Songs
- Miracle MaxAll Puppet Players featuring Shaun Michael McNamara
- Henchmen For Hire (Reprise)All Puppet Players featuring Seth Tucker
- A Boo To YouAll Puppet Players
- Pit of DispairAll Puppet Players
- When You Were DeadAll Puppet Players featuring Haley McHardy
- Vizzini's SongAll Puppet Players
- Inigo's AnguishAll Puppet Players featuring Seth Tucker
- The Singing EelsAll Puppet Players featuring Jennie Rhiner, Shannon Phelps and Kiley Bishop
- I Wear The PantsAll Puppet Players featuring Robert Paul Brown and Jennie Rhiner
- As You WishAll Puppet Players featuring Haley McHardy and Zach Funk
- Henchmen For HireAll Puppet Players featuring Seth Tucker
- As You Wish (Reprise)All Puppet Players featuring Haley McHardy and Zach Funk