Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:01):
Scab.
Yes.
You know when you have that moment of absolute scatterbrain where you don't really know, like you do things like you forget your phones in your hand, or oh, I do this all the time.
Yeah.
I had a really bad moment of scatterbrain this week.
What happened? I've just had a really busy week with work and I was really tired and.
(00:22):
I went to go get a coffee at the local cafe where I go to whenever I work from home And I have my Cape Cup, which is this like lime green or mint green, Frank Green Cape Cup, which I take with me anyway, grab it, get on a lift, go down, get outside, walk to the cafe, walk inside and walk up to the register to pay.
(00:47):
And I look down and I'm staring at.
Something in my hand and I'm like, something doesn't look quite right.
What? What was that? I took my Bluetooth speaker with me.
Instead of my They look the same.
What? Yeah.
You're gonna have to show me a photo.
Yeah.
So anyway, I, this is like your should have gone to spec safe's moment.
(01:10):
The worst thing was is I looked at it for a good five seconds to be like, what is wrong? What is you knew it was the speaker or you were sort of like, why am I holding this? Or like just like.
You are not my coffee cup.
Did they notice? Oh yeah.
Quite.
They were just a bit like, oh.
And I was like, I'll, I'll be back.
(01:32):
So I just went back and got my capec and came back and got my coffee.
Oh, that is hilarious.
I don't even know how I did it.
You hadn't had your coffee it, yeah.
So anyway, that's what happens when it gets scatter brain.
You do things like that.
You are funny.
29
00:01:51,166.66666667 --> 00:02:06,16.66666667
Coming up this week on Spin Cycle, we are diving into influencer fallout, courtroom showdowns and tech billionaires behaving badly from Blake Lively, dropping emotional distress claims to Elon Musk rage quitting the White House, plus leaked out Booth haircare scandal.
30
00:02:06,16.66666667 --> 00:02:08,326.66666667
And Taylor Swift buying back her masters again.
31
00:02:08,566.66666667 --> 00:02:13,816.66666667
And yes, Erin Patterson took the stand and we break it down for you in this week's edition of Death Cat Diaries.
32
00:02:28,938.6355248 --> 00:02:34,908.6355248
Welcome to Spin Cycle, where we dig into the stories shaping the world and take a closer look at the patterns, power plays.
33
00:02:34,908.6355248 --> 00:02:42,618.6355248
And yes, the biases hiding in plain sight where Gab and Claire, two friends with MBAs, A lot of opinions and a healthy amount of skepticism.
34
00:02:42,918.6355248 --> 00:02:45,918.6355248
We are here to help you think twice and maybe have a few laughs.
35
00:02:46,218.6355248 --> 00:02:47,73.6355248
Let's get spinning.
36
00:02:47,314.14572888 --> 00:02:54,29.14572888
Gab, what's top of mind for you this week? Random one for me, but I thought I was being cost savvy this week.
37
00:02:54,34.14572888 --> 00:02:54,304.14572888
Mm-hmm.
38
00:02:54,329.14572888 --> 00:02:55,949.14572888
And I was like, well, sorry.
39
00:02:56,9.14572888 --> 00:02:57,59.14572888
Last week.
40
00:02:57,419.14572888 --> 00:03:01,629.14572888
And I had those notes in the mail to get your free first box of HelloFresh.
41
00:03:01,954.14572888 --> 00:03:02,174.14572888
Yes.
42
00:03:02,179.14572888 --> 00:03:02,439.14572888
Yes.
43
00:03:02,649.14572888 --> 00:03:04,899.14572888
So anyway, did it last week? Great.
44
00:03:05,199.14572888 --> 00:03:07,629.14572888
This week I had it in my mind.
45
00:03:07,629.14572888 --> 00:03:09,159.14572888
You need to skip it if you don't wanna use it.
46
00:03:09,204.14572888 --> 00:03:09,604.14572888
Mm-hmm.
47
00:03:10,374.14572888 --> 00:03:16,494.14572888
Then anywho, I check my bank account Wednesday morning and I've been charged like a ridiculous amount.
48
00:03:16,494.14572888 --> 00:03:22,614.14572888
I'm like, oh no, it's the HelloFresh because you've got the cutoff time for the thing you just made.
49
00:03:23,94.14572888 --> 00:03:29,624.14572888
Do you even get to pick your recipes? No, and that's the, like this, what I wanna talk about is I feel like it was a make or break moment.
50
00:03:29,624.14572888 --> 00:03:37,124.14572888
'cause I looked at the recipes and it was like three recipes that they chose for me, and they were the most random recipes.
51
00:03:37,124.14572888 --> 00:03:38,564.14572888
I'm like, surely you'd pick the most.
52
00:03:39,89.14572888 --> 00:03:41,519.14572888
Common ones, like when something like this happens.
53
00:03:41,879.14572888 --> 00:03:43,799.14572888
Anyway, I was like, okay, fine, I'll deal with it.
54
00:03:43,799.14572888 --> 00:03:48,119.14572888
I'll have this random dish a burger.
55
00:03:48,149.14572888 --> 00:03:49,919.14572888
These are supposed to be my lunches for work.
56
00:03:49,949.14572888 --> 00:03:50,819.14572888
That's what I've been using it for.
57
00:03:50,819.14572888 --> 00:03:52,469.14572888
I'm like, I'm not gonna bring a burger to work.
58
00:03:52,469.14572888 --> 00:03:55,4.14572888
And I can't remember what the other one was, but I'm like, okay, cool.
59
00:03:55,4.14572888 --> 00:03:56,114.14572888
Fine, I can deal with it.
60
00:03:56,564.14572888 --> 00:04:00,314.14572888
Then I'm like, okay, so when's it arriving? Saturday morning.
61
00:04:01,4.14572888 --> 00:04:02,144.14572888
I'm not gonna be around this weekend.
62
00:04:02,444.14572888 --> 00:04:03,749.14572888
Oh no, G.
63
00:04:03,849.14572888 --> 00:04:12,914.14572888
So I'm like, okay, I've got these recipes that I didn't want and I can't even receive them, and I'm gonna be wait till Monday.
64
00:04:13,334.14572888 --> 00:04:19,9.14572888
So what am I gonna do? Any who? This is a shout out to HelloFresh because I just called them.
65
00:04:19,489.14572888 --> 00:04:21,889.14572888
I explained my situation like I'm not gonna be there.
66
00:04:21,889.14572888 --> 00:04:22,549.14572888
I am sorry.
67
00:04:22,939.14572888 --> 00:04:29,149.14572888
Any who Eventually, after waiting on hold for quite a long period of time and going through the rounds I managed to.
68
00:04:29,969.14572888 --> 00:04:32,69.14572888
I didn't get a refund, but you got a credit.
69
00:04:32,69.14572888 --> 00:04:32,669.14572888
I got a credit.
70
00:04:32,819.14572888 --> 00:04:32,999.14572888
Okay.
71
00:04:32,999.14572888 --> 00:04:33,569.14572888
So it's something.
72
00:04:33,749.14572888 --> 00:04:39,349.14572888
So now I've put a reminder in my diary, which is like the night of the cutoff is and it's in capital letters.
73
00:04:39,349.14572888 --> 00:04:40,9.14572888
It's so aggressive.
74
00:04:40,9.14572888 --> 00:04:43,329.14572888
It's cancel, do not forget, cancel or choose recipe.
75
00:04:43,359.14572888 --> 00:04:44,649.14572888
So it's how they get you.
76
00:04:44,709.14572888 --> 00:04:45,549.14572888
It's the business model.
77
00:04:45,549.14572888 --> 00:04:46,509.14572888
It's how they get you.
78
00:04:46,999.14572888 --> 00:04:51,289.14572888
And what about you? What's been on your mind, top of mind? So I've been watching this new show.
79
00:04:51,379.14572888 --> 00:04:54,529.14572888
It's on Foxtail, but I imagine it would be on binge and it's called.
80
00:04:55,69.14572888 --> 00:04:57,829.14572888
Billionaires playground and it is so good.
81
00:04:57,829.14572888 --> 00:05:00,679.14572888
It's like below deck on land.
82
00:05:00,739.14572888 --> 00:05:02,959.14572888
But Australian is it like Big Brother.
83
00:05:03,109.14572888 --> 00:05:11,969.14572888
What is this? This company where they do like luxury holidays and you have a full concierge team, butlers, chefs, housekeeping.
84
00:05:13,564.14572888 --> 00:05:13,784.14572888
Wow.
85
00:05:14,39.14572888 --> 00:05:18,479.14572888
And they hire out these like luxury houses and then plan your.
86
00:05:19,94.14572888 --> 00:05:21,644.14572888
Holiday and it's insane.
87
00:05:21,704.14572888 --> 00:05:32,804.14572888
And like the first guests that came through were just, this is what I imagine billionaires would be like, or people that aspire to think they're richer than what they are.
88
00:05:32,834.14572888 --> 00:05:33,519.14572888
Hang on, hang on, hang on.
89
00:05:33,554.14572888 --> 00:05:39,74.14572888
So they do all, they say plan what? The holiday of all these random billionaires that they're bringing together on this holiday.
90
00:05:39,569.14572888 --> 00:05:44,99.14572888
So this was like a group of women in the first episode and the next one was this like ex-army guy.
91
00:05:44,249.14572888 --> 00:05:46,559.14572888
So they force these people PeopleNet on go together? No, not force.
92
00:05:46,559.14572888 --> 00:05:50,579.14572888
Like these people hire like the holiday and they just agree to be filmed like they do on Below Deck.
93
00:05:51,449.14572888 --> 00:05:51,479.14572888
Oh.
94
00:05:51,479.14572888 --> 00:05:56,369.14572888
Where they like, they're charted the boat and they get a slight discount for allowing below deck to film.
95
00:05:56,369.14572888 --> 00:06:03,404.14572888
And quite often they're just excited to be five seconds of fame and, well this is fascinating 'cause obviously if you're a billionaire, you don't need the money.
96
00:06:03,434.14572888 --> 00:06:10,664.14572888
Why would they do this? The board? No, I suspect it's people that don't have money and they like to outwardly project.
97
00:06:10,964.14572888 --> 00:06:11,534.14572888
Oh yeah.
98
00:06:11,594.14572888 --> 00:06:12,374.14572888
It felt like that.
99
00:06:12,374.14572888 --> 00:06:14,924.14572888
Like these women were like caviar.
100
00:06:14,974.14572888 --> 00:06:20,494.14572888
This lady was like going on about how, new grape wines need to be, a certain degree of temperature.
101
00:06:20,494.14572888 --> 00:06:22,234.14572888
And the guy's like, it's been in the fridge for three days.
102
00:06:22,234.14572888 --> 00:06:26,464.14572888
Like, what do you want from me lady? Oh, oh, okay.
103
00:06:26,464.14572888 --> 00:06:26,824.14572888
No, sorry.
104
00:06:26,884.14572888 --> 00:06:27,484.14572888
This is the next bit.
105
00:06:27,514.14572888 --> 00:06:28,24.14572888
Yeah.
106
00:06:28,54.14572888 --> 00:06:32,104.14572888
This one lady brings the lead concierge aside and was like, I've got feedback for you.
107
00:06:32,104.14572888 --> 00:06:32,974.14572888
And she's okay, bring it.
108
00:06:32,974.14572888 --> 00:06:34,354.14572888
And thinking it's gonna be quite bad.
109
00:06:34,654.14572888 --> 00:06:37,724.14572888
Her feedback was, it's quite inconvenient.
110
00:06:37,724.14572888 --> 00:06:42,284.14572888
The bin in the bathroom is just not in the most optimum.
111
00:06:42,779.14572888 --> 00:06:44,789.14572888
Location for using the bin.
112
00:06:44,819.14572888 --> 00:06:46,979.14572888
And it's quite inconvenient for me.
113
00:06:47,549.14572888 --> 00:06:50,939.14572888
And you could just see this woman be like, okay, yep.
114
00:06:50,969.14572888 --> 00:06:52,289.14572888
That, that's absolutely fair.
115
00:06:52,339.14572888 --> 00:07:00,619.14572888
I just wonder if anything actually real went wrong, how much she would escalate it if that's her reaction to the way the bin is, and surely she can move it herself.
116
00:07:01,339.14572888 --> 00:07:01,969.14572888
I have no idea.
117
00:07:01,969.14572888 --> 00:07:04,369.14572888
And then this lady dropped in for the day with her dog and they.
118
00:07:04,814.14572888 --> 00:07:07,244.14572888
Very stressed that they do not allow dogs in the property.
119
00:07:07,694.14572888 --> 00:07:11,234.14572888
And they call like the owners of the property and the owners were like, no dogs.
120
00:07:11,564.14572888 --> 00:07:20,24.14572888
And then they're like, okay, well if she agrees to pay a thousand dollars for us to deep clean the carpet and the dog's not allowed on the furniture, we'll allow it.
121
00:07:20,324.14572888 --> 00:07:22,124.14572888
And they go up to the lady and they're like, you gotta pay a thousand bucks.
122
00:07:22,124.14572888 --> 00:07:25,534.14572888
And she's like, that's a fair, fair cost to have my dog.
123
00:07:26,164.14572888 --> 00:07:27,514.14572888
Just to pop in for the day.
124
00:07:27,514.14572888 --> 00:07:29,314.14572888
A thousand dollars cost just straight up.
125
00:07:29,614.14572888 --> 00:07:32,644.14572888
So it's either someone who has no money or someone who's just.
126
00:07:33,114.14572888 --> 00:07:34,464.14572888
Infinitely wealthy.
127
00:07:35,304.14572888 --> 00:07:45,984.14572888
But why? One thing with that is if the whole thing is that they're billionaires, are they, do they have, is that the prerequisite or you're saying No, they could be a billionaire there, or, I don't know.
128
00:07:45,984.14572888 --> 00:07:48,504.14572888
It's just the show's called, I don't know how Rich she's, anyway, all right.
129
00:07:48,504.14572888 --> 00:07:49,284.14572888
I'm gonna watch her.
130
00:07:49,464.14572888 --> 00:07:49,854.14572888
I don't know.
131
00:07:49,854.14572888 --> 00:07:53,364.14572888
The things that I've learned is that the richer someone is, the more private that person is.
132
00:07:54,444.14572888 --> 00:07:54,864.14572888
Oh yeah.
133
00:07:54,864.14572888 --> 00:07:56,484.14572888
The less that they're gonna talk about it.
134
00:07:56,544.14572888 --> 00:07:56,874.14572888
Yeah.
135
00:07:56,874.14572888 --> 00:07:59,604.14572888
They, if you, and also how long they've been wealthy.
136
00:07:59,844.14572888 --> 00:08:00,654.14572888
Yes.
137
00:08:01,194.14572888 --> 00:08:01,704.14572888
Like.
138
00:08:02,724.14572888 --> 00:08:07,884.14572888
We always joke that if you see someone walking along with like a Rolex and driving a Mercedes, they are poor.
139
00:08:08,214.14572888 --> 00:08:15,924.14572888
But if that person's wearing, driving a hybrid Corolla and has a smart watch, I.
140
00:08:16,704.14572888 --> 00:08:17,154.14572888
Oh yeah.
141
00:08:17,154.14572888 --> 00:08:21,64.14572888
Or even just like in TrackX like Adam Sandler, you know what I mean? Yeah, yeah.
142
00:08:21,64.14572888 --> 00:08:24,754.14572888
But yeah, no, I think that's a fair, I think that's a fair theory on that actually.
143
00:08:25,684.14572888 --> 00:08:26,914.14572888
Anyway, so that's my top of mind.
144
00:08:26,914.14572888 --> 00:08:27,724.14572888
Highly recommend.
145
00:08:28,344.14572888 --> 00:08:30,204.14572888
But Gab, tell me about our first segment.
146
00:08:31,34.14572888 --> 00:08:33,104.14572888
The first thing I really wanted to talk about.
147
00:08:33,644.14572888 --> 00:08:42,574.14572888
This week is something that's really come up more in social media in Australia, and that is the launch of Boof Haircare.
148
00:08:42,574.14572888 --> 00:08:44,104.14572888
I dunno if you've heard of it, Claire.
149
00:08:44,554.14572888 --> 00:08:46,114.14572888
I've seen the tiktoks.
150
00:08:46,234.14572888 --> 00:08:47,14.14572888
Okay, good.
151
00:08:47,14.14572888 --> 00:08:56,894.14572888
So basically there's been a controversy this week with Indie Clinton who's been promoting booth hair care and her involvement with booth hair care, which essentially is about hair growth.
152
00:08:57,314.14572888 --> 00:08:58,664.14572888
So it's like a product line.
153
00:08:59,474.14572888 --> 00:09:08,744.14572888
That's dedicated to helping people like promote hair growth to, thicken your hair make it seem more lush, targeting women who want to have a thick ponytail.
154
00:09:08,744.14572888 --> 00:09:10,604.14572888
Who is, by the way, I might be a bit daft.
155
00:09:10,604.14572888 --> 00:09:14,539.14572888
Who's Indie Clinton? She's like a TikTok influencer.
156
00:09:14,969.14572888 --> 00:09:15,259.14572888
Okay.
157
00:09:15,624.14572888 --> 00:09:18,744.14572888
Will I know it because I'm a heavy duty TikTok user.
158
00:09:19,139.14572888 --> 00:09:19,684.14572888
Maybe not.
159
00:09:19,689.14572888 --> 00:09:23,279.14572888
You may have seen her stuff, but maybe you just didn't recognize her name.
160
00:09:23,279.14572888 --> 00:09:24,4.14572888
She's not in my algorithm.
161
00:09:24,719.14572888 --> 00:09:25,679.14572888
She's not in your algorithm.
162
00:09:25,679.14572888 --> 00:09:26,519.14572888
Make she old now.
163
00:09:26,549.14572888 --> 00:09:28,529.14572888
'cause now we're talking about it and our phones are in the room.
164
00:09:28,649.14572888 --> 00:09:30,179.14572888
I have seen the booth haircare.
165
00:09:30,239.14572888 --> 00:09:34,349.14572888
Tiktoks, but I've seen the tiktoks more from a controversy perspective.
166
00:09:34,589.14572888 --> 00:09:38,519.14572888
'cause a lot of people are asking them to share the academic research.
167
00:09:39,284.14572888 --> 00:09:44,354.14572888
In the product that they're claiming, which is also probably why Indie Clinton's not in my algorithm.
168
00:09:44,414.14572888 --> 00:09:46,484.14572888
Yeah, and also, we don't have kids.
169
00:09:46,544.14572888 --> 00:09:48,254.14572888
She's also mummy blogger vibes.
170
00:09:48,374.14572888 --> 00:09:48,674.14572888
She's a mum talk.
171
00:09:48,674.14572888 --> 00:09:48,764.14572888
Okay.
172
00:09:48,764.14572888 --> 00:09:49,364.14572888
Yeah, totally.
173
00:09:49,694.14572888 --> 00:09:53,414.14572888
So what's happened this week is she's promoting that.
174
00:09:54,374.14572888 --> 00:09:56,24.14572888
That's absolutely fine, you would think.
175
00:09:56,414.14572888 --> 00:10:08,84.14572888
However, what's come out is that in all of the promotion of her saying that she's using this product, she's actually been wearing hair extensions and like wigs in the content.
176
00:10:08,804.14572888 --> 00:10:10,94.14572888
What? Yes.
177
00:10:10,154.14572888 --> 00:10:11,654.14572888
So that makes no sense.
178
00:10:11,684.14572888 --> 00:10:23,54.14572888
I would just would've thought that in this day and time where we've got, millennials, gen Z people really looking for authenticity and brand alignment with influences, you can break that trust really quickly.
179
00:10:23,54.14572888 --> 00:10:26,294.14572888
So you're telling me a brand that's been not.
180
00:10:26,924.14572888 --> 00:10:34,604.14572888
Overly forthcoming on their academic research and their marketing material has wigs and hair extensions Yeah.
181
00:10:35,144.14572888 --> 00:10:39,974.14572888
Are getting a bit of pushback from customers.
182
00:10:40,54.14572888 --> 00:10:54,614.14572888
Because it's false advertising, right? Oh, so the brand's response has been from the founder, Rachel Wilde, basically saying that the choice was to use wigs and extensions as a form of an artistic expression.
183
00:10:54,674.14572888 --> 00:10:56,774.14572888
Isn't that misleading though? Yeah, it is.
184
00:10:56,774.14572888 --> 00:10:57,344.14572888
It is.
185
00:10:57,344.14572888 --> 00:11:02,234.14572888
And I think for their target market especially with a product like that, you're preying on vulnerability.
186
00:11:02,234.14572888 --> 00:11:04,324.14572888
You're saying, your life's better when your hair is thick.
187
00:11:04,329.14572888 --> 00:11:06,759.14572888
It's almost like teeth whitening, right? It's not transparent.
188
00:11:06,819.14572888 --> 00:11:07,719.14572888
No, it's not.
189
00:11:07,769.14572888 --> 00:11:15,959.14572888
So it sparks that bigger, larger conversation about that transparency in influencer marketing, which is more and more important.
190
00:11:16,249.14572888 --> 00:11:22,79.14572888
I don't write you my algorithm, the content is a lot less polished these days and what it was say five, seven years ago.
191
00:11:22,319.14572888 --> 00:11:26,249.14572888
Because people want real stories or real connection and.
192
00:11:26,804.14572888 --> 00:11:28,544.14572888
The Aussies is quite skeptical.
193
00:11:28,554.14572888 --> 00:11:32,664.14572888
They wanna buy a product that's actually real and has results as well.
194
00:11:32,674.14572888 --> 00:11:38,104.14572888
I've never used it, but Bondi Boost actually has content which shows people's hair growth over a period of using it.
195
00:11:38,264.14572888 --> 00:11:38,714.14572888
Exactly.
196
00:11:38,764.14572888 --> 00:11:44,729.14572888
And because you, they're playing this sort of space, it does have that challenge of not just transparency, but ethics as well.
197
00:11:45,29.14572888 --> 00:11:50,159.14572888
I don't know if Indie Clinton owns a stake in the company, but she hasn't been putting the advertising.
198
00:11:50,744.14572888 --> 00:11:53,804.14572888
Tag on her videos promoting it.
199
00:11:54,584.14572888 --> 00:11:55,634.14572888
That's fascinating.
200
00:11:55,874.14572888 --> 00:11:58,544.14572888
I don't know if that's, I think actually that might be illegal now.
201
00:11:58,574.14572888 --> 00:12:03,124.14572888
'cause remember I thought you'd you're being paid you to I think you're supposed to have that.
202
00:12:03,124.14572888 --> 00:12:03,664.14572888
It's sponsored.
203
00:12:03,664.14572888 --> 00:12:05,664.14572888
You're supposed to, especially when you've, so if she's not being paid, gifted.
204
00:12:06,524.14572888 --> 00:12:07,4.14572888
No gifted.
205
00:12:07,4.14572888 --> 00:12:08,864.14572888
You still have to 'cause it's in kind.
206
00:12:09,104.14572888 --> 00:12:09,314.14572888
Yeah.
207
00:12:09,314.14572888 --> 00:12:13,844.14572888
And because of the nature of the size of her network, she's a broadcaster essentially.
208
00:12:13,844.14572888 --> 00:12:15,434.14572888
So she has that influencing power.
209
00:12:16,229.14572888 --> 00:12:18,239.14572888
But overall, this feels so predatory.
210
00:12:18,239.14572888 --> 00:12:27,779.14572888
Like hair growth for so many people is such a vulnerable topic and a vulnerable aspect of people's image, and it just makes me feel uncomfortable.
211
00:12:27,779.14572888 --> 00:12:32,279.14572888
The fact that they're promoting it's, see, it's so Inge Ingenuine.
212
00:12:32,459.14572888 --> 00:12:32,759.14572888
Yeah.
213
00:12:32,759.14572888 --> 00:12:34,499.14572888
And it's also the launch of the brand.
214
00:12:34,559.14572888 --> 00:12:39,659.14572888
So I just don't know if this is gonna be just a small hump and they'll recover or.
215
00:12:39,909.14572888 --> 00:12:46,449.14572888
I'm just curious and how that sort of affect affected the results they were probably hoping to get in this launch period of time.
216
00:12:46,499.14572888 --> 00:12:54,59.14572888
The other thing I'll say for the founder, Rachel Wilde, the title of our segment is Indie Clinton's Booth Haircare Backlash.
217
00:12:54,389.14572888 --> 00:12:57,479.14572888
She's really tied her brand to the influencer.
218
00:12:57,929.14572888 --> 00:13:00,29.14572888
Yeah, she has, and a lot of people do these days.
219
00:13:00,29.14572888 --> 00:13:02,429.14572888
That's how you get the younger generation get saturation.
220
00:13:02,609.14572888 --> 00:13:08,989.14572888
The fact that they've come out saying it's artistic expression she's also admitted that they played a part in the content.
221
00:13:08,989.14572888 --> 00:13:11,719.14572888
So I don't know if that has made it any better, to be honest.
222
00:13:11,899.14572888 --> 00:13:12,769.14572888
No, I can't tell you.
223
00:13:12,769.14572888 --> 00:13:18,199.14572888
But until I actually see proof that these products work and some actual reviews, I certainly wouldn't be interested.
224
00:13:19,911.81239618 --> 00:13:21,621.81239618
Gab, it's actually happened.
225
00:13:21,951.81239618 --> 00:13:23,31.81239618
It is the inevitable.
226
00:13:23,31.81239618 --> 00:13:24,201.81239618
We all knew it was gonna happen.
227
00:13:24,231.81239618 --> 00:13:24,951.81239618
It was happening.
228
00:13:25,790.14573111 --> 00:13:29,570.14573111
We all knew that Donald Trump at Elon Musk would have a falling out.
229
00:13:29,780.14573111 --> 00:13:33,560.14573111
It's probably the miracle that they've lasted as long as they have.
230
00:13:33,840.14573111 --> 00:13:40,650.14573111
Elon Musk was appointed to lead a newly created US government body, which was the Department of Government Efficiency.
231
00:13:40,650.14573111 --> 00:13:42,90.14573111
It sounds like it should be in the office.
232
00:13:42,120.14573111 --> 00:13:43,595.14573111
What do we call it? Doge? Doge.
233
00:13:43,665.14573111 --> 00:13:44,700.14573111
Doge Doge.
234
00:13:44,700.14573111 --> 00:13:47,220.14573111
Because I think was also like a meme coin as well.
235
00:13:47,640.14573111 --> 00:13:52,770.14573111
So he would've thought it was so funny and clever, but he is not elected so.
236
00:13:53,490.14573111 --> 00:14:00,630.14573111
As a special government employee, he can only be hired for a maximum 130 days of service and a 365 day period.
237
00:14:00,810.14573111 --> 00:14:03,900.14573111
So he was coming to the conclusion of that period.
238
00:14:04,440.14573111 --> 00:14:08,70.14573111
And it was always said that it was only three months.
239
00:14:08,100.14573111 --> 00:14:08,820.14573111
Yeah, exactly.
240
00:14:09,30.14573111 --> 00:14:09,360.14573111
Yeah.
241
00:14:09,570.14573111 --> 00:14:13,350.14573111
And we just think back when he started, which was, Trump's inauguration.
242
00:14:14,250.14573111 --> 00:14:19,20.14573111
I spent such a short amount of time and so much chaos.
243
00:14:19,80.14573111 --> 00:14:20,190.14573111
Oh, so much chaos.
244
00:14:20,190.14573111 --> 00:14:22,890.14573111
Although doesn't January seem like so long ago.
245
00:14:23,130.14573111 --> 00:14:23,790.14573111
Yeah, exactly.
246
00:14:24,330.14573111 --> 00:14:32,865.14573111
So Elon Musk appointed himself and I think it was kind of a gift to himself for his support to Trump during the presidential elections.
247
00:14:33,565.14573111 --> 00:14:35,625.14573111
He said, we're gonna disrupt traditional.
248
00:14:36,225.14573111 --> 00:14:37,875.14573111
Government systems, they're bureaucratic.
249
00:14:37,875.14573111 --> 00:14:38,985.14573111
There's so much waste.
250
00:14:39,285.14573111 --> 00:14:44,325.14573111
We are gonna be Abe to apply first principles thinking, what does that even mean? Great question.
251
00:14:44,475.14573111 --> 00:14:46,5.14573111
I don't think he knew what it meant.
252
00:14:46,815.14573111 --> 00:14:48,765.14573111
And it was very much a PR stunt.
253
00:14:49,35.14573111 --> 00:14:49,275.14573111
Oh yeah.
254
00:14:49,280.14573111 --> 00:14:49,690.14573111
To appeal to, yeah.
255
00:14:49,695.14573111 --> 00:14:51,885.14573111
Big ideas with no no gravity.
256
00:14:51,975.14573111 --> 00:14:52,245.14573111
Yeah.
257
00:14:52,245.14573111 --> 00:14:56,475.14573111
And I think the spin was that they want to appeal to anti-establishment and PR tech voters.
258
00:14:57,255.14573111 --> 00:14:59,625.14573111
He promised to slash red tape and bureaucracy.
259
00:15:00,510.14573111 --> 00:15:11,250.14573111
Get AI and automation in, bring blockchain and FinTech into the mix and really reduce that waste is what he said.
260
00:15:11,820.14573111 --> 00:15:15,930.14573111
What actually happened is he caused absolute carnage and chaos.
261
00:15:16,230.14573111 --> 00:15:18,820.14573111
He really has done more harm than good.
262
00:15:19,540.14573111 --> 00:15:27,880.14573111
He estimated to have saved 175 billion in savings, which is actually hilarious 'cause the New York Times said it's closer to about 8 million.
263
00:15:28,510.14573111 --> 00:15:28,960.14573111
Wow.
264
00:15:29,210.14573111 --> 00:15:39,220.14573111
And I guess that's what happens when you bring in a bunch of uni grads and other underqualified individuals to rip out costs without knowing what you actually know, what you're doing.
265
00:15:40,700.14573111 --> 00:15:51,860.14573111
Doge has been quietly dismantled, and I think people are describing it as mission, somewhat not semi accomplished, but also back on that.
266
00:15:52,595.14573111 --> 00:15:53,795.14573111
In three months.
267
00:15:54,95.14573111 --> 00:15:59,355.14573111
It's not a long time to form a group and then dismantle it.
268
00:15:59,835.14573111 --> 00:16:02,595.14573111
Oh, this whole thing was a bit of a, it's so you are right.
269
00:16:02,595.14573111 --> 00:16:03,255.14573111
It's a stunt.
270
00:16:03,255.14573111 --> 00:16:04,665.14573111
Like it's so strange.
271
00:16:05,115.14573111 --> 00:16:09,195.14573111
The extensive spending and potential to increase the federal deficit by 2.5
272
00:16:09,195.14573111 --> 00:16:09,825.14573111
trillion.
273
00:16:10,155.14573111 --> 00:16:14,505.14573111
Well, he's already made a dint with the 175 billion that saving.
274
00:16:14,505.14573111 --> 00:16:16,575.14573111
So really it's only a 2.3
275
00:16:16,575.14573111 --> 00:16:17,865.14573111
trillion deficit.
276
00:16:18,40.14573111 --> 00:16:18,280.14573111
Exactly.
277
00:16:18,430.14573111 --> 00:16:22,840.14573111
It's basically free, right? It's, that's girl math, Trump math.
278
00:16:22,900.14573111 --> 00:16:23,650.14573111
It's Trump map.
279
00:16:25,210.14573111 --> 00:16:33,100.14573111
On Musk's way out, he got the golden keys to the White House whilst calling Trump's big, beautiful bill.
280
00:16:33,720.14573111 --> 00:16:34,740.14573111
An abomination.
281
00:16:36,715.68102191 --> 00:16:44,245.6810219
Full disclosure, Claire, I'm currently sitting on my mattress under a douna at the Family beach house right now.
282
00:16:44,365.6810219 --> 00:16:45,145.6810219
Chatting with you.
283
00:16:45,265.6810219 --> 00:16:47,275.6810219
And where are you? I'm in my wardrobe.
284
00:16:47,305.6810219 --> 00:16:48,385.6810219
I love this for us.
285
00:16:48,435.6810219 --> 00:16:56,835.6810219
And our listeners are probably wondering why we're doing this, and that's because we actually already recorded this segment a couple of days ago.
286
00:16:56,835.6810219 --> 00:16:59,505.6810219
But so much has happened, hasn't it? I.
287
00:17:00,405.6810219 --> 00:17:05,295.6810219
Not calling ourselves the oracle or anything, but we foreshadowed on Thursday.
288
00:17:05,295.6810219 --> 00:17:13,575.6810219
When we recorded this segment, we talked about what was happening in the disintegration of Elon Musk and Donald Trump's relationship, and we're like, the breakup is imminent.
289
00:17:13,605.6810219 --> 00:17:14,295.6810219
It's coming.
290
00:17:14,725.6810219 --> 00:17:17,635.6810219
Effectively we did that Thursday night.
291
00:17:18,115.6810219 --> 00:17:21,595.6810219
Friday morning we woke up and the boys were fighting.
292
00:17:22,945.6810219 --> 00:17:26,185.6810219
They were and the internet absolutely exploded.
293
00:17:27,115.6810219 --> 00:17:36,355.6810219
Where this all began is Musk Slam Trump's proposed legislation that one big, beautiful bill and called it a disgusting Bowman Nation.
294
00:17:36,895.6810219 --> 00:17:46,285.6810219
And what the bill referred to essentially was major cuts to electric vehicles subsidies and the move would spark an impact that would affect Tesla.
295
00:17:46,315.6810219 --> 00:17:50,575.6810219
So that is obviously what's concerned Elon here.
296
00:17:51,340.6810219 --> 00:17:54,760.6810219
Elon so self interested in his own agenda.
297
00:17:55,270.6810219 --> 00:17:59,230.6810219
He was upset at the impact to the electric vehicle subsidies.
298
00:17:59,800.6810219 --> 00:18:04,510.6810219
He was upset that he was actually getting phased out of the White House.
299
00:18:04,690.6810219 --> 00:18:07,690.6810219
Let's be clear again, Trump does whatever he wants.
300
00:18:07,690.6810219 --> 00:18:10,720.5910219
If Trump wanted Elon Musk to stay, Elon would still be there.
301
00:18:10,894.4685729 --> 00:18:13,219.2300219
But Trump was just like, all right, Elon Time's up.
302
00:18:13,249.2300219 --> 00:18:13,939.2300219
Thank you so much.
303
00:18:13,939.2300219 --> 00:18:15,49.2300219
He's the keys to the White House.
304
00:18:15,319.2300219 --> 00:18:15,979.2300219
Thanks for the T.
305
00:18:15,979.2300219 --> 00:18:16,969.2300219
That's such a good shout.
306
00:18:17,509.2300219 --> 00:18:35,399.2300219
What's essentially happened since then? Friday morning we woke up and I mean it's only Monday now, but Friday was the day that Elon then went to Twitter and dropped a bomb, the really big bomb real Donald Trump is in the Epstein files.
307
00:18:35,819.2300219 --> 00:18:38,549.2300219
This is the real reason they've not been made public.
308
00:18:38,579.2300219 --> 00:18:39,599.2300219
Have a nice day.
309
00:18:39,689.2300219 --> 00:18:42,479.2300219
Dj JTI mean, aggressive.
310
00:18:44,99.2300219 --> 00:18:50,639.2300219
It's some people also knew, like we've seen photos of Jeffrey Epstein and Donald Trump previously, so we knew that they were involved.
311
00:18:50,849.2300219 --> 00:18:55,994.2300219
The extent of that involvement, we're not sure we could probably have a thought on it.
312
00:18:56,549.2300219 --> 00:19:03,389.2300219
The other thing is that Elon Musk was sparring on his own ex social media platform.
313
00:19:03,389.2300219 --> 00:19:04,919.2300219
Donald Trump was on truth social.
314
00:19:06,344.2300219 --> 00:19:10,214.2300219
Donald Trump was saying, yes, Elon Musk, you've been a disappointment.
315
00:19:10,844.2300219 --> 00:19:14,114.2300219
You're behaving badly going Grace and Elon.
316
00:19:14,204.2300219 --> 00:19:15,164.2300219
I'm not doing that.
317
00:19:16,484.2300219 --> 00:19:20,294.2300219
What we understand is that Elon Musk wants to talk to Trump.
318
00:19:20,294.2300219 --> 00:19:21,464.2300219
He wants to have a conversation.
319
00:19:22,4.2300219 --> 00:19:25,604.2300219
The White House wants Trump to have a conversation with Elon Musk and calm him down.
320
00:19:25,934.2300219 --> 00:19:28,244.2300219
Donald Trump does not wanna talk to Elon Musk.
321
00:19:28,294.2300219 --> 00:19:39,634.2300219
Yeah, and what I understand as well is Tesla and Elon Musk, they are perceived as one thing really.
322
00:19:39,634.2300219 --> 00:19:40,474.2300219
So this is.
323
00:19:40,864.2300219 --> 00:19:45,664.2300219
Just looking at it from a business perspective on what's happened in the last couple of days, it's pretty insane.
324
00:19:46,84.2300219 --> 00:19:55,204.2300219
Tesla's stocks have dropped significantly, dropping more than 14%, which equates to what, $150 billion market value loss.
325
00:19:55,924.2300219 --> 00:20:00,694.2300219
This is significant because Tesla doesn't really advertise.
326
00:20:00,694.2300219 --> 00:20:08,134.2300219
It really does rely on Musk's personal brand here, so I would think that from his perspective.
327
00:20:09,4.2300219 --> 00:20:16,174.2300219
At the point where you want Trump to talk to you and start smoothing things out because everything is just so volatile right now.
328
00:20:16,804.2300219 --> 00:20:17,374.2300219
Exactly.
329
00:20:17,374.2300219 --> 00:20:31,854.2300219
And we previously have spoken about Elon Musk but Tesla effectively is valued on its current revenues and its profitability for what it sells today, but it's also what it could achieve in the future.
330
00:20:32,394.2300219 --> 00:20:34,434.2300219
So that's its potential contracts.
331
00:20:34,484.2300219 --> 00:20:51,214.2300219
We gave the example that there's a vision that one day Tesla would own all the bus contracts for many states in America, and that evaluation is cooked into the share price With what's occurring, Musk is effectively killing the dreams for those contracts.
332
00:20:51,264.2300219 --> 00:20:53,994.2300219
If you are being Missy, you are causing drama.
333
00:20:54,24.2300219 --> 00:20:56,244.2300219
You're committing crimes, which he potentially could be doing.
334
00:20:56,244.2300219 --> 00:21:01,824.2300219
He could be leaking government information, he could be making threats, he could be deported.
335
00:21:01,914.2300219 --> 00:21:06,594.2300219
There are people that have called for his immigration status to be reviewed.
336
00:21:07,254.2300219 --> 00:21:14,724.2300219
Suddenly those future opportunities don't seem so great anymore, and that impacts the share price on that.
337
00:21:14,724.2300219 --> 00:21:18,624.2300219
Actually, this whole calling him an illegal alien.
338
00:21:19,224.2300219 --> 00:21:26,574.2300219
Yes, he was born in South Africa, but he did move to Canada in 1989 and then to US, and he went to college at Penn.
339
00:21:26,814.2300219 --> 00:21:29,904.2300219
He's actually been a US citizen since 2002.
340
00:21:29,934.2300219 --> 00:21:30,744.2300219
He's a citizen.
341
00:21:30,834.2300219 --> 00:21:35,214.2300219
Trump also was calling for the ability to deport JU citizens.
342
00:21:35,394.2300219 --> 00:21:37,464.2300219
So if that's the case, ah, they go.
343
00:21:37,824.2300219 --> 00:21:38,154.2300219
Yeah.
344
00:21:38,454.2300219 --> 00:21:45,894.2300219
And Trump also likes to do whatever he wants to do, there's every opportunity that they might pursue something like this.
345
00:21:46,164.2300219 --> 00:21:57,174.2300219
I don't think it'll get to that I think that Elon Musk will be eventually put back in his box, but this is a man who can't deal with rejection.
346
00:21:57,174.2300219 --> 00:21:59,964.2300219
He thought he was gonna get to be Trump's right hand man.
347
00:21:59,964.2300219 --> 00:22:05,664.2300219
For years, he effectively paid for his position in the tune of three to $400 million he spent in the electoral campaign.
348
00:22:06,174.2300219 --> 00:22:08,814.2300219
He's now dealing with the consequences of his own actions.
349
00:22:09,144.2300219 --> 00:22:09,774.2300219
He knew like.
350
00:22:10,149.2300219 --> 00:22:15,579.2300219
How did he not know this was gonna be the end result? Trump cues in, spits out everyone that he comes into contact with.
351
00:22:16,929.2300219 --> 00:22:18,519.2300219
Maybe he thought he was different.
352
00:22:18,609.2300219 --> 00:22:21,969.2300219
It's honestly such a sour breakup.
353
00:22:21,969.2300219 --> 00:22:24,519.2300219
It's almost reminds me of those relationships.
354
00:22:24,519.2300219 --> 00:22:26,109.2300219
You go, oh, they would never do that.
355
00:22:26,109.2300219 --> 00:22:27,819.2300219
Even if we broke up, they would never do that.
356
00:22:27,819.2300219 --> 00:22:32,109.2300219
And then when you break up, each party really does show their true colors.
357
00:22:32,529.2300219 --> 00:22:37,89.2300219
One thing I wanted to touch on as well is this whole black eye rumor and speculation.
358
00:22:37,809.2300219 --> 00:22:43,929.2300219
He said it was Elon had a black eye when he rock up at a recent White House Tech round table.
359
00:22:44,379.2300219 --> 00:22:47,979.2300219
At the time, he said it was because he was play fighting with his son.
360
00:22:48,9.2300219 --> 00:22:53,49.2300219
I'm gonna give a go at saying the name, I think the kid's name is Ex Asha 12.
361
00:22:53,649.2300219 --> 00:22:54,849.2300219
I think I'm saying that right.
362
00:22:55,509.2300219 --> 00:23:06,789.2300219
And but now the rumors of that, perhaps it was a physical altercation with one of the senior cabinet members, a bit of a fist fight happening in the White House that Elon Musk rammed.
363
00:23:07,419.2300219 --> 00:23:12,189.2300219
Besson's rib cage of like a rugby player and then fell and besson punched him in the face.
364
00:23:12,759.2300219 --> 00:23:19,749.2300219
Can you just imagine the awkwardness of Elon Musk trying to like spear tackle someone that is just, you've already seen him dance.
365
00:23:19,749.2300219 --> 00:23:24,669.2300219
You can only imagine how clunky and awkward he would've been so awkward and I don't know.
366
00:23:24,669.2300219 --> 00:23:29,889.2300219
I can imagine him calling out some kind of like karate voodoo thing as well.
367
00:23:29,889.2300219 --> 00:23:30,909.2300219
Just cringe.
368
00:23:31,419.2300219 --> 00:23:34,959.2300219
And also he was offered makeup.
369
00:23:35,679.2300219 --> 00:23:38,529.2300219
To cover up the black eye and he insisted on having it out.
370
00:23:38,529.2300219 --> 00:23:39,999.2300219
'cause I think he wanted to prove a point.
371
00:23:41,379.2300219 --> 00:23:42,789.2300219
Oh, that's so interesting.
372
00:23:43,479.2300219 --> 00:24:02,859.2300219
And what's this as well, he's teased a couple of times, but now with this fallout, do you think he's gonna pursue this idea of a another party, the America Party as an alternative to the Republicans or the Democrats? It's definitely something that's been spoken about.
373
00:24:02,919.2300219 --> 00:24:12,429.2300219
I don't know where it would go because it would need to be a centrist party and Elon Musk has pissed off the Democrats, which are the left-leaning, and he is also upset.
374
00:24:12,429.2300219 --> 00:24:17,109.2300219
A lot of the conservatives, the right-leaning, so I don't know how he's gonna find middle ground.
375
00:24:17,139.2300219 --> 00:24:22,599.2300219
But the US system isn't set up for more than two parties because it's a winner.
376
00:24:22,599.2300219 --> 00:24:23,49.2300219
Takes all.
377
00:24:23,979.2300219 --> 00:24:24,549.2300219
Approach.
378
00:24:24,699.2300219 --> 00:24:31,479.2300219
So unless Elon Musk had the majority, it's never really gonna get the legs it's looking to achieve.
379
00:24:31,509.2300219 --> 00:24:33,609.2300219
It's just gonna further dilute the vote.
380
00:24:33,939.2300219 --> 00:24:42,249.2300219
Might be good for the Democrats, but it really depends on where they're able to build momentum because it would cost a lot of money.
381
00:24:42,249.2300219 --> 00:24:52,119.2300219
And I think it also take a lot of time, like it's when people say comments like in Australia, oh we could have a Greens Prime Minister potentially with the way that we're swinging.
382
00:24:52,884.2300219 --> 00:24:59,514.2300219
That is a very long way off because of the way that our centrist politics and our preferential voting system is set up.
383
00:24:59,514.2300219 --> 00:25:00,984.2300219
It just takes a long time.
384
00:25:01,284.2300219 --> 00:25:03,354.2300219
Like I don't know if we'll see that in our generation.
385
00:25:03,864.2300219 --> 00:25:04,824.2300219
It's really hard to say.
386
00:25:05,994.2300219 --> 00:25:12,194.2300219
It is really hard to say, but then I think about when Trump first decided that he'd go into the running and people are, yeah.
387
00:25:12,194.2300219 --> 00:25:15,734.2300219
As if that's never gonna happen and look what he's achieved.
388
00:25:16,34.2300219 --> 00:25:21,224.2300219
I think particularly with this as well, there's that extra element of the US Constitution where.
389
00:25:21,719.2300219 --> 00:25:25,769.2300219
Because he wasn't born in the US I don't think he can actually be a president.
390
00:25:25,919.2300219 --> 00:25:30,149.2300219
He can form a party, but he wouldn't be able to be that ultimate leader.
391
00:25:30,869.2300219 --> 00:25:48,509.2300219
But think, I think he's also doing the third party approach because he's tried to get back in with the Democrats and they weren't having, they're just like, no, not interested you, but, 'cause Elon Musk used to be a democratic donor and he was heavily involved in supporting the Democratic Party, and it was only in the year before.
392
00:25:49,64.2300219 --> 00:25:53,114.2300219
The previous US election that he switched to supporting Donald Trump.
393
00:25:53,714.2300219 --> 00:25:55,664.2300219
So they're not keen for him to come back.
394
00:25:55,664.2300219 --> 00:25:56,534.2300219
So he's got nothing left.
395
00:25:56,559.2300219 --> 00:26:00,189.2300219
The MAGA and the Republicans don't really want him.
396
00:26:00,489.2300219 --> 00:26:03,309.2300219
He's got nowhere to be if he wants to be involved in politics.
397
00:26:05,179.2300219 --> 00:26:05,419.2300219
Now.
398
00:26:05,479.2300219 --> 00:26:08,269.2300219
We spoke about this initially when we recorded this, but.
399
00:26:08,584.2300219 --> 00:26:11,794.2300219
He's having a little bit of a brand identity crisis now.
400
00:26:11,844.2300219 --> 00:26:12,504.2300219
Exactly.
401
00:26:12,624.2300219 --> 00:26:17,454.2300219
Also, he relies very heavily on the government contracts he has with his space endeavors.
402
00:26:17,694.2300219 --> 00:26:22,974.2300219
So if they were to get pulled and Tesla's also not doing well.
403
00:26:23,754.2300219 --> 00:26:26,364.2300219
A few weeks ago we spoke about a margin call, which is where.
404
00:26:26,754.2300219 --> 00:26:44,64.2300219
Effectively all the debt that's funded by investment banks and other equity houses, they get a bit concerned with the rating of the asset, so they make the holder of the asset, so that would be Elon Musk stump up cash to reduce the risk that they have on those loads.
405
00:26:44,64.2300219 --> 00:26:45,84.2300219
And it's called a margin call.
406
00:26:45,724.2300219 --> 00:26:49,474.2300219
If things keep going sour and potentially government contracts get ended.
407
00:26:49,879.2300219 --> 00:26:58,99.2300219
There's a risk that Elon Musk will become up for a margin call, and he's not a very liquid person, so being not liquid means that he would be in a lot of strife.
408
00:26:58,99.2300219 --> 00:27:15,169.2300219
So I actually do believe there's a reality where if Elon Musk doesn't settle down, he'll keep defunding the value of Tesla, and he may actually have to sell his ownership or relinquish his leadership position in an efforts to retain some of his value.
409
00:27:17,599.2300219 --> 00:27:19,249.2300219
His value's already slipping.
410
00:27:19,349.2300219 --> 00:27:24,419.2300219
I think something needs to happen pretty quickly to turn this thing around.
411
00:27:24,479.2300219 --> 00:27:29,819.2300219
Or do we think that people are just gonna forget about this in a couple of days? It's gonna, everything will stabilize.
412
00:27:30,629.2300219 --> 00:27:34,619.2300219
I think there's still a few threats and dramas to occur, but we'll just keep an eye on it.
413
00:27:34,619.2300219 --> 00:27:35,729.2300219
I guess that's all we can do.
414
00:27:37,124.2300219 --> 00:27:44,144.2300219
And underneath all these headlines is basically this stark reminder, really, that business leaders start to play with politics.
415
00:27:44,144.2300219 --> 00:27:48,199.2300219
It can get explosive, and that's what we've seen these last few days, a hundred percent.
416
00:27:50,752.1363171 --> 00:27:52,852.1363171
I'm very excited about this one, Claire.
417
00:27:52,912.1363171 --> 00:28:00,232.1363171
Yeah, tell me, and that's we, that we finally have an update on Blake Lively and the Justin Baldoni case this week.
418
00:28:00,322.1363171 --> 00:28:01,702.1363171
Really? We do.
419
00:28:01,762.1363171 --> 00:28:04,372.1363171
So there've been some key things this week.
420
00:28:04,422.1363171 --> 00:28:13,932.1363171
The biggest one has been that Blake Lively has dropped two emotional distress claims that she had raised against Justin Baldoni in their ongoing legal battle.
421
00:28:13,962.1363171 --> 00:28:18,222.1363171
The court case is set for March next year, so it's still a long while away.
422
00:28:18,222.1363171 --> 00:28:18,462.1363171
And.
423
00:28:18,772.1363171 --> 00:28:37,252.1363171
It certainly is still openness, still claims against him, but she's dropped those two this week, and the reason for that is that his team requested medical records from her because part of this and what she has accused him of is.
424
00:28:37,532.1363171 --> 00:28:42,662.1363171
That he's caused her such emotional distress that they, his team believed that they should be.
425
00:28:42,662.1363171 --> 00:28:50,972.1363171
If that's the case, then there should be records within her therapy sessions that she spoke about this at the time, and so we're left here going.
426
00:28:51,32.1363171 --> 00:28:51,752.1363171
Interesting.
427
00:28:51,782.1363171 --> 00:28:59,642.1363171
Why would you refuse if you are quite confident about your case? Yes.
428
00:28:59,762.1363171 --> 00:29:03,962.1363171
So she's done this in a matter of retaining privacy, but.
429
00:29:04,727.1363171 --> 00:29:10,877.1363171
Is she entitled to that given what she's trying to pursue against Justin Baldoni? Yeah, exactly.
430
00:29:10,877.1363171 --> 00:29:16,897.1363171
She this case is so public it is affecting both of their reputations and it already has so much.
431
00:29:17,437.1363171 --> 00:29:19,417.1363171
I just think we're past that point now.
432
00:29:19,417.1363171 --> 00:29:25,687.1363171
They have disclosed so much text messages, intimate conversations and footage and everything.
433
00:29:25,687.1363171 --> 00:29:28,57.1363171
So it's a very strange to me.
434
00:29:28,287.1363171 --> 00:29:32,67.1363171
Justin Baldoni definitely prior to Christmas, was running this in the.
435
00:29:32,422.1363171 --> 00:29:33,652.1363171
Court of public opinion.
436
00:29:33,982.1363171 --> 00:29:36,977.1363171
He was just putting it all out there that he came in to fight.
437
00:29:38,397.1363171 --> 00:29:41,637.1363171
I think it really started to shift the narrative against Blake Lively.
438
00:29:41,637.1363171 --> 00:29:47,177.1363171
And then he just kept on launching grenades, when they shared the text messages and she referred to Taylor Swift as a dragon.
439
00:29:47,477.1363171 --> 00:29:49,937.1363171
Oh, remember that? I think I suppressed that.
440
00:29:49,937.1363171 --> 00:29:50,837.1363171
That was so gross.
441
00:29:51,47.1363171 --> 00:29:53,627.1363171
And Blake Lively and Taylor Swift have no longer friends.
442
00:29:53,717.1363171 --> 00:29:58,457.1363171
I was actually gonna ask, because what happened? Have they been seen together since? No.
443
00:29:58,847.1363171 --> 00:30:02,567.1363171
Really? I think Taylor Swift really distanced herself from Blake Lively.
444
00:30:02,897.1363171 --> 00:30:04,187.1363171
And then the second thing is.
445
00:30:04,832.1363171 --> 00:30:09,722.1363171
Taylor Swift would've never allowed her song to be used in the movie if she knew what was happening was occurring.
446
00:30:10,332.1363171 --> 00:30:17,292.1363171
If she knew that Dustin Baldoni was doing what he was doing, would she have allowed the, yeah, no, it does not make sense at all.
447
00:30:17,292.1363171 --> 00:30:18,942.1363171
She, she doesn't, she's a clever woman.
448
00:30:18,972.1363171 --> 00:30:25,242.1363171
She would not have done that, which is, I think also bolsters a lot of the directive towards Justin Baldoni.
449
00:30:25,472.1363171 --> 00:30:32,462.1363171
You did say that Blake Lively's reason for not providing the records is from this perspective of, I wanna keep my privacy.
450
00:30:33,542.1363171 --> 00:30:39,607.1363171
The question now is that gonna reframe our thoughts around Justin Bald? I actually think where we are at the moment, it won't.
451
00:30:39,607.1363171 --> 00:30:44,407.1363171
I think it, honestly, we're at this point where it just doesn't look really good on her right now.
452
00:30:44,497.1363171 --> 00:30:45,997.1363171
It doesn't, it's been very messy.
453
00:30:45,997.1363171 --> 00:31:04,657.1363171
I think definitely Justin Baldoni giving the amount of information in the volume he did and just made it publicly available, it helped them to control the narrative and it really, I would say it's benefited him in overall, regardless of what happened.
454
00:31:04,707.1363171 --> 00:31:06,237.1363171
There's true two sides to every story.
455
00:31:06,237.1363171 --> 00:31:07,557.1363171
It sits somewhere in the middle.
456
00:31:07,767.1363171 --> 00:31:10,437.1363171
He's really won back the narrative and he's maintained it.
457
00:31:10,767.1363171 --> 00:31:21,537.1363171
And I don't know if this is strategic little dropping of information or not, but for Blake Lively I would definitely say she's probably feeling quite lonely, I would say so as well.
458
00:31:21,637.1363171 --> 00:31:30,487.1363171
The court case or the trial is set for the 9th of March next year, so it is far from over, but we will be keeping a close eye on it and seeing how it unfolds.
459
00:31:30,697.1363171 --> 00:31:34,867.1363171
I do wanna know if we'll get it ends with us Justin B's version.
460
00:31:34,872.1363171 --> 00:31:35,112.1363171
I want it.
461
00:31:35,527.1363171 --> 00:31:36,8.1363171
I need it.
462
00:31:36,552.1363171 --> 00:31:40,57.1363171
I've been waiting for, it scored high, it's scored higher, it's scored really well.
463
00:31:40,357.1363171 --> 00:31:41,677.1363171
And what, since the case.
464
00:31:42,57.1363171 --> 00:31:42,567.1363171
Wait, hang on.
465
00:31:42,627.1363171 --> 00:31:43,767.1363171
What people have seen it.
466
00:31:43,827.1363171 --> 00:31:52,317.1363171
So prior to the movie being released, they did customer testing with Blake Lively's version with the Taylor Swift song and Justin B's version.
467
00:31:52,467.1363171 --> 00:31:52,887.1363171
Interesting.
468
00:31:52,887.1363171 --> 00:31:57,237.1363171
And his version tested far better, but her version had the Taylor Swift song.
469
00:31:57,767.1363171 --> 00:32:04,727.1363171
With the pressure that she was putting on Sony, Sony went with her version, so Justin B's version hit the cladding room floor.
470
00:32:04,727.1363171 --> 00:32:05,747.1363171
We never got to see it.
471
00:32:06,137.1363171 --> 00:32:07,187.1363171
They need to release it.
472
00:32:07,187.1363171 --> 00:32:09,827.1363171
They totally can take advantage of the situation here.
473
00:32:09,977.1363171 --> 00:32:10,997.1363171
Oh my god, this director's cut.
474
00:32:10,997.1363171 --> 00:32:11,867.1363171
It would be so good.
475
00:32:12,107.1363171 --> 00:32:13,517.1363171
The second thing though is.
476
00:32:13,877.1363171 --> 00:32:21,222.1363171
It would cover the amount of quirks in the movie where there's just like coffee cups that weren't there before and they just disappear and then they, oh, we all understand it.
477
00:32:21,377.1363171 --> 00:32:21,947.1363171
Oh my God.
478
00:32:21,947.1363171 --> 00:32:24,197.1363171
And the fishnets under the pajamas.
479
00:32:24,197.1363171 --> 00:32:25,427.1363171
That makes no sense.
480
00:32:25,787.1363171 --> 00:32:31,187.1363171
No woman would ever go to bed and put a pair of pajama pants over her fishnets.
481
00:32:31,187.1363171 --> 00:32:33,257.1363171
No, I've stand by thinking about that.
482
00:32:33,257.1363171 --> 00:32:35,207.1363171
That is like nails sound a blackboard.
483
00:32:35,207.1363171 --> 00:32:37,517.1363171
You know what I so uncomfortable like does not make sense.
484
00:32:37,517.1363171 --> 00:32:38,387.1363171
The static.
485
00:32:38,687.1363171 --> 00:32:40,7.1363171
I just, nah, nah.
486
00:32:40,97.1363171 --> 00:32:40,667.1363171
Not for me.
487
00:32:40,757.1363171 --> 00:32:40,997.1363171
Nah.
488
00:32:42,693.8029838 --> 00:32:54,243.8029838
Not moving far away from Blake Lively, but what's happened is Taylor Swift essentially broke the music industry and rebuilt it in her image and she's won the day.
489
00:32:54,663.8029838 --> 00:32:58,323.8029838
I don't know what the TE fan, what are we called or what are the Taylor Swifties, sorry.
490
00:32:58,533.8029838 --> 00:33:00,603.8029838
I wouldn't traditionally say that I'm a swifty.
491
00:33:00,603.8029838 --> 00:33:05,133.8029838
I'm not an anti swifty, but I had, this is something I have seen in my algorithm this week.
492
00:33:05,748.8029838 --> 00:33:06,828.8029838
What happened is.
493
00:33:08,73.8029838 --> 00:33:16,83.8029838
Taylor Swift lost control of her own music, rerecorded, most of it, made it more profitable, and now she owns the originals again.
494
00:33:16,293.8029838 --> 00:33:22,173.8029838
So breaking down what happened at 15, Taylor Swift signed to big machine records.
495
00:33:22,383.8029838 --> 00:33:28,953.8029838
Like many young artists, she didn't own her own master recordings, and that was her first self-titled debut album.
496
00:33:29,328.8029838 --> 00:33:31,428.8029838
Fast forward to 2019 big machine.
497
00:33:31,428.8029838 --> 00:33:36,258.8029838
And with it, her entire early catalog is sold to Scooter Braun for throwing 30 million.
498
00:33:36,678.8029838 --> 00:33:42,388.8029838
Scooter Braun has had a number of court cases, particularly with a dispute he had with Kesha.
499
00:33:43,78.8029838 --> 00:33:44,489.8029838
Ah, it's him, the same guy.
500
00:33:44,494.8029838 --> 00:33:44,673.8029838
It's him.
501
00:33:44,673.8029838 --> 00:33:44,794.8029838
Same guy.
502
00:33:44,794.8029838 --> 00:33:44,795.8029838
Yep.
503
00:33:46,108.8029838 --> 00:33:52,378.8029838
And Taylor said that she found out with the rest of us that her catalog had been sold and she accused Braun of being a bully.
504
00:33:52,408.8029838 --> 00:33:54,958.8029838
And she vowed to regain control.
505
00:33:55,708.8029838 --> 00:34:02,8.8029838
And I think the absolute point that Scooter Braun would never have estimated Taylor Swift to do.
506
00:34:03,268.8029838 --> 00:34:04,978.8029838
She rerecorded everything.
507
00:34:05,503.8029838 --> 00:34:07,823.8029838
She found the loophole, she found the legal loophole.
508
00:34:08,498.8029838 --> 00:34:09,248.8029838
She went rogue.
509
00:34:09,278.8029838 --> 00:34:13,328.8029838
She announced that she'll rerecord all six of her early AL albums and she meant it.
510
00:34:13,658.8029838 --> 00:34:16,418.8029838
Fearless Taylor's version dropped in 2021.
511
00:34:16,478.8029838 --> 00:34:17,768.8029838
Red Taylor's version.
512
00:34:18,593.8029838 --> 00:34:19,253.8029838
Speak now.
513
00:34:19,253.8029838 --> 00:34:23,218.8029838
1989 each broke the charts.
514
00:34:23,578.8029838 --> 00:34:30,238.8029838
And I gotta say it was really exciting when they were released 'cause you'd listen to it and they were different 'cause she's a different person and she's grown.
515
00:34:30,238.8029838 --> 00:34:31,978.8029838
Some extra songs dropped as well.
516
00:34:31,978.8029838 --> 00:34:36,688.8029838
And the fans, the swifties got completely behind her.
517
00:34:37,248.8029838 --> 00:34:39,348.8029838
IHeartRadio ditched the original versions.
518
00:34:39,778.8029838 --> 00:34:43,18.8029838
I, for one, would exclusively prioritize.
519
00:34:43,468.8029838 --> 00:34:59,208.8029838
Taylor's version where I could, of course we didn't have it for reputation but we had it for the others, and it was the ultimate vote with your wallet moment because Scooter Braun would never have expected his versions of the songs to reduce in value the way they did.
520
00:34:59,688.8029838 --> 00:35:04,668.8029838
And then for Taylor Swift to have gained the amount of popularity, I think it actually improved her to be honest.
521
00:35:04,728.8029838 --> 00:35:04,968.8029838
And.
522
00:35:05,493.8029838 --> 00:35:15,633.8029838
I think it shows the power of loyalty, like her following, it is a conscious decision to go in there and choose her recordings versus the old ones.
523
00:35:15,663.8029838 --> 00:35:18,558.8029838
It's completely irrational and they termed it Omics.
524
00:35:18,563.8029838 --> 00:35:18,753.8029838
Omics.
525
00:35:19,23.8029838 --> 00:35:22,893.8029838
I know, because it doesn't make sense when you think about.
526
00:35:23,213.8029838 --> 00:35:29,213.8029838
Economic models, but effectively her fan base was so loyal, they boycotted the originals.
527
00:35:29,843.8029838 --> 00:35:34,73.8029838
No other artist could have achieved what Taylor Swift did and had the benefit of what she did.
528
00:35:34,493.8029838 --> 00:35:39,718.8029838
So when she actually was able to purchase back the catalog from Scooter Bra which she did last week.
529
00:35:40,408.8029838 --> 00:35:42,148.8029838
It would've been a couple of hundred million.
530
00:35:42,538.8029838 --> 00:35:43,198.8029838
Oh, that's a lot.
531
00:35:43,408.8029838 --> 00:35:45,388.8029838
That's less than what he bought it for.
532
00:35:45,388.8029838 --> 00:35:45,688.8029838
No.
533
00:35:45,748.8029838 --> 00:35:46,318.8029838
Yes.
534
00:35:46,348.8029838 --> 00:35:46,888.8029838
I don't know.
535
00:35:46,888.8029838 --> 00:35:53,788.8029838
Like it's undisclosed, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's not much more than what he paid for because he realized he had a diminishing asset.
536
00:35:53,788.8029838 --> 00:35:53,848.8029838
I.
537
00:35:54,958.8029838 --> 00:36:05,608.8029838
She's a genius, but I would say the door that she opened has been closed because now the industry, they prevent this from happening in the recording artists.
538
00:36:05,658.8029838 --> 00:36:15,108.8029838
Taylor Swift found that loophole, but there are strict rerecording clauses in contracts and many of them block rerecording for 10, 30 years, sometimes forever.
539
00:36:15,923.8029838 --> 00:36:21,563.8029838
Taylor Swift took a huge risk in doing this but I think it has paid off for her, it's her content.
540
00:36:21,563.8029838 --> 00:36:22,433.8029838
It's her creativity.
541
00:36:22,463.8029838 --> 00:36:29,383.8029838
What are you saying the risk is of her rerecording or from her buying When she said she would rerecord, she wouldn't have known how it would've played out.
542
00:36:29,383.8029838 --> 00:36:32,113.8029838
She wouldn't have known how successful or unsuccessful it would've been.
543
00:36:32,113.8029838 --> 00:36:34,693.8029838
And fortunately for her, it has played off for her.
544
00:36:35,203.8029838 --> 00:36:35,383.8029838
Yeah.
545
00:36:35,383.8029838 --> 00:36:41,553.8029838
And I think in the end, from what we can see, it was really important for her to take back her own power, and she certainly has.
546
00:36:41,553.8029838 --> 00:36:41,943.8029838
Mm-hmm.
547
00:36:42,721.9111153 --> 00:36:45,31.9111153
A quick legal note before we dive in.
548
00:36:45,241.9111153 --> 00:36:47,941.9111153
Erin Patterson's trial is still underway in Victoria.
549
00:36:48,91.9111153 --> 00:36:51,631.9111153
She has pleaded not guilty and remains presumed innocent.
550
00:36:51,841.9111153 --> 00:36:55,291.9111153
We're only summarizing evidence heard in open court and reputable news.
551
00:36:55,471.9111153 --> 00:37:01,261.9111153
This is commentary, not news, facts or verdict, calling if you're a juror, witness or otherwise involved in the case.
552
00:37:01,321.9111153 --> 00:37:04,261.9111153
Please stop listening now and return after the trial ends.
553
00:37:06,15.902045 --> 00:37:13,935.902045
After the last sip of coffee on a Saturday afternoon, three people dead.
554
00:37:14,535.902045 --> 00:37:18,765.902045
One more clinging to life from the fatal mushrooms.
555
00:37:19,245.902045 --> 00:37:26,800.902045
At the beef Wellington Mu, we bring you the death diaries.
556
00:37:30,259.2353783 --> 00:37:30,379.2353783
Hmm.
557
00:37:31,79.2353783 --> 00:37:32,4.2353783
It never gets old.
558
00:37:32,274.2353783 --> 00:37:32,814.2353783
I know.
559
00:37:32,814.2353783 --> 00:37:34,884.2353783
It's our favorite part of the episode.
560
00:37:34,944.2353783 --> 00:37:35,154.2353783
I know.
561
00:37:35,154.2353783 --> 00:37:36,144.2353783
I love playing this one.
562
00:37:36,174.2353783 --> 00:37:38,724.2353783
And something huge has happened this week, Claire.
563
00:37:38,814.2353783 --> 00:37:39,744.2353783
We were, we were wrong.
564
00:37:39,744.2353783 --> 00:37:40,494.2353783
Well, let say we were.
565
00:37:40,879.2353783 --> 00:37:41,220.2353783
We were so wrong.
566
00:37:41,334.2353783 --> 00:37:46,644.2353783
I was very wrong 'cause I was just like, this thing's done and dusted we're into final arguments.
567
00:37:46,644.2353783 --> 00:37:47,994.2353783
The defense is not bringing extra.
568
00:37:48,114.2353783 --> 00:37:52,44.2353783
This is, you know, why would they bother? I was at work and I remember opening up the age.
569
00:37:52,719.2353783 --> 00:37:55,289.2353783
And seeing Erin is entering Yes.
570
00:37:55,289.2353783 --> 00:37:56,339.2353783
I, I, me text you like, oh my God, you texted me.
571
00:37:56,339.2353783 --> 00:37:57,434.2353783
Immediately I saw it.
572
00:37:57,509.2353783 --> 00:37:59,909.2353783
I was like, oh my God, I can't believe it.
573
00:37:59,999.2353783 --> 00:38:06,89.2353783
Listened to a number of podcasts and also news reporters that were there and they said when they announced it, everyone was collective.
574
00:38:06,89.2353783 --> 00:38:06,149.2353783
Ha.
575
00:38:06,329.2353783 --> 00:38:08,159.2353783
'cause they could not believe it.
576
00:38:08,234.2353783 --> 00:38:15,89.2353783
So is she diluted or is this desperation? I have no idea.
577
00:38:15,89.2353783 --> 00:38:16,469.2353783
It is unprecedented.
578
00:38:16,469.2353783 --> 00:38:17,934.2353783
I think we can definitely say, mm-hmm.
579
00:38:19,304.2353783 --> 00:38:30,974.2353783
One thing we do know with our court system is that if Aaron's barrister knew that Aaron was guilty, if Aaron had confessed, he cannot put her on the stand, he would be risking his legal license.
580
00:38:31,184.2353783 --> 00:38:32,504.2353783
Really? And he certainly wouldn't be doing that.
581
00:38:32,834.2353783 --> 00:38:38,654.2353783
So he, do you know much about him? He is a very well established criminal barrister.
582
00:38:38,654.2353783 --> 00:38:39,584.2353783
He's excellent.
583
00:38:39,584.2353783 --> 00:38:40,664.2353783
He's very well regarded.
584
00:38:40,669.2353783 --> 00:38:40,819.2353783
Mm.
585
00:38:41,174.2353783 --> 00:38:47,544.2353783
One thing I didn't realize with Barristers is they interchange between prosecuting and defending.
586
00:38:48,39.2353783 --> 00:38:49,149.2353783
Oh, they just get hired.
587
00:38:49,149.2353783 --> 00:38:51,999.2353783
They're in like a So freelance.
588
00:38:52,89.2353783 --> 00:38:59,609.2353783
Yeah, they, they effectively are their own independent contractor and they get hired by lawyers and it could be the prosecution, it could be for the defense.
589
00:39:00,49.2353783 --> 00:39:02,374.2353783
So they interchange, which I thought was fascinating.
590
00:39:02,374.2353783 --> 00:39:02,809.2353783
That is fascinating.
591
00:39:02,839.2353783 --> 00:39:07,994.2353783
I had no, until someone explained this to me, Erin started her deliberation.
592
00:39:08,174.2353783 --> 00:39:09,299.2353783
She is still on.
593
00:39:09,299.2353783 --> 00:39:11,609.2353783
So it's Thursday afternoon when we're recording this.
594
00:39:11,609.2353783 --> 00:39:13,979.2353783
'cause Miss Gab is going away for the long weekend.
595
00:39:14,9.2353783 --> 00:39:14,579.2353783
I certainly am.
596
00:39:15,734.2353783 --> 00:39:22,34.2353783
And Erin concluded her fourth day, and in the fourth day she was cross-examined by the defense.
597
00:39:22,34.2353783 --> 00:39:29,64.2353783
So she had roughly three days or two and a half days of her defense barrister questioning, and he was preempting the discussion.
598
00:39:29,424.2353783 --> 00:39:33,354.2353783
And then today we had the cross-examination from the prosecutor and.
599
00:39:34,944.2353783 --> 00:39:36,984.2353783
That would be one of the hardest things you're ever gonna do.
600
00:39:37,14.2353783 --> 00:39:42,474.2353783
'cause you've got someone who's literally unpacking everything you said, how you said it, what you meant.
601
00:39:42,504.2353783 --> 00:39:43,854.2353783
And you have to be on your game.
602
00:39:43,854.2353783 --> 00:39:48,24.2353783
And I think, and if you haven't told the truth, this is where you're gonna get unpicked because.
603
00:39:48,654.2353783 --> 00:39:50,94.2353783
This person knows what you said.
604
00:39:50,94.2353783 --> 00:39:52,434.2353783
And they go, but didn't you tell me this? Oh, exactly.
605
00:39:52,434.2353783 --> 00:39:55,74.2353783
They've got the cheat, they've got the cheat sheet of what they said.
606
00:39:55,74.2353783 --> 00:39:56,604.2353783
It's like a test, honestly.
607
00:39:56,724.2353783 --> 00:39:56,814.2353783
Mm-hmm.
608
00:39:57,184.2353783 --> 00:39:58,294.2353783
So take me through it.
609
00:39:58,374.2353783 --> 00:40:02,334.2353783
Let's go through, let's take the listeners through what's actually happened day by day this week.
610
00:40:03,249.2353783 --> 00:40:05,679.2353783
Monday we had Erin enter the jury box.
611
00:40:05,739.2353783 --> 00:40:11,939.2353783
At the conclusion, at the start of Monday, we had the police investigator who was conducting the search on her house.
612
00:40:11,939.2353783 --> 00:40:16,829.2353783
He concluded his evidence and then we had Erin enter the box again.
613
00:40:16,829.2353783 --> 00:40:18,89.2353783
We didn't think this was gonna happen.
614
00:40:18,269.2353783 --> 00:40:26,879.2353783
And Erin entered, she shared her background, her how she met her partner, Simon.
615
00:40:27,299.2353783 --> 00:40:28,379.2353783
Their relationship.
616
00:40:28,619.2353783 --> 00:40:39,59.2353783
She shared a lot of sort of personal information herself about having low self-esteem, disordered eating, and a difficult relationship with her appearance, particularly after she had children.
617
00:40:39,479.2353783 --> 00:40:39,959.2353783
How she.
618
00:40:40,739.2353783 --> 00:40:43,579.2353783
S met her Christian faith and engaged in Christmas faith.
619
00:40:43,579.2353783 --> 00:40:45,229.2353783
And one thing I thought was super interesting mm-hmm.
620
00:40:45,499.2353783 --> 00:40:48,349.2353783
Is when you enter the jury box, you have to swear an oath.
621
00:40:48,649.2353783 --> 00:40:52,369.2353783
You can swear an affirmation or you can swear on the Bible.
622
00:40:52,369.2353783 --> 00:40:52,429.2353783
Yeah.
623
00:40:52,819.2353783 --> 00:40:54,79.2353783
She chose to do an affirmation.
624
00:40:55,129.2353783 --> 00:40:57,739.2353783
What? Which was like super interesting.
625
00:40:57,739.2353783 --> 00:41:05,419.2353783
But if you are a religious person and you don't choose the Bible, that's interesting, isn't it? Super interesting, isn't it? I didn't know you could do that.
626
00:41:05,599.2353783 --> 00:41:05,749.2353783
Yeah.
627
00:41:05,749.2353783 --> 00:41:06,529.2353783
You get choices.
628
00:41:06,529.2353783 --> 00:41:07,879.2353783
I think you can choose like whatever.
629
00:41:08,419.2353783 --> 00:41:11,209.2353783
Artifact or an affirmation if you're not like atheist.
630
00:41:11,379.2353783 --> 00:41:20,219.2353783
So Monday really was setting that scene of humanizing Erin, humanizing her I guess from her perspective, what community, how Yeah.
631
00:41:20,219.2353783 --> 00:41:22,19.2353783
Involved she was, all of that.
632
00:41:22,169.2353783 --> 00:41:25,949.2353783
She also spoke about the relationship she had with the Pattersons.
633
00:41:26,39.2353783 --> 00:41:26,399.2353783
Mm.
634
00:41:26,459.2353783 --> 00:41:33,259.2353783
Particularly, ian and Gail, and she said that Gail helped her a lot, particularly with raising the children, with being a new mother.
635
00:41:33,439.2353783 --> 00:41:38,869.2353783
She had a really great relationship with them and she lamented that with the separation with Simon.
636
00:41:38,869.2353783 --> 00:41:45,109.2353783
She was so sad and grieving the distance that I created in her relationship with Ian and Gail.
637
00:41:45,469.2353783 --> 00:41:46,879.2353783
Oh, Dawn and Gail.
638
00:41:46,879.2353783 --> 00:41:47,449.2353783
Don and Gail.
639
00:41:47,449.2353783 --> 00:41:47,779.2353783
Yes.
640
00:41:47,899.2353783 --> 00:41:48,199.2353783
Thank you.
641
00:41:48,199.2353783 --> 00:41:49,219.2353783
Ian's alive.
642
00:41:49,219.2353783 --> 00:41:49,849.2353783
Ian Wilkinson.
643
00:41:49,849.2353783 --> 00:41:50,629.2353783
He survived.
644
00:41:50,899.2353783 --> 00:41:51,769.2353783
Ian is the pastor.
645
00:41:51,799.2353783 --> 00:41:52,249.2353783
Thank you.
646
00:41:52,399.2353783 --> 00:41:53,299.2353783
You're most welcome.
647
00:41:55,24.2353783 --> 00:42:02,734.2353783
So then at that sort of soft launch, the strain relationship with the Patterson family and it built the groundwork that there wasn't a motive here.
648
00:42:02,734.2353783 --> 00:42:11,44.2353783
Like why on earth would someone who has a great relationship with these people and respects and has that connection hurt these people? Yeah.
649
00:42:11,44.2353783 --> 00:42:16,734.2353783
And hearing about her talk about them and how they've always been good to her and they've never done anything wrong.
650
00:42:16,734.2353783 --> 00:42:21,174.2353783
Why would she want to hurt them? That was definitely a strong point.
651
00:42:21,714.2353783 --> 00:42:23,34.2353783
As part of her testimony.
652
00:42:23,64.2353783 --> 00:42:24,534.2353783
Yep, absolutely agree with that one.
653
00:42:26,124.2353783 --> 00:42:34,14.2353783
On Tuesday, Erin made an admission that she concedes that there has to have been death cap mushrooms in the beef wellingtons.
654
00:42:34,194.2353783 --> 00:42:36,24.2353783
So she confirmed that? Yes.
655
00:42:36,534.2353783 --> 00:42:37,554.2353783
Hang on, hang on.
656
00:42:37,614.2353783 --> 00:42:39,354.2353783
She's admitted that they were in there.
657
00:42:39,624.2353783 --> 00:42:41,244.2353783
Not that she knew they were there.
658
00:42:42,174.2353783 --> 00:42:42,234.2353783
Oh.
659
00:42:42,264.2353783 --> 00:42:49,584.2353783
But she concedes that the way that those must tender the lunch something had been impacted was from eating.
660
00:42:50,109.2353783 --> 00:42:52,239.2353783
Mushrooms that were in the Beef Wellington lunch.
661
00:42:52,659.2353783 --> 00:42:53,319.2353783
Okay.
662
00:42:53,859.2353783 --> 00:42:59,169.2353783
And she's still saying that they came from the grocer in Glen Waverley or Mountain Waverley.
663
00:42:59,349.2353783 --> 00:43:02,979.2353783
So what Erin said is that they were mushrooms from the grocer.
664
00:43:03,939.2353783 --> 00:43:08,589.2353783
From Woolies, potentially also from an Asian grocer in Mount Waverley.
665
00:43:08,799.2353783 --> 00:43:08,979.2353783
Yeah.
666
00:43:09,309.2353783 --> 00:43:18,69.2353783
And that she was trying the mix called Delle, which she cooked down with garlic shallots, and the mushrooms finally minced and she found that it was quite bland.
667
00:43:18,279.2353783 --> 00:43:21,729.2353783
So she reached for a container of dehydrated mushrooms in her pantry.
668
00:43:22,809.2353783 --> 00:43:31,419.2353783
And they must have been some of the mushrooms that she previously had dehydrated up that she foraged and they must have contained their cat mushrooms.
669
00:43:31,419.2353783 --> 00:43:32,199.2353783
And she didn't know that.
670
00:43:33,579.2353783 --> 00:43:35,469.2353783
Bad has, she's not said that yet, though.
671
00:43:36,249.2353783 --> 00:43:40,359.2353783
She did say that she had the, the mushrooms from the grocer and they were smelly.
672
00:43:40,359.2353783 --> 00:43:41,769.2353783
They had a strong smell.
673
00:43:41,919.2353783 --> 00:43:42,279.2353783
Yeah.
674
00:43:42,579.2353783 --> 00:43:50,469.2353783
I think this was the first time that she said, yeah, there were mushrooms that forage from a foraging origination that ended up in the beef Wellington.
675
00:43:51,429.2353783 --> 00:43:56,679.2353783
During the opening statements, they said that she admitted that she forage, she had a dehydrator and this was all panic.
676
00:43:56,679.2353783 --> 00:43:59,949.2353783
Everything that she did after the lunch was her panicking and the lies as well.
677
00:43:59,949.2353783 --> 00:44:00,579.2353783
She acknowledged that.
678
00:44:00,579.2353783 --> 00:44:01,214.2353783
She told lies.
679
00:44:02,184.2353783 --> 00:44:04,414.2353783
Oh, it's, It's getting sticky.
680
00:44:04,514.2353783 --> 00:44:10,604.2353783
What I also wanna talk about is her online relationships with these women in the Facebook group.
681
00:44:10,874.2353783 --> 00:44:11,234.2353783
Yeah.
682
00:44:11,234.2353783 --> 00:44:13,264.2353783
But we gossip in our like group chats.
683
00:44:13,294.2353783 --> 00:44:14,74.2353783
No, I know.
684
00:44:14,74.2353783 --> 00:44:17,74.2353783
But they spoke specifically about talking about the family and.
685
00:44:17,459.2353783 --> 00:44:21,419.2353783
FM and all that kind of, all that kind of stuff.
686
00:44:21,809.2353783 --> 00:44:28,229.2353783
I know we do, but would you talk to someone who you have never met before about it? I guess maybe you would even more 'cause you don't know them.
687
00:44:28,229.2353783 --> 00:44:28,619.2353783
I don't know.
688
00:44:29,139.2353783 --> 00:44:29,889.2353783
It's all relative.
689
00:44:29,889.2353783 --> 00:44:31,989.2353783
That could be who your friends are.
690
00:44:32,619.2353783 --> 00:44:32,799.2353783
Yeah.
691
00:44:32,799.2353783 --> 00:44:36,159.2353783
And she's a skilled online sleuth, isn't she? So these are her peeps.
692
00:44:36,189.2353783 --> 00:44:38,709.2353783
But also Erin stated herself that she's an introvert.
693
00:44:38,809.2353783 --> 00:44:39,489.2353783
Yeah, like.
694
00:44:41,154.2353783 --> 00:44:45,294.2353783
You know, gamers, they can develop really close friendships with the people they game with.
695
00:44:45,564.2353783 --> 00:44:48,504.2353783
Actually, I'm not one of those people, but you're right, they can.
696
00:44:48,504.2353783 --> 00:44:49,74.2353783
They do.
697
00:44:49,854.2353783 --> 00:44:52,374.2353783
So yeah, it is interesting.
698
00:44:52,734.2353783 --> 00:44:54,954.2353783
But I dunno, I didn't read too much about for that.
699
00:44:54,954.2353783 --> 00:45:03,754.2353783
I was just like, ah, people gossip and, talk about stresses in their life and decompress with people that they connect with and maybe they'll just, who she connects with, particularly living in the country.
700
00:45:04,234.2353783 --> 00:45:05,134.2353783
Yeah, that's true.
701
00:45:06,4.2353783 --> 00:45:06,909.2353783
And what about.
702
00:45:07,909.2353783 --> 00:45:08,599.2353783
Cancer.
703
00:45:09,289.2353783 --> 00:45:17,569.2353783
She said that she lied about having cancer because what she really wanted to talk about was having weight loss surgery.
704
00:45:18,559.2353783 --> 00:45:19,219.2353783
Interesting.
705
00:45:19,219.2353783 --> 00:45:26,214.2353783
Because why would you like talk to them about how to tell the children you've got cancer? Because that would traumatize the children.
706
00:45:27,709.2353783 --> 00:45:29,419.2353783
I wonder if she panicked or.
707
00:45:30,739.2353783 --> 00:45:31,969.2353783
Maybe she was looking for sympathy.
708
00:45:31,969.2353783 --> 00:45:32,419.2353783
I don't know.
709
00:45:32,569.2353783 --> 00:45:34,819.2353783
Like it wasn't about, it wasn't the lie.
710
00:45:34,819.2353783 --> 00:45:42,99.2353783
It was about she wanted to feel appreciated and the center feel cared for and not left, alone if she is lonely.
711
00:45:42,309.2353783 --> 00:45:42,759.2353783
Yeah.
712
00:45:42,759.2353783 --> 00:45:42,760.2353783
Yeah.
713
00:45:43,29.2353783 --> 00:45:45,279.2353783
Well, she doesn't have her parents, her parents have passed away.
714
00:45:45,519.2353783 --> 00:45:45,729.2353783
Yeah.
715
00:45:46,629.2353783 --> 00:45:47,739.2353783
So that's Tuesday.
716
00:45:47,799.2353783 --> 00:45:53,19.2353783
And what happened on Wednesday? Wednesday? She admitted that she got rid of the dehydrator.
717
00:45:53,289.2353783 --> 00:45:56,249.2353783
She talked about what happened immediately following the lunch.
718
00:45:56,669.2353783 --> 00:45:56,759.2353783
Mm-hmm.
719
00:45:56,999.2353783 --> 00:46:01,589.2353783
And it all came down to I panicked, I stressed, I got anxious.
720
00:46:01,589.2353783 --> 00:46:06,239.2353783
I didn't do the right thing, but it wasn't in a place of malicious intent.
721
00:46:06,239.2353783 --> 00:46:12,479.2353783
It was purely everything I did was me panicking because people have gotten very, very sick.
722
00:46:12,659.2353783 --> 00:46:14,759.2353783
And I think it may have been because of something I did.
723
00:46:15,874.2353783 --> 00:46:17,824.2353783
You can't r argue with that either.
724
00:46:17,824.2353783 --> 00:46:19,204.2353783
That seems like a human response.
725
00:46:19,234.2353783 --> 00:46:21,154.2353783
When you butcher something, I do this all the time.
726
00:46:21,574.2353783 --> 00:46:22,954.2353783
I think I've screwed up with something.
727
00:46:23,44.2353783 --> 00:46:27,304.2353783
And so instead of just leaving it, I have to, I have to try, you know, I keep going.
728
00:46:27,304.2353783 --> 00:46:28,744.2353783
Make and then make it worse.
729
00:46:28,924.2353783 --> 00:46:29,284.2353783
Digging in.
730
00:46:29,284.2353783 --> 00:46:29,794.2353783
Yeah.
731
00:46:29,799.2353783 --> 00:46:30,664.2353783
Until you butcher it.
732
00:46:31,84.2353783 --> 00:46:32,824.2353783
And if you're panicking, you're like, nah, no, that wasn't me.
733
00:46:32,974.2353783 --> 00:46:37,654.2353783
And then you're like, I always remember this one time you overcompensate, right? Yes, yes.
734
00:46:37,654.2353783 --> 00:46:39,754.2353783
And you you lie and you're just like, ah.
735
00:46:39,784.2353783 --> 00:46:43,414.2353783
Then you dar deep and you're like, oh, I really should just fess up at this point.
736
00:46:43,414.2353783 --> 00:46:45,334.2353783
But you're like, one more.
737
00:46:45,514.2353783 --> 00:46:45,814.2353783
Yeah.
738
00:46:45,814.2353783 --> 00:46:47,254.2353783
And hopefully it all goes away.
739
00:46:47,254.2353783 --> 00:46:49,504.2353783
And then you get to the point you're like, I should never have done that.
740
00:46:49,504.2353783 --> 00:46:52,24.2353783
I should have just told the truth from the very beginning.
741
00:46:52,714.2353783 --> 00:46:56,914.2353783
Granted, nothing of this significance has ever happened to me.
742
00:46:56,944.2353783 --> 00:47:00,94.2353783
No, no, no one's ever died after I cook them lunch.
743
00:47:00,144.2353783 --> 00:47:00,624.2353783
God.
744
00:47:01,549.2353783 --> 00:47:02,89.2353783
Oh God.
745
00:47:02,904.2353783 --> 00:47:09,864.2353783
So today we had the prosecutor questioning Aaron and I would say Aaron's defense barrister.
746
00:47:09,894.2353783 --> 00:47:11,304.2353783
He tried to take the edge off.
747
00:47:11,724.2353783 --> 00:47:14,874.2353783
He tried to remove the opportunity for gotcha moments by asking everything.
748
00:47:15,714.2353783 --> 00:47:17,424.2353783
So therefore, the.
749
00:47:18,114.2353783 --> 00:47:24,509.2353783
Prosecutor, doesn't really have that much, uncharted territory that Erin hasn't already answered.
750
00:47:24,957.5687116 --> 00:47:34,197.5687116
Yeah, actually one thing that was quite interested is, or interesting, is that Erin said that there was no designated plates, it was just everyone grabbed a plate.
751
00:47:34,827.5687116 --> 00:47:40,512.5687116
She said that she didn't have gray plates, that she wasn't quite sure what they were talking about, so that she just had a random assortment of plates.
752
00:47:40,512.5687116 --> 00:47:47,547.5687116
So that also was broken down, and the prosecutor was just rehashing pointed questions to say.
753
00:47:48,132.5687116 --> 00:47:54,192.5687116
Did you know it was there? What did you Dehydrate we're showing pictures of from Erin's phone of her dehydrating.
754
00:47:54,192.5687116 --> 00:47:56,52.5687116
Things in the dehydrator.
755
00:47:56,612.5687116 --> 00:48:01,502.5687116
'Cause the angle they were going for was to get her to say that she'd only ever dehydrated mushrooms.
756
00:48:01,502.5687116 --> 00:48:02,792.5687116
It was only ever mushrooms.
757
00:48:03,182.5687116 --> 00:48:08,982.5687116
And Erin said, no, I'd done fruit and other bits and pieces just to see what I could add into the foods.
758
00:48:10,582.5687116 --> 00:48:12,22.5687116
What day is it Thursday now.
759
00:48:12,847.5687116 --> 00:48:25,367.5687116
The latest that we've seen is that they have found a phone, a photo on her sa well, they've asked her about a photo found on her Samsung tablet which was an image of death cap mushrooms.
760
00:48:26,327.5687116 --> 00:48:28,157.5687116
Oh, this has happened this afternoon.
761
00:48:28,157.5687116 --> 00:48:28,217.5687116
Yeah.
762
00:48:29,12.5687116 --> 00:48:43,22.5687116
So if I, oh, and this is fresh off the press, but essentially Erin has been they've has denied that they a photo that was found on her Samsung tablet showing the death cut, mushrooms being dehydrated.
763
00:48:43,682.5687116 --> 00:48:44,12.5687116
Oh.
764
00:48:44,12.5687116 --> 00:48:47,342.5687116
And they were identified by the mushroom expert guy.
765
00:48:47,402.5687116 --> 00:48:47,942.5687116
Yeah.
766
00:48:48,392.5687116 --> 00:48:49,862.5687116
That is interesting.
767
00:48:50,432.5687116 --> 00:48:51,362.5687116
And, that's tough.
768
00:48:51,362.5687116 --> 00:48:59,122.5687116
When you've got her in the box like that, how you wouldn't, they wouldn't, I'm assuming she wasn't expecting they would go find that or she knew about that.
769
00:48:59,122.5687116 --> 00:49:01,312.5687116
That seems like a, something we've not heard about yet.
770
00:49:01,342.5687116 --> 00:49:07,72.5687116
Were they the devices that she tried to factory reset? Possibly, but if you have iPhones, at least they're all in sync.
771
00:49:07,72.5687116 --> 00:49:09,442.5687116
This is the problem with Androids, I tell you what.
772
00:49:09,497.5687116 --> 00:49:09,917.5687116
Mm-hmm.
773
00:49:11,387.5687116 --> 00:49:15,782.5687116
So where to from here? The judge today said that.
774
00:49:16,307.5687116 --> 00:49:25,397.5687116
It's likely that this trial is now gonna push into late June, so it's the 5th of June Today he said it could be the rest of the month it takes.
775
00:49:25,727.5687116 --> 00:49:33,887.5687116
They were expecting that we would be on the closing end, but he went back to the jury and said, Hey, it's likely that this examination will continue for a few more days.
776
00:49:34,367.5687116 --> 00:49:36,857.5687116
The defense has alluded that they do have more witnesses coming.
777
00:49:37,237.5687116 --> 00:49:37,458.5687116
Oh, okay.
778
00:49:37,702.5687116 --> 00:49:43,672.5687116
And then, and then they will have closing arguments and then the judge will summarize everything that's been heard as well.
779
00:49:43,672.5687116 --> 00:49:47,782.5687116
And then provide instruction to the jury to then start jury camp.
780
00:49:48,232.5687116 --> 00:49:49,192.5687116
Just deliberations.
781
00:49:49,282.5687116 --> 00:49:50,482.5687116
Deliberations.
782
00:49:50,482.5687116 --> 00:49:52,312.5687116
And they're gonna be sequestered.
783
00:49:52,312.5687116 --> 00:49:52,402.5687116
Mm-hmm.
784
00:49:53,662.5687116 --> 00:49:55,552.5687116
It's actually going a bit longer than what I thought.
785
00:49:55,932.5687116 --> 00:49:58,692.5687116
If you were the news, you would be loving this.
786
00:49:58,842.5687116 --> 00:49:59,502.5687116
Oh yeah.
787
00:49:59,502.5687116 --> 00:50:00,317.5687116
This has gotta be.
788
00:50:02,527.5687116 --> 00:50:04,177.5687116
You Victoria's story of the year.
789
00:50:04,177.5687116 --> 00:50:05,17.5687116
A hundred percent.
790
00:50:05,17.5687116 --> 00:50:13,147.5687116
But could you imagine you're a news reporter, you're sitting there, it's getting to the Thailand, and they're like, and Erin Patterson is going to testify, and you're like, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
791
00:50:13,147.5687116 --> 00:50:13,417.5687116
Yep.
792
00:50:13,697.5687116 --> 00:50:18,677.5687116
That would be like kryptonite, candy, like it's basically.
793
00:50:19,202.5687116 --> 00:50:25,172.5687116
The best day ever for someone who is heavily involved in reporting on the court proceedings.
794
00:50:25,292.5687116 --> 00:50:30,442.5687116
Absolutely, and, and this is why I would love to be a juror, because what an experience, a hundred percent.
795
00:50:30,622.5687116 --> 00:50:31,852.5687116
That's it from us this week.
796
00:50:31,912.5687116 --> 00:50:33,862.5687116
Lawsuits were dropped, weeks were worn.
797
00:50:34,12.5687116 --> 00:50:37,252.5687116
Elon rage quit, and Taylor somehow became even more powerful.
798
00:50:37,432.5687116 --> 00:50:42,952.5687116
If you liked what you heard, make sure to rate and review and share it with a friend who loves a little bit of drama with their headlines.
799
00:50:43,192.5687116 --> 00:50:46,522.5687116
And don't forget, we'll be back next week with more headlines and more hot takes.
800
00:50:46,582.5687116 --> 00:50:47,212.5687116
See you then.