In this harrowing milestone episode, Charity unpacks one of the most shocking and heartbreaking cases to ever come through the foster care system—the murder of Lisa Knoefel, a dedicated social worker and loving mother, at the hands of the teen she brought into her home to protect.
What began as an act of compassion—taking in 16-year-old Sabrina Zunich, a girl with a traumatic past and severe mental health struggles—quickly twisted into something unimaginable. Grooming. Manipulation. A secret relationship. And a murder-for-hire plot orchestrated by the one person Lisa should have been able to trust: her husband, Kevin Knoefel.
Charity walks through Sabrina’s turbulent childhood, the psychological vulnerabilities that made her a target, the disturbing evolution of her relationship with Kevin, and the brutal 178-stab murder that shook Willoughby Hills, Ohio. This episode also highlights systemic failures in foster care, the red flags that were missed, and how a teenager in crisis was weaponized by a manipulative adult to destroy the very family trying to help her.
Episode Highlights
- Lisa Knoefel’s passion for protecting children—and how it tragically cost her life
- Sabrina’s childhood trauma: addiction, instability, neglect, and mental health struggles
- The foster care statistics behind placement instability and teen vulnerability
- How Sabrina initially thrived in the Knoefel home before the dynamic shifted
- Early red flags: accusations of favoritism, emotional distancing, and inappropriate closeness with Kevin
- The grooming trajectory: massages, sexual “jokes,” escalating boundaries, and Kevin planning a future with Sabrina
- Kevin’s manipulation: coercing Sabrina with threats of suicide, love-bombing, and promises of a life together
- The life insurance motive—$785,000—and the plan to stage a burglary
- The chilling details of the murder: 178 stab wounds and a bent knife
- Megan’s courageous 911 call and her attempt to stop the attack
- Kevin’s suspicious behavior after the murder—calm demeanor, insurance paperwork, visiting Sabrina in jail
- Sabrina’s eventual cooperation with police and the unraveling of the conspiracy
- Trial outcomes:
- Kevin Knoefel — Life in prison + 12 years
- Sabrina Zunich — Life with parole eligibility in 30 years
- The deep failures in foster care oversight and ignored warning signs
- Where the surviving daughters and key figures are now
- How a system meant to save Sabrina instead placed her in the worst possible home
Reflection
Lisa Knoefel spent her life protecting children. She opened her home to a teenager who desperately needed safety. And she was betrayed by the system she trusted and the man she loved. This case is a devastating reminder: When red flags are ignored, vulnerable people pay the highest price.
Resources & References
Daughter Gets Life in Foster Mom's Stabbing Death
State of Ohio Vs. Kevin Knoefel
$6.2 Million Awarded in Lisa Knoefel Murder Case
What You Need To Know About The Sabrina Zunich Case Ahead Of The Premiere Of 'Snapped: Behind Bars
The Tragic Murder of Lisa Knoefel
Relationship Details Revealed Between Husband, Foster Daughter
Lisa Knoefel Murder: How Did She Die? Who Killed Her?
Graphic Details of Woman’s Murder Come Out in Husband’s Trial
Man Manipulated Teenage Foster Daughter to Fatally Stab His Wife
Sabrina Zunich Teen Killer Murders Foster Mother
© 2026 iHeartMedia, Inc.
