Songs
- If You Were GayJohn Tartaglia;Rick Lyon
- Story Of My LifeJohn Tartaglia & Shrek Ensemble
- Everyone's a Little Bit RacistJohn Tartaglia;Stephanie D'Abruzzo;Natalie Venetia Belcon;Jordan Gelber;Ann HaradaE
- Freak FlagJohn Tartaglia & Shrek Ensemble
- What Do You Do with a B.A. in English / It Sucks to Be MeJordan Gelber;John Tartaglia;Stephanie D'Abruzzo;Rick Lyon;Ann Harada;Natalie Venetia Belcon;Jennifer BarnhartE
- Fantasies Come TrueJohn Tartaglia;Stephanie D'Abruzzo;Rick Lyon
- My Girlfriend, Who Lives in CanadaJohn Tartaglia
- There's a Fine, Fine Line (Reprise) / What Do You Do with a B.A. in English? (Reprise)Rick Lyon;John Tartaglia;Natalie Venetia Belcon;Stephanie D'Abruzzo;Ann Harada;Jordan Gelber;Jennifer BarnhartE
- PurposeJohn Tartaglia;Avenue Q Ensemble
- GoodnightJohn Tartaglia
- Collage: Like To Get To Know You/Give A DamnJohn Tartaglia
- AmericaJohn Tartaglia
- Abraham, Martin And JohnJohn Tartaglia
- Light My FireJohn Tartaglia
- I'm Gonna Make You Love MeJohn Tartaglia
- I Am The WalrusJohn Tartaglia
- Wichita LinemanJohn Tartaglia
- Poto FlavusJohn Tartaglia
- ManhattanJohn Tartaglia
- Mash-Up (Reprise Finale)John Tartaglia, Jennifer Barnhart, Frankie Cordero, Stephanie D'Abruzzo, Dorien Davies & Tyler Bunch
- A Day In The Life/I Am The Walrus [Medley]John Tartaglia
- Light My FireJohn Tartaglia