April 17, 2024 • 42 mins
Sade Robinson tells a maintenance worker at her apartment building that she’s excited about her first date with 33-year-old Maxwell Anderson. Robinson texts Anderson about where to eat and tells him she is "feeling seafood". Anderson takes Sade to a place he used to work, the Twisted Fisherman. After dinner, they spend some more time together having drinks at Duke’s on Water. The couple leaves Duke’s together around 9 PM.
Around 9 AM April 2nd, Sade Robinson’s friend and coworker reports her missing to Milwaukee Police. The friend says Robinson isn’t returning her texts or calls and didn’t show up to work that morning. The friend shows officers a Snapchat that Robinson posted the night before, showing Robinson was at a sports bar, Duke’s on Water, the night before. Officers note that earlier that morning, Robinson’s blue Honda Civic was found burning near 30th and Lisbon, 2 miles from her apartment.
5:30 PM April 2, Cudahy Police respond to a call along Lake Michigan. At Warnimont Park, a popular recreation area, a park goer reports finding a severed human leg. According to a post from the Cudahy Sheriff’s office, the limb was found "in or near the water," east of the golf course, near the pump house.
Three days after the Warnimont Park discovery, another call to police about a severed body part. 11 miles away from the shores of Lake Michigan, in a Milwaukee west side neighborhood, a body part is found at a playground. Police received the call around 10 pm Friday night, but investigators are tight lipped on exactly where the body part is found, or what remains are recovered.
Within 24 hours, police respond to another call about the discovery of human remains. On Saturday just a few blocks from the same west side Milkwaukee area as Friday’s discovery Police set up crime scene near a park. Around 7:15 pm the medical examiner arrived to remove the body part. Police blocked off the area and canvassed well past midnight, according to neighbors.
The human remains are identified as belonging to Sade Robinson.
Joining Nancy Grace Today:
- Sheena Scarbrough - Sade’s mother
- Eric Faddis – Partner at Varner Faddis Elite Legal, Former Felony Prosecutor and Current Criminal Defense and Civil Litigation Attorney; Instagram: @e_fad @varnerfaddis; TikTok: @varnerfaddis
- Dr. John Delatorre – Licensed Psychologist and Mediator (specializing in forensic psychology); Psychological Consultant to Project Absentis: a nonprofit organization that searches for missing persons; Twitter, IG, and TikTok – @drjohndelatorre
- Joe Scott Morgan – Professor of Forensics: Jacksonville State University, Author, “Blood Beneath My Feet,” and Host: “Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan;” Twitter/X: @JoScottForensic
- Alexis Tereszcuk - CrimeOnline.com Investigative Reporter, Writer/Fact Checker at Lead Stories; X: @swimmie2009
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (00:07):
Breaking new Tonight, a crack in the disappearance and dismemberment
murder of a beautiful ten girl Shawdey Robinson did the
spoiled brat sun of a Milwaukee millionaire, Lure shaw Day
on a date turned murder.
Speaker 1 (00:28):
I'm Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (00:29):
This is Crime Stories and I want to thank you
for being with us.
Speaker 3 (00:32):
Five point thirty pm, April second, Cutahey Police respond to
a call along Lake Michigan at Warnemont Park, a popular
recreation area. A parkgoer reports finding a severed human leg.
According to a post from cuta Haey Sheriff's office, the
limb was found in or near the water east of
the golf course near the pump house. There are steep
cliffs leading to the shoreline in that area, and large
(00:55):
numbers of police canvassed the area and kept away gawkers.
Speaker 4 (00:58):
Three days after the Warnamont Park discovery, another call to
police about a severed body part. Eleven miles away from
the shores of Lake Michigan in a Milwaukee West Side neighborhood,
a body part is found at a playground. Within twenty
four hours, police respond to another call about the discovery
of human remains on Saturday, just a few blocks from
(01:19):
the same Westside Milwaukee area as Friday's discovery, police set
up a crime scene near a park.
Speaker 2 (01:26):
After a car is found on fire. Paired with a
pet tribute blanket found near some of the human remains,
police begin to focus on a beautiful young teen girl,
(01:48):
shaw Day Listen.
Speaker 5 (01:51):
Shade Robinson graduates with honors a semester early from Riverside
High School. She continues her education at Milwaukee Area Technical College,
working towards her a degree in criminal justice. In fact,
she's only a month away from graduating, but Robinson hasn't
been spending all her times in the books. She works
through high school and college at the Pizza Shuttle on
Milwaukee's Lower East Side. She makes such a difference at
(02:13):
work that her coworkers say Robinson is considered the heart
of Pizza Shuttle. Former owner Mark Gold says she is
the type of employee who never calls out and is
loved by customers and our coworkers. Robinson is heavily influenced
by her family, with many family members serving in the military.
Shade Robinson wants to look at career opportunities available for
her in the United States Air Force.
Speaker 2 (02:33):
Joining me is a very special guest, along with an
all star panel. Seriously the brain Trust, but just hearing
hold of Zapple speaking from crime online dot Com about Shade,
She's everything you want.
Speaker 1 (02:51):
Your child to pay.
Speaker 2 (02:53):
She's this fantastic student, she is working while she's going
to school, very close family, tons of relatives in the military,
and she is inspired to consider the US Air Force.
(03:16):
I mean, this is the.
Speaker 1 (03:18):
Girl we all want to have.
Speaker 2 (03:22):
I remember my grandmother. I would give her my school
picture every year and she could say, I can just
see see the mischief coming out of your eyes.
Speaker 1 (03:32):
Look at this girl. Can't you just see.
Speaker 2 (03:34):
The joy, just the love of life, crackling smart, just
beaming out of her. How in the world did she
collide cross paths with an alleged spoiled brat killer, the
(03:57):
son of a Milwaukee millionaire, a former ex high school
football star now a thirty something meters bartender.
Speaker 1 (04:11):
In addition to.
Speaker 2 (04:12):
Our all star panel of trial lawyer Eric Fattis, renowned psychologist,
doctor John Delatory, death investigator professor Joe Scott Morgan, and
investigative crime reporter Alexis Tereschuk. A special guest joining me.
This is Shawde's mother, Miss Gina Scarborough. You know, miss
(04:36):
Miss Scarborough. Whenever I have to travel for work, my
backpack is so heavy because I have all these mementos
of the twins.
Speaker 1 (04:44):
I carry with me and set up wherever I am.
Speaker 6 (04:48):
I know I heard you talking about your swins a lot.
Speaker 2 (04:50):
It's just killing me to think that you have this
picture instead of your girl.
Speaker 1 (04:56):
First of all, tell me about shaw Day Shady.
Speaker 6 (05:00):
This is beautiful, beautiful soul.
Speaker 7 (05:04):
I know that my kids were very special and different.
They my parents raised me, They raised us. We are
light workers. We put out positive energy, we exert we
help others. I'm a community advocate as a personal way
(05:26):
of my life, the way I live. I've worked for others.
I help others my whole life. I've raised my daughters
that way. My daughters have excelled. I have two daughters.
Speaker 8 (05:38):
This has called so much emotional effect to my family
or her. My parents who love my baby so much,
her grandparents, her uncles, her aunties are the community. Everyone
has pulled up. This has affected many people in Milwaukee.
I'm come here today.
Speaker 7 (05:58):
This is the hardest thing I would ever have to
do in my life to speak Shaddy's voice.
Speaker 6 (06:03):
Shadday was a beautiful soul. She was an amazing girl. Nancy.
Speaker 7 (06:08):
Everything he spoke is exactly what my daughter exerted. I
couldn't have asked for any better daughter. There was things
my daughter did that many adults were not even able
to accomplish in their lifetimes. And I'll be forty three
in a week. My birthday's life twenty seven Shoty's birthdays
(06:32):
on Mad the tenth. I had her on Mother's Day.
Speaker 6 (06:36):
The son of a.
Speaker 7 (06:37):
I'm gonna watch my language on this platform.
Speaker 6 (06:41):
But the son of a took my daughter from me
a month before. She's graduating with her Associate of Artist degree.
Speaker 7 (06:51):
She works so hard. She's a full time student. She
has two full time jobs. She has her own little
bachelor red apartment. She does to stay in a college
dorm campus. She has her own bacherette department. She has
her own car.
Speaker 6 (07:05):
She pays all of her own pills. This is trauma sizing, Nancy.
I never expect this is the pull up on my
front door. This is a normal.
Speaker 7 (07:18):
This is a twenty twenty four Jeffrey Dahmer. I need
him held accountable. I need justice for Shada. Hey, there
has been a lot of in the many black and
brown girls that I've been called missing in Milwaukee for
a moment, and all of them are going to be
held accountable now because they put they messed with the
(07:40):
wrong family, they mess with the wrong family.
Speaker 6 (07:44):
Because we're not gonna.
Speaker 7 (07:45):
Stick wide, and we're not gonna sit still, and we're
gonna call all of them out, and we're gonna speak
for the whole community, because I'm not about to sit
down and I'm not about to sit still on this one.
It's justice for Shada, Nancy. It's justice, Miss Scarborough.
Speaker 2 (08:00):
Like anything anything I or anybody on this panel could
say right now, it pales compared to what you just said.
And believe me, Miss Garborough, this story of Shahday has
(08:23):
not just touched people in Milwaukee.
Speaker 1 (08:26):
It has touched people around the world. And when you.
Speaker 2 (08:30):
Say you're not going to sit back, neither are we
until there is justice for your girl and the other
missing and murdered girls across Milwaukee. They're not all just missing,
they're dead. Many of them are dead exactly. Guys with
(08:54):
me is Shadai's mother, who is so much pain, but
she is joining us tonight to speak out for Shah Day.
Speaker 1 (09:08):
What happened? What led up to this night?
Speaker 6 (09:16):
Nancy. The last time I spoke to my daughter was
on Easter Sunday.
Speaker 7 (09:20):
Okay, we've seen her. She came by my parents' home.
We spent the Sunday together. This was Easter Sunday.
Speaker 6 (09:29):
Okay.
Speaker 7 (09:31):
I cooked for them, both of my daughters. We all
met by my parents' house where I'm currying the ad.
We all commute here. All my girls are busy. They're
my youngest is sixteen. They have a lot of activities.
They're working, they go to school. I have very successful
and independent, self sufficient darts. We harmy her nobody. We
(09:53):
just put out and help others into the universe.
Speaker 6 (09:56):
Okay. So I seen like she is. It's just very
It's like she's a nineteen twenty year old young lady.
Speaker 7 (10:04):
Okay, we all at this age. We have a lot
of friends. She's not in a relationship. She didn't have
a boyfriend. She wasn't tied down to anyone. She's single
and she's dating. I knew she hung out with her
coworkers at Pizza Shuttle. They went out to little bars
and hung out. Sometimes. I'm a very concerned mother. I'm
(10:24):
very overperspective. I always would put in shodday's ear, be careful.
I don't trust these people around Milwaukee. I'm just that
exercype of mom and my daughter's always mom.
Speaker 6 (10:36):
Just sit back. I try to give them space, let
them be independent.
Speaker 7 (10:40):
But I just been having this vibe and intuition and
I have been wanting her just to like not hang
out and.
Speaker 6 (10:46):
Go out to places for some reason.
Speaker 7 (10:49):
And I don't know exactly, and I'm still trying to
find out the facts, but I know that this type
of this individual, and I want to make clarity because
there's been a lot of trolls. There's been a lot
of media I can't interact and deal with. I'm grieving
my daughter right now. I want respects, I need time.
(11:10):
I'm gonna this is about advocating not only for my daughter,
but for all of the young women that are missing,
and for the actions to have been taken to find
my daughter. And there's a lot of information, but I
need the community and people to know that my daughter
helps others. She was a positive spirit. This this like
(11:33):
they they're claiming this was the first day, Like you know,
it's just a first day.
Speaker 6 (11:38):
I don't this dude, never she never mentioned this.
Speaker 1 (11:41):
Dude, Well, we're learning a little bit about that. Take
a listen to Dave Matt Crime Online.
Speaker 3 (11:47):
A month away from turning twenty, Shade Robinson tells a
maintenance worker at her building that she's excited about her
first date with thirty three year old Maxwell Anderson. Robinson
texts Anderson about where to eat and tells him she's seafood.
Anderson takesha day to a place he used to work,
the Twisted Fishermen. After dinner, they spend some more time together,
(12:07):
having drinks at Dukes on Water. The couple leaves Dukes
together around nine pm.
Speaker 1 (12:19):
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (12:25):
Straight out to Alexis Tereshung, joining US Crime online dot
Com investigative reporter. I want to make sure that we're
right about that this was at most a first maybe
a second, but most likely a first date, probably nothing
that she was.
Speaker 1 (12:44):
Telling everybody about.
Speaker 2 (12:47):
Tell me how we know, Alexis that the two actually
went out because reports are in Our investigation tells us
that there may have been either surveillance footage or witnesses
placing them at Twisted Fishermen, where he worked, and then
(13:09):
later at Dukes on water. How do we know that
they were together that night they met there.
Speaker 9 (13:15):
There are multiple surveillance cameras outside these restaurants, both of them,
that show her arriving walking through the east side of
the restaurant. He arrived on the west side of There's
such good video footage of this. This is just such
a good helpful part of the case. They go there together.
He used to work there at the Twisted Fishermen. So
(13:36):
the bartender there spoke with police and said they came in,
they sat at the bar together, they had a drink.
It seemed friendly and casual, nothing that would alert the
bartender to anything that was wrong. He said, they just
had a few drinks and they left within an hour.
They then, according to surveillance, leave together surveillance videos to
(13:57):
the next place.
Speaker 2 (13:58):
Joining us an all star panel to make sense of
what we know right now. But to missus Scarborough, this
is shaw Day's mother, Miss Scarborough, when did you really
I know that right now you're at your parents' home.
Speaker 1 (14:12):
I know that shaw Day, as.
Speaker 2 (14:14):
You beautifully described it, had her own little bachelorette pad
that she paid for from her two jobs. She's working
while getting her college degree. Amazing So when did somebody
realize they needed to call you and ask where's shaw day?
Speaker 7 (14:35):
It wasn't until Wednesday, Nancy, I like you, It was
a whole twenty four hours. I just had this Billy again,
like we spent. The last time I seen her was
on that Sunday for Easter. Everything was good, it was
a normal family visit. We all had a good interaction.
Then Monday, she facetimed me. That morning Monday, she facetimed me.
(14:59):
She was getting ready for work and we had a
good interaction. She's like mommy, like you know, so I
had some more you know, like getting dressed.
Speaker 6 (15:07):
I was at my job. I went to work that morning,
I got off.
Speaker 7 (15:11):
As soon as I got home from work, I was
receiving calls from like my.
Speaker 6 (15:17):
My, my mother, and my brother. We were all concerned
because we.
Speaker 7 (15:20):
All have the three sixty location app. Okay, we all
shared it as the family. So I have the app
shared with me, my mom, both of my daughters. Then
my daughter also shares shut ay. My oldest daughter also
shares the app with additional friends and like other groups.
But I have my own group with her, myself, my mother,
(15:42):
and my youngest darter. So we've seen her like this
location Monday, like again, Monday night she I seen her
getting I mean Monday morning, I've seen her getting ready
for work.
Speaker 6 (15:54):
She facetimed me. Then she that evening around three forty.
Speaker 7 (15:58):
Five, four o'clock, I got a text message from her
asking a cash apt for fifteen dollars. My daughters does
not ask me for money like she has. My daughter
makes more money to me. Literally, she's that was that boss, okay,
So like those in a big bill, I'm just that
type of mom. You need something, I'm gonna cash appy.
It's very strange that she asked me for fifteen dollars.
Speaker 2 (16:20):
Yet you know what's very odd about that, Miss Scarborough.
It reminds me of when Gabby Petito went missing and
her family started getting texts that didn't sound like her.
For instance, she wrote about her grandfather. She texted about
her grandfather, but she called him.
Speaker 1 (16:38):
By his full name. That would be like me writing.
Speaker 2 (16:44):
My producer right here Jackie and going hi Jackie, how's
Jackie today?
Speaker 1 (16:48):
It just doesn't make any just wrong.
Speaker 2 (16:52):
So you get this test asking for fifteen dollars, and
Shade would never have done that.
Speaker 1 (16:57):
I mean, if she needed she.
Speaker 2 (16:59):
Got a charge Apple pay you name it so you
knew right then something was wrong and then this take
a listen to Chief Jeffrey Norman.
Speaker 10 (17:10):
Saturday April six, MPD continued the search of in the
area and located additional human remains on the railroad tracks.
Learn you know. Saturday April six, MPD returned to the
area when Miss Robinson's family located her blanket. At this time,
do you take thus located additional human remains.
Speaker 11 (17:32):
According to court documents, the remains found Saturday included human
flesh and a foot. The foot had pink nail polish,
possibly mounting the polish on the leg found days earlier.
Speaker 1 (17:43):
Another thing that reallyncy.
Speaker 6 (17:45):
Can I say something real quisly?
Speaker 1 (17:46):
Yes?
Speaker 7 (17:47):
Please do I just, I just I just want to
clarify that the community. I want to make this clear, okay,
and I'm going to be holding all accountable that have
been I'm not blaming or attacking people. There have been
to tech business sergeants that I've been pulling up selectively
on my team. There has been the community. There have
been active members advocating for this case. I know it
(18:08):
is affecting many, but there is some faulty things that
have been being handled.
Speaker 6 (18:12):
Okay, First of all, I want to.
Speaker 7 (18:14):
Correct all of the chief executives that are pulling up
from my county and my community that are not pronouncing
my daughter's name correctly. I respectfully thank you Nancy Grace
and your team. The way you guys pulled up respectfully,
asked me my name, ask me my daughter's name, and
asked how to pronounce it. I respectfully thank you for that.
(18:34):
I wanted to tell you that first of all and foremost.
Speaker 6 (18:37):
Because a lot of these a lot of people.
Speaker 7 (18:39):
Are pulling up and being disrespectful, and this is my
own community.
Speaker 6 (18:42):
The mayor, the chief executive. They have not pulled up
to my front porch.
Speaker 7 (18:46):
They have not told me they're sorry, they have not
sent their conposis. They're on the news talking stop and
the community are the members who found my daughter's remains
and other items the second and third and the foe time.
They the public was not doing a job the first
time correctly for the community to keep kind of stuff
and doing their own search parties.
Speaker 1 (19:07):
Because I'm too weak to go out there and search
for my daughter.
Speaker 6 (19:10):
I'm sorry, Nancy, Don't be sorry.
Speaker 1 (19:13):
Don't be sorry.
Speaker 2 (19:15):
You're right and I got to tell you something, Miss Scarborough.
Guys you were hearing Chade's mother. I always do that
every case, and I did it with every case I
ever investigated a prosecuted.
Speaker 1 (19:28):
And this is.
Speaker 2 (19:29):
Why this may mean something to you, Miss Scarborough, because
when my fiancee was murdered at his funeral, it didn't
make me angry or mad, but I remember in the
middle of the funeral.
Speaker 1 (19:41):
I noticed it.
Speaker 2 (19:43):
The pastor kept referring to me as Mary throughout Keith's entire.
Speaker 1 (19:49):
Funeral, over and over and over. I mean, I wasn't.
Speaker 2 (19:52):
Angry, but I remember it to this day, and it's
just one of those things that just stick with you.
I know you don't care what any of these politicians say,
but for Pete's sake, at least get the name right.
Speaker 1 (20:08):
At least do that much.
Speaker 2 (20:10):
Guys we're talking about is so hard for everybody on
this panel to talk about this with Chadai's mom with us,
But she says she wants to justice and justice comes
at a price, let me tell you that, and that
price is suffering, and she is suffering right now. But
I'm going to talk about these facts because these facts
(20:34):
are what I pray to God. Are going to put
the son of a Milwaukee millionaire behind bars.
Speaker 1 (20:41):
For life because I believe in DNA.
Speaker 2 (20:44):
DNA cannot lie, science cannot lie. Joe Scott Morgan, we
just heard very upsetting details about fingernail and toenail polish
on the remains guys. Joseph Scott Morgan, renowned professor of
forensics Jacksonville State University, which has an incredible criminal justice program.
(21:07):
We've re enacted several crimes together. He is a professor forensics.
He is the author of Blood Beneath My Feet on Amazon,
and now he's the host of a hit series, Body
Bags with Joe Scott Morgan. Joe Scott, you know, we
talk about DNA all the time, how you can match
(21:28):
this and that, and every.
Speaker 1 (21:31):
Action has a reaction and leaves a trace.
Speaker 2 (21:34):
But when it comes down to human talk, like the
color of Chade's tonyill polish matches the color of her
fingernail polish, we're talking about a severed leg. Somebody at
the medical examiners went, look the polish matches.
Speaker 1 (21:53):
I don't need DNA. A jury's not gonna need DNA,
but they're gonna have it.
Speaker 12 (21:58):
Why because every contact, as you mentioned, does in fact
leave a trace. We've known that for over one hundred
years now, and it's coming to fruition here in the
world in which we inhabit. You know, you think about
things like tool marks and all these other identifiers fingerprints traditionally,
But DNA is going to play a big role in this,
and we're talking about proximity Nancy. With the alleged perpetrator here,
(22:23):
he will have had a very intimate contact, unfortunately, with Shade.
My apologies, missus Scarborough. I know that this is very painful,
but there will have been an intimate contact on some level.
Just this idea of dismemberment alone is going to leave
a trace behind, and it's not necessarily his trace on
(22:46):
her as much as it will be her trace on
him potentially, and ultimately it could be her shade that
actually brings him to justice. That's one redemptive point along this,
because her DNA will be found on him and it
(23:07):
will be pointing a big, accusing finger back at him.
Speaker 13 (23:11):
On Wednesday, April the fourth, our investigation led to a
person of interest, Maxwell Stephen Anderson, who lives in the
thirty one hundred block of South thirty ninth Street, where
He was arrested after a traffic stop near the home.
(23:32):
A search warrant was conducted.
Speaker 11 (23:35):
That search warrant unearthed evidence of blood in the home.
Investigators reportedly found blood on a comforter and on the
wall of a stairwell leading down to the basement. No
details have been released on whose blood was recovered.
Speaker 2 (23:47):
You were just hearing the Milwaukee City Sheriff Danita Ball
and Sydney Sumner chronell line.
Speaker 1 (23:54):
Not only did blood evidence.
Speaker 2 (23:57):
Emerge in his home, this guy, this idiot technical legal term,
left a phone trail.
Speaker 1 (24:07):
A mile white.
Speaker 2 (24:08):
You know, when you look at his home, you think, wow,
beautiful yard, immaculately kept.
Speaker 1 (24:15):
You know why not because of him?
Speaker 2 (24:18):
Thirty three year old former high school football star. He's
a nepo baby, nepotism baby. This thirty three year old guy,
Maxwell Anderson has a millionaire dad who ran a Milwaukee
insurance brokerage firm. Now what do we know about him?
(24:40):
Alexis Tereschuk, He.
Speaker 1 (24:42):
Has a rap sheet.
Speaker 9 (24:43):
He has been arrested for domestic I'm sorry, not just arrested,
convicted for domestic abuse, for disorderly conduct, and for drunk driving.
This guy has a rap sheet. A mile long. He
is not an upstanding citizen of the community. And as
I said, these are not just arrests we're waiting to
hear from. He has been convicted of all three of
(25:04):
these things.
Speaker 2 (25:04):
Did you just say he's not an upstanding member of
the community.
Speaker 1 (25:08):
You know what?
Speaker 12 (25:10):
That is?
Speaker 2 (25:11):
Certainly putting perfume on the pig. Guys, listen to Sidney
Sumner Crime Online following what Alexis has just told us.
Speaker 11 (25:20):
Growing up the son of a millionaire businessman, Maxwell Anderson
was a Catholic school prep football star with a bright future.
Anderson works for his millionaire dad's insurance companies with limited success,
but when his father moves to Florida, Anderson's days in
Milwaukee working as a bartender. A former co worker of Anderson,
Samantha Brenner, describes Anderson as erratic, sometimes getting drunk while
(25:41):
bartending at Victor's nightclub. A friend describes Anderson as childish
and having quite the temper.
Speaker 2 (25:47):
Joining me right now is renowned forensic psychologist and mediator
doctor John Adelatory now Delatory.
Speaker 1 (25:56):
No if it's to bartenders.
Speaker 2 (25:58):
My brilliant niece tended bar for a while while she
was in graduate school. Long story short, what do you
think this mom and dad are thinking about right now?
They pump all this money, all this time into their son.
It turns out to be a thirty three year old
(26:21):
abuser of alcohol, bully, tending bar erradically when he shows
up to work.
Speaker 14 (26:27):
Yeah, listen, they probably know who he is. And I'm
gonna be real frank with you here, Nancy. This isn't
the first person that he's done this too. Shade is
not the first person. This is someone who has a
long history and I'm not surprised to hear about a
rap she with disorderly conduct and domestic abuse. This is
not someone who just one day decides that he's going
(26:50):
to stock a nineteen year old and then dismember. This
isn't someone that does that. This is someone who has
been long planning and been engaging in problematics, escalating them
each time so that eventually he's comfortable with actually doing
the things that he's been fantasizing about. His parents knew
who he was, and they tried and they did whatever
(27:12):
it was that they tried and they did to get
him to not do those things, but ultimately he was
going to do it anyway.
Speaker 1 (27:18):
Let's have a little reality check.
Speaker 2 (27:20):
Alexi says he's not an upstanding citizen. Okay, Delaty, you're
also airbrushing the truth.
Speaker 1 (27:30):
Let me talk about this guy.
Speaker 2 (27:33):
Police find a foot apparent apparently human flesh at a playground,
pink nail polish matching up. In the home, they find blood,
gasoline containers, blood on a comforter, blood scattered throughout the home.
(27:58):
Let me tell you this, I'm I want to go
to you. Fattus with me. High profile trial lawyer, TV
legal analyst, founding partner of the Warner Fattest elite legal group, Eric.
I agree with Delatory. This isn't his first time at
the rodeo. You don't go from zero to one twenty
(28:22):
mph in two seconds. There has to be something some
revving up up to not only a murderer, but alluring,
luring her onto a day. How many times do you
think he watched her come in, have a drink, have dinner,
anything like that before he gets the guts up to say, hey,
(28:43):
would you like to go to dinner?
Speaker 1 (28:45):
He planned this.
Speaker 2 (28:47):
You think you go from zero to murder and dismemberment
and one night.
Speaker 1 (28:52):
Oh.
Speaker 2 (28:53):
I agree with miss Scarborough. This is not his first
time and dilatory. Hit the nail on the head about it, Eric.
Speaker 15 (29:00):
Yeah, Nancy, it's chilling to think about what was going
through Maxwell Anderson's mind allegedly as he appears to have
been preparing for this. You know, the details give rise
to a predatory nature here. There's a huge age gap, right,
and then there's also a friend who says that Maxwell
Anderson had a five foot by six foot deep hole.
Speaker 1 (29:20):
Dug in his backyard.
Speaker 15 (29:22):
And then we look at the rapidity how quickly this
turning from a murder to dismemberment in a like overnight.
That's not something that just happens on a whim in
my personal opinion, that's something that was planned out and
is just grotesque in terms of what we're learning.
Speaker 3 (29:40):
Anderson has his share of troubles with the law. He
gets violent with family in Colorado, steals a family member's car,
crashes into a patio, breaks his collarbone, gets misdemeanor charges
for that. While staying with a different relative, he refuses
to clean up after himself and win. The relatives try
to lay down the law, their ungrateful guest punches a
hole in the wall and breaks their cell phone. So
they can't call police for help. Maxill Anderson also has
(30:01):
two delegu eyes in the last ten years.
Speaker 2 (30:03):
Good Gravy Okay, Alexis Terraschuk. There's so much in this
guy's criminal history. Of course, he is presumed innocent until
proven guilty in the current case. You know, I'm looking
at a photo of him holding onto a strip and
a bus. Apparently the Milwaukee Transit captured the face of
(30:24):
the subject boarding and remaining on a bus. The booking
photo seems to be the same guy wearing the exact
clothing depicted on the subject who fled the scene of
the car arson, including a large ten backpack with ten
stripes that goes to corroborate the gas cans found in
(30:50):
his home. He is the guy, according to police, that
burned Shade's car that she worked so hard to.
Speaker 1 (30:58):
Buy all on her her.
Speaker 2 (31:00):
Own, holding down two jobs while going to college.
Speaker 9 (31:04):
There was an eyewitness to the burning of the car.
As Shade's mother said, this community did everything when it happened.
The eyewitness said they saw a man in a jacket
with a backpack closed the door of this Honda and
flick a lighter into the car and it burst into flames,
so the person started screaming he did that, he did that,
(31:25):
he did that, and he ran away. That person contacted
the police to tell them about being the actual eyewitness
to him burning it. This was absolutely the community being
on their high alert and really helping out here.
Speaker 1 (31:45):
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 5 (31:51):
A neighbor's security camera shows two figures entering Anderson's backyard
at nine twenty four pm. At twelve forty seven am,
a street camera shows Robinson's car departing Anderson's home. A
camera at Cutahey High School shows a car drive towards
the pumphouse at Warnamont Park at two fifty three am.
A figure is seen walking from the road and climbing
(32:13):
down the bluff to the beach several times. At four
thirty one am, the car leaves the park. Three hours later,
bus surveillance catches a man carrying a tan backpack walking
away from a fire at thirtieth and Lisbon. At eight
twelve am, Anderson, carrying a tan backpack, is seen boarding
(32:34):
a bus heading toward his home. Anderson gets off at
eight thirty five am and enters his backyard eight minutes later.
Speaker 2 (32:43):
Two Joseph Scott Morgan, Professor Forensics, Jacksonville State, Joe Scott,
what do you believe those ten backpacks are going to reveal?
And how is the search of the backpacks? And I
don't mean open the backpack and take everything out, I
mean the forensics of the backpacks.
Speaker 1 (33:01):
What is that search going to reveal?
Speaker 12 (33:03):
They're going to take that thing apart, piece by piece, Nancy,
And I can tell you down deep in those fibers,
you're going to find DNA evidence. You'll be able to
actually see perhaps body fluids, and I'm talking about blood
just with the unaided eye that might actually appear as
they are actually taking the thing apart and looking at it.
(33:24):
And they need to and they need to take a
look at all I mean all of his clothing in
that house. I you know, I got to join in
in Unison. I got to join Miss Scarborough in Unison
on this, on this particular point, and you as well, Nancy.
I think that this place should be locked down and
(33:45):
every square inch of it has to be examined. I
mean gone through with a fine tooth comb, because I
don't think this is his first rodeo. You do not
get to this level of violence. And I'm talking about
post mortem violence here just instantaneously doesn't happen like this.
(34:05):
This almost seems practiced in one level. You have to
have the tools, you have to have the ability. Now
in that basement down there, that's going to be a
treasure trove of biological evidence. My curiosity is peaqued in
the sense is do we have any kind of layering
of evidence there are there any other biological samples down
there that are not necessarily belonging to those of Shahda.
(34:29):
Have any other potential victims been down there at any
potential time? I think that that's very important. Here.
Speaker 2 (34:35):
Can I throw a scenario jumping off what Joe Scott
Morgan is saying to Eric Fattus, everybody jump in, please,
we need all of your brain power.
Speaker 1 (34:45):
Eric Fattus, think about it.
Speaker 2 (34:47):
You just told us that in the purp, the alleged
purpose backyard, there was a grave Doug, I mean a
full on grave five feet I believe you said, what
person does this? You have murdered at tained girl and
you dig a grave in the backyard and then you think,
(35:10):
oh wait, you know what, never mind, I'll just go
through a very lengthy dismemberment and then I'll scatter this
little girl's remains all across Milwaukee and he nobody will
piece it together.
Speaker 1 (35:21):
Well, he was wrong.
Speaker 2 (35:22):
My point is, Eric Fattis, was that grave for somebody else?
What else is in that backyard or in his childhood
home backyard?
Speaker 1 (35:33):
I mean, what has this guy been up to?
Speaker 15 (35:36):
Yeah, I mean that's the alarming prospect here is for
whom was he digging this five foot by six foot
grave in his own backyard? You know, his friends were
talked to and a lot of them said that they
had a creepy, weird vibe, he had erratic behavior, he
may have had an alcohol issue. And then we look
at you know, there are gas canisters found in his
home that he just quickly turns from date to homicide
(35:59):
to dismant to scattering human remains all across Milwaukee. It's
just not something that happens on spur of the moment.
Speaker 11 (36:05):
Nancy family and friends of shaw Day Robinson are still
looking for her remains, basing their searches where Robinson's phone pinged.
Volunteers canvas the bluffs and beach near Warnamont Park. There
have been no reports of law enforcement searching the area
of Kern and Pleasant Valley Park, where Robinson's phone pinged
before it traveled south to Warnamont. Both Kern and Pleasant
(36:26):
Valley have access to the Milwaukee River, where Anderson could
have scattered more remains. The family says they will not
stop searching until Robinson is found and can be properly
laid to rest too.
Speaker 2 (36:37):
Doctor John Delatory joining US renowned psychologist and mediator. Doctor Delatory,
I don't get it. A guy that is born with
a silver spoon in his mouth, sent to a fancy
Catholic school, football star and high school. You know those
people that their glory days were when they were in
(36:57):
the ninth grade.
Speaker 1 (37:00):
That's him.
Speaker 2 (37:02):
Then his dad gives him a job through nepotism within
the insurance company, the insurance brokerage company that the dad owns.
That didn't last long. Then he wanders around and ends
up bartending after several, let me say, brushes with the law.
That whole place, his whole house needs to be taken
(37:25):
apart the way Rex Huerman's home was the Long Island
serial killer suspect and searched because I'm not completely convinced
that that grave he dug in the backyard was meant
for this teen girl, This beautiful teen girl, shah Dave Robinson.
Speaker 1 (37:45):
So what else will we learn?
Speaker 2 (37:46):
So my question to you, doctor delatorious, how do you
go from a silver spoon in your mouth to three
hots and a cot and an orange jumpsuit?
Speaker 14 (37:54):
It takes a long time. Again, this isn't someone people
don't just snap right, that's a complete misnown or people
don't now. This is years of him building up to
get to this point. Now he's explored other ways in
which he's going to be engaging in violent acts, whether
it's using alcohol or whether it's domestic violence, intimate partner violence.
Speaker 1 (38:13):
Right. But it's not just this house.
Speaker 14 (38:15):
It's any place where the family used to live, or
property that the family would own, anything that he had
access to. This is someone who wants to be comfortable
when he's engaging in these violent acts, using the properties
that he already knows provides that sense of comfort, and
then he likes to flash it. As we see, this
isn't just disposing of body parts. He's putting it out
(38:38):
in places for people to see, for people to get scared.
This is someone who wants to be known for engaging
in these kinds of violent acts.
Speaker 1 (38:46):
Miss Scarborough.
Speaker 2 (38:48):
You have not even been able to have a funeral
foreshaw Day yet, Is that correct?
Speaker 1 (38:54):
Why?
Speaker 16 (38:55):
Yes, that's correct, Nancy. This is probably the hardest all right,
that we're struggling with right now. I'm trying to find
peace laying my daughter to arrests gig all. This just
give her her transition as she deserves because she was
taken too soon. My baby was only she didn't even
(39:18):
make twenty. She was twenty in a few weeks. I
made it, Nancy.
Speaker 1 (39:22):
They don't.
Speaker 17 (39:23):
They can't even provide us with a death certificate right now.
They don't even know the calls of my daughter's death.
They don't know when. Like they're not giving me enough information, Nancy.
This is so frustrating. There is no closure right now
for me and my family and everybody have to plan things.
(39:44):
But I will be having a community gathering this Friday,
and I will be letting the community know where with time,
in the place and event it will be at in Milwaukee,
just to have a candlelight balloon release.
Speaker 6 (40:00):
Can not even plan a memorial for my daughter right now.
Speaker 2 (40:02):
Also, I want everybody to know that there will be
a fundraiser for shah Day's funeral go to justice for
shah Day and that is spelled s a d E
like you would say saved, like sage is pronounced Shahday.
(40:23):
Justice for shah Day, our fallen angel, Missus Scarborough. Before
we sign off, I just want you to know how
much we are praying for you and thinking about you
and your whole family, and we will not rest until
(40:44):
her killer gets the maximum sentence in that jurisdiction, which
is life without parol. God, please be with Shahde's family.
Speaker 6 (40:56):
Thank you, thank you.
Speaker 2 (40:58):
This is.
Speaker 6 (41:02):
These are her earrings that came in the middle yesterday. Nancy.
I don't know if you can see.
Speaker 7 (41:06):
You had to go to my baby's place for the
first time and these came for her.
Speaker 6 (41:14):
These are her earrings and I have her earrings. These
are my baby. Series. Think this is so traumatic.
Speaker 1 (41:22):
You know what's so funny?
Speaker 2 (41:23):
Look what I've got My dad's shirt, my dad that
passed away.
Speaker 1 (41:29):
I don't know why.
Speaker 2 (41:30):
I just feel better having it with me, like your earrings. Guys,
let's just stop for one moment and remember an American hero,
police officer Michael Jensen, just twenty nine years old. Jensen's
shot in the line of duty Syracuse, New York, leaving
(41:53):
behind his loving parents and sweet sister, American hero police
officer Michael Jensen. I want to thank all of our
guests for being with us, specifically Hidey's mother, Missus Scarborough,
who suffered greatly to get Shaday's story out, and to
(42:16):
all our other guests, but especially to you for being
with us tonight and every night. Nancy Gray signing off,
good night friend,
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (00:07):
Breaking new Tonight, a crack in the disappearance and dismemberment
murder of a beautiful ten girl Shawdey Robinson did the
spoiled brat sun of a Milwaukee millionaire, Lure shaw Day
on a date turned murder.
Speaker 1 (00:28):
I'm Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (00:29):
This is Crime Stories and I want to thank you
for being with us.
Speaker 3 (00:32):
Five point thirty pm, April second, Cutahey Police respond to
a call along Lake Michigan at Warnemont Park, a popular
recreation area. A parkgoer reports finding a severed human leg.
According to a post from cuta Haey Sheriff's office, the
limb was found in or near the water east of
the golf course near the pump house. There are steep
cliffs leading to the shoreline in that area, and large
(00:55):
numbers of police canvassed the area and kept away gawkers.
Speaker 4 (00:58):
Three days after the Warnamont Park discovery, another call to
police about a severed body part. Eleven miles away from
the shores of Lake Michigan in a Milwaukee West Side neighborhood,
a body part is found at a playground. Within twenty
four hours, police respond to another call about the discovery
of human remains on Saturday, just a few blocks from
(01:19):
the same Westside Milwaukee area as Friday's discovery, police set
up a crime scene near a park.
Speaker 2 (01:26):
After a car is found on fire. Paired with a
pet tribute blanket found near some of the human remains,
police begin to focus on a beautiful young teen girl,
(01:48):
shaw Day Listen.
Speaker 5 (01:51):
Shade Robinson graduates with honors a semester early from Riverside
High School. She continues her education at Milwaukee Area Technical College,
working towards her a degree in criminal justice. In fact,
she's only a month away from graduating, but Robinson hasn't
been spending all her times in the books. She works
through high school and college at the Pizza Shuttle on
Milwaukee's Lower East Side. She makes such a difference at
(02:13):
work that her coworkers say Robinson is considered the heart
of Pizza Shuttle. Former owner Mark Gold says she is
the type of employee who never calls out and is
loved by customers and our coworkers. Robinson is heavily influenced
by her family, with many family members serving in the military.
Shade Robinson wants to look at career opportunities available for
her in the United States Air Force.
Speaker 2 (02:33):
Joining me is a very special guest, along with an
all star panel. Seriously the brain Trust, but just hearing
hold of Zapple speaking from crime online dot Com about Shade,
She's everything you want.
Speaker 1 (02:51):
Your child to pay.
Speaker 2 (02:53):
She's this fantastic student, she is working while she's going
to school, very close family, tons of relatives in the military,
and she is inspired to consider the US Air Force.
(03:16):
I mean, this is the.
Speaker 1 (03:18):
Girl we all want to have.
Speaker 2 (03:22):
I remember my grandmother. I would give her my school
picture every year and she could say, I can just
see see the mischief coming out of your eyes.
Speaker 1 (03:32):
Look at this girl. Can't you just see.
Speaker 2 (03:34):
The joy, just the love of life, crackling smart, just
beaming out of her. How in the world did she
collide cross paths with an alleged spoiled brat killer, the
(03:57):
son of a Milwaukee millionaire, a former ex high school
football star now a thirty something meters bartender.
Speaker 1 (04:11):
In addition to.
Speaker 2 (04:12):
Our all star panel of trial lawyer Eric Fattis, renowned psychologist,
doctor John Delatory, death investigator professor Joe Scott Morgan, and
investigative crime reporter Alexis Tereschuk. A special guest joining me.
This is Shawde's mother, Miss Gina Scarborough. You know, miss
(04:36):
Miss Scarborough. Whenever I have to travel for work, my
backpack is so heavy because I have all these mementos
of the twins.
Speaker 1 (04:44):
I carry with me and set up wherever I am.
Speaker 6 (04:48):
I know I heard you talking about your swins a lot.
Speaker 2 (04:50):
It's just killing me to think that you have this
picture instead of your girl.
Speaker 1 (04:56):
First of all, tell me about shaw Day Shady.
Speaker 6 (05:00):
This is beautiful, beautiful soul.
Speaker 7 (05:04):
I know that my kids were very special and different.
They my parents raised me, They raised us. We are
light workers. We put out positive energy, we exert we
help others. I'm a community advocate as a personal way
(05:26):
of my life, the way I live. I've worked for others.
I help others my whole life. I've raised my daughters
that way. My daughters have excelled. I have two daughters.
Speaker 8 (05:38):
This has called so much emotional effect to my family
or her. My parents who love my baby so much,
her grandparents, her uncles, her aunties are the community. Everyone
has pulled up. This has affected many people in Milwaukee.
I'm come here today.
Speaker 7 (05:58):
This is the hardest thing I would ever have to
do in my life to speak Shaddy's voice.
Speaker 6 (06:03):
Shadday was a beautiful soul. She was an amazing girl. Nancy.
Speaker 7 (06:08):
Everything he spoke is exactly what my daughter exerted. I
couldn't have asked for any better daughter. There was things
my daughter did that many adults were not even able
to accomplish in their lifetimes. And I'll be forty three
in a week. My birthday's life twenty seven Shoty's birthdays
(06:32):
on Mad the tenth. I had her on Mother's Day.
Speaker 6 (06:36):
The son of a.
Speaker 7 (06:37):
I'm gonna watch my language on this platform.
Speaker 6 (06:41):
But the son of a took my daughter from me
a month before. She's graduating with her Associate of Artist degree.
Speaker 7 (06:51):
She works so hard. She's a full time student. She
has two full time jobs. She has her own little
bachelor red apartment. She does to stay in a college
dorm campus. She has her own bacherette department. She has
her own car.
Speaker 6 (07:05):
She pays all of her own pills. This is trauma sizing, Nancy.
I never expect this is the pull up on my
front door. This is a normal.
Speaker 7 (07:18):
This is a twenty twenty four Jeffrey Dahmer. I need
him held accountable. I need justice for Shada. Hey, there
has been a lot of in the many black and
brown girls that I've been called missing in Milwaukee for
a moment, and all of them are going to be
held accountable now because they put they messed with the
(07:40):
wrong family, they mess with the wrong family.
Speaker 6 (07:44):
Because we're not gonna.
Speaker 7 (07:45):
Stick wide, and we're not gonna sit still, and we're
gonna call all of them out, and we're gonna speak
for the whole community, because I'm not about to sit
down and I'm not about to sit still on this one.
It's justice for Shada, Nancy. It's justice, Miss Scarborough.
Speaker 2 (08:00):
Like anything anything I or anybody on this panel could
say right now, it pales compared to what you just said.
And believe me, Miss Garborough, this story of Shahday has
(08:23):
not just touched people in Milwaukee.
Speaker 1 (08:26):
It has touched people around the world. And when you.
Speaker 2 (08:30):
Say you're not going to sit back, neither are we
until there is justice for your girl and the other
missing and murdered girls across Milwaukee. They're not all just missing,
they're dead. Many of them are dead exactly. Guys with
(08:54):
me is Shadai's mother, who is so much pain, but
she is joining us tonight to speak out for Shah Day.
Speaker 1 (09:08):
What happened? What led up to this night?
Speaker 6 (09:16):
Nancy. The last time I spoke to my daughter was
on Easter Sunday.
Speaker 7 (09:20):
Okay, we've seen her. She came by my parents' home.
We spent the Sunday together. This was Easter Sunday.
Speaker 6 (09:29):
Okay.
Speaker 7 (09:31):
I cooked for them, both of my daughters. We all
met by my parents' house where I'm currying the ad.
We all commute here. All my girls are busy. They're
my youngest is sixteen. They have a lot of activities.
They're working, they go to school. I have very successful
and independent, self sufficient darts. We harmy her nobody. We
(09:53):
just put out and help others into the universe.
Speaker 6 (09:56):
Okay. So I seen like she is. It's just very
It's like she's a nineteen twenty year old young lady.
Speaker 7 (10:04):
Okay, we all at this age. We have a lot
of friends. She's not in a relationship. She didn't have
a boyfriend. She wasn't tied down to anyone. She's single
and she's dating. I knew she hung out with her
coworkers at Pizza Shuttle. They went out to little bars
and hung out. Sometimes. I'm a very concerned mother. I'm
(10:24):
very overperspective. I always would put in shodday's ear, be careful.
I don't trust these people around Milwaukee. I'm just that
exercype of mom and my daughter's always mom.
Speaker 6 (10:36):
Just sit back. I try to give them space, let
them be independent.
Speaker 7 (10:40):
But I just been having this vibe and intuition and
I have been wanting her just to like not hang
out and.
Speaker 6 (10:46):
Go out to places for some reason.
Speaker 7 (10:49):
And I don't know exactly, and I'm still trying to
find out the facts, but I know that this type
of this individual, and I want to make clarity because
there's been a lot of trolls. There's been a lot
of media I can't interact and deal with. I'm grieving
my daughter right now. I want respects, I need time.
(11:10):
I'm gonna this is about advocating not only for my daughter,
but for all of the young women that are missing,
and for the actions to have been taken to find
my daughter. And there's a lot of information, but I
need the community and people to know that my daughter
helps others. She was a positive spirit. This this like
(11:33):
they they're claiming this was the first day, Like you know,
it's just a first day.
Speaker 6 (11:38):
I don't this dude, never she never mentioned this.
Speaker 1 (11:41):
Dude, Well, we're learning a little bit about that. Take
a listen to Dave Matt Crime Online.
Speaker 3 (11:47):
A month away from turning twenty, Shade Robinson tells a
maintenance worker at her building that she's excited about her
first date with thirty three year old Maxwell Anderson. Robinson
texts Anderson about where to eat and tells him she's seafood.
Anderson takesha day to a place he used to work,
the Twisted Fishermen. After dinner, they spend some more time together,
(12:07):
having drinks at Dukes on Water. The couple leaves Dukes
together around nine pm.
Speaker 1 (12:19):
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 2 (12:25):
Straight out to Alexis Tereshung, joining US Crime online dot
Com investigative reporter. I want to make sure that we're
right about that this was at most a first maybe
a second, but most likely a first date, probably nothing
that she was.
Speaker 1 (12:44):
Telling everybody about.
Speaker 2 (12:47):
Tell me how we know, Alexis that the two actually
went out because reports are in Our investigation tells us
that there may have been either surveillance footage or witnesses
placing them at Twisted Fishermen, where he worked, and then
(13:09):
later at Dukes on water. How do we know that
they were together that night they met there.
Speaker 9 (13:15):
There are multiple surveillance cameras outside these restaurants, both of them,
that show her arriving walking through the east side of
the restaurant. He arrived on the west side of There's
such good video footage of this. This is just such
a good helpful part of the case. They go there together.
He used to work there at the Twisted Fishermen. So
(13:36):
the bartender there spoke with police and said they came in,
they sat at the bar together, they had a drink.
It seemed friendly and casual, nothing that would alert the
bartender to anything that was wrong. He said, they just
had a few drinks and they left within an hour.
They then, according to surveillance, leave together surveillance videos to
(13:57):
the next place.
Speaker 2 (13:58):
Joining us an all star panel to make sense of
what we know right now. But to missus Scarborough, this
is shaw Day's mother, Miss Scarborough, when did you really
I know that right now you're at your parents' home.
Speaker 1 (14:12):
I know that shaw Day, as.
Speaker 2 (14:14):
You beautifully described it, had her own little bachelorette pad
that she paid for from her two jobs. She's working
while getting her college degree. Amazing So when did somebody
realize they needed to call you and ask where's shaw day?
Speaker 7 (14:35):
It wasn't until Wednesday, Nancy, I like you, It was
a whole twenty four hours. I just had this Billy again,
like we spent. The last time I seen her was
on that Sunday for Easter. Everything was good, it was
a normal family visit. We all had a good interaction.
Then Monday, she facetimed me. That morning Monday, she facetimed me.
(14:59):
She was getting ready for work and we had a
good interaction. She's like mommy, like you know, so I
had some more you know, like getting dressed.
Speaker 6 (15:07):
I was at my job. I went to work that morning,
I got off.
Speaker 7 (15:11):
As soon as I got home from work, I was
receiving calls from like my.
Speaker 6 (15:17):
My, my mother, and my brother. We were all concerned
because we.
Speaker 7 (15:20):
All have the three sixty location app. Okay, we all
shared it as the family. So I have the app
shared with me, my mom, both of my daughters. Then
my daughter also shares shut ay. My oldest daughter also
shares the app with additional friends and like other groups.
But I have my own group with her, myself, my mother,
(15:42):
and my youngest darter. So we've seen her like this
location Monday, like again, Monday night she I seen her
getting I mean Monday morning, I've seen her getting ready
for work.
Speaker 6 (15:54):
She facetimed me. Then she that evening around three forty.
Speaker 7 (15:58):
Five, four o'clock, I got a text message from her
asking a cash apt for fifteen dollars. My daughters does
not ask me for money like she has. My daughter
makes more money to me. Literally, she's that was that boss, okay,
So like those in a big bill, I'm just that
type of mom. You need something, I'm gonna cash appy.
It's very strange that she asked me for fifteen dollars.
Speaker 2 (16:20):
Yet you know what's very odd about that, Miss Scarborough.
It reminds me of when Gabby Petito went missing and
her family started getting texts that didn't sound like her.
For instance, she wrote about her grandfather. She texted about
her grandfather, but she called him.
Speaker 1 (16:38):
By his full name. That would be like me writing.
Speaker 2 (16:44):
My producer right here Jackie and going hi Jackie, how's
Jackie today?
Speaker 1 (16:48):
It just doesn't make any just wrong.
Speaker 2 (16:52):
So you get this test asking for fifteen dollars, and
Shade would never have done that.
Speaker 1 (16:57):
I mean, if she needed she.
Speaker 2 (16:59):
Got a charge Apple pay you name it so you
knew right then something was wrong and then this take
a listen to Chief Jeffrey Norman.
Speaker 10 (17:10):
Saturday April six, MPD continued the search of in the
area and located additional human remains on the railroad tracks.
Learn you know. Saturday April six, MPD returned to the
area when Miss Robinson's family located her blanket. At this time,
do you take thus located additional human remains.
Speaker 11 (17:32):
According to court documents, the remains found Saturday included human
flesh and a foot. The foot had pink nail polish,
possibly mounting the polish on the leg found days earlier.
Speaker 1 (17:43):
Another thing that reallyncy.
Speaker 6 (17:45):
Can I say something real quisly?
Speaker 1 (17:46):
Yes?
Speaker 7 (17:47):
Please do I just, I just I just want to
clarify that the community. I want to make this clear, okay,
and I'm going to be holding all accountable that have
been I'm not blaming or attacking people. There have been
to tech business sergeants that I've been pulling up selectively
on my team. There has been the community. There have
been active members advocating for this case. I know it
(18:08):
is affecting many, but there is some faulty things that
have been being handled.
Speaker 6 (18:12):
Okay, First of all, I want to.
Speaker 7 (18:14):
Correct all of the chief executives that are pulling up
from my county and my community that are not pronouncing
my daughter's name correctly. I respectfully thank you Nancy Grace
and your team. The way you guys pulled up respectfully,
asked me my name, ask me my daughter's name, and
asked how to pronounce it. I respectfully thank you for that.
(18:34):
I wanted to tell you that first of all and foremost.
Speaker 6 (18:37):
Because a lot of these a lot of people.
Speaker 7 (18:39):
Are pulling up and being disrespectful, and this is my
own community.
Speaker 6 (18:42):
The mayor, the chief executive. They have not pulled up
to my front porch.
Speaker 7 (18:46):
They have not told me they're sorry, they have not
sent their conposis. They're on the news talking stop and
the community are the members who found my daughter's remains
and other items the second and third and the foe time.
They the public was not doing a job the first
time correctly for the community to keep kind of stuff
and doing their own search parties.
Speaker 1 (19:07):
Because I'm too weak to go out there and search
for my daughter.
Speaker 6 (19:10):
I'm sorry, Nancy, Don't be sorry.
Speaker 1 (19:13):
Don't be sorry.
Speaker 2 (19:15):
You're right and I got to tell you something, Miss Scarborough.
Guys you were hearing Chade's mother. I always do that
every case, and I did it with every case I
ever investigated a prosecuted.
Speaker 1 (19:28):
And this is.
Speaker 2 (19:29):
Why this may mean something to you, Miss Scarborough, because
when my fiancee was murdered at his funeral, it didn't
make me angry or mad, but I remember in the
middle of the funeral.
Speaker 1 (19:41):
I noticed it.
Speaker 2 (19:43):
The pastor kept referring to me as Mary throughout Keith's entire.
Speaker 1 (19:49):
Funeral, over and over and over. I mean, I wasn't.
Speaker 2 (19:52):
Angry, but I remember it to this day, and it's
just one of those things that just stick with you.
I know you don't care what any of these politicians say,
but for Pete's sake, at least get the name right.
Speaker 1 (20:08):
At least do that much.
Speaker 2 (20:10):
Guys we're talking about is so hard for everybody on
this panel to talk about this with Chadai's mom with us,
But she says she wants to justice and justice comes
at a price, let me tell you that, and that
price is suffering, and she is suffering right now. But
I'm going to talk about these facts because these facts
(20:34):
are what I pray to God. Are going to put
the son of a Milwaukee millionaire behind bars.
Speaker 1 (20:41):
For life because I believe in DNA.
Speaker 2 (20:44):
DNA cannot lie, science cannot lie. Joe Scott Morgan, we
just heard very upsetting details about fingernail and toenail polish
on the remains guys. Joseph Scott Morgan, renowned professor of
forensics Jacksonville State University, which has an incredible criminal justice program.
(21:07):
We've re enacted several crimes together. He is a professor forensics.
He is the author of Blood Beneath My Feet on Amazon,
and now he's the host of a hit series, Body
Bags with Joe Scott Morgan. Joe Scott, you know, we
talk about DNA all the time, how you can match
(21:28):
this and that, and every.
Speaker 1 (21:31):
Action has a reaction and leaves a trace.
Speaker 2 (21:34):
But when it comes down to human talk, like the
color of Chade's tonyill polish matches the color of her
fingernail polish, we're talking about a severed leg. Somebody at
the medical examiners went, look the polish matches.
Speaker 1 (21:53):
I don't need DNA. A jury's not gonna need DNA,
but they're gonna have it.
Speaker 12 (21:58):
Why because every contact, as you mentioned, does in fact
leave a trace. We've known that for over one hundred
years now, and it's coming to fruition here in the
world in which we inhabit. You know, you think about
things like tool marks and all these other identifiers fingerprints traditionally,
But DNA is going to play a big role in this,
and we're talking about proximity Nancy. With the alleged perpetrator here,
(22:23):
he will have had a very intimate contact, unfortunately, with Shade.
My apologies, missus Scarborough. I know that this is very painful,
but there will have been an intimate contact on some level.
Just this idea of dismemberment alone is going to leave
a trace behind, and it's not necessarily his trace on
(22:46):
her as much as it will be her trace on
him potentially, and ultimately it could be her shade that
actually brings him to justice. That's one redemptive point along this,
because her DNA will be found on him and it
(23:07):
will be pointing a big, accusing finger back at him.
Speaker 13 (23:11):
On Wednesday, April the fourth, our investigation led to a
person of interest, Maxwell Stephen Anderson, who lives in the
thirty one hundred block of South thirty ninth Street, where
He was arrested after a traffic stop near the home.
(23:32):
A search warrant was conducted.
Speaker 11 (23:35):
That search warrant unearthed evidence of blood in the home.
Investigators reportedly found blood on a comforter and on the
wall of a stairwell leading down to the basement. No
details have been released on whose blood was recovered.
Speaker 2 (23:47):
You were just hearing the Milwaukee City Sheriff Danita Ball
and Sydney Sumner chronell line.
Speaker 1 (23:54):
Not only did blood evidence.
Speaker 2 (23:57):
Emerge in his home, this guy, this idiot technical legal term,
left a phone trail.
Speaker 1 (24:07):
A mile white.
Speaker 2 (24:08):
You know, when you look at his home, you think, wow,
beautiful yard, immaculately kept.
Speaker 1 (24:15):
You know why not because of him?
Speaker 2 (24:18):
Thirty three year old former high school football star. He's
a nepo baby, nepotism baby. This thirty three year old guy,
Maxwell Anderson has a millionaire dad who ran a Milwaukee
insurance brokerage firm. Now what do we know about him?
(24:40):
Alexis Tereschuk, He.
Speaker 1 (24:42):
Has a rap sheet.
Speaker 9 (24:43):
He has been arrested for domestic I'm sorry, not just arrested,
convicted for domestic abuse, for disorderly conduct, and for drunk driving.
This guy has a rap sheet. A mile long. He
is not an upstanding citizen of the community. And as
I said, these are not just arrests we're waiting to
hear from. He has been convicted of all three of
(25:04):
these things.
Speaker 2 (25:04):
Did you just say he's not an upstanding member of
the community.
Speaker 1 (25:08):
You know what?
Speaker 12 (25:10):
That is?
Speaker 2 (25:11):
Certainly putting perfume on the pig. Guys, listen to Sidney
Sumner Crime Online following what Alexis has just told us.
Speaker 11 (25:20):
Growing up the son of a millionaire businessman, Maxwell Anderson
was a Catholic school prep football star with a bright future.
Anderson works for his millionaire dad's insurance companies with limited success,
but when his father moves to Florida, Anderson's days in
Milwaukee working as a bartender. A former co worker of Anderson,
Samantha Brenner, describes Anderson as erratic, sometimes getting drunk while
(25:41):
bartending at Victor's nightclub. A friend describes Anderson as childish
and having quite the temper.
Speaker 2 (25:47):
Joining me right now is renowned forensic psychologist and mediator
doctor John Adelatory now Delatory.
Speaker 1 (25:56):
No if it's to bartenders.
Speaker 2 (25:58):
My brilliant niece tended bar for a while while she
was in graduate school. Long story short, what do you
think this mom and dad are thinking about right now?
They pump all this money, all this time into their son.
It turns out to be a thirty three year old
(26:21):
abuser of alcohol, bully, tending bar erradically when he shows
up to work.
Speaker 14 (26:27):
Yeah, listen, they probably know who he is. And I'm
gonna be real frank with you here, Nancy. This isn't
the first person that he's done this too. Shade is
not the first person. This is someone who has a
long history and I'm not surprised to hear about a
rap she with disorderly conduct and domestic abuse. This is
not someone who just one day decides that he's going
(26:50):
to stock a nineteen year old and then dismember. This
isn't someone that does that. This is someone who has
been long planning and been engaging in problematics, escalating them
each time so that eventually he's comfortable with actually doing
the things that he's been fantasizing about. His parents knew
who he was, and they tried and they did whatever
(27:12):
it was that they tried and they did to get
him to not do those things, but ultimately he was
going to do it anyway.
Speaker 1 (27:18):
Let's have a little reality check.
Speaker 2 (27:20):
Alexi says he's not an upstanding citizen. Okay, Delaty, you're
also airbrushing the truth.
Speaker 1 (27:30):
Let me talk about this guy.
Speaker 2 (27:33):
Police find a foot apparent apparently human flesh at a playground,
pink nail polish matching up. In the home, they find blood,
gasoline containers, blood on a comforter, blood scattered throughout the home.
(27:58):
Let me tell you this, I'm I want to go
to you. Fattus with me. High profile trial lawyer, TV
legal analyst, founding partner of the Warner Fattest elite legal group, Eric.
I agree with Delatory. This isn't his first time at
the rodeo. You don't go from zero to one twenty
(28:22):
mph in two seconds. There has to be something some
revving up up to not only a murderer, but alluring,
luring her onto a day. How many times do you
think he watched her come in, have a drink, have dinner,
anything like that before he gets the guts up to say, hey,
(28:43):
would you like to go to dinner?
Speaker 1 (28:45):
He planned this.
Speaker 2 (28:47):
You think you go from zero to murder and dismemberment
and one night.
Speaker 1 (28:52):
Oh.
Speaker 2 (28:53):
I agree with miss Scarborough. This is not his first
time and dilatory. Hit the nail on the head about it, Eric.
Speaker 15 (29:00):
Yeah, Nancy, it's chilling to think about what was going
through Maxwell Anderson's mind allegedly as he appears to have
been preparing for this. You know, the details give rise
to a predatory nature here. There's a huge age gap, right,
and then there's also a friend who says that Maxwell
Anderson had a five foot by six foot deep hole.
Speaker 1 (29:20):
Dug in his backyard.
Speaker 15 (29:22):
And then we look at the rapidity how quickly this
turning from a murder to dismemberment in a like overnight.
That's not something that just happens on a whim in
my personal opinion, that's something that was planned out and
is just grotesque in terms of what we're learning.
Speaker 3 (29:40):
Anderson has his share of troubles with the law. He
gets violent with family in Colorado, steals a family member's car,
crashes into a patio, breaks his collarbone, gets misdemeanor charges
for that. While staying with a different relative, he refuses
to clean up after himself and win. The relatives try
to lay down the law, their ungrateful guest punches a
hole in the wall and breaks their cell phone. So
they can't call police for help. Maxill Anderson also has
(30:01):
two delegu eyes in the last ten years.
Speaker 2 (30:03):
Good Gravy Okay, Alexis Terraschuk. There's so much in this
guy's criminal history. Of course, he is presumed innocent until
proven guilty in the current case. You know, I'm looking
at a photo of him holding onto a strip and
a bus. Apparently the Milwaukee Transit captured the face of
(30:24):
the subject boarding and remaining on a bus. The booking
photo seems to be the same guy wearing the exact
clothing depicted on the subject who fled the scene of
the car arson, including a large ten backpack with ten
stripes that goes to corroborate the gas cans found in
(30:50):
his home. He is the guy, according to police, that
burned Shade's car that she worked so hard to.
Speaker 1 (30:58):
Buy all on her her.
Speaker 2 (31:00):
Own, holding down two jobs while going to college.
Speaker 9 (31:04):
There was an eyewitness to the burning of the car.
As Shade's mother said, this community did everything when it happened.
The eyewitness said they saw a man in a jacket
with a backpack closed the door of this Honda and
flick a lighter into the car and it burst into flames,
so the person started screaming he did that, he did that,
(31:25):
he did that, and he ran away. That person contacted
the police to tell them about being the actual eyewitness
to him burning it. This was absolutely the community being
on their high alert and really helping out here.
Speaker 1 (31:45):
Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Speaker 5 (31:51):
A neighbor's security camera shows two figures entering Anderson's backyard
at nine twenty four pm. At twelve forty seven am,
a street camera shows Robinson's car departing Anderson's home. A
camera at Cutahey High School shows a car drive towards
the pumphouse at Warnamont Park at two fifty three am.
A figure is seen walking from the road and climbing
(32:13):
down the bluff to the beach several times. At four
thirty one am, the car leaves the park. Three hours later,
bus surveillance catches a man carrying a tan backpack walking
away from a fire at thirtieth and Lisbon. At eight
twelve am, Anderson, carrying a tan backpack, is seen boarding
(32:34):
a bus heading toward his home. Anderson gets off at
eight thirty five am and enters his backyard eight minutes later.
Speaker 2 (32:43):
Two Joseph Scott Morgan, Professor Forensics, Jacksonville State, Joe Scott,
what do you believe those ten backpacks are going to reveal?
And how is the search of the backpacks? And I
don't mean open the backpack and take everything out, I
mean the forensics of the backpacks.
Speaker 1 (33:01):
What is that search going to reveal?
Speaker 12 (33:03):
They're going to take that thing apart, piece by piece, Nancy,
And I can tell you down deep in those fibers,
you're going to find DNA evidence. You'll be able to
actually see perhaps body fluids, and I'm talking about blood
just with the unaided eye that might actually appear as
they are actually taking the thing apart and looking at it.
(33:24):
And they need to and they need to take a
look at all I mean all of his clothing in
that house. I you know, I got to join in
in Unison. I got to join Miss Scarborough in Unison
on this, on this particular point, and you as well, Nancy.
I think that this place should be locked down and
(33:45):
every square inch of it has to be examined. I
mean gone through with a fine tooth comb, because I
don't think this is his first rodeo. You do not
get to this level of violence. And I'm talking about
post mortem violence here just instantaneously doesn't happen like this.
(34:05):
This almost seems practiced in one level. You have to
have the tools, you have to have the ability. Now
in that basement down there, that's going to be a
treasure trove of biological evidence. My curiosity is peaqued in
the sense is do we have any kind of layering
of evidence there are there any other biological samples down
there that are not necessarily belonging to those of Shahda.
(34:29):
Have any other potential victims been down there at any
potential time? I think that that's very important. Here.
Speaker 2 (34:35):
Can I throw a scenario jumping off what Joe Scott
Morgan is saying to Eric Fattus, everybody jump in, please,
we need all of your brain power.
Speaker 1 (34:45):
Eric Fattus, think about it.
Speaker 2 (34:47):
You just told us that in the purp, the alleged
purpose backyard, there was a grave Doug, I mean a
full on grave five feet I believe you said, what
person does this? You have murdered at tained girl and
you dig a grave in the backyard and then you think,
(35:10):
oh wait, you know what, never mind, I'll just go
through a very lengthy dismemberment and then I'll scatter this
little girl's remains all across Milwaukee and he nobody will
piece it together.
Speaker 1 (35:21):
Well, he was wrong.
Speaker 2 (35:22):
My point is, Eric Fattis, was that grave for somebody else?
What else is in that backyard or in his childhood
home backyard?
Speaker 1 (35:33):
I mean, what has this guy been up to?
Speaker 15 (35:36):
Yeah, I mean that's the alarming prospect here is for
whom was he digging this five foot by six foot
grave in his own backyard? You know, his friends were
talked to and a lot of them said that they
had a creepy, weird vibe, he had erratic behavior, he
may have had an alcohol issue. And then we look
at you know, there are gas canisters found in his
home that he just quickly turns from date to homicide
(35:59):
to dismant to scattering human remains all across Milwaukee. It's
just not something that happens on spur of the moment.
Speaker 11 (36:05):
Nancy family and friends of shaw Day Robinson are still
looking for her remains, basing their searches where Robinson's phone pinged.
Volunteers canvas the bluffs and beach near Warnamont Park. There
have been no reports of law enforcement searching the area
of Kern and Pleasant Valley Park, where Robinson's phone pinged
before it traveled south to Warnamont. Both Kern and Pleasant
(36:26):
Valley have access to the Milwaukee River, where Anderson could
have scattered more remains. The family says they will not
stop searching until Robinson is found and can be properly
laid to rest too.
Speaker 2 (36:37):
Doctor John Delatory joining US renowned psychologist and mediator. Doctor Delatory,
I don't get it. A guy that is born with
a silver spoon in his mouth, sent to a fancy
Catholic school, football star and high school. You know those
people that their glory days were when they were in
(36:57):
the ninth grade.
Speaker 1 (37:00):
That's him.
Speaker 2 (37:02):
Then his dad gives him a job through nepotism within
the insurance company, the insurance brokerage company that the dad owns.
That didn't last long. Then he wanders around and ends
up bartending after several, let me say, brushes with the law.
That whole place, his whole house needs to be taken
(37:25):
apart the way Rex Huerman's home was the Long Island
serial killer suspect and searched because I'm not completely convinced
that that grave he dug in the backyard was meant
for this teen girl, This beautiful teen girl, shah Dave Robinson.
Speaker 1 (37:45):
So what else will we learn?
Speaker 2 (37:46):
So my question to you, doctor delatorious, how do you
go from a silver spoon in your mouth to three
hots and a cot and an orange jumpsuit?
Speaker 14 (37:54):
It takes a long time. Again, this isn't someone people
don't just snap right, that's a complete misnown or people
don't now. This is years of him building up to
get to this point. Now he's explored other ways in
which he's going to be engaging in violent acts, whether
it's using alcohol or whether it's domestic violence, intimate partner violence.
Speaker 1 (38:13):
Right. But it's not just this house.
Speaker 14 (38:15):
It's any place where the family used to live, or
property that the family would own, anything that he had
access to. This is someone who wants to be comfortable
when he's engaging in these violent acts, using the properties
that he already knows provides that sense of comfort, and
then he likes to flash it. As we see, this
isn't just disposing of body parts. He's putting it out
(38:38):
in places for people to see, for people to get scared.
This is someone who wants to be known for engaging
in these kinds of violent acts.
Speaker 1 (38:46):
Miss Scarborough.
Speaker 2 (38:48):
You have not even been able to have a funeral
foreshaw Day yet, Is that correct?
Speaker 1 (38:54):
Why?
Speaker 16 (38:55):
Yes, that's correct, Nancy. This is probably the hardest all right,
that we're struggling with right now. I'm trying to find
peace laying my daughter to arrests gig all. This just
give her her transition as she deserves because she was
taken too soon. My baby was only she didn't even
(39:18):
make twenty. She was twenty in a few weeks. I
made it, Nancy.
Speaker 1 (39:22):
They don't.
Speaker 17 (39:23):
They can't even provide us with a death certificate right now.
They don't even know the calls of my daughter's death.
They don't know when. Like they're not giving me enough information, Nancy.
This is so frustrating. There is no closure right now
for me and my family and everybody have to plan things.
(39:44):
But I will be having a community gathering this Friday,
and I will be letting the community know where with time,
in the place and event it will be at in Milwaukee,
just to have a candlelight balloon release.
Speaker 6 (40:00):
Can not even plan a memorial for my daughter right now.
Speaker 2 (40:02):
Also, I want everybody to know that there will be
a fundraiser for shah Day's funeral go to justice for
shah Day and that is spelled s a d E
like you would say saved, like sage is pronounced Shahday.
(40:23):
Justice for shah Day, our fallen angel, Missus Scarborough. Before
we sign off, I just want you to know how
much we are praying for you and thinking about you
and your whole family, and we will not rest until
(40:44):
her killer gets the maximum sentence in that jurisdiction, which
is life without parol. God, please be with Shahde's family.
Speaker 6 (40:56):
Thank you, thank you.
Speaker 2 (40:58):
This is.
Speaker 6 (41:02):
These are her earrings that came in the middle yesterday. Nancy.
I don't know if you can see.
Speaker 7 (41:06):
You had to go to my baby's place for the
first time and these came for her.
Speaker 6 (41:14):
These are her earrings and I have her earrings. These
are my baby. Series. Think this is so traumatic.
Speaker 1 (41:22):
You know what's so funny?
Speaker 2 (41:23):
Look what I've got My dad's shirt, my dad that
passed away.
Speaker 1 (41:29):
I don't know why.
Speaker 2 (41:30):
I just feel better having it with me, like your earrings. Guys,
let's just stop for one moment and remember an American hero,
police officer Michael Jensen, just twenty nine years old. Jensen's
shot in the line of duty Syracuse, New York, leaving
(41:53):
behind his loving parents and sweet sister, American hero police
officer Michael Jensen. I want to thank all of our
guests for being with us, specifically Hidey's mother, Missus Scarborough,
who suffered greatly to get Shaday's story out, and to
(42:16):
all our other guests, but especially to you for being
with us tonight and every night. Nancy Gray signing off,
good night friend,
Host
Nancy Grace
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Intentionally Disturbing
Join me on this podcast as I navigate the murky waters of human behavior, current events, and personal anecdotes through in-depth interviews with incredible people—all served with a generous helping of sarcasm and satire. After years as a forensic and clinical psychologist, I offer a unique interview style and a low tolerance for bullshit, quickly steering conversations toward depth and darkness. I honor the seriousness while also appreciating wit. I’m your guide through the twisted labyrinth of the human psyche, armed with dark humor and biting wit.