October 31, 2024 • 11 mins
In this episode of the AiSultana podcast, we explore how Artificial Intelligence is reshaping the landscape of qualitative research. From scalability and objectivity to real-time adaptive questioning, AI tools like Large Language Models (LLMs) offer a new frontier for gathering deep insights at an unprecedented scale. Join us as we dive into the practical applications, cost benefits, and ethical considerations of integrating AI into qualitative research. Discover how leading platforms are bridging the gap between qualitative depth and quantitative reach, and what this means for data integrity, strategic decision-making, and the future of AI-enabled research. Perfect for AI enthusiasts and industry professionals alike, this briefing provides a comprehensive look at the transformative power of AI in research.
Brought to you by AiSultana, a consultancy specializing in AI solutions for industry.
Join us daily for concise updates on crucial developments in AI, and why they matter to you.
Available via YouTube, Apple, and Spotify.
Don't forget to like and subscribe, and explore our free wine consumer app at www.aisultana.com.
Tune in to stay informed about the pivotal topics shaping the future of AI in industry.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
Okay, so get this, imagine thousands of interviews
(00:03):
all happening at the same time, like all at once.
And they're all led by an AI interviewer.
Sounds a little sci-fi, right?
A little bit, yeah.
But it's really happening right now.
It's out there in the world.
And that's exactly what we're diving into today,
this whole revolution in research.
That's right, this is AI-powered qualitative research,
which, like you said, it sounds very sci-fi.
(00:25):
Yeah, so, I mean, we all know qualitative research,
it's all about that human touch, right?
You're sitting down with somebody,
you're having a conversation,
you're getting those deep insights.
But now we're talking about AI stepping into that role.
So how does that even work?
Well, it's pretty fascinating, actually.
So you know all those chatbots you see popping up
everywhere you go online?
That's kind of the basic idea here.
We're talking about large language models, or LLMs.
(00:46):
And these LLMs are like super-powered interviewers,
in a way.
They can have structured conversations,
they can ask follow-up questions,
they can even dig deeper based on the responses they get.
So it's not just like a robot reading off a script,
it's actually like engaging with the person
on the other end of the interview.
Exactly.
It's designed to be dynamic,
to adapt to the flow of the conversation
(01:07):
just like a human interviewer would.
And here's the really mind-blowing part,
it can conduct thousands of these interviews
at the same time.
Hold on, thousands at the same time?
So how can it possibly keep up with all that information?
Okay, so imagine this, you've got a massive library
filled with books on every imaginable topic,
that's kind of like the LLM's knowledge base, right?
(01:28):
Now imagine a librarian who can instantly pull up
any book you need,
and even connect different books based on their content.
That's what the LLM is doing,
it's sifting through all that data-making connections
in real time.
Okay, my mind is officially blown.
Yeah.
So we're talking about a system
that can hold a conversation, adapt to the responses,
and handle thousands of these interviews all at once.
(01:50):
What's the catch?
There's gotta be a downside here.
Well, there are definitely challenges.
One of the big ones is making sure
these AI interviewers are reliable.
Because at the end of the day,
we need to be confident in the data
that we're collecting, right?
We need to know it's accurate.
Yeah, so how do we know the AI isn't just like
making stuff up, or misinterpreting the answers?
(02:10):
That's where the programming comes in.
These LLMs are trained on massive data sets,
and they're designed to follow
specific interview structures.
It's like giving them a detailed playbook
for how to conduct the interview.
Okay, so it's not just random questions
being thrown out there.
It's like a carefully designed process.
Right, but it's not just about following a script either.
Remember, these LLMs can adapt.
(02:32):
They can analyze the responses,
they can identify inconsistencies,
they can even flag potential red flags.
Wait, inconsistent responses, red flags?
You're making this sound like a detective story.
In a way it is.
These AI interviewers are constantly analyzing the data,
looking for patterns, making sure the information
they're gathering is reliable.
So they're like lie detectors.
Well, not exactly.
(02:53):
But they can definitely spot inconsistencies
or contradictions in the responses.
Let's say someone claims to have worked at a certain company,
but their answers about their role
or the company's products don't quite add up.
The AI can pick up on those discrepancies.
That's pretty impressive.
It's like having a built-in fact checker for every interview.
Exactly.
It's all about ensuring data integrity,
(03:14):
making sure that what we're getting is accurate
and reliable, but you know.
Let's go beyond the technical stuff for a second
and think about the human side of this.
Okay, so we've got this super efficient
data-crunching AI interviewer.
But where does the human element fit in?
I mean, can AI really replace those nuances
of human interaction?
That's the million dollar question, isn't it?
(03:36):
And it's one that researchers are really grappling
with right now.
On the one hand, we have this amazing technology
that can process information at a scale
we could only dream of before.
But on the other hand,
there's that intangible human element, right?
The intuition, the empathy,
the ability to read between the lines.
You know, it's funny you mentioned those chatbots earlier.
I remember trying out one of those customer service bots
(03:57):
online and it was so frustrating.
It kept giving me these canned responses,
totally missing the point of what I was asking.
Yeah, I think we've all had that experience at some point.
And it highlights a key difference
between those basic chatbots and these AI interviewers.
These LLMs are designed to go beyond
simple keyword recognition.
They're trained to understand context,
(04:19):
to pick up on nuances in language,
and to respond in a way that feels more natural and engaging.
So it's not just about answering questions,
it's about understanding the intent behind those questions.
Exactly, it's about recognizing
that human communication is complex.
There are often layers of meaning beneath the surface.
And that's something that researchers are constantly
working to improve in these AI interviewers.
(04:40):
Okay, but even with all those advancements,
are there situations where a human interviewer
is just better suited?
Like what about really sensitive topics?
I imagine some people might be more hesitant
to open up to a machine.
That's a great point.
And it's one where the research gets really interesting.
You might think people would be more guarded with an AI,
but studies have shown that the opposite
(05:01):
can actually be true.
Really?
You're telling me people are more likely
to spill the beans to a robot.
In some cases, yes.
Think about it when you're talking to a human.
There's always that element of judgment, right?
Whether conscious or not, but with an AI,
that perceived judgment goes away.
It's like talking to a neutral party.
(05:21):
Someone who's just there to listen
without any preconceived notions.
That makes sense.
It's like when you're venting to a friend.
Sometimes it's easier to just let it all out
when you know they're not gonna judge you.
Exactly.
And that can be especially powerful
when dealing with sensitive topics.
Things that people might be hesitant to discuss
with another human.
For example, there's been research looking at the use
of AI interviewers in healthcare settings,
(05:44):
where patients might be more willing
to disclose personal information
or sensitive symptoms to an AI.
That's fascinating.
It's like having a digital therapist
who's always available and never gets tired of listening.
But what about those situations
where you really need that human touch?
Like let's say you're conducting a job interview.
Can AI really assess things
like personality, communication skills, cultural fit?
(06:06):
That's where things get a bit more tricky.
While AI can certainly analyze responses
and flag potential red flags,
it's still limited in its ability to grasp
those more nuanced aspects of human interaction.
So it's not about AI replacing human interviewers
altogether, it's more about finding the right balance right.
Using AI to streamline certain processes
and free up human researchers to focus on those areas
(06:29):
where their expertise is truly invaluable.
That's a great way to put it.
Think of it like a partnership,
where AI and human researchers are working together
to achieve a common goal.
AI can handle the heavy lifting,
analyzing large data sets,
identifying patterns, generating initial insights.
And then human researchers can step in
to provide that deeper level of analysis,
interpretation and contextual understanding.
(06:50):
So it's not a case of us versus them.
It's about finding ways to leverage the strengths
of both AI and human intelligence
to create a more robust and insightful research process.
Exactly.
And I think that's one of the most exciting things
about this field right now.
We're still in the early stages
of exploring all the possibilities,
but the potential is enormous.
Imagine a future where AI can help us uncover hidden trends,
(07:13):
challenge our assumptions,
and ultimately gain a deeper understanding
of human behavior and motivation.
It sounds like we're on the verge of a major shift
in how research is conducted.
It's almost like we're entering a new era
where AI becomes this indispensable partner
in the research process.
I think that's a great way to look at it.
It's not about AI replacing humans.
It's about AI augmenting our capabilities,
(07:34):
helping us see things we might've missed,
and pushing the boundaries of what's possible in research
and pushing the boundaries of what's possible in research.
So if we fast forward a few years,
what might this AI-powered research landscape look like?
Like, what kind of changes can we expect to see?
Well, for starters, I think we'll see a lot more integration
of AI tools into existing research workflows.
(07:56):
Like, imagine a world where AI can transcribe interviews,
code data, and even identify key themes and patterns.
Oh, that would free up a lot of time for researchers
so they could really focus on the bigger picture.
Absolutely.
It would allow them to spend more time
interpreting the data, developing insights,
and communicating their findings in compelling ways.
But it's not just about efficiency either.
(08:19):
AI can also help us uncover insights
that we might've missed using traditional methods.
You know, that reminds me of a story I read about
how AI was used to analyze customer reviews
for a major retailer.
And the AI was able to pick up on these subtle patterns
in the language that human analysts had totally overlooked.
And it turned out that customers who used certain phrases
in their reviews were much more likely
(08:40):
to become repeat buyers.
That's a great example of how AI can help us see things
in a new light.
By analyzing massive amounts of data,
AI can identify subtle correlations and patterns
that might not be apparent to the human eye.
And those insights can be incredibly valuable
for businesses, researchers, policymakers alike.
But with all this talk about AI's capabilities,
(09:02):
it's easy to get caught up in the hype.
So what are some of the limitations
we need to be aware of?
What can't AI do?
Well, one of the biggest limitations of AI
is that it's still very much dependent
on the data it's trained on.
So if the data is biased or incomplete,
the AI's output will reflect those biases.
So it's like that saying garbage in garbage out.
Exactly.
That's why it's so important to be mindful of data quality
(09:25):
and to ensure that the data we're feeding
into these AI systems is representative and unbiased.
And what about the ethical considerations?
We talked about data privacy earlier.
Are there any other ethical dilemmas we need to grapple with
as AI becomes more prevalent in research?
Yeah, I think transparency is a big one.
As researchers, we need to be open about how
we're using AI in our work.
(09:46):
And we need to be clear about the potential limitations
and biases of these tools.
We also need to be mindful of the potential impact of AI
on human jobs and livelihoods.
As AI becomes more sophisticated,
it's inevitable that some tasks that were previously done
by humans will be automated.
It sounds like we're heading into uncharted territory here.
There's a lot of excitement about the potential of AI,
(10:08):
but also a lot of uncertainty about the long-term
implications.
That's true.
But I think that's part of what makes this field so fascinating.
We're at the forefront of a technological revolution.
And we have the opportunity to shape how this technology is
developed and used.
We're at the forefront of a technological revolution.
And we have the opportunity to shape how this technology is
developed and used.
So what's the one thing?
(10:29):
If there was just one takeaway, you
hope our listeners get from this deep dive
into AI and qualitative research, what would it be?
Hmm.
That's a good question.
I think I would want them to come away with a sense of wonder
and curiosity.
AI is this incredibly powerful tool.
And it has the potential to completely transform
(10:50):
the way we understand the world around us.
But it's up to us to use it responsibly and ethically
and to always remember that human element.
That's what makes research so meaningful in the first place.
Well said.
And on that note, I think it's time to wrap up this deep dive.
We've covered a lot of ground today,
from the technical nuts and bolts of AI interviewers
to the broader societal and ethical implications
(11:12):
of this technology.
It's been a fascinating journey.
And I hope our listeners have surfaced
with a newfound appreciation for this evolving
world of qualitative research.
Until next time, keep diving deep
and keep those questions coming at us.
Okay, so get this, imagine thousands of interviews
(00:03):
all happening at the same time, like all at once.
And they're all led by an AI interviewer.
Sounds a little sci-fi, right?
A little bit, yeah.
But it's really happening right now.
It's out there in the world.
And that's exactly what we're diving into today,
this whole revolution in research.
That's right, this is AI-powered qualitative research,
which, like you said, it sounds very sci-fi.
(00:25):
Yeah, so, I mean, we all know qualitative research,
it's all about that human touch, right?
You're sitting down with somebody,
you're having a conversation,
you're getting those deep insights.
But now we're talking about AI stepping into that role.
So how does that even work?
Well, it's pretty fascinating, actually.
So you know all those chatbots you see popping up
everywhere you go online?
That's kind of the basic idea here.
We're talking about large language models, or LLMs.
(00:46):
And these LLMs are like super-powered interviewers,
in a way.
They can have structured conversations,
they can ask follow-up questions,
they can even dig deeper based on the responses they get.
So it's not just like a robot reading off a script,
it's actually like engaging with the person
on the other end of the interview.
Exactly.
It's designed to be dynamic,
to adapt to the flow of the conversation
(01:07):
just like a human interviewer would.
And here's the really mind-blowing part,
it can conduct thousands of these interviews
at the same time.
Hold on, thousands at the same time?
So how can it possibly keep up with all that information?
Okay, so imagine this, you've got a massive library
filled with books on every imaginable topic,
that's kind of like the LLM's knowledge base, right?
(01:28):
Now imagine a librarian who can instantly pull up
any book you need,
and even connect different books based on their content.
That's what the LLM is doing,
it's sifting through all that data-making connections
in real time.
Okay, my mind is officially blown.
Yeah.
So we're talking about a system
that can hold a conversation, adapt to the responses,
and handle thousands of these interviews all at once.
(01:50):
What's the catch?
There's gotta be a downside here.
Well, there are definitely challenges.
One of the big ones is making sure
these AI interviewers are reliable.
Because at the end of the day,
we need to be confident in the data
that we're collecting, right?
We need to know it's accurate.
Yeah, so how do we know the AI isn't just like
making stuff up, or misinterpreting the answers?
(02:10):
That's where the programming comes in.
These LLMs are trained on massive data sets,
and they're designed to follow
specific interview structures.
It's like giving them a detailed playbook
for how to conduct the interview.
Okay, so it's not just random questions
being thrown out there.
It's like a carefully designed process.
Right, but it's not just about following a script either.
Remember, these LLMs can adapt.
(02:32):
They can analyze the responses,
they can identify inconsistencies,
they can even flag potential red flags.
Wait, inconsistent responses, red flags?
You're making this sound like a detective story.
In a way it is.
These AI interviewers are constantly analyzing the data,
looking for patterns, making sure the information
they're gathering is reliable.
So they're like lie detectors.
Well, not exactly.
(02:53):
But they can definitely spot inconsistencies
or contradictions in the responses.
Let's say someone claims to have worked at a certain company,
but their answers about their role
or the company's products don't quite add up.
The AI can pick up on those discrepancies.
That's pretty impressive.
It's like having a built-in fact checker for every interview.
Exactly.
It's all about ensuring data integrity,
(03:14):
making sure that what we're getting is accurate
and reliable, but you know.
Let's go beyond the technical stuff for a second
and think about the human side of this.
Okay, so we've got this super efficient
data-crunching AI interviewer.
But where does the human element fit in?
I mean, can AI really replace those nuances
of human interaction?
That's the million dollar question, isn't it?
(03:36):
And it's one that researchers are really grappling
with right now.
On the one hand, we have this amazing technology
that can process information at a scale
we could only dream of before.
But on the other hand,
there's that intangible human element, right?
The intuition, the empathy,
the ability to read between the lines.
You know, it's funny you mentioned those chatbots earlier.
I remember trying out one of those customer service bots
(03:57):
online and it was so frustrating.
It kept giving me these canned responses,
totally missing the point of what I was asking.
Yeah, I think we've all had that experience at some point.
And it highlights a key difference
between those basic chatbots and these AI interviewers.
These LLMs are designed to go beyond
simple keyword recognition.
They're trained to understand context,
(04:19):
to pick up on nuances in language,
and to respond in a way that feels more natural and engaging.
So it's not just about answering questions,
it's about understanding the intent behind those questions.
Exactly, it's about recognizing
that human communication is complex.
There are often layers of meaning beneath the surface.
And that's something that researchers are constantly
working to improve in these AI interviewers.
(04:40):
Okay, but even with all those advancements,
are there situations where a human interviewer
is just better suited?
Like what about really sensitive topics?
I imagine some people might be more hesitant
to open up to a machine.
That's a great point.
And it's one where the research gets really interesting.
You might think people would be more guarded with an AI,
but studies have shown that the opposite
(05:01):
can actually be true.
Really?
You're telling me people are more likely
to spill the beans to a robot.
In some cases, yes.
Think about it when you're talking to a human.
There's always that element of judgment, right?
Whether conscious or not, but with an AI,
that perceived judgment goes away.
It's like talking to a neutral party.
(05:21):
Someone who's just there to listen
without any preconceived notions.
That makes sense.
It's like when you're venting to a friend.
Sometimes it's easier to just let it all out
when you know they're not gonna judge you.
Exactly.
And that can be especially powerful
when dealing with sensitive topics.
Things that people might be hesitant to discuss
with another human.
For example, there's been research looking at the use
of AI interviewers in healthcare settings,
(05:44):
where patients might be more willing
to disclose personal information
or sensitive symptoms to an AI.
That's fascinating.
It's like having a digital therapist
who's always available and never gets tired of listening.
But what about those situations
where you really need that human touch?
Like let's say you're conducting a job interview.
Can AI really assess things
like personality, communication skills, cultural fit?
(06:06):
That's where things get a bit more tricky.
While AI can certainly analyze responses
and flag potential red flags,
it's still limited in its ability to grasp
those more nuanced aspects of human interaction.
So it's not about AI replacing human interviewers
altogether, it's more about finding the right balance right.
Using AI to streamline certain processes
and free up human researchers to focus on those areas
(06:29):
where their expertise is truly invaluable.
That's a great way to put it.
Think of it like a partnership,
where AI and human researchers are working together
to achieve a common goal.
AI can handle the heavy lifting,
analyzing large data sets,
identifying patterns, generating initial insights.
And then human researchers can step in
to provide that deeper level of analysis,
interpretation and contextual understanding.
(06:50):
So it's not a case of us versus them.
It's about finding ways to leverage the strengths
of both AI and human intelligence
to create a more robust and insightful research process.
Exactly.
And I think that's one of the most exciting things
about this field right now.
We're still in the early stages
of exploring all the possibilities,
but the potential is enormous.
Imagine a future where AI can help us uncover hidden trends,
(07:13):
challenge our assumptions,
and ultimately gain a deeper understanding
of human behavior and motivation.
It sounds like we're on the verge of a major shift
in how research is conducted.
It's almost like we're entering a new era
where AI becomes this indispensable partner
in the research process.
I think that's a great way to look at it.
It's not about AI replacing humans.
It's about AI augmenting our capabilities,
(07:34):
helping us see things we might've missed,
and pushing the boundaries of what's possible in research
and pushing the boundaries of what's possible in research.
So if we fast forward a few years,
what might this AI-powered research landscape look like?
Like, what kind of changes can we expect to see?
Well, for starters, I think we'll see a lot more integration
of AI tools into existing research workflows.
(07:56):
Like, imagine a world where AI can transcribe interviews,
code data, and even identify key themes and patterns.
Oh, that would free up a lot of time for researchers
so they could really focus on the bigger picture.
Absolutely.
It would allow them to spend more time
interpreting the data, developing insights,
and communicating their findings in compelling ways.
But it's not just about efficiency either.
(08:19):
AI can also help us uncover insights
that we might've missed using traditional methods.
You know, that reminds me of a story I read about
how AI was used to analyze customer reviews
for a major retailer.
And the AI was able to pick up on these subtle patterns
in the language that human analysts had totally overlooked.
And it turned out that customers who used certain phrases
in their reviews were much more likely
(08:40):
to become repeat buyers.
That's a great example of how AI can help us see things
in a new light.
By analyzing massive amounts of data,
AI can identify subtle correlations and patterns
that might not be apparent to the human eye.
And those insights can be incredibly valuable
for businesses, researchers, policymakers alike.
But with all this talk about AI's capabilities,
(09:02):
it's easy to get caught up in the hype.
So what are some of the limitations
we need to be aware of?
What can't AI do?
Well, one of the biggest limitations of AI
is that it's still very much dependent
on the data it's trained on.
So if the data is biased or incomplete,
the AI's output will reflect those biases.
So it's like that saying garbage in garbage out.
Exactly.
That's why it's so important to be mindful of data quality
(09:25):
and to ensure that the data we're feeding
into these AI systems is representative and unbiased.
And what about the ethical considerations?
We talked about data privacy earlier.
Are there any other ethical dilemmas we need to grapple with
as AI becomes more prevalent in research?
Yeah, I think transparency is a big one.
As researchers, we need to be open about how
we're using AI in our work.
(09:46):
And we need to be clear about the potential limitations
and biases of these tools.
We also need to be mindful of the potential impact of AI
on human jobs and livelihoods.
As AI becomes more sophisticated,
it's inevitable that some tasks that were previously done
by humans will be automated.
It sounds like we're heading into uncharted territory here.
There's a lot of excitement about the potential of AI,
(10:08):
but also a lot of uncertainty about the long-term
implications.
That's true.
But I think that's part of what makes this field so fascinating.
We're at the forefront of a technological revolution.
And we have the opportunity to shape how this technology is
developed and used.
We're at the forefront of a technological revolution.
And we have the opportunity to shape how this technology is
developed and used.
So what's the one thing?
(10:29):
If there was just one takeaway, you
hope our listeners get from this deep dive
into AI and qualitative research, what would it be?
Hmm.
That's a good question.
I think I would want them to come away with a sense of wonder
and curiosity.
AI is this incredibly powerful tool.
And it has the potential to completely transform
(10:50):
the way we understand the world around us.
But it's up to us to use it responsibly and ethically
and to always remember that human element.
That's what makes research so meaningful in the first place.
Well said.
And on that note, I think it's time to wrap up this deep dive.
We've covered a lot of ground today,
from the technical nuts and bolts of AI interviewers
to the broader societal and ethical implications
(11:12):
of this technology.
It's been a fascinating journey.
And I hope our listeners have surfaced
with a newfound appreciation for this evolving
world of qualitative research.
Until next time, keep diving deep
and keep those questions coming at us.
Popular Podcasts
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
Ridiculous History
History is beautiful, brutal and, often, ridiculous. Join Ben Bowlin and Noel Brown as they dive into some of the weirdest stories from across the span of human civilization in Ridiculous History, a podcast by iHeartRadio.