All Episodes

October 13, 2025 37 mins

DP and the Danettes recap a busy weekend in the NFL and college football. CBS Sports CFB analyst Rick Neuheisel breaks down James Franklin being fired by Penn State and hails USC's win over Michigan as Lincoln Riley's signature moment. Baseball HOF pitcher John Smoltz dives into Seattle's gritty game 1 win over the Blue Jays and voices frustration with today's game often giving quick hooks to starting pitchers. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
You are listening to the Dan Patrick Show on Fox
Sports Radio.

Speaker 2 (00:04):
Thursday morning, we will be in South Bend and if
you have an opportunity to join us, we'll be outside
Legends Pub on the campus and Notre Dame Thursday and Friday.
First come, first serve, standing room only. Parking is self
directed there. And I'm not sure what the weather is.
I didn't check. I just thought, okay, it'll be football

(00:26):
weather in South Bend. Pauli as our resident meteorologist. What's
it looking like on Thursday and Friday.

Speaker 3 (00:32):
A little balmy, a little warm, almost high of sixty
eight and partly cloudy.

Speaker 4 (00:36):
That's not football weather. It might be football weather.

Speaker 3 (00:38):
When we start our show, no, which is fifty five
degrees as football.

Speaker 2 (00:41):
Wee, but it can't be as cold as Las Vegas
was when we were out there for the Super Bowl.

Speaker 4 (00:46):
Weirdly cold.

Speaker 2 (00:46):
Yeah, that's We're up at four thirty in the morning
and all of a sudden you go outside and you're like, oh,
I hope those heat lamps are on. But it's a
great atmosphere. Been out there for a few football games.
The atmosphere is wonderful. And USC coming to town off
a big win against Michigan. I was a big win.
That might be Lincoln Riley's biggest win of his career

(01:09):
at USC. Not a lot of coverage because USC not
ranked in the top twenty five. They will be now
the big news over the weekend as James Franklin got
fired as the head coach at Penn State. And when
you're the first team since nineteen seventy eight to lose
consecutive games as a favor to twenty or more points,
and you're already on a warm seat. They decided, I

(01:32):
mean forty nine million dollars to go away. I wish
somebody would do that. I don't want you around so much. Here,
take this money and go away. But James Franklin, he'll
get a job. If you look at his overall record,
you go, dang, that's impressive. It isn't until you start
looking at the meaningful games. And as I said last week,

(01:56):
and I heard from the Penn State alumni, why are
you picking? Why are you piling on? I'm only pointing
out something. If you want to be a big time program,
you have to have high standards. Michigan wouldn't have settled
for that. Ohio State, Georgia Alabama, just to name a few.
You don't lose those games. You don't lose that many
games to top ten teams, and they did and it

(02:18):
cost him. But we'll talk to Rick new Heiseel, the
former coach who's been fired a couple of times. He
works for CBS. He was out in Eugene for the
Oregon game against Indiana, and Indiana Indiana dominated that game.
That was a wonderful performance and I thought, boy, can
they hold up in that environment against an Oregon team

(02:40):
that I thought was just going to be too fast.
This is different for Indiana Indiana. I didn't think Indiana
was a playoff team last year. I certainly do this year.
They got a quarterback, two receivers, the defense is really good,
and you know, they could be talking about a bigger
picture here by the end of the year. But we'll
talk to Rick new Heeiseel. New Heeisel, the CBS crew

(03:02):
is on the field, and he gave an oh by
the way, that he didn't think Bill Belichick would be
the head coach at North Carolina after this season. He'll
talk about that. North Carolina had a bye week. Now
they go out to cal and who knows what happens
if they come back with a loss eight seven, seven
to three. DP show email address TP at Danpatrick dot com,

(03:23):
Twitter handle that DP show. I'm gonna be honest with
you as I always am. I forgot there was baseball
last night. I forgot that the Blue Jays and the
Mariners played last night Game one of the ALCS. Big
Dumper hit a home run, and here is the call
of the game winning. Do we have this, Marvin?

Speaker 5 (03:43):
Yep?

Speaker 6 (03:43):
This is from Friday.

Speaker 5 (03:44):
Oh okay, yep.

Speaker 2 (03:48):
Three two pits out of the way. Sayah drive, They said,
right field, all right, bullock for the lock up single.
He The Americas are gonna play for the America League.

Speaker 1 (03:59):
Exam good ship.

Speaker 2 (04:00):
The Marinis win the battle at Seattle at fifteen nights.
The Marinis win it three to two, So fifteen innings
on Friday they get into the ALCS. They have to
go to Toronto. I think they had travel problems, playing issues, delays,
but then they pick up the win last night. You
have baseball today tonight. You got Dodgers Brewers Game one,

(04:23):
and you have Mariners Blue Jays Game two. I couldn't
help but think when the Brewers won and the first
thing I thought of Vin Scully and Bob Buker. Don
you imagine that showdown between those teams, but those broadcasters
in the building first thing I thought of. But in
memory of those great broadcasters, hopefully we get a great series.

(04:47):
All right, Chiefs over the Lions. I guess everybody's back
on the Chiefs banwagon. And they didn't have a penalty
called last night on the Chiefs Navenia. Yeah, Chargers over
the Dolphins. It's more than just one law the Dolphins
that it's a bad situation and they could have won
that game. It's where, Okay, you lost the game, you

(05:09):
played pretty well. The Chargers did what you want them
to do. They score. I just I was surprised at
Miami with too a tongue of Iloa's comments after the game,
because in a loss, I want to see what you do.
I want to I want to hear what you're talking about.
You know, Aaron Glenn, the Jets head coach, wasn't really

(05:32):
recognizing the elephant in the room talking about Justin fields
and how bad he played nine sacks minus ten yards passing.
I'll give you that comment coming up in a moment.
But here is too a tongue of Ioloa, who threw
three interceptions, talking about his teammates.

Speaker 7 (05:48):
I think it starts with the leadership in helping articulate
that for the guys, and then what we're expecting out
of the guys, right, we're expecting this?

Speaker 5 (05:57):
Are we getting that?

Speaker 2 (05:58):
Are we not getting that?

Speaker 4 (05:59):
We have guys showing up to.

Speaker 7 (06:01):
Player only meetings late, guys not showing up to player
only meeting Like, there's a lot that goes into that.
Do we have to make this mandatory? Do we not
have to make this mandatory? So so it's it's a
lot of it's a lot of things of that nature
that we got to get cleaned up. And it starts
with the little things like that.

Speaker 2 (06:21):
Okay, if you're a leader, then why don't you handle
this in house? Why did it get to a press conference?
You're the quarterback? Why did it get to a press conference?
You don't have to tell us everything, tell us what
we need to know or you think we need to know. Now,
all of a sudden, I'm questioning your quarterback, and I'm

(06:41):
questioning your coach and the front office here and the players. Congratulations,
you gave us the trifecta there, But when you throw
three interceptions. That's when you have to go with your
hat in your hand and say, hey, this starts with me,
and I hope to get it together. I want all

(07:02):
of us to meet and understand and air this out
so how we can rectify this. We're one in five
right now, and they are playing as if they want
to get their coach fired, and they're talking as if
they want to get their coach fired. Don't tell me.
You don't have to. I mean, I'm in the content business.

(07:22):
I love it. But if I'm a teammate or I'm
a coach, shut up. Do what you need to do first,
and then if you want to talk about other things,
how about we talk as a group. But man, that
felt like, man, this is leadership. Okay, maybe he is
throwing himself under the bus, but it doesn't sound like that.

(07:43):
You threw three picks. You were at home, you should
have won the game. I don't think you should be
calling people out. And hey, guys are showing up late
to meetings. If you have player only meetings after six weeks,
that says an awful lot about your team. Player only
meeting after week two that says an awful lot, not
only about the players, but also the coaches. All right, Seaton,

(08:07):
what's the poll question today? Oh, by the way, here's
Aaron Glenn. He's the head coach of the Jets and
Justin Fields. Did he have a zero point zero zero
quarterback rating?

Speaker 4 (08:18):
You can't have a zero. You get like you can't.

Speaker 3 (08:20):
I think you get like fifty two points just for
showing up like the SATs.

Speaker 4 (08:24):
Oh you get like seven hundred.

Speaker 2 (08:25):
Okay, all right, here's the question to Aaron Glenn, the
Jets head coach on Justin Fields for next week.

Speaker 5 (08:34):
Just numbers knocking steam? You know you don't need to
be your quarterback next week? Or come on, man, what
kind of question is that?

Speaker 1 (08:41):
Hey?

Speaker 5 (08:41):
Your games?

Speaker 7 (08:44):
There's a number of guys that you know, I mean,
sometimes this league is like this and there are guys
that have bad games.

Speaker 5 (08:49):
That doesn't mean you just bench them. Come on, you
know better than that. Okay, that's a fair question. It is.

Speaker 2 (08:57):
I mean, Aaron Glenn can act tough and about culture
and whatever. You know what, that's a fair question because
Justin Fields he was sacked nine times and I watch
a lot of the game and a lot of those
are because of him. Because you hold onto the ball
or you don't get rid of it quick enough, or
you try to make something happen with your legs. It

(09:20):
feels like every week I talk about this, get the
ball out or go down? Get the ball out or
go down? First read right there go. Kurt Warner was
talking about that, one of the greatest quarterbacks at reading
quickly getting the ball out. Kurt Warner's saying, you got
a guy open right there go. It's well, he's kind
of you know, maybe I can know it's right there.

(09:44):
And this is the difference between that quarterback who comes
out of college into the NFL and I got to
do all of this in college in high school to
the guy two or three years later who understands I
need to get the ball out quickly, read it and react.
And Justin Fields was running around and I didn't think
the Jets offensive line was that bad. But he threw

(10:06):
for forty five yards and he was sacked nine times,
so you could see you could feel Aaron Glenn's a
little frosty that. How dare you ask me if Justin
Fields off that performance is going to be my quarterback
next week?

Speaker 5 (10:21):
All right?

Speaker 2 (10:21):
Seaton Poll question, what are you thinking about?

Speaker 8 (10:24):
Well, we normally start with who had the worst weekend?
But this one I want to start. Before we can
populate who had the worst weekend, we have to figure
out if this person actually had a bad.

Speaker 5 (10:33):
Weekend or not.

Speaker 8 (10:35):
James Franklin, did he have a bad weekend? Got fired,
lost another one, but is likely going to get picked
up pretty soon by a probably pretty good program, and
got a massive check for getting fired. Is that a

(10:58):
bad weekend?

Speaker 2 (11:03):
It's an embarrassing weekend. It's like, you know, you have
you're a really good guy, but you had one night
that you you know, you messed up and you're like,
all right, that feels bad, and you wake up the
next day and you go all right, and then further
along it doesn't feel as bad. I think the embarrassing
part of that, and but boy that it'll make you

(11:24):
feel a whole lot better with that forty nine million dollars.
So I would I would say it in the moment,
had a bad night, bad weekend, lost his job. But
bigger picture is you're going to get paid, and he'll
coach someplace else next year.

Speaker 8 (11:40):
Yes, he's going to get that, you know, forty nine
million dollars, and then he's going to get hired at
a place like Arkansas or something. Who's going to be like,
holy crap, we got James Franklin. This is amazing, and
he's going to be treated like a savior there. That's
how he's going to land on his feet. For getting
fired is crazy. I don't know that there is a

(12:00):
more lucrative profession than being a failed college football coach.
No doubt, it's the best gig in the world.

Speaker 2 (12:07):
Yeah, and we'll talk to Rick Neuheisel about that. You know,
did they do the right thing because this is mid
season and this is where you don't want somebody to
win their way back, and he could have won his
way back, and then now you have a real dilemma
as well. Well, I mean, you can always fire him,
but this is where this can't continue. But man, you

(12:30):
have to ask the alumni in the boosters, Hey, we
we have to pony up and pay this guy off.
Somebody's got to write a check, yeah, Paul.

Speaker 3 (12:42):
And this buyout for James Franklin goes back to twenty
twenty one. In twenty twenty he was four and five.
In twenty twenty one, he was seven and six and
people were bailing on him. The current president gave him
a ten year extension after a seven and six season,
which is still being questioned by people in Penn State.
But the next three years eleven wins, ten wins, thirteen wins.

Speaker 2 (13:03):
Why a ten year deal.

Speaker 4 (13:04):
After a seven and six season.

Speaker 2 (13:06):
Yeah, I mean, even even if he was, you know,
had eleven wins, like ten years, it's an eternity. And yes,
you may lose your coach, but you gotta be damn
sure if you're going to give him a ten year deal,
you have to be sure. And I was never sure

(13:26):
in it because he didn't win big games. And if
that's what you want to be and you want to
prove that you belong with Ohio State, in Michigan and
Oregon in the Big ten, now Indiana and the big like,
you have to you know, hey, we don't put up
with this.

Speaker 8 (13:43):
Yeah see, but I think that he I mean, he
got a ten year deal because that's kind of the norm,
isn't it. Like you could even go back to Charlie
Weiss where he got a ten year deal, and then
people they just get ten year deals with a monstrous
buyout at the end of it, knowing that no one's
ever going to see the the end of that contract,
the life of that contract is.

Speaker 2 (14:03):
I just don't understand ten years, even for baseball players,
like we're giving them a fifteen year deal. Man, there's
a lot that can go wrong in fifteen years, ten
years with a coach five years, that's the max. Five years.
Five years. Then you can establish your identity, you can
get your players, we can find out how good you are.

(14:25):
Then after that then we can discuss. But man, this
is that's expensive divorce. Yeah, Pauline.

Speaker 3 (14:32):
However, if you're Indiana University, you have to offer your
coach Signetti a ten year contract now or someone else
will in February.

Speaker 2 (14:42):
But isn't five years enough.

Speaker 3 (14:44):
It's like a game that's being played by the agents
of college football and everyone's in on the joke. They
all work together to get these monster extensions for each
other because they know they'll get it elsewhere.

Speaker 2 (14:54):
But I'm going to give you five but I'm going
to pay you accordingly. Signetti, India is like the sixth
highest paid coach in the Big Ten, Right, I'm going
to pay you in accordance to what you're doing and
what you've done with this program. I'm going to give
you five years.

Speaker 5 (15:11):
I don't need to give you ten.

Speaker 2 (15:14):
Are you here for the bigger picture, because we're here
for this at five years and he might say or
his agent go, hey, why not ten? This guy got
ten and that guy got ten.

Speaker 5 (15:25):
No.

Speaker 2 (15:26):
College football is changing too rapidly, and you can be
really good and then really bad. And I think that's
where you have to be careful with falling in love
with somebody.

Speaker 8 (15:35):
Yeah, yeah, I mean you look Jimbo Fisher ten year contract,
James Franklin obviously, Brian Kelly ten year deal, Kirby Smart
ten year extension. They're all getting these ten year contracts
to maximize whatever money they could get.

Speaker 2 (15:49):
All right, your phone call says we always do every Monday,
best and worst of the weekend. Up next next Rick Neuheisel,
who talked about Bill Belichick over the weekend not coming
back for another their year in his opinion, and did
Penn State do the right thing and firing James Franklin.
We're back after this.

Speaker 1 (16:06):
Be sure to catch the live edition of The Dan
Patrick Show weekdays at nine am Eastern six am Pacific
on Fox Sports Radio and the iHeartRadio app.

Speaker 9 (16:16):
Paully fools Gohare with Tony Foodsco. Yeah, as everybody knows,
we're the hosts of the award winning Polly Antoni Foodsco.

Speaker 5 (16:22):
Show.

Speaker 9 (16:22):
Yeah, but instead of us telling you how great we are,
here's how Dan Patrick described us when he came on
our show.

Speaker 2 (16:28):
Quick, knowledgeable and funny, opinionated. What you doing interrupting our promo?

Speaker 5 (16:34):
Yeah, you wasn't talking about you. You took those clips
totally of context.

Speaker 9 (16:39):
Oh yeah, well after this promo, I'm gonna take you
out and beat you.

Speaker 4 (16:42):
Let me put this into context.

Speaker 1 (16:45):
Shut up.

Speaker 9 (16:45):
Yeah, anyway, just listen to the Paully and Toni Fusco
Show on iHeartRadio, Apple podcasts O wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 2 (16:51):
Yea uh Rick Neuheisel, CBS sports college football analyst, and
he was in you Gene for the big upset with
Indiana and Oregon, which we'll talk about in a moment.
We been spending a lot of time talking about Penn State.
Did Penn State do the right thing? With James Franklin.

Speaker 10 (17:12):
You know, it's hard to imagine a business saying it's
the right thing when they're letting fifty million dollars go
out the door and dead money, which is exactly what
this is but I think, Dan, what we're in is
an era where we're asking so much of our fan
base to participate financially with nil you know, the collectives.

(17:33):
I know we're doing it in house, but still that
money's got to come from somewhere. And so I think
what we've got is a bunch of kind of pseudo owners.
And this is what happened with Jimbo Fisher at Texas
A and m some rich oil guy said he's got
to go, I'll write the check. And I'm sure something
close to that happened at Penn State and Patcraft had

(17:53):
to move.

Speaker 2 (17:55):
You know, the record. If you just look at his
record overall record, you go, that's pretty impressive and just
about any university would sign up for that. But I
said last week, there's there's the blue blood programs that
wouldn't put up with that kind of one loss record
to ranked teams. Ohio State, wo Michigan Wood and Alabama wouldn't,
Georgia wouldn't. Penn State had to decide are we do

(18:17):
we want to be in that group? Are we going
to accept this? And I thought Franklin did a wonderful
job in restoring you know, agreed some of the greatness
to that program, But it's not a coincidence that he
couldn't be, you know, ranked teams.

Speaker 10 (18:32):
The number of games that went the other way make
it no longer a coincidence. I agree with that there
was something in the DNA that just didn't allow them
to play free in those games, So I get it.
I don't know that in the middle of the season
it makes a lot of sense, but it does put
them as the best job available. And if they're looking

(18:53):
for a guy, I know Kurt Signetti's name is the
one that everybody's using if they're looking for somebody.

Speaker 6 (18:58):
It does allow the winels to start turning.

Speaker 2 (19:02):
How do you get paid or how does the university
pay you when you get fired?

Speaker 6 (19:06):
Is it?

Speaker 10 (19:09):
The Jimmy Sexton deal for Gus Malson was half of
it was due in thirty days, so he had twenty
one million coming at the end of that deal, and
so Gus got.

Speaker 6 (19:19):
Ten point eight ten point eight in thirty.

Speaker 10 (19:22):
Days, and then over the life of the contract they
paid the other ten point eight.

Speaker 6 (19:27):
I penned the song did I Ever Tell You You're My Hero?

Speaker 10 (19:30):
To Gus spouse, You're everything that I would like to
be Bette Midler didn't sing it with as much emotion
as I did.

Speaker 2 (19:38):
I promise you the Indiana handling Oregon. You were at
that game and it felt like Indiana buzz the better
team and kind of took control of it. Was there
a turning point for you in that game.

Speaker 6 (19:53):
I think it was shocking.

Speaker 10 (19:55):
I was thinking that the Oregon offense would be just
too fast. I just had in my mind, you know,
maybe you know the Midwestern farm Plotters would be on
defense and it was just going to be lightning fast.
Whether it be the pace or the speed of the players.
They kept their edges.

Speaker 6 (20:12):
All day long. That is a dang good.

Speaker 10 (20:14):
Defense playing for Indiana, to go along with a rising
star in Fernando Mendoza and two really good, probable NFL
guys playing wide receiver. I just think that's a really
good football team. And I think it was kind of
shocking to Oregon that they could not use their speed
to an advantage.

Speaker 6 (20:33):
Give the Hoosiers all the credit in the world.

Speaker 2 (20:36):
Talking to Rick new Heisl CBS Sports College football analysts,
they were in Eugene for Indiana's win at Oregon. I'm
watching the broadcast and you were very matter of factly
saying Bill Belichick will be relieved of his duties at
North Carolina or something similar to that at the end
of the year.

Speaker 10 (20:54):
I can't imagine this going much longer if what we're
seeing continues, and what we're seeing is a very average
to below average team on the field that doesn't look
like they're having any fun, doesn't look inspired. The coach
has taken, you know, breaks in the middle of the season.
I asked a couple of guys that I know who

(21:15):
played for Coach Belichick, would he ever take like little
vacations in the middle of a bye week.

Speaker 6 (21:22):
Says that car was parked in that parking lot twenty
four to seven. That's where he lived.

Speaker 10 (21:27):
I just don't see this as something that both sides
are going to say can continue one for the legacy,
especially if the money's right for Belichick. I see at
the end of the season this going in a vastly
different direction.

Speaker 2 (21:39):
But does somebody hire him in the NFL, let's say
the Dolphins job was open.

Speaker 10 (21:45):
I can't imagine. I can't imagine somebody can go and
get Bill Belichick at this age, and given what we
just saw and the guy who said no distractions has
been distraction with a capital D.

Speaker 2 (21:58):
I thought it was a big win for us, an
impressive win to beat Michigan. I don't know how good
Michigan is, and I'm not quite sure how good USC is,
but you got to win that game knowing you got
Notre Dame this weekend.

Speaker 10 (22:11):
To me, it's the best win Lincoln Riley's had at
SC because, as you point out, he has to be
able to play with the bullies and Michigan had just
run rough shot over Nebraska, not so much in the points,
but in terms of just running the ball. For SC
to hold up in the trenches and to find a

(22:31):
way to win that game puts them in the contest.
And now they've got a real banner game this week
against the Irish, kind of a must win for both
of them.

Speaker 6 (22:39):
As it relates to.

Speaker 2 (22:40):
CFP, any memories of South Bend were taking the show
there later in the week.

Speaker 10 (22:46):
You know, I've never been there for a game. I
have been there for spring practice. I got to speak
at a spring clinic for Brian Kelly. I have been there.
Tony Alford used to be their running back coach. He
was my running back coach at Washington, so he gave
me the tour. The place is unbelievable. I mean it
is unbelievable. You're in for a treat, but it's it's

(23:08):
gonna be raucous for game day. And how about the
Irish with just kind of presto chango. They're back right
controlling their own destiny again with the two quality losses.

Speaker 2 (23:19):
Great to talk to you, Thanks for joining us, have
a great week.

Speaker 6 (23:22):
Always a pleasure, my friend.

Speaker 1 (23:24):
Rick new Isel. Fox Sports Radio has the best sports
talk lineup in the nation. Catch all of our shows
at Foxsports Radio dot com and within the iHeartRadio app
search FSR to listen live.

Speaker 2 (23:37):
John Smoltz, Hall of Famer baseball on Fox lead analyst
and he was on the call with Joe Davis for
the Alds, Blue Jays Yankees in the booth for the
Mariners and Jays got underway last night first pitch tonight,
Game two from Toronto at I think five oh three
Eastern on Fox. Before I get to the baseball, we

(23:58):
were just talking about respected bands, great bands that you
don't like, and Seaton came up with the who Fritzy
doesn't like Springsteen or Dylan and the Beatles. Marvin who
was your pick, Jimmy Hendrick, Pauli, Pink Floyd, Pink Floyd,
what about you, John respected band that you don't like.

Speaker 5 (24:21):
You know, I'm not much of a I'm not much
a follower of that of bands. You know.

Speaker 11 (24:27):
I grew up, as you know, playing the accordion, take
it or leave it? Weird Al Yankovich, you know, I mean,
he's would make fun of the accordion.

Speaker 5 (24:40):
He was brilliant, actually, But I don't know.

Speaker 11 (24:43):
I hear a lot of people talk about black Eyed Peas,
but I'm not a good guy to really.

Speaker 5 (24:48):
Ask when it comes to bands.

Speaker 2 (24:51):
I don't follow anybody, to be honest, when's the last
time you played the accordion?

Speaker 11 (24:57):
I tried to play it at my daughter's wedding in May.
I was gonna we have a famous chicken dance song
that we play every wedding. My daughter did a great
job and running the she found in the court and
you can't find him anymore. And the key was stuck
so he couldn't play it. So it either saved me

(25:17):
or but that would have been the last time.

Speaker 5 (25:20):
It's been a long time.

Speaker 2 (25:22):
Is that the no no no no no no no
no no no no no, no, no, no, no, no, no no.

Speaker 5 (25:27):
That's the song we kind of grew up on.

Speaker 2 (25:30):
Actually, all right, let's talk baseball here. Now you've seen
Seattle in the in the Blue Jay. I was surprised
Seattle won that game, considering fifteen innings, going cross country,
traveled issues, and a Toronto team that seemed to be
on fire. From what happened with the Yankees. What was
the big difference do you think last night?

Speaker 11 (25:53):
Well, the big difference was Toronto's offense didn't get on
base a lot and other than the first inning, Bryce
Miller had one of the greatest games I think you'll
ever see a young man pitch given the circumstances. Look,
this is a hard team to face, and especially at home.
We saw the Yankees get absolutely obliterated on great pitching
by the Yankees, just made it look like they'd never

(26:14):
pitched before. So I was a little bit surprised that
Seattle was able to hang in there on adrenaline alone.
I've been part of those long eighteen inning game. Come back,
try to play, you know, a day and a half later.
It takes its toll. But as they said on the telecast,
if they can hang in there, adrenaline gets you through
the rest of that game. And Bryce Miller was a
batter or two away from this being an ugly game,

(26:37):
and it turned into an epic game because he had
first pitch home run, then runners on first and second,
one out, and that's when the crowd in Toronto and
their offense gets going and they never got another run.

Speaker 5 (26:50):
I don't think anyone could have predicted that.

Speaker 2 (26:52):
When do you know to take out a pitcher if
it's just mathematically with pitches or I mean, and how
much is gut feeling talking to the catcher, you know,
getting a sense of something more than just the analytics
say I got to pull you.

Speaker 5 (27:08):
Yeah.

Speaker 11 (27:08):
I think the biggest thing that gets overlooked is the
swings the hitters are putting on the picture. I don't
think they look at it as a direct response. They'll
look at analytics, spin or velocity or just basically say
third time through, I'm not even going to let him
get there. And I think the managers that in this
postseason have let their player have a moment is winning

(27:29):
the games, meaning pictures that are going into the eighth
inning are winning. Pictures that get taken out by fourth
or fifth inning. You start rolling the dice, and I'll
be honest, the Seattle Mariners are here because the greatest
picture of our generation was only able to go six innings.
If he goes seven innings, I don't think you can
make an argument that Seattle would be here. So they

(27:50):
benefited from all that work that they put in the
file off pitches and get his pitch count up.

Speaker 5 (27:56):
I was watching that game. I was shocked.

Speaker 11 (27:59):
But based on the ear, he's never pitched over one
hundred and five pitches. So Seattle is a benefactor from
what Toronto does.

Speaker 5 (28:07):
Very well and make your pitch count go way up.

Speaker 2 (28:10):
The Dodgers have been relying on their starters, but it
feels like they have to because of that bullpin.

Speaker 11 (28:16):
Absolutely, it's a total flip of the script. Last year
they had no starters that they could count on, so
they relied on their bullpens guys, and they used them
and just really all of them got hurt. And now
they've established such a depth that is working in their
favor that you're seeing guys like Blake Snell first time
ever ever getting into seventh inning.

Speaker 5 (28:39):
In a postseeding game.

Speaker 11 (28:40):
I mean that to me is like, shouldn't be a narrative,
but it is, and I think now you're seeing again pitchers.
At one point it was twelve and one. The pitcher
that went longer than the other pitcher, they won the game.
I know lately it has been a couple losses, but
I think teams are going to have to trust their
starters and know that they are having a moment and

(29:01):
don't look. I'll give you one sixty two analytical reasoning
and philosophy, I'll give it to you one sixty two.
It doesn't apply in a best of five and a
best of seven.

Speaker 5 (29:11):
It doesn't.

Speaker 11 (29:12):
It's just it doesn't work that way. And when you don't,
when you don't deviate, you're really running the risk of
that one sixty two model not working in a best
of seven, because you never know if that one guy
is going to be on that exceeds what he would
do in the regular season, if you'd never give him
that moment, I think you miss out.

Speaker 2 (29:32):
What were your thoughts on Dave Roberts leaving Clayton Kershaw
in or having him come back for that next inning?

Speaker 11 (29:40):
Yeah, I mean I saw it from afar. I thought that,
you know, Clayton Kersall, what a moment. I just can't
even imagine the adrenaline and the rush that he was
going through. Knowing his careers over and he's had a
couple of those weird innings in postseason in his history.
It really is hard to explain. But I think for
for Dave Roberts and everything that he believes and trusted

(30:03):
his team, and that was a two to zero situation,
right if it's two to one, I think the things
are different. I know you say, oh, it's just one game,
but in a short series that could mean the difference.
I think he trusted what his team was capable of doing,
even if that didn't go well, and it certainly didn't,
and it approved that, you know, the next game they

(30:23):
were able to handle and get that win.

Speaker 2 (30:27):
Do you think like there's certain trends and we've spoken
about this, that you go in and throw as hard
as you can for as long as you can, then
next man up. That's basically pitching. But when it comes
to hitting, are we going to find more teams with
their best player leading off with success with Otani Kyle Schwarber,
I don't know if you have other teams that come

(30:49):
to mind that we're going to hit you right away
I'm going to get more at bats with my guy.

Speaker 5 (30:55):
And that's where I kind of differ philosophically. One sixty two.
I get it.

Speaker 11 (30:59):
You might get thirty five to forty more at bats
and your best player, and that might win you one
to two to three baseball games, which could be the
difference for some teams in the postseason. I still don't
get that because now you're not running the same models
in a best best a seven series. How many more
at bats is Otani gonna get it if it goes
seven versus the second hitter?

Speaker 5 (31:19):
And is that going to be enough to help him
win a game? Now?

Speaker 11 (31:22):
Otani's a freak. Let's leave him alone. He's the leadoff hitter.
He can hit for power, he can steal. But I'm talking,
let's just talk about Schwarber, you know, not getting him
into RBI situations. You look at Toronto and how they're built.
Guerrero bats in the three spot. It's perfect for him.
Imagine if Guerrero their best hitter or Bulper Schett their
best hitter, is leading off. Now, all of a sudden,

(31:43):
you in a short series as a pitcher, I have
an advantage I think over their best hitter. Because he's
not going to come up with too many times with
runners in scoring position. So one sixty two, again, I
get it. I've never understood it in a best of five,
but that's the thing. They never changed. So if you
do it the whole regular season, you're going to do
it in the postseason. And that's like splitting hairs a

(32:05):
little bit for me. But I would you imagine Barry
Bonds today, he would be leading off, thank you, thank
you for a guy who gave up nine home runs,
Thank you, lead off home run. I don't care like
those are the kind of things that in the postseason
when you're not giving your best hitter the chances to
get with runners on over the course of the season.

(32:26):
That's what that's my only argument about that. That narrative
that works in the one sixty two. Like Aaron Judge
batting second, he had a third a lot, But Aaron
Judge is another great example of putting him in a
spot to have fear factor for runners on.

Speaker 5 (32:40):
And I get it.

Speaker 11 (32:41):
You know, nine guys, you start your lineup the way
you want and then it never works that way the
rest of the game.

Speaker 5 (32:46):
I understand that.

Speaker 2 (32:48):
Has anybody ever asked you to autograph a ball that
you gave up for a home run like the hitter
as any you don't believe so so that that's no
go you.

Speaker 5 (33:01):
I would have done it. Oh, I would have done
it for sure.

Speaker 2 (33:03):
So Bond said, hey, you know, I hit this one
off of you.

Speaker 6 (33:06):
Would you autograph this?

Speaker 5 (33:07):
Oh? Sure.

Speaker 11 (33:08):
Now I've seen the flip where Bond's at the All
Star Game, some pitcher came to ask him for an
autograph and he said, heck, no, you hit me twice.
I at signing nothing. We're working on some Hall of
Fame resumes. Dale Murphy, Steve Garvey, Don Maddingly, Yeah, anybody else,
anybody else? Steve Garvey was a ten time All Star, Johnny, Yeah, no,

(33:32):
Steve Garvey was. I mean when I think of the Dodgers,
I think of Steve Garvey when I grew up watching,
you know, the seventies and the early eighties. But they're
all worthy, and you know, I'm I'm partial obviously to
Dale Murphy and what he did and how he did
it was such bad baseball teams, you know, I mean,
that's one thing that people don't take into consideration. Then

(33:54):
of course you got Andrew Jones coming up, who I
think is surefire Hall of Fame player who's yet to
get in. But but Don Mattingly is one of the
guys that everybody who from New York talks about and
how good he was and if he could have stayed healthier,
the numbers he would have put up, he would have
thrived in today's era. And that argument goes, I'll argue

(34:16):
anybody that the Tony Gwinns, the guys who did not
hit for power, could have thrived today because they don't swing,
you know, from.

Speaker 5 (34:25):
Their dairy air, and they would get on base a lot.

Speaker 2 (34:27):
More, but they would be swinging differently John, because they
would be brought up differently. Tony Gwyne brought up you
got to swing hard, Wade Boggs, Rodkrue. Unfortunately, they would
be told, hey, this is what the analytics say.

Speaker 11 (34:41):
True, unless they have the special gift like an arise
like there are we're seeing a shift. It's slow. But
the Toronto Blue Jays and the Milwaukee Brewers are not flukes.
And why they're here. They put the ball in play,
they don't strike out. If you look at the last
twenty five World Series champions, you're not going to find
three of them that are in the top ten in
my memory that we're leading the league in strikeouts or

(35:03):
in top ten of strikeouts. It's hard to do. I know,
home runs are king and I get it. Like, but
when you can combine the boat, which Toronto does and
Milwaukee does, it changed. It changes how team plays against you.
It changes the narrative of you're gonna have to work
harder to get Toronto Blue Jays from eliminating them from
the series.

Speaker 5 (35:22):
Yeah.

Speaker 2 (35:22):
I've been saying that put the ball in play, get
a walk, take an extra base, steal a bit, like
all of these different things, and Milwaukee has done that.
They don't have star power, but it feels like they're
going to always be testing you and you're not. They're
not waiting for a beginning. It's just we're gonna it's uh,
death by water torture. It's going to be deep drip, drip, drip, drip.

Speaker 5 (35:46):
No doubt.

Speaker 11 (35:46):
And we've already seen a game and unfortunately the young
you know, fitcher for Philadelphia. When you put the ball
in play, you never know what's going to happen. But
when you swing in this you know what's going to happen.
And it's nothing, and and and again one sixty two.
They don't care how many strikeouts there are. But in
a postseason game, man, man on third, I've seen it.
We've seen the fifteen inning game. Just make contact. Game

(36:08):
over couldn't do it. And I think for Milwaukee that's
what makes them special. And they run, they field, they
have great arms, and they basically have drafted players that
fit the Mint narrative of how they're going to play
and that's why they Nobody, there is not one expert,
not one baseball expert, said Milwaukee, you have the best
record in baseball leaving spring training, not one.

Speaker 2 (36:28):
Did you cry at your daughter's wedding?

Speaker 5 (36:31):
I did not.

Speaker 11 (36:33):
I did not, but I tell you it was I
had two of them this year, so one more coming
up in November. But I definitely if I would have cried,
if I'd have played the accordion probably See.

Speaker 2 (36:46):
I got three daughters. There is no way I can
get through this without crying.

Speaker 6 (36:51):
No.

Speaker 11 (36:51):
Well, I've been very fortunate to have some really good
sun in laws and that helps.

Speaker 2 (36:56):
And maybe you didn't care about your daughters as much
as I care about mine, so you're kind of.

Speaker 5 (37:03):
That's a good part.

Speaker 2 (37:04):
Yeah, Yeah, you're you were happy to get them out
of the house. I get it. I understand it, John,
I understand it. Hey have fun on the call. Tell
Joe we said hello and thanks for joining us. Oh well,
thanks Dan, all right, thanks John Smoltz.
Advertise With Us

Hosts And Creators

Todd "Fritzy" Fritz

Todd "Fritzy" Fritz

Dan Patrick

Dan Patrick

Patrick "Seton" O'Connor

Patrick "Seton" O'Connor

Paul Pabst

Paul Pabst

Marvin Prince

Marvin Prince

Popular Podcasts

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.

24/7 News: The Latest

24/7 News: The Latest

The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.