Daily Review with Clay and Buck - Sep 8 2025

ENOUGH!

A breakdown of one of the most disturbing crime stories in recent memory: the brutal murder of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska on a Charlotte light rail train. Buck Sexton, hosting solo while Clay Travis is off for the day, leads with this tragic incident, emphasizing its significance as a national story that mainstream media outlets have largely ignored.

The segment opens with commentary on President Donald Trump's remarks at the Museum of the Bible in Washington, D.C., where he addressed the Charlotte stabbing and broader issues of violent crime in Democrat-run cities. Buck highlights the systemic failures that allowed the alleged killer, Decarlos Brown Jr. —a career criminal with 13 prior arrests—to remain free despite repeated offenses, including assaults on women. The show critiques progressive criminal justice policies, particularly no-cash bail and leniency toward repeat offenders, arguing that these policies directly contribute to rising urban crime rates.

Manufacturing Delusion

Buck previews his upcoming book, Manufacturing Delusion: How the Left Uses Brainwashing, Indoctrination, and Propaganda Against You, which explores how totalitarian regimes and modern leftist movements alike manipulate legal systems and public perception to consolidate power. This sets the stage for a detailed critique of the recent appeals court decision upholding the $83 million defamation judgment against President Donald Trump in the E. Jean Carroll case. Buck argues that the ruling is not only excessive but emblematic of a broader effort to weaponize the legal system against political opponents. He underscores how New York’s temporary extension of the statute of limitations enabled the lawsuit, calling it a targeted and unethical maneuver designed to punish Trump retroactively.

The hour also highlights a significant legal victory for the Trump administration, as the Supreme Court lifts a lower court’s restraining order that had blocked federal immigration enforcement operations in Los Angeles. Buck credits Trump’s judicial appointments for preserving constitutional sanity and preventing the judiciary from becoming a tool of the anti-Trump resistance. This decision, he argues, reinforces the importance of conservative control over the courts, especially in the face of ongoing efforts to undermine immigration enforcement and national sovereignty.

We've Noticed

 the failure of progressive criminal justice policies and the media’s selective outrage. Buck Sexton opens the hour by revisiting the brutal murder of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska, emphasizing the media blackout surrounding the case despite its viral spread on social media. He argues that the mainstream media, including outlets like The New York Times and The Washington Post, deliberately ignore stories that don’t align with their ideological narrative—particularly when the racial dynamics of a crime don’t fit the preferred script. Sexton contrasts this with the wall-to-wall coverage of cases like George Floyd, Trayvon Martin, and Jussie Smollett, asserting that the media only amplifies stories that can be framed as examples of systemic racism or white-on-black violence.

The hour expands to include another tragic case: the stabbing death of Dr. Julie Gard Schnuelle, a former Auburn University veterinary professor, who was murdered while walking her dog in Alabama. Sexton draws a direct line between these two cases—both involving white female victims and black male suspects with extensive criminal histories—and the broader failures of the justice system. He argues that these are not isolated incidents but symptoms of a systemic refusal to incarcerate dangerous repeat offenders due to ideological commitments to social justice, racial equity, and decarceration. Sexton calls for a national reckoning on crime, demanding that public safety take precedence over political correctness.

President Trump’s recent remarks are also featured prominently in this hour. Trump condemns cashless bail policies and vows to take federal action to restore law and order in cities like Chicago. Sexton praises Trump’s tough-on-crime stance and frames it as a necessary corrective to the chaos unleashed by progressive prosecutors and Democrat-run cities. 

Heather Mac Donald 

Heather Mac Donald, author of The War on Cops and When Race Trumps Merit, reinforces Sexton’s arguments with data and analysis. Mac Donald cites a 2023 study from the National Academy of Sciences showing that black-on-white violence is far more common than the reverse, yet receives far less media attention. She criticizes the criminal justice system for prioritizing the rights of offenders over the safety of law-abiding citizens and calls for the construction of more j