“Closure” and “Finality” Ring Hollow with Victim’s Families

Bryan Kohberger’s lifesaving plea has been accepted and he now resides in the care and custody of the Idaho corrections system. Presumably, for the rest of his life. He was not asked, nor did he volunteer a statement with an explanation or motive for the attacks, nor did he disclose the whereabouts of the weapon(s) and/or other evidence, nor did he offer any apologies or comfort to the surviving family members. He only said he was guilty and the prosecutor and judge took him at his word.

The prosecutor and the trial judge are on record saying this outcome will bring some form of finality for the victims’ families and allow them to begin to move forward with their lives. In this episode, we address the shortsightedness of imagining there is ever finality to a highly publicized case in either courts of law or the court of public opinion.

Bill explains that while Kohberger promised to never appeal the decision, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) ruled a short seven years ago that the 6th Amendment to the Constitution guarantees the right to an appeal even where a defendant waived that right as part of his plea agreement. Ironically in that case, SCOTUS overruled the Idaho Supreme Court who had previously denied the defendant his right to appeal. Bill addresses several legal scenarios where an appeal(s) could still be possible, if not probable, for Kohberger.

 

We look ahead and discuss the increasing media intensity that has been present from the moment the four victims were discovered in their off-campus housing early on a Sunday morning. This was never a local story, but one that was featured on national and international news platforms from the gruesome beginning through Kohberger’s sentencing. Now that previously withheld information and documentation have been released and the people with direct and indirect involvement in the investigation and prosecution are free to speak to the media, the doors have opened wide to the legions of people who want to question, speculate, and opine about the entire process. Similarly, the “experts” are lining up to offer their presumptions and opinions. Books and magazine articles are being written, movies and documentaries are already in production, podcasts and blogs dedicated to True Crime and psycho killers are churning out new episodes daily. 

There is no chance or hope for finality to this story, and honestly there never was! The devastating and lasting impact this will have on the families and the Moscow community will play out over the coming years.