Can’t Handle The Crime And Scandal

James Duncan vanished from his quiet West Virginia home in 1983, his family said he never came home after another usual night of drinking at the local pub.  But what started as a missing person’s case quickly unraveled into something far darker. A backyard. A bullet. And a cover-up so bizarre, it sounds like something out of a backwoods horror film.

This week, we’re digging into the disappearance of James Duncan and trust us, this ...

Collin Howell was a man of God, a man who seemed to have established a good, honest life for himself.

A wife, beautiful children, career as a dentist and a well respected man within the community and the church.

But, let us tell you that this man was really an undercover garbage man, a serial sinner who seemed to be ticking off the 10 commandments like it was a shopping list.

Strap in friends! Rainy is on the case for this epsiode ...

Amy Lynn Bradley was on a dream cruise with her family when the worst thing imaginable happened.  One minute she was dancing at the nightclub, the next, she was just…gone. No signs of struggle. No mayday. She simply vanished into thin ocean air. 

The initial trail of bizarre clues lead everywhere from the ship’s crew to dark rumors on the surrounding Caribbean islands. In this episode, we unpack the wil...

When Colorado mum Kelsey Berreth vanished around Thanksgiving 2018, the case quickly gripped the headlines.

With a fiancé, a young daughter, and a seemingly picture-perfect life, nothing about her sudden disappearance made sense. As investigators dug deeper, they uncovered a tangled web of secret relationships, suspicious behavior, and a wicked game that never should have been played! 

As Rainy says, prepare your rage journals frie...

One day, Abraham Shakespeare was a regular guy with a lucky ticket. The next, he was a millionaire surrounded by vultures. As fast as the money came, so did the lies, the manipulation—and then, silence. This is the story of a lottery win gone wrong, and how sometimes more money doesn't equal more happiness.

Thanks for listening friends! Subscribe to stay up to date with our weekly episodes released every Wednesday.

Ina and Steven met at a homeless shelter and sparks flew. From there they embarked on a committed relationship together but experienced some pretty hard times, homelessness, drug addiction, and one hell of a messy living situation.  So, when news on a hefty inheritance comes in plus a castle they couldn’t believe their luck! 

All they have to do is sit tight and wait for the heir to the fortune to naturally pass away and hope that ...

Happy Monday, we felt like dropping a bonus episode episode to kick start the week! Enjoy. Today Lollie breaks down the bizarre and unsettling case of Brian and Ana Walshe. On New Year's Day 2023, Ana suddenly disappeared, setting off a chain of events that would expose  suspicious behaviour and damming web searches to match from the person closet to her. This case is still unfolding in the court system as we speak but it was too c...

Friends, We are excited to share the case we did for our first live show in Christchurch, New Zealand. It was too good not to share with all of you who couldn't be there.

A cricket umpire, a dominatrix, and a homemade sex dungeon...what could go wrong? We’re diving into the wild, twisted, and totally scandalous case of Peter Plumley-Walker, where kink, mystery, and courtroom drama collide.

Thanks for listening frien...

Hi Friends,

We had an issue with our original upload of this episode not playing on Apple Podcasts.

so here it is again for those who couldn’t download.

Today, Rainy dives into a chilling story set in the halls of Danvers High School.

A beloved teacher stays behind after class to help a student, but by the end of the day, both are missing. As the search intensifies, no one could have predicted the horrifying outcome that would shak...

Today, Rainy dives into a chilling story set in the halls of Danvers High School.

A beloved teacher stays behind after class to help a student, but by the end of the day, both are missing. As the search intensifies, no one could have predicted the horrifying outcome that would shake the entire community and nation to its core.

Thanks for listening friends!

Subscribe to stay up to date with our weekly epi...

When a successful businessman and a beloved member of a South Carolina community, is found dead at the bottom of his grand staircase, it appears to be a tragic fall in his own home. But as family members begin to dig a little deeper into the circumstances unsettling details emerge. Was this really just a freak accident—or something far more deliberate?

Thanks for listening friends! Subscribe to stay up to date with ...

In 2016, 19-year-old Sarah Stern disappeared from her home in New Jersey, sparking an investigation that would uncover far more than anyone expected. What seemed like a simple missing persons case quickly turned into something more sinister, involving the ultimate betrayal and a shocking connection to those closest to her.

 As the investigation unfolded, the truth about Sarah's disappearance became more complicated than anyone coul...

Today we explore the haunting cold case of 15-year-old Kirsty Bentley, who vanished on New Year's Eve in 1998 from the small town of Ashburton, New Zealand.

Weeks later, a gruesome discovery sparked widespread speculation and numerous theories about what happened to Kirsty.

 Despite extensive investigations, the identity of her killer remains unknown. Join us as we unravel the chilling details of New Zealand's most famous cold case...

Strap in gals and guys, today we’re diving into the wild, infuriating, and downright outrageous Casey Anthony case...and we can't handle this crime and scandal!

 A little girl’s gone missing, and what follows is a rollercoaster of lies, lies, more lies, and drama that left us—and the entire world—speechless. We’re breaking down all the jaw-dropping moments, the twists that didn’t make sense, and the questions that still haunt us to...

Today, Rainy dive's into the Mahek and Ansreen Bukhari TikTok influencer case that shocked the world. Mahek Bukhari wasn’t just another TikTok influencer—she had thousands of followers, a glamorous online persona, and a carefully curated image.

But behind the filters and viral dance moves, a dangerous secret was brewing. When her mother, Ansreen Bukhari, became entangled in a relationship that threatened to unravel their perfect i...

Make sure you’ve caught up on Ep 058, part one of the Jodi Arias case before jumping into part two. Trust us, you’ll want to hear this whole wild story!

Jodi Arias’ story captivated the world, but which version of it was true? From the moment she walked into the courtroom, the media and the public were hooked on her ever-changing explanations and elaborate tales. In this second episode of our two-parter we follow the trail of confl...

Part 2 available on our patreon now! 

In the small, seemingly peaceful town of Mesa, Arizona, the shocking discovery of Travis Alexander’s brutal murder sends ripples through his community and leaves investigators scrambling for answers. As detectives dig deeper, a tangled web of secrets, lies, and hidden relationships begins to unfold. Who could want to harm a man with such a promising future?

In this first part of our wild two-p...

This week we’re talking about Collin Griffith, a teenager at the center of not one, but two suspicious family deaths. First, his dad. Then, his mom. And when the dust settled in the courtroom?      Let’s just say, the outcome had people talking. Was this a case of terrible luck, self-defense, or something way more twisted?

Grab a drink, get comfy, and let’s break down this wild case that we’re certain will leaving you fuming!

PATRE...

In December 2010, a young woman was found dead in a luxury Melbourne apartment building under very strange circumstances. The official story says one thing, but the evidence? It raises a lot of questions.

This case has it all—bizarre details, a controversial investigation, and a theory that seems almost impossible. Was it a tragic accident, or is there more to the story?

Join Lollie & Rainy as they dig into the mystery surround...