Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
This is Alec Baldwin and you're listening to Here's the
Thing from My Heart Radio. When Kurt Anderson started working
on his new podcast, Nixon at War, he thought he
knew a fair amount about Richard Nixon's presidency, including two
defining experiences. His nineteen sixty eight campaign promised to end
(00:22):
the Vietnam War and his nineteen seventy three resignation due
to Watergate, devastating but unrelated events, or so he thought.
The surprising connection between those two are at the heart
of Nixon at War. You may know Kurt Anderson from
his award winning radio program Studio three sixty. He's a
(00:43):
prize winning novelist and historian whose three most recent books,
Evil Geniuses, Fantasy Land, and you Can't Spell America Without Me.
We're all New York Times bestsellers. Anderson says, to understand
Nixon's plans for Vietnam, you need to appreciate how much
was at stake for Nixon when he ran in nineteen
(01:05):
Richard Nixon, despite the fact that he was not a
beloved figure in America as vice president, he had a
very kind of meteoric young career. As a very young man,
had never really been in politics right out of World
War Two, was elected to the House in California, like
had promptly after two terms of the Senate in California,
before he had even had a couple of years in
the Senate, was picked the vice president by Dwight Eysmower.
(01:26):
And and so then of course he was going to
run for president in nineteen sixty and and barely lost,
but then lost again when he ran for governor of California.
So this incredible rise, this recent fall, and this is
a guy who never felt comfortable in his own skin
with the world, didn't like socializing. Was this weirdo, this resentful,
(01:51):
paranoid weirdo, who had done really well and now it
was all slipping away. This was his last chance. This
is his last chance to get back at the Kennedy
Ivy League elites who beating him in nineteen sixty He
moved to the heart of it, right and moved to
the upper East side of Manhattan after he got beaten
for the government of California. And and just right there
(02:11):
in the middle of it where everyone hated Hi murdered
and he hated them, but by god, he was gonna
do it. And and so this was this real then
Jean's field comeback attempt. That's where he is as as
a figure, I often think that someone is chosen as
vice president who can come in hand you to do
things the president won't do. Eisenhowerd was probably the last
(02:34):
president of the United States chosen by acclamation. Did not
want to be the president, was pressured into doing that.
Not a details guy at that point in his life,
wanted to go play golf and take it easy. So
he brings Nixon and by my lights to do the
dirty work. Who better the Nixons to do dirty work.
I mean, Eisenhoward needed somebody who was a political hitman
and enforcer. And so because he wasn't going to micromanage
(02:55):
that way, Eisenhower and Nixon cuts his teeth on Alger
Hiss and all this kind of pumpkin papers and all
this other stuff. He's an anti communist tool, if you will,
during a time when anti communism seemed too many people
in the country the right thing to be doing. My
favorite scene about the American nineteen fifties is in Manchurian
Candidate when Angela landsbois there with her husband and he says,
(03:18):
there are hundred five communists and the government. I said,
though a hundred forty five, how many other hundred eighty nine?
He just keeps changing the number right in the same
paragraph that he's talking, which is not unlike certain moments
in Joe McCarthy's real life where he was saying, you know,
he changed the number all the time. No, I mean,
(03:40):
you know, the Soviet Union having been our buddies in
World War Two, suddenly we're not our buddies, and suddenly
had the atomic bomb, and then the hydrogen bomb. Anti
communism got out of control and created McCarthyism. But it
wasn't it wasn't nuts to be frightened of the Soviet Union,
even though it went crazily too far. And yeah, Richard
Nixon saw this is how he could make his career
(04:01):
and did. And making an enemy of the people out
of aldra Hiss along with Jeheger Hoover in the around
nineteen fifty was the way he did it, and it worked.
And squishy soft Dwight Eisenhower, who by the way, and
won World War Two for the Islands. I'll pick this
anti communists, as you say, tool hitman to uh show
that he was good as an e communist, even though
(04:23):
that didn't stop the John Birch Society later in the
fifties into the sixties of claiming that Dwight Eisenhower was
a conscious stooge of the Soviet Union. Well, it's funny
when I think when you see Eisenhower, oh, PSC won
World War Two. Yes, but I always think Eisenhower's career,
even though you think that there's an inextricable link between
the military and the government at that point, there wasn't
(04:44):
necessarily one and and and the man that won World
War Two, of course exited the office in his farewell
speech warning about the creating the phrase military industrial complex papabah.
But what I was thinking is I see Eisenhower to
me as president was like as if Ted Williams was president.
It's like the guy that won all these games. He
was a hero, but he wasn't necessarily what we could
we equate now with the president as an executive. No,
(05:06):
and figurehead is unfair too, but he was. He was
a hero and then beat twice the same liberal elite
egghead and like Stevenson who was running against him. You
mentioned passingly in the piece about your own background, in
your own family and for your Republican household. Would you say,
when Nixon is elected in sixty eight, where are you well?
(05:28):
When Nixon's elected in sixty eight? Just fourteen? Your fourteen
and your parents were pro Nixon. Oh, definitely, I was
pro Nixon when I was thirteen. I was. I was
a little teenage republic I went to teenage Republican camp.
Had a had a poster of Nixon on my wall.
I wish I had photographs of that whole He had
a poster of Nixon on your wall. In terms of
(05:49):
decorating your room. You were like the Roger Stone of
your generation. I hate to say that a little bit,
but then again, you know, summer of sixty eight came.
My older brother and sisters took me in hand, and
by the fall I was a hippie. Now, comparatively speaking,
now you have how many siblings. That's you plus three,
It is me plus three. And the other ones were
(06:11):
more liberally inclined than they were older. So I was
the youngest and they've gone through the countercultural transformation ahead
of me. It was the one window where your siblings
were more politically evolved than you were. That didn't last long.
And then they definitely, definitely were politically culturally all that
they were, you know, fifteen eighteen one, so they were
(06:31):
into the late sixties. And and what happened to you
when you were four to I don't know. I smoked pot,
I started reading other books and other things than William F.
Buckley Jr. And Uh, I self radicalized like but no,
I but your parents did Republicans absolutely, although interestingly I
(06:53):
described the kinds of Nebraska Republicans my parents were, which
is to say atheists, big public radio enthusiasts, when when
public radio began, big environmentalists and and pro choice and
so on and so on. And my mother, who outlived
my father, finally left the Republican Party at the end
of the ninety nineties because it was no longer her party. Gasp.
(07:14):
Did she vote for Bill? She probably didn't vote for Bill,
but she started a Bob Terry, who was our senator,
was a sort of her entryway drug to becoming a
now sixty eight, I'm ten years old, big turning point
for me politically. Through the eyes of my father and
through the lens of his progressive he was a democratic
commitment in our town and so forth, through his eyes
(07:38):
and This is after Kennedy is killed, of course, so
everybody's just, you know, just just seething with emotion. Bobby
Bobby Kennedy. So we're watching the convention and it's like,
are you rooting for the Chicago police? Are you rooting
for the demonstrator? Who are you rooting for? My dad,
I was rooting for the protesters. He was an anti police.
He was a very, very middle of the road Democrat,
but he was rooting for the protesters. And I'm wondering,
what was that like for you? Were your parents rooting
(08:00):
for the Chicago cops. So they weren't. They were the
extinct species of decent liberal Republicans, although they considered themselves
conservative and we're kind of very Goldwater Fans back then.
But as the party moved right and they didn't, they
thought they didn't have a party. So, no, they weren't
in favor. Were the issues more important to them? Military?
Strong military was somewhat important, but conservation actually was a
(08:21):
huge thing for them, and actual liberty not to be
run by religious nuts, because they were anti religious, really,
and they wanted to live a free life with as
few you know, rules and regulations as possible. Really, and
my father also his his profession, he was a lawyer,
and and he his specialty was labor law, representing corporations
(08:44):
and management. And so he was not viciously anti union.
And in fact, subsequently school teachers against whom he negotiated
contracts had said to me since he died, like, you know,
your dad was always a decent guy, and he always
was fair and somebody managements well exactly, so I was
the opposite of a red diaper baby. You were a
boss baby something like that. You were suiting tie baby.
(09:09):
Well I wasn't. I didn't go that whole Alex Keaton thing. Ever,
although in retrospect, I guess you could you could see that.
I mean as no as a twelve thirty funeral. I
must have been an insufferable little dick, you know, with
my little Republican talking points. Pretty but as you mentioned,
I'm conveniently using you and your family to frame what
Republicanism was back then. You say Goldwater Republican on in
(09:31):
the heartland, but at first is New Yorker was Rockefeller right? Correct?
Were the whole thing? We're like, we don't give a
shit about abortion, we don't give a shit about you
want to order a gay wedding cake. Just lower my
taxes and cut the regulation on my business exactly. And
my parents were very pro civil rights, and my mother,
until she left the party, always referred to it as
the Party of Lincoln, the Party of Lincoln. We're the
Party of Lincoln. Everett Dirkson was was her and their hero, who,
(09:55):
by the way, helped Lennon Johnson passed the Civil Rights
Act and the Voting Rights Act. So you know, they
were economic conservatives, absolutely, and they believe in the strong military.
But all the other stuff, all the culture war stuff
that didn't know, which wasn't part of Republicanism very much
back then until Richard Nixon made it so was not
their cup of tea at all. Now, I don't expect
(10:17):
you to concur with me here, but before we launched
into Nixon full blown in the war, I want to
just go trace backwards and say that if Elsberg, who
himself was a self described hawk during the period prior
to the Pentagon Papers and working at RAND, eventually realized
that this policy is a catastrophic and immoral. But I'm
(10:39):
assuming that when the truth of the Pentagon Papers, when
the Rand Corporation submits their report that's around what year
sixty seven, no, sixty eight they finished, and it was
it was really right before Nickson mcame president that they finished.
So there was it was it safe to assume that
kind of information, that's specific cash of paperwork was not
made available to Johnson. Johnson did not know about the
(11:01):
Rand Report. Well, it was actually I mean Rand was
part of it, and Elbert worked for Rand, as you say, um,
but it was it was a Defense Department report, commission commission,
and so it was under commission under mcnamaraon LBJ and
finished under Clark Clifford and lb J. So yeah, Johnson
was very much aware of it. Did it go to him?
I don't actually know that, but it was secret, So,
(11:24):
but I'm always wondering, and I've said this to his
face to Bob Caro. You obviously have all this worship
of Johnson and his political acumen and the kind of
heft and the grandeur of his career and his position
in our history and how determinative was in our history
beyond Kennedy's death and sixty three and what he did
in those years. But let's face facts. At one point,
(11:45):
did he know that the Vietnam War was wrong anymoral
and why don't you call him on that? And I'm
wondering in the research you did, did Johnson know before
he left? Yes, he definitely did. I mean that we
have a bit of a phone call he had had
back in the nineteen sixties six, you know, with Eugene
McCarthy saying, I want to get out of it as
much as you do. Jeane hated you know, it's awful. Um.
(12:08):
I mean, he was not a you know, a moralist
in the in the Bobby Kennedy sense, say, you know,
but he knew it was a bad deal and he
made a mistake and he needed to get out. And
then you know, in sixty eight and as you hear
in this show with his conversations with Nixon and his
conversation with his Secretary of State Dean Russ and other
people like I will tell America I'm not running and
(12:28):
I got nine months to try to really start our
way out. Johnson wants to get out and Nixon doesn't
want to get out because he wants it to stay
so he can get us out. He could be the hero.
Well he wants to, Yes, he wants to. Nixon wants
it both ways. Nixon wants to get elected by saying,
these Democrats have met bungled this war, and I'll be
a tough minded guy who will finish it right and
(12:49):
and soon. But then when when peace is at hand
in the night, Nixon goes, oh, this is gonna beat me.
This is gonna elect Humbert Humphrey the vice president, and
we I gotta I gotta postpone this piece thing. So
explain to the listeners what's the thing. Johnson tells Nixon
in the phone call not to do that. Nixon does
well Johnson Johnson tells Nixon not to do multiple times.
(13:10):
Nixon says he's not going to do it multiple times
in the fall of sixty eight, which is talk and
and say I'll do a better deal for you South Vietnam.
I'll do a better deal for you North Vietnam. Elect me, everybody,
and I'll end this war because I won't have this
Johnson Kennedy baggage. And and he keeps quiet for a
little bit, but then he Nixon freaks out, thinks he's
(13:32):
gonna lose, and just like goes full Nixon and tries
to mess up these Paris piece talks to end the
Vietnam War had really started to take off and there
was about to be a big breakthrough, and Nixon didn't
want that to happen. A week or two, Well, he
does a lot of stuff. Most he does this thing
that he spent the rest of his life covering up.
(13:53):
He gets this fascinating woman named Anna Chenault, this Chinese
teenage reprovocateur. Well, but she's she deserves her own podcast,
she deserves her own biopic. Anyway. She meets this uh
as a nineteen hole reporter in China during World War Two,
meets this General Marrison. They moved to America. He dies
(14:14):
right away. She's rich. She's this glamorous, rich, anti communist,
right wing widow living at the Watergate like too good
to be true, and becomes Nixon's biggest female donor and finagler.
She also is good pals in her anti communist way
with the South. FETA music ambassador to the US introduces
(14:35):
the two of them at this secret meeting in the
summer of n at which Richard Nixon says, Okay, Mr Ambassador,
you and President too of South Vietnam. You've gotta understand
this woman your pal, and Channault is my person to you.
She she is my whatever I'm want you to do,
she's the person telling you that. And when a couple
(14:56):
of a few months later, when the election gets closed
and this and this He's breakthrough is about to happen,
he Nixon and Nixon's people set out what he called
the Dragon Lady to go tell too and the ambassador no, no, no, no,
don't go along with this piece deal. You gotta you
gotta make sure this doesn't have a better deal. When
we come in, you'll get and I'll owe you right.
(15:18):
And so don't make anything happen before November five. You know,
it reminds me of the whole hostage crisis with Carter.
And they go and they basically, if I'm not mistaken,
they do the same thing. Don't release the hostages to
weaken in there. We gotta get rid of Carter. Is
it similar? Well, is it's comparable. This was an ongoing war.
This wasn't a few dozen hostages. This was an ongoing
war where hundreds of Americans were dying every week. And
(15:40):
they're saying, let's extend this so I can get elected.
I mean, what's interesting to me about this part of
the story. It was eclipsed in history and in the
popular understanding by Watergate. But this is where it all began.
This is the thing he did which was illegal and
and a federal crime. Undoubtedly a citizen messing around with
(16:00):
foreign policy, you know, in this very specific way. And
then he was worried the rest of his time alive
and certainly as president, that this was going to come
out and uh lead to his downfall. So what did
he do? He committed burglaries that led to his downfall.
Author and podcaster Kurt Anderson. If you want to deep
(16:23):
dive on the Vietnam War, Ken Burns and Lynn Novic's
eighteen hour documentary is a good place to start. Ken
Burns told me he screened a final version for Senator
John McCain, a decorated pow who was particularly fascinated by
the interviews with North Vietnamese soldiers. What you begin to
(16:43):
realize is that at that point of combat, which is
where human beings are at their very worst, they're really
good at killing the other people and avoiding being killed
or all this stuff happens, but it's hell, and we
couldn't even possibly imagine what it's like, and we've tried
so hard in so many films from Civil War through
World War Two into this. But they recognize each other,
and they that recognition is transcendent, and so he wants
(17:06):
to see what they're saying, and what they're saying sounds
so exactly like our marines and our army guys. And
so you have a marine, for example, Karmar Lantis, who says,
you know, we're not the dominant species on the planet
because we're nice, right, And people complained that, oh, the
military turns young men into killing machines. I'd suggest it's
only finishing school. Here more of my conversation with Ken
(17:30):
Burns and Lynn Novik that Here's the Thing dot Org.
After the break, Kurt Anderson talks about Nixon and Henry
Kissinger's faithful decision to bomb neutral Cambodia. Bi'm Alec Baldwin
(17:52):
and you're listening to Here's the thing. Kurt Anderson says,
Richard Nixon had a number of close advisors, but on
they listened to a few. Henry Kissinger definitely had his
ear and his trust, even though they mistrusted each other
because they were both manipulating guys. They were scorpions in
the Oval office together but Bob Holdenman, his chief of staff,
(18:15):
he he thought was a smart political guy and a
tough guy and all that. But like in terms of
oh should I get out of Vietnam sooner rather than later? Kissinger,
if he was of a mind to do that, I
think could have done that, and could have you know,
could have talked him out conceivably of all kinds of things.
Did he have his trust though? Because when he gives
that speech, and you're talking about like episode five or six,
(18:36):
he gives that speech and Kissinger there's a long clip
of kissing going, I've never heard of speech delivered like this,
to the greatest speech that an actor never could have read,
that written that speech, And he said, I think I
was as good as any actor in Hollywood. He says,
and and and what's what's the speech again? He gives
There was the famous silent majority speech back in the
fall at sixty nine he gave. But this was afterwards
(18:59):
and the Kissinger actually says the one non ass kissing
thing in these hours of tapes with Nix and he says,
he but that wasn't as well delivered as this one,
Mr President, And yes, you're right, and we run that
so long those calls. Kissinger called him I think five
times that night, just to keep trying to keep giving
him the drug was praised. The only thing that cemented
(19:19):
since trust for kissing him was that all you had
to do. No, that was part of the anti he
That was the entry admission. He had to do that
just constantly, obviously because Nixon was so needy for it.
But no, they had actual substantive conversations about politics and
geopolitics and Russian Vietnam and all the rest. But they
(19:40):
were both a moral people and just full of just
amazing to me listening to these hours of tape, kind
of grotesque. A morality about killing, killing on the massive scales,
whether it's Mela, the Meli massacre, or tens of thousands
and then eventually millions in Cambodia now much as made
(20:00):
not by you. You You've mentioned it glassingly. Nixon was
a profound anti Semite. Apparently that never entered Kissinger's mind.
I Kissinger was unaware of that. Oh, he was fully
aware of it. He just had to shut up and
stuck it up. Yeah, not be be one of the
good Jews, as Nixon more than once talked about. Um,
you know, William Sapphire, who later became a New York
(20:22):
Times columnist, was Jewish and his and Agnew's most uh
you know, Nixon and agnew esque speechwriter before he went
off to become a cultur prize winning columnists. So he
was of two minds. I mean, he wasn't, you know
ku klux Klan committed and devoted to his anti Semitism.
But he was. And again it's they're all over the tapes,
(20:42):
especially when he was with Bob Holdaman alone, and they
could just expose and and share their anti Semitic feelings.
But no, I mean he understood that Kissinger was a
really smart guy who was as ruthless and amoral as
he was, and it was a match made in hell.
The you and I worked on a book together, our
Trump parody book. But I would say to people that
(21:04):
I found it just absolutely I was dumb struck by
how Trump was able to draw together so many bad people.
I thought, were there really this many bad people who
wanted to come to Washington and to pervert the course
of this government to these purposes? I thought, I couldn't
(21:26):
even imagine there were that many of them. Can the
same be said of Nixon or was Nixon not as bad.
It's a complicated question. I was talking about the other
day comparing Trump to Nixon. Now, I mean, on the
one hand, Nixon had actual noble ambitions of being a word,
accomplished good things and China, so the Union, those were
(21:47):
good things, and Kissenger helped him stipulating those an E
p A, Oh my god. On domestic politics, he was
the most liberal president between you know, lb J and
Joe Biden. I mean literally, I mean, but what he
did with and in Southeast Asia is unforgivable because it
was to him a side show to the big game
(22:08):
with China and the Soviet Union. It was just let's
not let Saigon follow the comedies. Before November seventy two,
that that was it. I mean, after his first year,
we realized we're not gonna win this. They're not gonna
stand up. This is gonna fall. I just got to
make sure it doesn't fall. Before November seventy two, it
was inexcusable and it was awful. Now he had bad people. Well,
(22:31):
when when you hear the quotes, when you interrojected, when
you hear the quote when Haig says we're within an
eyelash of victory. And this is in nineteen seventies, seventy one.
This is like, no, we aren't General Haig, and no,
Haig was his military right hand guy throughout this. And
what's extraordinary about that line from Hague at that point
it's Kistener and Nixon knew that wasn't true, that they
(22:52):
knew that this was a lost game, but that we
couldn't speed up the withdrawal because then Saigon would fall
and he would have lost Vietnam. And there's no comparison
between Donald Trump and Richard Nixon and I Q and
even in morality, although I mean an experience, yeah so,
but I don't want to say and therefore Nixon is good.
(23:13):
I mean, in the argument between who's the worst president,
it's a kind of a tie between an apple and orange,
you know, I mean, Nixon was intelligent, Nixon actually had
some things he wanted to do. Nixon was not bad
as a domestic president, Henry kissing, you're really smart guy,
on and on and on. But what they did in
Vietnam and what they did in Watergate, what he did
(23:34):
in Watergate to undermine American confidence in this possibly fatal
way along with extending Vietnam? Is this one to punch?
I mean, that's that's just inexcusable. I mean if I mean,
we'll see, right, or maybe we'll see if we live
long enough, what happens to this country. But was Richard
Nixon were responsible for its downfall if we come to
(23:55):
a downfall, or Donald Trump? Both together and and in
a certain way, which I did really realized before working
on this piece. You know, marinating in Nixon for a
year during the last year of the Trump administration, I
saw the connections between them, even though one was a moron,
one was more mentally ill than the other, one was
a bigger liar than Nixon. But you saw how Richard
(24:19):
Nixon began the rot in the Republican Party and in
just this cynicism and nihilism that became so big in
the beginnings at the beginning of the Republican mantra of
he's a sociopath, but he's our socioth Yes, exactly. Even
though they got rid of him, and when people, as
people have said to me, as I've been talking about
(24:41):
this podcast, well water Gate, we got rid of him
and it was all good and we're all fine. Well, yeah,
and it was good what Baker and Goldwater and all
those Republicans didn't said, Mr President, you gotta get out
of here, you gotta resign. This isn't this is no
longer tenable. But there's a certain self flattering focus on
as opposed to what was just beginning to happen in
(25:03):
the Republican Party. It's like, you know, don't end in
nineteen seventy four when Gerald four takes over and everything's good,
We're gonna have tanks in the street and look enough, yeah, no,
and and and I get it, and it was a
good thing that we did that, but like here in
one Land, we haven't had that moment where who good,
We're safe now, you know. No, well, I mean, I
(25:25):
mean that proposed the book that we did, and the
whole crap I did on S and L and so
forth with Trump, And people would ask me for some
thumbnail analysis and they say to compare Trump and Nixon,
and I'd say, well, I'm going to paraphrase, and I say,
all honorable presidents are the same, and all dishonorable presidents
are dishonorable in their own way. You know that you
really can't compare them. They're very very very different people.
(25:45):
And again Nixon because of the breath of his experience
and Trump with none. But what I do see is
that both of them brought a lot of bad people
with him, and Haldmen and Irlckman were bad people. Hague
is a bad guy in terms of what what I
believe the world of government should be. Lately, we've been
reading about as we already knew, but the details of
Trump's politicization of the Justice Department, his attorney generals. Well,
(26:08):
there was Richard Nixon who had taken his campaign manager,
John Mitchell and made him attorney general and just made
him like part of the criminal gang that then went
on to do Watergate and cover it up and all
the rest. So that politicization of the Department of Justice,
that we're all, look what he did, Look what Trump said? Well,
this guy did it? You know, yes, exactly. Now, obviously
(26:31):
something that is as sweeping as this in terms of history,
there's a lot of history there. Nixon becoming elected in
nine and why uh, you know, as I've told people,
it's like Dracula polls the stake out of his art,
gets out of the coffin and goes to marry your girlfriend.
You're like, you just can't believe the improbability of this
whole fucking thing. But in the breadth of this the convention,
(26:53):
Nixon wins silent majority. On through the war, I want
to stop and take a moment because there's so much
there to cover and talk at out of the expansion
of the war into Cambodia and allows which I viewed
as war crimes. I mean, these are guys should have
been prosecuted for war crimes. I mean, to me, the
war crime that we're committed were what they caused to
happen in Cambodia. That they caused the crazy faction of
(27:16):
Communists in Cambodia to win the civil war that had
barely started in six sixty nine when the Wigs and
presidency began. But then this bombing, this this relentless bombing
this neutral country of not very many people by the
US to get rid of those Vietcong centuaries, whipped up
this civil war and certainly made it. You know, who
(27:37):
are you for, the communists or these people who are
sending thousands of tons of bombs into your homes every
day and every week for a year after year. And
of course that made the camer Rouge eventually win that war,
and and the genocide of killing two million of their
seven million fellow citizens. So what happened there really is,
(27:59):
I mean, very arguably a war crime. It's not hyperbole,
but yes, expanding the war when he was elected to
end it, and then thinking that they could at least
be seen as not giving in, not bugging out, and
and maybe we can just scare the North Vietnamese a
little bit enough to be more tractable at the peace talks.
That's what going into Cambodia was about. That's what going
(28:20):
into Louis was about. And just also a kind of
bloody minded desire to keep fighting and not losing a war.
Americans don't lose wars. We've never lost a war. That
was for both of them, but especially I think Nixon,
both of them, meaning Kissinger and Nixon, but for Nixon, like,
I just can't be the guy who loses the war.
And yeah, now I'm gonna lose the war, but I'm
(28:41):
gonna just bomb the hell out of him, even on
the way out, even if I can't do North Vietnam.
I think it's literally I want to kill as many
of them as I can before I signed a document
in Paris, yes, which they justified to themselves in a
rational way as all we're getting you know, it's it's
part of the negotiation process. But now, I mean they
really didn't get anything more than they could have gotten,
(29:03):
you know, much earlier in the presidency. But they just
kept at it. And it's yeah, it's absolutely inexcusable. It's
almost impossible, I guess. I mean this is true of
any president. We've imposed a contemporary seco analysis of them. Uh,
and people positive things like if all these guys have
been given a really cursory psychiatric examination, they would have
been ruled ineligible for the job, but no one more
(29:26):
so than Nixon. And I feel like Nixon is somebody
who if only he had a friend, if only he
had a counselor if only he had someone who said
to him, don't do this. I mean, you have a
chance to become I'm not gonna see a great president.
Because it was a very turbulent time because Vietnam is
the anti communist thing overdone if you will. Everybody knew
(29:47):
if you study Vietnam and college that they were not
a Sino based or Russo based communist satellite they were
like fuck you to the Chinese and fuck you to
the Russia. They wanted to be left alone. They wanted
to be their own independent tree, and they would take
from different people to fight the United States, which was
a very wealthy country at that time, and we were
doing the whole guns and butter thing which would later
come back to haunt us by spending trillions of dollars
(30:09):
to fight a war halfway around blah blah blah, all
things we know about Vietnam and the kind of thumbnail way.
But I do believe that Nixon is somebody who if
he only had an advisor that really had his heart,
he could have become a very good president. Do you agree?
I totally agree. And again a dozen years ago I
developed this contrarian view of Nixon as this reading about
(30:30):
what he had done and allowed to be done um
domestically that we talked about earlier. I mean, between that
and ending the war in Vietnam, if you'd done it
more expeditiously and hadn't let the Pentagon papers and everything
else throw him off the rails and go go nuts,
and then China in the whole Union, yeah, I think
he would have been remembered as this unlikable guy he was,
(30:51):
but as a really really good president. Absolutely are think
eight years in the White House would have helped him
erase the image unlikable guy that he was. Well, I
don't know. I mean, he was such an un Californian,
Californian and a deeply unlikable tip shoes on the beach.
I was took exactly, not a natural politician, so beloved
never but he said he was gonna in the war
(31:13):
he did, and look at all this other stuff he did,
and look at China. No, he would be today, absent
Watergate and absent all the Vietnam craziness that I didn't
really realize before doing this show led directly to Watergate,
he would be not in the bottom five or ten,
he be in the top five or ten. Best selling
(31:35):
author Kurt Anderson, If you're enjoying this conversation, tell a
friend and be sure to follow here's the thing on
the I Heart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you
get your podcasts. When we come back, Kurt Anderson talks
about how Nixon became fixated on winning over protesters at home.
(32:05):
I'm Alec Baldwin and you're listening to Here's the Thing.
In the early morning of May, just days after four
students were killed at Kent State University, Nixon went to
the Lincoln Memorial to talk to protesters himself at five am.
He recorded the experience on a dictaphone, which is memorialized
(32:28):
in Kurt Anderson's podcast, Nixon at War. I walked over
to a group of them, walked up to them, and
your hands. They were not unfriendly, as a matter of fact,
they sad, of course, quite surprised. As one of the
protesters said afterward, it was so freaky because I have
(32:51):
tried to explain it. Michaels in Vietnam were the same
as there is to stop the children and the war,
to bring peace. Our goal was not to get into
Cambo again by what we were doing, but to get
out of Vietnam. There's need to be wished. They did
not respond. I hope that they're hatred of the war,
WHI try could well understand would not turn into a
(33:15):
bitter hatred of our whole system, our country and everything.
And it stood for I said, I know you, probably
most of you think I'm an s op, but I
want you to know that I understand just how you feel.
Kurt Anderson says Nixon's frustration was that his plan to
(33:36):
draw down US troops while training the South Vietnamese just
wasn't working. Nixon did start vietnamizing the war pretty rapidly
and significantly, which means for our listeners, which means saying, hey,
this is not our war to win the South Vietnamese,
the non communist southern half of this country that was
(33:56):
divided after the French occupation failed in the nineteen fifties
between the North who became communists, in the South, who,
in the view of the communists, became the puppet of
the United States. So Nixon is is elected to in
the war, and he begins reducing the draft. First year
was drawing not very many truths, but then more and more.
(34:18):
We had five and fifty thousand when he was elected,
and as many as five hundred dying a week, and
six thousand boys my brother's age and even my age
almost being drafted every week. And he brought all that
down because he understood that was not politically tenable and
it was for better or worse, all about politics for him.
If I can end the draft and reduce the number
(34:40):
of Americans killed. He knew it would not country at
doubts it would not be a problem for him anymore.
And so his approval ratings for how he was handling
Vietnam stayed high for the almost the whole time, and
he went up and down, and he responded by giving
speeches and announcing further reductions in the draft and everything else.
So vietnamization and was saying, Hey, South Vietnam, it's on you.
(35:03):
We're getting out of here. We're not getting out here immediately,
but we're getting out of here, and therefore you will
be fighting your own war against your North Vietnamese brothers.
During the time that you did this, and you had
mentioned getting into the weeds quote unquote and the research.
What was something that surprised you that you found out? Well,
I mean not so much facts, although this in anal story.
I had heard of her, maybe, but I knew nothing
(35:26):
about that. And it was interesting because he had covered
it up and then and then the Nixon Nights to
this day, the Nixon Library still so no, no, no,
that's not don't even pay attention to that. Don't look
in those files, paying no attention to that woman in
the channel dress in the corner well exactly, So that
was a kind of surprise to me. But these moments
on the tape, listening to the tapes gave me a
(35:48):
sense of their humanity or in humanity that I just
didn't have before that I just reading you just don't
I didn't get as much as hearing them talking admitting
we're screwed, or laughing about massacres. All those things were
just in the sense that I now feel as though
(36:08):
I was there with these guys as they were running
their horror show. So not so much facts, although I
had heard, because it's well known about this visit of
Nixon's at five am to hang with the protesters at
the Lincoln Memorial, which is an amazing scene, and I
think we did pretty good justice to it. But I
never knew the thing that he didn't did at dawn
(36:29):
and went to the empty capital alone and sat in
his old chair where Representative Nixon sat. And then as
they're leaving, going through the statuary hall in the middle
of the Capitol, there's this black woman mopping the floor
at six am in the morning, and he goes over
to her and says, you know, my mother was a saint.
You remind me of my mother. You'd be a saint too.
(36:50):
I mean, it's this crazy scene. So so the details
throughout of how they sound, how they interact, his his craziness.
When Daniel Alsberg appears and arrested and admits you, I'm
the Pentagon papers leaker, that he couldn't get Alger Hiss
out of his mind. What happened. He was a guy
who works in the State Department as a young man
(37:11):
in the in the nineteen thirties and into the forties,
and then ran a nonprofit, was a big liberal guy,
had been a Communist, as so many people had in
the nineteen thirties, and it was alleged and perhaps maybe
probably true, had given papers, not atomic secrets or anything,
but had dealt with the Soviets. And and then that
(37:31):
was I put it in a pumpkin. That was part
of the pumpkin thing. And that was that became a
thing in fifty when Richard Dixon was fresh to the
house and Richard Nixon rode that to prominence. Really the persecution, prosecution,
call it what you will. Of Aldre was along with
Jagar Hoover's help, was how Nixon became famous. Mr Anti
(37:53):
communist who wasn't a nut like Joe McCarthy, and that
was his beginning of his queer So twenty years later,
when there's this leak of the Pentagon papers, wholly different thing.
It's not about a Cold War, it's about this actual
war we're fighting, and it's all it's so different, but
he sees it as just the same. It's another pinko
guy and he's Jewish to boot doing this bad thing,
(38:16):
and all the newspapers are not only supporting him, they're
printing it. So to him it was just it's it's
aldre Hess all over again. It's communists against me all
over again. It's the liberal elite all over again. And
he kind of lost it. The thing that was surprising
to me, even though it's silly, was I couldn't believe
in Watts said when he was going to resign that
he got up and took a swing at a kissinger. Myself,
(38:39):
I didn't think men had that kind of passion in
that white Well. William Watts, he was the kind of
administrator of the National Security Council, so he was an
important guy. He made sure the trains ran on time
in the National Security Council which Nixon and Kissinger had
made more powerful than it had ever been, of concentrating
all the national security, foreign policy decision making, policy making
in the White House, while was the guy that Kissinger
(39:01):
had personally hired and finally got too much for him,
as it did for other liberal ivy legal elitist that
Kissinger had hired. And he's quit and yeah, took a
swing at him, and then Hague al Hague told him
right after that you can't quit. Your commander of chief
is giving an order. He said, well, I did, General Haig,
and as he says, and that was the end of
my career in government. I mean, I'm of the belief
(39:23):
that we've never recovered from the Vietnam War. Did that
take hold of you while you're doing this work about
just the kind of suffocating tragedy that was Vietnam Absolutely,
and how it combined under Richard Nixon with Watergate and
all of the the undermining of the rule of law,
of decency and everything else into one horrible explosive thing
(39:46):
that began all of the things that we haven't recovered from.
And the way Nixon used Vietnam and used the countercultural
moment at the time and used all these things at
the time politically to make the this this fissure that
are broken up between the hard hats and the hippies
and all that he turned into this unhealable wound, and
(40:09):
this fisher became the chasm that Donald Trump, in his
way has been still exploiting, is still exploiting between the
regular folks and the working class guys and these liberals
and these professors and these newspaper people, and turned into
this permanent wound that we have never recovered from. And
(40:29):
also the war powers that comes in three during Nixon's
second term, which has been flouted by Democrats and Republicans
since we've learned nothing about that, which is, if we're
going to invest all this power into a commander in
chief and an executive without any of the advising instead
of the Congress. It was, among other things, the time
when we still believed we hadn't had this happen yet,
right President's wage war, and here was a president, the
(40:53):
third president, to wage this particular war. We didn't know
how to stop that or control that that This was
a whole new kind of war. So I don't want
to excuse Congress's ineffectual exercise of power in the instance,
but they didn't fell down on the job. Look at
the rock, I mean fell down on the job again.
And the kind of expansive authorization of war that happened
(41:14):
in two thousand one. But evil geniuses, fantasy Land, your
last couple of books, many books prior to that, and
again you I'm always she lacking you and laddering you
all the time, but but effortlessly. No. Let's quote Nixon
in his resignation speech to the staff. When he turns,
everybody says, this is not the most elegant house, but
he's the best house because that has a heart. He says,
(41:36):
that's great speech. And then he said, we don't say goodbye.
The French have award for it. Or of war, he says,
Or of war to you. Kart Anderson, our revoir to
you as well. Kurt Anderson, host of a new podcast
called Nixon at War. I'm Alec Baldwin. Here's the thing.
(41:57):
Is brought to you by I Heart Radio. We're produced
by Kathleen Russo, Carrie donohue and Zack McNeice. Our engineer
is Frank Imperial.