Songs
- Foolish to ThinkBryce Pinkham
- Stop! Wait! What?!Bryce Pinkham
- SibellaBryce Pinkham
- Poison in My PocketBryce Pinkham, Jefferson Mays, & Catherine Walker
- Tra La LaBryce Pinkham, Carly Hughes & '17 Again' Studio Cast
- It's Not Like In The MoviesBryce Pinkham;Kyle McArthur
- How Do You Do This Again? / You Don't Know What I Know (Reprise)Bryce Pinkham;Kate Baldwin
- Steppin' Out with My Baby / I'll Capture Your HeartBryce Pinkham, Corbin Bleu, Megan Sikora, & Holiday Inn Original Broadway Ensemble
- The Little Things in LifeBryce Pinkham
- It's a Lovely Day TodayBryce Pinkham, Megan Sikora, & Megan Lawrence
- Holiday Inn / Happy HolidayBryce Pinkham, Megan Lawrence, & Holiday Inn Original Broadway Ensemble
- Be Careful, It's My HeartBryce Pinkham, Lora Lee Gayer, & Corbin Bleu
- Let's Say It with FirecrackersBryce Pinkham, Corbin Bleu, Lora Lee Gayer, & Holiday Inn Original Broadway Ensemble
- Introduction / Washington Irving SongBryce Pinkham
- Entrance of the CouncilBryce Pinkham
- Ballad of the RobbersBryce Pinkham
- There's Nowhere to Go but Up! [Reprise]Bryce Pinkham
- Foolish to Think [Reprise]Bryce Pinkham
- Poison in My Pocket [Reprise]Bryce Pinkham
- It's Not Like In The MoviesBryce Pinkham;Kyle McArthur