All Episodes

November 12, 2018 28 mins

The Lit Killer is back and it's all my fault. What's my connection to this monster?

EINHORN'S EPIC PRODUCTIONS & iHEARTRADIO PRESENT: LETHAL LIT: A TIG TORRES MYSTERY 

Created & Executive Produced By: Heather Einhorn & Adam Staffaroni. Written, Created, & Executive Produced By: Alex Segura & Monica Gallagher, 

Directed By: JB Blanc, Produced By: Aroop Sanakkayala, Chris Peterson, & Sandy Smallens.  

With performances by: Rebecca Soler, JB Blanc, Matt Gumley, Paul Guyet, Jennifer Jiles, Rachel Oremland, Alba Ponce de Leon, Shelly Shenoy, Luke Slattery, and Gayle Artino Post Production Supervisor & Mixer: Michael Sinterniklaas, Recording Engineer & Dialogue Editor: Michael Schneider, Sound Designer: Justin Kohler, Composer: Jared Faber, Art: Rebecca Mock, Creative Direction & Design: Ryan McCann, Creative Consultant: Monique Chavez, Studio Manager: Clark Cheng, Production Coordination: Gayle Artino & Laura Martin, Production Assistants: Rachel Slotky & Francesca Calo. Recorded at NYAV Post in New York City 

Featuring the songs "Jupiter" performed by Donna Missal - Courtesy of Harvest Records under license from Universal Music Enterprises, and “Guardian Alien” Performed By Dana Williams, Written By Dana Williams (SESAC) and Aaron Pfenning (SESAC) - Courtesy of The Royalty Network, Inc. on behalf of Smiggs Songs (ASCAP), Cactus Palace (SESAC) and Dana Williams 

Lethal Lit: A Tig Torres Mystery is a production by Einhorn’s Epic Productions for iHeartRadio.  

Head to TigTorres.com to share theories, discover new evidence, and follow case updates.  

For more information visit EinhornsEpicProductions.com

Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Hey, Lethal listeners tig torres here, stay tuned for the
next episode of Lethal lit But first, a quick word
from today's sponsor. Oh my god, I got it's Superget this,
get this one table. They're all one killer. Just returning
on me the true about school. Come on, get the

(00:24):
hell hop three times in case you couldn't tell that
was intense. This whole town has legit lost their minds.
To bring our new listeners up to speed, this is
my lone girl on a Mission podcast. I'm back in

(00:45):
my hometown of Hollow Falls trying to crack open the
lit killer case. The lit killer was a serial murderer
who scream queened this town a decade ago, leaving bodies
posed like literary references from your high school reading list.
My aunt, Beth, his last victim, took all the blame,
and since I know she wasn't the killer, I'm back

(01:05):
for justice only. I didn't count on the real murderer
making an encore appearance, resulting in one very dead Tony
del Canto folly, and I witnessed his body drop from
three stories up. Now the whole town is freaking out
because they're open and shut. Case isn't so shut anymore,
and guess who's to blame. So let's cut back to

(01:30):
Hollow Falls High, where you're fearless heroine was hiding in
a closet. No, oh, hey, Principal Block, come with me.
I'm tig Torres and this is Lethal lit I've ever

(01:53):
been so obsessed with something that you couldn't eat or sleep,
that's me this case. My aunt's innocence has been part
of my DNA since we left this town years ago.
But if you've been plugged into the real freaks of
Hollow Falls, then you already know that. Less well known

(02:13):
is the fact that Hollow Falls and its residents are
invested in keeping the lit killer dead and buried. So
Tony's murder, even hinting that the lit killer is back,
things around here are going to go from zero to
Riverdale real quick. Maybe my new pals at the Talent
the student newspaper will help out. Maybe not, But first

(02:35):
I had to get through this meeting with Principal Block. Mrs.
I'm going to make this brief. Exactly what in the
hell do you think you're doing? Principal Ronald Block is
a Hollow Falls lifer super imposing I think infinity war
Thanos minus the whole purple part. He lives alone and

(02:58):
has been working at the high school since graduating college.
What does that tell us, Well, it means Block was
around the first time the lit killer terrorized the town.
It also means he wants to keep the glassy eyed
status quo at Hollow Falls High. Is he a suspect?
I'm not sure yet, but until I know otherwise, I

(03:19):
have to treat him like one. Let's go back to
our chat. Are you listening, Yes, sir, I'm just still
a bit freaked out. You can relax now. I know
you've been through and seen a lot. As much as
I blame you for bringing this new chaos into my school,
I don't want any of my students being chased around
like some looney Tunes clip. So take a breath for

(03:43):
the moment you're in what they call a safe space.
Block showing me even an ounce of compassion through me,
as did the creepy stuffed bird on his desk. His
name was Henry and he was the school's original mascot,
the reason they're the Hollow Fall Hawks. But historical mascot
or no, Keeping an old dead bird on your desk

(04:05):
is well it's kind of glass a hollow falls. All right,
Mr Doris, we're done here. One more thing, though, Principal
Block seems the resemblance to your aunt isn't just skin deep.
I said you could go, Mr Doris, and I totally will.
But first, can you tell me anything about Tony's case?
Did you not hear what I said? Are they reopening

(04:26):
the lit killer case? I'm not trying to cause trouble.
I will give you major trouble unless you stand up,
turn around, and walk out. This instant trouble was something
I could count on finding me no matter what. When
Max and I found that first tape of my aunt
Beth's recordings at the Star Diner, I knew it wouldn't
be the last, but the clue gave me some doubts.

(04:49):
I figured out the quote. It was from a clockwork
arnge by Anthony Burgess. Is it better for a man
to have chosen evil than to have good imposed upon him?
But it was hard a solid GPS pen. I needed
to brainstorm with Ali Win and Max the talent crew
if we had any hope of finding that next tape
or you got snagged by Principal Mussolini. Yeah, it was

(05:13):
super lit. But that bird, right, Henry has reserved seating
in all of my nightmares. Okay, So in terms of clues,
Who've got the free fall and clockwork orange quotes plus
the note from Tony's good morning Losers. So this is
scary on grande listeners. Meet Ella high Smith, spoiled daughter

(05:33):
of the mayor of Hollow Falls, and until a few
days ago, the arm candy of one Tony del Canto.
Since then, she's kind of been basking in the veiled
glow of her new gig girlfriend in mourning. So here's
the deal, freaks and geeks, all this serial killer talk
from little Miss Murder has got to stop, right about

(05:55):
the important stuff. I'm the tragedy here. My boyfriend, my
sweet strong Tony is gone Hill and Tig. Don't think
I didn't notice. Tony's death was right after he had
a run in with you Big city Torres back with
a podcast full of lies about a new killer, when
it was her psycho aunt who racked up the body

(06:16):
count in the first place. So this want to be
true crime doc of yours has got to go. It's
distracting from Daddy and all the good things he's doing
for this town. So your boyfriend got acts, but you
want us to write about your daddy and you way
a compartmentalize your grief, Electra, I don't know or care
what that means. Just don't tell me how to grieve.

(06:37):
Tony was my sweet baybear and you need to leave
him out of this pathetic side hustle. Can I just
ask what conceiler you're using to mask your too your
stained eyes, because it is doing a fabulous job. Self
censor yourselves before someone else does it for you. Okay,
configure yourselves off blast as if we needed more drama.
But Ella high Smith would have to wait when and

(06:59):
I had another tape to find? Oh, this place, it's disgusting.
Why do I get pared on all the dusty and
gross missions when and I have just walked into a
used bookstore known as the book Barge. The place wreaked
of aged cat pie and lemon scented lysol. While stalling

(07:20):
out on deciphering where my aunt's clockwork orange clue was pointing,
we found out a fun fact. Anthony Burgess's dystopian book
was banned in Hollow Falls, well mostly banned. You couldn't
find it at the school or at the library, which
left the book Barge the dumpiest of dumps as our
last hope. So far we've found two copies of the

(07:42):
book with nothing special in them. Why would anybody come
in here? Much less bodish? Hi? Uh? Do you have
any other copies of A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess?
I can only find these? What do you see which
to get? Okay, hey, wait a second, you're the tourist

(08:04):
kid christ a lot of helps she was. In fact,
she asked us to leave a few minutes later. If
I hadn't looked at the clock above the register, we
probably would have two. But there it was orange. H nothing,
It's just the hour hand on your clock is orange.

(08:27):
It's funny. Why is that funny? Really? Because the book?
Never mind? Um? Actually, ma'am, do you have a band aid?
By any chance? This looks like a cvous to you?
Girly customer service here is ond? I know, I'm sorry,
but I think I cut my ankle on one of
your shelves and I don't want to get blood on

(08:49):
your floor. And all right, Jesus age, hang on, let
me go check in the back. Last thing I need
to sing the story in her defense. I was up
to no good, and when she came back, she caught
me balanced on a stool with the clock in my
hands busted. In that moment, I did the only thing

(09:12):
I could think of. What did all you do to
get back here? Like cloth? Slow down for plea? Please
be another tea? If I had arrested for stealing a
quick down, yes, but I found it to be kidding
Clock her Grange, You were so not my favorite books,

(09:33):
but I could seriously kis this clock right now? Are you?
The tape we found at the book Barge gave us
another snippet of Aunt Beth recording her notes from the
original lit Killer murders. We brought it back to the
Talent offices to give it a listen. It shows what
you found. Guys. You should have seen that place. You
should have some serious Jomo right now kissing out That

(09:55):
means Win hated it, Alexa. Fast forward to the Hide
and Seek Intrigue. Brace yourself for synergy. This new Man
Beth tape zoomed in on one of the Lip Killer's
first victims, Tony Delcanto's dad in Big Tone. Delcanto was
a local businessman with the spotty record and the varsity

(10:16):
football coach at Hollow Falls High had a reputation for
being hot headed, violent and prone to screaming at the kids.
I was already looking into him because of his business dealings.
Some associates had been caught up in some shady stuff.
But I think ever connected back to Delcanto directly. When
we ended up dead beaten to death in the back

(10:37):
of a local dive bar, the Wet Whistle, A lot
of people chalked it up to karma, but people don't
get beaten to death in Hollow Falls, and definitely not
with stones. A few weeks after Tony Sor's body was found,
Aunt Beth returned to the crime scene. Sneaking into the
office in the back of the bar, she discovered a
beat up copy of The Lottery and Other Stories by

(10:59):
Sure Jackson, shoved between two stacks of invoices. She also
knew the Hollow Falls p D had been in a
hurry to clear the case, so a tattered paperback wasn't
going to raise any of their thick eyebrows. Why did
it catch her attention? Well, if you're not familiar with
the story, I'll give you a spoiler. It ends with
a death by stoning. It was a type written message

(11:23):
on a note card stepped into the middle of the
book at the conclusion of the Lottery short story. Here's
what it said. I hope you've enjoyed the first few
chapters of our tail. It's quite the epic saga, I
promise you, and you've only just begun. Reminds me of
a book I once loved. Stuff your eyes with wonder,

(11:43):
he said, live as if you dropped dead in ten seconds.
Such a strong, powerful climax. Perhaps I'll save that for
my final chapter. But that's still aways away. No happy
rating the quote, at least according to Steiner's from then
hype link, Bradberry seminar hold that thought you guys right, Victorus,

(12:14):
This pirate radio operation is done, and I believe you
have a few things that belong to us. That's Detective
Laura Carver again. It's a safe bet to say she
doesn't want the case reopened. Kind of makes you look
bad when a serial killer, you said, committed suicide is
up and murdering again, right, filer under suspicious. These officers

(12:35):
are here to collect the evidence you're withheld and therefore contaminated,
And the notes over fast and we might not have
any problems. We'll also be confiscating a recording epintment. Why Mtorius,
I hope I don't need to remind you of our
little chat. Close the notes, good eye, Principal Detective Lane,
grab those. Your little d I Y radio show has

(12:59):
been draw some unwanted attention. That was the hidden evidence
gives me more than enough reason. This is total Mr Price, Sorry, kids,
but these notes are considered evidence in connection with a
recent homicide. US do you think serious? Right now? Hey,
it's my laptop? Is this even legal? Don't you need

(13:21):
some kind of probable cause? School grounds tour? As what
Principal Block says goes he gets an anonymous tip, we
act on it. I didn't realize anonymous was spelled e
l l A real. So what connects my podcast equipment
to the murder? Can you at least tell me that? Listen, kid,
I don't have to climb jack to you. Boys. Let's

(13:42):
wrap this up and move out. This is such b
s So sorry, Tig Tig you okay, we'll say something.
Did you guys hear that they said recent thomicide? Looks
like the cops are treating Tony's death like a homicide.
Not a suicide. That's huge. We need to keep your

(14:03):
eyes on the prize. Ace. They didn't get your MP's teapes,
did they? They did? But I have copies on the clouds,
So we're good. What can we do to help? I
know what we can do, what we should we discuss? What?
Where are you guys going? Oh, typical dudes so great

(14:24):
at communication? Hey? You sure you're okay? You're shaking. I'm no,
I'm actually not okay. I need more allies. I need
more evidence, and I need to keep getting the word out.
They can't just shut me up. Just take everything I've
worked to build. Hey, you're not alone. We are with

(14:46):
you on this. I'm with you on this. Thanks. I
just I don't know what to do next. I need
to think. Damn, I can't stop my hands from shading here,
grab my hand. Just stop and breathe for a second.

(15:08):
I'm sorry. I mean, I'm sure my clammy book barge
hands aren't going to help that much. But no, this
it's nice. Thanks. When it's cool. I like you, Taurus,
you know I feel like Wait, did my and Beth
mentioned sam Steiner on that tape? What her partner sam Steiner?

(15:32):
She worked with him at the paper, but when we
went there they said he was long gone. Am Beth
mentioning him on this new tape? Though, I bet you anything,
he's still in town. Come on, let's go. Are you
sure you're ready to? Yeah? I'm sure. Whatever. When we
visited the Hollow Falls Ledger, they told us Sam Steiner

(15:53):
had gone full hermit. But even shut ins have to
eat right, and what better spot than the one stront
most people in town of Bold. Hey, welcome to the
star dining home of out of this world eating CATTERA booth, ladies,
I guess I should say Ridge, you're engineering? But what Hi? Phil?

(16:14):
Do you remember me from the other day? You're the
one sniffing around the Sorry, yeah that was me. So
how well do you know the regulars here? Phil? I'm
looking for one in particular, older dude mid fifties at
Sam kind of a loner, regulars, specials who called bad

(16:36):
in the bathroom. I'm a little kiddo. Yeah, I see
Sam a lot loves the b lt not too chatty,
good tipper. Not here now, though, Oh that's okay. You
know what I think we'd like a booth? Please thank yourself?
Are you cool? With hanging out for a bit to

(16:58):
see if Sam shows up. I'm know it's a long shot.
Luckily we didn't have to wait long before our hunch
paid off. Hey look old Sawlock. That's got to be him. Hey,
Mr Steiner, Sam Steiner, I'm take Truss Beth Trust's niece.

(17:20):
And I was wondering funny thing. It seems like people
in this town don't like being recorded. But we managed
to calm Sam down long enough to get a few
minutes with him. Sam, seriously, thank you for doing this. Yeah,
you're totally doing us a solid. Don't let me yet.
I'm thinking my food will go. The best I can

(17:42):
do is give you a few tips, and if you're smart,
you'll take him to herd. I could save your life.
I'm all your Sam, But do you mind if I
ask you a few quick things first? Okay? Shoot, So
you worked at the Hall of Fall's ledger right for
my aunt path Yeah, for a while. She was. She

(18:05):
was great. A few people in this life are, you know,
genuinely good inside, but she was. We were both on
the cop speaking though I did some municipal reporting too,
small paper problems and all that. When the lid killer arrived.
It was all hands on, dick, What was that like?

(18:27):
It was nuts? What do you think this is a
It's a strange town. The buzzing't even before the first
body was discovered and your men she ran into that
case headed on. She was fearless and innocent. Right you
believe that too? Don't you look at it? Do you
want to prove your aunt wasn't the likuler dig up

(18:50):
the next person? The liquilar murdered the person he got
to after your aunt died? What who is that? I
thought Beth Torres was the last her back. As McClellan said,
the medium is the message. Don't just take everything and
face value. You get stuff in this down when someone

(19:10):
wants you to have it, don't forget that anything else
you can tell us, Sam yea quit now? Why do
you still can't that? This case eight year in alive
and you don't want to end up like her. The
best cases, you'll wind up like me and I barely
even get out of the house these days. The lind

(19:31):
killer will break you. Your heart is sold, your spirit?
Can you watch it? This sweater is already the perfect
amount of distress. Hey win take I'm glad I found
you. You You guys ready for some tea one over here? Hope? No,

(19:53):
that's not what that means. What's up next? Always been arrested?
What that boy went full baby driver on the cops
and try to steal your stuff back with a moral?
That's really stupid and sweet? Sweet or not? We had
a problem when and Max noted he wasn't about to

(20:13):
get bailed out by any parentals anytime soon. But after
our run ins with the cops, we needed to tag
in an actual adult on this one, so we called
up the Talents faculty advisor, Harry Levinson. Hey, guys, it's
Mr Levinson. I just wanted to let you know about Ali.
I'm at the police station. It might be a little while,
but I'm sure it's all just a big misunderstanding. I'll

(20:35):
let you know when I have more figures. He's already
down there in old dead mode. Such a daddy. I
feel like I owe Ali for trying to get my
stuff back. I'm going to head over. Hey, did you
guys notice there was a car still out there on
the lot. Yeah, the red camera probably block because he
has like zero homeland. If he's here, let's go talk
to him. Are you insane. The first thing he'll ask

(20:58):
is why we're here. Look, Black knows something about Tony's death,
and if there's any intel to get I want it.
I can't believe you guys are talking me into this.
Come on, Max, I thought you gave up that Damsel
in Distress act in first grade. Okay, First of all,
Jordan Harris consistently stole from my cubby hole, and I
had everybody to be afraid. Somebody's are right his door,

(21:23):
it's open and the lights are off. Well, everyone achieves
serenity on the who you okay? So us? Yeah, I'm fine.
I just slipped on something. Um, hold on, it's starting
here and let me still play on my phone. Uh no,
no way. That is blood on the floor and we

(21:43):
are officially in the danger zone. It's coming from Block's office.
Are you kidding me? We need to get out of
here and call the cost could be heard in that.
I mean, obviously that sucks for them and all but
hashtag I'm with her. We need to get out of
here and call the boys in Blue. Okay, wait here, Chase,
don't Yellow, you need back up. This is aft. I

(22:05):
know what you're thinking. This goes against everything you learned
from watching horror movies. Oh yeah, this is bad, This
is so bad. Oh my god, only ship the face
or parts of it belonged to Principal Block. I say

(22:29):
parts of it, because his head was sliced in half
by an axe. The entire office was splattered with blood.
In less than a week, I've been inches away from
two dead bodies, people I've seen alive hours before. I
don't I'm not sure yet I can describe what that.

(22:52):
This feels like Sarah Party from High Principle Lock was
half dead on school ground residence, wondering if the town
toorious serial murderer blood killer has returned. All right, that's enough,

(23:17):
we need more info. We'll circle back to you tomorrow.
In the meantime, enough with the podcast, Torres, So what
is it then? Certainly not a suicide. Don't push my kid,
like I said, shut it. You'll be in some pis.
You can't just silence us. You know, words already out
and people need to know what's happening. Let us handle it.
Go on home, Hey, Detective Carver, what now? Torres? Every

(23:44):
Crime and Punishment. Frez Kolnikov slices Lizabetta's face in half
with an act. We're looking for real evidence, not ap
English highlights. Okay, like the note, but not does your
name on it? Tig? That's see scary stuff. Did you
steal evidence from a crime scene? Again? Torresm Is that
what I'm hearing? I found the note post Principal Block

(24:07):
body discovery. I almost missed it while trying not to
look at the shell of a man I once thought
was a suspect. But when I picked up that note card,
I knew exactly what it was. Hello again, dear Tig,
so nice to see you. It really does feel like
old times, though it'll be a spell before you reach

(24:29):
the heights of our dearly departed Beth. She did have
a rough go of it there in the end. Huh,
But as Dostoyevsky said, pain and suffering are always inevitable
for a large intelligence and a deep heart. Let's hope
you and your little squad survive long enough to get
to the next chapter. I knew the lid killer was

(24:52):
back the second I'd seen Tony Delcanto's dead body. Now
the cops knew they were back to on the next
episode of Letha Litt, What do you mean, Mr Levinson? Well,
I don't always say it. It just felt to me

(25:12):
that your aunt Beth was a bit off. You've probably
already heard about her obsession with the case, but it
seemed she was so utterly consumed with understanding, with getting
in his head that she may have taken it too far.

(25:46):
Iinhorn's Epic Productions and I Heart Radio present legally in
a take Tourism Mystery Created an executive produced by Heather
Einhorn and Adam STAFFARONI written created an executive pretty by
Alex Sigura and Monica Gallagher. Was directed by J. B. Bloch,
produced by A Rupe, Senna, Kayla, Chris Peterson and Sandy Smallen.

(26:10):
Art by Rebecca Mock. Creative direction and design by Ryan mccam,
with performances by Rebecca Silaire, J B. Block, Matt Gumley,
Paul Guide, Jennifer Giles, Rachel Orum, Land, Alba Ponsta Leone,
Shelley Shnoy, Luke Slattery, and Keil Artino. Post production supervisor

(26:31):
Michael Sinterer Nicholas, recording engineer and dialog editor Michael Schneider,
mixer Michael sinter Nicholas, sound designer Justin Kohler composer Jered Faber,
Creative consultant Monique Chavez, studio manager Clark Chang, Production coordination
Gail Artina and Laura Martin, Production assistant Rachel Slotsky and

(26:56):
Francesca Collo. Recorded at n y V Post in New
York City, featuring the song's Jupiter performed by Donna Missile
courtesy of Harvest Records under license from Universal Music Enterprises.
And Guardian Alien performed by Dana Williams, written by Dana
Williams s C, s A C and Aaron Fenning s E.

(27:17):
S A C courtesy of the Royalty Network, Inc. On
behalf of Snig's songs ascap Captus Pallace s C, s
A C and Dana Williams Letha litt A. Take Torres's
Mystery is a production by Ironhorn's Epic Productions for I
Heart Radio Head to take Torrest dot com to share theories,

(27:38):
discover new evidence, and follow case updates. For more information,
visit Einhorn's Epic Productions dot com
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

On Purpose with Jay Shetty

On Purpose with Jay Shetty

I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!

Stuff You Should Know

Stuff You Should Know

If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.