All Episodes

November 19, 2024 41 mins

Colin is joined by former Alabama QB and ESPN college football analyst Greg McIlory to break down the playoff rankings and preview the playoff!

They start by discussing how much of a “cold weather” advantage Big Ten teams will have when hosting SEC teams from a warmer climate (3:00). They debate whether Georgia’s mediocre O-line could sink them in the playoffs when faced with a team with a strong defensive front like Penn State (5:00) and explain why fans shouldn’t judge Oregon for their narrow escape over Wisconsin (8:15)

They discuss why Alabama has been overlooked due to living in the shadow of Nick Saban (13:00) and whether Texas is the best “eye test” team in the country (22:30). They parse what to make of Colorado and whether they deserve to make the playoff (28:00) and debate what Ohio State’s true identity is besides “talented” (31:00)

Finally, they try to diagnose what is “off” about LSU (44:30) and end with who could be the surprise team in the playoff and why a Lane Kiffin vs Steve Sarkisian matchup in the national championship isn’t out of the question (59:30).

Follow Colin and The Volume on Twitter for the latest content and updates! 

#Volume #Herd

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:01):
The volume.

Speaker 2 (00:04):
College football reactions presented by j Jaylab has the best
audio products in the game. They're ready to take care
of you this football season, traveling to watch your favorite
team or just streaming the game at home. Find the
Blue Box at Walmart, Target, Best Buy, or go to
JLab dot com. Love their stuff the Blue Box. Here's

(00:27):
the Alabama quarterback that won a Natty in twenty ten
with a Crimson Tide. He's the host of OLA's College Football,
Greg McElroy, who we bring on two or three times
a year. The latest college football rankings have come out
BYU is gone. I don't have a problem with it,
I think, and I'm assuming most of you who've listened
to my show know what the college football rankings were.

(00:48):
Oregon one, Ohio State two, Texas three, Penn State four.
Not sure I buy Penn State, Indiana five, Notre Dame six, Bama,
who I think is better than advertised at seven, Miami eight.
Don't know if I buy him, Ole Miss nine, Georgia ten,
and Tennessee who I had winning the Natty eleven, and
Boise State twelve. So here's let me just throw this
out there. For years and years I heard Greg big

(01:08):
Ten fans always state, why don't we have to go
south to play our bowl games? So what's interesting is
Georgia would have to go to Penn State, it's pickham Ole,
Miss would have to go to Indiana, and Alabama would
have to go to Notre Dame. I do think that's
an advantage for cold weather teams over warm weather teams.

Speaker 1 (01:28):
Do you, absolutely that's a huge deal, especially looking at
the I mean, what did Wisconsin just do this past week?
I mean, and I know that right now it's not
frigid temperatures in Madison, but they just got rid of
their air raid style offensive coordinator because it's hard to
throw and to be a pass happy offense in November

(01:50):
in the Big Ten, well raise it by at least
I don't know, three or four times the intensity in
the playoff setting in December. I mean, look, I've lived
in Cincinnati in New Jersey in my time in the NFL.
The day I left Cincinnati, it was minus thirty two
degrees wind chill, and I thought to myself, I'm never
coming back.

Speaker 3 (02:10):
If I have to retire, I will.

Speaker 1 (02:11):
I cannot play in this We don't even have an
indoor facility at the Bengals, I cannot do it anymore. Yeah, so,
long story short, I think you go to Columbus, you
go to Penn State. Depending on the day, it could
be a three to five point advantage in favor of
the home team.

Speaker 2 (02:26):
Yeah, no, I agree with that. It's interesting. I think
Georgia is better than Penn State, but I do think
Penn State matches up well with Georgia because Penn State's
defensive intensity upfront and George's very inconsistent on line. If
this game was in Georgia, I wouldn't be surprised if
they won by twenty. But I think it's a weird

(02:47):
matchup for Georgia, a team I really like. But you
know this, in the NFL, the two things. There's a
couple of things that guarantee consistency in the NFL. Beyond
a great quarter a good defense keeps you in every game,
and a great old line even on games you don't
play well, keepshin games like the Detroit Lions. It's hard

(03:09):
to play bad when you literally have four Pro bowlers,
three Pro bowlers up front. It just you know what
I mean. And so when you look at Georgia, I
love Georgia, but their O line worries me and I
think they're in consistency. All boils down to their front.
Do you think they could win a national championship with it?

(03:30):
I don't think you can win a World Series with
a bad bullpen or or a Super Bowl or a
Natty with a bad offensive line. Can Georgia win a Natty?

Speaker 3 (03:39):
Yes they can.

Speaker 1 (03:40):
And while I am totally on board with you, based
on what we saw against ole Miss, I did that
game calling and it was it wasn't pretty.

Speaker 3 (03:48):
I mean, they're you know, I.

Speaker 1 (03:50):
Will say this about ole Miss is a defensive line
like in a gotta have it situation, when those guys
know it's a contract game, all right, Like buckle up. Yeah,
there's a bunch of guys that are going to be
a handful, not just at this level, but at the
next level as well. With all due respect to Penn State,
do I think they can cause problems for George's offensive line?

Speaker 3 (04:08):
Yes?

Speaker 1 (04:09):
Did I think they were going to cause problems to
Ohio State's offensive line?

Speaker 3 (04:14):
Yes? Did they know?

Speaker 1 (04:16):
And my biggest problem with Penn State has long been
in the biggest game of the year, they scored six
offensive points and you can tell me about goal line stands.
All right, cool, you had a goal line stand, I'll
raise you. Will Howard fumbling it over the pylon for
a touch back. So and if not for the pick six,
I mean, who knows? And to me, I just I

(04:38):
just don't trust them. I don't think they have receivers
that can separate. I think their tight end is an
absolute machine and is pound for pound. If maya a
Heisman ballot, I think you do too. He's in consideration
for a Heisman Trophy ballot. Top three.

Speaker 2 (04:55):
Yes, for seventeen catches against USC, the.

Speaker 1 (05:00):
Guy would be a top The guy would be a
top ten running back in the Big Ten. I mean,
he's just that versatile, He's just that good. He's the
closest thing in college football this year to Brock Bowers.
So I love him. But I don't know about their
ability to stretch the field. And against teams like Georgia,
against teams that are at the highest levels of the sport,
you have to create chunk yardage. You can't just have thirteen, fourteen,

(05:23):
fifteen play drives. It's just not gonna happen. How did
Oregon beat Ohio State? They cut the head off the
snake by hitting forty yard throws down field. And I
don't think Penn State has that capability, or at least
I haven't seen anything to make me believe they have
it at this point of the season.

Speaker 2 (05:37):
So I think Oregon, being a West Coast guy, West
coast travels pretty easy. I mean, Washington to Arizona State's
considered a long roady, but you always played it.

Speaker 1 (05:50):
That's been a house of horrors for Washington for a
long time.

Speaker 2 (05:53):
But Oregon these schools. You know, USC goes to Maryland,
that's like four road trips in one. It really is.
So Oregon this weekend goes to Madison. Well, how many
conference games in a row of they played? I thought
Oregon looked eight. I think I thought Oregon looked exhausted.

(06:14):
And so there's there's a game every year where I'm like,
remember years ago in Ohio State got beat by Purdue
by like thirty, and You're like, the hell is that?
I feel like, just take this game out, Just take
it out, because I think Oregon and ASIN would beat
him by twenty six neutral feel would beat him by sixteen.
I still think Oregon's speed is I think Oregon can

(06:39):
win a Natty. I don't know if they could beat
Texas player for player, But I didn't take anything negative
out of the Wisconsin game. I'm like, Oregon's played eight
straight conference games, they're college kids. They look tired.

Speaker 1 (06:52):
Well, first of all, I could not agree with you more.

Speaker 3 (06:56):
You're a football guy, Colin. Yeah, Like you're a foot like.

Speaker 1 (06:58):
You know, you followed the game for a really long
time and you have covered it as well, if not
better than anybody in my generation of sports media. You
are a football guy through and through. You know the
dynamics of having to play two straight months against quality competition,

(07:19):
or the dynamics of having to travel out on a
Thursday for a Saturday night game because you're three time
zones away. Like, that's a very difficult thing that teams
have to deal with. Oregon played their C game at
best offensively, I mean, they did not play well whatsoever.
Dylan Gabriel threw an uncharacteristic interception on a throw that

(07:40):
he's made ninety nine times out of one hundred, and
the one that he doesn't make it's because the receiver
drops it. He misses the throw inside it's intercepted. They
couldn't really stretch the field and that's really what their
offense has decided to do is to create big plays.
I thought Wisconsin was very disciplined and kind of kept
it in front of him and didn't and they kind

(08:00):
of forced Oregon to play a game that they're not
Super Bowl super comfortable playing. But you know what that
taught me this past weekend, Colin, was that Oregon is adaptable.
They're not one of the Oregon of Chip Kelly was, Hey,
we got out tempo yet, and we're going to have
better defensive players than you realize. But we want to
win games thirty five to twenty eight this Oregon. If

(08:22):
you want to make it a track meet like it
was at times against Ohio State, cool, We'll win the
game in the thirties, maybe if the forties that's what's necessary,
that's what we'll do. But we can also win a
game in the teams. And I think that this has
shown the evolution of Dan Lanning and the evolution of
the program. Whereat the offense doesn't have their best stuff,
Hey guys, guess what on defense, Let's raise this. Let's
raise the stakes a little bit, get a little more aggressive,

(08:43):
and see if we can't dictate our terms and win
the game with our side of the football. So I
came away more impressed with Oregon, even in a lackluster
performance offensively.

Speaker 2 (08:56):
So Greg McElroy is many of you know as a friend.
Is he and Joel Platter people I really like to
talk college football with. They're so prepared, and they both
played the quarterback position. Alabama's fascinating first of all. Jalen Milroll,
I don't know, and I do this for a living.
I don't know what to make of him as a

(09:16):
pro prospect. I really like him as a college quarterback.
I think he throws a beautiful deep ball. He's got
really like a Russell Wilson deep ball touch. It's a
beautiful ball, incredibly catchable. And I think Kaylen de Boor,
I think we forget that. Kaylen de Boor is a
great coach and took over a great program. But you're

(09:37):
instituting your own culture. And I think Nick was more
of a little bit more of a screamer, a volume
coach like Loud. That's not Kaylan. He's more of a
teacher and a mentor. So there's an adjustment for the
players in Alabama. It's a new way. So they've had
a couple of really bad halves, really bad halves, and

(09:59):
I'm like, Okay, but I don't care if you're taking
If I'm taking over Nike, it's a great company. I'm
trying to change the culture in institute my worldview. So
I think Alabama now is actually underrated. I think it's
gonna I think by the end of this season, you're
gonna look at them and go, God, they're really good.
They have an NFL first second round quarterback, they have
an excellent coach. But so I'm defending Alabama. My take

(10:23):
is they get cherry picked a little more than most
teams because they lose Nick and they're gonna lose some
guys in the portal, and people cherry pick them. It's
very hard to follow Nick Caleb is Kaylen's learning as
he goes. Alabama's not Washington, Okay, al The culture's different,

(10:44):
the demands are different, the intensity, the media. It's a
relentless job. Washington's not. They got the Seahawks right down
the road. If you lose, people forget very quickly. I
think he's done a great job. I think Alabama now
is underrated. You know the program better than anybody. Am
I overstating what they can do. I think they can
win a Natty. In fact, I would take them over

(11:06):
I would over Georgia. But I don't think that's I
don't think that's the view of most experts.

Speaker 1 (11:15):
I think that they've been a bit of a punching
bag this year, understandably because we chase false gods in sports,
you know, like, do you realize that I don't know.
I mean you you cover the NBA. Did Michael Jordan
ever miss a game winning shot? Absolutely not, because I

(11:36):
check YouTube highlights and I don't see a lot of
misses on there. Like we chase false gods, and I
feel like, even though we're just one year removed, people
will look at Nick Saban's tenure and they're going to
sit there and think, oh, well, he never played close
against teams after a law after a big win. Oh well,
he never had a two point win against South Carolina,

(11:59):
who at the time was like a five hundred football team.
Oh well, well he never did this, And the realities,
it's not true. Nick Saban after a win or after
a loss, excuse me, was like eight and fourteen against
the spread in the last five years. You know, It's
like it's like nobody ere in the last ten years
or something. It was like some absurd number. I mean,
it's it's ridiculous. It's not accurate. The people don't want

(12:21):
to remember that because they just remember the dominance and
the greatness for so long. And that's not disparging Nick
at all. I think he's the greatest coach in the
history of college football. It's just people don't realize that
he also had teams that had flaws and that had
growing experiences, and I think this team has had that.

(12:41):
And the unfortunate thing about this team is his team
is going to go or at least it has up
to this point. How their quarterback goes to be. This
quarterback dependent is a challenge. Your best offensive weapon outside
of Jalen milro is a true freshman who is an
undersized wide receiver. It has freak show qualities, but he's

(13:02):
not you know, he's not Megatron. There's going to be
some defensive backs that he has a tough matchup against,
and there's going to be some that he torches. But
he's young. Your running game is really good, and your
offensive line is developing into a star. That is what
I think is most encouraging about where Alabama's going on
their trajectory. And they're very young on defense with a

(13:22):
new system, and they've played a little better and better
down the stretch too. So I think you're buying low
on Alabama if you buy him now, can they win
the Natty? I think it's all matchup driven. That's what
I think is cool about where we're going is it's
very matchup driven. But I do think they can do
it if the you know, if things bounce their way
in they play their a game down the stretch.

Speaker 2 (13:43):
The NFL season's rolling along. The contenders are separating from
the pack. The one thing that hasn't changed this season
is Draft King sports book and official sports book partner
of the NFL. Are friends at the volume. It's the
number one place to bet touchdowns. Fade at the corner
of the end zone, running back breaks through line, gallop
sixty yards for a touchdown. They don't care how you

(14:03):
get them. They want to bet on touchdowns and you
should at DraftKings the best place to do it. If
you're ready to place your first bet. Make it simple.
A player scoring a touchdown, just go to DraftKings Sportsbook.
App takes ninety seconds. Download it. Make your pick. Here's
a reason new customers do a touchdown. Dance on your
own bet five bucks, that's it, and get one hundred
and fifty bucks in bonus bets if your bet wins.

(14:26):
Score big. DraftKings Sportsbook number one place to bet touchdowns.
Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app and use the code colin
cli in gott to use the code coli in get
one hundred and fifty bucks in bonus bets if your
bet wins betting just five bucks only on DraftKings. The
Crown is yours.

Speaker 4 (14:45):
Gambling problem called one eight one hundred gambler in New
York call eight seven seven eight hope and why, or
text hope and why four six seven three six nine.
In Connecticut, help is available for problem gambling called eight
eight eight seven eight nine seven seven seven seven or
visit CCPG dot org. Please play responsibly on behalf of
Boothill Casino in Resorting, Kansas twenty one and over. Agent
eligibility varies by jurisdiction Voyd and Ontario. Bet must win

(15:08):
to receive reward. Bonus bets expire one hundred and sixty
eight hours after issue ins four. Additional terms and responsible
gaming resources see DKNG, dot co slash ft ball.

Speaker 2 (15:23):
So Texas is number three. I actually have made the
argument that getting pushed around and humiliated at home against
Georgia is the greatest way to lose if they had
a lost to Georgia on a bad call or a
fluky fumble. Texas is usc. It's a glamour program that
gets arrogant very quickly because it's in a great college

(15:45):
town with lots of options, beautiful people, music, and food.
It's cool. Most college towns aren't cool. It's like when
I worked at ESPN.

Speaker 3 (15:55):
Come on, there's a lot of cool college towns. I
got to push back there a little bit.

Speaker 2 (15:59):
Right now, Oh, I think Austin and La are in
Miami Corala.

Speaker 3 (16:03):
They're very cool.

Speaker 2 (16:05):
Fair enough, so I learned years ago when I worked
at ESBN. It's a sports factory, and it's easy to
be a sports factory because there's nothing to f and
do in Connecticut. You go to Fox a Fox, You're
not going to stay there for an extra hour and
a half. You got a cute girlfriend. You go to
Santa Monica. You'll have you know, you'll have a margarita.

(16:26):
And so I think Texas and USC get very confident,
very quick. It's a bigger city media, it's a more
national market like Austin's a cool market. So I think
getting pushed around by Georgia was perfect. It keeps them humble,
and now they've kind of slid under the radar because
a lot of people sold their stock. I still think,

(16:47):
I test Texas is the best team when I watch
them size speed. Georgia looks like some of Nick Saban's
National championship teams. Right or wrong.

Speaker 1 (16:59):
I love Texas's ceiling. Why haven't they scratched it? That's
my problem because I think if you want to bottle
up their best performances, and at this point, maybe the
Michigan game was it.

Speaker 3 (17:13):
Maybe that was the best performance.

Speaker 1 (17:14):
Maybe they broke Michigan and had that game not gone
that way, maybe Michigan be a different team. But here's
my problem with them.

Speaker 3 (17:22):
Call it.

Speaker 1 (17:23):
I watched them, and I'm talking more specifically to their offense.
I like their defense a lot. I think their defense
is really good, and I think their offense looked great
against Florida. Why don't I get that version of Texas
on offense every week? I mean, you have really no excuse.
You have a veteran offensive line, you have a veteran quarterback.

(17:43):
You got really talented and deep group of wide receivers
and weapons. Your tight end is very difficult to cover
in a matchup problem. You have a run game that
can get complex in a hurry, and an RPO and
a system that can make it very difficult on the
posing defenses. Why is it that we're playing sideline to
sideline so much? Like why don't we take the top
off the defense? Why don't we throw it downfield? I

(18:03):
just I think Texas's offense is looking a lot like
NFL offenses right now, where I just get so tired
of the dink and dunk, catch and run, Like take
throw it down field, like you have Josh Allen and
Patrick Mahomes. Throw it forty yards down field, and let's

(18:24):
see what we got like this whole you know, sideline
to sideline, five yards down the field, catch, run, high
percentage efficient, stay ahead of the change. We're gonna play analytics.
You got four downs to get it in plus territory.
Like to me, that's great, it works, it wins, but
it's boring, like take some shots, and I just think
Texas has yet to do that with great conviction. I

(18:45):
think it's in there, it just hasn't happened yet, and
I'm hoping that we see it before the season runs out,
because I gotta be honest with you, callin like, I
think Texas is in a position right now where they're
number three in the country according to the College of
Ball Playoff Committee, but if you really look at their resume,
they haven't really earned that spot. That's almost exclusively on
EE tests. And if they were to win against Kentucky

(19:07):
this week, which is expected, they're a three touchdown favorite,
and then lose to A and M next week, their
best win might very well be a six and six
Vanderbilt team, and that's not going to be enough to
unseat an Ole Miss or a Tennessee or another team
in the SEC that's ten and two with a much
stronger resume. So I think Texas needs to play well

(19:28):
down the stretch because I think next week becomes a
playoff game if they don't play well and if they lose.

Speaker 2 (19:33):
Having played the quarterback position, I've said this, I think
Shdur Sanders is the best quarterback I've seen. I think
he's athletic, but he really prefers sitting in the pocket.
I think sometimes he holds the ball a little long,
but he throws off platform. He can throw moving left, right,
moving up in the pocket, back rolling. I think he
throws a really pretty catchable, accurate football. He can be hurried,

(19:54):
he can be frenetic, and he's still accurate. Cam Ward
is a lot of backyard football stuff that I don't
think translates to the NFL very well. He'll make a team,
somebody will roll the dice on him, and if he
gets a good old line in playmakers, he'll have some success.
I don't think it feels as sustainable, though Cam's talented
as Shahduur Sanders.

Speaker 3 (20:12):
Yeah, you know.

Speaker 2 (20:15):
The Cowboys, you know the NFL. Michael Irvin told me
today Colorado football.

Speaker 3 (20:21):
We know this.

Speaker 2 (20:22):
I mean, it's the republic. What do they call it.
There's a joke conservatives called Boulder the Republic of Boulder
or something. It's a quirky town, very left leaning. It's
a good time.

Speaker 3 (20:36):
You know.

Speaker 2 (20:37):
It's not a it's not a legitimate, well healed, strongly
capitalized college football program. Dion has made it really fun
and deserves all the credit. I think. I think Dion
would take the cowboy job, and shaduor Sanders, I think
he's going to be a really good pro. When you
watched Colorado, I would love to see them get in

(20:58):
because I think they have arguable the two best college
football players. What do you make of Colorado? I didn't
buy them at all early in the season, and now
I watch them and I'm like, Warren SAPs done a
pretty good job. They're pretty stout up front. I kind
of buy them because I just think if you have
the best college quarterback, it's probably worth two touchdowns in

(21:19):
college football probably.

Speaker 1 (21:25):
I think that Shador is probably the best pro prospect
right now. I agree with you on the shot clock
in the pocket and the pocket mobility stuff and the
awareness of the rush is something that I am concerned about, yeah,
as it translates to the next level. I just having
been back there and been in an NFL pocket, like

(21:48):
there are very few clean pockets now. It's a lot
cleaner now because of the RPO and some of the
stuff that you know, you just can do a lot
of different things, and one you can't hit quarterbacks, so
that's beneficial as well. But I look at Colorado right
now and they have thirty three sacks. That's made them different.
They're in the top half of the country in rush defense,

(22:09):
which is a huge difference from a year ago. They
always had wide outs, The offensive line has been fine,
but they really at the same time, have they played
a defense that's anywhere near the caliber of what they
would see when they get in the college football playoffs.

Speaker 3 (22:25):
And I think the answer to that is no. And
I think they would struggle.

Speaker 1 (22:30):
And you make it a perimeter game, make it a
catch and run game, and their weapons against your weapons,
and let's see what happens and Travis Hunter has two
picks and locks down one side of the field and
you know, and goes off for a buck sixty in
the air. Could that happen? Absolutely, But ultimately I don't
think it would end very well given the sheer quantity

(22:51):
of NFL level defensive players that every playoff team at
the top of the league's will be able to trot
out onto the field. So I would love it. I've
been shamelessly rooting for them one because every former player
thinks they could coach, you know, just not many of

(23:14):
us get that opportunity. So to see Dion make the
most of this opportunity gives all of us hope that
maybe we could do it too. That's for That's one
and two. I think it's just been cool to see
that it doesn't have to be done a certain way.
There's this expectation that this tried and true way, this
is how you build a program, this is how you
do it, and it's not necessarily always going to be

(23:36):
the same. It depends on the place, it depends on
the coach, depends on the personality. And it's been refreshing
to see somebody that's done it a little different and
that has not made a lot of friends along the way.
Like he's kind of, you know, gone anti establishment and
say this is how we do it, and so be
it if you don't like it, and that to me
is refreshing. So I'm happy for him, and I hope

(23:57):
they went out. I'm not gonna apologize in saying that
I hope we see him in the playoff.

Speaker 2 (24:01):
So I made the argument the other day, I don't
I thought the win over Penn State. Penn State had
opportunities to win that game. And I'm not saying Penn
State's not worthy of the playoff, but if Indiana beat
Ohio State and Oregon beat Ohio State, in my opinion,
the two best teams they've played, because if Indiana beats
Ohio State, they're for real now they're a thirteen point

(24:22):
Underdine probably won't, but I made the argument is if
Ohio State lost to Oregon in Indiana, man, I that
doesn't I mean that you're certainly not getting a home
game from me in the playoff. What do you make
of Ohio State? I call them the whack a mole team.
Every time I'm watching it, something else pops up that

(24:43):
worries me. Ye first it was their defense Oregon. Then
it was their offense Penn State, or it was their
offense against Nebraska, and then it was their quarterback play
Will Howard against Penn State. And I'm like, something's off.
There's just something. And by the way, I felt this
for the last two to three years against Michigan, where
Michigan had an absolute identity Nick Saban's team's identity. What

(25:11):
is Ohio State in your eyes? Beyond talented?

Speaker 1 (25:17):
I think they're I ain't. They're a team that wants
to be rugged, but they still have a bun, you
know what I mean, Like they want to be rugged,
but they still have a lot of sports cars. It's like,
you know, they they they have a dirt road that
you have to run in the Big ten to win
a championship, and they can't decide if they want to

(25:37):
take their you know, Ford F one fifty or their
GMC Sierra, or if they just want to say forget it, well,
who cares if we if we blow an axle, Like,
let's drive the Ferrari and see what happens. I think
that there is a bit of an identity. Do they
want to be a running team? They want to utilize
quarterback run? Do they want to do they want to

(25:59):
be a passing team? Are they a team that wants
to work off play action? Like I think they can
do all those things. I think they do everything well,
but they don't do anything elite, and that to me
is a little bit jaw dropping given their personnel. Like
I think they have a good defensive line, I don't
think they have an elite defensive line. Like I think
they have good run stopping defensive ends, but I don't

(26:22):
think they have defensive vends that scare me to death.
And I can put my tackles on one on one
against them in an obvious passing situation. I think they
have really athletic linebackers, and I think those guys are
actually an upgrade from what they've had in the past.
But I also think they can sometimes over pursue and
Oregon hit them with some misdirections to my violation stuff.
I hate they have really good corners, but I also
don't know if those corners have seen elite elite level

(26:46):
wide receivers outside of that game against Oregon. And guess what,
every team they play in the playoff will likely have
elite level wide receivers. So it's a roundabout way of
saying I think Ohio State has a crazy high ceiling
and if they ever put it all together, it'd be
a special thing for all of us to watch. But

(27:08):
it's Week eleven. Yeah, what are we waiting for? And
I hope badly it happens this week and not because
of Indiana or anything. I just want to see it.
You don't accumulate that many pros on one roster and
not just want something more. It feels a little bit
like the twenty fifteen team, you know what I mean.
Like when they were in twenty fifteen, they had the
best roster, but they didn't have the best team. And

(27:31):
I don't know why that was.

Speaker 2 (27:33):
I made this argument. I think to Urban Meyer a
year ago, I said, they're receiving recruiting has been so good.
Brian Hartline, I mean, it's just all five star guys
that even at practice, it's art, it's beautiful, and it's
hard not to be seduced as a head coach when

(27:53):
you're looking at these incredible first round wide receivers and
you have good backs, not pedestrian, they're good backs. You
have world class receivers. And I think at practice, I
think in game in film rooms, it's literally like putting
ice cream in front of an eight year old. It's
like I'm going to eat it, even if I know

(28:14):
it's not good for me. And I think, what's happened.
They're receiving. Recruiting is so good that it's seductive, and
they sometimes whenever they have a bad drive, we're throwing
the ball, We're going to the perimeter, and it's like
this happens now. Saban his recruiting on the perimeter was
great as well. But the culture of Alabama was really

(28:36):
about physicality, and when I thought Michigan separated from Ohio State.
It wasn't better players until the very last team. It
was a better identity and understanding of what they were. Hell,
they beat Penn State. They didn't throw a pass in
the second half on the road. So I think this
may not make sense, but you know a little. You
know some of this in the NFL. If your best

(28:58):
athletes are on the perimeter, it's seductive. You're going to
be a morphinesse football team Cincinnati between losing Joe Mixon,
Higgins and Chase. Of course, you're gonna throw the ball.
It's just it's too appealing not to. And I feel
like with Ohio State, I don't know if they need
an eight minute drive to kill the clock. Is it

(29:20):
in them running the ball and eating up clock? Is
it in them? I don't know if it is.

Speaker 3 (29:27):
Yeah, I think that's perfectly fair.

Speaker 1 (29:28):
And they're also sometimes when I watch Ohio State and
I felt like this a little bit like when I
watched the Lincoln Riley led Oklahoma teams.

Speaker 3 (29:37):
And this is not comparing Ryan Dade and Lincoln Riley,
this is.

Speaker 1 (29:40):
Not I just feel like they look at a six
yard gain like it's a failure. You know what, I mean,
like sometimes when I watch them, it's like, oh, handoff
to Judkins up the middle, gain of five at second
and five, it's like guys are walking back to the
you know, their heads are hung.

Speaker 3 (29:56):
It's like that was a great play.

Speaker 1 (29:58):
I mean, I just think there is such pressure to
not just perform at a high level, but to have
a highly intoxicated offense that goes up and down the field.
But also when you have an offense that can score fifty,
you're hanging your defense out to dry.

Speaker 3 (30:15):
So then if you.

Speaker 1 (30:16):
Want to lean into your offense, now everyone's gonna call
you soft because that's that's what people have been saying
for the last two years. That's why you lost to
Michigan because you're quote soft. That's not true. We aren't soft.
And just Michigan was the better team on that day.

Speaker 2 (30:30):
And Michigan last year had better personnel. They were stacked.

Speaker 1 (30:33):
It wasn't close. They were they were significantly more talented,
and look at the.

Speaker 2 (30:37):
Draft they that, yeah, there's still more Michigan guys exactly.

Speaker 3 (30:42):
So I just think that I think that I think
Ohio State needs to just stay the course. Man.

Speaker 1 (30:50):
They they're really talented. Don't try to be Michigan that
has a good quarter. Don't try to be Michigan. Don't
try to be penst It.

Speaker 3 (30:58):
Just don't.

Speaker 1 (30:59):
Don't try to be twenty fifteen Ohio State. Just be you,
and you, the you that you are right now is
plenty good enough to go win a national championship. But
I think it's going to require improved offensive line play,
which we've seen it's been better the last few weeks.
I think it's going to require slightly more aggressive defensive

(31:20):
philosophy with pressures and being able to ramp things up
a little bit. And I think it's going to require
them being a little bit more willing to roll the
dice on the perimeter some of their coverages.

Speaker 3 (31:34):
I think.

Speaker 1 (31:34):
Don't think you can play quarters all the time beat
high level teams. I don't think you can play press
man all the time beat high level teams. I just
think it's gonna be interesting to watch them. I think
there's plenty of talent in there. I just I think
you're right. I think it comes down to identity and
how they want to play into it.

Speaker 2 (31:49):
Are you struggling to find the right candidates, Well, good news,
there's a place to go to get help. It's called
zip recruiter doesn't work for you fast and easy right now,
this second. You can try it for free. All you
do is go to ZipRecruiter dot com slash colin. It's
the hiring site that employers trust the most, according to
G two. So how quickly does zip recruiter work instantly?

(32:09):
They have a powerful matching technology helps you find the
top talent fast saves your time and money. Four out
of five employers who post on zip recruiter listen to this.
Four to five get a quality candidate within the first day.
So see for yourself. All you have to do do
it for free ZipRecruiter dot com, slash colin right now,
free I mean free. That's the same price as a
perfect sunset. Try it free exclusive web address, ZipRecruiter dot com,

(32:33):
slash colin, c O L I N zip recruiter. The
smartest way to hire.

Speaker 3 (32:40):
Really is.

Speaker 2 (32:45):
Finally Brian Kelly, So, I do think it's harder to
create cultures in the transfer portal and il era. You're
walking on eggshells, you know. If a guy I mean,
if you have three receivers and ones not getting reps,
I mean, you can coach as hard as you used to,
and I thought Brian was over the top with his
sideline annex. But you know this college football. I've heard

(33:06):
that more than once. He's not the only coach to
ever do that. But with USC, there's limitations a their offenses.
All kids outside of Woody Marks in the center, they're
all coming back, really really young team, And I get
the exact same USC team every Saturday. They lead in
the fourth, but they can't extend drives because the O
line is a year away, and they just can't put

(33:28):
teams away. But I feel like I get the exact
same team every game, even the Maryland lost the Nebraska win,
It's the same team. With LSU, it's all over the map.
But I also feel that Brian Kelly's personality is all
over the map. It's the Southern twang, it's screaming, it's fun.
He's a combustible, emotional guy, and I feel like it's

(33:50):
feeding into LSU. I thought it would work. I thought
it was a perfect fit. Something is off. What is it?

Speaker 3 (34:02):
Well? I think I think it's it's all fair well one.

Speaker 1 (34:08):
I still think it's gonna work. I just know that
program too well. Calling It's like you just can't screw
it up. It's just there's too many guys. Now you
don't have the built in advantage of pre nil that
you once had because guys are now willing to listen
to overtures from other places. So there there was a

(34:30):
time where like every coach in the country is trying
to get the Monroe Louisiana because they had the best
offensive line of defensive line talent in the world, like
per capita, like you get, like, look at the NFL
guys from Monroe Louisiana.

Speaker 3 (34:42):
I mean, it's just ridiculous.

Speaker 1 (34:45):
So they had a little bit of a stranglehold on
that part of the country and and now that you know,
the lid is off. But what I would say about
Brian Kelly is that they are relying on personnel on
the defensive side that is just not good enough. They're
just not talented enough. And I think they have enough offensively.
I think their quarterbacks fantastic when he knows what color

(35:09):
jersey they're wearing, which is not always a guarantee with
nus Meyer. He will take some risks and unnecessarily so
I don't think they've been committed enough to the run game.
And I also don't think that they are a team
right now that if their offense doesn't have their a
game that they can win. Like their defense struggles and
they have a good coordinator, they just don't have the

(35:31):
person now. And when we think LSU personnel on defense
and the best, like very few from this year's group
would be starting on some of the best LSU teams
on that side of the block.

Speaker 2 (35:42):
No, I think that's I think that's fair. And I
when I watch him, I kind of feel half to
half game to game, I'm not exactly sure.

Speaker 3 (35:49):
What I get.

Speaker 2 (35:51):
At their very best, they're really good, but they're just
wildly inconsistent. And I thought it would work. I really did.
I was like one of my strongest takes, like this
dude won Cincinnati. I mean, people forget Notre Dame. Notre
Dame is hard. You have a religious umbrella. It is
a cold, northern small town, academically harder than average. It's

(36:17):
hard to get all the academic schools Northwestern, Stanford, Notre Dame.
Have they ever all been good at once? It's hard.
And I've talked to Notre damers like it's it's it's
no day at the beach and frankly that part of
the country. You have to get on a plane for
every single recruit. So I to win at Notre Dame,
I think has always been I think in the seventies

(36:38):
and eighties it was a glamour program that's just another
cold weather place. I think it's hard, and you know,
there's there's limitations on. They've always had this austere feeling
about what they are and it's like, just pay the
tight end six hundred thousand to be done with it.
I think I think Notre Dame still kind of struggles
sometimes with hey, we're above that.

Speaker 3 (36:59):
No they're not.

Speaker 2 (37:00):
Florida State's paned, go pay it, let's get move on.
If they're so, we're gonna wrap it up here. If
I said, forget the national championship, but somebody in this
playoff is going to win three games and we're all
going to look up and go, man, did we look
past them? It? Is there a team because I don't know.

(37:23):
I I think Tennessee is a matchup team. Yeah, it
may not be a year. Is there a team in
here that you do things undervalued?

Speaker 3 (37:32):
Yes? Ole Miss.

Speaker 1 (37:36):
Now, Ole Miss has a bit of a unique circumstance
surrounding their program and the way they've compiled their roster.
So I think in the regular season with ole Miss,
I think Lane would admit this culture is something that
is going to be a challenge. Yeah, having guys that
are just universally invested in the place because they've been

(38:00):
there for six months, how do you develop any type
of appeal for the community or for the university, Like
I'm here to play ball, I'm doing this, like I'm
getting paid this, Like this is what we do. So
as a result, I thought that there would be games
this year that would be close because guys weren't going
to be all in on a week to week basis.

(38:20):
That happened against Kentucky and it also happened against LSU.
They had no business losing either game.

Speaker 3 (38:27):
None.

Speaker 1 (38:27):
I mean I'm talking they completely They played their D
game and if they had one fourth and seven stop
on their on the Kentucky twenty yard line on a
deep ball down the left side, game over, ole Miss wins.
And they had nuss Meyer wrapped up three different times
on the game winning drive that are the game tying

(38:48):
drive that sent it to overtime against LSU, Like that
had no business losing either game. I've seen them at
their best and I've seen them at their worst, and
I'm telling you you do not want to see them
at their best.

Speaker 3 (38:58):
They are that good.

Speaker 1 (38:58):
Yeah, and they have weapons, and they have players, and
they have defensive linemen that can take over the game
at three different positions. And you can do that at
three different positions your cook with gas.

Speaker 2 (39:11):
So if Sark meets Kiffen in the Natty, You're not shocked.

Speaker 3 (39:16):
I would not be shocked at all.

Speaker 1 (39:18):
Yeah, as crazy as we keep talking about Indiana and
how is Indiana. Ole Miss, up until a couple of
years ago, had never in the history of the state
of Mississippi as a team won eleven games, So we
have seen like Indiana just won ten for the first time.
Ole Miss won eleven for the first time last year,
So I mean we are I mean, Lane Kiffen is

(39:40):
in uncharted territory with what he's done at that program,
deserves immense credit.

Speaker 2 (39:43):
Yeah, don't don't judge a coach by his first job.
Lane has resurrected his career. Sark had some personal demons,
overcame those, but Sark was Everybody kind of felt like
Sark was gonna work even the Washington job. Growing up
around that program. They were a disaster when he took
it over, and they immediately he got him seven wins nine.
He knew what he was doing. Yeah, Lane Kiffin had
to go backwards before he could step forward. But I

(40:06):
easy guy to root for. He can be self deprecating.
He's really good. He had a rougherly struggle, fired in
an airport in Los Angeles, had the deal with old
Al Davis. I'm happy for Lane, all right. Greg McElroy
a Natty in twenty ten with the Alabama Crimson Tide.
We've taken too much of his time. We do this
a couple times a year, and mental respect for you

(40:27):
and your knowledge of the game. You're really really good
for our audience. You know, I love you and you're
just terrific. And thank you again.

Speaker 3 (40:33):
You're a great friend. Calin, You're the best that's ever done.
In my opinion, I'm always grateful to spend the time
with you. Buddy.

Speaker 1 (40:41):
The volume.

Speaker 2 (40:42):
So it's twenty twenty four, and let's talk about something
really really important. If you're ever injured, check out Morgan
and Morgan's, America's largest injury law firm, and they're there
for you. Over one hundred offices nationwide. Think about that,
more than a thousand lawyers with over twenty billion. That's
a B twenty billion dollars recovered for over five hundred

(41:05):
thousand clients. Things happen in life unexpectedly. Submitting an injury
claim with Morgan and Morgan is really really easy. Like
winning in the NFL is hard. We know that quarterbacking
in the NFL is hard, Submitting a claim is easy.
You're ever injured, check out Morgan and Morgan. Their fee
is free unless they win. For more information, go to

(41:25):
for thepeople dot com, slash Colin or dial pound law
from your cell phone. Pretty easy. That's for the people
dot com, slash Colin, or pound law pound five to
nine from your cell Morgan and Morgan has a proven
track record of fighting for you to get a full
and fair compensation if there's an unexpected accident in your life.

(41:48):
This is a paid advertisement
Advertise With Us

Hosts And Creators

Colin Cowherd

Colin Cowherd

Jason McIntyre

Jason McIntyre

Popular Podcasts

The Joe Rogan Experience

The Joe Rogan Experience

The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.

True Crime Tonight

True Crime Tonight

If you eat, sleep, and breathe true crime, TRUE CRIME TONIGHT is serving up your nightly fix. Five nights a week, KT STUDIOS & iHEART RADIO invite listeners to pull up a seat for an unfiltered look at the biggest cases making headlines, celebrity scandals, and the trials everyone is watching. With a mix of expert analysis, hot takes, and listener call-ins, TRUE CRIME TONIGHT goes beyond the headlines to uncover the twists, turns, and unanswered questions that keep us all obsessed—because, at TRUE CRIME TONIGHT, there’s a seat for everyone. Whether breaking down crime scene forensics, scrutinizing serial killers, or debating the most binge-worthy true crime docs, True Crime Tonight is the fresh, fast-paced, and slightly addictive home for true crime lovers.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.