Snowfall and Suspicion: The Karen Read Case – Part One - Ep. 84

In the chilling kickoff to Season 2, we unravel the tangled mystery surrounding the death of Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe. After a night of drinking, he’s found lifeless in the snow outside a fellow officer’s home—and his girlfriend, Karen Read, is accused of hitting him with her SUV and leaving him to die in a blizzard.

But the defense paints a darker picture: a possible cover-up involving law enforcement, missing surveillance footage, and a web of conflicting evidence. Was this a tragic accident—or something far more sinister?

This episode dives deep into the events leading up to that fateful night, the volatile relationship between Karen and John, and the explosive courtroom battle that followed.

 

Highlights Include: 

• A nor’easter, a night of drinking, and a body in the snow
• Broken taillight fragments and a strand of hair on a bumper
• Angry voicemails and texts that paint a volatile relationship
• Scratches, a German Shepherd, and theories of a dog attack
• Missing surveillance footage and suspicious Google searches
• A courtroom showdown with over 600 exhibits and 70 witnesses
• A relationship rekindled during the pandemic—and unraveling in tragedy
• Medical findings that challenge the prosecution’s narrative

Resources & Links 

  True Crime Today Podcast: The Trial of Karen Read 

A Guide to the Karen Read Case 

Karen Read & John O'Keefe's Relationship | Vinnie Politan Investigates 

Did Dunkin' Donuts Fight Uncover Deeper Issues in Read, O'Keefe Relationship? 

Conspiracy in Canton 

A Timeline of the Karen Read Case and the Story Behind the High-profile Massachusetts Murder Trial 

Karen Read Case: These Are the Key Players to Know 

Karen Read's Angry Voicemails to John O'Keefe 

Unpacking the Second Trial and Verdict That Cleared Karen Read of Murder 

Lead Investigator in Karen Read Case Fired from Massachusetts State Police After Vulgar Texts 

Karen Read Accused of Killing Her Police Officer Boyfriend 

Missing Video Footage 

Conspiracies, Cover-Up Claims, Dog Bite Analysis Swirl In Case Of Boston Cop ‘Taillight Murder’ 

Sign up to be a Patron today! Get access to t