Why So Many “Confident” Guys Are Secretly Insecure

Gay culture rewards visibility, desirability, and dominance, so a lot of what looks like confidence is actually performance under pressure. In this episode, we unpack the myths of self-confidence gay men inherit and what real confidence looks like when no one’s watching.

In this conversation, we explore:

• What traits often get mistaken for confidence in gay culture
• How social media amplifies performative confidence and quietly fuels insecurity
• Why confidence built on validation, desirability, or status is inherently fragile
• How childhood experiences and early coping strategies shape what confidence feels safe to express
• The difference between looking confident and being confident
• Why real confidence isn’t the absence of insecurity and why it naturally shifts over time

This episode isn’t about fixing yourself or learning how to project confidence. It’s about understanding why the version you were taught to chase often feels exhausting, and what a quieter, more grounded confidence actually looks like in real life.

Today's Hosts:

• Michael DiIorio - Take the 360° Self-Review for Gay Men
• Matt Landsiedel
• Reno Johnston

Support the Show - viewer and listener support helps us to continue making episodes

- CONNECT WITH US -

• Watch podcast episodes on YouTube
• Join the Gay Men's Brotherhood Facebook community
• Get on our email list to get access to our monthly Zoom calls
• Follow us on Instagram | TikTok
• Learn more about our community at GayMenGoingDeeper.com

- LEARN WITH US -

• Building Better Relationships online course: Learn how to nurture more meaningful and authentic connections with yourself and others.
• Healing Your Shame online course: Begin the journey toward greater confidence and self-worth by learning how to recognize and deal with toxic shame.
• Gay Men Going Deeper Coaching Collection: Lifetime access to BOTH courses + 45 coaching videos and 2 workshop series.
• Take the Attachment Style Quiz to determine your attachment style and get a fr...

Chapters

• (00:00:05) - Gays Go Deep: Why So Many Confident Gay Men Are
• (00:00:59) - How Confidence For Gay Men Is Decoded
• (00:04:32) - What Are The Traits That Get Mistaken for Confidence in
• (00:09:03) - The Gay Gay Male Hypothesis
• (00:10:39) - Gay Men Reveal How Much Confidence They Have
• (00:15:52) - The Need for Codependence
• (00:16:48) - What Makes a Confident Person?
• (00:21:58) - Is Your Confidence Dependent on Social Media?
• (00:23:11) - The Need for Self-Confidence
• (00:25:15) - Want to Attend a Connection Circle? Here!
• (00:26:10) - What Does Real Confidence Look Like In Real Life?
• (00:29:16) - What Does Real Confidence Look Like In Real Life?
• (00:33:28) - Is There A Difference Between Confidence And Heart-centered Confidence
• (00:35:59) - What does real confidence look like in real life?
• (00:36:24) -