Ep. 7 Ghost Ship & The Lighthouse Keeper that Never Leaves: Lake MI Tales

Share your thoughts or send a request

Dive deep into Lake Michigan’s most chilling true stories: the Rouse Simmons “Christmas Tree Ship” that still haunts the waters after sinking in 1912, and Waugoshance Lighthouse where a prankster keeper’s ghost terrorizes visitors over a century later.

Explore with me these well-documented ghost sightings, archaeological discoveries, and ongoing paranormal activity on America’s deadliest Great Lake. 

Features the tragic tale of “Captain Santa” Herman Schuenemann and 17 lost souls, plus the infamous John Herman whose supernatural pranks continue to this day. Real history, real hauntings, real Lake Michigan maritime mysteries.

RESOURCES & REFERENCES:

•Wisconsin Historical Society Maritime Archaeology Reports

•Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum Archives

•National Archives Maritime Records (RG 21)

•Wisconsin Shipwreck Coast National Marine Sanctuary

•Rogers Street Fishing Village Museum, Two Rivers, WI

•Gulliver Historical Society Lighthouse Records

•“Michigan’s Haunted Lighthouses” by Dianna Higgs Stampfler

•“The Historic Christmas Tree Ship” by Rochelle Pennington

•Jason Asselin’s 2016 viral ghost ship footage

•Manitowoc County Historical Society collections

•Multiple documented eyewitness accounts (1912-present)

All historical facts verified through primary sources and maritime archaeological evidence.

Hello to all my fellow wanderers of the weird... the curious collectors of the uncanny... the strange and unusual souls who feel most at home in the shadows. Welcome to Creepy Shit.

Each week, I'll take you on a journey through genuinely haunted locations where the veil wears thin, unravel forgotten folklore that explains why that cold spot won't leave your bedroom corner, and share the essential knowledge.

No bullshit, no over-dramatic whispers, just the authentically creepy stories and spiritual survival skills you crave. Think of this as your paranormal field guide – equal parts campfire tales, cultural history, and "what to do when that shadow in the hallway definitely isn't your coat rack."

So come on, strange and unusual friends. Let's explore the unexplained together. New episodes weekly – for those who know the night has always held more truth than the day.

Follow on Instagram @creepy_shit_podcast for haunting images, paranormal evidence, and behind-the-scenes glimpses into the research behind each episode.