Songs
- I've Grown Accustomed to Her FaceHarry Hadden-Paton
- A Hymn to HimHarry Hadden-Paton
- I'm an Ordinary ManHarry Hadden-Paton
- The 23rd IngredientHarry Hadden-Paton;Carmen Cusack;Tony Yazbeck;Robert Sella
- The Music Plays OnHarry Hadden-Paton;Laura Shoop
- WondrousHarry Hadden-Paton
- Bella Donna Di AgoniaHarry Hadden-Paton;Kanisha Marie Feliciano;Michele Ragusa
- Prologue (The Music Plays On)Harry Hadden-Paton;Laura Shoop
- Bella Donna Di Agonia [Reprise]Harry Hadden-Paton;Laura Shoop;Robert Sella;Emily Pynenburg