Defending History: The Quest for American Truth Amidst Revisionism

History isn't always what we think it is – from the coins in our pockets to the death of America's first president, misconceptions abound. When a numismatist listener points out that Americans have never actually made "pennies" but rather "one cent pieces," it opens a conversation about historical accuracy that spans centuries.

The conversation takes a fascinating turn as David Barton reveals details about the upcoming book "American Story 3: A World at War." Six weeks before completion, the research team discovered declassified government documents from the 1970s that completely change the narrative on significant aspects of World War II. Rather than focusing on dry facts and dates, the book brings to life the extraordinary stories of Medal of Honor recipients and everyday heroes whose courage shaped history.

Prepare to have your understanding of World War II challenged. Did you know Japanese forces attacked Alaska, but the American government suppressed this information to prevent public panic? Or that German submarine crews would come ashore at night to ride attractions at Coney Island before returning to sink American ships during daylight? These remarkable stories reveal how much of our history remains hidden in plain sight.

The discussion exposes how educational standards have sometimes misrepresented American history, particularly in Advanced Placement courses that once reduced all of World War II to four paragraphs focusing exclusively on negative American actions while omitting Hitler, the Holocaust, Pearl Harbor, and virtually every significant figure from the conflict. This kind of revisionism inspired the hosts to expand their historical focus and combat such distortions.

What makes this episode particularly compelling is how it demonstrates that historical accuracy matters – not just for academic reasons, but because these stories shape our understanding of who we are as Americans and what values we stand for. By returning to primary sources and firsthand accounts, we discover a richer, more nuanced view of our shared past.

Support the show