime scene, and that sparked the
conservation movement.
Speaker 5 (15:13):
Such damage led to the first legal plant protection in Britain.
Speaker 2 (15:21):
Some of those laws, however, would arrive too late. The
Killarney fern or Trichomani's speciosum, admired for its lacy, almost
translucent leaves, nearly went extinct in Scotland. And that brings
us back to the present day and our pandemic induced
(15:42):
plant mania. It reminds me of something that doctor Arinovi
told us.
Speaker 3 (15:47):
But you buy it illegal plants, you may be financing
the destruction of an irreplaceable ecosystem that cannot come back.
So the stakes are kind of high, and like I said,
we unfortunately now have evidence that this big plant craze
during the pandemic may have wiped out several species around
the world just just from poaching.
Speaker 4 (16:04):
So it's it's not trivial.
Speaker 2 (16:06):
But who is really to blame? Is that boom and
prices and the surgeon poaching really driven by millennials. To
find the answer, we had to go to the coastal
cliffs of northern California. High above crashing waves and not
far from the meandering curves of Highway One, rose Dudleya Farinosa,
(16:29):
a small cliff dwelling succulent nicknamed bluff lettuce. Around twenty eighteen,
succulent poachers started plaguing these coasts, plucking thousands of Dudleya
from the cliff side. Many of the people who were
caught were Korean. One stole six hundred thousand dollars worth
(16:49):
of succulents. Headline writers pounced. Soon news agencies were claiming
that these thieves were motivated by quote, housewives and hipsters,
people who are willing to pay hundreds of dollars for
a single succulent. You might remember our friend doctor Jared
margolis So.
Speaker 7 (17:10):
The obvious sort of narratives emerged that every housewife and
hipster in South Korea wanted one of these Dudleia, and
that there was this succulent mania happening in East Asia
that was driving this trade, and that people just saw
an opportunity to steal the plants and make a huge
profit off of it.
Speaker 2 (17:27):
In other words, the madness of crowds was just working
its magic again. But something about that narrative didn't sit
right with doctor Margulis, Like, why would somebody steal Dudleya.
Speaker 7 (17:42):
These plants were legally available for purchase from a variety
of outlets in California, and they sort of looked like
a commonplace succulent, you know, they have a nice, pretty
rosette shape, and they put out a lovely sort of
inflorescence in flower. They're not a rare species, and so
people were pretty confused why suddenly it looked like people
were stealing them by the thousands from their habitat.
Speaker 2 (18:03):
Not to mention that bluff lettuce, it's not a beginner's plant.
Speaker 7 (18:07):
Dudley As are really hard to grow as houseplants, and
they really require an enormous amount of specialized care to
keep them alive outside of their native habitat. On the
West coast of California. So these were not plants that
were being bought and sold by our typical succulent consumer.
Speaker 2 (18:24):
This didn't sound like the madness of crowds at work.
This sounded like something else. Doctor Margulis needed to know more.
Speaker 7 (18:32):
I decided I had to go spend some time in
South Korea to try to really understand and do my
best to analyze these narratives and what was really happening
in the trade there.
Speaker 2 (18:45):
So Margoulis flew to Korea. He visited nurseries and garden
centers and talked to shop owners about dudley A sales.
He discovered they were not a widely popular succulent plant
amongst mainstream consumers in Seoul. Margulis popped into three of
the city's largest succulent markets. Only one was selling the
(19:06):
California Succulent. The vendor complained about a lack of demand.
This didn't fit the narrative played out back home.
Speaker 7 (19:15):
These plants are really were only being sought by highly
specialized collectors with a typically with a lot of skill
and capacity to care for them, owning and maintaining either
professional greenhouses or renting space in someone else's greenhouse in
order to keep them alive. This was not sort of
being driven by mainstream consumer culture.
Speaker 2 (19:35):
One plant dealer told Markulla's point blank, this isn't about
Chinese collectors, or Japanese collectors or Korean collectors. This is
about individual collectors and what they want. Millennial plant moms
and plant dads weren't driving the crime spree in California.
It was a small group of collectors, hardcore hobbyists, demanding
(19:57):
that the plant be ripped from the ground, and as
it turns out, they'd do just about anything to have it.
(20:18):
You can hear the pain in doctor Novi's voice when
he thinks back to the spirit of sancty heist.
Speaker 3 (20:24):
It would almost have been better if, like somebody was
trying to steal our computers and like ruin the plants incidentally,
because you know, you should have understand petty theft. But
this is like premeditated, Let's find the rarest plant around
here and steal it, taking it away from public usage.
Speaker 2 (20:45):
After the initial shock of the robbery, the botanic Garden
notified police, who at first didn't really understand the magnitude
of the crime.
Speaker 3 (20:53):
Probably the first second we were talking to law enforcement
they probably were like, you know, this is some person
in a neighborhood, and like, you know, some neighbors stole
their prizes. But like, you know, as soon as we
said here's who we are, this plant could sell for
between ten and fifteen thousand dollars on the open market.
Like they're like, oh, and I think they treated it
like any object you know of that level value, if
you know, if somebody called up and said, you know,
(21:14):
someone stole my car.
Speaker 2 (21:15):
But the Botanic Garden was already at a disadvantage when
it comes to high level plant crimes. Most local law
enforcement officers are extremely inexperienced.
Speaker 3 (21:25):
Back in the nineteen nineties, when the Garden did have
the theft of psychic heads, the garden benefited from the
fact that the Sheriff's office in San Diego had an
Agricultural Crimes division.
Speaker 2 (21:33):
That's right, an entire unit dedicated to plant crimes, which
is not super common, especially these days.
Speaker 3 (21:40):
So there are no longer, to our knowledge, detectives within
the San Diego law enforcement community that are specifically trained
on and or daily dealing with agricultural, plant and animal theft.
Speaker 4 (21:51):
Law enforcement doesn't get to practice it as much.
Speaker 3 (21:54):
It means a certain kind of expertise is not present
when it does happen.
Speaker 2 (21:58):
So to say the least, the police did not turn
up many promising leads. At one point, they suggested the
possibility of an inside job. The idea had merit. One
prominent plant influencer online bragged that whenever he volunteered at
botanic gardens, he'd steal rare clippings. The practice called proplifting,
(22:20):
a portmanteau of propagate and shoplifting, is increasingly common. A
Reddit page dedicated to legal and I Stress legal proplifting
has more than two hundred thousand members. But in San Diego,
the theft of the Spirit of Sancty went beyond simple proplifting.
This was the work of an obsessive who knew what
(22:42):
they were doing, and it would only be solved with
the help of other obsessives. And that is when the
gardens started getting tips from other plant lovers. People began
trawling forums and social media looking for somebody, anybody trying
to sell the famed plant.
Speaker 3 (23:04):
We started to get from the online aroid community saying, hey,
we're seeing some chatter, you know, in some of the
you know, blogs and social media. So that there might
be a plant for sale that sounds like it might
potentially be yours. The timing is right, the size and
this and that.
Speaker 2 (23:21):
Pictures of the plant in question began turning up in
the San Diego botanist inbox. One of them caught Novi's eye.
Speaker 3 (23:28):
Plant people are like dog people, and you know, we
look at the plants in the same way that dog
people or other pet owners, you know, or pet parents,
you know, look at their pets. And so, you know,
we know how many leaves that were on that one,
We know the color differences between young leaves and old leaves,
and so we told law enforcement and others that the
plant in question looked a heck of a lot like
(23:49):
our plant.
Speaker 2 (23:50):
So the police did their investigation.
Speaker 3 (23:52):
Law enforcement actually went to see one of the individuals
who some people in the community thought either may have
stolen it or somehow acquired it, you know, maybe they
thought it was legal and was reselling it. Law enforcement
told us that the person had an all buy or
just there wasn't enough evidence.
Speaker 4 (24:07):
They couldn't move any further.
Speaker 2 (24:12):
So the investigation stalled, and Novena's colleagues resigned themselves to
the fact that the plant was probably lost forever.
Speaker 3 (24:21):
I would put money on the fact that this plant died.
I mean, this thing was so hacked up, like you know,
they're very hard to root. I think somebody sold this
plant for fifteen thousand dollars and the person who bought
it didn't really know what they're doing, and.
Speaker 4 (24:33):
I think it died.
Speaker 5 (24:35):
You know.
Speaker 3 (24:35):
That's like for us, you know, and when you've cared
for that plant for ten or more years and it's
it's pretty devastating, you know. But I think, like everything else,
you know, you try to build resilience from tragedy.
Speaker 2 (24:48):
But that's tough. Because the theft at the San Diego
Botanic Garden, it's not uncommon. The list of thefts from
institutions to community gardens stretches from Jerusalem to Sydney to
Penang Church, New Zealand. A single plant where three thousand
(25:08):
New Zealand dollars was pilford in Coral Gables, Florida, robbers
ran off with two thousand dollars worth of greenery in
Brooklyn five thousand dollars and because of these thieves, the
public has lost priceless bonzize, rare orchids, and the world's
smallest water lily. The basic fact is, if you know
(25:32):
a botanic garden, somebody has probably stolen from.
Speaker 3 (25:36):
This is not someone's stealing a loaf of bread because
they're hungry, right, I mean, this is somebody very clearly
taking something that's not theirs, that's being maintained by a public,
nonprofit institution to benefit the public and posterity, and deciding
to try to create personal value and wealth gain out
of that theft.
Speaker 4 (25:53):
So, I mean, I.
Speaker 3 (25:54):
Don't think we have to dance around whether or not
it's evil. Is it, you know, evil on a high level.
That's a different.
Speaker 2 (25:59):
Question, and it's a question we're going to grapple with
for the rest of this show because rhymes like this
go far beyond questions of whether it's right or wrong
to steal. It shows how a passionate hobby or obsession
could put the planet end people's lives at risk. Next episode,
(26:21):
we dive deeper into the shadows following a team of
poachers and join the detectives who are hot on their tail.
Speaker 9 (26:28):
Ended up going to this really kind of sketchy pot
of just flown cattail knocker territory in Mexico. I'm just
gone met us on the side of the highway on
his Marta black and he was departure.
Speaker 2 (26:41):
I'm Summer rain Oaks. Join us again next time for
Bad Seeds. Bad Seeds is a production of School of
Humans and iHeart Podcasts. I'm your Host Summer rain Oaks.
Lucas Riley is our writer, Gabby Watts is our producer,
and Amelia Brock is our senior producer. Fact Checking is
(27:02):
by Savannah Hugely and Zoe Farrow. Music is by Claire Campbell.
Sound design and score is by Jesse Niswanger. Development was
by Brian Lavin and Jacob Selzer. Special thanks to our
voice actors Etily's Perez, Frank Swain, Reuben wu and Paul Feiffe.
Executive producers are Brian Lavin, Elsie Crowley, Brandon Barr, Virginia
(27:25):
Prescott and Jacob Selzer.
Speaker 1 (27:40):
School of Humans
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.
The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show
The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show. Clay Travis and Buck Sexton tackle the biggest stories in news, politics and current events with intelligence and humor. From the border crisis, to the madness of cancel culture and far-left missteps, Clay and Buck guide listeners through the latest headlines and hot topics with fun and entertaining conversations and opinions.