Mental Health Diversion: A Second Chance Beyond Criminal Charges | William Pernik

Welcome to Counselor: Beyond Conventional Defense with William Pernik, criminal defense attorney and advocate for holistic, client-centered legal representation. In this episode, William breaks down one of the most transformative opportunities in criminal defense today: Mental Health Diversion. This program offers eligible individuals the chance to pause their criminal case, undergo treatment and supervision, and—upon successful completion—have their charges dismissed entirely. William explains who qualifies, the benefits and challenges of the program, why some attorneys hesitate to use it, and the life-changing results it can produce when done right. He also shares real-world success stories and provides guidance on how clients and their families can advocate for this powerful alternative to traditional prosecution. Timestamps:

00:00:00 – Introduction

00:00:33 – Understanding Mental Health Diversion

00:01:45 – Ideal Candidates for Mental Health Diversion

00:05:34 – Benefits of Mental Health Diversion

00:06:21 – Challenges and Considerations in Mental Health Diversion

00:08:04 – Understanding the Commitment Required for Mental Health Diversion

00:10:01 – Why Some Lawyers Avoid Mental Health Diversion

00:13:52 – Success Stories of Mental Health Diversion

00:15:08 – The Impact of Mental Health Diversion on Clients

00:15:54 – Using Mental Health Diversion as a Tool

00:16:03 – The Role of Treatment in Legal Representation

00:17:31 – The Limitations of Mental Health Diversion

00:18:39 – Closing Remarks and Contact Information What is Mental Health Diversion, and why does it matter? It’s an alternative legal pathway for defendants whose crimes stem from mental health or substance use issues. Instead of heading straight toward a conviction, qualifying individuals enter treatment, follow a structured plan, and—if successful—emerge with a clean slate. Who benefits from this approach? Those willing to commit to treatment, follow strict supervision, and address the root causes of their legal troubles. It’s not a shortcut—it’s a second chance that requires dedication and personal growth. Why isn’t it used more often? William explains the misconceptions among attorneys, the added work required to implement it, and why many lawyers stick to traditional defense strategies—even when diversion might serve their client better. Real Change, Real Lives From clients overcoming long-term addiction to individuals repairing family relationships, William shares how Mental Health Diversion has rewritten the stories of people who once felt trapped by the justice system. Challenges & Limitations It’s not for everyone. William discusses when diversion may fall short, the situations where it’s less effective, and how to set realistic expectations. Tune in to learn: Who qualifies for Mental Health Diversion and how to apply The legal and personal benefits of completing the program Common challenges and how to overcome them Why some attorneys avoid this option—and why you shouldn’t How this program can heal individuals, families, and communities This episode is a must-listen for defendants, families, and advocates seeking compassionate, effective alternatives to traditional prosecution.