Illinois Property Tax Prosecutions, Part 1: Acquittals, Public Corruption, And What Snyder Changed

Episode Summary: In this episode of Devine Intervention: Shedding Light on Illinois Property Tax, host Nora Devine welcomes back attorney John Mitchell of Wilkie Farr & Gallagher to discuss recent corruption prosecutions in the Illinois property tax space. Mitchell, a former federal prosecutor who secured a high-profile acquittal for lobbyist Mike McClain, explains how federal bribery law under 18 U.S.C. § 666 has shifted following the Supreme Court’s decision in United States v. Snyder. Together, they unpack the differences between bribery and gratuities, how these changes affected recent property tax cases, and why proving quid pro quo arrangements is now more challenging for prosecutors. They also explore the real costs of investigations, the role of Illinois’ gift ban in federal cases, and the importance of compliance for both public officials and private citizens.

Key Timestamps:

00:01 – Show introduction and John Mitchell’s background 04:15 – Recap of the Mike McClain acquittal and its significance 07:40 – Recent corruption cases in the Cook County Assessor’s Office 12:28 – The role of 18 U.S.C. § 666 in prosecuting bribery cases 16:10 – How United States v. Snyder narrowed the definition of bribery 20:45 – Distinguishing between bribery and gratuities in practice 25:32 – Testimony from assessor’s office employees and credibility challenges 30:15 – Why prosecutors targeted a private property owner instead of officials 34:55 – Hidden costs of federal investigations and trials 38:20 – How Illinois’ Gift Ban Act factors into federal prosecutions 42:10 – Nora’s closing remarks and where to find John Mitchell

About the Show:

Devine Intervention: Shedding Light on Illinois Property Tax is hosted by attorney Nora Devine, who has practiced in the property tax field since 2005. Each episode breaks down complex issues at the intersection of property taxation, law, and public policy. Through conversations with legal experts and practitioners, Nora provides clear, actionable insights for property owners, professionals, and public officials.