Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Ejaaz:
So there's this company called windsurf which in (00:02):
undefined
Ejaaz:
the last 24 hours got stolen from open ai (00:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
and sold not once but twice for (00:08):
undefined
Ejaaz:
over 3 billion dollars and then (00:12):
undefined
Ejaaz:
everyone lost their minds completely when they realized that (00:15):
undefined
Ejaaz:
two of the co-founders were taking almost all of that money (00:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
for themselves and leaving the rest of the (00:21):
undefined
Ejaaz:
company 250 employees in the (00:23):
undefined
Ejaaz:
dust and as you can imagine josh this sparked a lot of outrage online but it (00:26):
undefined
Ejaaz:
did end up having a fairy tale ending when another company swooped in and bought (00:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
the rest of the company and the 250 employees got paid josh i'm exhausted can (00:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
you tell me what's happening well (00:42):
undefined
Josh:
I'm actually not sure myself this feels like an episode out of like a sitcom (00:44):
undefined
Josh:
or a silicon valley episode where there's so much drama so many twists and turns (00:47):
undefined
Josh:
that seemingly don't make any sense i mean it was. (00:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Acquired i have a fun anecdote for you josh actually the office that the windsurf (00:54):
undefined
Ejaaz:
company was set up in guess no (00:58):
undefined
Josh:
Not silicon valley, (01:02):
undefined
Josh:
oh man it's so real silicon valley was such a testament at the. (01:06):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Time so i swear they (01:09):
undefined
Josh:
Were they were ahead of the curve but yeah i i'm actually i'm excited to record (01:10):
undefined
Josh:
this episode because i need you to explain to me a lot of what's happening i (01:14):
undefined
Josh:
don't know too much about the recent news i've been very much in in the grok (01:17):
undefined
Josh:
rabbit hole i know a lot of the earlier topics maybe i could help set the stage before we get into it. (01:21):
undefined
Josh:
So for people who aren't familiar, Windsurf was not always Windsurf. (01:26):
undefined
Josh:
It was a company that was founded in 2021 called Exifunction. (01:29):
undefined
Josh:
And it was founded by two MIT graduates initially focused on GPU optimization. (01:33):
undefined
Josh:
So they were a GPU optimizer company. (01:37):
undefined
Josh:
They were doing absolutely nothing relative to what they're doing today. (01:39):
undefined
Josh:
Three years later, they raised a series C round at $150 million, (01:43):
undefined
Josh:
which valued them unicorn status, one and a quarter billion dollars. (01:46):
undefined
Josh:
And that was when they rebranded to Windsurf. And Windsurf was not a GPU optimization (01:50):
undefined
Josh:
company. It was instead the company that we all know today, which is the AI (01:55):
undefined
Josh:
coding companion, cursor competitor, vibe coding extraordinaire. (01:59):
undefined
Josh:
Exactly. Yeah. So that's when they kind of came into their final form, (02:04):
undefined
Josh:
which was only last year. (02:07):
undefined
Josh:
So the first three years of operation, this like strange company trying to figure (02:09):
undefined
Josh:
it out last year, it was huge. (02:14):
undefined
Josh:
And then we get into 2025 where their annual revenue went from not a lot to (02:15):
undefined
Josh:
a hundred million plus. And I think this is where I'm going to hand it off to (02:19):
undefined
Josh:
you because things got crazy. (02:22):
undefined
Josh:
They turned into a really big company. They started collecting valuable data. (02:23):
undefined
Josh:
Their revenue went through the roof into the nine figures. (02:26):
undefined
Josh:
And that's where this drama begins. (02:29):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So Josh, do you remember around that time, it became a kind of trending narrative that AI... (02:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Coding or coders was going to replace software engineers. So companies were (02:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
getting really nervous and software engineers were getting really nervous because (02:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
they were kind of like consistently held in as like the highest regard of employee, right? (02:46):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You had like knowledge workers, product managers, and then you had like the (02:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
wizards at the top that could like create software with their fingers. (02:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then you had AI come along and be like, well, actually, we might be able (02:58):
undefined
Ejaaz:
to replace you in about six months. (03:01):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So all of these companies' valuations skyrocketed, Winsurf being one of them, right? (03:03):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Cursor was another popular one. And there was this massive frenzy for all the (03:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
model creator companies like OpenAI, Claude, Meta, to try and acquire one of (03:11):
undefined
Ejaaz:
these companies so that they can have that feature set within their own product suite. (03:17):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And OpenAI kind of came in guns ablaze and said, Winsurf, we have tried to buy Cursor. (03:21):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It's not working. We need you. And we are willing to pay big bucks. (03:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So they offered basically $3 billion and it's written here in this Reuters article, (03:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
but that's basically the headline takeaway that they offered $3 billion to buy these guys out. (03:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And that was a huge price tag at the time, but it was what a lot of individuals (03:42):
undefined
Ejaaz:
thought, a lot of people thought that Winsurf and AI vibe coding companies was worth at the time. (03:47):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And the reason why it was worth this much was because it was like this magical (03:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
tool where you could type words and turn words into fully fledged apps, (03:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
games, tools, services, (04:01):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Therapy apps, gym logs, whatever you might, whatever your mind could potentially think of. (04:03):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It's like turning chat gbt into like this like app (04:08):
undefined
Ejaaz:
maker and that as you can imagine is a billion dollar multi-billion dollar industry (04:11):
undefined
Ejaaz:
and you can kind of like see on my screen here like there's this like demo on (04:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
this website where you can effectively just type words in and say like hey i (04:19):
undefined
Ejaaz:
want you to create like a folder or a website that like kind of displays my (04:24):
undefined
Ejaaz:
profile picture and all these kinds of things and it just (04:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You can see it coding in real time on the left here, Josh. (04:30):
undefined
Josh:
Yeah, and the interface is the thing that's different, right? (04:33):
undefined
Josh:
Because when you're using ChatGPT, it can code very well, but you only have (04:36):
undefined
Josh:
a text box and it kind of spits out code, but then you have to put it into your (04:39):
undefined
Josh:
compiler and it creates this like very messy workflow. (04:42):
undefined
Josh:
What Windsurf did is they kind of took that whole workflow and compressed it (04:45):
undefined
Josh:
down into one really powerful tool. (04:48):
undefined
Josh:
And that's what we're seeing here, right? It's like, this is the developers (04:50):
undefined
Josh:
come all in one, build your code, generate your code, debug your code all under one roof. Right. (04:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So you can imagine that if you are a software engineer that learns how to use (04:59):
undefined
Ejaaz:
this tool or gets access to a tool like this, you can suddenly work at 10x your (05:04):
undefined
Ejaaz:
speed and output, right? (05:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So there's this term that's often used in tech, which is called like 100x engineer, (05:10):
undefined
Ejaaz:
and they're usually super rare. (05:14):
undefined
Ejaaz:
This tool turns everyone into 100x engineer. (05:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And that means that you could hire probably fewer engineers to get your thing (05:20):
undefined
Ejaaz:
done, or you could scale your company 100x from where it is right now, (05:24):
undefined
Ejaaz:
just using existing employees and access to this tool, which is insane, right? (05:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So you can imagine something like this is worth a ton of money. (05:31):
undefined
Ejaaz:
But if you remember on a previous episode, Josh, we actually mentioned that (05:34):
undefined
Ejaaz:
OpenAI wasn't just, didn't just get to where they were on their own, right? (05:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
They had some pretty impressive backers behind them. And one of their backers (05:44):
undefined
Ejaaz:
was this little known company called Microsoft. (05:48):
undefined
Josh:
I remember that. (05:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You remember Microsoft? You know, they've been around a while, (05:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
right and some of the terms that microsoft struck with open air when they invested (05:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
i think something to the tune of 16 billion dollars josh or is it like 24 i (06:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
feel like i'm off by like 10 billion which is just like tens of billions tens (06:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
of billions okay let's just go with casual tens of billions (06:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Part of the terms that they struck with OpenAI was that they get full access (06:12):
undefined
Ejaaz:
and IP control over OpenAI's models up until the year 2030. (06:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And also they get a significant chunk of revenue that OpenAI generates. (06:20):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And the final point, which is what is about to cause the rift that I'm about (06:25):
undefined
Ejaaz:
to describe, was access to any and all IP that they may acquire as well, Josh. (06:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So as you can imagine, OpenAI is buying this massively valuable company, (06:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Windsurf, for $3 billion. (06:41):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And their plan presumably is to build an amazing product suite and earn tons of money from it. (06:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
But Microsoft would be eligible to owning the IP of Windsurf. (06:48):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And Sam Altman, OpenAI didn't like this. (06:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So the rumor behind the scene was that Sam Altman was negotiating with Microsoft, (06:54):
undefined
Ejaaz:
basically trying to get them off the cap table with that respect and not give (07:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
them access to Windsurf. (07:03):
undefined
Ejaaz:
There was a lot of back and forth, a lot of insider knowledge, (07:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
basically saying that Satya wasn't happy and that they couldn't come to an agreement. (07:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So the rumor was Satya walked away from the negotiating table. (07:11):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Now, typically, when an offer is made as big as this, $3 billion, (07:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It comes with some terms and conditions. (07:20):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And usually it comes with an expiry date. (07:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So if, God forbid, anything goes wrong, the deal suddenly becomes off the table. (07:24):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So, you know, typically anyone has kind of like an out. (07:29):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And what happened after Microsoft walked away from the negotiating table was (07:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
that this $3 billion dollar offer josh expired on july 11th so literally a few (07:36):
undefined
Ejaaz:
days ago and that's when all the drama started (07:42):
undefined
Josh:
Unwinding expiration that is like a tremendous amount of money just to let, (07:45):
undefined
Josh:
expire right i feel like if i was i mean put yourself (07:51):
undefined
Josh:
in the the shoes of a windsurf employee where you own (07:54):
undefined
Josh:
equity you are worth on paper now a tremendous amount (07:58):
undefined
Josh:
of money and you're sitting there every day waking up looking at (08:00):
undefined
Josh:
like the news like am i going to get this money or is this (08:04):
undefined
Josh:
going to respond and then it expires it's like an option if you have a call (08:06):
undefined
Josh:
option it just expired worthless you you're left with nothing so now the windsurf (08:09):
undefined
Josh:
employee i guess i'll play that role because i'm pretty clueless in this whole (08:14):
undefined
Josh:
thing i'm pretty sad but i know my company's still worth a lot so like what (08:16):
undefined
Josh:
happens next to me as the windsurf employee after okay a ideal falls through i. (08:21):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Want you to to envision this josh okay so you're a windsurf employee and you've (08:26):
undefined
Ejaaz:
kind of been told that OpenAI is going to buy you for $3 billion. (08:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You go to bed one day, you wake up the next, and you realize that the deal has expired, right? (08:35):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then a couple of hours, yeah, it's expired, it's done. (08:40):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then a couple of hours later, you open up your laptop and you see this tweet. (08:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Josh, tell me about your reaction. (08:50):
undefined
Josh:
Big welcome to Mohan Solo and others from the Windsurf team joining DeepMind. (08:52):
undefined
Josh:
Now, if I remember correctly, the name of my CEO is the same handle that that was tagged in this post. (08:56):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Exactly. (09:03):
undefined
Josh:
Okay, you're good so far. I believe I've just learned that the CEO of my company, (09:03):
undefined
Josh:
as well as other, I guess, higher executives. (09:08):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You, the Windsurf team. (09:11):
undefined
Josh:
Me. I'm joining Google. I'm going to Google today. You're joining Google. (09:13):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You're joining Google, Josh. You're joining Google. Congrats. (09:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Are they paying me $3 billion? (09:20):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Exactly. And now your question is, are you paying $3 billion? (09:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Well, what if I told you this, Josh? They're not paying you $3 billion. (09:25):
undefined
Ejaaz:
They're paying you a little less. They're paying you $2.4 billion. (09:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Okay. How does that sound? So far, so good? Yeah. (09:35):
undefined
Josh:
I mean, at least better than nothing. (09:38):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You'll take that. You'll take it, right? (09:39):
undefined
Josh:
That'll make me multimillionaire for sure. That seems pretty chill. (09:41):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Sounds good. Except that there's one clause, which is that $2.4 billion is actually (09:45):
undefined
Ejaaz:
being used to buy your CEO that was just named in that tweet, (09:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
one of his other co-founders and about four researchers on the entire company team. (09:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So this $2.4 (10:03):
undefined
Josh:
Billion is really just an acqui-hire for the talent. (10:04):
undefined
Josh:
A hundred percent. And they're still not buying my company. (10:10):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Yeah. So the long story short of this is Google announced that they struck a (10:14):
undefined
Ejaaz:
deal with Winsurf, particularly the CEO, and agreed to pay $2.4 billion, (10:20):
undefined
Ejaaz:
but primarily to hire Winsurf CEO and one other co-founder and a group of key researchers, (10:26):
undefined
Ejaaz:
along with the non-exclusive rights, non-exclusive licensing rights to some (10:32):
undefined
Ejaaz:
of Winsurf's technology. (10:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So this is, as you said, yeah, you just got zapped. They just paid a couple (10:41):
undefined
Josh:
Hundred million dollars, took the talent out of my company, and now I'm just (10:44):
undefined
Josh:
left with the shell, which is devastating, right? (10:47):
undefined
Josh:
I work so hard on building this. I am the reason this value exists because I (10:50):
undefined
Josh:
have been working hardcore engineering on this for years, And that seems really upsetting. (10:54):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Think about it. You are a founding engineer of this company. (10:59):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You're a founding employee of this company. (11:02):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Typically, you'd expect when you go from zero to $3 billion, (11:04):
undefined
Ejaaz:
you're going to see at least some of that. (11:08):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Surely, they're not going to concentrate over $1.25 billion for a single person. (11:11):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Surely, that's ludicrous, right? But that's unfortunately exactly what happened. (11:17):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So $2.4 billion for like five people and non-exclusive licensing rights for (11:21):
undefined
Ejaaz:
like some of Windsurf's tech. (11:27):
undefined
Ejaaz:
But the majority of the 250 people, its core business, the IP, (11:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
the product, the brand, and the remaining team just kind of got left to the wayside. (11:33):
undefined
Ejaaz:
This was a pure play acquire. (11:38):
undefined
Josh:
Yikes. And I guess we could kind of speculate on what led to this. (11:41):
undefined
Josh:
Like if you remember, we actually spoke about this briefly on the show when (11:45):
undefined
Josh:
OpenAI made the offer to acquire Windsurf, immediately Anthropic and a few others (11:49):
undefined
Josh:
started pulling out their contracts with Windsurf. (11:53):
undefined
Josh:
So they were making the product less valuable because they didn't want to give (11:56):
undefined
Josh:
their data over to OpenAI. (12:00):
undefined
Josh:
As a result, it lowered the valuation of the company. (12:02):
undefined
Josh:
So when OpenAI then steps away and Winsurf still has to deal with the lost customers (12:05):
undefined
Josh:
of Anthropic and whoever else stepped away, well, suddenly the company is worth a little bit less. (12:12):
undefined
Josh:
And now Google steps in, they're like, okay, well, maybe we get a discount because (12:16):
undefined
Josh:
now your average revenue or your recurring revenue is way lower than it was (12:19):
undefined
Josh:
just a few months ago. So there's your 25% haircut. (12:24):
undefined
Josh:
And then they're like, well, we don't actually want the business because the (12:27):
undefined
Josh:
business is kind of failing. There's a lot of drama. (12:31):
undefined
Josh:
There's a lot of, a lot of your larger clients aren't interested because they're direct competitors. (12:33):
undefined
Josh:
So let's just take the talent. And that is such a sad thing to watch your baby (12:37):
undefined
Josh:
just get pummeled over and over again by these high executives. (12:42):
undefined
Josh:
But it's on, it's on brand, right? Like we've seen this happen before. (12:47):
undefined
Josh:
Zuck is offering hundreds of millions to billions for employees. (12:50):
undefined
Josh:
And now Google is doing the same exact thing. (12:54):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I think you just highlighted a really important trend, which has just been confirmed. (12:57):
undefined
Ejaaz:
By these events, Josh, which is the stars of the show for any AI company are (13:01):
undefined
Ejaaz:
its researchers, are its model creators. (13:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
They're the ones that are selling for like multiples of a top NBA super sports star, right? (13:10):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Hundreds and hundreds of millions, potentially billions for a single person. (13:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
That is just an absurd amount of money and has probably never been seen the (13:23):
undefined
Ejaaz:
like from any kind of industry before, right? (13:27):
undefined
Josh:
They're like professional sports athletes. (13:29):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Yeah. Yeah, they're not worth their weight in gold. They're worth a hundred (13:31):
undefined
Ejaaz:
times their weight in gold, apparently, right? (13:35):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then the second thing I think that's happening here, Josh, (13:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
is Google got a bit antsy when they saw that Zuck aggressively poached OpenAI's staff. (13:40):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I think they hired like, what, 10 people? So that's probably somewhere around (13:48):
undefined
Ejaaz:
$2.5 billion spent, if we want to believe the rumors of like hundreds of millions (13:53):
undefined
Ejaaz:
being spent for certain researchers. (13:58):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So Google's probably watched this happen over the last two weeks, (14:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
which is an insane thing to say, by the way. (14:03):
undefined
Ejaaz:
This has happened over the last two weeks and thought, oh shit, we're next in line. (14:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
We're the next best model provider for many a reason. (14:10):
undefined
Ejaaz:
They have access to all our AI papers so they can see who the best researchers that we have are. (14:13):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And Zuck's probably reaching out to all of these. So they saw this opportunity (14:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
and jumped on it and decided to do the opposite and say, well, screw you, Zuck. (14:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I know what you're coming for, but I'm going to jump ahead of the curve and (14:27):
undefined
Ejaaz:
actually poach these guys before you do so that we keep bolstering confidence (14:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
in our team and our ability to build up the team? What do you think of that? Is that fair? (14:34):
undefined
Josh:
Yeah, well, one of the biggest things I've been wondering is like, (14:39):
undefined
Josh:
how are they actually worth $100 million? How are they worth a billion dollars for a single person? (14:42):
undefined
Josh:
And I posted this publicly and I like did some digging and the answer is really, (14:47):
undefined
Josh:
it's still a fuzzy answer, but basically they're a series of difficult problems, (14:52):
undefined
Josh:
most of which are unknown that are required to be solved in order to reach this goal. (14:56):
undefined
Josh:
So in the case of training improvements, I mean, we spoke about Kimi K2 yesterday. (15:01):
undefined
Josh:
The reason that model performed so well is was because a novel breakthrough (15:06):
undefined
Josh:
that a researcher discovered and then deployed into the code base. (15:09):
undefined
Josh:
And now they have a model that competes with Claude, but it's open source and free to use. (15:12):
undefined
Josh:
So that's a huge advantage. And that is a multi-billion dollar advantage at scale. (15:16):
undefined
Josh:
So if you can pay one researcher to come up with a novel breakthrough like this (15:20):
undefined
Josh:
and then deploy it to your code base, then suddenly you have gained billions (15:24):
undefined
Josh:
of dollars of market cap. and it compounds because the scale is so large. (15:28):
undefined
Josh:
And this exists all the way down the stack because when you're doing a training (15:32):
undefined
Josh:
run, I mean, a lot of these companies have 100,000, 200,000 GPUs that are all (15:34):
undefined
Josh:
focused on one single training run. (15:38):
undefined
Josh:
And that means they can't be serving customers. They can't be serving queries (15:41):
undefined
Josh:
to make the company money. (15:44):
undefined
Josh:
It is a net spend that they're incurring to train this model. (15:45):
undefined
Josh:
And in the case that an engineer didn't make the right decision or went down (15:49):
undefined
Josh:
the wrong decision tree, that could cost them many, many billions of dollars, (15:54):
undefined
Josh:
days, weeks of time. and in this world, those weeks cost a lot of money. (15:59):
undefined
Josh:
So basically what I realized, what I came to consensus on is they're just giving (16:03):
undefined
Josh:
themselves the best probability by having the most intelligent people on the (16:06):
undefined
Josh:
specific topic of making the correct decision trees required to get to where they want to go. (16:11):
undefined
Josh:
And that is why the stakes are so high. And that's why they're being paid billions (16:15):
undefined
Josh:
of dollars because someone like Ilya, who has been around for a decade plus, (16:19):
undefined
Josh:
is probably most likely to make the right decisions, even though it's no guarantee. (16:23):
undefined
Ejaaz:
What you've just described is the wild west and (16:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
i love how you described it as kind of like an ai model (16:31):
undefined
Ejaaz:
josh you were like it's probabilistic we don't (16:34):
undefined
Ejaaz:
really know which path it's going to take but they're running it through this (16:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
model and they're estimating that the output would be like this so they're spending (16:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
hundreds of millions of dollars i thought it was beautifully done but josh if (16:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
you remember at the start of this episode i said that it ended like a fairy (16:47):
undefined
Ejaaz:
tale So right now, we're at devastation point, right? (16:52):
undefined
Josh:
I'm deep in my nightmare right now. I'm living it. I've just seen my entire (16:56):
undefined
Josh:
C-suite get poached for two and a half billion dollars. I got nothing. (16:59):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You just hustled for five to 10 years and you have nothing to show for it. (17:02):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You have a family of kids to feed and you promised them you're going to get (17:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
them millions and nothing's happened, right? (17:11):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So here's what happens next. Do you remember way back when, and I think this (17:14):
undefined
Ejaaz:
is like a year ago, when the first AI engineer agent was released. (17:19):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It was this thing called Devin, D-E-V-I-N. Do you remember that? (17:25):
undefined
Josh:
I do, yeah. Yeah. (17:28):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Yeah. Do you remember the hype that was caused because of it? (17:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I think they released like this 30 second demo of this really slick AI agent. (17:34):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It's kind of like ChatGPT, but it was just doing all the coding and engineers (17:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
lost their mind. They were like, oh my God, I would. There were two camps. (17:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
One, I would love using a tool like this and it'll enhance me 10x or whatever. (17:46):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then a vast swathe of people online that hated it and said, (17:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
there's no way it's as good as it is. and then, you know, A16Z jumped in. (17:56):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I think they threw them like a $200 million check, classic A16Z. (18:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And there was a lot of hype around this. That was like one of the clearest signals (18:03):
undefined
Ejaaz:
early on that Vibe coding was going to become a thing. Do you remember that? (18:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I do. So this company that created Devin is called Cognition. (18:10):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And we saw this post come up literally the day after Google's acquisition. (18:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So imagine you wake up one day, you realize you've lost the OpenAI deal. You're like, damn. (18:21):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then a few hours later, So you see the tweet from Logan Kilpatrick from (18:26):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Google saying, hey, we bought you for $2.4 billion. (18:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
You're elated until you realize that you're not getting paid any of that stuff. (18:33):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So you go into like peak depression. (18:37):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then the next day, you see an announcement from Cognition. (18:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And this is the official announcement on Cognition's website. (18:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Cognition acquires Winsurf. (18:45):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And it's this joint announcement from the CEO of Cognition, which is Scott Wu. (18:48):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And one of the co-founders and by the way this is the co-founder that didn't (18:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
get included in the $2.4 billion win self deal Man, that's got to sting Yeah, (18:59):
undefined
Ejaaz:
yeah, yeah Well, calling him a co-founder is kind of like a bit of a (19:04):
undefined
Ejaaz:
kind of like graceful title to give him. But his name is Jeff Wang. (19:08):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And he was the recently appointed CEO after the two co-founders just ditched him, basically. (19:12):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And they were like, okay, Jeff, you're head of BD, but we need you to step up (19:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
as CEO because we're going to bounce and take this billion dollar check. (19:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
But you're the new CEO. So this guy, Jeff Wang, and this CEO, Scott Wu of Cognition, (19:25):
undefined
Ejaaz:
struck a deal to basically take over the remaining IP, product, (19:33):
undefined
Ejaaz:
brand, And remaining team, most importantly, 250 individuals all have families, (19:38):
undefined
Ejaaz:
mouths to feed, whatever lives to live and include them in this package deal. (19:43):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So this was the major announcement that like kind of like swept the social media (19:48):
undefined
Ejaaz:
realms and made everyone super happy and elated by this and, (19:52):
undefined
Ejaaz:
you know, gave them their happy ending. (19:56):
undefined
Josh:
What was the total cost that they paid? Did they announce that? (19:58):
undefined
Ejaaz:
That's a great question. Let me pull up this tweet of this guy called Harry. (20:01):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Oh, here we are. His title is Harry Digresses. (20:06):
undefined
Ejaaz:
It wasn't official how much they got paid for, but there were some really amazing (20:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
deal terms in this, Josh. (20:13):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So I'll highlight a few things here. The first one is this. (20:14):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So not only were all 250 employees that were left behind going to get paid, (20:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
but they were going to have all their cliffs removed and have accelerated vesting on all their equity. (20:24):
undefined
Josh:
Amazing. Okay. So they're making things right, or at least as best they can. (20:30):
undefined
Josh:
It's not the $3 billion dollar offer initially but like they're doing the best (20:33):
undefined
Josh:
they can and i mean as an employee of windsurf that feels really good feels. (20:36):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Really good but then you're you're wondering you're wondering well how much (20:41):
undefined
Ejaaz:
am i am i getting paid like like how much are we getting acquired (20:44):
undefined
Josh:
For yeah let's say i had one percent i mean that's 30 million dollars i was (20:47):
undefined
Josh:
about to bag and now so where are we at now it. (20:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Might be it might be a little less but he basically does this (20:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
rundown and estimates it to be around 300 to 400 million dollars which is a (20:57):
undefined
Ejaaz:
significant drop from what you are going to get paid but it's also not nothing (21:04):
undefined
Ejaaz:
the other way i was thinking about it is it's probably all in cognition stock (21:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
josh there's no way they had that much (21:13):
undefined
Josh:
Cash yeah just cash sitting on hand okay so my my 30 million dollars is now (21:15):
undefined
Josh:
three million dollars in stock for cognition which is a private company not (21:20):
undefined
Josh:
even liquid oh yeah lots of tax implications, (21:27):
undefined
Josh:
okay so i mean at least i have a job i guess is where i'll end up on this is like cool. (21:31):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I mean, now that I recounted to you, Josh, you're still screwed. (21:38):
undefined
Josh:
You're still screwed, dude. At this point, I'm just happy to be employed. (21:43):
undefined
Josh:
I'm just glad that I still have some sort of a job. I'm hopefully collecting some sort of paycheck. (21:45):
undefined
Josh:
One day, it is hopeful that the stock will be worth money, and then I'll be (21:50):
undefined
Josh:
able to sell it and cash out. But man, yeah, what a roller coaster. (21:54):
undefined
Josh:
And it kind of sets this new paradigm, right? Where you can cut, (21:57):
undefined
Josh:
you could kind of rip the value out of a company and then just kind of throw the rest to the side. (22:00):
undefined
Josh:
But it's this really interesting ideological debate you could have as a founder (22:05):
undefined
Josh:
of a company whose fiduciary duty is to serve right by the shareholders. (22:10):
undefined
Josh:
And in this case, your shareholders are the employees that you've given stock options to. (22:14):
undefined
Josh:
And in the case that they're just going away and they've destroyed the value (22:19):
undefined
Josh:
of the company, they've extracted the value of the acquisition. (22:24):
undefined
Josh:
They have kind of just left the shell of a company and left the people who are (22:28):
undefined
Josh:
responsible for putting them in that place on the side of the road and like (22:32):
undefined
Josh:
that doesn't feel very good but there's really nothing legally preventing them (22:36):
undefined
Josh:
from stopping that it's really just an ideological, (22:40):
undefined
Josh:
debate in this case it doesn't i mean i'd be pretty i'd be pretty upset sure (22:44):
undefined
Josh:
if i'm one of the founders i just made a billion i'm now a billionaire like (22:48):
undefined
Josh:
that's cool but for everyone else. It kind of leaves a bed for the. (22:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Majority of people. Yeah, you're screwed. I don't know whether it's because (22:55):
undefined
Ejaaz:
of all the time I've spent in web three, Josh, but I've kind of grown numb to (23:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
all this like terrible, appalling behavior, unequitable behavior. (23:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And so I kind of look at a story like this and I'm like, oh yeah, (23:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
he got paid billions and left the entire company and team to dry. (23:12):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Yeah. Happens all the time, I guess. But like, I'm just, I'm noticing this trend, (23:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
particularly within AI that there's this more wild (23:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
west kind of degenerate behavior when it comes to acquisitions like people are (23:25):
undefined
Ejaaz:
ruthless and i don't know whether this is maybe it's my naivety when it comes (23:30):
undefined
Ejaaz:
to like vc deals and acquisitions and mergers maybe i just i just don't know (23:33):
undefined
Ejaaz:
maybe this happens all the time but this seems like the most extremely skewed version of this and (23:37):
undefined
Josh:
We often refer to it on the show as like the game of thrones and (23:44):
undefined
Josh:
i don't think there's a much better description than that where it really is (23:47):
undefined
Josh:
cutthroat and this happens a lot in traditional venture and acquisitions but (23:50):
undefined
Josh:
this scale i think has never been greater and that's probably what stands out (23:53):
undefined
Josh:
among all of these headlines is just how much money is being made lost and thrown (23:58):
undefined
Josh:
around to position yourself better to get to this point of agi but you have (24:02):
undefined
Josh:
a tweet you had a post here it looks. (24:07):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Funny just to round us out josh just to like put a bit of cherry on this cake (24:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
well the tldr is like everyone hates varoon mohan the former ceo who took the (24:15):
undefined
Ejaaz:
1.5 billion dollar check or however much it was. (24:22):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And everyone loves Scott Wu, the CEO of Cognition Lambs, who stepped up, (24:25):
undefined
Ejaaz:
gave the 250 employees a salary and a lifeline and accelerated vesting. (24:29):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So no matter the size of the money, shout out to Scott Wu. He didn't need to do that. (24:35):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And then, you know, Varun, I wonder, you know, whether his reputation survives this. (24:39):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I can see the reasoning why you would take the big check, but also like leaving (24:44):
undefined
Ejaaz:
all your employees out like that to drive without even giving them, (24:49):
undefined
Ejaaz:
I don't know, a couple mil is kind of insane. But here we are. (24:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
So what's the price on your reputation? (24:56):
undefined
Josh:
Like, would you take a couple billion dollars to just go work on AGI and let the. (24:58):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Media do a thing for a couple of weeks? I know a lot of people that would do (25:02):
undefined
Ejaaz:
it. I know a lot of people. I mean, I'm one of them. (25:04):
undefined
Josh:
I'd probably do that, right? Like, a couple billion dollars? I don't know. (25:07):
undefined
Josh:
But also, yeah, it's tough. Well, it's funny because at this graphic, (25:11):
undefined
Josh:
it's a win-win for both of them. (25:14):
undefined
Josh:
Like, Varun is, or I'm not sure how you pronounce his name, but he's hated. (25:15):
undefined
Josh:
The CEO of Winsurf is not liked, but he's rich. and Scott Wu is loved. (25:20):
undefined
Josh:
And now he has a bunch of employees that really want to work hard to make this (25:25):
undefined
Josh:
work for him and really want to add value to his company and can go to sleep (25:29):
undefined
Josh:
with a good conscience knowing he's done well and he's done right by these people. (25:33):
undefined
Josh:
Whereas our windsurf buddy cannot do that. So maybe he will just be, (25:37):
undefined
Josh:
one of them will be crying in their $100 million mansion while the other will (25:41):
undefined
Josh:
be surrounded by people who love him dearly. (25:45):
undefined
Ejaaz:
Yeah, I think that's pretty much it. An absolutely outrageous, (25:48):
undefined
Ejaaz:
but weirdly normal day in the world of AI, Josh. (25:51):
undefined
Ejaaz:
We thank you guys for listening. We are trying out this new format. (25:56):
undefined
Ejaaz:
We've said this before, where we kind of talk about trending topics and be or (26:00):
undefined
Ejaaz:
try and be the first guys to talk about it and put it in front of your feeds. (26:05):
undefined
Ejaaz:
We are welcoming any and all feedback. So, you know, any kind of comments or (26:09):
undefined
Ejaaz:
DMs, it's all open, go for it. (26:13):
undefined
Ejaaz:
And if you could like, subscribe and share it with all your friends or anyone (26:16):
undefined
Ejaaz:
who you think would be interested in this kind of thing, we would be eternally (26:18):
undefined
Ejaaz:
grateful and we'll see you on the next episode see you (26:22):
undefined
Josh:
On the next one peace guys. (26:25):
undefined
Music:
Music (26:27):
undefined