July 31, 2025 • 34 mins
In the small town of Moran, Virginia, three lives are intertwined in a dark tale: Tardy Gosling, a compassionate veterinarian; Jeev Plumtree, an energetic elementary school teacher; and Cordelia Gosling, an overprotective mother. As preparations for Tardy and Jeev’s wedding spark conflict, Cordelia takes a dark path—from subtle sabotage to a deadly obsession culminating in a brutal stabbing in the nearby forest with garden shears. Unique facts such as bloodstains on the wedding dress, Cordelia’s obsession journal filled with sabotage plans, and digital traces from searches for “how to separate a couple” will be thoroughly examined.
In this episode, you’ll learn how investigators piece together forensic evidence—shoe prints, blood sample analysis, and phone call reconstructions—to uncover the perpetrator’s motive and method. Learn about the warning signs of family conflict, the importance of financial and digital trails, and valuable lessons on how love and obsession can turn into murder.
In this episode, you’ll learn how investigators piece together forensic evidence—shoe prints, blood sample analysis, and phone call reconstructions—to uncover the perpetrator’s motive and method. Learn about the warning signs of family conflict, the importance of financial and digital trails, and valuable lessons on how love and obsession can turn into murder.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:05):
In the heart of this tragedy were three individuals whose
lives had become inextricably intertwined. Tardi Gosling, a thirty two
year old local veterinarian with a gentle nature and a
passion for animal welfare. Jev Plumtree, a twenty eight year
old elementary school teacher with contagious energy, And Cordelia Gosling,
(00:26):
Tardi's fifty eight year old mother, a pillar of the
community known for her charitable works and impeccable taste. No
one could have predicted the dark turn of events that
would forever change the lives of these three individuals and
the entire town of Moran. Tardi had grown up as
the only child of Cordelia and the late Edmund Gosling.
(00:48):
From a young age, it was evident that Tardi had
inherited his father's kind heart and his mother's sharp intellect. Cordelia,
widowed when Tardy was only ten, poured all her energy
into raising him to be the perfect gentleman, meticulously managing
every aspect of his life, from his education to his
social circle, always pressuring him to excel and meet her
(01:09):
strict expectations. As Tardy grew older, he found solace in
the company of animals, which led him to study veterinary medicine,
much to Cordelia's initial dismay, as she had hoped he
would follow in his father's footsteps and become a surgeon. However,
seeing her son's dedication and success in the field he
had chosen, she eventually softened her stance. Throughout his life,
(01:34):
Tardy had always sought his mother's approval. Their relationship was complex,
marked by Cordelia's over protective love and Tardy's desire for independence.
He often found himself torn between his own desires and
his mother's expectations, a conflict that would reach a critical
point in the most tragic way. Jev Plumtree, on the
(01:54):
other hand, had a very different upbringing. Born into a loving,
working class family in an neighboring town, she had always
been a stocky child. Her childhood was marked by cruel
taunts from her peers and well meaning but hurtful comments
from her relatives about her weight. Despite these challenges, Jev's
parents instilled in her a strong sense of self worth
(02:17):
and a determination to pursue her dreams. As she grew up,
Jev channeled her experiences into a passion for education and
child psychology, believing that by becoming a teacher, she could
make a difference in the lives of children by fostering
acceptance and kindness in the next generation. Her warm personality
(02:37):
and innovative teaching methods quickly made her a favorite among
students and parents alike. It was while teaching at Marian
Elementary School that Tardy and Jev's paths crossed One rainy
Tuesday afternoon at the Marian Animal Shelter. Jeev had taken
her class on a field trip to learn about animal
care and adoption. Tardi, who volunteered at the shelter in
(02:59):
his life spare time, was instantly captivated by Jev's enthusiasm
and the way she interacted with the children and animals.
Their connection was immediate and powerful. Tardy was drawn to
Jev's confidence and zest for life, while Jev was charmed
by Tardy's gentle nature and quick wit. They began dating
(03:19):
shortly after, and their relationship blossomed, revealing a deep compatibility
and shared values. For the first time in his life,
Tardi felt truly seen and accepted for who he was,
not for what someone else wanted him to be. Jev,
in turn, found in Tardy a partner who appreciated her
mind and spirit, never making her feel insecure about her appearance.
(03:42):
Their love story seemed like a fairy tale come true
in the small town of Marion, but few knew that
their happiness would soon be brutally tested. After a whirlwind
romance of just over a year, Tardy decided to propose
to Jev. He planned an elaborate surprise, enlisting the help
of Jev's students to create a treasure hunt that led
(04:02):
her through her favorite spots in Marion, ending at the
animal shelter where they had first met. There, surrounded by
wagging tails and purring cats, Tardi got down on one
knee and asked Jev to be his wife. Overcome with emotion,
Jev accepted without hesitation. The couple's joy was palpable as
(04:22):
they shared the news with friends and colleagues. The town
was thrilled, with many seeing their union as the perfect marriage. However,
one crucial person had yet to be informed, Cordelia Gosling. Tardy,
aware of his mother's tendency to be critical, had hesitated
to introduce Jev to her. He had mentioned Jev in passing,
(04:43):
but had never brought her home or shared details about
their relationship. Now, with an engagement ring on Jev's finger,
he knew he could no longer avoid the inevitable meeting.
The couple arrived at the Gosling family home, a grand
Victorian mansion that had been in the family for generations.
Cordelia greeted them at the door, her smile fading slightly
(05:03):
as her gaze fell on Jev. The air grew thick
with tension as they sat in the formal living room,
Cordelia's eyes darting between her son and his fiancee. When
Tardy announced their engagement, the room fell silent. Cordelia's face
showed a range of emotions surprise, disbelief, and finally, poorly
disguised disgust. Her voice was cold as she asked how
(05:27):
long they had been together, her disapproval evident in every
cutting word. Jev, always optimistic, tried to build a bridge
by complimenting the house and asking about the family heirlooms,
but Cordelia's responses were terse and brief, and her eyes
never fully met Jev's. As the awkward visit came to
an end, Cordelia pulled Tardy aside, her whispered words carrying
(05:50):
a tone of desperation. She couldn't understand how her perfect
son could choose some one so different. Tardy left his
childhood home with a heavy heart, torn between his love
for Jev and his desire for his mother's approval. Little
did he know this was only the beginning of a
conflict that would escalate beyond his worst nightmares. In the
(06:11):
weeks following the engagement announcement, Tardi and Jeev became immersed
in wedding preparations. They envisioned a celebration that reflected their personalities,
rustic yet elegant, to be held in the local botanical gardens.
Jev's excitement was contagious as she flipped through Bridle magazines
and created pinterest boards, while Tardi was swept up in
(06:33):
her joy. However, Cordelia's disapproval cast a shadow over their happiness.
She began a subtle campaign of sabotage, questioning every decision
and suggesting alternatives that invariably excluded Jev's preferences. When Jev
chose a flowing, Bohemian wedding dress that made her feel beautiful,
Cordelia insisted on a more traditional, form fitting gown. When
(06:57):
the couple decided on a menu of comfort foods they
both loved, Cordelia pushed for a healthier selection. Each interaction
left Jev feeling more insecure and Tardy increasingly frustrated. The
arguments between mother and son became more frequent, often ending
with Cordelia in tears, lamenting how Tardy had changed and
(07:17):
no longer valued her opinions. One particularly heated exchange occurred
during a cake tasting session. As Jeev savored a piece
of chocolate cake, her eyes lighting up with delight, Cordelia muttered, softly,
are you sure you need that, dear? The comment, though
said quietly, didn't escape Jev's ears. Tardy, seeing the hurt
(07:39):
in his fiance's eyes, finally snapped mother enough, he exclaimed,
his voice ringing out in the small bakery. Your behavior
is unacceptable. If you can't be supportive, maybe you shouldn't
be involved in the wedding preparations at all. Cordelia's face
went pale, her lips pressed into a thin line. Without
a word, she gathered things and left the bakery, leaving
(08:02):
behind a stunned silence. That night, Tardy received a barrage
of messages from his mother, alternating between guilt tripping him
for his outburst and expressing concern about his choice of fiancee.
She questioned whether he was truly happy, suggesting that perhaps
he felt obliged to marry Jev out of pity or
a misguided sense of political correctness. Tardy, confused and emotionally drained,
(08:27):
confided in Jev about his mother's messages. Despite her own hurt,
Jev showed remarkable compassion and suggested that they try harder
to include Cordelia, to show her that their love was
real and that there was room in their lives for everyone.
Following Jev's advice, Tardy attempted to reconcile with his mother.
(08:47):
He invited her to dinner, hoping that in a more
intimate setting, Cordelia might see the depth of their relationship. However,
the dinner was a disaster. Cordelia spent the evening making
backhanded compliments and veiled comments about Jev's health and appearance.
Each remark chipped away at Jev's self esteem and drained
(09:09):
Tardy's patience. As the wedding day drew closer, the tension
continued to Mount, Cordelia's behavior became increasingly erratic. She started
showing up unannounced at Tardy's veterinary clinic, pleading with him
to reconsider the marriage. She even went so far as
to contact Taddy's ex girlfriends, hoping to rekindle old relationships
(09:30):
and drive a wedge between the engaged couple. Taddy, torn
between his love for Jev and his desire to please
his mother, found himself in an impossible position. He loved
Jev with all his heart, but the prospect of cutting
ties with his only living relative was unbearable. As the
conflict reached its peak, neither of them could have foreseen
(09:50):
the tragic turn of events that was about to unfold.
As the wedding day approached, Cordelia's behavior took a darker turn.
What had started as disapp roval and passive aggressive comments
evolved into a full blown obsession with stopping the wedding
at any cost. Cordelia became convinced that she was acting
out of love for her son, protecting him from making
(10:12):
a life ruining mistake. Cordelia's days were consumed with researching
ways to sabotage the wedding. She spent hours online delving
into forums and websites that promoted body shaming and extreme diets.
Her search history was filled with queries like how to
break up a couple and signs your child is in
(10:32):
an abusive relationship. She even consulted a local psychic, desperate
to find any sign that the marriage was destined for failure.
Her fixation on Jev's weight took her down a dangerous path.
Cordelia began to see Jev not as a person, but
as a problem to be eliminated. She started following Jev
(10:52):
around town, observing her routines and habits from a distance.
She watched as Jev shopped for groceries, exorcized at the
local park, or met friends for coffee. Each observation only
fueled Cordelia's irrational hatred. One afternoon, Cordelia followed Jev to
a boutique that specialized in plus size clothing. She stood
(11:14):
outside the window, watching as Jev tried on bridal lingerie,
a smile lighting up her face as she admired her reflection,
Something inside Cordelia snapped. The sight of Jev's joy and
self acceptance was more than she could bear. It was
at that moment that her plans took a more sinister turn.
Cordelia's once immaculate home became a reflection of her deteriorating
(11:38):
mental state. Post it notes with scribbled plans and delusions
covered every surface. She neglected her appearance and social obligations,
becoming a recluse as she devoted all her time to
her mission of saving Tardy. In her more lucid moments,
Cordelia was horrified by her own thoughts and actions, breaking
(11:58):
down in tears, overwhelmed by guilt and confusion. But these
moments were fleeting, quickly eclipsed by her obsession. As her
mental state worsened, Cordelia's behavior grew increasingly erratic. She made
anonymous phone calls to Jev's workplace, spreading malicious rumors about
her competence as a teacher. She sent Tardy articles and
(12:20):
statistics about the health risks associated with obesity, framing them
as well meaning maternal advice. Tardy, aware of his mother's
increasingly alarming behavior, tried to reason with her. He attempted
to explain his love for Jev, to make her understand
that happiness and worth weren't defined by physical appearance, but
(12:42):
his words fell on deaf ears in Cordelia's distorted reality.
Only she could see the truth, and it was her
duty to act accordingly. The day before the wedding, Cordelia's
obsession reached its peak. She became convinced that drastic measures
were necessary to save her son from a lifetime of misery.
With a grim sense of determination, she began to formulate
(13:05):
a plan that would alter the course of their lives forever.
The sun rose on what should have been a day
of anticipation and joy in Marian. However, instead of palpable excitement,
the town was enveloped in a strange tension, as though
it could sense the impending tragedy. Tardy and Jev, despite
the stress of the past few months, were filled with
(13:26):
excitement about their impending wedding. They had decided to spend
the day apart, following the old tradition of not seeing
each other before the ceremony. Jev woke early, her heart
like despite the conflicts with Cordelia, she had a full
day of activities planned, the final fitting of her dress,
a manicure and pedicure with her bridesmaids, and a quiet
(13:47):
dinner with her parents. As she followed her morning routine,
she allowed herself to day dream about the life she
and Tardy would build together across town. Tardy also rose
with the sun, his mind filled with last minute details
and a lingering worry about his mother's mental state. He
had invited Cordelia to breakfast, hoping for one last chance
(14:08):
to reconcile before the wedding. As he sat in the
local cafe, nervously toying with his coffee cup, he couldn't
shake the feeling that something was terribly wrong. Cordelia, however,
had no intention of meeting her son for breakfast. She
had spent the night pacing her house, her mind filled
with dark thoughts and desperate plans. In the early hours
(14:30):
of the morning, she had made a chilling decision. If
she couldn't persuade Tardy to call off the wedding, she
would have to take matters into her own hands. As
the day progressed, Cordelia's behavior became increasingly erratic. She made
a series of strange purchases at the local hardware store, rope,
duct tape, and a pair of sharp gardening shears. The cashier,
(14:53):
who had known Cordelia for years, felt a pang of
unease as He scanned the items, but dismissed it as
pre wedding nerves. Meanwhile, Jev was enjoying a relaxing day
with her bridesmaids, laughing and chatting at the beauty salon. Suddenly,
she felt a chill run down her spine, as if
someone had walked over her grave. Shaking off the feeling,
(15:13):
she focused on the excitement of the day ahead, unaware
of the danger drawing ever closer. By late afternoon, Cordelia
had worked herself into a frenzy. She had convinced herself
that eliminating Jev was the only way to save her
son from a life of misery. With a disturbing calm,
she loaded her purchases into her car and set out
(15:35):
to find Jev. It didn't take her long. She saw
Jev leaving the salon, saying good bye to her friends.
As she prepared to return home for dinner with her parents,
Cordelia approached her with a stiff smile on her face. Jev,
surprised to see Cordelia but always hopeful for reconciliation, greeted
her warmly. Cordelia suggested they take a short drive to
(15:57):
talk before the wedding, and clear the air between them.
Despite her doubts, Jev agreed, not wanting to start her
marriage with unresolved conflict. As they drove out of town,
Cordelia's demeanor changed. Her smile disappeared, replaced by a cold,
determined expression. Jev, sensing the shift, began to feel uneasy.
(16:18):
She asked Cordelia to turn around, but her pleas fell
on deaf ears. Cordelia drove them to a secluded area
on the outskirts of town, a wooded spot where she
and Edmund had once picnicked in happier times. When the
car stopped, Jev's unease turned to fear. She reached for
her phone, only to find there was no signal. What
(16:38):
happened next was a blur of violence and terror. Cordelia,
with strength fueled by madness, overpowered Jev. The sounds of
their struggle echoed through the forest as Jev fought for
her life, but Cordelia, driven by her obsession and hatred,
was relentless. In the end, it was the gardening shears
(16:59):
that delivered the fatal blow, silencing Jev's please and ending
her life. When the reality of what she had done
sank in, Cordelia stood over Jev's body, her mind numb,
the forest around her seemed to close in, the shadows
deepening as the sun began to set. With trembling hands,
she began the grim task of hiding her crime. Her
(17:21):
once immaculate clothes were now stained with the evidence of
her horrible act. As darkness fell over Marian, two families
waited anxiously for their loved ones to return. Tardi, worried
by his mother's absence at breakfast and by Jev's lack
of response to his calls, began to fear that his
worst nightmares were coming true. Jev's parents, sitting at a
(17:44):
restaurant table with untouched plates and unanswered toasts, felt a
growing sense of dread, fearing something terrible had happened. Jev
Plumtree's final moments would later be pieced together by forensic
experts and detectives, but the full horror of the event
would never be known by anyone except Cordelia Gosling. What
is known is that Cordelia lured Jev to the secluded
(18:07):
woodland area under the pretense of reconciliation. The place, once
a sight of happy memories for Cordelia, became the setting
for an unimaginable act of violence. Investigators would later find
signs of a struggle spread over a wide area, indicating
that Jev had fought with all her strength for her life. Cordelia,
(18:27):
despite her age, had the advantage of surprise and a weapon.
The gardening shears, chosen for their sharp blades and ease
of use, became the instrument of Jev's death. The medical
examiner would later determine that Jev suffered multiple stab wounds,
the fatal blow piercing her heart. In her final moments,
(18:48):
Jev had tried to call Tady, a fact that seemed
to enrage Cordelia even more. Neighbours living on the outskirts
of the wooded area would later report hearing screams, but
they dismo missed them as the sounds of animals or
teenagers playing pranks. After the act, Cordelia's meticulous nature took over.
She had come prepared with cleaning supplies, trash bags, and
(19:10):
a change of clothes. Methodically, she cleaned the scene, bagging
her bloodstained clothes and the murder weapon. She wrapped Jev's
body in a tarp, Struggling to move the woman, who
was larger than herself. In a cruel twist of fate,
it was Jeev's size that presented the greatest challenge for Cordelia.
Unable to move the body far, she was forced to
(19:32):
cover it with leaves and branches, creating a temporary and
ultimately ineffective burial. As Cordelia worked, her mind raised, fluctuating
between moments of panic and eerie calm. In her distorted reality,
she had done what was necessary to protect her son.
She convinced herself that Tardy would understand that he would
(19:53):
thank her for saving him from a life of ridicule
and misery. Once she had dealt with the physical evidence
as best she could, Cordelia focused on creating an alibi.
She drove to a nearby town, disposing of the bloodied
clothes and murder weapon in various dumpsters along the way.
She then went to a small cafe, making sure to
(20:14):
speak with the waiter and stay long enough to be remembered.
When night fell, Cordelia returned home, showering and scrubbing her
skin as if she could wash away the horror of
what she had done. She burned the clothes she had
worn during the clean up in her fireplace, watching as
the last physical traces of her crime turned to ash. Meanwhile,
(20:35):
Jev's body lay in the forest. The woman who had
once been so vibrant, was now silent and still. The
creatures of the forest, curious about the new presence in
their habitat, began to disturb the hastily concealed grave. A
light rain began to fall, slowly washing away some of
Cordelia's attempts to cover her tracks. Back in town, concern
(20:56):
was growing. Tardy, frantic with worry, had begun calling hospitals
and police stations. Jeev's parents, gripped by a growing fear,
had already reported their daughter missing. As the hours passed,
the joy and anticipation that should have marked the eve
of the wedding were replaced by a growing sense of
dread and despair. No one knew that the truth about
(21:19):
what had happened in those woods would soon come to light,
forever changing the lives of everyone in Marian, and revealing
the devastating consequences of unchecked prejudice and obsession. Dawn broke
on what should have been the wedding day of Tardy
and Jev, but instead of celebrations, Marian awoke to the
sound of sirens and the somber faces of law enforcement.
(21:42):
The idyllic town had become the epicenter of a missing
person investigation, with jev Plumtree's disappearance shaking the community to
its core. Detective Elias Holloway, a seasoned investigator from the
State Police, took charge of the case. His first step
was to interview Tardie, who was beside himself with worry
and guilt. Tardi tearfully recounted the tensions with his mother,
(22:06):
his voice breaking as he expressed his fear that Cordelia
had done something terrible. As the investigation progressed, suspicions initially
focused on Tardi. It wasn't uncommon. Detective Holloway knew for
the partner to be responsible in cases of disappearance. However,
Tardi's genuine distress and his solid alibi he had been
(22:29):
with his friends at his bachelor party all night, quickly
ruled him out as a suspect. Attention then turned to Cordelia.
Her recent erratic behavior, combined with Tardi's concerns, made her
a person of interest. When questioned, Cordelia maintained a calm facade,
providing a detailed account of her movements the day before.
(22:50):
She claimed to have spent the afternoon and evening in
a nearby town, even producing a cafe receipt as proof,
but inconsistencies soon began to emerge. The cafe waiter remembered
seeing Cordelia arrive much later than she had claimed. A
neighbour reported seeing Cordelia's car return to her house late
at night, contradicting her statement that she had been home
(23:11):
the entire evening. As the police dug deeper, they discovered
Cordelia's unusual recent purchases from the hardware store. The cashier's
testimony about her strange behaviour added another piece to the puzzle.
A search warrant was obtained for the Gosling residence, where
investigators found traces of blood in Cordelia's car, despite her
(23:32):
obvious attempts to clean it. The breakthrough in the case
came on the second day of the investigation. A dog walker,
straying from the usual path in the woods where Cordelia
and Edmond had once picnicked, stumbled upon Jev's poorly concealed body.
The grim discovery transformed the case from a missing person
investigation into a homicide forensic teams descended on the scene,
(23:55):
meticulously documenting and collecting evidence. Despite Cordelia's efforts to clean
the crime scene, she had left behind crucial clues fibers
from her clothing, a partial footprint on a discarded water bottle,
and DNA evidence tying her to the scene. As the
evidence mounted, the carefully constructed facade of Cordelia began to crumble.
(24:19):
During a tense interrogation, she finally broke down, confessing to
the murder in a rambling, incoherent monologue that revealed the
depths of her obsession and prejudices. Cordelia's confession sent shock
waves through Marion. Friends and neighbors who had known her
for years struggled to reconcile the respected community member with
(24:39):
the woman capable of such a heinous act. For Tadi,
the revelation was devastating. The knowledge that his own mother
had murdered the woman he loved all because of her
fat phobia and obsessive need for control was almost unbearable.
He fell into a deep depression, blaming himself for not
seeing the signs and for failing to protect Jev. Jev's
(25:00):
parents were inconsolable. The woman who had touched so many
lives with her kindness and passion for teaching, had been
taken from them in the most cruel and senseless way.
As Cordelia was taken into custody, the picturesque town of
Marion was left to grapple with the aftermath of a
crime that exposed the dark undercurrents that had been hiding
(25:21):
beneath its serene surface. In the weeks following Cordelia's arrest,
the full extent of her descent into obsession and madness
came to light. Investigators combing through her home found journals
detailing her growing fixation on Jev's weight and her determination
to end the relationship at any cost. The journals revealed
a mind in disarray, filled with disjointed entries that alternated
(25:43):
between self justification and moments of clarity in which Cordelia
seemed horrified by her own thoughts. Psychologists who evaluated Cordelia
diagnosed her with a severe personality disorder, exacerbated by unresolved
grief over the death of her husband and an unhealthy
attachment to her son. A key piece of evidence came
(26:05):
from Cordelia's computer. Despite her attempts to erase her search history.
Forensic experts were able to recover data showing her extensive
research into ways to break up relationships and her consumption
of harmful ideologies regarding body image. Testimonies from witnesses also
played a crucial role in building the case against Cordelia.
(26:26):
Several of Tardi's ex girlfriends came forward, revealing Cordelia's attempts
to rekindle their relationships with Tardi. Their statements highlighted a
pattern of interference in her son's love life. Perhaps the
most damning testimony came from the principle of Marion Elementary School.
The principle revealed that just days before the murder, Cordelia
(26:47):
had approached him trying to get Jev fired by making
false accusations about her conduct with students. This showed how
far Cordelia was willing to go to sabotage Jev's life.
As the case progressed, the prosecution built a strong argument
for premeditated murder. Cordelia's purchases at the hardware store, her
(27:07):
careful selection of the location, and her attempts to create
an alibi all pointed to a crime planned in advance,
not an impulsive act. Cordelia's defense team tried to argue
for a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity,
citing her mental health issues and an apparent break from reality. However,
(27:29):
the evidence of premeditation made it difficult to sustain this defense.
Throughout the trial, Tardi struggled to come to terms with
his mother's actions. He gave key testimony about Cordelia's behavior
in the months leading up to the murder, his voice
barely audible as he recounted the growing tension and his
own inability to recognize the danger Cordelia posed. Cordelia Gosling's
(27:53):
trial ended with a guilty verdict. She was sentenced to
life in prison without the possibility of parole, take king
into account her age and mental state to avoid the
death penalty. As she was led out of the court room,
the once proud woman now appeared small and broken, the
weight of her actions finally sinking in. For Tardi, the
end of the trial brought no solace. He was left
(28:16):
grappling with the double tragedy of losing both the woman
he loved and the mother he thought he knew. In
the months following the trial, Tardi threw himself into his
work at the animal shelter, finding comfort in caring for
creatures who offered him unconditional love. But the pain of
his losses lingered, and the question of whether he could
(28:37):
have done more to prevent the tragedy haunted him. The
town of Marion, too, struggled to recover from the shock.
Cordelia Gosling had been a respected figure in the community
for decades, known for her charitable work and refined manners.
Her fall from grace and the brutality of her crime
exposed the hidden currents of judgment, control and obsession that
(28:59):
had veested beneath the surface. Conversations about mental health, fat phobia,
and toxic relationships began to emerge as people tried to
make sense of how something so horrific could happen in
their quiet, close knit town. In the weeks following her arrest,
more details of Cordelia's descent into madness came to light.
(29:20):
Investigators combing through her meticulously kept home found stacks of journals,
each entry revealing a woman unraveling under the weight of
her own obsessions. Some entries were filled with lists ways
to make Jev feel unwelcome, diets Jev should follow tactics
to push her out of Tardy's life. Others were heartbreaking
(29:40):
confessions of guilt and confusion, moments when Cordelia seemed aware
that she was losing control but couldn't stop herself. Psychologists
diagnosed Cordelia with severe narcissistic personality disorder, combined with unresolved
grief and an unhealthy emotional dependence on her son. The
combination had pushed her into a state of obsessive control,
(30:02):
where Tardy's independence and love for Jev were seen as
personal betrayals. She became fixated on Jev's weight, seeing it
as symbolic of everything that was wrong in the relationship
and in her life. In her distorted view, she truly
believed that by removing Jev, she was saving Tardy from
a lifetime of misery. One of the most damning pieces
(30:23):
of evidence against Cordelia came from her Internet history, which
forensic investigators were able to recover despite her attempts to
delete it. Her searches revealed a dark path of obsession.
She had spent countless hours on websites promoting extreme dieting
and body shaming, searching for ways to convince Tardy to
leave Jev or sabotage their relationship. She had even visited
(30:47):
forums that discussed methods to manipulate family members or break
up couples, leaving a digital trail that showed just how
far her mind had spiraled into delusion. In court, whichness
painted a picture of a woman who had always been controlling,
but who had become increasingly erratic in the months leading
up to the wedding. Friends and neighbors who had once
(31:09):
admired Cordelia for her poise and generosity now described unsettling encounters,
snide comments about Jev's appearance, an unyielding need to control
every aspect of her son's life, and a growing sense
of paranoia. Several of Tardy's ex girlfriends testified about Cordelia's
interference in their relationships, revealing a pattern of manipulation and
(31:31):
control that spanned years. Perhaps the most chilling testimony came
from the principle of Marian Elementary School, who recounted how
just days before the murder, Cordelia had tried to have
Jev fired. She had made false accusations about Jev's conduct
with her students, claiming that Jev was unfit to teach
due to her weight and mental state. The principal, aware
(31:55):
of Jev's stellar reputation and beloved status among students and parents,
had dismissed Cordelia's claims, but the attempt showed just how
determined Cordelia had been to destroy Jev's life. As the
trial progressed, the prosecution made a strong case for premeditated murder.
Cordelia's purchases of the rope, duct tape, and gardening shears,
(32:16):
her calculated choice of a secluded location, and her attempts
to establish an alibi all pointed to a meticulously planned crime.
Her defense team argued that her deteriorating mental state had
pushed her to the breaking point, but the evidence of
premeditation made it difficult to mount a successful insanity defense. Tardi,
(32:38):
caught in the middle of the tragedy, was forced to
testify against his own mother. His voice cracked with emotion
as he recounted the increasing tension between Jeev and Cordelia
and the guilt he felt for not doing more to
protect the woman he loved. He described Cordelia's escalating behavior
in the months before the wedding, her constant criticism of Jev,
(33:01):
her attempts to undermine the relationship, and the final explosive
confrontation in the bakery, where Tardi had told his mother
to stay out of the wedding preparations. As he spoke,
the courtroom remained silent, the weight of the tragedy hanging
over everyone present. For Tardi, the trial was not just
about seeking justice for Jev, but about coming to terms
(33:23):
with the fact that the woman who had raised him,
who he had loved and admired, had committed an act
of unimaginable violence. The verdict came swiftly. Cordelia Gosling was
found guilty of first degree murder and sentenced to life
in prison without the possibility of parole. The sentence brought
a measure of closure to the community of Marion, but
(33:45):
for Tardi and Jev's family, the wounds would take much
longer to heal. In the months that followed, Tardi continued
to work at the animal shelter, finding solace in the
quiet routine of caring for the animals. His grief was
still raw, but the unconditional love of the creatures he
cared for offered him a sense of peace that he
(34:06):
couldn't find elsewhere. The town of Marion, too, began to heal,
though the memory of what had happened would linger for
years to come. Cordelia, once a respected member of the community,
now spent her days in a prison cell, her mind
a labyrinth of delusion and regret. The journals she had
once meticulously filled with plans to control her son's life
(34:30):
now sat in evidence boxes, a haunting testament to the
dangers of unchecked obsession and the devastating consequences it can
have on those we love.
In the heart of this tragedy were three individuals whose
lives had become inextricably intertwined. Tardi Gosling, a thirty two
year old local veterinarian with a gentle nature and a
passion for animal welfare. Jev Plumtree, a twenty eight year
old elementary school teacher with contagious energy, And Cordelia Gosling,
(00:26):
Tardi's fifty eight year old mother, a pillar of the
community known for her charitable works and impeccable taste. No
one could have predicted the dark turn of events that
would forever change the lives of these three individuals and
the entire town of Moran. Tardi had grown up as
the only child of Cordelia and the late Edmund Gosling.
(00:48):
From a young age, it was evident that Tardi had
inherited his father's kind heart and his mother's sharp intellect. Cordelia,
widowed when Tardy was only ten, poured all her energy
into raising him to be the perfect gentleman, meticulously managing
every aspect of his life, from his education to his
social circle, always pressuring him to excel and meet her
(01:09):
strict expectations. As Tardy grew older, he found solace in
the company of animals, which led him to study veterinary medicine,
much to Cordelia's initial dismay, as she had hoped he
would follow in his father's footsteps and become a surgeon. However,
seeing her son's dedication and success in the field he
had chosen, she eventually softened her stance. Throughout his life,
(01:34):
Tardy had always sought his mother's approval. Their relationship was complex,
marked by Cordelia's over protective love and Tardy's desire for independence.
He often found himself torn between his own desires and
his mother's expectations, a conflict that would reach a critical
point in the most tragic way. Jev Plumtree, on the
(01:54):
other hand, had a very different upbringing. Born into a loving,
working class family in an neighboring town, she had always
been a stocky child. Her childhood was marked by cruel
taunts from her peers and well meaning but hurtful comments
from her relatives about her weight. Despite these challenges, Jev's
parents instilled in her a strong sense of self worth
(02:17):
and a determination to pursue her dreams. As she grew up,
Jev channeled her experiences into a passion for education and
child psychology, believing that by becoming a teacher, she could
make a difference in the lives of children by fostering
acceptance and kindness in the next generation. Her warm personality
(02:37):
and innovative teaching methods quickly made her a favorite among
students and parents alike. It was while teaching at Marian
Elementary School that Tardy and Jev's paths crossed One rainy
Tuesday afternoon at the Marian Animal Shelter. Jeev had taken
her class on a field trip to learn about animal
care and adoption. Tardi, who volunteered at the shelter in
(02:59):
his life spare time, was instantly captivated by Jev's enthusiasm
and the way she interacted with the children and animals.
Their connection was immediate and powerful. Tardy was drawn to
Jev's confidence and zest for life, while Jev was charmed
by Tardy's gentle nature and quick wit. They began dating
(03:19):
shortly after, and their relationship blossomed, revealing a deep compatibility
and shared values. For the first time in his life,
Tardi felt truly seen and accepted for who he was,
not for what someone else wanted him to be. Jev,
in turn, found in Tardy a partner who appreciated her
mind and spirit, never making her feel insecure about her appearance.
(03:42):
Their love story seemed like a fairy tale come true
in the small town of Marion, but few knew that
their happiness would soon be brutally tested. After a whirlwind
romance of just over a year, Tardy decided to propose
to Jev. He planned an elaborate surprise, enlisting the help
of Jev's students to create a treasure hunt that led
(04:02):
her through her favorite spots in Marion, ending at the
animal shelter where they had first met. There, surrounded by
wagging tails and purring cats, Tardi got down on one
knee and asked Jev to be his wife. Overcome with emotion,
Jev accepted without hesitation. The couple's joy was palpable as
(04:22):
they shared the news with friends and colleagues. The town
was thrilled, with many seeing their union as the perfect marriage. However,
one crucial person had yet to be informed, Cordelia Gosling. Tardy,
aware of his mother's tendency to be critical, had hesitated
to introduce Jev to her. He had mentioned Jev in passing,
(04:43):
but had never brought her home or shared details about
their relationship. Now, with an engagement ring on Jev's finger,
he knew he could no longer avoid the inevitable meeting.
The couple arrived at the Gosling family home, a grand
Victorian mansion that had been in the family for generations.
Cordelia greeted them at the door, her smile fading slightly
(05:03):
as her gaze fell on Jev. The air grew thick
with tension as they sat in the formal living room,
Cordelia's eyes darting between her son and his fiancee. When
Tardy announced their engagement, the room fell silent. Cordelia's face
showed a range of emotions surprise, disbelief, and finally, poorly
disguised disgust. Her voice was cold as she asked how
(05:27):
long they had been together, her disapproval evident in every
cutting word. Jev, always optimistic, tried to build a bridge
by complimenting the house and asking about the family heirlooms,
but Cordelia's responses were terse and brief, and her eyes
never fully met Jev's. As the awkward visit came to
an end, Cordelia pulled Tardy aside, her whispered words carrying
(05:50):
a tone of desperation. She couldn't understand how her perfect
son could choose some one so different. Tardy left his
childhood home with a heavy heart, torn between his love
for Jev and his desire for his mother's approval. Little
did he know this was only the beginning of a
conflict that would escalate beyond his worst nightmares. In the
(06:11):
weeks following the engagement announcement, Tardi and Jeev became immersed
in wedding preparations. They envisioned a celebration that reflected their personalities,
rustic yet elegant, to be held in the local botanical gardens.
Jev's excitement was contagious as she flipped through Bridle magazines
and created pinterest boards, while Tardi was swept up in
(06:33):
her joy. However, Cordelia's disapproval cast a shadow over their happiness.
She began a subtle campaign of sabotage, questioning every decision
and suggesting alternatives that invariably excluded Jev's preferences. When Jev
chose a flowing, Bohemian wedding dress that made her feel beautiful,
Cordelia insisted on a more traditional, form fitting gown. When
(06:57):
the couple decided on a menu of comfort foods they
both loved, Cordelia pushed for a healthier selection. Each interaction
left Jev feeling more insecure and Tardy increasingly frustrated. The
arguments between mother and son became more frequent, often ending
with Cordelia in tears, lamenting how Tardy had changed and
(07:17):
no longer valued her opinions. One particularly heated exchange occurred
during a cake tasting session. As Jeev savored a piece
of chocolate cake, her eyes lighting up with delight, Cordelia muttered, softly,
are you sure you need that, dear? The comment, though
said quietly, didn't escape Jev's ears. Tardy, seeing the hurt
(07:39):
in his fiance's eyes, finally snapped mother enough, he exclaimed,
his voice ringing out in the small bakery. Your behavior
is unacceptable. If you can't be supportive, maybe you shouldn't
be involved in the wedding preparations at all. Cordelia's face
went pale, her lips pressed into a thin line. Without
a word, she gathered things and left the bakery, leaving
(08:02):
behind a stunned silence. That night, Tardy received a barrage
of messages from his mother, alternating between guilt tripping him
for his outburst and expressing concern about his choice of fiancee.
She questioned whether he was truly happy, suggesting that perhaps
he felt obliged to marry Jev out of pity or
a misguided sense of political correctness. Tardy, confused and emotionally drained,
(08:27):
confided in Jev about his mother's messages. Despite her own hurt,
Jev showed remarkable compassion and suggested that they try harder
to include Cordelia, to show her that their love was
real and that there was room in their lives for everyone.
Following Jev's advice, Tardy attempted to reconcile with his mother.
(08:47):
He invited her to dinner, hoping that in a more
intimate setting, Cordelia might see the depth of their relationship. However,
the dinner was a disaster. Cordelia spent the evening making
backhanded compliments and veiled comments about Jev's health and appearance.
Each remark chipped away at Jev's self esteem and drained
(09:09):
Tardy's patience. As the wedding day drew closer, the tension
continued to Mount, Cordelia's behavior became increasingly erratic. She started
showing up unannounced at Tardy's veterinary clinic, pleading with him
to reconsider the marriage. She even went so far as
to contact Taddy's ex girlfriends, hoping to rekindle old relationships
(09:30):
and drive a wedge between the engaged couple. Taddy, torn
between his love for Jev and his desire to please
his mother, found himself in an impossible position. He loved
Jev with all his heart, but the prospect of cutting
ties with his only living relative was unbearable. As the
conflict reached its peak, neither of them could have foreseen
(09:50):
the tragic turn of events that was about to unfold.
As the wedding day approached, Cordelia's behavior took a darker turn.
What had started as disapp roval and passive aggressive comments
evolved into a full blown obsession with stopping the wedding
at any cost. Cordelia became convinced that she was acting
out of love for her son, protecting him from making
(10:12):
a life ruining mistake. Cordelia's days were consumed with researching
ways to sabotage the wedding. She spent hours online delving
into forums and websites that promoted body shaming and extreme diets.
Her search history was filled with queries like how to
break up a couple and signs your child is in
(10:32):
an abusive relationship. She even consulted a local psychic, desperate
to find any sign that the marriage was destined for failure.
Her fixation on Jev's weight took her down a dangerous path.
Cordelia began to see Jev not as a person, but
as a problem to be eliminated. She started following Jev
(10:52):
around town, observing her routines and habits from a distance.
She watched as Jev shopped for groceries, exorcized at the
local park, or met friends for coffee. Each observation only
fueled Cordelia's irrational hatred. One afternoon, Cordelia followed Jev to
a boutique that specialized in plus size clothing. She stood
(11:14):
outside the window, watching as Jev tried on bridal lingerie,
a smile lighting up her face as she admired her reflection,
Something inside Cordelia snapped. The sight of Jev's joy and
self acceptance was more than she could bear. It was
at that moment that her plans took a more sinister turn.
Cordelia's once immaculate home became a reflection of her deteriorating
(11:38):
mental state. Post it notes with scribbled plans and delusions
covered every surface. She neglected her appearance and social obligations,
becoming a recluse as she devoted all her time to
her mission of saving Tardy. In her more lucid moments,
Cordelia was horrified by her own thoughts and actions, breaking
(11:58):
down in tears, overwhelmed by guilt and confusion. But these
moments were fleeting, quickly eclipsed by her obsession. As her
mental state worsened, Cordelia's behavior grew increasingly erratic. She made
anonymous phone calls to Jev's workplace, spreading malicious rumors about
her competence as a teacher. She sent Tardy articles and
(12:20):
statistics about the health risks associated with obesity, framing them
as well meaning maternal advice. Tardy, aware of his mother's
increasingly alarming behavior, tried to reason with her. He attempted
to explain his love for Jev, to make her understand
that happiness and worth weren't defined by physical appearance, but
(12:42):
his words fell on deaf ears in Cordelia's distorted reality.
Only she could see the truth, and it was her
duty to act accordingly. The day before the wedding, Cordelia's
obsession reached its peak. She became convinced that drastic measures
were necessary to save her son from a lifetime of misery.
With a grim sense of determination, she began to formulate
(13:05):
a plan that would alter the course of their lives forever.
The sun rose on what should have been a day
of anticipation and joy in Marian. However, instead of palpable excitement,
the town was enveloped in a strange tension, as though
it could sense the impending tragedy. Tardy and Jev, despite
the stress of the past few months, were filled with
(13:26):
excitement about their impending wedding. They had decided to spend
the day apart, following the old tradition of not seeing
each other before the ceremony. Jev woke early, her heart
like despite the conflicts with Cordelia, she had a full
day of activities planned, the final fitting of her dress,
a manicure and pedicure with her bridesmaids, and a quiet
(13:47):
dinner with her parents. As she followed her morning routine,
she allowed herself to day dream about the life she
and Tardy would build together across town. Tardy also rose
with the sun, his mind filled with last minute details
and a lingering worry about his mother's mental state. He
had invited Cordelia to breakfast, hoping for one last chance
(14:08):
to reconcile before the wedding. As he sat in the
local cafe, nervously toying with his coffee cup, he couldn't
shake the feeling that something was terribly wrong. Cordelia, however,
had no intention of meeting her son for breakfast. She
had spent the night pacing her house, her mind filled
with dark thoughts and desperate plans. In the early hours
(14:30):
of the morning, she had made a chilling decision. If
she couldn't persuade Tardy to call off the wedding, she
would have to take matters into her own hands. As
the day progressed, Cordelia's behavior became increasingly erratic. She made
a series of strange purchases at the local hardware store, rope,
duct tape, and a pair of sharp gardening shears. The cashier,
(14:53):
who had known Cordelia for years, felt a pang of
unease as He scanned the items, but dismissed it as
pre wedding nerves. Meanwhile, Jev was enjoying a relaxing day
with her bridesmaids, laughing and chatting at the beauty salon. Suddenly,
she felt a chill run down her spine, as if
someone had walked over her grave. Shaking off the feeling,
(15:13):
she focused on the excitement of the day ahead, unaware
of the danger drawing ever closer. By late afternoon, Cordelia
had worked herself into a frenzy. She had convinced herself
that eliminating Jev was the only way to save her
son from a life of misery. With a disturbing calm,
she loaded her purchases into her car and set out
(15:35):
to find Jev. It didn't take her long. She saw
Jev leaving the salon, saying good bye to her friends.
As she prepared to return home for dinner with her parents,
Cordelia approached her with a stiff smile on her face. Jev,
surprised to see Cordelia but always hopeful for reconciliation, greeted
her warmly. Cordelia suggested they take a short drive to
(15:57):
talk before the wedding, and clear the air between them.
Despite her doubts, Jev agreed, not wanting to start her
marriage with unresolved conflict. As they drove out of town,
Cordelia's demeanor changed. Her smile disappeared, replaced by a cold,
determined expression. Jev, sensing the shift, began to feel uneasy.
(16:18):
She asked Cordelia to turn around, but her pleas fell
on deaf ears. Cordelia drove them to a secluded area
on the outskirts of town, a wooded spot where she
and Edmund had once picnicked in happier times. When the
car stopped, Jev's unease turned to fear. She reached for
her phone, only to find there was no signal. What
(16:38):
happened next was a blur of violence and terror. Cordelia,
with strength fueled by madness, overpowered Jev. The sounds of
their struggle echoed through the forest as Jev fought for
her life, but Cordelia, driven by her obsession and hatred,
was relentless. In the end, it was the gardening shears
(16:59):
that delivered the fatal blow, silencing Jev's please and ending
her life. When the reality of what she had done
sank in, Cordelia stood over Jev's body, her mind numb,
the forest around her seemed to close in, the shadows
deepening as the sun began to set. With trembling hands,
she began the grim task of hiding her crime. Her
(17:21):
once immaculate clothes were now stained with the evidence of
her horrible act. As darkness fell over Marian, two families
waited anxiously for their loved ones to return. Tardi, worried
by his mother's absence at breakfast and by Jev's lack
of response to his calls, began to fear that his
worst nightmares were coming true. Jev's parents, sitting at a
(17:44):
restaurant table with untouched plates and unanswered toasts, felt a
growing sense of dread, fearing something terrible had happened. Jev
Plumtree's final moments would later be pieced together by forensic
experts and detectives, but the full horror of the event
would never be known by anyone except Cordelia Gosling. What
is known is that Cordelia lured Jev to the secluded
(18:07):
woodland area under the pretense of reconciliation. The place, once
a sight of happy memories for Cordelia, became the setting
for an unimaginable act of violence. Investigators would later find
signs of a struggle spread over a wide area, indicating
that Jev had fought with all her strength for her life. Cordelia,
(18:27):
despite her age, had the advantage of surprise and a weapon.
The gardening shears, chosen for their sharp blades and ease
of use, became the instrument of Jev's death. The medical
examiner would later determine that Jev suffered multiple stab wounds,
the fatal blow piercing her heart. In her final moments,
(18:48):
Jev had tried to call Tady, a fact that seemed
to enrage Cordelia even more. Neighbours living on the outskirts
of the wooded area would later report hearing screams, but
they dismo missed them as the sounds of animals or
teenagers playing pranks. After the act, Cordelia's meticulous nature took over.
She had come prepared with cleaning supplies, trash bags, and
(19:10):
a change of clothes. Methodically, she cleaned the scene, bagging
her bloodstained clothes and the murder weapon. She wrapped Jev's
body in a tarp, Struggling to move the woman, who
was larger than herself. In a cruel twist of fate,
it was Jeev's size that presented the greatest challenge for Cordelia.
Unable to move the body far, she was forced to
(19:32):
cover it with leaves and branches, creating a temporary and
ultimately ineffective burial. As Cordelia worked, her mind raised, fluctuating
between moments of panic and eerie calm. In her distorted reality,
she had done what was necessary to protect her son.
She convinced herself that Tardy would understand that he would
(19:53):
thank her for saving him from a life of ridicule
and misery. Once she had dealt with the physical evidence
as best she could, Cordelia focused on creating an alibi.
She drove to a nearby town, disposing of the bloodied
clothes and murder weapon in various dumpsters along the way.
She then went to a small cafe, making sure to
(20:14):
speak with the waiter and stay long enough to be remembered.
When night fell, Cordelia returned home, showering and scrubbing her
skin as if she could wash away the horror of
what she had done. She burned the clothes she had
worn during the clean up in her fireplace, watching as
the last physical traces of her crime turned to ash. Meanwhile,
(20:35):
Jev's body lay in the forest. The woman who had
once been so vibrant, was now silent and still. The
creatures of the forest, curious about the new presence in
their habitat, began to disturb the hastily concealed grave. A
light rain began to fall, slowly washing away some of
Cordelia's attempts to cover her tracks. Back in town, concern
(20:56):
was growing. Tardy, frantic with worry, had begun calling hospitals
and police stations. Jeev's parents, gripped by a growing fear,
had already reported their daughter missing. As the hours passed,
the joy and anticipation that should have marked the eve
of the wedding were replaced by a growing sense of
dread and despair. No one knew that the truth about
(21:19):
what had happened in those woods would soon come to light,
forever changing the lives of everyone in Marian, and revealing
the devastating consequences of unchecked prejudice and obsession. Dawn broke
on what should have been the wedding day of Tardy
and Jev, but instead of celebrations, Marian awoke to the
sound of sirens and the somber faces of law enforcement.
(21:42):
The idyllic town had become the epicenter of a missing
person investigation, with jev Plumtree's disappearance shaking the community to
its core. Detective Elias Holloway, a seasoned investigator from the
State Police, took charge of the case. His first step
was to interview Tardie, who was beside himself with worry
and guilt. Tardi tearfully recounted the tensions with his mother,
(22:06):
his voice breaking as he expressed his fear that Cordelia
had done something terrible. As the investigation progressed, suspicions initially
focused on Tardi. It wasn't uncommon. Detective Holloway knew for
the partner to be responsible in cases of disappearance. However,
Tardi's genuine distress and his solid alibi he had been
(22:29):
with his friends at his bachelor party all night, quickly
ruled him out as a suspect. Attention then turned to Cordelia.
Her recent erratic behavior, combined with Tardi's concerns, made her
a person of interest. When questioned, Cordelia maintained a calm facade,
providing a detailed account of her movements the day before.
(22:50):
She claimed to have spent the afternoon and evening in
a nearby town, even producing a cafe receipt as proof,
but inconsistencies soon began to emerge. The cafe waiter remembered
seeing Cordelia arrive much later than she had claimed. A
neighbour reported seeing Cordelia's car return to her house late
at night, contradicting her statement that she had been home
(23:11):
the entire evening. As the police dug deeper, they discovered
Cordelia's unusual recent purchases from the hardware store. The cashier's
testimony about her strange behaviour added another piece to the puzzle.
A search warrant was obtained for the Gosling residence, where
investigators found traces of blood in Cordelia's car, despite her
(23:32):
obvious attempts to clean it. The breakthrough in the case
came on the second day of the investigation. A dog walker,
straying from the usual path in the woods where Cordelia
and Edmond had once picnicked, stumbled upon Jev's poorly concealed body.
The grim discovery transformed the case from a missing person
investigation into a homicide forensic teams descended on the scene,
(23:55):
meticulously documenting and collecting evidence. Despite Cordelia's efforts to clean
the crime scene, she had left behind crucial clues fibers
from her clothing, a partial footprint on a discarded water bottle,
and DNA evidence tying her to the scene. As the
evidence mounted, the carefully constructed facade of Cordelia began to crumble.
(24:19):
During a tense interrogation, she finally broke down, confessing to
the murder in a rambling, incoherent monologue that revealed the
depths of her obsession and prejudices. Cordelia's confession sent shock
waves through Marion. Friends and neighbors who had known her
for years struggled to reconcile the respected community member with
(24:39):
the woman capable of such a heinous act. For Tadi,
the revelation was devastating. The knowledge that his own mother
had murdered the woman he loved all because of her
fat phobia and obsessive need for control was almost unbearable.
He fell into a deep depression, blaming himself for not
seeing the signs and for failing to protect Jev. Jev's
(25:00):
parents were inconsolable. The woman who had touched so many
lives with her kindness and passion for teaching, had been
taken from them in the most cruel and senseless way.
As Cordelia was taken into custody, the picturesque town of
Marion was left to grapple with the aftermath of a
crime that exposed the dark undercurrents that had been hiding
(25:21):
beneath its serene surface. In the weeks following Cordelia's arrest,
the full extent of her descent into obsession and madness
came to light. Investigators combing through her home found journals
detailing her growing fixation on Jev's weight and her determination
to end the relationship at any cost. The journals revealed
a mind in disarray, filled with disjointed entries that alternated
(25:43):
between self justification and moments of clarity in which Cordelia
seemed horrified by her own thoughts. Psychologists who evaluated Cordelia
diagnosed her with a severe personality disorder, exacerbated by unresolved
grief over the death of her husband and an unhealthy
attachment to her son. A key piece of evidence came
(26:05):
from Cordelia's computer. Despite her attempts to erase her search history.
Forensic experts were able to recover data showing her extensive
research into ways to break up relationships and her consumption
of harmful ideologies regarding body image. Testimonies from witnesses also
played a crucial role in building the case against Cordelia.
(26:26):
Several of Tardi's ex girlfriends came forward, revealing Cordelia's attempts
to rekindle their relationships with Tardi. Their statements highlighted a
pattern of interference in her son's love life. Perhaps the
most damning testimony came from the principle of Marion Elementary School.
The principle revealed that just days before the murder, Cordelia
(26:47):
had approached him trying to get Jev fired by making
false accusations about her conduct with students. This showed how
far Cordelia was willing to go to sabotage Jev's life.
As the case progressed, the prosecution built a strong argument
for premeditated murder. Cordelia's purchases at the hardware store, her
(27:07):
careful selection of the location, and her attempts to create
an alibi all pointed to a crime planned in advance,
not an impulsive act. Cordelia's defense team tried to argue
for a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity,
citing her mental health issues and an apparent break from reality. However,
(27:29):
the evidence of premeditation made it difficult to sustain this defense.
Throughout the trial, Tardi struggled to come to terms with
his mother's actions. He gave key testimony about Cordelia's behavior
in the months leading up to the murder, his voice
barely audible as he recounted the growing tension and his
own inability to recognize the danger Cordelia posed. Cordelia Gosling's
(27:53):
trial ended with a guilty verdict. She was sentenced to
life in prison without the possibility of parole, take king
into account her age and mental state to avoid the
death penalty. As she was led out of the court room,
the once proud woman now appeared small and broken, the
weight of her actions finally sinking in. For Tardi, the
end of the trial brought no solace. He was left
(28:16):
grappling with the double tragedy of losing both the woman
he loved and the mother he thought he knew. In
the months following the trial, Tardi threw himself into his
work at the animal shelter, finding comfort in caring for
creatures who offered him unconditional love. But the pain of
his losses lingered, and the question of whether he could
(28:37):
have done more to prevent the tragedy haunted him. The
town of Marion, too, struggled to recover from the shock.
Cordelia Gosling had been a respected figure in the community
for decades, known for her charitable work and refined manners.
Her fall from grace and the brutality of her crime
exposed the hidden currents of judgment, control and obsession that
(28:59):
had veested beneath the surface. Conversations about mental health, fat phobia,
and toxic relationships began to emerge as people tried to
make sense of how something so horrific could happen in
their quiet, close knit town. In the weeks following her arrest,
more details of Cordelia's descent into madness came to light.
(29:20):
Investigators combing through her meticulously kept home found stacks of journals,
each entry revealing a woman unraveling under the weight of
her own obsessions. Some entries were filled with lists ways
to make Jev feel unwelcome, diets Jev should follow tactics
to push her out of Tardy's life. Others were heartbreaking
(29:40):
confessions of guilt and confusion, moments when Cordelia seemed aware
that she was losing control but couldn't stop herself. Psychologists
diagnosed Cordelia with severe narcissistic personality disorder, combined with unresolved
grief and an unhealthy emotional dependence on her son. The
combination had pushed her into a state of obsessive control,
(30:02):
where Tardy's independence and love for Jev were seen as
personal betrayals. She became fixated on Jev's weight, seeing it
as symbolic of everything that was wrong in the relationship
and in her life. In her distorted view, she truly
believed that by removing Jev, she was saving Tardy from
a lifetime of misery. One of the most damning pieces
(30:23):
of evidence against Cordelia came from her Internet history, which
forensic investigators were able to recover despite her attempts to
delete it. Her searches revealed a dark path of obsession.
She had spent countless hours on websites promoting extreme dieting
and body shaming, searching for ways to convince Tardy to
leave Jev or sabotage their relationship. She had even visited
(30:47):
forums that discussed methods to manipulate family members or break
up couples, leaving a digital trail that showed just how
far her mind had spiraled into delusion. In court, whichness
painted a picture of a woman who had always been controlling,
but who had become increasingly erratic in the months leading
up to the wedding. Friends and neighbors who had once
(31:09):
admired Cordelia for her poise and generosity now described unsettling encounters,
snide comments about Jev's appearance, an unyielding need to control
every aspect of her son's life, and a growing sense
of paranoia. Several of Tardy's ex girlfriends testified about Cordelia's
interference in their relationships, revealing a pattern of manipulation and
(31:31):
control that spanned years. Perhaps the most chilling testimony came
from the principle of Marian Elementary School, who recounted how
just days before the murder, Cordelia had tried to have
Jev fired. She had made false accusations about Jev's conduct
with her students, claiming that Jev was unfit to teach
due to her weight and mental state. The principal, aware
(31:55):
of Jev's stellar reputation and beloved status among students and parents,
had dismissed Cordelia's claims, but the attempt showed just how
determined Cordelia had been to destroy Jev's life. As the
trial progressed, the prosecution made a strong case for premeditated murder.
Cordelia's purchases of the rope, duct tape, and gardening shears,
(32:16):
her calculated choice of a secluded location, and her attempts
to establish an alibi all pointed to a meticulously planned crime.
Her defense team argued that her deteriorating mental state had
pushed her to the breaking point, but the evidence of
premeditation made it difficult to mount a successful insanity defense. Tardi,
(32:38):
caught in the middle of the tragedy, was forced to
testify against his own mother. His voice cracked with emotion
as he recounted the increasing tension between Jeev and Cordelia
and the guilt he felt for not doing more to
protect the woman he loved. He described Cordelia's escalating behavior
in the months before the wedding, her constant criticism of Jev,
(33:01):
her attempts to undermine the relationship, and the final explosive
confrontation in the bakery, where Tardi had told his mother
to stay out of the wedding preparations. As he spoke,
the courtroom remained silent, the weight of the tragedy hanging
over everyone present. For Tardi, the trial was not just
about seeking justice for Jev, but about coming to terms
(33:23):
with the fact that the woman who had raised him,
who he had loved and admired, had committed an act
of unimaginable violence. The verdict came swiftly. Cordelia Gosling was
found guilty of first degree murder and sentenced to life
in prison without the possibility of parole. The sentence brought
a measure of closure to the community of Marion, but
(33:45):
for Tardi and Jev's family, the wounds would take much
longer to heal. In the months that followed, Tardi continued
to work at the animal shelter, finding solace in the
quiet routine of caring for the animals. His grief was
still raw, but the unconditional love of the creatures he
cared for offered him a sense of peace that he
(34:06):
couldn't find elsewhere. The town of Marion, too, began to heal,
though the memory of what had happened would linger for
years to come. Cordelia, once a respected member of the community,
now spent her days in a prison cell, her mind
a labyrinth of delusion and regret. The journals she had
once meticulously filled with plans to control her son's life
(34:30):
now sat in evidence boxes, a haunting testament to the
dangers of unchecked obsession and the devastating consequences it can
have on those we love.
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!