March 29, 2025 • 18 mins
In this episode of "The Deep Dive," we explore the intriguing concept of the Great Filter, a theory addressing the Fermi Paradox and the mystery of why we haven't encountered advanced extraterrestrial civilizations. We'll delve into the various stages of the Great Filter, from abiogenesis to advanced civilizations, and discuss whether this filter lies behind us or ahead of us. Join us as we examine potential explanations, including the Rare Earth Hypothesis, technological lifespan, and the possibility of self-destruction. We'll also explore ethical considerations, existential risks, and the implications for humanity's future. Tune in to understand the profound questions and challenges posed by the Great Filter and what it means for our place in the universe. 🌌🧬🚀
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
(00:00):
All right, so we've got a whole stack of articles here
(00:02):
all about the great filter,
and honestly, it's a bit of a mind trip.
The basic idea is that if the universe is so vast, right,
with billions of galaxies, trillions of stars,
statistically speaking,
we can't be the only intelligent life out there,
but we haven't found any concrete evidence.
(00:22):
So where is everybody?
Well, that's the Fermi paradox, isn't it?
Enrico Fermi, back in 1950,
just simply asked that.
Yeah. Where is everybody?
And it's a question that continues to haunt us today.
We've searched for radio signals,
looked for signs of advanced technology,
even sent our own messages out into the void.
Right. And still,
(00:43):
nothing definitive.
Yeah, it's almost like we're shouting
into this massive cosmic echo chamber,
and all we hear back is silence.
So what gives? Exactly.
Is there something preventing civilizations
from reaching a certain level
where they can communicate across the stars?
Well, that's where this theory
of the great filter comes in.
The great filter proposes
that somewhere on the long road,
(01:03):
from simple life to a space-faring civilization
that can communicate across the stars,
there's this hurdle that almost no one clears.
It might be a single catastrophic event
or a series of unbelievably improbable steps.
Either way, it's like a cosmic bottleneck
stopping most life from reaching
that point of galactic communication.
(01:26):
And here's the unsettling part.
We don't know where this filter is.
Right. Is it behind us,
meaning we're like the incredibly lucky ones
who somehow made it through?
Yeah. Or is it ahead of us,
meaning there's something terrible,
maybe even something we cause waiting to wipe us out?
It's the big question, isn't it?
Yeah, it is.
And to even begin to answer it,
we need to kind of lay out the steps
on this path to becoming a galactic civilization.
(01:48):
Okay. Each step is kind of a possible filter.
Right. It's a point where things could go really wrong.
Okay, so let's break it down a little bit.
The first hurdle, at least as I understand it,
is a biogenesis.
This is the transition from non-living matter
to living organisms.
Right.
And we still don't fully grasp
how that happened even here on Earth.
Yeah.
(02:09):
Was it just this one in a trillion chance occurrence?
It might've been.
If so, then maybe life itself is incredibly rare.
It's certainly a possibility.
Imagine a universe full of planets
that have all the right ingredients for life.
You know, water, organic molecules, a stable environment.
Yeah.
But if that jump from non-life to life
(02:30):
is just almost impossibly rare,
then most of those planets stay barren.
It's like having all the ingredients for a cake,
but never actually being able to bake it.
Yeah, exactly.
Okay, so let's say life does arise.
Yeah, okay.
What are some of the next potential filters
on this obstacle course?
Well, I mean, take a look at the history of life on Earth.
Yeah. Right.
It took billions of years to go
from those single-celled organisms
to complex, multicellular life.
(02:53):
Yeah.
Then there's the development of sexual reproduction,
a huge jump in genetic diversity.
Right.
Then you've got tool use, language, abstract thought.
I mean, each of these milestones is a potential filter.
Makes you realize just how many things had to go right
for us to even be here having this conversation.
Absolutely.
But even if a civilization makes it through
all those biological hurdles,
(03:13):
there's still that technological leap to contend with.
Yeah.
And that's where things get really interesting
and potentially scary.
Absolutely.
The development of technology,
especially really powerful technologies,
is seen as a prime contender for that great filter.
Okay.
Think about it.
I mean, we've already created weapons
capable of wiping ourselves out many times over.
(03:34):
Yeah.
And as we kind of delve deeper into things
like AI, genetic engineering,
the potential for catastrophic consequences
just keeps growing.
It's almost ironic, isn't it,
that the very tools that could allow us
to become a space-faring civilization
to reach out to other stars
could also be our undoing.
It's a tightrope walk, that's for sure.
It's a delicate balance
(03:55):
and one that perhaps many civilizations before us
have failed to maintain.
A sobering thought, isn't it?
It is.
And it leads us to the maybe even more unsettling question.
Where are WE on this timeline of potential filters?
Right.
Have we already passed the hardest parts?
Yeah.
Or is there some catastrophic event
(04:16):
waiting right around the corner?
Okay, so let's explore those two possibilities
a little bit.
First, let's look at the more optimistic
or maybe slightly lonely view.
Okay.
What if the great filter is behind us?
What does that say about humanity
and our place in the universe?
Well, if it's behind us,
it implies that we are one of the rare exceptions.
(04:38):
Maybe abiogenesis on Earth was a fluke,
you know, a one in a billion chance occurrence.
Right.
Or maybe we just got really, really lucky
and avoided some early hurdle that stopped everyone else.
Yeah.
Which just kind of slipped through.
It's almost like winning the cosmic lottery in that case.
Right.
But it also kind of puts a lot of pressure on us.
Oh yeah.
If we're one of the few that made it,
(04:58):
do we have a special responsibility
to spread life and intelligence throughout the universe?
Well, that's a question that philosophers
and ethicists are debating right now.
Yeah.
But let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Right.
And we haven't even left our solar system yet.
Right, we gotta learn to walk before we can run.
Exactly.
But it's still a very tantalizing thought, isn't it?
The universe is our oyster just waiting to be explored.
(05:21):
It is.
But what about the other possibility?
What if the great filter is still ahead of us?
Well, that's when things get a little more concerning.
Right.
If the filter is ahead of us,
it kind of implies that there's this universal challenge.
Yeah.
This hurdle that almost every civilization encounters
and fails to overcome.
Yeah.
(05:41):
And the potential culprits are both
numerous and a little terrifying.
Yeah, and we kind of touched on some of them earlier,
things like nuclear war,
runaway AI,
bioengineered pandemics.
Oh yeah, those are the things.
Those are all threats that we created ourselves.
It's like we're racing towards the finish line,
but we've booby-trapped the entire track along the way.
(06:04):
And it's not even just the things that we can foresee.
It could be unknown unknowns,
some cosmic dangers that we haven't even imagined yet.
Oh yeah.
A sudden gamma ray burst,
a rogue black hole passing through our solar system.
Right.
I mean, the UTIFS is full of potential hazards.
Or maybe, and this is a really chilling thought.
Yeah.
We become the filter
(06:25):
and not through some big catastrophic event,
but through like a gradual erosion
of our own values and principles.
Yeah.
What if we become so consumed with short-term gain,
with power and greed,
that we lose sight of the bigger picture,
our responsibility to ourselves,
to future generations, to the planet itself.
(06:48):
That's a really good point.
Yeah.
The filter doesn't have to be
some sudden explosion or a bang, right?
Right.
It could be more of a slow burn,
a gradual decline into self-destruction.
Right.
And the scariest part is that
it might not even be a conscious choice.
Yeah. Right.
It could just be a series of seemingly small decisions
that ultimately lead to our demise.
It's easy to get kind of swept up
(07:08):
in all this doom and gloom
when we're talking about the great filter.
It is heavy stuff.
But I think you have to admit,
humanity has a pretty remarkable track record of resilience.
Yeah, we do.
I mean, we've faced countless challenges
throughout our history.
We have.
And always seem to find a way to kind of bounce back.
That's true. Yeah.
And some of the articles you sent even pointed out
(07:29):
that life on Earth itself has already survived
multiple great filters, so to speak,
in the form of mass extinction events.
Oh, right.
Like take the Permian Triassic extinction, for example.
It wiped out almost all marine species.
Wow.
And most land vertebrates.
I mean, it was so bad, they call it the great dying.
It's hard to even wrap your head
(07:50):
around the stale of an event like that.
It is.
But life, you know, life found a way.
Life finds a way.
Adapted, evolved, and ultimately led
to the incredible biodiversity we see today.
So it's really a testament to the tenacity of life.
It's good.
Even in the face of those seemingly impossible odds.
You know, and that might even suggest that this resilience,
(08:10):
this ability to adapt and overcome,
that's a key characteristic of intelligent life.
Oh, interesting.
It's not just about intelligence alone.
It's about grit.
Yeah.
That will to survive.
Yeah, that drive.
That drive to thrive.
Yeah, I like that.
Keep going no matter what.
Yeah, so maybe that's a point in our favor
when we're thinking about this great filter, right?
(08:32):
Could be.
We've got that inherent drive,
that ability to learn from our mistakes,
adapt to changing circumstances,
and ultimately find a way forward.
Yeah, but as you mentioned before,
the challenges we face now,
they're a little bit different.
Yeah, how so?
Well, they're self-inflicted.
Oh, right.
Yeah, we're not dealing with like random asteroids
(08:53):
or volcanoes anymore.
Right.
We're dealing with the fallout of our own action.
Yeah.
Our own technology.
It's like we've created these problems for ourselves.
Yeah, a whole new level of responsibility,
a test unlike any we faced before.
So let's dig into some specific examples
of potential filter events,
things that could realistically happen in our lifetime even.
(09:13):
Okay.
I mean, one that pops into my head
and it seems like one that captures people's imaginations
is runaway AI.
It's a classic, isn't it?
It is.
I mean, we've seen it in science fiction for years.
Oh yeah, for decades.
But it's starting to feel more and more relevant.
Oh, absolutely.
Especially as our AI capabilities
keep growing at this crazy rate.
Yeah, exactly.
(09:34):
And the core concern isn't even necessarily
about machines becoming evil
in that kind of Hollywood sense.
No.
It's more about what happens when we create AI
that's way smarter than us.
But their goals don't quite align with ours.
Yeah, it's like that old saying
about the genie in the bottle.
(09:54):
Oh, yeah.
You gotta be careful what you wish for.
Right, because you just might get it.
Exactly, and you might not like the consequences.
And it's not like some evil genius
has to program in those harmful goals.
No, not at all.
It just arises these unintended side effects.
Right, it's more about misaligned objectives than malice.
And the more powerful the AI,
the worse those consequences could be.
(10:15):
That's a little scary.
It is a little scary.
That's why there's a whole bunch of people
researching AI safety and alignment.
Uh-huh, okay.
Trying to make sure these super smart systems
stay under our control and actually share our values.
So it's not all doom and gloom with AI.
Oh, not at all.
There's a chance we can kind of harness
the power of it for good.
I think so.
While still being aware of the risks.
(10:36):
Right, it's all about finding that balance.
So AI is a double-edged sword.
Yeah, powerful, but we need to use it carefully.
Great benefits and great risks.
Exactly, it all comes down to how we develop it
and how we use it.
Okay, so we talked about AI.
What about another potential filter we mentioned?
Yeah.
Global pandemics.
Oh yeah.
I mean, we just had a very real reminder.
We did.
(10:56):
Of how disruptive those can be.
Yeah.
How devastating.
For sure.
And it seems like this interconnectedness of the world
with everyone traveling all the time.
Yeah, all the time.
Big cities.
Dense populations.
It makes us more vulnerable.
It really does.
Than ever before.
Yeah, I mean, diseases can spread across the entire planet
in a matter of hours.
Right, it's incredible.
(11:17):
And the more we push into these wild areas,
the more likely we are to run into new things.
Yeah.
Pathogens that our bodies just aren't ready for.
Yeah, it's like we're playing this high stakes game of chance
with these tiny little threats.
We are.
And the stakes just keep getting higher.
They do, and you know, it's not just about bad luck either.
Okay.
Being ready, investing in public health.
(11:38):
Right.
Having systems in place that can catch things early.
Yeah.
And working together internationally
so we can act fast when something does happen.
So it's really about acknowledging those risks.
Exactly.
And being prepared.
Yep, learning from what's happened in the past.
Yeah.
And taking steps to prevent it from happening again.
All right, so we've covered AI, pandemics.
(11:59):
What about something totally out of our control?
Like what?
An asteroid impact.
Oh, the classics.
Yeah, the dinosaur scenario.
Wipes out everything.
Is there anything we can even do
to protect ourselves from that?
You know, there is, we're actually making good progress
in planetary defense these days.
Oh really?
Yeah, like that dark mission.
They smashed a spacecraft right into an asteroid.
(12:21):
Wow.
To try and knock it off course.
It's like something out of a movie.
It is, except it's real.
And it worked.
So we're not just sitting here hoping for the best.
Nope, not anymore.
We've got these amazing telescopes out there
hunting for anything that might be a threat.
Oh wow.
And we're building spacecraft that can actually
nudge an asteroid away if we need to.
(12:43):
It's pretty incredible when you think about it.
It is.
I mean, even with these existential threats looming,
we're finding ways to fight back,
protect ourselves, take control of our destiny.
You know, I think that's maybe the key
to getting past this great filter.
What do you mean?
It's not just luck, it's making a choice.
Consciously evolving.
Right.
We need to shape our future, not just wait
(13:05):
and see what happens.
I like that, being proactive instead of reactive.
Exactly.
We've been talking about some pretty intense stuff.
We have.
This whole great filter thing,
trying to understand why, you know.
Why we haven't found anyone else out there.
Exactly, even though the odds suggest we should have.
Right, it's a real head scratcher.
It is, and it leads to some pretty wild possibilities.
(13:26):
Yeah, like maybe we're totally alone.
Or maybe something terrible is waiting for us.
It's a bit daunting, isn't it?
Yeah.
It's the idea of some universal barrier or hurdle
that almost every civilization trips over.
It is, it makes you think about how fragile we might be.
Yeah.
But through all of this,
I keep coming back to something you said earlier.
What's that?
This conscious evolution idea.
(13:48):
Ah, yes.
It's a little bit tricky for me.
What does that actually look like?
Right.
Like how do we consciously evolve as a species
to avoid, you know.
Becoming another cosmic graveyard statistic.
Yeah, exactly.
Well, it's a big question.
Yeah.
There's no easy answer.
Right.
But I think it starts with a shift in perspective.
Okay.
Recognizing that the choices we make,
(14:09):
both individually and as a society,
they have consequences that go way beyond just us.
Right.
It's about understanding
that we're connected to everything.
Okay.
To each other, to our planet, to the universe itself.
So it's not just about like technological advancements
or scientific breakthroughs.
No, bigger than that.
It's more like a fundamental understanding of, you know.
(14:31):
Our place in the cosmos.
Yeah, recognizing that we're not separate
from this web of life.
We're a part of it.
We're woven right in.
Exactly, it's about moving past
that selfish, short-sighted view.
Yeah.
And embracing something more holistic.
Okay.
Something that values cooperation over competition.
You know. Right.
Sustainability over explication.
(14:52):
Thinking about the long-term.
Yeah, the long game.
Not just the immediate gratification.
Exactly.
It sounds almost like spiritual.
Maybe it is.
Like some kind of cosmic awakening.
It could be.
You know, this whole idea of the great filter.
Even if it's just a theory.
Yeah.
It can be like a catalyst for this kind of awakening.
It forces us to ask those big questions
(15:13):
about why we're here.
Right, what's our purpose?
What do we value?
What kind of legacy do we wanna leave behind?
It's like a wake-up call from the universe.
Yeah, urging us to take responsibility for our future.
As a species, not just as individuals.
And maybe, just maybe, this shift in consciousness,
this realization that we're all connected.
(15:34):
Maybe that's the key to getting past this filter.
Could be.
It's not about brute force.
It's not about technology.
It's on something deeper.
It's about wisdom, compassion.
Recognizing that our fate is tied
to the fate of everything else out there.
Absolutely.
Okay, so let's get down to brass tacks here.
Okay.
So here's some things we can actually do
(15:56):
to embody this conscious evolution.
Yeah, how do we take these big ideas
and actually put them into practice?
Yeah.
I think it starts with awareness.
Okay.
Just realizing that everything is connected.
Right.
The things we buy, the way we treat each other,
how we interact with the planet.
Yeah.
It all matters.
So it's about being mindful,
being intentional with our choices.
Exactly, understanding that even those small actions
(16:19):
can have a ripple effect.
It's not just about me.
It's about the bigger picture.
It's about the whole web.
Okay, so what else?
Well, we can support sustainable practices, right?
Yeah.
Advocate for social justice.
Through peace and understanding.
Exactly.
Invest in education, scientific research.
Exploration.
Yeah.
Not just for profit, but for the sake of knowledge,
(16:40):
for the betterment of humanity.
It sounds like a lot.
It is a lot.
It's changing our entire way of thinking.
But you're saying this isn't just some idealistic dream.
No, it's, yeah.
This is essential for our survival.
I think so, you know?
This great filter, whether it's real or not,
it's a reminder that we're not just passengers
on this planet with a crew.
(17:01):
Yeah.
We can steer the ship.
We can navigate the dangers.
We can choose where we go.
I like that.
That's a good way to put it.
We have the power to create a future
worthy of our place in the universe.
So as we kind of wrap up this deep dive
into the great filter,
what's the one thing you want our listeners
to take away from this?
I want them to remember that they are part
(17:23):
of something much bigger than themselves.
Okay.
They're citizens of the universe,
connected to every other living being.
Right.
Connected to the cosmos itself.
Embrace that connection.
Yeah, cherish it.
Let it guide your actions.
Exactly.
That's a beautiful message.
Thank you.
One of hope, responsibility, the potential we all have.
To make a real difference.
(17:44):
And who knows, maybe someday, way down the line,
if we make it past this great filter,
maybe we'll be the ones sending out the signals.
Yeah.
Welcoming other civilizations into the galactic community.
Showing them that it's possible.
Proving that intelligence and compassion can win out.
And conscious evolution.
That's a legacy worth fighting for.
It is.
Well, on that note,
(18:04):
we'll end our exploration of the great filter here.
It's been a journey.
But remember, the conversation doesn't end here.
Keep asking those big questions.
Keep learning.
Keep looking up at the stars.
With wonder.
With a sense of possibility.
And a sense of responsibility.
Until next time, keep diving deep.
All right, so we've got a whole stack of articles here
(00:02):
all about the great filter,
and honestly, it's a bit of a mind trip.
The basic idea is that if the universe is so vast, right,
with billions of galaxies, trillions of stars,
statistically speaking,
we can't be the only intelligent life out there,
but we haven't found any concrete evidence.
(00:22):
So where is everybody?
Well, that's the Fermi paradox, isn't it?
Enrico Fermi, back in 1950,
just simply asked that.
Yeah. Where is everybody?
And it's a question that continues to haunt us today.
We've searched for radio signals,
looked for signs of advanced technology,
even sent our own messages out into the void.
Right. And still,
(00:43):
nothing definitive.
Yeah, it's almost like we're shouting
into this massive cosmic echo chamber,
and all we hear back is silence.
So what gives? Exactly.
Is there something preventing civilizations
from reaching a certain level
where they can communicate across the stars?
Well, that's where this theory
of the great filter comes in.
The great filter proposes
that somewhere on the long road,
(01:03):
from simple life to a space-faring civilization
that can communicate across the stars,
there's this hurdle that almost no one clears.
It might be a single catastrophic event
or a series of unbelievably improbable steps.
Either way, it's like a cosmic bottleneck
stopping most life from reaching
that point of galactic communication.
(01:26):
And here's the unsettling part.
We don't know where this filter is.
Right. Is it behind us,
meaning we're like the incredibly lucky ones
who somehow made it through?
Yeah. Or is it ahead of us,
meaning there's something terrible,
maybe even something we cause waiting to wipe us out?
It's the big question, isn't it?
Yeah, it is.
And to even begin to answer it,
we need to kind of lay out the steps
on this path to becoming a galactic civilization.
(01:48):
Okay. Each step is kind of a possible filter.
Right. It's a point where things could go really wrong.
Okay, so let's break it down a little bit.
The first hurdle, at least as I understand it,
is a biogenesis.
This is the transition from non-living matter
to living organisms.
Right.
And we still don't fully grasp
how that happened even here on Earth.
Yeah.
(02:09):
Was it just this one in a trillion chance occurrence?
It might've been.
If so, then maybe life itself is incredibly rare.
It's certainly a possibility.
Imagine a universe full of planets
that have all the right ingredients for life.
You know, water, organic molecules, a stable environment.
Yeah.
But if that jump from non-life to life
(02:30):
is just almost impossibly rare,
then most of those planets stay barren.
It's like having all the ingredients for a cake,
but never actually being able to bake it.
Yeah, exactly.
Okay, so let's say life does arise.
Yeah, okay.
What are some of the next potential filters
on this obstacle course?
Well, I mean, take a look at the history of life on Earth.
Yeah. Right.
It took billions of years to go
from those single-celled organisms
to complex, multicellular life.
(02:53):
Yeah.
Then there's the development of sexual reproduction,
a huge jump in genetic diversity.
Right.
Then you've got tool use, language, abstract thought.
I mean, each of these milestones is a potential filter.
Makes you realize just how many things had to go right
for us to even be here having this conversation.
Absolutely.
But even if a civilization makes it through
all those biological hurdles,
(03:13):
there's still that technological leap to contend with.
Yeah.
And that's where things get really interesting
and potentially scary.
Absolutely.
The development of technology,
especially really powerful technologies,
is seen as a prime contender for that great filter.
Okay.
Think about it.
I mean, we've already created weapons
capable of wiping ourselves out many times over.
(03:34):
Yeah.
And as we kind of delve deeper into things
like AI, genetic engineering,
the potential for catastrophic consequences
just keeps growing.
It's almost ironic, isn't it,
that the very tools that could allow us
to become a space-faring civilization
to reach out to other stars
could also be our undoing.
It's a tightrope walk, that's for sure.
It's a delicate balance
(03:55):
and one that perhaps many civilizations before us
have failed to maintain.
A sobering thought, isn't it?
It is.
And it leads us to the maybe even more unsettling question.
Where are WE on this timeline of potential filters?
Right.
Have we already passed the hardest parts?
Yeah.
Or is there some catastrophic event
(04:16):
waiting right around the corner?
Okay, so let's explore those two possibilities
a little bit.
First, let's look at the more optimistic
or maybe slightly lonely view.
Okay.
What if the great filter is behind us?
What does that say about humanity
and our place in the universe?
Well, if it's behind us,
it implies that we are one of the rare exceptions.
(04:38):
Maybe abiogenesis on Earth was a fluke,
you know, a one in a billion chance occurrence.
Right.
Or maybe we just got really, really lucky
and avoided some early hurdle that stopped everyone else.
Yeah.
Which just kind of slipped through.
It's almost like winning the cosmic lottery in that case.
Right.
But it also kind of puts a lot of pressure on us.
Oh yeah.
If we're one of the few that made it,
(04:58):
do we have a special responsibility
to spread life and intelligence throughout the universe?
Well, that's a question that philosophers
and ethicists are debating right now.
Yeah.
But let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Right.
And we haven't even left our solar system yet.
Right, we gotta learn to walk before we can run.
Exactly.
But it's still a very tantalizing thought, isn't it?
The universe is our oyster just waiting to be explored.
(05:21):
It is.
But what about the other possibility?
What if the great filter is still ahead of us?
Well, that's when things get a little more concerning.
Right.
If the filter is ahead of us,
it kind of implies that there's this universal challenge.
Yeah.
This hurdle that almost every civilization encounters
and fails to overcome.
Yeah.
(05:41):
And the potential culprits are both
numerous and a little terrifying.
Yeah, and we kind of touched on some of them earlier,
things like nuclear war,
runaway AI,
bioengineered pandemics.
Oh yeah, those are the things.
Those are all threats that we created ourselves.
It's like we're racing towards the finish line,
but we've booby-trapped the entire track along the way.
(06:04):
And it's not even just the things that we can foresee.
It could be unknown unknowns,
some cosmic dangers that we haven't even imagined yet.
Oh yeah.
A sudden gamma ray burst,
a rogue black hole passing through our solar system.
Right.
I mean, the UTIFS is full of potential hazards.
Or maybe, and this is a really chilling thought.
Yeah.
We become the filter
(06:25):
and not through some big catastrophic event,
but through like a gradual erosion
of our own values and principles.
Yeah.
What if we become so consumed with short-term gain,
with power and greed,
that we lose sight of the bigger picture,
our responsibility to ourselves,
to future generations, to the planet itself.
(06:48):
That's a really good point.
Yeah.
The filter doesn't have to be
some sudden explosion or a bang, right?
Right.
It could be more of a slow burn,
a gradual decline into self-destruction.
Right.
And the scariest part is that
it might not even be a conscious choice.
Yeah. Right.
It could just be a series of seemingly small decisions
that ultimately lead to our demise.
It's easy to get kind of swept up
(07:08):
in all this doom and gloom
when we're talking about the great filter.
It is heavy stuff.
But I think you have to admit,
humanity has a pretty remarkable track record of resilience.
Yeah, we do.
I mean, we've faced countless challenges
throughout our history.
We have.
And always seem to find a way to kind of bounce back.
That's true. Yeah.
And some of the articles you sent even pointed out
(07:29):
that life on Earth itself has already survived
multiple great filters, so to speak,
in the form of mass extinction events.
Oh, right.
Like take the Permian Triassic extinction, for example.
It wiped out almost all marine species.
Wow.
And most land vertebrates.
I mean, it was so bad, they call it the great dying.
It's hard to even wrap your head
(07:50):
around the stale of an event like that.
It is.
But life, you know, life found a way.
Life finds a way.
Adapted, evolved, and ultimately led
to the incredible biodiversity we see today.
So it's really a testament to the tenacity of life.
It's good.
Even in the face of those seemingly impossible odds.
You know, and that might even suggest that this resilience,
(08:10):
this ability to adapt and overcome,
that's a key characteristic of intelligent life.
Oh, interesting.
It's not just about intelligence alone.
It's about grit.
Yeah.
That will to survive.
Yeah, that drive.
That drive to thrive.
Yeah, I like that.
Keep going no matter what.
Yeah, so maybe that's a point in our favor
when we're thinking about this great filter, right?
(08:32):
Could be.
We've got that inherent drive,
that ability to learn from our mistakes,
adapt to changing circumstances,
and ultimately find a way forward.
Yeah, but as you mentioned before,
the challenges we face now,
they're a little bit different.
Yeah, how so?
Well, they're self-inflicted.
Oh, right.
Yeah, we're not dealing with like random asteroids
(08:53):
or volcanoes anymore.
Right.
We're dealing with the fallout of our own action.
Yeah.
Our own technology.
It's like we've created these problems for ourselves.
Yeah, a whole new level of responsibility,
a test unlike any we faced before.
So let's dig into some specific examples
of potential filter events,
things that could realistically happen in our lifetime even.
(09:13):
Okay.
I mean, one that pops into my head
and it seems like one that captures people's imaginations
is runaway AI.
It's a classic, isn't it?
It is.
I mean, we've seen it in science fiction for years.
Oh yeah, for decades.
But it's starting to feel more and more relevant.
Oh, absolutely.
Especially as our AI capabilities
keep growing at this crazy rate.
Yeah, exactly.
(09:34):
And the core concern isn't even necessarily
about machines becoming evil
in that kind of Hollywood sense.
No.
It's more about what happens when we create AI
that's way smarter than us.
But their goals don't quite align with ours.
Yeah, it's like that old saying
about the genie in the bottle.
(09:54):
Oh, yeah.
You gotta be careful what you wish for.
Right, because you just might get it.
Exactly, and you might not like the consequences.
And it's not like some evil genius
has to program in those harmful goals.
No, not at all.
It just arises these unintended side effects.
Right, it's more about misaligned objectives than malice.
And the more powerful the AI,
the worse those consequences could be.
(10:15):
That's a little scary.
It is a little scary.
That's why there's a whole bunch of people
researching AI safety and alignment.
Uh-huh, okay.
Trying to make sure these super smart systems
stay under our control and actually share our values.
So it's not all doom and gloom with AI.
Oh, not at all.
There's a chance we can kind of harness
the power of it for good.
I think so.
While still being aware of the risks.
(10:36):
Right, it's all about finding that balance.
So AI is a double-edged sword.
Yeah, powerful, but we need to use it carefully.
Great benefits and great risks.
Exactly, it all comes down to how we develop it
and how we use it.
Okay, so we talked about AI.
What about another potential filter we mentioned?
Yeah.
Global pandemics.
Oh yeah.
I mean, we just had a very real reminder.
We did.
(10:56):
Of how disruptive those can be.
Yeah.
How devastating.
For sure.
And it seems like this interconnectedness of the world
with everyone traveling all the time.
Yeah, all the time.
Big cities.
Dense populations.
It makes us more vulnerable.
It really does.
Than ever before.
Yeah, I mean, diseases can spread across the entire planet
in a matter of hours.
Right, it's incredible.
(11:17):
And the more we push into these wild areas,
the more likely we are to run into new things.
Yeah.
Pathogens that our bodies just aren't ready for.
Yeah, it's like we're playing this high stakes game of chance
with these tiny little threats.
We are.
And the stakes just keep getting higher.
They do, and you know, it's not just about bad luck either.
Okay.
Being ready, investing in public health.
(11:38):
Right.
Having systems in place that can catch things early.
Yeah.
And working together internationally
so we can act fast when something does happen.
So it's really about acknowledging those risks.
Exactly.
And being prepared.
Yep, learning from what's happened in the past.
Yeah.
And taking steps to prevent it from happening again.
All right, so we've covered AI, pandemics.
(11:59):
What about something totally out of our control?
Like what?
An asteroid impact.
Oh, the classics.
Yeah, the dinosaur scenario.
Wipes out everything.
Is there anything we can even do
to protect ourselves from that?
You know, there is, we're actually making good progress
in planetary defense these days.
Oh really?
Yeah, like that dark mission.
They smashed a spacecraft right into an asteroid.
(12:21):
Wow.
To try and knock it off course.
It's like something out of a movie.
It is, except it's real.
And it worked.
So we're not just sitting here hoping for the best.
Nope, not anymore.
We've got these amazing telescopes out there
hunting for anything that might be a threat.
Oh wow.
And we're building spacecraft that can actually
nudge an asteroid away if we need to.
(12:43):
It's pretty incredible when you think about it.
It is.
I mean, even with these existential threats looming,
we're finding ways to fight back,
protect ourselves, take control of our destiny.
You know, I think that's maybe the key
to getting past this great filter.
What do you mean?
It's not just luck, it's making a choice.
Consciously evolving.
Right.
We need to shape our future, not just wait
(13:05):
and see what happens.
I like that, being proactive instead of reactive.
Exactly.
We've been talking about some pretty intense stuff.
We have.
This whole great filter thing,
trying to understand why, you know.
Why we haven't found anyone else out there.
Exactly, even though the odds suggest we should have.
Right, it's a real head scratcher.
It is, and it leads to some pretty wild possibilities.
(13:26):
Yeah, like maybe we're totally alone.
Or maybe something terrible is waiting for us.
It's a bit daunting, isn't it?
Yeah.
It's the idea of some universal barrier or hurdle
that almost every civilization trips over.
It is, it makes you think about how fragile we might be.
Yeah.
But through all of this,
I keep coming back to something you said earlier.
What's that?
This conscious evolution idea.
(13:48):
Ah, yes.
It's a little bit tricky for me.
What does that actually look like?
Right.
Like how do we consciously evolve as a species
to avoid, you know.
Becoming another cosmic graveyard statistic.
Yeah, exactly.
Well, it's a big question.
Yeah.
There's no easy answer.
Right.
But I think it starts with a shift in perspective.
Okay.
Recognizing that the choices we make,
(14:09):
both individually and as a society,
they have consequences that go way beyond just us.
Right.
It's about understanding
that we're connected to everything.
Okay.
To each other, to our planet, to the universe itself.
So it's not just about like technological advancements
or scientific breakthroughs.
No, bigger than that.
It's more like a fundamental understanding of, you know.
(14:31):
Our place in the cosmos.
Yeah, recognizing that we're not separate
from this web of life.
We're a part of it.
We're woven right in.
Exactly, it's about moving past
that selfish, short-sighted view.
Yeah.
And embracing something more holistic.
Okay.
Something that values cooperation over competition.
You know. Right.
Sustainability over explication.
(14:52):
Thinking about the long-term.
Yeah, the long game.
Not just the immediate gratification.
Exactly.
It sounds almost like spiritual.
Maybe it is.
Like some kind of cosmic awakening.
It could be.
You know, this whole idea of the great filter.
Even if it's just a theory.
Yeah.
It can be like a catalyst for this kind of awakening.
It forces us to ask those big questions
(15:13):
about why we're here.
Right, what's our purpose?
What do we value?
What kind of legacy do we wanna leave behind?
It's like a wake-up call from the universe.
Yeah, urging us to take responsibility for our future.
As a species, not just as individuals.
And maybe, just maybe, this shift in consciousness,
this realization that we're all connected.
(15:34):
Maybe that's the key to getting past this filter.
Could be.
It's not about brute force.
It's not about technology.
It's on something deeper.
It's about wisdom, compassion.
Recognizing that our fate is tied
to the fate of everything else out there.
Absolutely.
Okay, so let's get down to brass tacks here.
Okay.
So here's some things we can actually do
(15:56):
to embody this conscious evolution.
Yeah, how do we take these big ideas
and actually put them into practice?
Yeah.
I think it starts with awareness.
Okay.
Just realizing that everything is connected.
Right.
The things we buy, the way we treat each other,
how we interact with the planet.
Yeah.
It all matters.
So it's about being mindful,
being intentional with our choices.
Exactly, understanding that even those small actions
(16:19):
can have a ripple effect.
It's not just about me.
It's about the bigger picture.
It's about the whole web.
Okay, so what else?
Well, we can support sustainable practices, right?
Yeah.
Advocate for social justice.
Through peace and understanding.
Exactly.
Invest in education, scientific research.
Exploration.
Yeah.
Not just for profit, but for the sake of knowledge,
(16:40):
for the betterment of humanity.
It sounds like a lot.
It is a lot.
It's changing our entire way of thinking.
But you're saying this isn't just some idealistic dream.
No, it's, yeah.
This is essential for our survival.
I think so, you know?
This great filter, whether it's real or not,
it's a reminder that we're not just passengers
on this planet with a crew.
(17:01):
Yeah.
We can steer the ship.
We can navigate the dangers.
We can choose where we go.
I like that.
That's a good way to put it.
We have the power to create a future
worthy of our place in the universe.
So as we kind of wrap up this deep dive
into the great filter,
what's the one thing you want our listeners
to take away from this?
I want them to remember that they are part
(17:23):
of something much bigger than themselves.
Okay.
They're citizens of the universe,
connected to every other living being.
Right.
Connected to the cosmos itself.
Embrace that connection.
Yeah, cherish it.
Let it guide your actions.
Exactly.
That's a beautiful message.
Thank you.
One of hope, responsibility, the potential we all have.
To make a real difference.
(17:44):
And who knows, maybe someday, way down the line,
if we make it past this great filter,
maybe we'll be the ones sending out the signals.
Yeah.
Welcoming other civilizations into the galactic community.
Showing them that it's possible.
Proving that intelligence and compassion can win out.
And conscious evolution.
That's a legacy worth fighting for.
It is.
Well, on that note,
(18:04):
we'll end our exploration of the great filter here.
It's been a journey.
But remember, the conversation doesn't end here.
Keep asking those big questions.
Keep learning.
Keep looking up at the stars.
With wonder.
With a sense of possibility.
And a sense of responsibility.
Until next time, keep diving deep.
Popular Podcasts
Boysober
Have you ever wondered what life might be like if you stopped worrying about being wanted, and focused on understanding what you actually want? That was the question Hope Woodard asked herself after a string of situationships inspired her to take a break from sex and dating. She went "boysober," a personal concept that sparked a global movement among women looking to prioritize themselves over men. Now, Hope is looking to expand the ways we explore our relationship to relationships. Taking a bold, unfiltered look into modern love, romance, and self-discovery, Boysober will dive into messy stories about dating, sex, love, friendship, and breaking generational patterns—all with humor, vulnerability, and a fresh perspective.
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com