All Episodes

August 22, 2025 18 mins

This week on Crime Roundup, Sheryl McCollum and Joshua Schiffer dive into an explosive scandal out of rural Kentucky, where the murder of Judge Kevin Mullins has exposed a hidden world of courthouse corruption, sex-for-favors, and alleged misconduct at nearly every level of the local justice system. With reports of mirrored ceilings, sex parties, and jailhouse encounters involving law enforcement and officials, the hosts examine how deep the cover-up may run and what accountability looks like. They then turn to Bryan Kohberger, who has filed harassment complaints from inside a maximum-security prison. Sheryl and Joshua break down what those complaints reveal about prison power dynamics, the threat of extortion, and the likelihood of long-term solitary confinement.

 

Highlights:

  • (0:00) Welcome to Crime Roundup with Sheryl McCollum and Joshua Schiffer
  • (0:30) “The jail was a brothel.” Sheryl and Joshua set the stage for a story of scandal, power, and fallout
  • (1:00) Judge Kevin Mullins’ murder and the web of corruption unraveling in small-town Kentucky
  • (2:45) Sex-for-favors, law enforcement swingers, and an “open secret” exposed
  • (6:30) The fallout: who knew, who looked away, and why federal intervention may be necessary
  • (9:30) Bryan Kohberger files prison harassment complaints and faces the realities of life behind bars
  • (11:00) Maximum-security dynamics: power, protection, and life under constant threat
  • (12:00) Why solitary confinement may be Kohberger’s only option and how his mindset could make it worse
  • (15:00) Some cases are off-limits for now. Sheryl and Joshua explain why respecting the system comes first

 

About the Hosts

Joshua Schiffer is a veteran trial attorney and one of the Southeast’s most respected legal voices. He is a founding partner at ChancoSchiffer P.C., where he has litigated high-stakes criminal, civil rights, and personal injury cases for over two decades. Known for his bold courtroom presence and ability to clearly explain complex legal issues, Schiffer is a frequent media contributor and fearless advocate for accountability.

Sheryl “Mac” McCollum is an Emmy Award-winning CSI, a writer for CrimeOnline, forensic and crime scene expert for Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, and co-author of the textbook Cold Case: Pathways to Justice. She is the founder and director of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute, a national collaboration that advances techniques for solving cold cases and assists families and law enforcement with unsolved homicides, missing persons, and kidnappings.

 

🎧 Want more from Sheryl?

Catch her every Wednesday on Zone 7, where she doesn’t just talk cold cases, she works them. She’s joined by fellow forensic pros and criminal justice insiders for conversations straight from active investigations. Then on Mondays, tune in to Pathology with Dr. Priya, where the physical evidence takes center stage.

 

📢 If you enjoyed this episode, follow Crime Roundup on your favorite podcast platform and leave a review to help others find the show. Have a case suggestion? Email coldcase2004@gmail.com or connect with the hosts on social:

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:08):
Welcome to crime around up. I'm Cheryl McCollum, and y'all
already know the man, the mynth, the legend is here,
and y'all, this is gonna be a good Thursday night.
We're gonna talk about sex.

Speaker 2 (00:22):
Baby, all right, it's a rainy night in Georgia. This
is gonna be a hot one. We're gonna steam it up.

Speaker 1 (00:29):
One quote, the jail was a brothel. Now, if that
don't set the stage.

Speaker 2 (00:39):
I hope everybody knows exactly what Cherl's talking about, because
you know, we're gonna we're gonna delve into the depths
of Kentucky, uh and talk about the outrageous reports from
on the ground and this stuff circulating widely about there.

Speaker 1 (00:56):
Are people coming forward and it's one thing if you
hear there might have been a little sex for favors,
like you pull over your ex girlfriend for speeding and
y'all work out a deal right there on the side
of the road, and everybody goes on about their business.
People have heard of that.

Speaker 2 (01:10):
Yeah, rumors us.

Speaker 1 (01:12):
What they're talking about is, can you imagine if Otis
and Mayberry was checking himself out to go overnight to
sleep with at b.

Speaker 2 (01:22):
It is absolutely nuts what happened or what's being talked
about with this district Court judge Kevin Mullins, who just
remind everybody got shot to death back in September on
camera with an immediate turn in, you know, very interesting
dynamic there by one of his good buddies, Sheriff Sean

(01:46):
Mickey Stein's and Micky Stein's and the judge went back
years and Micky Stein's had just testified in a deposition,
and there are some lawsuits going around, and so there
were a bunch of whispers when the murder had and
everybody started getting involved about this complicated story. I actually
talked about it with Vinny last night about how the

(02:08):
daughter of the sheriff wasn't answering one phone call, but
then when called from the judge's phone or her number
was in the judge's phone. And the problem is that
there's video but no audio, and obviously the only surviving
audio source is highly biased, being that he's going to

(02:28):
be up on trial, quite possibly in a death penalty posture.
This is the murder of a public official that's basically
at the top of the how you get the death
penalty equation and really what's happening now, are people in
the community, now that the shock has worn off, coming

(02:49):
out and actually talking out in the open with big
news groups about literally sex parties. And these are sex
parties with everybody in county. And you know, there are
some really hilarious quotes about everybody in the county being
swingers and people literally walking into the judges chambers. As

(03:11):
you know, officials and inmates are in flagrante delicto. That's
your legal term of the day, sharel it's the polite
way of saying knocking boots, horizontal mambo, whatever you want
to call it. They were fornicating in chambers and apparently
this was just known.

Speaker 1 (03:30):
Oh it was an open secret. It had to be
because let me tell you something. They had cabins, they
had apartments. It wasn't just the chambers. They were paying
rent and mortgages in order to keep these parties going.
They some people have come out and said there were
sex swings, there were mirrored ceilings, there was cocaine. This

(03:51):
wasn't a little bitty after school party. This was a
full own dagum near diddy party.

Speaker 2 (03:58):
Oh yeah, no, it took the words out of my mouth.
This is the Kentucky version of Diddy. Uh. Because and
this some Ofasell casts are coming lottery from law enforcement member,
former employees at the jail, from the Sheriff's department, saying yeah,
I know about it. How oh I was invited, but

(04:20):
I don't get down like that. It makes me think
about all these Hollywood jokesters. And because you know that
the gossip, the innuendo had to have been overpowering, especially
in one of these small communities where they think they've
got a secret. You know that there were all kinds

(04:40):
of secret references. This is something that they enjoyed having
out in public as a public secret. Uh. And it
just you hear about it, you read about it, You
probably dream about it when you're a little teenager. And
now look we're seeing it. And without a doubt, Nicky

(05:01):
Steins is going to get put on trial for murder.

Speaker 1 (05:05):
And you know, you and I have both been around
long enough we know several judges that will give consideration
and favors to women that are attractive.

Speaker 2 (05:15):
There's some misogyny that is home cooked into the system. Unfortunately. Yes,
it just is what it is.

Speaker 1 (05:25):
And folks using their power in the system to say, hey,
you don't want to play ball. You could get ninety
days instead of thirty, and we could get cps to
take your kids. Who are they going to believe me
or a drug.

Speaker 2 (05:39):
Addict, and believe it or not. It's way more common
than I think people think, because unfortunately, the cases are
almost never prosecuted, and it may not even be a
violation of that officer's sworn duty because you run into
the issue of how do you tell sheriffs officers not

(06:00):
to quote unquote date and it has some very sticky
hr considerations, and it has been upheld multiple times that
activities that occur in police cars is not okay, but
it's certainly not something that's going to necessarily get you
in trouble. Now, the bigger problem is that there's just

(06:22):
cameras everywhere, and.

Speaker 1 (06:23):
You know, we're not making light of anything. I want
people to understand. Children are getting hurt here. There are
other spouses that are going to be embarrassed and hurt here.
You've got a religious community, You've got you know, parents,
You've got a lot of people that are going to

(06:44):
be hurt over all of these allegations. But you've also
had real estate agents possibly and law enforcement at every level,
and the judicial system at every level that's involved in
something where somebody says the whole town is involved. The
whole town.

Speaker 2 (07:01):
And when you're talking about these small towns that and
people that aren't familiar with them. You know what church
everybody goes to if you run for office? The church
you go to matters like you you go to the Methodists,
you go to the which one? Which preacher is going
to stand there in your in your campaign at you
know which community groups? Are you a Kawana? Are you

(07:22):
an elk are you these aren't people that are hermits.
If you want to win and keep getting elected in
small town America, you're out there in the community, walking
in the parade, sponsoring the scouts, doing the school appearances,
letting the kids turn the lights on. And now you've
got it that these people uh And remember, in theory,

(07:45):
the judicial law enforcement branches are separate. The just shouldn't
be having any kind of relations with with sheriffs like this,
but you know, you've got it happening in such a
naked and express way from all these reports, it really
makes you a question what's real and what's just you know,
messaging an image and are people really watching and do

(08:08):
people really care?

Speaker 1 (08:10):
Because do you think the US Attorney's going to get involved?

Speaker 2 (08:13):
I think they have to, because I think that any
investigation is going to be tainted in so many levels,
because you know they're going to send it to the
Kentucky version of the Kentucky GBI or whatever their high
executive level of investigations are. But those officers very often
are sourced from these small communities, getting ethically clean and

(08:37):
away from stuff. This is a judge. Judges go to
judges conferences. I was just talking with a prominent colleague
last night who is representing the spouse of a judge
and had just been recused or their judge. They were
set for trial in two weeks and the judge that

(08:59):
was supposed to try this very contentious family law case
just got back from the judicial conference that all the
judges go to in Georgia came back promptly announced to
all litigans he had to recuse because he'd served on
a committee with the judge that is the defendant respondent
in the family law action. Because you've got to get

(09:19):
away ethically. I don't know if that's possible in a
state like Kentucky. So they may need that US Attorney's
Office investigation, FBI investigation, but you know, their plates kind
of full over there as well.

Speaker 1 (09:37):
All right, well, let's jump to the next one. Coburger.
He has filed some complaints of sexual harassment. Now, y'all,
I'm just going to state something because it is factual,
not because any of this is for anybody's enjoyment. It's
not karma, but he has made in my opinion, being

(10:01):
somebody that has been with the Department of Corrections, been
in Rice Street as a deputy, this is equivalent to
telling the teacher it is not gonna be met with
remorse and regret to it is gonna be met with

(10:21):
They ramped up and constant just bullying.

Speaker 2 (10:29):
And we all knew you called it to the tea
about how challenging his entry into long term housing was
going to be. And people, you gotta understand, the folks
sitting around in prison, they're bored. They notice any change.
If you start putting fish in and out of the school,

(10:52):
they all know immediately. They've probably been talking about it
for months. They've been watching the case because you know,
states only have so many maximum security prisons. If you
if you're on death row in Georgia or super met man,
I generally can tell you what your address is here
in Georgia. There ain't very many place as they put them,

(11:12):
and so they were waiting for him. They know that
he has some funding which commissary accounts and out of
With these lifers and these man it's it's awful. The extortion,
it's awful. The threats on the outside. It there are
fears that you do not realize until you have spent

(11:33):
time exposed to the depravity of long term human hopeless storage,
because there is no consideration of the outside and your
family and your family's family, and your work and your
morals and ethics, because those morals and ethics got suspended
when you crossed over that line and they hit. I'll

(11:57):
give it to mister k I give them props for
using the grievance system as it was designed to work.

Speaker 1 (12:05):
Well. You know in his past life, whoever writes better
usually wins, and I'm sure he fired off some beautifully
written PhD level complaints. The issue is going to be,
where are you going if you think B block and
D block is any different than J block. Again, sir,

(12:28):
you are not prepared.

Speaker 2 (12:30):
Now his Gen Pop experience is going to be a
daily and constant threat for at least some period of
time because the other inmates are going to shake him
out and figure out what he's made of. And he
has also suffered from being a limited exposure a solitary
confinement in the pre trial process. He wasn't out there

(12:52):
in Gen Pop in a county jail. You know, they
had him on ad SEG lockdown. They're going to try
to acclimate him in the loosest security possible at that facility,
because when you get into the maximum security facilities, it's
all about keeping people from getting killed. That that's really

(13:12):
the prime directive is, Hey, we need to keep these
individuals tamped down and separated to the degree that the
killing and beatings are kept to a minimum, because we
all know they're going to happen. We know the statistics
about mental health, and then we know the people who
aren't mentally mentally ill and just terrible evil people that

(13:35):
did awful, violent things and are maladjusted to this is
where we put them. And mister Coberger I believe will
end up in some sort of segregated lockdown solitary in
the near future for extended periods of time.

Speaker 1 (13:54):
I agree, they're not going to have a choice if
they're going to try to, you know, keep him safe
and keep everybody else from just rioting to get to him.
Because he is odd, he is unusual. He could not,
you know, get with the group in high school. He
could not manage to get himself in with a crowd.
In college.

Speaker 2 (14:15):
He walks into your office, you know what you're up with?

Speaker 1 (14:20):
Oh yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2 (14:21):
I hate to say it, but you know, first impressions
do count. I imagine some of that had to do
with his decision to take a plea because you see
the just demeanor and appearance and outward projection of certain people.
It's tough, and I'm not going to say it's fair.
I don't. I know you can do things to make

(14:43):
yourself appear and work on your person skills and all that.
Some people didn't, and he's going to continue to struggle.
I got a bad feeling about him long term, because
I think he thinks he's smart enough to still get
out of it, get away when something happens.

Speaker 1 (14:59):
Yep, I don't have a good feeling either. But listen,
before we head out into this storm that's approaching here,
you know, it's just oh, it's beautiful. It's beautiful. But
I got to tell you something, friend of friend, y'all.
I don't know if y'all know this or not, but

(15:20):
I have been involved with a case that's pretty high
profile in Fulton County, and not once, but twice now
Joshua has said, Nah, let's not go there, let's hold off.
And I just want to tell y'all, you know, there's
some folks in this world that they would use this

(15:42):
opportunity and hey, let's get some clicks and let's make
this a little outrageous and we can use this for
our own gain. But as my friend, he's like, girl,
don't do it.

Speaker 2 (15:57):
Nope, you gotta respect. And it's not just my care
and friendship and love for you as a person. It's
the respect that I know you have for the system
and that you know I have for the system, and
you've got to have fidelity to the system. And the
system is and it's a case that I have commented on.
I know every single person involved except for one of

(16:19):
the lawyers, and that's because he just graduated from my
alma mater three years ago and one of my dear
friends was one of his instructors and it is a
great judge. It is a fascinating case. But you've got
to respect the process. And that's frustrating when that means
sit down, shut up, because I tell you, Mac, if

(16:42):
you want to get some clicks, boy, people would light
up talking about that one, especially giving your really unique
perspective that comes from only being you and your genuine
interest in these kinds of cases.

Speaker 1 (16:56):
Well, when we can talk, we will, But yeah, I.

Speaker 2 (16:59):
Just want to people know we're not ignoring it.

Speaker 1 (17:01):
We're not ignoring you. I have seen all the messages.
I've read most of them. I read all of them
because some of them, even the way they started, I
was like, not today, you know, I'll read that later.
But we will talk about it when we can and
it'll be great, but it's not appropriate right now.

Speaker 2 (17:18):
Yeah, it'll be great because I'm excited because when you see,
life is all about perspective, because you only view things
from your perspective, and one of the important parts of
wisdom and understanding is being able to reverse roles and
look at things from other perspectives. It's one of the
things whereas can't talk about because it's such a powerful tool. Hey,

(17:40):
get in the shoes of my person. Getting to talk
with Cheryl about this case is going to be great
because this is one of the most unique perspectives I've
ever thought of within a prosecution and defense, and that
perspective is absolutely unique, and I'm really looking forward to

(18:02):
academically as well as personally to hearing about Like I
just think it's gonna be fascinating.

Speaker 1 (18:08):
All right, well, let's go enjoy that storm and toast
that lightning.

Speaker 2 (18:13):
Y'all have a great week. I wish everybody the absolute
best smile out there. Remember to punch up. I've got
to punch down. Punch up. That's how you're gonna win
in this life. And thank y'all so much for tuning
in this week.

Speaker 1 (18:28):
We'll see y'all next week.
Advertise With Us

Host

Sheryl McCollum

Sheryl McCollum

Popular Podcasts

Crime Junkie

Crime Junkie

Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.

NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

Gregg Rosenthal and a rotating crew of elite NFL Media co-hosts, including Patrick Claybon, Colleen Wolfe, Steve Wyche, Nick Shook and Jourdan Rodrigue of The Athletic get you caught up daily on all the NFL news and analysis you need to be smarter and funnier than your friends.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.