September 26, 2025 • 81 mins
What happens when a Protestant youth pastor experiences three devastating church splits and starts questioning everything he believed about Christianity? In this explosive episode, we sit down with Peter Pelicaan, a former Protestant minister turned Catholic deacon, who reveals the shocking journey that led him to abandon his Protestant faith. WHAT YOU'LL DISCOVER:
The real reason behind Protestant church splits that church leaders won't tell you Why Peter believes the Catholic Church is the "original" Christianity The controversial prayer practice most Protestants reject (and why Catholics embrace it) What really happens during Catholic mass that Protestants don't understand The theological bombshell that made Peter question his entire ministry Why Protestant "Scripture alone" doctrine might be fundamentally flawed The unity crisis plaguing modern Christianity
EXPLOSIVE REVELATIONS: Peter doesn't hold back as he exposes the structural problems he witnessed in Protestant churches, from pastoral authority issues to theological inconsistencies. He shares intimate details about his crisis of faith, the backlash he faced from his community, and why he believes Catholics have preserved something Protestants lost centuries ago. This isn't your typical interfaith dialogue - it's a raw, honest conversation about religious conversion, church politics, and the price of following your convictions. Whether you're Protestant, Catholic, or just curious about Christianity, this episode will challenge everything you think you know about church unity and biblical interpretation. WARNING: Some viewers may find Peter's critiques of Protestant theology controversial. We encourage respectful dialogue in the comments.
TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 - Introduction & Peter's Background 15:30 - The Three Church Splits That Changed Everything 28:45 - Why He Started Reading Catholic Philosophy 42:10 - The Eucharist Revelation That Shocked Him 58:20 - Addressing Protestant Misconceptions About Catholics 1:12:35 - The Authority Crisis in Protestant Churches 1:18:50 - Prayer for Unity
CONNECT WITH US: Subscribe for more bold conversations about faith, creativity, and culture Instagram: @kngdmcrvs Website: www.kingdomcreatives.com.au
#CatholicProtestant #ChurchUnity #ReligiousConversion #ChristianDebate #FaithJourney
The real reason behind Protestant church splits that church leaders won't tell you Why Peter believes the Catholic Church is the "original" Christianity The controversial prayer practice most Protestants reject (and why Catholics embrace it) What really happens during Catholic mass that Protestants don't understand The theological bombshell that made Peter question his entire ministry Why Protestant "Scripture alone" doctrine might be fundamentally flawed The unity crisis plaguing modern Christianity
EXPLOSIVE REVELATIONS: Peter doesn't hold back as he exposes the structural problems he witnessed in Protestant churches, from pastoral authority issues to theological inconsistencies. He shares intimate details about his crisis of faith, the backlash he faced from his community, and why he believes Catholics have preserved something Protestants lost centuries ago. This isn't your typical interfaith dialogue - it's a raw, honest conversation about religious conversion, church politics, and the price of following your convictions. Whether you're Protestant, Catholic, or just curious about Christianity, this episode will challenge everything you think you know about church unity and biblical interpretation. WARNING: Some viewers may find Peter's critiques of Protestant theology controversial. We encourage respectful dialogue in the comments.
TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 - Introduction & Peter's Background 15:30 - The Three Church Splits That Changed Everything 28:45 - Why He Started Reading Catholic Philosophy 42:10 - The Eucharist Revelation That Shocked Him 58:20 - Addressing Protestant Misconceptions About Catholics 1:12:35 - The Authority Crisis in Protestant Churches 1:18:50 - Prayer for Unity
CONNECT WITH US: Subscribe for more bold conversations about faith, creativity, and culture Instagram: @kngdmcrvs Website: www.kingdomcreatives.com.au
#CatholicProtestant #ChurchUnity #ReligiousConversion #ChristianDebate #FaithJourney
Mark as Played
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.