July 5, 2025 • 15 mins
False teaching didn’t wait. From the start, the early church battled heresies that threatened the gospel itself. In this episode, we examine how movements like Gnosticism, Marcionism, and Montanism distorted truth—and how the church responded. We’ll explore the formation of the canon, the rise of creeds, and the struggle to preserve apostolic teaching. These early battles still shape today’s church, and understanding them helps us discern truth, pursue unity, and stand firm in the gospel.
Read: https://ready4eternity.com/why-so-many-churches-truth-comes-under-attack-part-2/
https://x.com/Ready4Eternity https://www.facebook.com/ready4eternity
The presence of any advertisements in connection with this content is determined solely by the hosting platform. I have no control over whether ads appear or not. I appreciate your understanding.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
Welcome to the Ready for Eternity
podcast, a podcast and blog dedicated to
inquisitive Bible students exploring
biblical truths that might not be fully
explored in typical
sermons or Bible studies.
(00:20):
My name is Eddie Lawrence.
Heresy struck early in church history,
and the church fought to defend truth,
and those battles still shape us today.
This is part two of "Why
Are There So Many Churches?"
(00:43):
The church's response to heresy shaped
Christianity for centuries to come.
Paul's teaching didn't
wait for the church to mature.
Deception appeared almost
immediately after Pentecost.
The apostles spent much of their time
correcting errors and defending truth.
(01:05):
This early battle against heresy explains
much about how our denominations formed.
The church's defensive strategies, some
brilliant and others problematic, echo
through history down to the present.
Understanding this struggle helps us
appreciate both our theological heritage
and our current divisions.
(01:28):
Three major heresies threatened the early
church's foundation.
One was Gnosticism.
Gnosticism was a broad and influential
movement that taught that salvation came
through secret knowledge, revealed only
to a spiritual elite.
Gnostics believed the physical world was
(01:48):
evil or inferior, and that only the
spirit was truly good.
Gnostics characterized
humanity into spiritual types.
Only certain individuals possessed the
inherent capacity to receive knowledge
and achieve salvation.
This introduced spiritual elitism,
(02:09):
suggesting that only some possessed the
capacity for salvation while others were
inherently excluded.
Gnosticism threatened the early church by
distorting the gospel, devaluing Jesus'
humanity, and dividing humanity into the
spiritual elites and ordinary people.
(02:33):
A second heresy was Marcionism.
Marcion of Sinope rejected the Old
Testament entirely and taught that the
God of Israel was a different, lower God
than the loving Father revealed by Jesus.
He also edited the New Testament to
exclude anything that sounded too Jewish,
(02:56):
keeping only parts of Luke
and some of Paul's letters.
His views forced the church to clarify
the continuity between the Old and New
Testaments and to begin defining an
authoritative list of
Christian scriptures.
Marcionism threatened the church by
attacking the unity of the Bible,
(03:16):
undermining Jesus' Jewish roots, and
promoting a distorted gospel.
A third major heresy in the
early church was Montanism.
Montanus and his followers believed that
the Holy Spirit was delivering new, final
revelations through them, often in
(03:37):
ecstatic and highly emotional prophecies.
Montanus believed the Holy Spirit was
giving them fresh truth that superseded
earlier scriptural revelation.
They called for radical purity, strict
fasting, and even welcoming martyrdom.
While Montanus affirmed some true
(03:58):
doctrines, the church eventually rejected
them for placing their prophecies on
parless scripture and rejecting the
authority of bishops.
Montanism threatened the church by
creating confusion over spiritual
authority, encouraging division, and
challenging the sufficiency of scripture.
(04:20):
Each heresy attracted followers, and each
threatened to destroy
Orthodox Christianity.
Several factors made the early church
vulnerable to deception.
For one, the New Testament
canon was still being formed.
Churches had not yet reached universal
(04:40):
consensus on which New Testament
documents God had inspired.
Churches possessed different collections
of texts, and uncertainty made it easier
for false teachers to
promote their own writings.
Another vulnerability was charismatic
personalities who led
many different movements.
(05:02):
Persuasive speakers attracted crowds
regardless of their message's truth.
People followed dynamic leaders rather
than testing their teaching.
Also, cultural philosophy
influenced church thinking.
The Greco-Roman world emphasized dualism,
(05:24):
the separation of spirit and matter.
Many Greeks pursued secret knowledge and
mystical experiences.
Therefore, culture conditioned some
believers to find some of these
unbiblical ideas attractive.
Early church leaders
developed a strategy to combat heresy.
(05:45):
They established three standards that
would preserve apostolic truth.
First, churches began compiling lists of
authoritative writings.
This process was informal, but gained
momentum as heresies spread.
Leaders asked crucial questions.
Which books came from the apostles or
(06:08):
their close associates?
Which text had been widely
accepted by the churches?
Which writings aligned
with known apostolic teaching?
This careful process eventually produced
our New Testament, but it took centuries
to complete, and it
wasn't without controversy.
(06:29):
Creed's were another
response of the church to heresy.
Short memorable statements of faith
emerged to counter false teaching.
These creeds clearly
affirmed essential church doctrines.
The most famous, the apostles' creed,
addressed Gnostic errors directly.
It declared that Jesus was born of the
(06:49):
Virgin Mary, affirming his humanity, and
suffered under Pontius Pilate,
confirming his physical death.
Creed served as teaching
tools and loyalty tests.
Anyone who could not affirm these basic
truths expressed in creeds was
immediately suspect.
(07:10):
And the third response to heresy was
apostolic succession.
Church leaders argued that true doctrine
came through the
apostles and their successors.
They claimed an unbroken chain of
authority from Jesus through
the apostles to current bishops.
This concept directly challenged Gnostic
(07:33):
claims about secret knowledge.
If the apostles had received hidden
truths, their
successors would know about them.
Since bishops denied any secret teaching,
then they claimed that none existed.
Eventually there was the rise of what was
referred to as Catholic Christianity.
(07:55):
The word Catholic means universal, or
according to the whole.
Early church leaders used it to mark off
true believers from heretical groups.
At this early date, Catholic was not the
name of a denomination.
It was a claim to continuity with the
apostles and a marker of Orthodox
(08:17):
teaching, that is, teaching according to
the whole, the whole church.
Calling themselves
Catholic was a bold declaration.
It said, "We are the true church, and
others are pretenders."
This strategy worked.
The Catholic Church became the dominant
form of Christianity, but it also planted
(08:39):
seeds of future problems.
For example, what happened when different
regions developed different practices?
What occurred when bishops
disagreed with each other?
Who decided which bishop
represented true Catholic teaching?
These questions would eventually split
the church into competing branches.
(09:02):
Key leaders emerged during this crucial
period who became known
as the Church Fathers.
They were early Christian leaders and
writers, mainly bishops, theologians, and
martyrs, who shaped the doctrine,
structure, and defense of the church in
its first few centuries.
Men like Clement of Rome, Ignatius of
(09:24):
Antioch, and Polycarp of Smyrna carried
apostolic teaching to
the next generation.
These apostolic fathers wrote letters
that still influenced Christianity today.
They defended Orthodox doctrine and
established church structure.
Their writings became very influential.
(09:47):
But they also began centralizing
authority in ways the
apostles never intended.
Simple biblical leadership gave way to
complex hierarchies.
This trend toward centralization reveals
an unavoidable tension.
The very structures intended to preserve
apostolic truth also
(10:07):
transformed how the church operated.
Building heresy resulted in movements
which would lead to institutionalization.
The early church's beautiful simplicity
eventually gave way to complex structures
that evolved to combat deception.
For better or worse, leaders created
(10:28):
systems and institutions intended to
preserve and protect apostolic teaching.
Their motive wasn't wrong.
Paul told Timothy to guard what has been
entrusted to you in 1
Timothy 6, verse 20.
The church needed ways to identify and
reject false teaching.
(10:49):
But like many well-meaning human
solutions, each one created new problems.
For example, creating creeds risked
oversimplifying complex truths.
Short statements couldn't capture every
nuance of biblical teaching.
Some important doctrines got less
attention than others.
(11:11):
Another problem was that emphasizing
apostolic succession
concentrated power in human hands.
Bishops gained enormous
influence over church life.
The system worked when bishops were
faithful, but failed when they weren't.
Not every solution led to new problems.
(11:31):
One of the major responses to heresy, the
formation of the New Testament canon,
stands out as a success.
It wasn't imposed by councils, but
recognized through
widespread church consensus.
The church affirmed writings already
trusted for their apostolic origin and
consistent use, even if regional
(11:54):
differences lingered for a time.
So what are the lessons for today?
The early church's battle against heresy
teaches us several important lessons.
First, false teaching
appears early and often.
Every generation faces deception and we
can't assume our time is different or
(12:15):
that we are immune to error.
Number two, scripture must
remain our final authority.
The church's response to heresy was not
entirely successful because it didn't
always base conclusions
exclusively on biblical truth.
When we drift from
scripture, we drift from safety.
(12:35):
Third, sound doctrine
requires careful thinking.
Scripture praises the Bereans for
examining scripture daily in Acts 17.
We must test every
teaching against God's word.
Fourth, structure serves
(12:55):
truth, not the reverse.
The church develops structures and
institutions to
preserve apostolic teaching.
When these become more important than
truth, we've lost our way.
And finally, unity around truth matters
more than unity for its own sake.
The early church separated from heretics
(13:16):
to preserve the gospel.
Sometimes, division is necessary to
maintain faithfulness.
Today's church faces similar challenges
with false teachers promoting secret
knowledge, cultural philosophy
influencing scripture interpretation, and
charismatic personalities attracting
(13:37):
followers regardless of truth.
We must base our response on clear
biblical standards and reliable,
biblically qualified leadership.
We must learn from history and avoid the
pitfalls that divided the church.
Most importantly, we must remember that
defending truth serves a higher purpose.
(14:00):
Jesus prayed for unity among believers so
that the world may believe.
The early church fought heresy to
preserve the life-saving gospel message,
and that same urgency
should drive us today.
In a world full of competing voices,
people need to hear the clear, unchanging
truth of the gospel—a truth worth
(14:22):
fighting for and
preserving for future generations.
Thanks for listening to the podcast.
We hope this episode has deepened your
understanding of scripture.
If you found this content valuable,
please share it with your friends.
For more biblical studies, visit our
website at readyforeternity.com.
(14:45):
That's the word "ready," the number four,
and the word "eternity."
Readyforeternity.com.
Be sure and leave a comment on the Ready
for Eternity Facebook
page or reach out on Twitter.
That's all for now.
Keep studying your Bible, growing closer
to God, and getting ready for eternity.
See you next time.
Welcome to the Ready for Eternity
podcast, a podcast and blog dedicated to
inquisitive Bible students exploring
biblical truths that might not be fully
explored in typical
sermons or Bible studies.
(00:20):
My name is Eddie Lawrence.
Heresy struck early in church history,
and the church fought to defend truth,
and those battles still shape us today.
This is part two of "Why
Are There So Many Churches?"
(00:43):
The church's response to heresy shaped
Christianity for centuries to come.
Paul's teaching didn't
wait for the church to mature.
Deception appeared almost
immediately after Pentecost.
The apostles spent much of their time
correcting errors and defending truth.
(01:05):
This early battle against heresy explains
much about how our denominations formed.
The church's defensive strategies, some
brilliant and others problematic, echo
through history down to the present.
Understanding this struggle helps us
appreciate both our theological heritage
and our current divisions.
(01:28):
Three major heresies threatened the early
church's foundation.
One was Gnosticism.
Gnosticism was a broad and influential
movement that taught that salvation came
through secret knowledge, revealed only
to a spiritual elite.
Gnostics believed the physical world was
(01:48):
evil or inferior, and that only the
spirit was truly good.
Gnostics characterized
humanity into spiritual types.
Only certain individuals possessed the
inherent capacity to receive knowledge
and achieve salvation.
This introduced spiritual elitism,
(02:09):
suggesting that only some possessed the
capacity for salvation while others were
inherently excluded.
Gnosticism threatened the early church by
distorting the gospel, devaluing Jesus'
humanity, and dividing humanity into the
spiritual elites and ordinary people.
(02:33):
A second heresy was Marcionism.
Marcion of Sinope rejected the Old
Testament entirely and taught that the
God of Israel was a different, lower God
than the loving Father revealed by Jesus.
He also edited the New Testament to
exclude anything that sounded too Jewish,
(02:56):
keeping only parts of Luke
and some of Paul's letters.
His views forced the church to clarify
the continuity between the Old and New
Testaments and to begin defining an
authoritative list of
Christian scriptures.
Marcionism threatened the church by
attacking the unity of the Bible,
(03:16):
undermining Jesus' Jewish roots, and
promoting a distorted gospel.
A third major heresy in the
early church was Montanism.
Montanus and his followers believed that
the Holy Spirit was delivering new, final
revelations through them, often in
(03:37):
ecstatic and highly emotional prophecies.
Montanus believed the Holy Spirit was
giving them fresh truth that superseded
earlier scriptural revelation.
They called for radical purity, strict
fasting, and even welcoming martyrdom.
While Montanus affirmed some true
(03:58):
doctrines, the church eventually rejected
them for placing their prophecies on
parless scripture and rejecting the
authority of bishops.
Montanism threatened the church by
creating confusion over spiritual
authority, encouraging division, and
challenging the sufficiency of scripture.
(04:20):
Each heresy attracted followers, and each
threatened to destroy
Orthodox Christianity.
Several factors made the early church
vulnerable to deception.
For one, the New Testament
canon was still being formed.
Churches had not yet reached universal
(04:40):
consensus on which New Testament
documents God had inspired.
Churches possessed different collections
of texts, and uncertainty made it easier
for false teachers to
promote their own writings.
Another vulnerability was charismatic
personalities who led
many different movements.
(05:02):
Persuasive speakers attracted crowds
regardless of their message's truth.
People followed dynamic leaders rather
than testing their teaching.
Also, cultural philosophy
influenced church thinking.
The Greco-Roman world emphasized dualism,
(05:24):
the separation of spirit and matter.
Many Greeks pursued secret knowledge and
mystical experiences.
Therefore, culture conditioned some
believers to find some of these
unbiblical ideas attractive.
Early church leaders
developed a strategy to combat heresy.
(05:45):
They established three standards that
would preserve apostolic truth.
First, churches began compiling lists of
authoritative writings.
This process was informal, but gained
momentum as heresies spread.
Leaders asked crucial questions.
Which books came from the apostles or
(06:08):
their close associates?
Which text had been widely
accepted by the churches?
Which writings aligned
with known apostolic teaching?
This careful process eventually produced
our New Testament, but it took centuries
to complete, and it
wasn't without controversy.
(06:29):
Creed's were another
response of the church to heresy.
Short memorable statements of faith
emerged to counter false teaching.
These creeds clearly
affirmed essential church doctrines.
The most famous, the apostles' creed,
addressed Gnostic errors directly.
It declared that Jesus was born of the
(06:49):
Virgin Mary, affirming his humanity, and
suffered under Pontius Pilate,
confirming his physical death.
Creed served as teaching
tools and loyalty tests.
Anyone who could not affirm these basic
truths expressed in creeds was
immediately suspect.
(07:10):
And the third response to heresy was
apostolic succession.
Church leaders argued that true doctrine
came through the
apostles and their successors.
They claimed an unbroken chain of
authority from Jesus through
the apostles to current bishops.
This concept directly challenged Gnostic
(07:33):
claims about secret knowledge.
If the apostles had received hidden
truths, their
successors would know about them.
Since bishops denied any secret teaching,
then they claimed that none existed.
Eventually there was the rise of what was
referred to as Catholic Christianity.
(07:55):
The word Catholic means universal, or
according to the whole.
Early church leaders used it to mark off
true believers from heretical groups.
At this early date, Catholic was not the
name of a denomination.
It was a claim to continuity with the
apostles and a marker of Orthodox
(08:17):
teaching, that is, teaching according to
the whole, the whole church.
Calling themselves
Catholic was a bold declaration.
It said, "We are the true church, and
others are pretenders."
This strategy worked.
The Catholic Church became the dominant
form of Christianity, but it also planted
(08:39):
seeds of future problems.
For example, what happened when different
regions developed different practices?
What occurred when bishops
disagreed with each other?
Who decided which bishop
represented true Catholic teaching?
These questions would eventually split
the church into competing branches.
(09:02):
Key leaders emerged during this crucial
period who became known
as the Church Fathers.
They were early Christian leaders and
writers, mainly bishops, theologians, and
martyrs, who shaped the doctrine,
structure, and defense of the church in
its first few centuries.
Men like Clement of Rome, Ignatius of
(09:24):
Antioch, and Polycarp of Smyrna carried
apostolic teaching to
the next generation.
These apostolic fathers wrote letters
that still influenced Christianity today.
They defended Orthodox doctrine and
established church structure.
Their writings became very influential.
(09:47):
But they also began centralizing
authority in ways the
apostles never intended.
Simple biblical leadership gave way to
complex hierarchies.
This trend toward centralization reveals
an unavoidable tension.
The very structures intended to preserve
apostolic truth also
(10:07):
transformed how the church operated.
Building heresy resulted in movements
which would lead to institutionalization.
The early church's beautiful simplicity
eventually gave way to complex structures
that evolved to combat deception.
For better or worse, leaders created
(10:28):
systems and institutions intended to
preserve and protect apostolic teaching.
Their motive wasn't wrong.
Paul told Timothy to guard what has been
entrusted to you in 1
Timothy 6, verse 20.
The church needed ways to identify and
reject false teaching.
(10:49):
But like many well-meaning human
solutions, each one created new problems.
For example, creating creeds risked
oversimplifying complex truths.
Short statements couldn't capture every
nuance of biblical teaching.
Some important doctrines got less
attention than others.
(11:11):
Another problem was that emphasizing
apostolic succession
concentrated power in human hands.
Bishops gained enormous
influence over church life.
The system worked when bishops were
faithful, but failed when they weren't.
Not every solution led to new problems.
(11:31):
One of the major responses to heresy, the
formation of the New Testament canon,
stands out as a success.
It wasn't imposed by councils, but
recognized through
widespread church consensus.
The church affirmed writings already
trusted for their apostolic origin and
consistent use, even if regional
(11:54):
differences lingered for a time.
So what are the lessons for today?
The early church's battle against heresy
teaches us several important lessons.
First, false teaching
appears early and often.
Every generation faces deception and we
can't assume our time is different or
(12:15):
that we are immune to error.
Number two, scripture must
remain our final authority.
The church's response to heresy was not
entirely successful because it didn't
always base conclusions
exclusively on biblical truth.
When we drift from
scripture, we drift from safety.
(12:35):
Third, sound doctrine
requires careful thinking.
Scripture praises the Bereans for
examining scripture daily in Acts 17.
We must test every
teaching against God's word.
Fourth, structure serves
(12:55):
truth, not the reverse.
The church develops structures and
institutions to
preserve apostolic teaching.
When these become more important than
truth, we've lost our way.
And finally, unity around truth matters
more than unity for its own sake.
The early church separated from heretics
(13:16):
to preserve the gospel.
Sometimes, division is necessary to
maintain faithfulness.
Today's church faces similar challenges
with false teachers promoting secret
knowledge, cultural philosophy
influencing scripture interpretation, and
charismatic personalities attracting
(13:37):
followers regardless of truth.
We must base our response on clear
biblical standards and reliable,
biblically qualified leadership.
We must learn from history and avoid the
pitfalls that divided the church.
Most importantly, we must remember that
defending truth serves a higher purpose.
(14:00):
Jesus prayed for unity among believers so
that the world may believe.
The early church fought heresy to
preserve the life-saving gospel message,
and that same urgency
should drive us today.
In a world full of competing voices,
people need to hear the clear, unchanging
truth of the gospel—a truth worth
(14:22):
fighting for and
preserving for future generations.
Thanks for listening to the podcast.
We hope this episode has deepened your
understanding of scripture.
If you found this content valuable,
please share it with your friends.
For more biblical studies, visit our
website at readyforeternity.com.
(14:45):
That's the word "ready," the number four,
and the word "eternity."
Readyforeternity.com.
Be sure and leave a comment on the Ready
for Eternity Facebook
page or reach out on Twitter.
That's all for now.
Keep studying your Bible, growing closer
to God, and getting ready for eternity.
See you next time.
Popular Podcasts
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
24/7 News: The Latest
The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.