All Episodes

October 17, 2024 15 mins
Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:14):
Seven oh six here at fifty five KRS detalk station,
Bryan Thomas wishing everyone a happy Thursday and welcoming back
to the fifty five KRC Morning Show. Find them online
at b I p p S Buckeye Ensued for a
Public Policy BPI dot org. God, welcome back to Jim Waters.
It's a pleasure to have you on the program.

Speaker 2 (00:32):
It's fine, except it's the Bluegrass Institute. We're in KENTUCKYSTA.

Speaker 1 (00:37):
That's twice. That is twice this morning. I've screwed up,
and my sincere apologies and I also had apologize.

Speaker 2 (00:46):
Okay, I just want everybody to know where we're.

Speaker 1 (00:48):
At Bluegrass Institute. I apologize, and you know that. I
also apologize. They're on the program for not talking about
UH and compared to Ohio Issue one, which is complex
and crazy, two very simple but very important amendments that
folks in Kentucky are going to be voting on Amendments
one and two. So my apologies for not, you know,
focusing a little bit more on that, but sounds to

(01:09):
me like they're both great ideas.

Speaker 2 (01:10):
Okay, you're talking to us today, so thank you.

Speaker 1 (01:13):
And I know you're a you're in a debate the
other day, a link debate with Bridget Bloom, who is
all over Kentucky amendment to let's move that one aside.
Let's start with issue one, which is very simple and
I think very easy to understand. Amendment one. No person
who is not a citizen of the United States shall
be allowed to vote in this state, period, right right.

Speaker 2 (01:35):
Yeah, well, you know, and the Constitution already says that,
but we've seen around the country where that you know,
cities in particular, have tried to get around that and
allow non citizens to vote on local issues. And I
think the legislature just wanted to close any loopholes there.
So it's it is very simple. You're right, it's a

(01:56):
very simple amendment, and that it really just clarifies and
really closes any possibility of that happening. I think it's
more of a preventing move, Brian. You know, it's more
about preventing what we've maybe seen and what some of
the concerns have been from what have been seen in
other states, like like something like what could happen in
Louisville or you know, one of our cities. Yeah, so proactive,

(02:19):
I think that's.

Speaker 1 (02:21):
Listen, if it's happened elsewhere, it certainly could happen in
the Commonwealth, so why not get ahead of it. Look,
let's not let happen over there, happened here. So I
imagine this is probably in Kentucky got pretty much widespread support,
Well I would.

Speaker 2 (02:36):
I think so. Well, of course, we'll know for sure
here in about nineteen days. But but you know, I
know that that was the intention of legislators, and I
think everybody pretty well understands that. I haven't heard much
much disagreement about that. So and you know, getting people
shaking their heads on one might help us on too.

(02:58):
We'll see. You know, it's you know, when these things
are on the ballot that sometimes that's how that works too.
So I wonder if I could give us momentum on
amendment too.

Speaker 1 (03:08):
So it may very well, because honestly, I don't understand
how the opportunity for school choice that any parent, I
don't care what your political stripe is, how any parent
could not desire at least the ability to choose which
schools their children go to, just as a concept. What's
wrong with giving parents choice? And then you pivot over

(03:30):
to the reason that people are against this idea of choice. Oh,
they'll make arguments about public money going to you know,
maybe religious institutions. But the bottom line is this is
in order to maintain the monopoly teachers unions have over education,
which is currently enshrined in the Kentucky Constitution.

Speaker 2 (03:47):
Yeah. That was on full display in our debate the
other night, incidentally, Bet, But you know, our polling is
indicated that across the board, whatever the political persuasion, a
school choice is at popular idea among a strong majority
of Kentucky. Is up to seventy percent in many in
many groups, and even with Democrats and Independence a strong majority.

(04:10):
The key here is to get that translated into you know,
passage of this amendment. Now, this amendment doesn't create a
school choice policy, right. This amendment simply says that our
Constitution cannot be interpreted as prohibiting the legislature from passing
those policies that would fund a school choice program like

(04:34):
we see in Ohio and Indiana and Tennessee and every
state surrounding US. I mean, there are over three hundred
thousand kids today who will be in a charter school
in the seven neighboring states arounding Kentucky, but none in
Kentucky because we are that far.

Speaker 1 (04:49):
Behind well, and your state legislator has tried to allow
for some funding formulas to help, you know, give the choice,
but they keep getting shot down by your Supreme Court
because is your Constitution as currently written, prohibits the use
of public money outside of public schools. So that's the lynchpin.

Speaker 2 (05:08):
Yeah, yeah, as it's interpreted any well, that's true. But
this amendment would will allow the legislature to quit looking
at having to look over their shoulders of what the
court wants, and really looking forward to what families and
students in our state need. And the Kentucky Summitive Assessment,

(05:29):
which just came out in the last couple of weeks,
shows that a majority of our students are not proficient
in math, reading, and science. And so here we have
this issue, and then we have the superintendents and the
bureaucrats and the unions bragging about an eighty nine percent
graduation rate. And I'm saying, wait a minute, what's the

(05:49):
diploma we're handing out? Is it worth anything?

Speaker 1 (05:52):
Equity?

Speaker 2 (05:52):
But what is that worth?

Speaker 1 (05:53):
That's equity, brother, that's equity, full display, and it's.

Speaker 2 (05:57):
Not helping our kids. I am not helping our kids
for the future. And that's and that's another thing, by
the way, on this, I think that we see a
real dichotomy in this debate between those of us who
really say, let's put students first, let the system adjust,
whatever the system does, it's going to do, but let
the students get what they need, versus those who say,

(06:19):
we need to protect the system, we need to prop
up the system. But the funding for education is not
for a system, it's not for a school. It is
to educate students. And if they take those dollars, Brian,
wherever they go, whether it's a traditional public school, a
public charter school, or a private school, parochial school, and
they get the education they need, then those dollars have

(06:42):
been properly used because that is what they're for. And
to all this nonsense about this would take money away
from our education system, the truth of the matter is
that even if this amendment passes, our constitution would require
the legislature to create a separate programs or a schools
choice program. It would not even take any state dollars

(07:05):
away from public schools. So why why is and there
so there's a lot of fear mongering from the governor,
and a lot of myths being thrown out there about
how this would divert money away from public education. You know,
it's interesting to me, we don't talk about that that way.
We don't talk that way when it comes to other
public goods that we're funding with public dollars. For example,

(07:28):
Medicare recipients they can use their dollars at whatever hospital
or whatever healthcare provider they need, and nobody says, well,
you're diverting money from one to the other. Why Because
the money doesn't belong to the provider. It belongs to
the patient to do what they need to do with it.
So indeed, give the individual there is the dignity of
making their own decisions.

Speaker 1 (07:49):
You know. And most notably because a lot of people
argue that, oh, you know this is you're supporting religious
organizations with the taxpayer dollars. Well, both, there's religious hospitals
out there, like the Athletic Health System hospitals, they're getting
Medicare dollars. That's an excellent point. I hadn't heard that
one before, so big props to you, Jim for bringing
that up. Well, so, and here's the language the religious.

Speaker 2 (08:10):
Yeah, on the religious issue, I mean, we already allowed
dollars to be used at religious institutions of education, pell
grants and and the GI bill. Those dollars were the
individual recipient took those dollars and decided where they spent it,
and they could be spent at Cincinnati Christian University with

(08:31):
THEAH or whatever that they could be used, that dollars
could be used at those schools. So we don't, we don't.
We don't have this problem when it comes to higher education.
Why should that be an issue with K through twelve?
The question is are our kids getting educated? And the
fact is the majority of them are not? So what
are we going to do about it? I've asked for
other solutions. I asked bridget the other night, what about

(08:54):
other solutions?

Speaker 1 (08:55):
Oh?

Speaker 2 (08:55):
By the way, one other argument that comes up a
lot is well, you're just taking money and giving it
to the wealthy. You know that this is just going
to benefit wealthy kids who are already in private schools. Well, okay,
then will you agree? Will the governor and his minions
agree that we will begin with a program that targets
low income families in failing school means? We'll be happy

(09:19):
to begin there.

Speaker 1 (09:20):
Amen, And that's the point. You don't know which direction
of the General Assembly is going to go, but the
language at least allows for the consideration of it. Quote
the General Assembly may provide financial support for the education
of students outside the system of common school with the
operative word, as you are pointing out, is may Will

(09:40):
they do it? Don't know? Might they do it in
some smaller baby step like you just suggested. Maybe that'll
be fa.

Speaker 2 (09:49):
Yeah, a lot of states. And by the way, we
just released a snapshot of thirteen northern Kentucky school districts
on our website. It's not the work and Brian, you
can see there is a great differ diference between say
a Beechwood, you know, and and and uh, some of
the other districts that are you know, the Beechwood's doing
well compared to you know, let's say Newport or you know,

(10:12):
are you know some of these other districts that Bellevue
is Dayton and so forth. You know. And so if
a parent lives in one of those districts that's not
performing as well and they want an option, what options
do they have if they can't write a check to
a private school or they can't up and move to
a better public school district. What options do they have

(10:34):
right now? Not many in Kentucky, not many at all.

Speaker 1 (10:38):
Well, and this, if the legislative solution is an effective one,
it will create more of these private schools or these
alternative schools competition. The public schools will then have to
compete with probably better performing at least in terms of
educational outcomes, and maybe they'll get their act together and
a majority will then become proficient, whereas currently, as you

(11:02):
point out, they are not.

Speaker 2 (11:04):
Around the country, that's what we've seen. We've seen where
there are choices, the more choices the state has, the
better their public education system performs. And in Kentucky we
have more than doubled per pupil funding since care in
nineteen ninety inflation adjustment. We're spending twenty one thousand dollars
per pupil in those northern Kentucky districts and across our state.

(11:27):
And yet the majority of our kids aren't being educated.
But in states that have increased spending less, the more
choices they've given parents, their public systems are outperforming Kentucky.
What is the problem here? Why can't we do this?

Speaker 1 (11:42):
It's just and you know, that there is even a
debate on this, Jim, because in the final analysis, all
I see is the people against the idea of this
freedom of choice or the looking or at least for
alternatives outside of the public school model. It's the teachers' union.
They have monopoly currently, They have monopoly on the education
materials that our children are consuming, and they have a

(12:04):
monopoly ownership of them. A majority of the students being
non proficient. That's a failing grade, my friend, right there.
There's got to be a better way, and it's currently
not as the status quo.

Speaker 2 (12:16):
It's about the system for them, it's not about the students.
And by the way, the superintendents haven't been very helpful
on this either. Quite frankly, they're the ones that have
sued to stop these school choice bills. By the way,
we have a case in the Kentucky Supreme Court about
charter schools. They probably aren't going to hear that case
until after the election, of course, So there is an

(12:37):
opportunity that even no matter what happens with this amendment,
if the Supreme Court will wake up and the Bluegrass
Institute filed an a meekas brief. Chad Meredith, former Solicitor
General of our state did great work for us on
making the case about what did the founders really mean
when they talked about common schools? What were they concerned about?

(12:59):
And it was to deny parents' options. It was they
didn't want taxes increase more than necessary. Isn't that ironic?
In the five we're in it because the other side
never saw a tax increase, they didn't absolutely adure.

Speaker 1 (13:12):
Isn't that the truth? Jim Water is doing a fun,
a phenomenal job in support of the issues both one
and two. They seem like simple, prudent, proper ways to go.
And again, I keep going back to the idea, a
parent of any political stripe has to want choice fundamentally
that you are did any parent be willing to sacrifice
their children's education merely to supportort support the monopoly that

(13:35):
is the public the teachers union. I just don't think
that washes logically or reasonably, or that any real loving
parent would embrace that. Right.

Speaker 2 (13:45):
This isn't and this is not about destroying public education.
This is about making it better, forcing it to get better.
And it's a beau fan not an either or. And
when we see that, we see all a rising tide lifts.

Speaker 1 (14:00):
All the boat check out.

Speaker 2 (14:01):
That's what we need to have happen here.

Speaker 1 (14:03):
Yep, Jim, water is always a pleasure. Keep up the
great work. I'll recommend and you can read all about this, folks,
BIPs Bipps dot org. It's the Bluegrass Institute's website right
there on the front page there's your information BIPs dot org.
Thanks again, Jim for spending time by listeners and me
real pleasure.

Speaker 2 (14:18):
Thanks for having us today. I appreciate it.

Speaker 1 (14:20):
Thank you anytime, my friend. Anytime stick around, folks, got
more to talk about. Bottom of the hour, we're gonna
hear about. Well, get out the vote, Donovan and Neil,
Americans for prosperity. First of a word, form my dear
friends at Plumb Type Plumbing, plumbing done right. It is
always plumbing done right. Can vouch for it. I've seen
them at work in my home. You've done work for
a lot of my friends and just listen. I just
recommend them to my mom the other day. She has

(14:42):
a plumbing project and she says, well, that's going to
call somebody that's closer to my set. Then I said, mom,
Plum Type Plumbing helping you in the entire area. They
go from north of Kentucky all the way up to Dayton.
Call them up. Would I recommend a bad company to
my mom? You know I wouldn't. A plus with a
better business feer. They're great at customer service. They live
by the motto plumbing done right, so they can do

(15:03):
my mom's project, sadly I can't. They can never sewing
you anything you do not need. They're great about letting
you know when they're going to be there. You get
a window when you schedule the appointment, and emergency services
are always welcome right there. Twenty four hour days, seven
day a week for emergencies. When your chandelier is raining
as mine was. Licensed plumbers doing the work and the
price is always right. You can call them five one

(15:25):
three seven two seven tight t I t E five
one three seven two seven eighty four eighty three. Visit
them online at plumtight dot com. This is fifty five
KRC an iHeartRadio station.

Brian Thomas News

Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

Stuff You Should Know
Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.

The Bobby Bones Show

The Bobby Bones Show

Listen to 'The Bobby Bones Show' by downloading the daily full replay.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.