Dating Is Nuts

Dating Is Nuts

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent 10 years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories. Adapted from For Love Or Peanut Butter, the beloved dating column on Slackjaw, Dating Is Nuts = Nobody Wants This + How I Met Your Mother, only in a first person podcast performed by a comedian that feels like an audiobook but in short, deliciously bingeable episodes. .

Episodes

July 2, 2025 9 mins

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories. On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly goes on her third and fourth dates with Andrew. Things are getting serious, right? Her head, heart, and mom are all on board. Now she just needs her libido to join the squad.This is the tenth full episode of season 2 (#210) Join us on Patreon for behind the scenes making the podc...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.

On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly details her second "not a date" hangout with surfer dude Dex, and how she has feelings for him even though she shouldn't...This is the ninth full episode of season 2 (#209)

Join the Patreon to become an OG Lover Nutter! 

https://patreon.com/kellyshanley?utm_medium=unknown&utm_so...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.

On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly goes on a second date with Carter that pales in comparison to the first. Why did the vibes die mid date?!

This is the eighth full episode of season 2 (#208)SHOW NOTES:Based on the beloved dating column For Love Or Peanut Butter, Dating Is Nuts stars comedian Kelly Shanley recount...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.

On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly hopes to go on her second date with her dreamy childhood crush, Brooks, who keeps her hopes up with daily deep talk phone calls.

This is the seventh full episode of season 2 (#207)

SHOW NOTES:

Based on the beloved syndicated dating column from Slackjaw; For Love Or Peanut Butter, Dat...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.

On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly shares her sweet second date with Andrew, a lake front sunset viewing. Too bad Kelly's neuroses won't just relax and let her enjoy herself.This is the sixth full episode of season 2 (#206)


SHOW NOTES:

Based on the beloved syndicated dating column from Slackjaw; For Love...

Mark as Played
April 23, 2025 12 mins

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.


On this episode of the Dating Is Nuts podcast, Kelly introduces suitor number 4 from her accidental summer of love Dex. Dick pics may have played a surprising role in their courtship...

This is the fifth full episode of season 2 (#205)


SHOW NOTES:

Based on the beloved syndicated dating column from Slackjaw; For Love Or Peanut Butter,...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories.


On this episode of the FLOPB dating podcast, Kelly shares her first date with suitor number three, Carter. Hard to believe what a great wingwoman her neighborhood bear turned out to be!

This is the fourth full episode of season 2 (#204)


SHOW NOTES:

Based on the syndicated column of the same name, FLOPB stars comedian Kelly Sh...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who spent ten years on the dating apps in LA. These are her stories. On this episode of the FLOPB dating podcast, Kelly can't believe it when she runs into the dreamboat from her childhood, and he's actually interested in her!This is the third full episode of season 2 (#203) SHOW NOTES:Based on the syndicated column of the same name, FLOPB stars comedian Kelly Shanley recounting some of her worst da...

Mark as Played

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic who's been living in LA for 16 years and spent 10 of them on the dating apps.

On this episode of the FLOPB dating podcast, Kelly shares how the universe seemed to have a clear favorite of the four guys she dated that summer...

For Love Or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating podcast in which a seemingly eligible (yet perpetually single) woman finally delves into the WHY and the HO...

Mark as Played
February 26, 2025 12 mins

On this episode of the FLOPB dating podcast, Kelly introduces four guys she dated in the same summer. Follow along for the How I Met Your Mother style reveal of which one she ends up with!

SHOW NOTES:

Based on the syndicated column of the same name, FLOPB stars comedian Kelly Shanley recounting some of her worst dates, heartbreaks, and lessons learned during her 10 years of being single in LA. An endless supply of dating app disaster...

Mark as Played
February 14, 2025 4 mins

After a healthy hiatus, your favorite dating podcast is BACK! Season 2 is getting a makeover for its February 26th, 2025 debut. Not only are we starting a new adventure that results in actual romance (shocking but true), but we're also adding video!

If you're new here... for Love Or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating podcast in which a seemingly eligible (yet perpetually single) woman finally delves into the WHY a...

Mark as Played

This week on FLOPB dating pod, we're talking about height and dating. So controversial! Kelly shares how she went from height snob (over 6' please) to falling for a short king.


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-thirties, and chang...

Mark as Played
September 18, 2024 15 mins

FLOPB dating podcast is back after a summer break! On this week's episode, Kelly flips the script. Instead of another tale about a random dude who ruined her shot at love, this time SHE's the asshole.


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her...

Mark as Played
July 17, 2024 12 mins

Have you ever been on a date that you couldn't wait to be over, only to find out your date was SUPER into it? In this episode of the FLOPB dating pod, Kelly talks about the many times this has happened to her, and her theory as to what the F is happening...


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves...

Mark as Played

On this episode of the FLOPB dating pod, Kelly shares - in great detail - the creepiest date she ever went on. Buckle up, it gets très icky.


SHOW NOTES

For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-thirties, and changes her life forever.

Kelly Shanley is ...

Mark as Played
June 19, 2024 11 mins

This week on FLOPB dating pod, Kelly's date goes wrong in more ways than one. You can pick your favorite.


SHOW NOTES

For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-thirties, and changes her life forever.

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic, writer, and actor...

Mark as Played
June 6, 2024 9 mins

This week on the FLOPB dating podcast, Kelly shares the angst of being a late bloomer as well as the perks.


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-thirties, and changes her life forever.

Kelly Shanley is a standup comic, writer, and act...

Mark as Played

In this episode of the FLOPB Dating pod, Kelly shares one of her all time (least) favorite date disasters. The kind that's so bad it's good. So many cringey moments not even fro-yo could save it.


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-...

Mark as Played
May 9, 2024 8 mins

On this episode of the FLOPB dating podcast, there was a time when Kelly thought being an independent woman meant not having any needs. At least none that she couldn't take care of herself. No reason to bother her romantic partner with something as inconvenient as her needs! She was wrong...


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette ...

Mark as Played
April 24, 2024 12 mins

On this edition of FLOPB dating pod, Kelly recounts the time she got catfished, and the unexpected lesson she learned from it.


SHOW NOTES: For Love or Peanut Butter (FLOPB) is a true life, humorous dating column turned podcast in which a seemingly eligible bachelorette who can’t find love finally delves into the WHY and the HOW she has remained single into her mid-thirties, and changes her life forever.

Kelly Shanley is a standup co...

Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    United States of Kennedy is a podcast about our cultural fascination with the Kennedy dynasty. Every week, hosts Lyra Smith and George Civeris go into one aspect of the Kennedy story.

    Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

    Stuff You Should Know

    If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.

    The Breakfast Club

    The World's Most Dangerous Morning Show, The Breakfast Club, With DJ Envy And Charlamagne Tha God!

    24/7 News: The Latest

    The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.