Ep.11 Asylum Point Park: Whispers from Lake Winnebago

Share your thoughts or send a request

We are visiting our First Asylum on the show today - On the tranquil shores of Lake Winnebago, families picnic and anglers cast their lines into peaceful waters. But beneath the serene surface of Asylum Point Park lies one of Wisconsin’s darkest chapters—a story of institutional failure, forgotten graves, and spirits that refuse to rest.

Join us as we explore the haunting history of the Northern Asylum for the Insane, which opened its doors in 1873 and became home to some of Wisconsin’s most troubled souls. From the attempted assassin of Theodore Roosevelt to the hundreds of unnamed patients buried in unmarked graves hidden in the woods, this is a place where tragedy and the unexplained intertwine.

We’ll dive into documented paranormal encounters, including reports of a spirit named Rufus who still roams Sherman Hall, and examine the scandals that rocked the institution—including the 1934 death that triggered a legislative investigation and led to 30 dismissals. But this isn’t just another abandoned asylum story. Unlike most institutions of its era, Winnebago Mental Health Institute never closed its doors, evolving from a place of suffering into a modern treatment facility that courageously displays its dark past.

Is Asylum Point truly haunted, or does the weight of historical trauma simply leave an imprint that sensitive souls can feel? We’ll explore the evidence and let you decide.

*Content Note: This episode deals with historical mental health treatment practices and institutional abuse. While approached respectfully, listener discretion is advised.*

References & Resources

Primary Historical Sources:

- Wisconsin Department of Health Services - Winnebago Mental Health Institute official history

- Winnebago County Parks Department historical documentation

- Legislative inquiry records, 1934 (Wisconsin State Archives)

Key Research Sources:

- “Tracking Down the Insane Asylum Cemetery in Oshkosh” - Wisconsin Frights

- Haunted Rooms America - Wisconsin’s Most Haunted Places survey

- Winnebago Mental Health Institute: Julaine Farrow Museum collection

- Wikipedia: Winnebago Mental Health Institute historical timeline

**Visit Asylum Point:**

Asylum Point Park & Lighthouse

3300 Sherman Road, Oshkosh, WI

Open daily 4am-11pm

**Julaine Farrow Museum:**

4150 Sherman Road, Oshkosh, WI

Open February-October, Thursdays 1:00-3:30pm

Call 920-235-4910 ext. 2311 for appointments

*PLEASE RESPECT ALL POSTED SIGNS AND REMEMBER THAT PARTS OF THE FACILITY ARE STILL AN ACTIVE MEDICAL CAMPUS.* 

Hello to all my fellow wanderers of the weird... the curious collectors of the uncanny... the strange and unusual souls who feel most at home in the shadows. Welcome to Creepy Shit.

Each week, I'll take you on a journey through genuinely haunted locations where the veil wears thin, unravel forgotten folklore that explains why that cold spot won't leave your bedroom corner, and share the essential knowledge.

No bullshit, no over-dramatic whispers, just the authentically creepy stories and spiritual survival skills you crave. Think of this as your paranormal field guide – equal parts campfire tales, cultural history, and "what to do when that shadow in the hallway definitely isn't your coat rack."

So come on, strange and unusual friends. Let's explore the unexplained together. New episodes weekly – for those who know the night has always held more truth than the day.

Follow on Instagram @creepy_shit_podcast for haunting images, paranormal evidence, and behind-the-scenes glimpses into the research behind each episode.