November 8, 2018 • 11 mins
Sometimes people accidentally harm others, and sometimes it's intentional. Either way, there's no way to explain what happens to the subjects of today's tour through the Cabinet.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:03):
Our world is full of the unexplainable, and if history
is an open book, all of these amazing tales are
right there on display, just waiting for us to explore.
Welcome to the Cabinet of Curiosities. When you think of
(00:28):
movie stars, there are way too many to pick from
these days, and each year it seems those names and
faces get swapped out for a brand new crowd. But
a century ago, the list was a lot smaller, and
sitting right at the top of it all was Rudolph Valentino.
He was the original pop culture icon. Born in Italy,
(00:50):
he came to New York in nineteen twelve, where he
worked odd jobs bussing tables and gardening. It wasn't until
he was hired as a dancer when his luck started
to change. He found work in a traveling musical that
took him from New York all the way to California,
where he went on to pursue a stage career, although
he'd only ever performed in front of life audiences up
(01:11):
to that point, another actor took one look at Valentino
and suggested he try his hand at films. With his
striking good looks and his knack for wooing the ladies.
Rudolf Valentino became known around Hollywood as the Latin Lover,
and eventually only by his last name Valentino. He came
up in the era of silent movies, of which he
(01:33):
performed in almost forty Unfortunately, like other notable film legends
such as James Dean and Bruce Lee, Valentino's career was
cut short. He died at the young age of just
thirty one. Over one hundred thousand people line New York
streets to pay their respects to him. There were reports
of suicidence by mourning fans, as well as a public riot. However,
(01:57):
as strange and unexpected as his passing us, the circumstances
surrounding it were even stranger. In fact, Valentino's death may
have been the first of several linked to one common culprit.
A ring. That's right, a tiny piece of jewelry he
wore on his pinkie. He bought it in San Francisco
(02:17):
from a shopkeeper with a dire warning. The ring, a
silver band with the stone in the middle, was cursed.
Valentino didn't want to hear it. He was a success
now and he wanted something to show how far he'd come.
He purchased the ring despite the owner's cautionary tale, and
it quickly became his signature. He wore it in publicity
(02:38):
photos and even in his motion pictures, most notably Two
is the Young Rajah. It was a commercial and critical flop,
the first of several for the young actor. His next
three films were all box office disappointments. Despite Valentino's immense
talents and dashing good looks. It seemed like the shopkeeper
(02:59):
had been right. The actor's signature ring had been holding
him back. Unfortunately for Valentino, it was too late to
do anything about it. While on tour to promote his
last film, The Son of the Chic, Valentino came down
with a case of bleeding ulcers and required surgery. At first,
everything seemed to be okay, but doctors discovered he developed
(03:21):
an infection known as peritonitis, an inflammation of lung tissue
leading to fluid build up inside the lungs. Nothing could
be done, His condition got worse, and by the end
of August of NIX he was gone. The ring, however,
did not go with him. Instead, it was passed down
to his lover, another actor Poland Negri, but she immediately
(03:44):
fell ill after taking possession of it, and her career suffered.
She managed to survive, but passed the ring onto singer
and actor Russ Colombo. Colombo had been described as a
doppelganger of sorts to Valentino, and it turned out to
be true in more ways than one. Days after he
accepted Negri's gift, Colombo died after a bizarre shooting accident
(04:07):
involving a friend. The ring then bounced to another of
Columbo's acquaintances, a man named Joe Casino, who was so
afraid of the curse he locked the ring away and
refused to take it out for anyone. But the allure
proved to be too great, and even Joe succumbed to
its call. He'd only been wearing the ring a week
when he was struck and killed by a truck. Casino's brother,
(04:31):
Del was the next to claim the ring and decided
to lend it to a Rudolph Valentino memorabilia collector. Perhaps
he hoped that the curse hadn't been a curse at all,
Maybe the ring had just been an innocent part of
a bunch of odd coincidences. Well, you might think that
if the ring's journey ended there, but it didn't. One night,
Dell came home to find his house had been robbed.
(04:53):
Guess what had been taken. That's right, Valentino's ring. The
thief was quickly caught by police, though, but didn't go quietly.
An officer fired a warning shot that ended up killing
him instead. Several years later, figure skater Jack Dunn slipped
the ring onto his finger for a screen test the film,
(05:14):
a biopic about the late Valentino. Ten days later, Done
passed away from a rare blood disease. After that, the
ring was locked away, never to be seen or worn again. Today,
no one knows where it is, and Valentino's spirit is
said to haunt many locations around Los Angeles searching for it.
(05:35):
That bus boy from Italy certainly made a name for
himself in his short time on Earth. While his career
had not been as prolific as some of his peers,
he still remembered and watched to this day, and the
name Valentino has become synonymous with the notion of the
Hollywood heartthrob. After all, it does have a nice ring
(05:57):
to it, doesn't it. We're taught from a very young
age that lightning never strikes in the same place twice.
But lightning is unpredictable and controllable, and it lacks an agenda.
(06:22):
You might say that lightning is definitely not a serial killer.
Because serial killers do have an agenda. They can and
do hunt the same areas for new victims. They often
have a particular victim type or compulsion for what they
do or who they do it too. That was the
case in Birmingham, England. Her name was Mary Ashford and
(06:44):
she had plans to go dancing with her friend Hannah Cox.
One Monday evening. She walked from her home in Langley
Heath to Hannah's house and dropped off her party dress
for that night. After work, she came by to change,
and then the two of them headed out to the
party together. Mary and Hannah had danced with several men
throughout the night, but two had entirely captured their attentions,
(07:08):
Benjamin Carter and Abraham Thornton. The two couples departed the
dance around midnight, but after walking Hannah to her door,
Benjamin headed back to the dance. Mr. Thornton and Mary, however,
had other plans They walked the route to Mary's grandfather's house,
talking until about four in the morning, when Mary went
(07:28):
back to Hannah's to pick up her work clothes from
the night before. That was the last time anyone saw
her alive. Early the next morning, a man walking through
pipe Hayes Park came across a pile of women's clothing
next to a large pit filled with water. He told
the locals what he'd found, and, filled with a growing
sense of dread, they knew what had to be done.
(07:51):
They dredged the pit and came up with the body
a woman who, according to the police, had been drowned.
She had bruises up and down her arms, clear signs
of a struggle just before her murder. Beside the pit,
authorities also found two sets of footprints in the mud.
One had been Mary Ashford's, another set belonged to Abraham Thornton.
(08:15):
He admitted to spending the evening with the late miss Ashford,
but swore up and down that he didn't kill her.
The police didn't see it that way, and despite having
no evidence beyond his muddy footprints, Thornton went on trial
for her murder. He was their only suspect and his
odds of beating the rap were slim. Everyone, especially the public,
(08:35):
thought that he was guilty, but public opinion was not
enough to build a case upon the police just didn't
have the evidence to convict him, and Thornton was acquitted
of the charges. Even after numerous petitions for retrials by
Mary's family, it could never be proven that he killed her.
When one of Mary's brothers attempted to ask the judge
(08:56):
for a retrial, Thornton defended himself by dredging up a
piece of medieval law that allowed him to challenge Mary's
brother to a trial by battle. If he won, he
would be acquitted. If he lost, then he would be hanged.
Mary's brother refused the challenge and Abraham Thornton was once
again a freeman. Then another body turned up. She was
(09:21):
found in the same place, pipe Hayes Park, under the
same circumstances. Her name was Barbara Forrest and she worked
as a nurse at a children's hospital. She too had
been assaulted and strangled after a night of dancing and
guess where the police began their questioning. That's right, with
a man named Thornton. As it turned out, he'd been
(09:42):
her co worker at the children's home, and there was
blood on his pants. Unfortunately, DNA testing still had years
to go before it would be used in police investigations.
It just wasn't enough evidence to convict him, and Thornton
walked away without ever seeing the inside of a cell.
People close to the victims remember both women feeling uneasy
(10:06):
about their lives just before they were taken. Mary had
told Hannah's mother she had bad feelings about the week
to come. Barbara Forrest had told a coworker a little
over a week before her murder, this is going to
be my unlucky month. I just know it. Both murders
had been committed in the same place, using the same method,
(10:28):
under similar circumstances, all by a man named Thornton. But
it wasn't the work of a serial killer. And we
know that to be true. Why because Mary Ashford was
murdered in eighteen seventeen, while Barbara forrest death occurred much later,
(10:48):
one fifty seven years later, to be precise. I hope
you've enjoyed today's guided tour of the Cabinet of Curiosities.
Subscribe for free on Apple Podcasts, or learn more about
the show by visiting Curiosities podcast dot com. The show
was created by me Aaron Mankey in partnership with how
(11:11):
Stuff Works. I make another award winning show called Lore,
which is a podcast, book series, and television show and
you can learn all about it over at the World
of Lore dot com. And until next time, stay curious.
Our world is full of the unexplainable, and if history
is an open book, all of these amazing tales are
right there on display, just waiting for us to explore.
Welcome to the Cabinet of Curiosities. When you think of
(00:28):
movie stars, there are way too many to pick from
these days, and each year it seems those names and
faces get swapped out for a brand new crowd. But
a century ago, the list was a lot smaller, and
sitting right at the top of it all was Rudolph Valentino.
He was the original pop culture icon. Born in Italy,
(00:50):
he came to New York in nineteen twelve, where he
worked odd jobs bussing tables and gardening. It wasn't until
he was hired as a dancer when his luck started
to change. He found work in a traveling musical that
took him from New York all the way to California,
where he went on to pursue a stage career, although
he'd only ever performed in front of life audiences up
(01:11):
to that point, another actor took one look at Valentino
and suggested he try his hand at films. With his
striking good looks and his knack for wooing the ladies.
Rudolf Valentino became known around Hollywood as the Latin Lover,
and eventually only by his last name Valentino. He came
up in the era of silent movies, of which he
(01:33):
performed in almost forty Unfortunately, like other notable film legends
such as James Dean and Bruce Lee, Valentino's career was
cut short. He died at the young age of just
thirty one. Over one hundred thousand people line New York
streets to pay their respects to him. There were reports
of suicidence by mourning fans, as well as a public riot. However,
(01:57):
as strange and unexpected as his passing us, the circumstances
surrounding it were even stranger. In fact, Valentino's death may
have been the first of several linked to one common culprit.
A ring. That's right, a tiny piece of jewelry he
wore on his pinkie. He bought it in San Francisco
(02:17):
from a shopkeeper with a dire warning. The ring, a
silver band with the stone in the middle, was cursed.
Valentino didn't want to hear it. He was a success
now and he wanted something to show how far he'd come.
He purchased the ring despite the owner's cautionary tale, and
it quickly became his signature. He wore it in publicity
(02:38):
photos and even in his motion pictures, most notably Two
is the Young Rajah. It was a commercial and critical flop,
the first of several for the young actor. His next
three films were all box office disappointments. Despite Valentino's immense
talents and dashing good looks. It seemed like the shopkeeper
(02:59):
had been right. The actor's signature ring had been holding
him back. Unfortunately for Valentino, it was too late to
do anything about it. While on tour to promote his
last film, The Son of the Chic, Valentino came down
with a case of bleeding ulcers and required surgery. At first,
everything seemed to be okay, but doctors discovered he developed
(03:21):
an infection known as peritonitis, an inflammation of lung tissue
leading to fluid build up inside the lungs. Nothing could
be done, His condition got worse, and by the end
of August of NIX he was gone. The ring, however,
did not go with him. Instead, it was passed down
to his lover, another actor Poland Negri, but she immediately
(03:44):
fell ill after taking possession of it, and her career suffered.
She managed to survive, but passed the ring onto singer
and actor Russ Colombo. Colombo had been described as a
doppelganger of sorts to Valentino, and it turned out to
be true in more ways than one. Days after he
accepted Negri's gift, Colombo died after a bizarre shooting accident
(04:07):
involving a friend. The ring then bounced to another of
Columbo's acquaintances, a man named Joe Casino, who was so
afraid of the curse he locked the ring away and
refused to take it out for anyone. But the allure
proved to be too great, and even Joe succumbed to
its call. He'd only been wearing the ring a week
when he was struck and killed by a truck. Casino's brother,
(04:31):
Del was the next to claim the ring and decided
to lend it to a Rudolph Valentino memorabilia collector. Perhaps
he hoped that the curse hadn't been a curse at all,
Maybe the ring had just been an innocent part of
a bunch of odd coincidences. Well, you might think that
if the ring's journey ended there, but it didn't. One night,
Dell came home to find his house had been robbed.
(04:53):
Guess what had been taken. That's right, Valentino's ring. The
thief was quickly caught by police, though, but didn't go quietly.
An officer fired a warning shot that ended up killing
him instead. Several years later, figure skater Jack Dunn slipped
the ring onto his finger for a screen test the film,
(05:14):
a biopic about the late Valentino. Ten days later, Done
passed away from a rare blood disease. After that, the
ring was locked away, never to be seen or worn again. Today,
no one knows where it is, and Valentino's spirit is
said to haunt many locations around Los Angeles searching for it.
(05:35):
That bus boy from Italy certainly made a name for
himself in his short time on Earth. While his career
had not been as prolific as some of his peers,
he still remembered and watched to this day, and the
name Valentino has become synonymous with the notion of the
Hollywood heartthrob. After all, it does have a nice ring
(05:57):
to it, doesn't it. We're taught from a very young
age that lightning never strikes in the same place twice.
But lightning is unpredictable and controllable, and it lacks an agenda.
(06:22):
You might say that lightning is definitely not a serial killer.
Because serial killers do have an agenda. They can and
do hunt the same areas for new victims. They often
have a particular victim type or compulsion for what they
do or who they do it too. That was the
case in Birmingham, England. Her name was Mary Ashford and
(06:44):
she had plans to go dancing with her friend Hannah Cox.
One Monday evening. She walked from her home in Langley
Heath to Hannah's house and dropped off her party dress
for that night. After work, she came by to change,
and then the two of them headed out to the
party together. Mary and Hannah had danced with several men
throughout the night, but two had entirely captured their attentions,
(07:08):
Benjamin Carter and Abraham Thornton. The two couples departed the
dance around midnight, but after walking Hannah to her door,
Benjamin headed back to the dance. Mr. Thornton and Mary, however,
had other plans They walked the route to Mary's grandfather's house,
talking until about four in the morning, when Mary went
(07:28):
back to Hannah's to pick up her work clothes from
the night before. That was the last time anyone saw
her alive. Early the next morning, a man walking through
pipe Hayes Park came across a pile of women's clothing
next to a large pit filled with water. He told
the locals what he'd found, and, filled with a growing
sense of dread, they knew what had to be done.
(07:51):
They dredged the pit and came up with the body
a woman who, according to the police, had been drowned.
She had bruises up and down her arms, clear signs
of a struggle just before her murder. Beside the pit,
authorities also found two sets of footprints in the mud.
One had been Mary Ashford's, another set belonged to Abraham Thornton.
(08:15):
He admitted to spending the evening with the late miss Ashford,
but swore up and down that he didn't kill her.
The police didn't see it that way, and despite having
no evidence beyond his muddy footprints, Thornton went on trial
for her murder. He was their only suspect and his
odds of beating the rap were slim. Everyone, especially the public,
(08:35):
thought that he was guilty, but public opinion was not
enough to build a case upon the police just didn't
have the evidence to convict him, and Thornton was acquitted
of the charges. Even after numerous petitions for retrials by
Mary's family, it could never be proven that he killed her.
When one of Mary's brothers attempted to ask the judge
(08:56):
for a retrial, Thornton defended himself by dredging up a
piece of medieval law that allowed him to challenge Mary's
brother to a trial by battle. If he won, he
would be acquitted. If he lost, then he would be hanged.
Mary's brother refused the challenge and Abraham Thornton was once
again a freeman. Then another body turned up. She was
(09:21):
found in the same place, pipe Hayes Park, under the
same circumstances. Her name was Barbara Forrest and she worked
as a nurse at a children's hospital. She too had
been assaulted and strangled after a night of dancing and
guess where the police began their questioning. That's right, with
a man named Thornton. As it turned out, he'd been
(09:42):
her co worker at the children's home, and there was
blood on his pants. Unfortunately, DNA testing still had years
to go before it would be used in police investigations.
It just wasn't enough evidence to convict him, and Thornton
walked away without ever seeing the inside of a cell.
People close to the victims remember both women feeling uneasy
(10:06):
about their lives just before they were taken. Mary had
told Hannah's mother she had bad feelings about the week
to come. Barbara Forrest had told a coworker a little
over a week before her murder, this is going to
be my unlucky month. I just know it. Both murders
had been committed in the same place, using the same method,
(10:28):
under similar circumstances, all by a man named Thornton. But
it wasn't the work of a serial killer. And we
know that to be true. Why because Mary Ashford was
murdered in eighteen seventeen, while Barbara forrest death occurred much later,
(10:48):
one fifty seven years later, to be precise. I hope
you've enjoyed today's guided tour of the Cabinet of Curiosities.
Subscribe for free on Apple Podcasts, or learn more about
the show by visiting Curiosities podcast dot com. The show
was created by me Aaron Mankey in partnership with how
(11:11):
Stuff Works. I make another award winning show called Lore,
which is a podcast, book series, and television show and
you can learn all about it over at the World
of Lore dot com. And until next time, stay curious.
Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities News
Host
Aaron Mahnke
Popular Podcasts
United States of Kennedy
United States of Kennedy is a podcast about our cultural fascination with the Kennedy dynasty. Every week, hosts Lyra Smith and George Civeris go into one aspect of the Kennedy story.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com