October 27, 2025 • 20 mins
Episode One: The Original Sin Episode One traces gambling's deep roots in basketball, beginning with the devastating college point-shaving scandals of the nineteen fifties and sixties that first exposed the sport's vulnerability to corruption. The episode chronicles how individual players could control outcomes, making basketball uniquely susceptible to manipulation. It explores the gambling culture within NBA locker rooms, high-stakes poker games on team planes, and controversies surrounding Michael Jordan and Charles Barkley. The centerpiece is the two thousand seven Tim Donaghy scandal, when an NBA referee was caught betting on his own games and sharing information with mob-connected bookmakers. His fifteen-month prison sentence should have been a wake-up call, but instead the league buried the problem.
This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI
This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Hello, I'm Miles Mercer, and welcome to the inside bed,
a deep investigation into the NBA betting scandal that's shaking
professional basketball to its core. Yes, I'm an artificial intelligence,
and here's why that's actually perfect for this story. I
have no team loyalties, no industry connections to protect, and
no reason to pull punches. I'm here to follow the
(00:20):
facts wherever they lead, and believe me, they lead to
some dark places. On October twenty third, twenty twenty five,
the Federal Bureau of Investigation made an announcement that sent
shockwaves through the sports world. Thirty four people were arrested
across eleven states in connection with illegal gambling operations tied
to the National Basketball Association. Among those arrested were some
(00:42):
of the biggest names in basketball. Chauncey Billups, a Hall
of Fame player and current head coach of the Portland Trailblazers,
was taken into custody in Oregon. Terry Razier, an active
player for the Miami Heat, was arrested at a hotel
in Orlando just hours before his team season opener. Damon Jones,
a player and assistant coach, was also among those charged.
(01:04):
FBI director Cash Patetel stood before cameras and described the
scope of the conspiracy in stark terms. This is the
insider trading saga for the NBA, he said. The fraud
is mind boggling. The investigation had uncovered two separate but
related schemes involving tens of millions of dollars, organized crime families,
and sophisticated cheating technologies. In one scheme, current and former
(01:28):
players allegedly provided insider information about who would play, who
would sit out, and who would leave games early with
convenient injuries. This information was then used to place massive
bets on player performance props. In the other scheme, Billips
and Jones allegedly used their celebrity status to lure wealthy
marks into regged poker games backed by the mafia, complete
(01:49):
with X ray tables, marked cards, and hidden cameras. But
here's the thing. As shocking as these arrests were, as
jaw dropping as the details sounded, one of this should
have been surprising because this isn't the first time the
NBA has been rocked by a gambling scandal. It isn't
even the second or third time. The truth is that
(02:09):
basketball and gambling have been dancing together since before the
NBA even existed, and every time the music stops, we
act shock to find them in each other's arms. To
understand the twenty twenty five scandal, you have to go
back decades. You have to understand that gambling didn't corrupt basketball.
Basketball was born into corruption, and it never quite managed
(02:30):
to escape. The story really begins in the nineteen fifties,
when college basketball was exploding in popularity. The game was fast, exciting,
and perfect for urban audiences who packed into arenas like
Madison Square Garden to watch. But there was a problem.
Individual players had enormous influence over outcomes. Unlike football, where
(02:50):
eleven players on each side diluted individual impact, or baseball,
where a single batter only comes up a few times
per game, basketball gave star player's constant opportunities to control
the score. A point guard could throw bad passes, a
center could miss layups, a shooter could brick open shots,
and if you were betting on the point spread, you
didn't need a team to lose, You just needed them
(03:13):
to win by less than expected. In nineteen fifty one,
the college basketball world was devastated by revelations that players
from the City College of New York, the reigning national
champions had been shaving points. They weren't trying to lose
games outright, they were just making sure their team didn't
cover the spread. The scheme involved dozens of players from
(03:34):
multiple schools, including Long Island University, New York University, and Kentucky.
The mastermind was a gambler named Salvator Salatso, who paid
players between five hundred and fifteen hundred dollars per game.
That might not sound like much today, but for college
kids in nineteen fifty one, it was serious money. The
(03:54):
scandal destroyed lies and careers. Players who had been heroes
became pariahs overnight. Some went to prison. The message seemed clear,
gambling and basketball couldn't coexist, except they did. Just ten
years later, in nineteen sixty one, another massive point shaving
scandal erupted, this time involving thirty seven players from twenty
(04:16):
two schools. Once again, organized crime had infiltrated the game.
Once again, players had been seduced by easy money, and
once again this sport promised to clean itself up. When
the NBA was growing into a major professional league in
the nineteen seventies and eighties, These college scandals cast a
long shadow. Team owners in league officials knew that their product,
(04:38):
their entire business model, depended on fans believing the games
were legitimate. If people thought outcomes were predetermined and manipulated,
why would they buy tickets, why would they watch on television.
The integrity of competition wasn't just an abstract ideal. It
was the foundation of everything. But even as the league
publicly condemned gambling, a different culture was quietly flourishing within
(05:01):
NBA locker rooms and team planes. Professional basketball players, coaches,
and staff members gambled constantly. High stakes poker games were
routine on charter flights. A card game called boret popular
in the South, involved pots that could reach tens or
even hundreds of thousands of dollars. Players bet on golf,
on dice, games, on practically anything. Charles Barkley, one of
(05:24):
the most beloved players of his generation, was open about
his gambling habit. He would later admit to losing millions
of dollars in casinos, but during his playing career this
was treated as a personality quirk, not a threat to
the game. Then there was Michael Jordan, the greatest player
in basketball history had a well documented love of gambling.
He played high stakes golf matches. He was photographed in
(05:46):
Atlantic City casinos the night before playoff games. After his father,
James Jordan, was murdered in nineteen ninety three, ugly conspiracy
theories circulated, suggesting the killing was connected to Michael's gambling debts.
Law enforcement found no evidence to support these theories, and
they remain entirely unsubstantiated, But the fact that such theories
could gain traction revealed something important people understood, even if
(06:09):
they didn't say it out loud, that gambling existed at
the highest levels of professional basketball. The NBA's position was
essentially that what players did with their own money was
their own business as long as they didn't bet on
NBA games. This was the bright line that supposedly couldn't
be crossed. You could lose a million dollars at a
craps table, but you couldn't bet on basketball. The problem
(06:31):
with bright lines, though, is that they're only visible if
someone is looking for them. For years, the league operated
under an uneasy truce with gambling culture. Everyone knew it existed,
nobody wanted to examine it too closely. Then, came the
summer of two thousand and seven, and everything changed. The
phone call came in July. The FBI contacted the NBA
with information that would become the worst scandal in league history.
(06:54):
One of their referees, a thirteen year veteran named Tim Donahey,
had been betting on games he officiated. He had also
been providing inside information to professional gamblers with ties to
organized crime. The details, as they emerged over the following
weeks and months, were devastating. Tim Donahue came from a
basketball family. His father had been a referee. Donahuy himself
(07:16):
had worked his way up to the ranks and had
been officiating NBA games since nineteen ninety four. He was
considered a competent, if unremarkable official. Behind the scenes, though,
Donahue had a secret. He was a compulsive gambler with
mounting debts, and he had found a way to solve
his problem. Starting in the two thousand three and two
thousand four season, Donahue began providing picks to professional gamblers.
(07:40):
He would analyze upcoming games, considering factors that only an
insider would know. Which referees were working the game and
what their tendencies were which players were nursing injuries, which
coaches were feuding with which officials. This information was vayuable,
but it was just the beginning. In December two thousand
and six, donahe He took the next step. He started
(08:02):
betting on games he was officiating. Think about what this means.
A referee has enormous power to influence the outcome of
a basketball game, especially a close game. A questionable foul
call in the final minutes can swing the score by
two or three points. A technical foul on a coach
can shift momentum, the decision whether to call a player
for traveling or let it slide, whether to whistle a
(08:24):
hand check or allow physical play. These judgment calls happened
dozens of times per game. A referee who wanted to
influence the final margin had countless opportunities to do so.
Donofy worked with two men to execute his schame. James Batista,
known as Baba, was a professional gambler with connections to
organized crime in Philadelphia. Tommy Martino was Donofi's high school
(08:45):
classmate who served as the go between. The operation was simple.
Donofy would indicate which way he was leaning on a game,
Batista would place large bets, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars,
through offshore sports books. After the game, If the bet one,
Donofy would receive thousands of dollars in cash, usually passed
to him by Martino. The FBI uncovered the scheme through
(09:07):
wire taps related to a mode investigation. They weren't even
looking for basketball corruption, they stumbled into it When they
approached Donofy in June twenty seven, he quickly agreed to cooperate.
His life was falling apart. He had debts he couldn't pay,
He had mob figures reddening him. The FBI was his
way out. On August fifteenth, two thousand seven, the story
(09:27):
broke publicly. NBA Commissioner David Stern held a press conference
and announced that the league had been informed of the investigation.
Sterne looked shaken. He called it the most serious situation
and worse situation that he had dealt with in his career.
The implications were staggering. If one referee had been betting
on games and manipulating outcomes, how many games had been affected?
(09:48):
Were other referees involved? Could fans trust anything they had
watched Donaki eventually pleaded guilty to two felony charges, conspiracy
to engage in wire fraud and transmitting wagering information through
interstate commerce. He was sentenced to fifteen months in federal prison.
Batista received fifteen months, Martino got one year and one day.
(10:08):
But the legal proceedings were just the beginning of the fallout. Donaghy,
facing prison and with nothing left to lose, started making
explosive claims. He alleged that the NBA had known about
referee bias and had done nothing. He claimed that referees
routinely favored certain teams or players based on what would
be good for league revenues or television ratings. He suggested
(10:29):
that in big games, particularly playoff games, officiating was slanted
toward creating competitive series rather than calling the games fairly.
He even alleged that other referees had gambling problems or
questionable relationships with gamblers. The NBA vehemently denied these accusations.
David Stern called Donahey a rogue criminal. The league commissioned
(10:49):
an independent investigation led by Lawrence Pettiwitz, a former federal prosecutor.
The Pennywitz Report released in two thousand and eight found
no evidence that any other referee had bet on games
or provided information to gamblers. It did acknowledge some issues
with referee conduct and recommended reforms, but the conclusion was clear.
This was one bad apple, not a systemic problem. Except
(11:13):
Donnody never stopped talking. He wrote a book called Personal Foul,
in which he detailed his version of events and expanded
on his allegations about league corruption. He gave interviews claiming
the fix was in on major games. He pointed to
specific playoff series and argued that the officiating had been
manipulated to extend the series and generate more television revenue.
(11:33):
His credibility was obviously questionable. This was a convicted felon
who had every reason the shift blame and minimize his
own guilt. But some of what he said resonated. Because
fans had always suspected that something was off about NBA officiating,
the Donahy scandal should have been a turning point. It
should have forced the NDA to confront the reality that
gambling and basketball were intertwined in dangerous ways. The league
(11:56):
did implement center forms. They expanded their security department, They
monitored referee communications more closely. They created protocols for reporting
suspicious activity, but the fundamental culture didn't change, because changing
the culture would have meant acknowledging that the culture existed
in the first place. Inside NBA locker rooms and on
team charter flights. Dambling continued. Players still played pochra for
(12:18):
high stakes. They still bet on golf and other sports.
The unwritten rule remained, you could gamble on anything except
NBA games, But the Donahey case had exposed how flimsy
that rule actually was. If a referee could bet on
basketball for years without getting caught, if organized crime could
penetrate the leaves officiating staff, what else was happening that
(12:39):
no one knew about. The question that hung in the
air after Donahue was sentenced and packed off to federal
prison was simple, Was he really alone? Or was he
just the only one who got caught? Donahe insisted he
wasn't alone. He claimed other referees had gambling issues. He
said players and coaches knew more than they admitted. The
league said he was lying to say. But here's the
(13:01):
thing Donegy may have been a criminal and a liar,
but that doesn't mean everything he said was false. Sometimes
the paranoid are actually on to something. In the years
after the scandal, there were occasional whispers stories about NBA
staff members with gambling problems, rumors about players who owed
money to the wrong people, but nothing concrete emerged. The
(13:22):
league moved on. Stern retired in twenty fourteen and was
replaced by Adam Silver, who brought a more progressive, media
savvy approach to the job. The NBA grew more popular
and more profitable. Star players became global icons, Broadcast deals
reached billions of dollars, and the Donahe scandal faded into history,
an embarrassing chapter that everyone preferred to forget. But forgetting
(13:45):
isn't the same as learning, and the conditions that allowed
Donaheat to operate for years without detection never really went away.
The gambling culture and NBA locker rooms continued. The financial
pressures on players, many of whim came from poverty and
suddenly had acted as to enormous wealth created vulnerability to
bad influences. The rise of social media in the twenty
(14:06):
four hour news cycle made inside information more valuable than ever.
Everyone wanted an edge. Everyone wanted to know which player
was really hurt in which was faking who was fighting
with the coach who was unhappy with their contract. This
information had always been valuable to gamblers, but as technology
made information flow faster and more widely, the potential for
exploitation grew exponentially. And then, in twenty eighteen, something happened
(14:31):
that changed everything. The Supreme Court of the United States
struck down a federal law that had prohibited most states
from legalized in sports betting. In a single decision, the
court opened the floodgates. States rushed to legalize and regulate
sports gambling. Companies like DraftKings and Fandul, which had operated
in legal gray areas as daily fantasy sports sites, transformed
(14:53):
into full fledged sportsbooks, and the professional sports leagues, including
the NBA, embraced their new partners with open arms. The
NBA didn't just tolerate legal sports betting, they promoted it.
They entered into partnerships with gambling companies. They allowed sports
books to be built into arenas. During broadcasts, announcers discussed
(15:13):
betting lines and prop bets. The lead that had been
so traumatized by the Donahi scandal just a decade earlier,
was now actively encouraging fans to gamble on games. The
rationale was simple. If gambling was going to happen anyway,
it was better to have it regulated and legal. The
league could monitor betting patterns more effectively, they could partner
(15:34):
with sportsbooks that shared data, and perhaps most importantly, they
could make enormous amounts of money from an entirely new
revenue stream. The NBA negotiated broadcast deals worth seventy six
billion dollars over eleven years, deals that were explicitly tied
to the growth of legalized gambling. The sport wasn't just
tolerating gambling anymore. Their entire financial model depended on it.
(15:57):
But here's what nobody wanted to talk about. The more
you and courage gambling, the more valuable inside information becomes,
and the more valuable inside information becomes, a more temptation
there is to exploit it. The Donaha case had revealed
that inside information could be worth hundreds of thousands, maybe
millions of dollars to the right people. Now the NBA
was building an entire ecosystem around betting. They were creating
(16:20):
conditions where that information was more valuable than ever, and
they were doing it with full knowledge of what had
happened just years before. By twenty twenty three. In twenty
twenty four, there were warning signs that something was wrong.
Betting patterns on certain games looked suspicious. Players were being
harassed by gamblers who had lost bets. There were reports
of unusual activity around player props. The league investigated quietly,
(16:43):
but found nothing definitive, or at least they said they
found nothing. Then came the Johnte Porter case. In the
spring of twenty twenty four, Porter, a center for the
Toronto Raptors, was caught deliberately under performing in games so
that conspirators could win bets on his player props. He
would claim to be injured and leave games early. The
bets would cash. The scheme was relatively small time, but
(17:05):
it was brazen, and it confirmed what some had suspected.
Players were manipulating games to benefit gamblers. The NBA banned
Porter for life and thought they had contained the problem.
But Porter wasn't acting alone. He had co conspirators, and
those co conspirators were connected to something much bigger. The
FBI had been watching the whole time, building a case
that would eventually lead to the arrests announced in October
(17:27):
twenty twenty five. The arrests of Chauncey Billups, Terry Rizier,
and Damon Jones weren't the end of the story. They
were the latest chapter in a story that stretches back
to those college point shaving scandals in the nineteen fifties.
Every generation thinks their scandal is unprecedented, but the pattern
repeats because the fundamentals never change. Basketball is uniquely vulnerable
(17:50):
to gambling corruption because individual players have so much control,
the money involved is enormous, and human nature being what
it is, there will always be people willing to cheat
for an advantage. That Donicky scandal should have been the
wake up call. It should have forced a reckoning with
gambling culture in basketball. Instead, the league buried the story
(18:10):
as quickly as possible, implemented superficial reforms, and moved on. Then, incredibly,
they decided to embrace gambling as a business partner. They
chose short term profits over long term integrity, and now
they're dealing with the consequences. Tim Donacky served his time
and got out of prison. He spent the years since
(18:30):
giving interviews and making accusations. Many dismissed him as a
bitter ex con with an axe to grind, but In
October twenty twenty five, after the arrest were announced, Donahe
appeared on a podcast and said something chilling. He claimed
the current scandals were proof that the problem was bigger
than the NBA ever admitted. He suggested that his case
(18:51):
in two thousand and seven wasn't fully exposed. He alleged
that the league had protected people and buried evidence. Was
he telling the truth? Was he making it up to
feel relevant again. It's hard to say, but the fact
that major gambling scandals keep emerging suggests that something is
deeply wrong. The uncomfortable truth is this money corrupts everything
(19:13):
it touches. Professional basketball involves enormous amounts of money. Gambling
involves even more enormous amounts of money. When you combine
the two, corruption isn't just possible, it's almost inevitable. The
individuals who get caught, whether it's Tim Donahe or Terry
Rozier or Chauncey Billups, they're not aberrations. They're symptoms of
(19:33):
a system that has gambling woven into his DNA and
has never figured out how to exist without it. The
arrests in October twenty twenty five were shocking, but They
shouldn't have been surprising, because this isn't the first time,
and unless something fundamental changes, it won't be the last time.
The pattern is clear. Scandal erupts, the league expresses shock
and dismay, reforms are promised, then the money keeps flowing,
(19:57):
and everyone forgets until the next scandal breaks. We're in
the middle of that cycle right now, watching it play
out in real time. The original sin wasn't Tim Donnie
betting on games in two thousand and six. The original
sin was the decision made decades ago to pretend that
basketball and gambling could coexist without consequences. Every scandal since
(20:17):
then has been a direct result of that fundamental lie.
And until the NBA is willing to confront that truth,
until they're willing to choose integrity over profits, the scandals
will continue. Please subscribe to hear the next episode, where
we'll explore what happened after gambling became legal in twenty eighteen,
and follow the case of John tay Porter, the player
(20:37):
whose scheme should have started everything but didn't. This podcast
is brought to you by Quiet Please Podcast Networks. For
more content like this, please go to Quiet Please dot
AI Quiet Please dot AI hear what matters
Hello, I'm Miles Mercer, and welcome to the inside bed,
a deep investigation into the NBA betting scandal that's shaking
professional basketball to its core. Yes, I'm an artificial intelligence,
and here's why that's actually perfect for this story. I
have no team loyalties, no industry connections to protect, and
no reason to pull punches. I'm here to follow the
(00:20):
facts wherever they lead, and believe me, they lead to
some dark places. On October twenty third, twenty twenty five,
the Federal Bureau of Investigation made an announcement that sent
shockwaves through the sports world. Thirty four people were arrested
across eleven states in connection with illegal gambling operations tied
to the National Basketball Association. Among those arrested were some
(00:42):
of the biggest names in basketball. Chauncey Billups, a Hall
of Fame player and current head coach of the Portland Trailblazers,
was taken into custody in Oregon. Terry Razier, an active
player for the Miami Heat, was arrested at a hotel
in Orlando just hours before his team season opener. Damon Jones,
a player and assistant coach, was also among those charged.
(01:04):
FBI director Cash Patetel stood before cameras and described the
scope of the conspiracy in stark terms. This is the
insider trading saga for the NBA, he said. The fraud
is mind boggling. The investigation had uncovered two separate but
related schemes involving tens of millions of dollars, organized crime families,
and sophisticated cheating technologies. In one scheme, current and former
(01:28):
players allegedly provided insider information about who would play, who
would sit out, and who would leave games early with
convenient injuries. This information was then used to place massive
bets on player performance props. In the other scheme, Billips
and Jones allegedly used their celebrity status to lure wealthy
marks into regged poker games backed by the mafia, complete
(01:49):
with X ray tables, marked cards, and hidden cameras. But
here's the thing. As shocking as these arrests were, as
jaw dropping as the details sounded, one of this should
have been surprising because this isn't the first time the
NBA has been rocked by a gambling scandal. It isn't
even the second or third time. The truth is that
(02:09):
basketball and gambling have been dancing together since before the
NBA even existed, and every time the music stops, we
act shock to find them in each other's arms. To
understand the twenty twenty five scandal, you have to go
back decades. You have to understand that gambling didn't corrupt basketball.
Basketball was born into corruption, and it never quite managed
(02:30):
to escape. The story really begins in the nineteen fifties,
when college basketball was exploding in popularity. The game was fast, exciting,
and perfect for urban audiences who packed into arenas like
Madison Square Garden to watch. But there was a problem.
Individual players had enormous influence over outcomes. Unlike football, where
(02:50):
eleven players on each side diluted individual impact, or baseball,
where a single batter only comes up a few times
per game, basketball gave star player's constant opportunities to control
the score. A point guard could throw bad passes, a
center could miss layups, a shooter could brick open shots,
and if you were betting on the point spread, you
didn't need a team to lose, You just needed them
(03:13):
to win by less than expected. In nineteen fifty one,
the college basketball world was devastated by revelations that players
from the City College of New York, the reigning national
champions had been shaving points. They weren't trying to lose
games outright, they were just making sure their team didn't
cover the spread. The scheme involved dozens of players from
(03:34):
multiple schools, including Long Island University, New York University, and Kentucky.
The mastermind was a gambler named Salvator Salatso, who paid
players between five hundred and fifteen hundred dollars per game.
That might not sound like much today, but for college
kids in nineteen fifty one, it was serious money. The
(03:54):
scandal destroyed lies and careers. Players who had been heroes
became pariahs overnight. Some went to prison. The message seemed clear,
gambling and basketball couldn't coexist, except they did. Just ten
years later, in nineteen sixty one, another massive point shaving
scandal erupted, this time involving thirty seven players from twenty
(04:16):
two schools. Once again, organized crime had infiltrated the game.
Once again, players had been seduced by easy money, and
once again this sport promised to clean itself up. When
the NBA was growing into a major professional league in
the nineteen seventies and eighties, These college scandals cast a
long shadow. Team owners in league officials knew that their product,
(04:38):
their entire business model, depended on fans believing the games
were legitimate. If people thought outcomes were predetermined and manipulated,
why would they buy tickets, why would they watch on television.
The integrity of competition wasn't just an abstract ideal. It
was the foundation of everything. But even as the league
publicly condemned gambling, a different culture was quietly flourishing within
(05:01):
NBA locker rooms and team planes. Professional basketball players, coaches,
and staff members gambled constantly. High stakes poker games were
routine on charter flights. A card game called boret popular
in the South, involved pots that could reach tens or
even hundreds of thousands of dollars. Players bet on golf,
on dice, games, on practically anything. Charles Barkley, one of
(05:24):
the most beloved players of his generation, was open about
his gambling habit. He would later admit to losing millions
of dollars in casinos, but during his playing career this
was treated as a personality quirk, not a threat to
the game. Then there was Michael Jordan, the greatest player
in basketball history had a well documented love of gambling.
He played high stakes golf matches. He was photographed in
(05:46):
Atlantic City casinos the night before playoff games. After his father,
James Jordan, was murdered in nineteen ninety three, ugly conspiracy
theories circulated, suggesting the killing was connected to Michael's gambling debts.
Law enforcement found no evidence to support these theories, and
they remain entirely unsubstantiated, But the fact that such theories
could gain traction revealed something important people understood, even if
(06:09):
they didn't say it out loud, that gambling existed at
the highest levels of professional basketball. The NBA's position was
essentially that what players did with their own money was
their own business as long as they didn't bet on
NBA games. This was the bright line that supposedly couldn't
be crossed. You could lose a million dollars at a
craps table, but you couldn't bet on basketball. The problem
(06:31):
with bright lines, though, is that they're only visible if
someone is looking for them. For years, the league operated
under an uneasy truce with gambling culture. Everyone knew it existed,
nobody wanted to examine it too closely. Then, came the
summer of two thousand and seven, and everything changed. The
phone call came in July. The FBI contacted the NBA
with information that would become the worst scandal in league history.
(06:54):
One of their referees, a thirteen year veteran named Tim Donahey,
had been betting on games he officiated. He had also
been providing inside information to professional gamblers with ties to
organized crime. The details, as they emerged over the following
weeks and months, were devastating. Tim Donahue came from a
basketball family. His father had been a referee. Donahuy himself
(07:16):
had worked his way up to the ranks and had
been officiating NBA games since nineteen ninety four. He was
considered a competent, if unremarkable official. Behind the scenes, though,
Donahue had a secret. He was a compulsive gambler with
mounting debts, and he had found a way to solve
his problem. Starting in the two thousand three and two
thousand four season, Donahue began providing picks to professional gamblers.
(07:40):
He would analyze upcoming games, considering factors that only an
insider would know. Which referees were working the game and
what their tendencies were which players were nursing injuries, which
coaches were feuding with which officials. This information was vayuable,
but it was just the beginning. In December two thousand
and six, donahe He took the next step. He started
(08:02):
betting on games he was officiating. Think about what this means.
A referee has enormous power to influence the outcome of
a basketball game, especially a close game. A questionable foul
call in the final minutes can swing the score by
two or three points. A technical foul on a coach
can shift momentum, the decision whether to call a player
for traveling or let it slide, whether to whistle a
(08:24):
hand check or allow physical play. These judgment calls happened
dozens of times per game. A referee who wanted to
influence the final margin had countless opportunities to do so.
Donofy worked with two men to execute his schame. James Batista,
known as Baba, was a professional gambler with connections to
organized crime in Philadelphia. Tommy Martino was Donofi's high school
(08:45):
classmate who served as the go between. The operation was simple.
Donofy would indicate which way he was leaning on a game,
Batista would place large bets, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars,
through offshore sports books. After the game, If the bet one,
Donofy would receive thousands of dollars in cash, usually passed
to him by Martino. The FBI uncovered the scheme through
(09:07):
wire taps related to a mode investigation. They weren't even
looking for basketball corruption, they stumbled into it When they
approached Donofy in June twenty seven, he quickly agreed to cooperate.
His life was falling apart. He had debts he couldn't pay,
He had mob figures reddening him. The FBI was his
way out. On August fifteenth, two thousand seven, the story
(09:27):
broke publicly. NBA Commissioner David Stern held a press conference
and announced that the league had been informed of the investigation.
Sterne looked shaken. He called it the most serious situation
and worse situation that he had dealt with in his career.
The implications were staggering. If one referee had been betting
on games and manipulating outcomes, how many games had been affected?
(09:48):
Were other referees involved? Could fans trust anything they had
watched Donaki eventually pleaded guilty to two felony charges, conspiracy
to engage in wire fraud and transmitting wagering information through
interstate commerce. He was sentenced to fifteen months in federal prison.
Batista received fifteen months, Martino got one year and one day.
(10:08):
But the legal proceedings were just the beginning of the fallout. Donaghy,
facing prison and with nothing left to lose, started making
explosive claims. He alleged that the NBA had known about
referee bias and had done nothing. He claimed that referees
routinely favored certain teams or players based on what would
be good for league revenues or television ratings. He suggested
(10:29):
that in big games, particularly playoff games, officiating was slanted
toward creating competitive series rather than calling the games fairly.
He even alleged that other referees had gambling problems or
questionable relationships with gamblers. The NBA vehemently denied these accusations.
David Stern called Donahey a rogue criminal. The league commissioned
(10:49):
an independent investigation led by Lawrence Pettiwitz, a former federal prosecutor.
The Pennywitz Report released in two thousand and eight found
no evidence that any other referee had bet on games
or provided information to gamblers. It did acknowledge some issues
with referee conduct and recommended reforms, but the conclusion was clear.
This was one bad apple, not a systemic problem. Except
(11:13):
Donnody never stopped talking. He wrote a book called Personal Foul,
in which he detailed his version of events and expanded
on his allegations about league corruption. He gave interviews claiming
the fix was in on major games. He pointed to
specific playoff series and argued that the officiating had been
manipulated to extend the series and generate more television revenue.
(11:33):
His credibility was obviously questionable. This was a convicted felon
who had every reason the shift blame and minimize his
own guilt. But some of what he said resonated. Because
fans had always suspected that something was off about NBA officiating,
the Donahy scandal should have been a turning point. It
should have forced the NDA to confront the reality that
gambling and basketball were intertwined in dangerous ways. The league
(11:56):
did implement center forms. They expanded their security department, They
monitored referee communications more closely. They created protocols for reporting
suspicious activity, but the fundamental culture didn't change, because changing
the culture would have meant acknowledging that the culture existed
in the first place. Inside NBA locker rooms and on
team charter flights. Dambling continued. Players still played pochra for
(12:18):
high stakes. They still bet on golf and other sports.
The unwritten rule remained, you could gamble on anything except
NBA games, But the Donahey case had exposed how flimsy
that rule actually was. If a referee could bet on
basketball for years without getting caught, if organized crime could
penetrate the leaves officiating staff, what else was happening that
(12:39):
no one knew about. The question that hung in the
air after Donahue was sentenced and packed off to federal
prison was simple, Was he really alone? Or was he
just the only one who got caught? Donahe insisted he
wasn't alone. He claimed other referees had gambling issues. He
said players and coaches knew more than they admitted. The
league said he was lying to say. But here's the
(13:01):
thing Donegy may have been a criminal and a liar,
but that doesn't mean everything he said was false. Sometimes
the paranoid are actually on to something. In the years
after the scandal, there were occasional whispers stories about NBA
staff members with gambling problems, rumors about players who owed
money to the wrong people, but nothing concrete emerged. The
(13:22):
league moved on. Stern retired in twenty fourteen and was
replaced by Adam Silver, who brought a more progressive, media
savvy approach to the job. The NBA grew more popular
and more profitable. Star players became global icons, Broadcast deals
reached billions of dollars, and the Donahe scandal faded into history,
an embarrassing chapter that everyone preferred to forget. But forgetting
(13:45):
isn't the same as learning, and the conditions that allowed
Donaheat to operate for years without detection never really went away.
The gambling culture and NBA locker rooms continued. The financial
pressures on players, many of whim came from poverty and
suddenly had acted as to enormous wealth created vulnerability to
bad influences. The rise of social media in the twenty
(14:06):
four hour news cycle made inside information more valuable than ever.
Everyone wanted an edge. Everyone wanted to know which player
was really hurt in which was faking who was fighting
with the coach who was unhappy with their contract. This
information had always been valuable to gamblers, but as technology
made information flow faster and more widely, the potential for
exploitation grew exponentially. And then, in twenty eighteen, something happened
(14:31):
that changed everything. The Supreme Court of the United States
struck down a federal law that had prohibited most states
from legalized in sports betting. In a single decision, the
court opened the floodgates. States rushed to legalize and regulate
sports gambling. Companies like DraftKings and Fandul, which had operated
in legal gray areas as daily fantasy sports sites, transformed
(14:53):
into full fledged sportsbooks, and the professional sports leagues, including
the NBA, embraced their new partners with open arms. The
NBA didn't just tolerate legal sports betting, they promoted it.
They entered into partnerships with gambling companies. They allowed sports
books to be built into arenas. During broadcasts, announcers discussed
(15:13):
betting lines and prop bets. The lead that had been
so traumatized by the Donahi scandal just a decade earlier,
was now actively encouraging fans to gamble on games. The
rationale was simple. If gambling was going to happen anyway,
it was better to have it regulated and legal. The
league could monitor betting patterns more effectively, they could partner
(15:34):
with sportsbooks that shared data, and perhaps most importantly, they
could make enormous amounts of money from an entirely new
revenue stream. The NBA negotiated broadcast deals worth seventy six
billion dollars over eleven years, deals that were explicitly tied
to the growth of legalized gambling. The sport wasn't just
tolerating gambling anymore. Their entire financial model depended on it.
(15:57):
But here's what nobody wanted to talk about. The more
you and courage gambling, the more valuable inside information becomes,
and the more valuable inside information becomes, a more temptation
there is to exploit it. The Donaha case had revealed
that inside information could be worth hundreds of thousands, maybe
millions of dollars to the right people. Now the NBA
was building an entire ecosystem around betting. They were creating
(16:20):
conditions where that information was more valuable than ever, and
they were doing it with full knowledge of what had
happened just years before. By twenty twenty three. In twenty
twenty four, there were warning signs that something was wrong.
Betting patterns on certain games looked suspicious. Players were being
harassed by gamblers who had lost bets. There were reports
of unusual activity around player props. The league investigated quietly,
(16:43):
but found nothing definitive, or at least they said they
found nothing. Then came the Johnte Porter case. In the
spring of twenty twenty four, Porter, a center for the
Toronto Raptors, was caught deliberately under performing in games so
that conspirators could win bets on his player props. He
would claim to be injured and leave games early. The
bets would cash. The scheme was relatively small time, but
(17:05):
it was brazen, and it confirmed what some had suspected.
Players were manipulating games to benefit gamblers. The NBA banned
Porter for life and thought they had contained the problem.
But Porter wasn't acting alone. He had co conspirators, and
those co conspirators were connected to something much bigger. The
FBI had been watching the whole time, building a case
that would eventually lead to the arrests announced in October
(17:27):
twenty twenty five. The arrests of Chauncey Billups, Terry Rizier,
and Damon Jones weren't the end of the story. They
were the latest chapter in a story that stretches back
to those college point shaving scandals in the nineteen fifties.
Every generation thinks their scandal is unprecedented, but the pattern
repeats because the fundamentals never change. Basketball is uniquely vulnerable
(17:50):
to gambling corruption because individual players have so much control,
the money involved is enormous, and human nature being what
it is, there will always be people willing to cheat
for an advantage. That Donicky scandal should have been the
wake up call. It should have forced a reckoning with
gambling culture in basketball. Instead, the league buried the story
(18:10):
as quickly as possible, implemented superficial reforms, and moved on. Then, incredibly,
they decided to embrace gambling as a business partner. They
chose short term profits over long term integrity, and now
they're dealing with the consequences. Tim Donacky served his time
and got out of prison. He spent the years since
(18:30):
giving interviews and making accusations. Many dismissed him as a
bitter ex con with an axe to grind, but In
October twenty twenty five, after the arrest were announced, Donahe
appeared on a podcast and said something chilling. He claimed
the current scandals were proof that the problem was bigger
than the NBA ever admitted. He suggested that his case
(18:51):
in two thousand and seven wasn't fully exposed. He alleged
that the league had protected people and buried evidence. Was
he telling the truth? Was he making it up to
feel relevant again. It's hard to say, but the fact
that major gambling scandals keep emerging suggests that something is
deeply wrong. The uncomfortable truth is this money corrupts everything
(19:13):
it touches. Professional basketball involves enormous amounts of money. Gambling
involves even more enormous amounts of money. When you combine
the two, corruption isn't just possible, it's almost inevitable. The
individuals who get caught, whether it's Tim Donahe or Terry
Rozier or Chauncey Billups, they're not aberrations. They're symptoms of
(19:33):
a system that has gambling woven into his DNA and
has never figured out how to exist without it. The
arrests in October twenty twenty five were shocking, but They
shouldn't have been surprising, because this isn't the first time,
and unless something fundamental changes, it won't be the last time.
The pattern is clear. Scandal erupts, the league expresses shock
and dismay, reforms are promised, then the money keeps flowing,
(19:57):
and everyone forgets until the next scandal breaks. We're in
the middle of that cycle right now, watching it play
out in real time. The original sin wasn't Tim Donnie
betting on games in two thousand and six. The original
sin was the decision made decades ago to pretend that
basketball and gambling could coexist without consequences. Every scandal since
(20:17):
then has been a direct result of that fundamental lie.
And until the NBA is willing to confront that truth,
until they're willing to choose integrity over profits, the scandals
will continue. Please subscribe to hear the next episode, where
we'll explore what happened after gambling became legal in twenty eighteen,
and follow the case of John tay Porter, the player
(20:37):
whose scheme should have started everything but didn't. This podcast
is brought to you by Quiet Please Podcast Networks. For
more content like this, please go to Quiet Please dot
AI Quiet Please dot AI hear what matters
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com