34. Stop Spiraling: What Healthy Membership Numbers REALLY Look Like...

Free Training + Membership Links

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club (MDMC)

👉 https://milliondollarmembershipspodcast.paigevandy.com/offers/RuWG9nLD/checkout?coupon_code=MONTHLYMDMC2025

 

Free On-Demand Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

👉 https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

 

In this episode, Paige breaks down the real performance metrics behind a healthy membership so you can finally stop spiraling every time call attendance is “low,” someone cancels, or members aren’t binging every single piece of content.

If you’ve ever thought, “My membership must be failing because not everyone is active…” this episode will be a full nervous system reset.

 

Paige walks you through industry averages for engagement, call attendance, cancellations, sales conversions, content consumption, and retention so you can see where you actually stand—and when it’s time to strategically adjust your approach instead of burning everything down and starting over… again.

 

You'll Discover:

1. The membership metrics almost no one talks about — and why understanding them will instantly calm your founder anxiety

2. What healthy engagement, call attendance, and content consumption actually look like (spoiler: it’s not what you think)

3. The surprising churn benchmarks that separate normal cancellations from red flags

4. Why your first 30 days with a new member determine everything about their long-term retention

5. The sales conversion ranges you should really be aiming for — so you stop expecting 90% of your audience to buy

6. How to tell the difference between a true strategy issue… and a simple numbers game

7. The #1 mistake founders make that keeps them restarting their membership every few months

 

If you’re tired of making emotional decisions about your membership based on vibes and feelings instead of actual data, this episode will give you the benchmarks, context, and confidence you’ve been missing.

 

Winter Enrollment for Million Dollar Memberships Club

Doors to Million Dollar Memberships Club are currently open and closing again on December 17, 2025. After that, we’re not reopening until spring 2026.

MDMC is for you if:

1. You have a membership idea you’re ready to bring to life or…

2. You already have members, but things feel chaotic, taped together, or growth is slower than you’d like

3. You want real systems, strategy, and support to build a sticky, scalable membership with strong retention and real recurring revenue

4. You’re tired of guessing if your metrics are “good” and want proven processes you can trust

5. You're ready to take your membership seriously and put the proper systems and strategies in place to scale to 7 figures

Inside MDMC you’ll get:

1. Monthly live calls and personalized support with Paige

2. Full setup & optimization guides so you don’t miss any critical steps

3. A loaded template vault (onboarding, emails, sales events, funnels, and more) so you’re never starting from scratch

4. A community of membership founders who actually understand your business model

 

If you’re listening in real time and you don’t want to wait another quarter to get your membership dialed in, join now:

👉 httphttps://milliondollarmembershipspodcast.paigevandy.com/offers/RuWG9nLD/checkout?coupon_code=MONTHLYMDMC2025

If doors are closed when you’re reading this, hop on the waitlist on that same page so you’re the first to know when enrollment reopens.

 

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast

Free Training: The 4-Part System to La