This month, we're releasing two versions of an episode that we already released years ago! Why? Because we love this episode, and we thought it'd be a fun one to do on the road for our 20th anniversary shows last year. Turns out it was!

"Prelude to a Fish" is one of those episodes that just came together, from its original ridiculous idea ("what if The Little Mermaid but also Splash but also Creature from the Black Lagoon?") to the final touch, which was a riff on "Kiss the Girl" written by our friends Paul and Storm. Paul and Paget, of course, play it perfectly every time, and the WorkJuice Players who appear as animals are absolutely hilarious and have a blast out-sillying each other.

We first staged this episode at SF Sketchfest on Jan 25, 2014 and then again at Largo in LA during our regular monthly run on Feb 1, 2014.

This recording is from the "Our Favorite Episodes" show at the Bell House in Brooklyn on Sunday, Oct 26, 2025. Jordan Katz did some killer post-production work on what was a rough recording, and we are grateful to have him!

Beyond Belief, "Prelude to a Fish" (NY variant)

Written by Ben Acker & Ben Blacker

Starring Paul F. Tompkins and Paget Brewster as Frank and Sadie Doyle; Mark Gagliardi, Joshua Malina, Annie Savage, Janet Varney, Craig Cackowski, and John Hodgman as animals; Krysta Rodriguez as Pearl; Marc Evan Jackson as Edgar; and Hal Lublin as the Spooky Narrator.

THE THRILLING ADVENTURE HOUR IS 100% INDEPENDENT.

Want every episode and more, including never-released audio, ad free? Want exclusive videos, including rehearsal videos?

To support the show and the people who make it, and to gain access to our complete back catalogue including never-released episodes (from as far back as 2005!), early access to the podcast, early access to tickets to our live shows, and more, join our Patreon community: https://www.patreon.com/thrillingadventurehour

Visit our store forBeyond Belief concert film DVDs!

Visit our video vault to stream a ton of live and live-to-Zoom TAH shows!

Produced by Ben Acker & Ben Blacker

Music by Jonathan Dinerstein

"Oolee oolee oolee" by Paul and Storm

Podcast produced and engineered by Jordan Katz

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

.css-aamugw{display:none;float:left;margin-right:0.5rem;}@media only screen and (max-height: 149px){.css-aamugw{display:block;}}Beyond Belief "Paint Misbehavin’" •iHeart

.css-x5l0ng{color:#27292D;display:inline-block;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-x5l0ng svg{color:#27292D;display:block;fill:#27292D;}.css-x5l0ng:focus{outline:.5rem auto -webkit-focus-ring-color;outline:.5rem auto Highlight;}The Thrilling Adventure Hour

Beyond Belief "Paint Misbehavin’"

Beyond Belief "Paint Misbehavin’" •
iHeart

The Thrilling Adventure Hour