Ryan Bridge: What is wrong with our state run services?

Health New Zealand is the country's largest organisation by far, it employs more than 80,000 people. 

Roughly the same number of teachers are employed by state schools in our education system, and these numbers dwarf any private enterprise that's currently operating here. 

Fletcher buildings has about 18,000 staff, Woolworths about 18,000, Fonterra about 16,000, the Warehouse in New Zealand, Kmart, they're up there too. 

Here's a question for you: which of these organisations provides a quality or even adequate service to us? 

When a private airline says they'll fly you somewhere on a certain date at a certain time, it generally happens. When you go to the supermarket, you generally know you can reliably leave with some milk and some bread in your hand. 

And when you go to Kmart, are you ever told you must wait 18 months for that $12 lamp that you've been eyeing up in the latest catalogue? No. 

So why does this happen with our healthcare system? 

Why are we constantly told you must wait, you must line up. It's never good enough. 

Is there a reason we have students failing exams, teacher shortages, low pay, hospital wait times, and a lack of access to quality care? 

Is the reason for this because they're all run by the state? 

I know, big question for a Tuesday. 

The workforces are never happy, but they heavily unionised too. Is that part of the problem or is that an attempt at a solution? 

Don't get me wrong, big Corporates have their own issues. We hate to see them profit and I don't imagine that we would stomach big profits off our kids' education or grandma's hip replacement. We consider these things to be basics, right? 

International examples of privatised healthcare don't exactly scream success, good day America, but if we're paying taxes, and an adequate service for basic needs is not being provided, is it not fair to ask whether the fact that they're public entities might just be part of the problem? 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Health New Zealand is the country's largest organization by far.
It employs more than eighty thousand people. Roughly the same
number of teachers are employed by state schools in our
education system. And these numbers dwarf any private enterprise that's
currently operating here. Fletcher Building's got about eighteen thousand staff,
will worse about eighteen thousand, Fonterra about sixteen thousand. The

(00:21):
warehouse in New Zealand, Kmart they're up there too. Here's
a question for you, which of these organizations provides a
quality or even adequate service to us. When a private
airline says they'll fly you somewhere on a certain date
at a certain time, it generally happens. When you go
to the supermarket, you generally know you can reliably leave

(00:41):
with some milk and some bread in your hand. And
when you go to kmart, are you ever told you
must wait eighteen months for that twelve dollars lamp that
you've been eyeing up in the latest catalog? No? So,
why does this happen with our healthcare system? Why are
we constantly told you must wait, you must line up.
It's never good enough? Is there a we have students
failing exams, teacher shortages, low pay, hospital wait times, and

(01:05):
a lack of access to quality care. Is the reason
for this because they're all run by the state. I know,
big question for a Tuesday Ryan settled down. The workforces
are never happy, but they heavily unionize too. Is that
part of the problem or is that an attempt at
a solution. Don't get me wrong, Big corporates have their
own issues. We hate to see them profit, and I

(01:28):
don't imagine that we would stomach big profits off our kids'
education or grandma's hip replacement. We consider these things to
be basics, right, and international examples of privatized healthcare don't
exactly scream success. Get America. But if we're paying taxes,
an adequate service for basic needs is not being provided.

(01:51):
Is it not fair to ask whether the fact that
their public entities might just be part of the problem.
For more from News Talks, that'd be us live on
air or online, and keep our shows with you wherever
you go with our podcasts on iHeartRadio.