July 23, 2025 • 28 mins
For the first time in decades, detectives have a solid lead on who killed Carla Walker. Forensic DNA testing of her powder blue dress is pointing to a surprising suspect. But authorities need one more DNA sample to close the case.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:11):
Carl even though she was seventeen. To be frank, she
looks like she's twelve. And to see her laying in
the calvert and what had been done to her, you know,
it just it broke my heart, and you know, I
felt an obligation. I needed to figure out who did this.
Speaker 2 (00:43):
The rape and murder of Carla Walker in nineteen seventy
four went unsolved for decades. It became the cold case
in Fort Worth, Texas that everyone seemed to talk about,
but no one could solve. It drew national attention when
it was featured on a crime TV show years later,
but even that didn't lead investigators to her killer. I'm
(01:11):
Ailan Lance Lesser, and this is America's Crime Lab. This
is Part three of the Carla Walker Case. If you
haven't listened to the previous episodes yet, go back and
listen so you can follow along to the case. I'm
here with producer Katherine Fenalosa Hey Catherine Hey Aylen. So
when we last talked, Detective Jeff Bennett and Fort Worth
(01:34):
had decided to test this second piece of DNA from
her dress, sort of a hail Mary, and send it
to the new lab outside of Houston. Yeap.
Speaker 3 (01:43):
Detective Bennett had run out of all other options, and
both he and investigator Paul Hols are just absolutely desperate
to find out the truth of what happened to Carla.
So Jeff Bennett decides to ship parts of Carlo's dress
off to AUTH room and then he basically just has
(02:04):
to sit around and wait.
Speaker 4 (02:10):
I remember it was July fourth, it was a Saturday morning,
about nine am. I get a phone call and I
see that it's David Middleman calling. I knew that he
had an answer. I could not answer the phone fast enough,
and David says, well, Jeff, we got a profile from
(02:32):
your DNA.
Speaker 3 (02:33):
David says, listen, we're able to extract DNA markers from
Carlo's clothes. We've been building out the family trees, and
I have a name for you.
Speaker 2 (02:46):
Who is it?
Speaker 3 (02:47):
The last name is McCurley, And David says, but there's
a problem because our genealogists are saying that there is
a Glenn Samuel mccurryly. But he died in nineteen seventy two,
and Carla was murdered in nineteen seventy four. What so
(03:15):
it can't be him.
Speaker 2 (03:17):
Unless he became a zombie. But yes, it.
Speaker 3 (03:20):
Can't exactly, it can't be him. The powder blue dress
that Carla wore to the Valentine's Day dance. Her sister Cindy,
who was eighteen at the time Carla was seventeen, had
worn that dress to a dance before Carla wore it.
So there is some thought right that any DNA that
(03:43):
they're pulling off the dress could actually have already been
there the night that Carla's abducted.
Speaker 2 (03:51):
Oh, that complicates things even more. And also just to clarify,
is this DNA semen or is it just like touched.
Speaker 3 (04:00):
I think it's semen, but that's also mixed with some
of Carlo's DNA.
Speaker 2 (04:06):
Of Carlo's DNA, Okay, I feel like that is very different.
If it's semen, it's not like Carla's sister wore the
dress and gave this guy a hug and then it's there.
It's like, no, something happened.
Speaker 3 (04:20):
We are talking about teenagers.
Speaker 2 (04:23):
True, and who knows what Carla's sister wants to say
or exactly.
Speaker 3 (04:28):
And these are all like really good kids from everybody
I've talked to, But you know, it's it's high school
in the early to mid seventies. They're partying, they're having fun.
Speaker 2 (04:44):
So David Middleman gave Jeff Bennett a name, but there's
this problem with it in that the name is of
someone who passed away two years before the crime exactly.
Speaker 3 (04:54):
So Jeff Bennett says, David, I have a question for you.
Did Glenn Samuel mccury have any sons? And David says,
we're not at that point yet in the family tree.
Give me some time and I will call you back.
Speaker 4 (05:12):
So he called back about an hour and a half later,
and he said, BINGO, Glenn Samuel McCurley had three boys.
Speaker 2 (05:22):
Ooh.
Speaker 3 (05:23):
Now, remember Jeff is put together a suspect list that
has eighty five people on it. Jeff is immediately scanning
down his list of suspects.
Speaker 4 (05:32):
Sure enough, number twenty two on my suspect.
Speaker 3 (05:35):
List Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior. Ooh, Jeff does confirm that
of the three mccury brothers, Glenn Junior was the only
one living in Texas at the time when Carla was killed.
And now he needs to focus in on Glenn.
Speaker 4 (06:02):
It was a goosebump moment for me that detectives had
worked forty six years to solve this case now as
a matter to see if we could locate Glenn mccurly
if he was still alive.
Speaker 3 (06:39):
It sort of blows Detective Bennett's mind when he gets
that information because for forty six years, any leads they've
gotten have led nowhere, and now not only did he
get a new lead, but he actually has a name,
(07:01):
like there is a suspect to now go and investigate.
Speaker 2 (07:05):
Why was Glenn McCurley Junior on the list in the
first place, because that means something else was indicating it
could be him.
Speaker 3 (07:15):
So he was in his thirties at the time that
Carla was abducted. And the reason he was on the
list is when remember the magazine to the gun that
they found in the parking lot of the Bowling Alley
At the time, detectives got a list of every single
person in the area that owned that type of gun,
(07:36):
and Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior owned a Ruger twenty two.
So back in the seventies, police interviewed every single person
in Fort Worth that owned that gun. Everyone else was
able to produce the gun. Glenn was the only person
who couldn't. He said that he had been on a
(07:59):
fishing tree and the gun was stolen and he just
never reported it.
Speaker 2 (08:05):
Oh that's interesting. Could be a clue or a red herring.
Speaker 3 (08:11):
Now, he did take a polygraph at the time and
he passed, so it was sort of like, huh not
him and the police moved on. I mean, they didn't
really have anything else to tie him to the murder.
Speaker 2 (08:25):
It is also interesting that he was willing to take
the polygraph if that was sort of the gold standard
at the time. Yeah, if he did it, you would
think he wouldn't want to take the polygraph. Even if
I don't trust the polygraph, it is interesting that he
was willing to take it, probably believing that it was
an effective way to catch someone.
Speaker 3 (08:47):
Lying prove his innocence.
Speaker 2 (08:49):
Yeah, so that is interesting to me. Yeah.
Speaker 3 (08:51):
So now detective Bennett has a name.
Speaker 4 (09:02):
So started doing some research. Located Glenn Samu McCurley still
living in Fort Worth, just a couple of miles from
the bowling alley that Carlo was abducted from. It was
in the middle of COVID, so we kind of used
that as a reason to have this. Police officers show
(09:23):
up at mccurley's residence.
Speaker 3 (09:29):
So two detectives go out to the house. This is
in twenty twenty, and they want to see does he
still live there? You know, this is forty six years later.
They have no idea and they sort of use it
being COVID as an excuse. You know, they're just going
door to door checking on residents. Do you have enough masks?
Are you okay? That type of thing.
Speaker 2 (09:50):
Oh interesting, a little undercover action happening here exactly.
Speaker 3 (09:56):
So they go, they knock in the door.
Speaker 4 (09:59):
His his wife came to the door and we asked
him we could talk with him. She said, he's in
the backyard.
Speaker 3 (10:09):
And I'm not sure if his wife called to him
in the backyard, but he comes around the side of
the house to come talk to officers.
Speaker 4 (10:23):
One of the first things he did is he lifted
up his hands and he goes, I didn't do it,
and in a joking kind of manner with this officer,
and he walks up and they just start joking back
and forth and having conversation. So we knew that he
was living there.
Speaker 3 (10:42):
And he's laughing.
Speaker 2 (10:44):
It does strike me as a little weird that he
would come out with his hands up and make this
joke about it. Wasn't me, Like, that's just the type
of joke I think someone would make who was super
confident in themselves and not at all of afraid of police,
and not at all worried that something bigger was happening.
Speaker 3 (11:05):
When the officers went there, they didn't get any signs
that there was anything amiss. I mean, they're an older couple,
they're at home, they've lived there for over fifty years.
He was a former truck driver and she used to
run the daycare at the local church. They had two
boys themselves, and really, detectives are just going on this
name that authoram provided. So the officers leave and the
(11:28):
mccurls have put their trash out for pickup, and the
police just, you know, look through the trash bag that's
on the curb and they take a few things, one
being a fast food drink cup and they take that
and they test the.
Speaker 4 (11:42):
Straw and that profile matched the profile that we had
uploaded into kotis. It was Glenn mccurley's DNA profile.
Speaker 2 (12:04):
Hang on, why are they testing the straw?
Speaker 3 (12:06):
So the detectives need to confirm his identity basically to
make sure that this person is actually Glenn McCurley Junior.
Speaker 2 (12:16):
And what does it mean that the DNA from the
straw matches the profile and codis.
Speaker 3 (12:21):
So it means that Glenn probably had something to do
with Carla's abduction. But remember Rodney, Carla's boyfriend said there
might have been more than one man who grabbed her
from the car.
Speaker 2 (12:35):
Yeah, I remember that. So that means the investigation is
not over, not even close. So what happens now?
Speaker 3 (12:52):
So Detective Bennett knows that Glenn McCurley was somehow involved
in Carla's disappearance, but he's got a figure out how
So a few days later, he and his partner Leah
go back to the mccurly house unannounced.
Speaker 2 (13:08):
I got to say, going back to this person's house,
you've got some kind of connection DNA wise, I would
be pretty nervous, shaking in my boots.
Speaker 3 (13:20):
Yeah, he knows that this could be a major break
in the case. They go back and their intention is
to ask him to come down to the police station
where they can question him. They knock on the door again.
His wife, Judy answers the door, and they asked to
speak to Glenn, and they sort of just say we're
(13:43):
looking into an old cold case, and we are just
talking to everybody that had been spoken to back in
the seventies.
Speaker 4 (13:51):
And she said, well, he's got liver cancer and so
he just got back from a treatment. And she said,
but I think he'll be glad to talk to you.
So we ended up doing the interview at their home.
Speaker 3 (14:09):
So Judy welcomes them into the house and they sit
Jeff Bennett and his partner with Glenn at a kitchen table.
They start asking Glenn, hey, I don't know if you
remember this young girl was abducted after a dance from
(14:31):
the bowling Alley. And Glenn is kind of a charming guy.
He's joking around with them. He doesn't know who Carla was.
He doesn't really remember the case. His wife does. Now.
She's sitting at the dining room table off to the side,
and every swaften she's sort of chiming in and oh, yeah,
(14:54):
I remember that case. Of course, that poor girl, it
was all over the news. They never who killed her.
But you know, Glenn is very comfortable, he's relaxed, he's
chatting with the officers.
Speaker 2 (15:08):
So neither of them seem super suspicious, at least in
how they're behaving.
Speaker 3 (15:13):
Not at all. So Jeff Bennett asks Glenn, so where
were you that February nineteen seventy four? Where were you
that evening? And Glenn says, well, you know, I am
was probably driving my wife around because she doesn't drive,
(15:34):
and that's what I used to do. She ran a
daycare center out of our local church, and whenever she
had errands to run, I would drive her around.
Speaker 4 (15:43):
His wife spoke up and she goes, well, no, Glenn,
don't you remember that was the week my dad was
having surgery in Midland, Texas. I was out of town
that week. And remember him looking back at her kind
of like, really.
Speaker 3 (15:57):
Oh, that's the first inkling that Jeff Bennett gets that
Glenn's not so thrilled with what his wife has just said.
Speaker 2 (16:21):
Do we know? It was that the story he was
giving years ago when they questioned him that he was
driving his wife around.
Speaker 3 (16:29):
There were two stories about Glenn back at the time.
One that he and his wife sort of did everything
together because she didn't drive. The other thing was he
was a long haul trucker and his route was basically
from Texas to California. He was out of town for stretches.
He did actually have a little bit of a criminal history,
(16:52):
but it was very minor. His parents had sent him
to a boy's home when he was a teen major.
Speaker 2 (17:01):
Kind of like a juvenile crime type home.
Speaker 3 (17:05):
I don't know exactly why his parents sent him, other
than they found him difficult at home, so he was
sent to this boy's home. He left that boy's home
and ended up stealing a car. So he did have
a criminal record based on the car theft. But other
than that, now he's in his seventies, all of that time,
(17:28):
he's having zero police interaction. Right. Yeah, So Jeff and
his partner say, listen, thank you so much for answering
our questions. Everyone that we're talking to. We're just asking
if we can take what's called a buckle swab, which
is a swab of the mouth to get a fresh
DNA sample. Oh so they asked Glenn, you know, hey,
(17:55):
would you mind And he says, oh, you know, I
already gave one the first time the police came and
asked me. Had he and his wife Judy at the
dining room table says essentially, Glenn silly, There was no
(18:17):
such thing as DNA evidence in nineteen seventy four. You
couldn't have given them a sample.
Speaker 2 (18:24):
Ough, she's a little beacon of truth over in the corner.
Duty is keeping it real.
Speaker 3 (18:37):
Good, Judy's totally keeping it real and frankly, just like
you said, did he give a DNA sample back then? Yeah,
I think we're so used to DNA being in the
conversation about things now that we forget that it's actually
fairly recent. I mean, certainly since the eighties that the
FBI's been using it, but you know, even more in
(18:58):
just like thinking about you know, know, like doing your
own genealogy and things like that, that's much more recent.
But we forget how recent it is. So Glenn sort
of screwed at this point, right, like, what is he
gonna say? No?
Speaker 2 (19:15):
He probably should say no, but yeah, maybe also just
the social pressure with his wife there and the police,
and I mean if he did it, I mean that's
a risky thing to do, to give your DNA. But
also maybe he's like, oh, they'll fumble the evidence, or
(19:36):
maybe they won't actually test it, they won't get around
to it. So I also get the argument for just
trying to fly under their radar.
Speaker 3 (19:44):
Also, don't forget he had been investigated before and they
didn't have anything on him, and he's already passed a
polygraph and a previous investigation back in the seventies. Are
you implicating yourself by not giving your DNA, now, you
know what I mean?
Speaker 2 (20:03):
Yeah, I mean, I think it's also interesting that he
probably doesn't know what evidence they do have, like do
they even have DNA to compare it against or are
they just collecting it? And so it's no harm to
give it if I did it. But also, I mean,
I do think it's so interesting with solving crime, how
(20:28):
just the social dynamics of a particular conversation can change
the trajectory of what happens. Because honestly, if Glenn McCurley
knew that they had solid DNA to compare his DNA against,
that would point to him he should not be giving
over his DNA in his mind. Obviously, I also feel
(20:51):
like he could easily come up with an excuse like
I'm tired of doing this. I already gave a polygraph.
I don't really trust DNA analyses. I don't like the
idea of my DNA getting out there into the system
and potentially pull it off in a compelling way.
Speaker 3 (21:06):
Yeah, and Alen, there's another reason that Glenn might not
have been too worried that detectives were there. So over
the years there have been other suspects that police have investigated.
Speaker 2 (21:17):
Oh wait, tell me about those people who are they?
Speaker 3 (21:21):
Let me take a step back. There are few things
I should fill you in on. First, Carla was murdered
in February, and apparently every February, Fort Worth hosts a rodeo.
I don't know if you've ever been to one.
Speaker 2 (21:35):
I actually did go to one one time, so you.
Speaker 3 (21:39):
Can picture what it's like. The one in Fort Worth
is massive, and it attracts people from all over and
it's basically sort of a temporary city springs up around
the rodeo site totally for all of the horses and
the cowboys and the hand and trailers and tents, and
(22:02):
they're there for several weeks.
Speaker 1 (22:05):
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (22:05):
I mean that adds a whole bunch of extra people
that could have somehow been connected to the Carla Walker case.
Speaker 3 (22:13):
Yeah, so a ton of people every February descend on
Fort Worth. And one year before Carla is murdered, another
young woman is abducted from her car and strangle in February.
In February, and then the same thing happens three years
(22:38):
after Carla's murder. Also in February, a young woman is
sexually assaulted and murdered, also around the time that this
rodeo is taking place in Fort Worth.
Speaker 2 (22:52):
Oh so maybe somebody is coming into town committing these
crimes and then leaving.
Speaker 3 (22:58):
Yeah, so keep that in mind. And then at one
point someone actually confesses to killing Carla. Who So, this guy,
Jimmy Dean Sasser actually walks into a police station three
years after Carla's death and he says he's the killer.
Speaker 4 (23:18):
And he was arrested for killing Carla.
Speaker 3 (23:22):
And he's ultimately indicted by a grand jury for Carla's murder.
Whoa yeah, and he spent seven months in jail awaiting trial.
But then he has a change of heart and Jimmy
Dean comes forward and says, you know what, it was
all a lie?
Speaker 2 (23:40):
What who does that?
Speaker 3 (23:42):
I know, it's kind of crazy, I think as it
was preparing to go to trial, he realized what he
had done, basically falsely confess to this crime. And I
guess all along police were a little suspen vicious of
his confession because he didn't know a lot of details
(24:05):
about Carlo's murder. He claims that he kidnapped her and
then ended up murdering her because he was angry that
she didn't go with him willingly. But he didn't know
anything about Rodney or the attack you know that Rodney
says happened in the car, so he sort of like
leaves Rodney out of the story entirely. The only info
(24:29):
he knew about Carla's case was what had been printed
in the newspaper, so kind of early on, I think
police weren't totally confident, but he ended up being indicted
and jailed.
Speaker 2 (24:48):
That is pretty intense because also I admittedly somewhat late
in life, only realized fully what a grand jury was
and the fact that it based is a mini trial
with a kind of jury where they decide there is
enough evidence to actually go to a real trial, which
(25:10):
means like they were on board to actually try to
convict this man based on evidence. So my point is
they got pretty far in the process. I mean, it
just shows yet again how you can't necessarily trust a
case just based off of a confession.
Speaker 3 (25:32):
And the reason he lied was that his marriage was
falling apart and he was sad, like what the Heck,
people do very weird things and I don't understand it,
but it happens like it. It is not uncommon for
police to have a suspect who has confessed to something.
(25:55):
Jimmy Dean Sasser actually turned himself into a police station
saying I did it. It's not like he was even
on a suspect list.
Speaker 2 (26:04):
Wow, that is strange because I get how if police
are questioning you and they're pressuring you, they want to
build their case against you, you end up just telling
them what they want to hear, almost out of social pressure.
I get that, But to go out of your way
to turn yourself in when you're not even a suspect,
that that is Honestly, I haven't heard many stories like that.
Speaker 3 (26:36):
So over the years, detectives have investigated a ton of suspects,
and now Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior is the latest that
they're looking into.
Speaker 2 (26:46):
So does he agree to give his DNA to Detective Bennett?
Speaker 3 (26:50):
Well, he's kind of stuck between a rock and a
hard place, you know what I mean, Like he looks
guilty if he refuses, but he could incriminate himself if
he does. And ultimately he agrees to give them a
DNA sample a buckle swap.
Speaker 2 (27:11):
Of his mouth. Next time on America's Crime Lab, she
asked me, you know, Jim, let me ask you a question.
Speaker 1 (27:24):
What do you want?
Speaker 2 (27:24):
Do you want a conviction or do you want the truth?
Speaker 4 (27:26):
I said, absolutely, I want the truth.
Speaker 1 (27:30):
He raised his hand and I was like, oh my god,
he's bleeding.
Speaker 4 (27:33):
He's bleeding. I tell everybody around he's bleeding. They're like
pleading to what I said, kept it a murder. I
have to be honest with you. That was a real
surprise who had ended up being at the end of
the day.
Speaker 2 (27:59):
America's Crime Labs produced by Rococo Punch for Kaleidoscope. Erica
Lance is our story editor and sound design is by
David Woji. Our producing team is Katherine Fedalosa and Jessica Albert.
Our executive producers are Kate Osborne, Mangesh Hadikadour and David
and Kristin Middleman and from iHeart Katrina Norville and Ali Perry.
(28:20):
Special thanks to Connell Byrne, Will Pearson, Carrie Lieberman, Nikki Etour,
Nathan Etowski, John Burbank, and the entire team at Authrum.
I'm Alan Lance Lesser thanks for listening,
Carl even though she was seventeen. To be frank, she
looks like she's twelve. And to see her laying in
the calvert and what had been done to her, you know,
it just it broke my heart, and you know, I
felt an obligation. I needed to figure out who did this.
Speaker 2 (00:43):
The rape and murder of Carla Walker in nineteen seventy
four went unsolved for decades. It became the cold case
in Fort Worth, Texas that everyone seemed to talk about,
but no one could solve. It drew national attention when
it was featured on a crime TV show years later,
but even that didn't lead investigators to her killer. I'm
(01:11):
Ailan Lance Lesser, and this is America's Crime Lab. This
is Part three of the Carla Walker Case. If you
haven't listened to the previous episodes yet, go back and
listen so you can follow along to the case. I'm
here with producer Katherine Fenalosa Hey Catherine Hey Aylen. So
when we last talked, Detective Jeff Bennett and Fort Worth
(01:34):
had decided to test this second piece of DNA from
her dress, sort of a hail Mary, and send it
to the new lab outside of Houston. Yeap.
Speaker 3 (01:43):
Detective Bennett had run out of all other options, and
both he and investigator Paul Hols are just absolutely desperate
to find out the truth of what happened to Carla.
So Jeff Bennett decides to ship parts of Carlo's dress
off to AUTH room and then he basically just has
(02:04):
to sit around and wait.
Speaker 4 (02:10):
I remember it was July fourth, it was a Saturday morning,
about nine am. I get a phone call and I
see that it's David Middleman calling. I knew that he
had an answer. I could not answer the phone fast enough,
and David says, well, Jeff, we got a profile from
(02:32):
your DNA.
Speaker 3 (02:33):
David says, listen, we're able to extract DNA markers from
Carlo's clothes. We've been building out the family trees, and
I have a name for you.
Speaker 2 (02:46):
Who is it?
Speaker 3 (02:47):
The last name is McCurley, And David says, but there's
a problem because our genealogists are saying that there is
a Glenn Samuel mccurryly. But he died in nineteen seventy two,
and Carla was murdered in nineteen seventy four. What so
(03:15):
it can't be him.
Speaker 2 (03:17):
Unless he became a zombie. But yes, it.
Speaker 3 (03:20):
Can't exactly, it can't be him. The powder blue dress
that Carla wore to the Valentine's Day dance. Her sister Cindy,
who was eighteen at the time Carla was seventeen, had
worn that dress to a dance before Carla wore it.
So there is some thought right that any DNA that
(03:43):
they're pulling off the dress could actually have already been
there the night that Carla's abducted.
Speaker 2 (03:51):
Oh, that complicates things even more. And also just to clarify,
is this DNA semen or is it just like touched.
Speaker 3 (04:00):
I think it's semen, but that's also mixed with some
of Carlo's DNA.
Speaker 2 (04:06):
Of Carlo's DNA, Okay, I feel like that is very different.
If it's semen, it's not like Carla's sister wore the
dress and gave this guy a hug and then it's there.
It's like, no, something happened.
Speaker 3 (04:20):
We are talking about teenagers.
Speaker 2 (04:23):
True, and who knows what Carla's sister wants to say
or exactly.
Speaker 3 (04:28):
And these are all like really good kids from everybody
I've talked to, But you know, it's it's high school
in the early to mid seventies. They're partying, they're having fun.
Speaker 2 (04:44):
So David Middleman gave Jeff Bennett a name, but there's
this problem with it in that the name is of
someone who passed away two years before the crime exactly.
Speaker 3 (04:54):
So Jeff Bennett says, David, I have a question for you.
Did Glenn Samuel mccury have any sons? And David says,
we're not at that point yet in the family tree.
Give me some time and I will call you back.
Speaker 4 (05:12):
So he called back about an hour and a half later,
and he said, BINGO, Glenn Samuel McCurley had three boys.
Speaker 2 (05:22):
Ooh.
Speaker 3 (05:23):
Now, remember Jeff is put together a suspect list that
has eighty five people on it. Jeff is immediately scanning
down his list of suspects.
Speaker 4 (05:32):
Sure enough, number twenty two on my suspect.
Speaker 3 (05:35):
List Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior. Ooh, Jeff does confirm that
of the three mccury brothers, Glenn Junior was the only
one living in Texas at the time when Carla was killed.
And now he needs to focus in on Glenn.
Speaker 4 (06:02):
It was a goosebump moment for me that detectives had
worked forty six years to solve this case now as
a matter to see if we could locate Glenn mccurly
if he was still alive.
Speaker 3 (06:39):
It sort of blows Detective Bennett's mind when he gets
that information because for forty six years, any leads they've
gotten have led nowhere, and now not only did he
get a new lead, but he actually has a name,
(07:01):
like there is a suspect to now go and investigate.
Speaker 2 (07:05):
Why was Glenn McCurley Junior on the list in the
first place, because that means something else was indicating it
could be him.
Speaker 3 (07:15):
So he was in his thirties at the time that
Carla was abducted. And the reason he was on the
list is when remember the magazine to the gun that
they found in the parking lot of the Bowling Alley
At the time, detectives got a list of every single
person in the area that owned that type of gun,
(07:36):
and Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior owned a Ruger twenty two.
So back in the seventies, police interviewed every single person
in Fort Worth that owned that gun. Everyone else was
able to produce the gun. Glenn was the only person
who couldn't. He said that he had been on a
(07:59):
fishing tree and the gun was stolen and he just
never reported it.
Speaker 2 (08:05):
Oh that's interesting. Could be a clue or a red herring.
Speaker 3 (08:11):
Now, he did take a polygraph at the time and
he passed, so it was sort of like, huh not
him and the police moved on. I mean, they didn't
really have anything else to tie him to the murder.
Speaker 2 (08:25):
It is also interesting that he was willing to take
the polygraph if that was sort of the gold standard
at the time. Yeah, if he did it, you would
think he wouldn't want to take the polygraph. Even if
I don't trust the polygraph, it is interesting that he
was willing to take it, probably believing that it was
an effective way to catch someone.
Speaker 3 (08:47):
Lying prove his innocence.
Speaker 2 (08:49):
Yeah, so that is interesting to me. Yeah.
Speaker 3 (08:51):
So now detective Bennett has a name.
Speaker 4 (09:02):
So started doing some research. Located Glenn Samu McCurley still
living in Fort Worth, just a couple of miles from
the bowling alley that Carlo was abducted from. It was
in the middle of COVID, so we kind of used
that as a reason to have this. Police officers show
(09:23):
up at mccurley's residence.
Speaker 3 (09:29):
So two detectives go out to the house. This is
in twenty twenty, and they want to see does he
still live there? You know, this is forty six years later.
They have no idea and they sort of use it
being COVID as an excuse. You know, they're just going
door to door checking on residents. Do you have enough masks?
Are you okay? That type of thing.
Speaker 2 (09:50):
Oh interesting, a little undercover action happening here exactly.
Speaker 3 (09:56):
So they go, they knock in the door.
Speaker 4 (09:59):
His his wife came to the door and we asked
him we could talk with him. She said, he's in
the backyard.
Speaker 3 (10:09):
And I'm not sure if his wife called to him
in the backyard, but he comes around the side of
the house to come talk to officers.
Speaker 4 (10:23):
One of the first things he did is he lifted
up his hands and he goes, I didn't do it,
and in a joking kind of manner with this officer,
and he walks up and they just start joking back
and forth and having conversation. So we knew that he
was living there.
Speaker 3 (10:42):
And he's laughing.
Speaker 2 (10:44):
It does strike me as a little weird that he
would come out with his hands up and make this
joke about it. Wasn't me, Like, that's just the type
of joke I think someone would make who was super
confident in themselves and not at all of afraid of police,
and not at all worried that something bigger was happening.
Speaker 3 (11:05):
When the officers went there, they didn't get any signs
that there was anything amiss. I mean, they're an older couple,
they're at home, they've lived there for over fifty years.
He was a former truck driver and she used to
run the daycare at the local church. They had two
boys themselves, and really, detectives are just going on this
name that authoram provided. So the officers leave and the
(11:28):
mccurls have put their trash out for pickup, and the
police just, you know, look through the trash bag that's
on the curb and they take a few things, one
being a fast food drink cup and they take that
and they test the.
Speaker 4 (11:42):
Straw and that profile matched the profile that we had
uploaded into kotis. It was Glenn mccurley's DNA profile.
Speaker 2 (12:04):
Hang on, why are they testing the straw?
Speaker 3 (12:06):
So the detectives need to confirm his identity basically to
make sure that this person is actually Glenn McCurley Junior.
Speaker 2 (12:16):
And what does it mean that the DNA from the
straw matches the profile and codis.
Speaker 3 (12:21):
So it means that Glenn probably had something to do
with Carla's abduction. But remember Rodney, Carla's boyfriend said there
might have been more than one man who grabbed her
from the car.
Speaker 2 (12:35):
Yeah, I remember that. So that means the investigation is
not over, not even close. So what happens now?
Speaker 3 (12:52):
So Detective Bennett knows that Glenn McCurley was somehow involved
in Carla's disappearance, but he's got a figure out how
So a few days later, he and his partner Leah
go back to the mccurly house unannounced.
Speaker 2 (13:08):
I got to say, going back to this person's house,
you've got some kind of connection DNA wise, I would
be pretty nervous, shaking in my boots.
Speaker 3 (13:20):
Yeah, he knows that this could be a major break
in the case. They go back and their intention is
to ask him to come down to the police station
where they can question him. They knock on the door again.
His wife, Judy answers the door, and they asked to
speak to Glenn, and they sort of just say we're
(13:43):
looking into an old cold case, and we are just
talking to everybody that had been spoken to back in
the seventies.
Speaker 4 (13:51):
And she said, well, he's got liver cancer and so
he just got back from a treatment. And she said,
but I think he'll be glad to talk to you.
So we ended up doing the interview at their home.
Speaker 3 (14:09):
So Judy welcomes them into the house and they sit
Jeff Bennett and his partner with Glenn at a kitchen table.
They start asking Glenn, hey, I don't know if you
remember this young girl was abducted after a dance from
(14:31):
the bowling Alley. And Glenn is kind of a charming guy.
He's joking around with them. He doesn't know who Carla was.
He doesn't really remember the case. His wife does. Now.
She's sitting at the dining room table off to the side,
and every swaften she's sort of chiming in and oh, yeah,
(14:54):
I remember that case. Of course, that poor girl, it
was all over the news. They never who killed her.
But you know, Glenn is very comfortable, he's relaxed, he's
chatting with the officers.
Speaker 2 (15:08):
So neither of them seem super suspicious, at least in
how they're behaving.
Speaker 3 (15:13):
Not at all. So Jeff Bennett asks Glenn, so where
were you that February nineteen seventy four? Where were you
that evening? And Glenn says, well, you know, I am
was probably driving my wife around because she doesn't drive,
(15:34):
and that's what I used to do. She ran a
daycare center out of our local church, and whenever she
had errands to run, I would drive her around.
Speaker 4 (15:43):
His wife spoke up and she goes, well, no, Glenn,
don't you remember that was the week my dad was
having surgery in Midland, Texas. I was out of town
that week. And remember him looking back at her kind
of like, really.
Speaker 3 (15:57):
Oh, that's the first inkling that Jeff Bennett gets that
Glenn's not so thrilled with what his wife has just said.
Speaker 2 (16:21):
Do we know? It was that the story he was
giving years ago when they questioned him that he was
driving his wife around.
Speaker 3 (16:29):
There were two stories about Glenn back at the time.
One that he and his wife sort of did everything
together because she didn't drive. The other thing was he
was a long haul trucker and his route was basically
from Texas to California. He was out of town for stretches.
He did actually have a little bit of a criminal history,
(16:52):
but it was very minor. His parents had sent him
to a boy's home when he was a teen major.
Speaker 2 (17:01):
Kind of like a juvenile crime type home.
Speaker 3 (17:05):
I don't know exactly why his parents sent him, other
than they found him difficult at home, so he was
sent to this boy's home. He left that boy's home
and ended up stealing a car. So he did have
a criminal record based on the car theft. But other
than that, now he's in his seventies, all of that time,
(17:28):
he's having zero police interaction. Right. Yeah, So Jeff and
his partner say, listen, thank you so much for answering
our questions. Everyone that we're talking to. We're just asking
if we can take what's called a buckle swab, which
is a swab of the mouth to get a fresh
DNA sample. Oh so they asked Glenn, you know, hey,
(17:55):
would you mind And he says, oh, you know, I
already gave one the first time the police came and
asked me. Had he and his wife Judy at the
dining room table says essentially, Glenn silly, There was no
(18:17):
such thing as DNA evidence in nineteen seventy four. You
couldn't have given them a sample.
Speaker 2 (18:24):
Ough, she's a little beacon of truth over in the corner.
Duty is keeping it real.
Speaker 3 (18:37):
Good, Judy's totally keeping it real and frankly, just like
you said, did he give a DNA sample back then? Yeah,
I think we're so used to DNA being in the
conversation about things now that we forget that it's actually
fairly recent. I mean, certainly since the eighties that the
FBI's been using it, but you know, even more in
(18:58):
just like thinking about you know, know, like doing your
own genealogy and things like that, that's much more recent.
But we forget how recent it is. So Glenn sort
of screwed at this point, right, like, what is he
gonna say? No?
Speaker 2 (19:15):
He probably should say no, but yeah, maybe also just
the social pressure with his wife there and the police,
and I mean if he did it, I mean that's
a risky thing to do, to give your DNA. But
also maybe he's like, oh, they'll fumble the evidence, or
(19:36):
maybe they won't actually test it, they won't get around
to it. So I also get the argument for just
trying to fly under their radar.
Speaker 3 (19:44):
Also, don't forget he had been investigated before and they
didn't have anything on him, and he's already passed a
polygraph and a previous investigation back in the seventies. Are
you implicating yourself by not giving your DNA, now, you
know what I mean?
Speaker 2 (20:03):
Yeah, I mean, I think it's also interesting that he
probably doesn't know what evidence they do have, like do
they even have DNA to compare it against or are
they just collecting it? And so it's no harm to
give it if I did it. But also, I mean,
I do think it's so interesting with solving crime, how
(20:28):
just the social dynamics of a particular conversation can change
the trajectory of what happens. Because honestly, if Glenn McCurley
knew that they had solid DNA to compare his DNA against,
that would point to him he should not be giving
over his DNA in his mind. Obviously, I also feel
(20:51):
like he could easily come up with an excuse like
I'm tired of doing this. I already gave a polygraph.
I don't really trust DNA analyses. I don't like the
idea of my DNA getting out there into the system
and potentially pull it off in a compelling way.
Speaker 3 (21:06):
Yeah, and Alen, there's another reason that Glenn might not
have been too worried that detectives were there. So over
the years there have been other suspects that police have investigated.
Speaker 2 (21:17):
Oh wait, tell me about those people who are they?
Speaker 3 (21:21):
Let me take a step back. There are few things
I should fill you in on. First, Carla was murdered
in February, and apparently every February, Fort Worth hosts a rodeo.
I don't know if you've ever been to one.
Speaker 2 (21:35):
I actually did go to one one time, so you.
Speaker 3 (21:39):
Can picture what it's like. The one in Fort Worth
is massive, and it attracts people from all over and
it's basically sort of a temporary city springs up around
the rodeo site totally for all of the horses and
the cowboys and the hand and trailers and tents, and
(22:02):
they're there for several weeks.
Speaker 1 (22:05):
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (22:05):
I mean that adds a whole bunch of extra people
that could have somehow been connected to the Carla Walker case.
Speaker 3 (22:13):
Yeah, so a ton of people every February descend on
Fort Worth. And one year before Carla is murdered, another
young woman is abducted from her car and strangle in February.
In February, and then the same thing happens three years
(22:38):
after Carla's murder. Also in February, a young woman is
sexually assaulted and murdered, also around the time that this
rodeo is taking place in Fort Worth.
Speaker 2 (22:52):
Oh so maybe somebody is coming into town committing these
crimes and then leaving.
Speaker 3 (22:58):
Yeah, so keep that in mind. And then at one
point someone actually confesses to killing Carla. Who So, this guy,
Jimmy Dean Sasser actually walks into a police station three
years after Carla's death and he says he's the killer.
Speaker 4 (23:18):
And he was arrested for killing Carla.
Speaker 3 (23:22):
And he's ultimately indicted by a grand jury for Carla's murder.
Whoa yeah, and he spent seven months in jail awaiting trial.
But then he has a change of heart and Jimmy
Dean comes forward and says, you know what, it was
all a lie?
Speaker 2 (23:40):
What who does that?
Speaker 3 (23:42):
I know, it's kind of crazy, I think as it
was preparing to go to trial, he realized what he
had done, basically falsely confess to this crime. And I
guess all along police were a little suspen vicious of
his confession because he didn't know a lot of details
(24:05):
about Carlo's murder. He claims that he kidnapped her and
then ended up murdering her because he was angry that
she didn't go with him willingly. But he didn't know
anything about Rodney or the attack you know that Rodney
says happened in the car, so he sort of like
leaves Rodney out of the story entirely. The only info
(24:29):
he knew about Carla's case was what had been printed
in the newspaper, so kind of early on, I think
police weren't totally confident, but he ended up being indicted
and jailed.
Speaker 2 (24:48):
That is pretty intense because also I admittedly somewhat late
in life, only realized fully what a grand jury was
and the fact that it based is a mini trial
with a kind of jury where they decide there is
enough evidence to actually go to a real trial, which
(25:10):
means like they were on board to actually try to
convict this man based on evidence. So my point is
they got pretty far in the process. I mean, it
just shows yet again how you can't necessarily trust a
case just based off of a confession.
Speaker 3 (25:32):
And the reason he lied was that his marriage was
falling apart and he was sad, like what the Heck,
people do very weird things and I don't understand it,
but it happens like it. It is not uncommon for
police to have a suspect who has confessed to something.
(25:55):
Jimmy Dean Sasser actually turned himself into a police station
saying I did it. It's not like he was even
on a suspect list.
Speaker 2 (26:04):
Wow, that is strange because I get how if police
are questioning you and they're pressuring you, they want to
build their case against you, you end up just telling
them what they want to hear, almost out of social pressure.
I get that, But to go out of your way
to turn yourself in when you're not even a suspect,
that that is Honestly, I haven't heard many stories like that.
Speaker 3 (26:36):
So over the years, detectives have investigated a ton of suspects,
and now Glenn Samuel McCurley Junior is the latest that
they're looking into.
Speaker 2 (26:46):
So does he agree to give his DNA to Detective Bennett?
Speaker 3 (26:50):
Well, he's kind of stuck between a rock and a
hard place, you know what I mean, Like he looks
guilty if he refuses, but he could incriminate himself if
he does. And ultimately he agrees to give them a
DNA sample a buckle swap.
Speaker 2 (27:11):
Of his mouth. Next time on America's Crime Lab, she
asked me, you know, Jim, let me ask you a question.
Speaker 1 (27:24):
What do you want?
Speaker 2 (27:24):
Do you want a conviction or do you want the truth?
Speaker 4 (27:26):
I said, absolutely, I want the truth.
Speaker 1 (27:30):
He raised his hand and I was like, oh my god,
he's bleeding.
Speaker 4 (27:33):
He's bleeding. I tell everybody around he's bleeding. They're like
pleading to what I said, kept it a murder. I
have to be honest with you. That was a real
surprise who had ended up being at the end of
the day.
Speaker 2 (27:59):
America's Crime Labs produced by Rococo Punch for Kaleidoscope. Erica
Lance is our story editor and sound design is by
David Woji. Our producing team is Katherine Fedalosa and Jessica Albert.
Our executive producers are Kate Osborne, Mangesh Hadikadour and David
and Kristin Middleman and from iHeart Katrina Norville and Ali Perry.
(28:20):
Special thanks to Connell Byrne, Will Pearson, Carrie Lieberman, Nikki Etour,
Nathan Etowski, John Burbank, and the entire team at Authrum.
I'm Alan Lance Lesser thanks for listening,
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Special Summer Offer: Exclusively on Apple Podcasts, try our Dateline Premium subscription completely free for one month! With Dateline Premium, you get every episode ad-free plus exclusive bonus content.
The Breakfast Club
The World's Most Dangerous Morning Show, The Breakfast Club, With DJ Envy, Jess Hilarious, And Charlamagne Tha God!
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.