Songs
- Lily's EyesRobert Westenberg;Mandy Patinkin
- Scene: The Library at Misselthwaite ManorRobert Westenberg;Mandy Patinkin
- Scene: The Library / Scene: Mary's RoomRobert Westenberg;Daisy Eagan;Alison Fraser
- Hello, Little GirlRobert Westenberg;Danielle Ferland
- AgonyRobert Westenberg;Chuck Wagner
- Agony (Reprise)Robert Westenberg;Chuck Wagner
- Agony (Into the Woods)Robert Westenberg;Chuck Wagner