Songs
- Finale: At the End of the World - Reprise [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Alyssa Martyn, Ross McLaren, Johan Munir, Wade McCollum, and It Happened in Key West Cast
- Undying Love - Reprise [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Alyssa Martyn, and Wade McCollum
- If You've Never Felt This Way [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, and Wade McCollum
- Elena from Town [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, and It Happened in Key West Cast
- I Feel Loved [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, and Alyssa Martyn
- Everything's Right with the World [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, Alyssa Martyn, Sophia Lewis, Hannah McIver, Johan Munir, Miguel Angel, and It Happened in Key West Cast
- Undying Love [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, and Wade McCollum
- Black Wedding 3 [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, Alyssa Martyn, Guido Garcia Lueches, Miguel Angel, Ross McLaren, and It Happened in Key West Cast
- At the End of the World - Reprise [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Alyssa Martyn, Wade McCollum, and It Happened in Key West Cast
- Black Wedding 2 [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Guido Garcia Lueches, Miguel Angel, and Ross McLaren
- At the End of the World [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, and Alyssa Martyn
- Black Wedding [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Guido Garcia Lueches, Miguel Angel, and Ross McLaren
- Don't Worry About a Thing [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, Alyssa Martyn, Guido Garcia Lueches, Mary-Jean Caldwell, Alexander Barria, Sophia Lewis, and Hannah McIver
- What More Could I Wish For? [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, and Alyssa Martyn
- Elena [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, Alyssa Martyn, and Guido Garcia Lueches
- Prologue / Wrecked in the Keys [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Wade McCollum, and Alyssa Martyn
- Overture / Radio News [Live]Jill Santoriello, Jason Huza, Jeremiah James, Val Adams, Mary Jean Caldwell, Sophia Lewis, and Hannah McIver
- Finale (feat. James Barbour & Kelley Dorney)Jill Santoriello
- Defarge Goodbye (feat. Kevin Earley)Jill Santoriello
- The Letter (feat. James Barbour)Jill Santoriello
- Let Her Be a Child (feat. Catherine Missal & James Barbour)Jill Santoriello
- The Bluff (feat. James Barbour & Ed Dixon)Jill Santoriello
- Without a Word (feat. Brandi Burkhardt)Jill Santoriello
- If Dreams Came True (Reprise) [feat. James Barbour]Jill Santoriello
- Everything Stays the Same (feat. Natalie Toro & Kevin Earley)Jill Santoriello
- Until Tomorrow (feat. Kevin Earley & Natalie Toro)Jill Santoriello
- Out of Sight, out of Mind (feat. Natalie Toro)Jill Santoriello
- Now at Last (feat. Simon Thomas & Brandi Burkhardt)Jill Santoriello
- I Can't Recall (feat. James Barbour)Jill Santoriello
- The Promise (feat. J. Mark MC Vey & Simon Thomas)Jill Santoriello
- Letter from Uncle (feat. Alex Santoriello)Jill Santoriello
- Reflection (feat. James Barbour)Jill Santoriello
- No Honest Way (feat. Ed Dixon & Craig Bennett)Jill Santoriello
- The Way It Ought to Be (London) [feat. James Barbour]Jill Santoriello
- You'll Never Be Alone (feat. Brandi Burkhardt & J. Mark MC Vey)Jill Santoriello
- Who Are You (feat. J. Mark MC Vey & Brandi Burkhardt)Jill Santoriello
- Prologue (feat. J. Mark MC Vey)Jill Santoriello
- If Dreams Came True (feat. Simon Thomas & James Barbour)Jill Santoriello
- The Way It Ought to Be (Reprise) [feat. James Barbour]Jill Santoriello