"Dear Theodosia"-The unsolved disappearance of the Vice President's daughters

She was born into history — daughter of Aaron Burr, the scandal-scarred Vice President who once shot Alexander Hamilton. Brilliant, beautiful, and fiercely educated, Theodosia Burr Alston was destined to be more than just a footnote. But in 1813, she boarded a ship bound for New York… and vanished without a trace.

In this haunting episode, the Society dives into the many mysteries surrounding Theodosia’s disappearance: pirates, shipwrecks, ghostly sightings, and even coded letters found decades later. Was it a tragic accident? Or a cover-up worthy of the Burr name?

With nods to Hamilton and a heavy dose of dark historical intrigue, we untangle fact from folklore—and explore what might’ve happened when history's current swept Theodosia out to sea.

🕯️ Secrets, shipwrecks, and the shadow of legacy await.

All Video & Audio Edited By Jeremy of Schroeder Audio

  If you would like to contact The SSOS E mail: [e-mail] TikTok : @SSODPodcast Instagram @Secretsocietyofstrangerspod Facebook: Secret Society of Strangers Podcast Merch available -  check out our linktree Full video episodes on our SSOS YouTube