Songs
- Barbara 2.0Kerry Butler, Rob McClure
- What's Wrong With Me? (Reprise)Kerry Butler, Ashley Park
- Praise the Saviour, Ye Who Know Him [piano]Kerry Butler
- The Solid Rock [piano]Kerry Butler
- More Love to Thee, O Christ [piano]Kerry Butler
- At Calvary [piano]Kerry Butler
- DisneylandKerry Butler
- When She Loved MeKerry Butler
- The Bare NecessitiesKerry Butler
- Second Star to the RightKerry Butler
- Minnie's Yoo HooKerry Butler
- Baby MineKerry Butler
- It's a Small World / God Help the OutcastsKerry Butler
- Colors of the WindKerry Butler
- Call Me a PrincessKerry Butler
- I'll TryKerry Butler
- When You Wish Upon a StarKerry Butler
- This Only Happens in the MoviesKerry Butler
- Maddy's PieceKerry Butler
- The Saddest Girl in the WorldKerry Butler
- EnoughKerry Butler
- Fly, Fly AwayKerry Butler
- Suddenly SeymourKerry Butler
- Somewhere That's GreenKerry Butler
- Finale: I Am Not a BoyKerry Butler;Deven May
- Hold Me, Bat Boy (Reprise)Kerry Butler;Kathy Brier;Trent Armand Kendall;Doug Storm;Jim Price;Daria Hardeman;Richard Pruitt;Kaitlin Hopkins;Sean McCourt;Deven May
- Finale: I Imagine You're UpsetKerry Butler;Deven May
- Inside Your HeartKerry Butler;Deven May
- Whatcha Wanna Do?Kerry Butler;Deven May;Doug Storm
- Ugly BoyKerry Butler;Kaitlin Hopkins;Deven May