The Shipwreck of the Liturgy: A Critical Look at the New Mass

Was the liturgical reform after Vatican II a renewal or a rupture? This podcast takes a critical look at the development and impact of the New Mass through the lens of Michael Davies' influential work, "Liturgical Shipwreck: 28 Years of the New Mass." We'll delve into the historical context surrounding the promulgation of the Novus Ordo Missae, Davies' arguments about its divergence from tradition and perceived Protestant influences, and the contrasting perspectives on its success and impact within the Catholic Church. Explore the concerns raised by Davies and others regarding the "dismantling of the traditional values and piety" and the ongoing debate surrounding the two forms of the Roman Rite.

Michael Davies's "Liturgical Shipwreck" critiques the New Mass (Novus Ordo Missae), arguing it represents a destructive break from the Traditional Latin Mass codified by St. Pius V. Davies supports this view by quoting various figures, including Msgr. Klaus Gamber, who considered the liturgical reforms a "destruction." The text highlights the author's belief that the changes, initiated after Vatican II and influenced by Protestant theology, have led to a decline in Catholic piety and practice, despite the Second Vatican Council's intentions for renewal. Davies points to the opinions of Cardinal Ottaviani and others who expressed serious reservations about the new liturgy. Ultimately, the work advocates for the restoration of the Traditional Latin Mass.