August 7, 2025 • 57 mins
Patia and Hannah speak with Cassie, who attended a Halloween party at an Oregon State University fraternity in 2008. The night started with costumes, loud music and a crowded basement full of college students.
By the end of the night, Cassie was in the ER, holding a bag that contained her bloodstained costume. She soon found herself in a police interview recounting what happened. The state brought charges, and the case went to trial.
Cassie’s story is a personal account of navigating the legal system after reporting a rape. She did everything “right" but still faced a long, painful process. Her experience echoes the questions we’ve wrestled with in high-profile campus sexual assault cases: What does justice actually look like?
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
This story contains adult content and language. Listener discretion is advised.
Speaker 2 (00:07):
Things started to hit me more of this really just happened, and.
Speaker 3 (00:13):
This is bad.
Speaker 4 (00:31):
Welcome to the Knife. I'm Hannah Smith.
Speaker 1 (00:33):
I'm patia Eton. This week we're speaking with a woman
named Cassie. In two thousand and eight, Cassie attended a
Halloween party at a fraternity at Oregon State University. The
party started out just like you'd picture it, fun costumes,
loud music.
Speaker 4 (00:45):
It was a packed house, but the night ended with
Cassie walking into an emergency room with her bloodstained costume
in a bag. After being seen by a doctor, she
would meet with two detectives who wanted to know exactly
what happened at that part.
Speaker 1 (01:00):
Let's get into the interview.
Speaker 2 (01:05):
So I'm from Portland, Oregon, and I grew up in
just the suburbs, just kind of pretty typical childhood. I
went to a private high school. I loved high school.
I had a great time, but I was also very
excited for college. I've never really been away from home
(01:31):
or my parents, so I ended up going to Oregon
State University.
Speaker 3 (01:36):
In Oregon.
Speaker 2 (01:37):
It's like growing up, you're either you're a dock or
a beaver in Oregon State is the Beaver's in My
family was always beavers, and so it kind of was
always that's where I'm going to go. Yeah, I was
excited for like that whole college experience.
Speaker 1 (01:52):
What were you looking forward to about, you know, going
off to college and what did you expect it to be?
Speaker 2 (01:57):
Like I was looking forward to just I guess freedom
is the best way to kind of that independence and
freedom of making my own choices. And it felt like
it was a way for me to kind of have
like a new start. I don't know if it was
just like a Catholic high school thing, but before we
(02:20):
went off to college, I feel like we were, you know,
kind of told that college could be scary and parties
could be scary, and I remember feeling nervous about stuff
like that. But when I made friends with these guys
that joined fraternities, it felt like, well, these parties aren't scary,
Like I just remember feeling it was a really like
(02:41):
care free time.
Speaker 3 (02:43):
I never worried about anything. My girlfriends would come.
Speaker 2 (02:46):
And it was just kind of like we were all
just like a big group of friends.
Speaker 3 (02:49):
I never felt scared.
Speaker 1 (02:53):
After spending her freshman year at Oregon State, Cassie was
feeling homesick, so in the fall of two thousand and seven,
she transferred to Portland's and it was the best of
both worlds. During the week she could be closer to
her family, but on the weekend she could hop on
I five and see all of her friends at OSU.
A few of those friends were involved in Greek life,
and OSU's Greek road doesn't look much different than it
(03:14):
does in the movies. Big houses, tree lined streets, buzzing
with students who are excited to belong to a social
network meant to last far beyond their college years. It
was exciting and it was a good time in Cassie's life.
But in the fall of two thousand and eight, everything changed.
Speaker 2 (03:31):
The fraternity that I spent a lot of time at
was Delta Kai, and one of my really good friends
at the time was a part of that fraternity, and
they were going to be hosting a joint party with
five Kapa PSI and I had never actually been to
that fraternity, but I was at Delta Chai all the time,
(03:53):
and it sounded really fun. There were only so many
people that were going to be in vie and so
it was exciting. So me and my girlfriend drove down
from Portland, and I remember being so excited trying to
find the perfect costume and I ended up choosing I
was Tinkerbell that night, and I was excited to be
(04:17):
at a new fraternity, meet new people, and there was
four of us that were going to meet up and
go to the party, and I was just really excited.
And I just remember all that excited energy of listening
to music and getting ready before the party and doing
makeup and just being really happy.
Speaker 1 (04:38):
Yeah, and it's such a specific experience to get dressed
up for Halloween and college in a town where it's
really cold at time of.
Speaker 2 (04:47):
Yes, totally, it was definitely like a time and a
place where we were just, you know, my girlfriend and
I had our little playlist that we had made to
do our makeup and hair, and definitely it was cold
a moment.
Speaker 1 (05:00):
Right, It's like you're an adult, but you're also dressed
up lake tinker Bell and you're going out with your friends. Yes,
tell us about arriving to the party. What did it
look and feel like? What were your first impressions of
the people and the vibe there.
Speaker 2 (05:14):
When we showed up it was, I think, bigger than
I thought it was going to be. There were a
lot of people lined up, like waiting to get inside.
There's like a whole guest list situation, and I remember
being cold waiting in line, and then when we finally
got up there, we weren't on the guest list, so
it was like, that's such a bummer and another typical
(05:36):
college thing where you're not on the list, can't get
into the party. And I remember kind of arguing with
the guy at the door and trying to get a
hold of my friend that was the fraternity member inside,
and I just remember it being.
Speaker 3 (05:49):
Loud, but also just it felt like fun. I was
still excited.
Speaker 2 (05:54):
Now, of course, looking back on it, I'm always like, well,
what if we just turned away.
Speaker 1 (05:59):
It's been almost two decades since Halloween two thousand and eight,
but sometimes this question still nags at Cassie. What if
she had just turned away? How might her life be different?
What version of herself would she be? That's because this
night that started out so full of joy and anticipation
unfolded in a way that would play out in the
(06:21):
media and in a courtroom, altering the course of Cassie's life.
But Cassie did get into the party and that night,
she walked in like any other college student, excited to
have fun on Halloween.
Speaker 2 (06:33):
But I got ahold of my friend and he came
up to the front door and let us all in.
I hadn't seen him in a while, and I remember
like giving him a big hug and saying I was
excited to be there.
Speaker 3 (06:45):
And it was just it was fun.
Speaker 2 (06:49):
Like we could hear the music, we could hear the
party downstairs in the basement, and so we were all
just excited to go down there and dance and hang out.
So there's like the makeshift college bar. There's super loud music.
That was two thousand and eight. Britney Spears had just
kind of come back and they were playing Womanizer, which
(07:09):
was one of me and my girlfriend's favorite songs, and
I remember hearing that as we came downstairs, and.
Speaker 3 (07:15):
We were just so happy, and it was just busy and.
Speaker 2 (07:18):
Dark, but like the whole glow, you know, black light thing.
It was just it was fun and there was a
lot of people, which most of the fraternity parties I
had been to hadn't been quite that big, but this
was a joint party between two houses, so it kind
of made sense. But we were just excited to dance.
And I remember the four of us kind of, you know,
(07:41):
got into the crowd and just kind of started dancing
and having a good time, and I was I was excited.
I remember just feeling really happy that I'd always loved
Halloween and but like it was going to be a
really good night.
Speaker 1 (07:56):
Yeah, those four people. Can you tell us who those
four people are?
Speaker 3 (08:00):
Yeah?
Speaker 2 (08:01):
So I was with my best friend Nick, who was
the one that was at Oregon State that we were
staying at his house, and we had been best friends
since high school. And then my other best friend, Carla,
who I had known also since high school. We were
on the same cheerleading team, and then we were with
(08:23):
one of Nick's roommates. Like I said, Carla and I
would go down there almost every weekend and stay at
Nick's house with him and his roommate, and so we're
all very close. I was also fairly newly single, so
it was kind of like, oh, I'm excited to see,
you know, maybe I can meet someone. I think we
had maybe been kind of dancing hanging out for maybe
(08:44):
an hour. It was like we were dancing and I
kind of like turned around and actually physically I ran.
Speaker 3 (08:49):
Into who are now know? It was Greg.
Speaker 2 (08:52):
And he was dressed as a Heineken bottle and were
kind of laughing about that, and then we kind of
ended up like talking, or as much as you can
talk on the crowded dance floor, and so then we
started dancing and everything was fine.
Speaker 3 (09:11):
I was having a good time.
Speaker 2 (09:12):
We ended up we were kissing on the dance floor,
and then all of a sudden I noticed I had
lost track of Nick and Carla, but I didn't think
too much of it at the time.
Speaker 3 (09:25):
And then after more time went.
Speaker 2 (09:26):
On, maybe you know, half an hour, forty five minutes,
and I still couldn't find them, and I was like thinking, Okay,
we should find them and maybe we can figure out.
We hadn't gotten anything to drink at that time, so
I'm like, oh, maybe they went to go get.
Speaker 3 (09:38):
A drink, and I want to go do that with them.
Speaker 1 (09:49):
Cassie had just turned twenty one, and earlier that night,
while she and her friend were getting ready for this party,
she had a total of two drinks, but since arriving
to the party, she'd had none. It's not worth mentioning
or it wouldn't be except that every move Cassie made
that night would later be scrutinized over and over and
(10:10):
over again.
Speaker 2 (10:11):
So I told Greg, I was like, I want to
go find my friends. You know, we can get something
to drink. And I remember he said, yeah, I'll go
with you. Let's go find your friends. And so we
go upstairs and to the main level, like where the
front door was, where there was everybody getting into the party.
(10:32):
We didn't see them up there, and so we went
up to the next level where the private rooms were
for the fraternity members, and somehow we ended up we
were in his room. I don't remember if it was like, oh, hey,
we can just grab like a drink in here or whatever.
I don't know if you've been in like a fraternity room,
but they don't actually or at least at Oregon State,
(10:55):
the members didn't actually sleep in their rooms. They had
like a sleeping porch area where they're a bunch of
like bunk beds and stuff.
Speaker 3 (11:01):
So the rooms were pretty small, and that a lot.
Speaker 2 (11:04):
Of them had just like futons or chairs or whatever
in them. I was like, you know, I thought he
was cute. He was really tall. I was like, tall guys,
and so I was kind of excited. I was like, Okay,
I'm newly single. This guy seems nice and we're sitting
on the futon and we were kind of started kissing
and making out.
Speaker 3 (11:24):
Is all consensual, everything's.
Speaker 2 (11:26):
Great at that time, and then all of a sudden
he asked me if I want to have sex, and
I kind of remember kind of laughing like, no, I
just met you, dude, Like that's not really Like can't
you know this is fine right now? And that's when
it kind of shifted all of a sudden. Then he
(11:49):
seemed to like shut down, and it was like the
vibe was just different. And then I tried to get
up to leave, and he grabbed my wrist and like
pulled me back down onto the futon. And I remember
his room was right off of the basketball court, so
(12:11):
I could hear people laughing and playing basketball outside, and
I remember thinking, oh my gosh, like, why can't I
say anything? Like I felt frozen, even though he was
By that point, he was holding me down with his
forearm and had just pushed my underwear aside and was
(12:34):
raping me. And I just remember hearing that laughter and
thinking the right out there I can hear them, like
why can't I scream? Or and I can also hear
people on the other side of the door in the hallway,
and just it felt it sounds probably cliche, but it
(12:54):
totally felt like an out of body experience where I
was watching this happen to me, and.
Speaker 3 (13:02):
I remember just a lot of pain.
Speaker 2 (13:07):
It was really painful, and just I felt sad.
Speaker 3 (13:14):
I just remember crying and.
Speaker 2 (13:18):
Just wondering when it would be over, like when he
would stop, and why why he.
Speaker 3 (13:25):
Was doing this because it seemed like.
Speaker 2 (13:31):
He seemed like a good guy when I met him,
as much as you can judge someone for a couple hours,
but I didn't get that kind of scary, creepy vibe
from him at all, and so I just.
Speaker 3 (13:45):
It shut down.
Speaker 1 (13:46):
It felt like it's terrible to think about finding yourself
in that situation, and you know, even though you had
met him only a couple of hours before, that is
pretty normal. You go to a party and you meet
people and you're all hanging out, and there were moments
that were consensual. It makes sense to me that you,
(14:07):
at some point in the night had felt comfortable and
then that that shifted, and so you're in you know
his room, how does it end? And how do you
get yourself away from him?
Speaker 2 (14:19):
He was finished, and I remember just kind of sitting
up and just.
Speaker 3 (14:26):
Being in shock.
Speaker 2 (14:27):
And I remember I just started to leave and I
went towards the door and it I don't know if
it was part of the shock that I was in
at the time, but I felt like I couldn't get
the door open.
Speaker 3 (14:43):
It felt locked.
Speaker 2 (14:44):
So I later found out that there wasn't a lock
on that door, but I think that just shows like
how like I could not open the door. I just
I felt like nothing, my hands weren't working, like I
couldn't connect to open the door. And I remember someone
opened the door from the outside of the room, and
(15:08):
I remember just coming out into this group and just
feeling such a.
Speaker 3 (15:16):
My brain felt hazy is the best description. I felt
like a zombie.
Speaker 2 (15:23):
I was now on the third floor and I had
to go downstairs. I remember I couldn't remember or figure
out which way the stairs were, and I just remember
kind of going in circles and I ended up running
into my friend, the fraternity member that had invited me
to the party, and I remember telling him I need
(15:45):
to find Nick and Carla and then he was actually
the first one that told me. He said, why is
there blood all over your costume? I hadn't even noticed,
and I looked down and there was just blood all
over the skirt part of the Tinkerbell costume.
Speaker 3 (16:02):
And then I told him, I said, I think I
was raped.
Speaker 2 (16:05):
And so then he just like frantically like tried to
find Nick and Carla, and we ended up finding them,
and I remember Nick making a really big deal like
we need to leave, she needs to get to the hospital,
and I remember fraternity members trying to get us to.
Speaker 3 (16:24):
Not go to the hospital. Oh my god, Yeah.
Speaker 2 (16:29):
I remember parts of it. And then from speaking with Nick.
Nick was not a very confrontational guy, and I remember
him getting very angry and yelling that we need It
was like they were almost physically trying to stop us
from leaving and saying, you know what, we can who
(16:52):
was it? We can, we can figure out. Let's go
find him. We'll talk about this. And I don't really
remember what I was thinking at that point. I kind
of let Nick and Carla be in charge, like, Okay,
I need to go to the hospital. I'm going to
do whatever they say. And then I remember just we
(17:14):
had walked to the party. I was sitting outside and
Nick and Carla were frantically trying to call friends with cars,
and so we finally found a friend that was already
like a designated DD for her group of friends that
she was going out with.
Speaker 3 (17:30):
We went home.
Speaker 2 (17:30):
They let me change. They put my costume and everything
into a bag to bring to the hospital. They wouldn't
let me shower.
Speaker 1 (17:39):
With her friends Nick and Carla by her side and
her blood stained tinker Bell costume in a bag, Cassie
walked into the emergency room. She waited for the doctor
for two hours before they could see her. It was excruciating.
All she wanted to do was go home. She wanted
to shower, and maybe, if not for the support of
(17:59):
Nick and Carla, she would have. But what Cassie didn't
know is that this was only the beginning of what
would be a long and painful legal process.
Speaker 2 (18:09):
The doctor was asking what had happened, and I had said,
you know, I was raped.
Speaker 3 (18:16):
I remember she asked me, you know, was.
Speaker 2 (18:19):
It or you know, vaginal and I just I couldn't
even you know, I remember saying I don't know.
Speaker 3 (18:29):
I just said I don't know. Just so many things which.
Speaker 2 (18:32):
Would later come back at trial, but now looking back
on it, I was instill just so much shock. I
couldn't even I think my brain was not even processing
what had happened. I knew I was raped, I knew
something was wrong, but I those detailed questions I couldn't.
(18:54):
I couldn't even explain what was happening or what happened
to me. And then she asked if I wanted to
talk to the police, and I, you know, I didn't
even think about it. I just I said yes, because
I knew something bad had happened to me and I
wanted to talk to them, and so she went to
(19:17):
start that process. And so then she said, I'm guessing
that would you also like a rape kit done? And
I said yes, and I remember being very scared. I
hadn't even had like my first pep smear yet, and
(19:37):
so I remember Carla stayed with me and was just
holding my hand, and I just remember crying. And it
was so painful because obviously a rape exam is it's
a crazy feeling because you're they're collecting evidence, but essentially
your body is the crime scene, so it's you know,
(20:01):
all lots of lots of poking and prodding and scraping,
and just.
Speaker 3 (20:07):
And after you had just I had just been raped.
Speaker 2 (20:10):
It felt so violating again, even though I knew I
wanted to do it to get the evidence, it was
also very triggering.
Speaker 3 (20:22):
It felt like the exam took hours. It didn't. I mean,
it's just a few minutes. And I also remember.
Speaker 2 (20:31):
They had my costume, but then they even had to
take my underwear and so having to go into the
bathroom and change and get, you know, some of their
underwear that they had at the hospital. That's when I
remember I kind of there's still so much bleeding happening,
and that was I think the born war.
Speaker 3 (20:48):
I saw that. It was like.
Speaker 2 (20:50):
Things started to hit me more of this is this
really just happened, and this is this is bad. Just
remember feeling scared and then even worse at that point
than the police separated all three of us, and so
(21:11):
I remember waiting in a part of the hospital. It
was just like an empty waiting room for some part
of the hospital. It was dark, it was in a
super uncomfortable chair. I had to wait there alone. I
didn't know where Nick and Carla were waiting. I had
to wait there for another hour or so, which I
understand now, but they had to wait for a female
(21:32):
officer to also be available to accompany the male officer
to interview me, So that was what ended up taking
a long time. But I just remember feeling scared and
lonely and kind of angry at that point too, for
(21:54):
why couldn't I wait with my friends.
Speaker 3 (21:56):
It just.
Speaker 2 (21:58):
Felt very overwhelming and isolating, and again like everything was
taking so long, and I just wanted to go home
as well, like two am and still just waiting for
the police to show up to talk to me.
Speaker 4 (22:12):
Yeah, of course, Like I would be angry too, like
you were victimized and had to go through this terrible thing,
and now you're the one having to wait around and
like have your body invaded. I also want to give
props to you and your incredible friends for like insisting
that you do this and taking care of you. You know,
But it sounds like a really difficult experience.
Speaker 3 (22:35):
Yeah, it was very It was very difficult and.
Speaker 2 (22:41):
Not something that I ever thought a situation I never
thought that I would be in.
Speaker 4 (22:50):
Yeah, of course.
Speaker 3 (22:52):
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (22:52):
I mean also at that point, you're very sleep deprived,
You're very tired. That makes everything more difficult. So the
female officer when she arrived, what happens at that point.
Speaker 2 (23:06):
So she arrives and her and the male officer interview
me together. The female officer was there just to be there.
The man was interviewing me, and immediately he.
Speaker 3 (23:24):
He made me feel comfortable.
Speaker 2 (23:26):
He just asked me what happened, and I started to
tell him my story. I wasn't sure if I even
remembered the guy's name. I think I said it was
Craig or Greg. I got through the story and he said,
I believe this happened to you.
Speaker 3 (23:47):
I just felt relief immediately.
Speaker 2 (23:51):
I don't think I was consciously thinking that I wouldn't
be believed, but just having that reassurance of I had
just said the most horrible thing that had happened to me,
and for him to say I believe this happened to you,
I felt.
Speaker 3 (24:03):
Like, maybe it will be okay.
Speaker 2 (24:08):
And then I remember just once Nick and Carla were
done with their interviews, we drove back to Nick's house.
Speaker 1 (24:23):
The drive from the hospital back to Nick's house that
night was mostly silent. At one point, Cassie tried to
call her mother and tell her what happened, but she
couldn't get the words out.
Speaker 4 (24:33):
She threw up.
Speaker 1 (24:34):
Nick took over the call. The detectives at the hospital
had asked Cassie to stay in town for another twenty
four hours because they'd have more questions for her. So
they went back to Nick's house and tried to get
some rest, and so I.
Speaker 2 (24:46):
Remember actually getting a little bit of sleep, and then
I remember being woken up by a detective at Nick's house.
Speaker 1 (24:57):
So he was physically in the house waking you up.
Speaker 3 (25:00):
The detective, Yeah, he was knocking on the door.
Speaker 2 (25:02):
I guess they had said they had tried to call
all of us, but we were all so tired none
of us spoke up to the phone call, and so, yeah,
so we woke up to it was Nick's roommate actually
opened the door and was for the officer and said,
you detectives are here to speak with you. And so
I remember kind of still being in pajamas, and they
had to drive me by the fraternity to physically point
(25:26):
out which one it had happened at. So I remember
being even scared to do that. I didn't even want
to drive by in a police car that I knew
I was totally safe. They showed me six photos of
men and I had to pick out. Greg was in
(25:48):
one of them, and I ended up picking him out
of the lineup. But I remember feeling so nervous, like,
oh my gosh, what if I messed this up? And
then once I picked out, you know, I said, I
think it's it's this guy.
Speaker 3 (26:03):
Then they said zero to one hundred? What percent?
Speaker 2 (26:06):
Are you sure that it's this guy? And then I
remember that stressed me out even more. I'm like, do
I say one hundred percent? But then what if it's wrong?
Then I, you know, should have said a lower percent.
I just remember already questioning myself how I was answering things.
Pretty sure I landed on I just picked like seventy
percent or something because I felt like I couldn't say
(26:28):
one hundred percent.
Speaker 3 (26:30):
It ended up being him.
Speaker 1 (26:32):
That thirty percent that you decided to sort of buffer in,
you know, you had spent a couple of hours with him.
What was that?
Speaker 2 (26:40):
Honestly, I think it was I was scared to be
wrong now looking back on it, and like, that was
one hundred percent him, And I'm pretty sure I knew that,
but I didn't want to say one hundred percent because
what if I was wrong and messed it up. I
felt it was such a traumatic experience for me. I
(27:01):
felt like I could pick him out of you know,
any group of people, like it was just burned into
my memory. But yeah, that's kind of Thirty percent was
just I don't want to be wrong. I don't want
to mess it up, So I'm going to go with
a number that's like more than fifty. But I don't
want to go all into it because what if I
am wrong?
Speaker 4 (27:23):
So it's already it's like a test anxiety, Yes, exactly,
super high stakes test someone puts in front of you,
and it's like if you fill in the wrong bubble,
you might never whatever, you might never get justice or something.
So it sounds like it was just like that anxiety
of like this high pressure question like how sure are you?
Speaker 2 (27:42):
Totally because I thought I didn't even think there was
going to be like how sure are you? I was
just Okay, I'm going to pick this guy, and so
then to kind of well how sure are you? Then
I even started thinking like, okay, are you asking that?
Because did I pick the wrong guy?
Speaker 1 (27:55):
Cassie did not pick the wrong guy. DNA found any
underwear Soko was wearing that night was later tested, and
those test results gave a one and ten billion chance
that the DNA belonged to anyone but Cassie. That is
considered a very strong positive DNA match. Cassie's medical examination
also showed that she had vaginal tearing, which is where
(28:17):
Cassie believes the blood came from. She was overwhelmed, but
for now the police were done asking Cassie questions. She
could finally go back home to Portland, and when she
got there, she went straight to her parents' house, where
she stayed for almost a month.
Speaker 2 (28:31):
I wanted to be with my parents, so I was
in pajamas all day, like just wanting to feel that
like comfort, blankets, like all the time. It felt like
I was ye like reverting to like a child. And
I remember also at that point being able to take
a shower, and I just still remember I could could
(28:54):
not get the water hot enough and after a very
long shower that I wanted to take a bath. It
was just such a feeling of I was just violated,
and I remember not really sleeping much that first night,
and then the next day I got a phone call
that they had found that it was Gregory's soaco and
(29:19):
he had been arrested and he was in jail in Corellis.
And then a couple of days later I got the
call that he had posted bail. His parents had come
and posted bail. The district attorney called me, I was
going to be going in for a grand jury hearing
(29:41):
to see if this case, if it was even going
to go to trial, there was enough evidence to take
it to trial. Also, at this point, like I first
kind of got inside of what it was going to
be like to be a victim in this legal process.
And there was believe it was eater ten people and
(30:02):
they could ask me questions when I was done telling
my story. And this was also the first time where
one of the men asked me why didn't you scream?
Speaker 3 (30:13):
Why didn't you say anything?
Speaker 2 (30:15):
If there were people around, if you could hear people outside,
why didn't you yell for help? And that was the
first time I got kind of hit with that victim blaming.
And I remember at that time I didn't really know
how to answer that. I was just like I was
(30:35):
in shock. I couldn't, you know. And then I also
remember feeling like, Okay, maybe I did the wrong thing,
I guess ORed, and so that was kind of my
first experience with the victim blaming and where I started
to maybe think, Okay, maybe this trial, this legal process
is going to be different and harder than I thought.
(30:59):
It felt like I was more on trial that I
had to prove myself in some way.
Speaker 1 (31:07):
Right, because you know, it's like you are not personally
bringing these charges. The state, right is bringing these charges.
The state has determined they think that something happened here
and that they can win this case.
Speaker 3 (31:19):
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (31:20):
So the grand jury does return an indictment.
Speaker 2 (31:24):
Yes, and at this point Greg is just he's out.
He had gone back to California and the story it
was on like the local news, and so that was
also a weird feeling. I remember watching the TV and
it came on and it was just like, you know,
(31:46):
it was just like turn it off.
Speaker 3 (31:48):
You know, I can't I can't see his mug.
Speaker 1 (31:51):
Shot or because you were not identified, but he was.
Speaker 2 (31:55):
He was, Yes, I was just identified as a Portland
State student.
Speaker 3 (32:01):
The stories would be online and people were able.
Speaker 2 (32:07):
To comment on the stories, and that that was also
a big thing for me that I could not stop
myself from looking up the news stories and then reading
all the hundreds of comments that people were just posting.
Almost all of them were bashing me, even though these
(32:30):
people didn't know who I was. But it was always,
you know, why she had a fraternity party? What did
she think was going to happen there? I heard that
she was wearing did you see her costume? Or just
you know, all these horrible things, And I just remember
I would just be sitting at my computer just crying
and trying to explain to my mom and my sister
(32:54):
and my friends like that I couldn't just stop looking
it up. I don't know, it was a very strange feeling.
It's like I couldn't look away from it.
Speaker 3 (33:03):
I had.
Speaker 2 (33:03):
I was checking daily, are there any new comments? And
it made me mad, and it made me sad, and
it just kind of just made me spiral.
Speaker 3 (33:14):
And then finally the.
Speaker 2 (33:17):
District Attorney's office just called me and said, okay, trials
set for May.
Speaker 3 (33:22):
So this is in two thousand and nine.
Speaker 2 (33:24):
Now, they had told me that that was actually a
pretty quick turnaround time from the assault happening in on
Halloween in two thousand and eight, and then for trial
to be in May two thousand and nine.
Speaker 1 (33:37):
Was Gregory offered a plea deal he was, did he
accept the plea deal?
Speaker 3 (33:44):
He did not.
Speaker 2 (33:45):
His whole defense became he was too drunk, He was
blackout drunk, so he can't be held accountable for what
he did during that time.
Speaker 1 (33:56):
At the trial, Gregory Sacho's defense leaned heavily into the
r that he simply didn't remember what happened that night
because he'd had too much to drink, but that if
something sexual did happen, then it must have been consensual.
At the Halloween party, fraternity members had been tallying drinks
on their arms. Gregory Sacho's arm showed twenty eight tally marks,
(34:17):
one for every drink he consumed, but at the same time,
Cassie's two drinks over the course of the entire evening
were heavily scrutinized during the trial.
Speaker 2 (34:28):
Yeah, I remember thinking that of like, you're going to
give me this much of a hard time, and I
had two drinks and he had what was marked as
twenty eight, Like it's I just yeah, remember being and
also just thinking, Okay, I'm a college student. You know,
me and my friends have all been very drunk a
(34:49):
handful of times. You don't rape people, that's not that's
not something that you do right, even if you are
very drunk.
Speaker 3 (34:58):
That's not a defense. That was ridiculous.
Speaker 2 (35:02):
And I also remember feeling even a little bit angry
like he I think he had made a statement like
I don't even remember meeting her.
Speaker 3 (35:10):
That made me feel angry.
Speaker 2 (35:11):
It's like you you raped me, and I cannot get
you out of my head, but yet you don't remember
meeting me.
Speaker 3 (35:19):
That really pissed me off.
Speaker 1 (35:22):
The trial took place seven months after the alleged drape.
For Cassie, it was not only the terror that came
with retelling her story in front of an audience, but
this strange and performative aspect of presenting herself to a jury.
Cover your tattoos, don't wear heels, wear makeup but not
too much makeup, be authentic but not too emotional. And
(35:42):
as if all of this wasn't difficult enough, Gregorysacho had
a lot of supporters, people who simply couldn't imagine he
would do this.
Speaker 2 (35:51):
Just seeing like the whole fraternity there, his family. I
remember feeling very intimidated by especially his mom.
Speaker 3 (36:03):
Again like silly things.
Speaker 2 (36:04):
You remember, it's you know, there's one woman's bathroom in
this courthouse. And I remember multiple times like washing my
hands next to his mom and just feeling terrified, like
she looked at me like I was ruining everything. That's
what I remember a lot about trials, feeling intimidated and.
Speaker 3 (36:27):
Scared.
Speaker 2 (36:29):
There was a little part of me I knew that
I wanted to keep doing this because I had also
had once I kind of started talking to more people.
A lot of acquaintances or friends of friends. Women would
come up and shared their stories, and I started to
feel like I was a part of this sad club
(36:54):
that nobody wanted to be in. But I felt like
I was getting more and more support hearing from all
these people. I had no ideas, like I had been
you know, acquaintances from high school that I thought I
knew fairly well, and then they would come up to
me and say that this happened to me at a
fraternity party as well, my sister had this happen. I
kind of held on to those stories to kind of
(37:17):
give me strength that trial, like I'm not alone in this.
The district attorney who ended up getting very close to you,
he's a great man, he had told me, he said,
you know, sadly, it's not about the truth. It's about
what you can prove in court, and that's always stuck
(37:38):
with me. The trial was four days and then on Friday,
the fifth day, the jury went out to deliberate, which
took a few hours, and then they came back with
their verdict and he was found guilty.
Speaker 1 (37:55):
On Tuesday May nineteenth, two thousand and nine, Gregory's Echo
was sentenced to eight years and four months for the
crime of first degree rape. After his sentence was completed,
he would then have eleven years of parole and have
to register as a sex offender.
Speaker 2 (38:11):
He was taken into custody right then, is handcuffed, taken away,
and then a week later I went back and spoke
at his sentencing, and that was a really empowering time
for me at as much time as I wanted to
say whatever I wanted, and that felt really good.
Speaker 3 (38:29):
Yeah, and then I'm left to kind of just go
on my life.
Speaker 4 (38:34):
So he is convicted and taken into custody, and I guess,
in you know, the movie version, that would sort of
be the end credits and there would be this sense
of victory. But you know, we know that that's not
really how it works legally, and maybe mainly emotionally, once
you've been through something like this, what did life look
(38:55):
like for you? After the trial?
Speaker 2 (38:58):
A family friend had spoken to me about that I
potentially had a lawsuit case that they had a lawyer
that they wanted me to speak with, and I ended
up speaking with him, and he was a personal injury lawyer,
and he thought that this was a really interesting case.
He also had daughters, and he said, I'm passionate about this.
(39:19):
I feel like around that time, it was kind of
coming out more about kind of some of these like
dangers at these fraternity environments, and it seemed like all
these bad things that kept happening at fraternities that they
weren't held really accountable in any way. And like the
lawyer had explained to me, you know, unfortunately, the way
to kind of get things to change is to have
(39:41):
them have to pay.
Speaker 3 (39:42):
Money, like that's what matters to these people.
Speaker 1 (39:46):
Pursuing a civil case against the fraternity meant that Cassie
would have to retell her story of the worst night
of her life all over again, after having just recently
gone through the trial. The civil suit was filed in
twenty ten, but was unsuccessful. Cassie lost in twenty twelve,
she appealed and in twenty fifteen she won.
Speaker 2 (40:06):
In twenty fifteen, they ruled in my favor, which in Oregon,
that was the first time the appeals court addressed if
fraternities could be held accountable for sexual assaults and rape
that happened on their premises, And so it kind of
set a precedent and made fraternities kind of think more
about their policies that they could have in place, kind
(40:29):
of regarding members drinking or cutting off access to personal rooms.
Speaker 1 (40:36):
Wow, so there was some you know, at least real
policy change there as a result of this. Yeah, that
feels important.
Speaker 2 (40:45):
Yes, definitely, that was really helpful for me, I think healing.
Speaker 1 (40:50):
Gregory Sacho served the entirety of his sentence, and in
twenty seventeen he was released. He moved back to California,
but was on parole and had to register as a
second Cassie had been working hard to move on with
her life. She'd gotten married, she'd become a mother. Finally
it started to feel like the darkest and most difficult
chapter of her life was ending. In twenty twenty two,
(41:13):
Cassie gave birth to twins, and just five days after
giving birth, She was laying on her sofa breastfeeding when
the phone ring. It was a crime victim advocate calling
to let her know that Gregorysacho was no longer on parole,
he was no longer a registered sex offender, and he
was no longer guilty of first degree rape. His two
thousand and nine conviction had been invalidated. Part of the
(41:36):
reason this crime victim called was to see if Cassie
felt like going through another trial if the state were
to once again pursue a first degree rape charge for
Gregory Sacho.
Speaker 2 (41:47):
If I didn't go forward, he was just free from everything,
everything was wiped off, his record, didn't have to register
as a sex offender, and so I was also so
in shock. Then took some days to think about it,
and I decided I did want to try to just
go forward and do trial again.
Speaker 3 (42:10):
So a couple months later, we were at a first
kind of.
Speaker 2 (42:14):
Pre trial hearing and greg was out, so he's appearing
over zoom and so it was the first time even
just seeing him like on a screen. You're both present
for this hearing, and the judge already was coming at
me with he literally said, why would you want to
(42:37):
go through with this again. You know, Greg has already
served his time. His life has already been ruined enough.
Why do we need to do this again. I was
trying to be so composed, and I just remember at
that time just breaking down crying, and the DA stepped
in for me and just said, Calsie's life has been
greatly changed as well, and brought me back to that.
(43:01):
It was just so much victim blaming. Still, why would
I want to do this to him again? He's already
served his time. Can't I just.
Speaker 3 (43:08):
Let this go? And that made me mad.
Speaker 2 (43:12):
But after a few weeks of kind of just I
kind of feel like I had kind of like a
mini breakdown, kind of started spiraling and decided I didn't
want to go through with trial again. I made the
decision that what was best for me. I was, you know,
a mom of three under two at that time. I
(43:33):
just couldn't do this again, even if it meant it
made me so angry that he was just going to
have a clean record and not have to register, but
it was what was best for me at the time.
Speaker 1 (43:44):
The jury that had delivered Sacho's guilty verdict back in
two thousand and nine was not unanimous, but At the time,
Oregon law didn't require a unanimous verdict. It required a
majority of ten out of the twelve jurors, except in
the case of first Dream murder. In twenty twenty, the
US Supreme Court ruled that the sixth Amendment to the
US Constitution required a unanimous verdict for serious criminal offenders.
(44:08):
So in twenty twenty two, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled
that this decision would apply retroactively, which meant it applied
to Greg Graysacho. His conviction was no longer valid. It
was almost like it never happened. He was no longer
on parole, he was no longer a registered sex offender, and.
Speaker 2 (44:27):
So I agreed to let him just plead. He wouldn't
even plead not guilty. Is that is, I guess, admitting
something he pled no contest to, just like a minor
assault charge. So there's nothing sexual. So he's off the registry.
I'm okay with it now. I mean, it's not ideal,
(44:51):
that was I mean, ultimately I fought trial to get
him convicted to have to have that consequence, which to
me seems very minor to what he put me through,
Like you should have to pay for what you did
by registering. Even if I know that he's off the
registry and doesn't have it on his record, I know
(45:15):
what happened. Everybody that is important to me knows what happened,
and I've come to realize that's what matters, and I
have to be okay with that.
Speaker 4 (45:26):
Yeah, I'm asking this question as someone who wants to
understand as well as I think maybe listeners will have
this question. But I'm not indicating that you shouldn't feel
like you want him on the sex offender list, because
I don't. I think you should feel how you want
to feel. I'm curious to know if he had to
(45:48):
still register as a sex offender, why do you think
that's important.
Speaker 3 (45:53):
I think that's a very valid question.
Speaker 2 (45:55):
And I had to think about that a lot too,
kind of when I was going through this, and I
think for me, what I felt was important about it
was he was out of prison and so that part
was done, but that registering as a sex offender felt
like something else he would have to do as a
(46:15):
consequence of what he did for me, and it felt
important as something that would still kind of change his life,
affect his life in some way, because I felt like
I was so greatly affected in so many ways. I
would have to get you know, anxiety meds to even
(46:37):
have a PAP smear. My whole birthing experience was that
was all very triggering and I had to get help
support around that, like just to get birth.
Speaker 3 (46:48):
It's felt like my life was so.
Speaker 2 (46:49):
Affected still and still is that him registering as a
sex offender felt like a little bit that it would
still affect his life in some way.
Speaker 4 (47:02):
Yeah, that makes total sense.
Speaker 1 (47:05):
How are you today today?
Speaker 3 (47:08):
I'm doing great.
Speaker 2 (47:10):
I'm finally at the point where it's a part of
my story, but it doesn't feel like it's my identity anymore.
And I think there's been so much that's gone into
that because it's been so long, lots of therapy and
work on myself, and also I feel like telling my
(47:30):
story has been a big part of the healing journey
for me. I'm part of the Rain Speaker's Bureau, where
I've shared my story. I've spoken at fraternities and sororities,
specifically in some college criminology classes.
Speaker 3 (47:45):
But that's also been a way that I feel like.
Speaker 2 (47:48):
It's helped make me the person that I am today.
Where I'm on the other side of this and able
to share my story as someone who feels strong where
I am now.
Speaker 1 (48:03):
Yeah, I think that's amazing, probably so powerful for those
people at those sororities and fraternities to hear a story
like yours and you know, nobody thinks it's going to
be them.
Speaker 4 (48:16):
I'm so appreciative of you reaching out and telling us
your story. I think it's like really powerful and you
tell it so well. So thank you so much. I'm
so glad that Cassie spoke with us and was willing
to tell us her story. I really found it to
(48:37):
be very powerful.
Speaker 1 (48:38):
Yeah, Cassie reached out to us in an email she
had listened to the show, and it feels really great
that we were a safe space for her to share this.
Speaker 4 (48:48):
Yeah, it does.
Speaker 1 (48:49):
One thing that it really stood out in the interview
is Cassie's experience getting a rape kit reporting to law
enforcement was so traumatizing, and she mentioned several times that
without having the support of two really close friends that
stayed by her side through the entire process, she probably
wouldn't have been able to do it.
Speaker 4 (49:11):
Cheers to her friends, seriously, what great friends. I loved
that part of the story where they were by her
side and helped her when she was like in chock
to know what to do for her best interest. It
was really really great, and her walking us through everything
that happened at the hospital was really powerful as well.
We hear so often from people like that experience can
(49:33):
be traumatizing, and I believe them, but it's a little vague,
and Cassie really walked us through exactly why and how
that is. Yeah, and it's easy to understand.
Speaker 1 (49:42):
And you know, one organization that Cassie mentioned to me
on one of our preliminary calls is the Rape, Abuse
and Incest National Network, And I looked up some statistics
on their website that really speak to Cassie's story and
what turns out to be, you know, sometimes a common
story on college campuses, and that is sexual violence among
(50:05):
undergraduate students. Twenty six point four percent of females and
six point eight percent of males experience rape or sexual
assault through physical force, violence or incapacitation.
Speaker 4 (50:17):
And only twenty percent of female student victims ages eighteen
to twenty four report to law enforcement. Hearing Cassie's story,
you know, these statistics aren't surprising, but like it's really sad.
And while it's not difficult to understand, I think it's
important to remember that there are so many more stories
out there that don't get reported.
Speaker 1 (50:38):
Yeah, and you know, the trauma didn't end after the trial,
as we heard from Cassie. So in two thousand and
nine the trial, Greg gory Sako's convicted of rape and
he's sentenced to prison, and he does go to prison,
and so at that point Cassie has this small sense
of like justice in her life. And then in twenty ten,
(51:02):
Greg Gorysaco's parents they end up publishing a guest opinion
in a smaller news publication called The Almanac, and it's
titled Guest Opinion How Alcohol Ruined a Student's Dreams. And
the letter is really troubling in my opinion. I mean,
it's essentially this warning shot for college students, like heavy
(51:23):
drinking could leave you very vulnerable to false accusations. I mean,
that is how I interpret what they're saying. And the
letter also references an accuser of their son, Greg Graysako,
who they name in the letter, but never references this
person as a victim.
Speaker 4 (51:39):
And you know, interesting, even though he's in prison at
this point that this has been convicted right at this
point of the letter being published. He's convicted and he's
in prison. And one quote from this opinion piece is
the problem with this case was that at the time
the alleged incident occurred, Gregory and his accuser were very
(52:00):
drunk or quote hammered as you might say. Okay, so
this is the quote from the piece, and a lot
of inaccuracy, a lot of inaccuracies.
Speaker 1 (52:10):
We know that Cassie was not drunk at this party,
and it is my interpretation that there's Cassie they're talking about, yeah,
and his accuser, his accuser, and Cassie has always maintained
that she had only two drinks the entire evening. In fact,
there was a moment at the hospital where law enforcement,
(52:31):
you know, determined she was sober to a point where
they didn't even need to take a toxicology test because
there was no reason to they didn't believe that she
was intoxicated. Yeah, and her friends also corroborated that version
of the night. So it's troubling to call her an
accuser and to say that she was hammered. She wasn't.
Speaker 4 (52:53):
Whereas it seems pretty clear that Gregory Sacho was based
on witness accounts as well as the fact that they
had been tallying the number of drinks in their arms
and he had twenty eight tally marks. But yeah, regardless,
you know, I think that there's been a lot sort
of written about the dangers of alcohol, and hey, that's fair, right, Like, yes,
(53:14):
alcohol can be very dangerous, but it's oftentimes been written
about in conjunction with the conversation around sexual assault and
rape on college campuses and sort of been pointed to, like, well,
that's the problem. Well, alcohol is the problem, and I'm
not saying it's not a problem, but it's not the
full answer.
Speaker 1 (53:34):
Right, It's not an excuse, it's not It might impaired judgment,
and it might lead to an increased risk of sexual violence,
but it certainly doesn't negate anything.
Speaker 4 (53:46):
Because there's plenty of people who get quote unquote hammered,
as they say in their letter, that don't act violent
or commit crimes against other people. And so obviously there's
another issue deeper in there that I think it's important
to look at.
Speaker 1 (54:01):
Yeah, absolutely so.
Speaker 4 (54:04):
In twenty twenty two, Sako's conviction for first degree rape
was invalidated and we talked about that in the episode.
It was because whenever his conviction happened, it was ORGAN
law that there had to be at least ten out
of twelve jurors for a conviction, and they, for whatever reason,
had that amount, you know, and he was convicted. And
then in twenty twenty two, based on a twenty twenty
(54:27):
Supreme Court ruling, Organ decided this would be retroactive in
all violent cases, which automatically meant that his conviction was invalidated.
It wasn't like under review. It just boom, it was over.
It was over. He no longer had a record, he
no longer had to register as a sex offender. He
(54:47):
had already served his time. So the big piece of this, though,
that we talked with Cassie about, is this idea of
him not having to register as a sex offender. And
it's sort of a hot topic. There's an ongoing debate
about the usefulness of sex offender registry. You know, there's
some people that say it does more harm than good
because it can create a false sense of security. It
(55:10):
can also disproportionately impact certain demographics and make it more
difficult for someone who's been convicted of various sexual offenses
to rehabilitate or reintegrate into society. You know, if there's
one person who has to register as a sex offender
in like a multi family home, this affects everyone in
that house. There's also a lot of good arguments in
(55:33):
favor of the sex offender registry that people, I think
rightly so want to know if there's someone who has
been convicted of a sexual offense who's in their neighborhood.
So I wanted to talk to Cassie about this because
it really seemed to impact her a lot, This idea
that Sokko would no longer have to register as a
(55:53):
sex offender. This, clearly when we talked to her, was
upsetting to her. He'd already served his time. But you know,
I was really curious to understand why that was a
piece that was such a big deal, so important to her.
And I think she made a really good point because
she talked. She talked about like, well, she doesn't get
the chance to sort of wipe this clean from her life,
(56:14):
Like even though she's moved on and she is happy
and has a good life, it's not like this doesn't
still affect her. It's never over for Cassie. It's something
that she lives with all the time. I mean even
in her first email to us, it was apparent how
deeply present this still is in her life and in
her mind. Yeah, I mean that moment when she talked
(56:36):
about like being remind of it, of it when she
was giving birth, It's like that sucks.
Speaker 1 (56:42):
That sucks. That should be just like such a beautiful memory.
I mean, childbirth is a lot of things, but like
I think most of us are able to look back
on it as like, Wow, what an incredible day, and
hers is haunted by this terrible thing that happened to her. Yeah,
only broad in my understanding of that perspective. And I
(57:03):
was really appreciative of her for sharing her thoughts and
feelings on it. Yeah, we're really thankful to Cassie for
sharing her story with us. Well, thank you so much
for listening. That is our episode for this week. We'll
be back next week. If you have a story for us,
we would love to hear it. Our email is The
Knife at Exactlyrightmedia dot com, or you can follow us
on Instagram at the Knife podcast or a Blue Sky
(57:26):
at the Knife Podcast.
Speaker 4 (57:27):
This has been an Exactly Right production, hosted and produced
by me Hannah Smith.
Speaker 3 (57:32):
And me Paytia Eten.
Speaker 1 (57:33):
Our producers are Tom Bryfogel and Alexis Samarosi.
Speaker 4 (57:36):
This episode was mixed by Tom Bryfogel.
Speaker 1 (57:39):
Our associate producer is Christina Chamberlain.
Speaker 4 (57:41):
Our theme music is by Birds in the Airport.
Speaker 1 (57:44):
Artwork by Vanessa Lilac.
Speaker 4 (57:45):
Executive produced by Karen Kilgarriff, Georgia Hardstark, and Danielle Kramer.
This story contains adult content and language. Listener discretion is advised.
Speaker 2 (00:07):
Things started to hit me more of this really just happened, and.
Speaker 3 (00:13):
This is bad.
Speaker 4 (00:31):
Welcome to the Knife. I'm Hannah Smith.
Speaker 1 (00:33):
I'm patia Eton. This week we're speaking with a woman
named Cassie. In two thousand and eight, Cassie attended a
Halloween party at a fraternity at Oregon State University. The
party started out just like you'd picture it, fun costumes,
loud music.
Speaker 4 (00:45):
It was a packed house, but the night ended with
Cassie walking into an emergency room with her bloodstained costume
in a bag. After being seen by a doctor, she
would meet with two detectives who wanted to know exactly
what happened at that part.
Speaker 1 (01:00):
Let's get into the interview.
Speaker 2 (01:05):
So I'm from Portland, Oregon, and I grew up in
just the suburbs, just kind of pretty typical childhood. I
went to a private high school. I loved high school.
I had a great time, but I was also very
excited for college. I've never really been away from home
(01:31):
or my parents, so I ended up going to Oregon
State University.
Speaker 3 (01:36):
In Oregon.
Speaker 2 (01:37):
It's like growing up, you're either you're a dock or
a beaver in Oregon State is the Beaver's in My
family was always beavers, and so it kind of was
always that's where I'm going to go. Yeah, I was
excited for like that whole college experience.
Speaker 1 (01:52):
What were you looking forward to about, you know, going
off to college and what did you expect it to be?
Speaker 2 (01:57):
Like I was looking forward to just I guess freedom
is the best way to kind of that independence and
freedom of making my own choices. And it felt like
it was a way for me to kind of have
like a new start. I don't know if it was
just like a Catholic high school thing, but before we
(02:20):
went off to college, I feel like we were, you know,
kind of told that college could be scary and parties
could be scary, and I remember feeling nervous about stuff
like that. But when I made friends with these guys
that joined fraternities, it felt like, well, these parties aren't scary,
Like I just remember feeling it was a really like
(02:41):
care free time.
Speaker 3 (02:43):
I never worried about anything. My girlfriends would come.
Speaker 2 (02:46):
And it was just kind of like we were all
just like a big group of friends.
Speaker 3 (02:49):
I never felt scared.
Speaker 1 (02:53):
After spending her freshman year at Oregon State, Cassie was
feeling homesick, so in the fall of two thousand and seven,
she transferred to Portland's and it was the best of
both worlds. During the week she could be closer to
her family, but on the weekend she could hop on
I five and see all of her friends at OSU.
A few of those friends were involved in Greek life,
and OSU's Greek road doesn't look much different than it
(03:14):
does in the movies. Big houses, tree lined streets, buzzing
with students who are excited to belong to a social
network meant to last far beyond their college years. It
was exciting and it was a good time in Cassie's life.
But in the fall of two thousand and eight, everything changed.
Speaker 2 (03:31):
The fraternity that I spent a lot of time at
was Delta Kai, and one of my really good friends
at the time was a part of that fraternity, and
they were going to be hosting a joint party with
five Kapa PSI and I had never actually been to
that fraternity, but I was at Delta Chai all the time,
(03:53):
and it sounded really fun. There were only so many
people that were going to be in vie and so
it was exciting. So me and my girlfriend drove down
from Portland, and I remember being so excited trying to
find the perfect costume and I ended up choosing I
was Tinkerbell that night, and I was excited to be
(04:17):
at a new fraternity, meet new people, and there was
four of us that were going to meet up and
go to the party, and I was just really excited.
And I just remember all that excited energy of listening
to music and getting ready before the party and doing
makeup and just being really happy.
Speaker 1 (04:38):
Yeah, and it's such a specific experience to get dressed
up for Halloween and college in a town where it's
really cold at time of.
Speaker 2 (04:47):
Yes, totally, it was definitely like a time and a
place where we were just, you know, my girlfriend and
I had our little playlist that we had made to
do our makeup and hair, and definitely it was cold
a moment.
Speaker 1 (05:00):
Right, It's like you're an adult, but you're also dressed
up lake tinker Bell and you're going out with your friends. Yes,
tell us about arriving to the party. What did it
look and feel like? What were your first impressions of
the people and the vibe there.
Speaker 2 (05:14):
When we showed up it was, I think, bigger than
I thought it was going to be. There were a
lot of people lined up, like waiting to get inside.
There's like a whole guest list situation, and I remember
being cold waiting in line, and then when we finally
got up there, we weren't on the guest list, so
it was like, that's such a bummer and another typical
(05:36):
college thing where you're not on the list, can't get
into the party. And I remember kind of arguing with
the guy at the door and trying to get a
hold of my friend that was the fraternity member inside,
and I just remember it being.
Speaker 3 (05:49):
Loud, but also just it felt like fun. I was
still excited.
Speaker 2 (05:54):
Now, of course, looking back on it, I'm always like, well,
what if we just turned away.
Speaker 1 (05:59):
It's been almost two decades since Halloween two thousand and eight,
but sometimes this question still nags at Cassie. What if
she had just turned away? How might her life be different?
What version of herself would she be? That's because this
night that started out so full of joy and anticipation
unfolded in a way that would play out in the
(06:21):
media and in a courtroom, altering the course of Cassie's life.
But Cassie did get into the party and that night,
she walked in like any other college student, excited to
have fun on Halloween.
Speaker 2 (06:33):
But I got ahold of my friend and he came
up to the front door and let us all in.
I hadn't seen him in a while, and I remember
like giving him a big hug and saying I was
excited to be there.
Speaker 3 (06:45):
And it was just it was fun.
Speaker 2 (06:49):
Like we could hear the music, we could hear the
party downstairs in the basement, and so we were all
just excited to go down there and dance and hang out.
So there's like the makeshift college bar. There's super loud music.
That was two thousand and eight. Britney Spears had just
kind of come back and they were playing Womanizer, which
(07:09):
was one of me and my girlfriend's favorite songs, and
I remember hearing that as we came downstairs, and.
Speaker 3 (07:15):
We were just so happy, and it was just busy and.
Speaker 2 (07:18):
Dark, but like the whole glow, you know, black light thing.
It was just it was fun and there was a
lot of people, which most of the fraternity parties I
had been to hadn't been quite that big, but this
was a joint party between two houses, so it kind
of made sense. But we were just excited to dance.
And I remember the four of us kind of, you know,
(07:41):
got into the crowd and just kind of started dancing
and having a good time, and I was I was excited.
I remember just feeling really happy that I'd always loved
Halloween and but like it was going to be a
really good night.
Speaker 1 (07:56):
Yeah, those four people. Can you tell us who those
four people are?
Speaker 3 (08:00):
Yeah?
Speaker 2 (08:01):
So I was with my best friend Nick, who was
the one that was at Oregon State that we were
staying at his house, and we had been best friends
since high school. And then my other best friend, Carla,
who I had known also since high school. We were
on the same cheerleading team, and then we were with
(08:23):
one of Nick's roommates. Like I said, Carla and I
would go down there almost every weekend and stay at
Nick's house with him and his roommate, and so we're
all very close. I was also fairly newly single, so
it was kind of like, oh, I'm excited to see,
you know, maybe I can meet someone. I think we
had maybe been kind of dancing hanging out for maybe
(08:44):
an hour. It was like we were dancing and I
kind of like turned around and actually physically I ran.
Speaker 3 (08:49):
Into who are now know? It was Greg.
Speaker 2 (08:52):
And he was dressed as a Heineken bottle and were
kind of laughing about that, and then we kind of
ended up like talking, or as much as you can
talk on the crowded dance floor, and so then we
started dancing and everything was fine.
Speaker 3 (09:11):
I was having a good time.
Speaker 2 (09:12):
We ended up we were kissing on the dance floor,
and then all of a sudden I noticed I had
lost track of Nick and Carla, but I didn't think
too much of it at the time.
Speaker 3 (09:25):
And then after more time went.
Speaker 2 (09:26):
On, maybe you know, half an hour, forty five minutes,
and I still couldn't find them, and I was like thinking, Okay,
we should find them and maybe we can figure out.
We hadn't gotten anything to drink at that time, so
I'm like, oh, maybe they went to go get.
Speaker 3 (09:38):
A drink, and I want to go do that with them.
Speaker 1 (09:49):
Cassie had just turned twenty one, and earlier that night,
while she and her friend were getting ready for this party,
she had a total of two drinks, but since arriving
to the party, she'd had none. It's not worth mentioning
or it wouldn't be except that every move Cassie made
that night would later be scrutinized over and over and
(10:10):
over again.
Speaker 2 (10:11):
So I told Greg, I was like, I want to
go find my friends. You know, we can get something
to drink. And I remember he said, yeah, I'll go
with you. Let's go find your friends. And so we
go upstairs and to the main level, like where the
front door was, where there was everybody getting into the party.
(10:32):
We didn't see them up there, and so we went
up to the next level where the private rooms were
for the fraternity members, and somehow we ended up we
were in his room. I don't remember if it was like, oh, hey,
we can just grab like a drink in here or whatever.
I don't know if you've been in like a fraternity room,
but they don't actually or at least at Oregon State,
(10:55):
the members didn't actually sleep in their rooms. They had
like a sleeping porch area where they're a bunch of
like bunk beds and stuff.
Speaker 3 (11:01):
So the rooms were pretty small, and that a lot.
Speaker 2 (11:04):
Of them had just like futons or chairs or whatever
in them. I was like, you know, I thought he
was cute. He was really tall. I was like, tall guys,
and so I was kind of excited. I was like, Okay,
I'm newly single. This guy seems nice and we're sitting
on the futon and we were kind of started kissing
and making out.
Speaker 3 (11:24):
Is all consensual, everything's.
Speaker 2 (11:26):
Great at that time, and then all of a sudden
he asked me if I want to have sex, and
I kind of remember kind of laughing like, no, I
just met you, dude, Like that's not really Like can't
you know this is fine right now? And that's when
it kind of shifted all of a sudden. Then he
(11:49):
seemed to like shut down, and it was like the
vibe was just different. And then I tried to get
up to leave, and he grabbed my wrist and like
pulled me back down onto the futon. And I remember
his room was right off of the basketball court, so
(12:11):
I could hear people laughing and playing basketball outside, and
I remember thinking, oh my gosh, like, why can't I
say anything? Like I felt frozen, even though he was
By that point, he was holding me down with his
forearm and had just pushed my underwear aside and was
(12:34):
raping me. And I just remember hearing that laughter and
thinking the right out there I can hear them, like
why can't I scream? Or and I can also hear
people on the other side of the door in the hallway,
and just it felt it sounds probably cliche, but it
(12:54):
totally felt like an out of body experience where I
was watching this happen to me, and.
Speaker 3 (13:02):
I remember just a lot of pain.
Speaker 2 (13:07):
It was really painful, and just I felt sad.
Speaker 3 (13:14):
I just remember crying and.
Speaker 2 (13:18):
Just wondering when it would be over, like when he
would stop, and why why he.
Speaker 3 (13:25):
Was doing this because it seemed like.
Speaker 2 (13:31):
He seemed like a good guy when I met him,
as much as you can judge someone for a couple hours,
but I didn't get that kind of scary, creepy vibe
from him at all, and so I just.
Speaker 3 (13:45):
It shut down.
Speaker 1 (13:46):
It felt like it's terrible to think about finding yourself
in that situation, and you know, even though you had
met him only a couple of hours before, that is
pretty normal. You go to a party and you meet
people and you're all hanging out, and there were moments
that were consensual. It makes sense to me that you,
(14:07):
at some point in the night had felt comfortable and
then that that shifted, and so you're in you know
his room, how does it end? And how do you
get yourself away from him?
Speaker 2 (14:19):
He was finished, and I remember just kind of sitting
up and just.
Speaker 3 (14:26):
Being in shock.
Speaker 2 (14:27):
And I remember I just started to leave and I
went towards the door and it I don't know if
it was part of the shock that I was in
at the time, but I felt like I couldn't get
the door open.
Speaker 3 (14:43):
It felt locked.
Speaker 2 (14:44):
So I later found out that there wasn't a lock
on that door, but I think that just shows like
how like I could not open the door. I just
I felt like nothing, my hands weren't working, like I
couldn't connect to open the door. And I remember someone
opened the door from the outside of the room, and
(15:08):
I remember just coming out into this group and just
feeling such a.
Speaker 3 (15:16):
My brain felt hazy is the best description. I felt
like a zombie.
Speaker 2 (15:23):
I was now on the third floor and I had
to go downstairs. I remember I couldn't remember or figure
out which way the stairs were, and I just remember
kind of going in circles and I ended up running
into my friend, the fraternity member that had invited me
to the party, and I remember telling him I need
(15:45):
to find Nick and Carla and then he was actually
the first one that told me. He said, why is
there blood all over your costume? I hadn't even noticed,
and I looked down and there was just blood all
over the skirt part of the Tinkerbell costume.
Speaker 3 (16:02):
And then I told him, I said, I think I
was raped.
Speaker 2 (16:05):
And so then he just like frantically like tried to
find Nick and Carla, and we ended up finding them,
and I remember Nick making a really big deal like
we need to leave, she needs to get to the hospital,
and I remember fraternity members trying to get us to.
Speaker 3 (16:24):
Not go to the hospital. Oh my god, Yeah.
Speaker 2 (16:29):
I remember parts of it. And then from speaking with Nick.
Nick was not a very confrontational guy, and I remember
him getting very angry and yelling that we need It
was like they were almost physically trying to stop us
from leaving and saying, you know what, we can who
(16:52):
was it? We can, we can figure out. Let's go
find him. We'll talk about this. And I don't really
remember what I was thinking at that point. I kind
of let Nick and Carla be in charge, like, Okay,
I need to go to the hospital. I'm going to
do whatever they say. And then I remember just we
(17:14):
had walked to the party. I was sitting outside and
Nick and Carla were frantically trying to call friends with cars,
and so we finally found a friend that was already
like a designated DD for her group of friends that
she was going out with.
Speaker 3 (17:30):
We went home.
Speaker 2 (17:30):
They let me change. They put my costume and everything
into a bag to bring to the hospital. They wouldn't
let me shower.
Speaker 1 (17:39):
With her friends Nick and Carla by her side and
her blood stained tinker Bell costume in a bag, Cassie
walked into the emergency room. She waited for the doctor
for two hours before they could see her. It was excruciating.
All she wanted to do was go home. She wanted
to shower, and maybe, if not for the support of
(17:59):
Nick and Carla, she would have. But what Cassie didn't
know is that this was only the beginning of what
would be a long and painful legal process.
Speaker 2 (18:09):
The doctor was asking what had happened, and I had said,
you know, I was raped.
Speaker 3 (18:16):
I remember she asked me, you know, was.
Speaker 2 (18:19):
It or you know, vaginal and I just I couldn't
even you know, I remember saying I don't know.
Speaker 3 (18:29):
I just said I don't know. Just so many things which.
Speaker 2 (18:32):
Would later come back at trial, but now looking back
on it, I was instill just so much shock. I
couldn't even I think my brain was not even processing
what had happened. I knew I was raped, I knew
something was wrong, but I those detailed questions I couldn't.
(18:54):
I couldn't even explain what was happening or what happened
to me. And then she asked if I wanted to
talk to the police, and I, you know, I didn't
even think about it. I just I said yes, because
I knew something bad had happened to me and I
wanted to talk to them, and so she went to
(19:17):
start that process. And so then she said, I'm guessing
that would you also like a rape kit done? And
I said yes, and I remember being very scared. I
hadn't even had like my first pep smear yet, and
(19:37):
so I remember Carla stayed with me and was just
holding my hand, and I just remember crying. And it
was so painful because obviously a rape exam is it's
a crazy feeling because you're they're collecting evidence, but essentially
your body is the crime scene, so it's you know,
(20:01):
all lots of lots of poking and prodding and scraping,
and just.
Speaker 3 (20:07):
And after you had just I had just been raped.
Speaker 2 (20:10):
It felt so violating again, even though I knew I
wanted to do it to get the evidence, it was
also very triggering.
Speaker 3 (20:22):
It felt like the exam took hours. It didn't. I mean,
it's just a few minutes. And I also remember.
Speaker 2 (20:31):
They had my costume, but then they even had to
take my underwear and so having to go into the
bathroom and change and get, you know, some of their
underwear that they had at the hospital. That's when I
remember I kind of there's still so much bleeding happening,
and that was I think the born war.
Speaker 3 (20:48):
I saw that. It was like.
Speaker 2 (20:50):
Things started to hit me more of this is this
really just happened, and this is this is bad. Just
remember feeling scared and then even worse at that point
than the police separated all three of us, and so
(21:11):
I remember waiting in a part of the hospital. It
was just like an empty waiting room for some part
of the hospital. It was dark, it was in a
super uncomfortable chair. I had to wait there alone. I
didn't know where Nick and Carla were waiting. I had
to wait there for another hour or so, which I
understand now, but they had to wait for a female
(21:32):
officer to also be available to accompany the male officer
to interview me, So that was what ended up taking
a long time. But I just remember feeling scared and
lonely and kind of angry at that point too, for
(21:54):
why couldn't I wait with my friends.
Speaker 3 (21:56):
It just.
Speaker 2 (21:58):
Felt very overwhelming and isolating, and again like everything was
taking so long, and I just wanted to go home
as well, like two am and still just waiting for
the police to show up to talk to me.
Speaker 4 (22:12):
Yeah, of course, Like I would be angry too, like
you were victimized and had to go through this terrible thing,
and now you're the one having to wait around and
like have your body invaded. I also want to give
props to you and your incredible friends for like insisting
that you do this and taking care of you. You know,
But it sounds like a really difficult experience.
Speaker 3 (22:35):
Yeah, it was very It was very difficult and.
Speaker 2 (22:41):
Not something that I ever thought a situation I never
thought that I would be in.
Speaker 4 (22:50):
Yeah, of course.
Speaker 3 (22:52):
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (22:52):
I mean also at that point, you're very sleep deprived,
You're very tired. That makes everything more difficult. So the
female officer when she arrived, what happens at that point.
Speaker 2 (23:06):
So she arrives and her and the male officer interview
me together. The female officer was there just to be there.
The man was interviewing me, and immediately he.
Speaker 3 (23:24):
He made me feel comfortable.
Speaker 2 (23:26):
He just asked me what happened, and I started to
tell him my story. I wasn't sure if I even
remembered the guy's name. I think I said it was
Craig or Greg. I got through the story and he said,
I believe this happened to you.
Speaker 3 (23:47):
I just felt relief immediately.
Speaker 2 (23:51):
I don't think I was consciously thinking that I wouldn't
be believed, but just having that reassurance of I had
just said the most horrible thing that had happened to me,
and for him to say I believe this happened to you,
I felt.
Speaker 3 (24:03):
Like, maybe it will be okay.
Speaker 2 (24:08):
And then I remember just once Nick and Carla were
done with their interviews, we drove back to Nick's house.
Speaker 1 (24:23):
The drive from the hospital back to Nick's house that
night was mostly silent. At one point, Cassie tried to
call her mother and tell her what happened, but she
couldn't get the words out.
Speaker 4 (24:33):
She threw up.
Speaker 1 (24:34):
Nick took over the call. The detectives at the hospital
had asked Cassie to stay in town for another twenty
four hours because they'd have more questions for her. So
they went back to Nick's house and tried to get
some rest, and so I.
Speaker 2 (24:46):
Remember actually getting a little bit of sleep, and then
I remember being woken up by a detective at Nick's house.
Speaker 1 (24:57):
So he was physically in the house waking you up.
Speaker 3 (25:00):
The detective, Yeah, he was knocking on the door.
Speaker 2 (25:02):
I guess they had said they had tried to call
all of us, but we were all so tired none
of us spoke up to the phone call, and so, yeah,
so we woke up to it was Nick's roommate actually
opened the door and was for the officer and said,
you detectives are here to speak with you. And so
I remember kind of still being in pajamas, and they
had to drive me by the fraternity to physically point
(25:26):
out which one it had happened at. So I remember
being even scared to do that. I didn't even want
to drive by in a police car that I knew
I was totally safe. They showed me six photos of
men and I had to pick out. Greg was in
(25:48):
one of them, and I ended up picking him out
of the lineup. But I remember feeling so nervous, like,
oh my gosh, what if I messed this up? And
then once I picked out, you know, I said, I
think it's it's this guy.
Speaker 3 (26:03):
Then they said zero to one hundred? What percent?
Speaker 2 (26:06):
Are you sure that it's this guy? And then I
remember that stressed me out even more. I'm like, do
I say one hundred percent? But then what if it's wrong?
Then I, you know, should have said a lower percent.
I just remember already questioning myself how I was answering things.
Pretty sure I landed on I just picked like seventy
percent or something because I felt like I couldn't say
(26:28):
one hundred percent.
Speaker 3 (26:30):
It ended up being him.
Speaker 1 (26:32):
That thirty percent that you decided to sort of buffer in,
you know, you had spent a couple of hours with him.
What was that?
Speaker 2 (26:40):
Honestly, I think it was I was scared to be
wrong now looking back on it, and like, that was
one hundred percent him, And I'm pretty sure I knew that,
but I didn't want to say one hundred percent because
what if I was wrong and messed it up. I
felt it was such a traumatic experience for me. I
(27:01):
felt like I could pick him out of you know,
any group of people, like it was just burned into
my memory. But yeah, that's kind of Thirty percent was
just I don't want to be wrong. I don't want
to mess it up, So I'm going to go with
a number that's like more than fifty. But I don't
want to go all into it because what if I
am wrong?
Speaker 4 (27:23):
So it's already it's like a test anxiety, Yes, exactly,
super high stakes test someone puts in front of you,
and it's like if you fill in the wrong bubble,
you might never whatever, you might never get justice or something.
So it sounds like it was just like that anxiety
of like this high pressure question like how sure are you?
Speaker 2 (27:42):
Totally because I thought I didn't even think there was
going to be like how sure are you? I was
just Okay, I'm going to pick this guy, and so
then to kind of well how sure are you? Then
I even started thinking like, okay, are you asking that?
Because did I pick the wrong guy?
Speaker 1 (27:55):
Cassie did not pick the wrong guy. DNA found any
underwear Soko was wearing that night was later tested, and
those test results gave a one and ten billion chance
that the DNA belonged to anyone but Cassie. That is
considered a very strong positive DNA match. Cassie's medical examination
also showed that she had vaginal tearing, which is where
(28:17):
Cassie believes the blood came from. She was overwhelmed, but
for now the police were done asking Cassie questions. She
could finally go back home to Portland, and when she
got there, she went straight to her parents' house, where
she stayed for almost a month.
Speaker 2 (28:31):
I wanted to be with my parents, so I was
in pajamas all day, like just wanting to feel that
like comfort, blankets, like all the time. It felt like
I was ye like reverting to like a child. And
I remember also at that point being able to take
a shower, and I just still remember I could could
(28:54):
not get the water hot enough and after a very
long shower that I wanted to take a bath. It
was just such a feeling of I was just violated,
and I remember not really sleeping much that first night,
and then the next day I got a phone call
that they had found that it was Gregory's soaco and
(29:19):
he had been arrested and he was in jail in Corellis.
And then a couple of days later I got the
call that he had posted bail. His parents had come
and posted bail. The district attorney called me, I was
going to be going in for a grand jury hearing
(29:41):
to see if this case, if it was even going
to go to trial, there was enough evidence to take
it to trial. Also, at this point, like I first
kind of got inside of what it was going to
be like to be a victim in this legal process.
And there was believe it was eater ten people and
(30:02):
they could ask me questions when I was done telling
my story. And this was also the first time where
one of the men asked me why didn't you scream?
Speaker 3 (30:13):
Why didn't you say anything?
Speaker 2 (30:15):
If there were people around, if you could hear people outside,
why didn't you yell for help? And that was the
first time I got kind of hit with that victim blaming.
And I remember at that time I didn't really know
how to answer that. I was just like I was
(30:35):
in shock. I couldn't, you know. And then I also
remember feeling like, Okay, maybe I did the wrong thing,
I guess ORed, and so that was kind of my
first experience with the victim blaming and where I started
to maybe think, Okay, maybe this trial, this legal process
is going to be different and harder than I thought.
(30:59):
It felt like I was more on trial that I
had to prove myself in some way.
Speaker 1 (31:07):
Right, because you know, it's like you are not personally
bringing these charges. The state, right is bringing these charges.
The state has determined they think that something happened here
and that they can win this case.
Speaker 3 (31:19):
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (31:20):
So the grand jury does return an indictment.
Speaker 2 (31:24):
Yes, and at this point Greg is just he's out.
He had gone back to California and the story it
was on like the local news, and so that was
also a weird feeling. I remember watching the TV and
it came on and it was just like, you know,
(31:46):
it was just like turn it off.
Speaker 3 (31:48):
You know, I can't I can't see his mug.
Speaker 1 (31:51):
Shot or because you were not identified, but he was.
Speaker 2 (31:55):
He was, Yes, I was just identified as a Portland
State student.
Speaker 3 (32:01):
The stories would be online and people were able.
Speaker 2 (32:07):
To comment on the stories, and that that was also
a big thing for me that I could not stop
myself from looking up the news stories and then reading
all the hundreds of comments that people were just posting.
Almost all of them were bashing me, even though these
(32:30):
people didn't know who I was. But it was always,
you know, why she had a fraternity party? What did
she think was going to happen there? I heard that
she was wearing did you see her costume? Or just
you know, all these horrible things, And I just remember
I would just be sitting at my computer just crying
and trying to explain to my mom and my sister
(32:54):
and my friends like that I couldn't just stop looking
it up. I don't know, it was a very strange feeling.
It's like I couldn't look away from it.
Speaker 3 (33:03):
I had.
Speaker 2 (33:03):
I was checking daily, are there any new comments? And
it made me mad, and it made me sad, and
it just kind of just made me spiral.
Speaker 3 (33:14):
And then finally the.
Speaker 2 (33:17):
District Attorney's office just called me and said, okay, trials
set for May.
Speaker 3 (33:22):
So this is in two thousand and nine.
Speaker 2 (33:24):
Now, they had told me that that was actually a
pretty quick turnaround time from the assault happening in on
Halloween in two thousand and eight, and then for trial
to be in May two thousand and nine.
Speaker 1 (33:37):
Was Gregory offered a plea deal he was, did he
accept the plea deal?
Speaker 3 (33:44):
He did not.
Speaker 2 (33:45):
His whole defense became he was too drunk, He was
blackout drunk, so he can't be held accountable for what
he did during that time.
Speaker 1 (33:56):
At the trial, Gregory Sacho's defense leaned heavily into the
r that he simply didn't remember what happened that night
because he'd had too much to drink, but that if
something sexual did happen, then it must have been consensual.
At the Halloween party, fraternity members had been tallying drinks
on their arms. Gregory Sacho's arm showed twenty eight tally marks,
(34:17):
one for every drink he consumed, but at the same time,
Cassie's two drinks over the course of the entire evening
were heavily scrutinized during the trial.
Speaker 2 (34:28):
Yeah, I remember thinking that of like, you're going to
give me this much of a hard time, and I
had two drinks and he had what was marked as
twenty eight, Like it's I just yeah, remember being and
also just thinking, Okay, I'm a college student. You know,
me and my friends have all been very drunk a
(34:49):
handful of times. You don't rape people, that's not that's
not something that you do right, even if you are
very drunk.
Speaker 3 (34:58):
That's not a defense. That was ridiculous.
Speaker 2 (35:02):
And I also remember feeling even a little bit angry
like he I think he had made a statement like
I don't even remember meeting her.
Speaker 3 (35:10):
That made me feel angry.
Speaker 2 (35:11):
It's like you you raped me, and I cannot get
you out of my head, but yet you don't remember
meeting me.
Speaker 3 (35:19):
That really pissed me off.
Speaker 1 (35:22):
The trial took place seven months after the alleged drape.
For Cassie, it was not only the terror that came
with retelling her story in front of an audience, but
this strange and performative aspect of presenting herself to a jury.
Cover your tattoos, don't wear heels, wear makeup but not
too much makeup, be authentic but not too emotional. And
(35:42):
as if all of this wasn't difficult enough, Gregorysacho had
a lot of supporters, people who simply couldn't imagine he
would do this.
Speaker 2 (35:51):
Just seeing like the whole fraternity there, his family. I
remember feeling very intimidated by especially his mom.
Speaker 3 (36:03):
Again like silly things.
Speaker 2 (36:04):
You remember, it's you know, there's one woman's bathroom in
this courthouse. And I remember multiple times like washing my
hands next to his mom and just feeling terrified, like
she looked at me like I was ruining everything. That's
what I remember a lot about trials, feeling intimidated and.
Speaker 3 (36:27):
Scared.
Speaker 2 (36:29):
There was a little part of me I knew that
I wanted to keep doing this because I had also
had once I kind of started talking to more people.
A lot of acquaintances or friends of friends. Women would
come up and shared their stories, and I started to
feel like I was a part of this sad club
(36:54):
that nobody wanted to be in. But I felt like
I was getting more and more support hearing from all
these people. I had no ideas, like I had been
you know, acquaintances from high school that I thought I
knew fairly well, and then they would come up to
me and say that this happened to me at a
fraternity party as well, my sister had this happen. I
kind of held on to those stories to kind of
(37:17):
give me strength that trial, like I'm not alone in this.
The district attorney who ended up getting very close to you,
he's a great man, he had told me, he said,
you know, sadly, it's not about the truth. It's about
what you can prove in court, and that's always stuck
(37:38):
with me. The trial was four days and then on Friday,
the fifth day, the jury went out to deliberate, which
took a few hours, and then they came back with
their verdict and he was found guilty.
Speaker 1 (37:55):
On Tuesday May nineteenth, two thousand and nine, Gregory's Echo
was sentenced to eight years and four months for the
crime of first degree rape. After his sentence was completed,
he would then have eleven years of parole and have
to register as a sex offender.
Speaker 2 (38:11):
He was taken into custody right then, is handcuffed, taken away,
and then a week later I went back and spoke
at his sentencing, and that was a really empowering time
for me at as much time as I wanted to
say whatever I wanted, and that felt really good.
Speaker 3 (38:29):
Yeah, and then I'm left to kind of just go
on my life.
Speaker 4 (38:34):
So he is convicted and taken into custody, and I guess,
in you know, the movie version, that would sort of
be the end credits and there would be this sense
of victory. But you know, we know that that's not
really how it works legally, and maybe mainly emotionally, once
you've been through something like this, what did life look
(38:55):
like for you? After the trial?
Speaker 2 (38:58):
A family friend had spoken to me about that I
potentially had a lawsuit case that they had a lawyer
that they wanted me to speak with, and I ended
up speaking with him, and he was a personal injury lawyer,
and he thought that this was a really interesting case.
He also had daughters, and he said, I'm passionate about this.
(39:19):
I feel like around that time, it was kind of
coming out more about kind of some of these like
dangers at these fraternity environments, and it seemed like all
these bad things that kept happening at fraternities that they
weren't held really accountable in any way. And like the
lawyer had explained to me, you know, unfortunately, the way
to kind of get things to change is to have
(39:41):
them have to pay.
Speaker 3 (39:42):
Money, like that's what matters to these people.
Speaker 1 (39:46):
Pursuing a civil case against the fraternity meant that Cassie
would have to retell her story of the worst night
of her life all over again, after having just recently
gone through the trial. The civil suit was filed in
twenty ten, but was unsuccessful. Cassie lost in twenty twelve,
she appealed and in twenty fifteen she won.
Speaker 2 (40:06):
In twenty fifteen, they ruled in my favor, which in Oregon,
that was the first time the appeals court addressed if
fraternities could be held accountable for sexual assaults and rape
that happened on their premises, And so it kind of
set a precedent and made fraternities kind of think more
about their policies that they could have in place, kind
(40:29):
of regarding members drinking or cutting off access to personal rooms.
Speaker 1 (40:36):
Wow, so there was some you know, at least real
policy change there as a result of this. Yeah, that
feels important.
Speaker 2 (40:45):
Yes, definitely, that was really helpful for me, I think healing.
Speaker 1 (40:50):
Gregory Sacho served the entirety of his sentence, and in
twenty seventeen he was released. He moved back to California,
but was on parole and had to register as a
second Cassie had been working hard to move on with
her life. She'd gotten married, she'd become a mother. Finally
it started to feel like the darkest and most difficult
chapter of her life was ending. In twenty twenty two,
(41:13):
Cassie gave birth to twins, and just five days after
giving birth, She was laying on her sofa breastfeeding when
the phone ring. It was a crime victim advocate calling
to let her know that Gregorysacho was no longer on parole,
he was no longer a registered sex offender, and he
was no longer guilty of first degree rape. His two
thousand and nine conviction had been invalidated. Part of the
(41:36):
reason this crime victim called was to see if Cassie
felt like going through another trial if the state were
to once again pursue a first degree rape charge for
Gregory Sacho.
Speaker 2 (41:47):
If I didn't go forward, he was just free from everything,
everything was wiped off, his record, didn't have to register
as a sex offender, and so I was also so
in shock. Then took some days to think about it,
and I decided I did want to try to just
go forward and do trial again.
Speaker 3 (42:10):
So a couple months later, we were at a first
kind of.
Speaker 2 (42:14):
Pre trial hearing and greg was out, so he's appearing
over zoom and so it was the first time even
just seeing him like on a screen. You're both present
for this hearing, and the judge already was coming at
me with he literally said, why would you want to
(42:37):
go through with this again. You know, Greg has already
served his time. His life has already been ruined enough.
Why do we need to do this again. I was
trying to be so composed, and I just remember at
that time just breaking down crying, and the DA stepped
in for me and just said, Calsie's life has been
greatly changed as well, and brought me back to that.
(43:01):
It was just so much victim blaming. Still, why would
I want to do this to him again? He's already
served his time. Can't I just.
Speaker 3 (43:08):
Let this go? And that made me mad.
Speaker 2 (43:12):
But after a few weeks of kind of just I
kind of feel like I had kind of like a
mini breakdown, kind of started spiraling and decided I didn't
want to go through with trial again. I made the
decision that what was best for me. I was, you know,
a mom of three under two at that time. I
(43:33):
just couldn't do this again, even if it meant it
made me so angry that he was just going to
have a clean record and not have to register, but
it was what was best for me at the time.
Speaker 1 (43:44):
The jury that had delivered Sacho's guilty verdict back in
two thousand and nine was not unanimous, but At the time,
Oregon law didn't require a unanimous verdict. It required a
majority of ten out of the twelve jurors, except in
the case of first Dream murder. In twenty twenty, the
US Supreme Court ruled that the sixth Amendment to the
US Constitution required a unanimous verdict for serious criminal offenders.
(44:08):
So in twenty twenty two, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled
that this decision would apply retroactively, which meant it applied
to Greg Graysacho. His conviction was no longer valid. It
was almost like it never happened. He was no longer
on parole, he was no longer a registered sex offender, and.
Speaker 2 (44:27):
So I agreed to let him just plead. He wouldn't
even plead not guilty. Is that is, I guess, admitting
something he pled no contest to, just like a minor
assault charge. So there's nothing sexual. So he's off the registry.
I'm okay with it now. I mean, it's not ideal,
(44:51):
that was I mean, ultimately I fought trial to get
him convicted to have to have that consequence, which to
me seems very minor to what he put me through,
Like you should have to pay for what you did
by registering. Even if I know that he's off the
registry and doesn't have it on his record, I know
(45:15):
what happened. Everybody that is important to me knows what happened,
and I've come to realize that's what matters, and I
have to be okay with that.
Speaker 4 (45:26):
Yeah, I'm asking this question as someone who wants to
understand as well as I think maybe listeners will have
this question. But I'm not indicating that you shouldn't feel
like you want him on the sex offender list, because
I don't. I think you should feel how you want
to feel. I'm curious to know if he had to
(45:48):
still register as a sex offender, why do you think
that's important.
Speaker 3 (45:53):
I think that's a very valid question.
Speaker 2 (45:55):
And I had to think about that a lot too,
kind of when I was going through this, and I
think for me, what I felt was important about it
was he was out of prison and so that part
was done, but that registering as a sex offender felt
like something else he would have to do as a
(46:15):
consequence of what he did for me, and it felt
important as something that would still kind of change his life,
affect his life in some way, because I felt like
I was so greatly affected in so many ways. I
would have to get you know, anxiety meds to even
(46:37):
have a PAP smear. My whole birthing experience was that
was all very triggering and I had to get help
support around that, like just to get birth.
Speaker 3 (46:48):
It's felt like my life was so.
Speaker 2 (46:49):
Affected still and still is that him registering as a
sex offender felt like a little bit that it would
still affect his life in some way.
Speaker 4 (47:02):
Yeah, that makes total sense.
Speaker 1 (47:05):
How are you today today?
Speaker 3 (47:08):
I'm doing great.
Speaker 2 (47:10):
I'm finally at the point where it's a part of
my story, but it doesn't feel like it's my identity anymore.
And I think there's been so much that's gone into
that because it's been so long, lots of therapy and
work on myself, and also I feel like telling my
(47:30):
story has been a big part of the healing journey
for me. I'm part of the Rain Speaker's Bureau, where
I've shared my story. I've spoken at fraternities and sororities,
specifically in some college criminology classes.
Speaker 3 (47:45):
But that's also been a way that I feel like.
Speaker 2 (47:48):
It's helped make me the person that I am today.
Where I'm on the other side of this and able
to share my story as someone who feels strong where
I am now.
Speaker 1 (48:03):
Yeah, I think that's amazing, probably so powerful for those
people at those sororities and fraternities to hear a story
like yours and you know, nobody thinks it's going to
be them.
Speaker 4 (48:16):
I'm so appreciative of you reaching out and telling us
your story. I think it's like really powerful and you
tell it so well. So thank you so much. I'm
so glad that Cassie spoke with us and was willing
to tell us her story. I really found it to
(48:37):
be very powerful.
Speaker 1 (48:38):
Yeah, Cassie reached out to us in an email she
had listened to the show, and it feels really great
that we were a safe space for her to share this.
Speaker 4 (48:48):
Yeah, it does.
Speaker 1 (48:49):
One thing that it really stood out in the interview
is Cassie's experience getting a rape kit reporting to law
enforcement was so traumatizing, and she mentioned several times that
without having the support of two really close friends that
stayed by her side through the entire process, she probably
wouldn't have been able to do it.
Speaker 4 (49:11):
Cheers to her friends, seriously, what great friends. I loved
that part of the story where they were by her
side and helped her when she was like in chock
to know what to do for her best interest. It
was really really great, and her walking us through everything
that happened at the hospital was really powerful as well.
We hear so often from people like that experience can
(49:33):
be traumatizing, and I believe them, but it's a little vague,
and Cassie really walked us through exactly why and how
that is. Yeah, and it's easy to understand.
Speaker 1 (49:42):
And you know, one organization that Cassie mentioned to me
on one of our preliminary calls is the Rape, Abuse
and Incest National Network, And I looked up some statistics
on their website that really speak to Cassie's story and
what turns out to be, you know, sometimes a common
story on college campuses, and that is sexual violence among
(50:05):
undergraduate students. Twenty six point four percent of females and
six point eight percent of males experience rape or sexual
assault through physical force, violence or incapacitation.
Speaker 4 (50:17):
And only twenty percent of female student victims ages eighteen
to twenty four report to law enforcement. Hearing Cassie's story,
you know, these statistics aren't surprising, but like it's really sad.
And while it's not difficult to understand, I think it's
important to remember that there are so many more stories
out there that don't get reported.
Speaker 1 (50:38):
Yeah, and you know, the trauma didn't end after the trial,
as we heard from Cassie. So in two thousand and
nine the trial, Greg gory Sako's convicted of rape and
he's sentenced to prison, and he does go to prison,
and so at that point Cassie has this small sense
of like justice in her life. And then in twenty ten,
(51:02):
Greg Gorysaco's parents they end up publishing a guest opinion
in a smaller news publication called The Almanac, and it's
titled Guest Opinion How Alcohol Ruined a Student's Dreams. And
the letter is really troubling in my opinion. I mean,
it's essentially this warning shot for college students, like heavy
(51:23):
drinking could leave you very vulnerable to false accusations. I mean,
that is how I interpret what they're saying. And the
letter also references an accuser of their son, Greg Graysako,
who they name in the letter, but never references this
person as a victim.
Speaker 4 (51:39):
And you know, interesting, even though he's in prison at
this point that this has been convicted right at this
point of the letter being published. He's convicted and he's
in prison. And one quote from this opinion piece is
the problem with this case was that at the time
the alleged incident occurred, Gregory and his accuser were very
(52:00):
drunk or quote hammered as you might say. Okay, so
this is the quote from the piece, and a lot
of inaccuracy, a lot of inaccuracies.
Speaker 1 (52:10):
We know that Cassie was not drunk at this party,
and it is my interpretation that there's Cassie they're talking about, yeah,
and his accuser, his accuser, and Cassie has always maintained
that she had only two drinks the entire evening. In fact,
there was a moment at the hospital where law enforcement,
(52:31):
you know, determined she was sober to a point where
they didn't even need to take a toxicology test because
there was no reason to they didn't believe that she
was intoxicated. Yeah, and her friends also corroborated that version
of the night. So it's troubling to call her an
accuser and to say that she was hammered. She wasn't.
Speaker 4 (52:53):
Whereas it seems pretty clear that Gregory Sacho was based
on witness accounts as well as the fact that they
had been tallying the number of drinks in their arms
and he had twenty eight tally marks. But yeah, regardless,
you know, I think that there's been a lot sort
of written about the dangers of alcohol, and hey, that's fair, right, Like, yes,
(53:14):
alcohol can be very dangerous, but it's oftentimes been written
about in conjunction with the conversation around sexual assault and
rape on college campuses and sort of been pointed to, like, well,
that's the problem. Well, alcohol is the problem, and I'm
not saying it's not a problem, but it's not the
full answer.
Speaker 1 (53:34):
Right, It's not an excuse, it's not It might impaired judgment,
and it might lead to an increased risk of sexual violence,
but it certainly doesn't negate anything.
Speaker 4 (53:46):
Because there's plenty of people who get quote unquote hammered,
as they say in their letter, that don't act violent
or commit crimes against other people. And so obviously there's
another issue deeper in there that I think it's important
to look at.
Speaker 1 (54:01):
Yeah, absolutely so.
Speaker 4 (54:04):
In twenty twenty two, Sako's conviction for first degree rape
was invalidated and we talked about that in the episode.
It was because whenever his conviction happened, it was ORGAN
law that there had to be at least ten out
of twelve jurors for a conviction, and they, for whatever reason,
had that amount, you know, and he was convicted. And
then in twenty twenty two, based on a twenty twenty
(54:27):
Supreme Court ruling, Organ decided this would be retroactive in
all violent cases, which automatically meant that his conviction was invalidated.
It wasn't like under review. It just boom, it was over.
It was over. He no longer had a record, he
no longer had to register as a sex offender. He
(54:47):
had already served his time. So the big piece of this, though,
that we talked with Cassie about, is this idea of
him not having to register as a sex offender. And
it's sort of a hot topic. There's an ongoing debate
about the usefulness of sex offender registry. You know, there's
some people that say it does more harm than good
because it can create a false sense of security. It
(55:10):
can also disproportionately impact certain demographics and make it more
difficult for someone who's been convicted of various sexual offenses
to rehabilitate or reintegrate into society. You know, if there's
one person who has to register as a sex offender
in like a multi family home, this affects everyone in
that house. There's also a lot of good arguments in
(55:33):
favor of the sex offender registry that people, I think
rightly so want to know if there's someone who has
been convicted of a sexual offense who's in their neighborhood.
So I wanted to talk to Cassie about this because
it really seemed to impact her a lot, This idea
that Sokko would no longer have to register as a
(55:53):
sex offender. This, clearly when we talked to her, was
upsetting to her. He'd already served his time. But you know,
I was really curious to understand why that was a
piece that was such a big deal, so important to her.
And I think she made a really good point because
she talked. She talked about like, well, she doesn't get
the chance to sort of wipe this clean from her life,
(56:14):
Like even though she's moved on and she is happy
and has a good life, it's not like this doesn't
still affect her. It's never over for Cassie. It's something
that she lives with all the time. I mean even
in her first email to us, it was apparent how
deeply present this still is in her life and in
her mind. Yeah, I mean that moment when she talked
(56:36):
about like being remind of it, of it when she
was giving birth, It's like that sucks.
Speaker 1 (56:42):
That sucks. That should be just like such a beautiful memory.
I mean, childbirth is a lot of things, but like
I think most of us are able to look back
on it as like, Wow, what an incredible day, and
hers is haunted by this terrible thing that happened to her. Yeah,
only broad in my understanding of that perspective. And I
(57:03):
was really appreciative of her for sharing her thoughts and
feelings on it. Yeah, we're really thankful to Cassie for
sharing her story with us. Well, thank you so much
for listening. That is our episode for this week. We'll
be back next week. If you have a story for us,
we would love to hear it. Our email is The
Knife at Exactlyrightmedia dot com, or you can follow us
on Instagram at the Knife podcast or a Blue Sky
(57:26):
at the Knife Podcast.
Speaker 4 (57:27):
This has been an Exactly Right production, hosted and produced
by me Hannah Smith.
Speaker 3 (57:32):
And me Paytia Eten.
Speaker 1 (57:33):
Our producers are Tom Bryfogel and Alexis Samarosi.
Speaker 4 (57:36):
This episode was mixed by Tom Bryfogel.
Speaker 1 (57:39):
Our associate producer is Christina Chamberlain.
Speaker 4 (57:41):
Our theme music is by Birds in the Airport.
Speaker 1 (57:44):
Artwork by Vanessa Lilac.
Speaker 4 (57:45):
Executive produced by Karen Kilgarriff, Georgia Hardstark, and Danielle Kramer.
Popular Podcasts
CrimeLess: Hillbilly Heist
It’s 1996 in rural North Carolina, and an oddball crew makes history when they pull off America’s third largest cash heist. But it’s all downhill from there. Join host Johnny Knoxville as he unspools a wild and woolly tale about a group of regular ‘ol folks who risked it all for a chance at a better life. CrimeLess: Hillbilly Heist answers the question: what would you do with 17.3 million dollars? The answer includes diamond rings, mansions, velvet Elvis paintings, plus a run for the border, murder-for-hire-plots, and FBI busts.
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.