Perspective with Heather du Plessis-Allan: Our kids' education is too important to muck around

You can't accuse Erica Stanford of mucking around, can you?

NCEA is gone. Marks out of 100 are back, grades from A to E are back, needing to pass 4 subjects at least in order to get the qualification is back.

Now, how long have we been talking about the need to do this? About the fact that NCEA is rubbish, that it's been gamed, that it's not respected by employers, that it's not understood by parents? How long have we talked about this? 

And then within 18 months of Erica Stanford taking over the education portfolio, the changes are made.

 This is absolutely, by the way, the right thing to do. Nowhere, in none of the assessments of what's happening at NCEA Level 1, 2 or 3, do you hear anyone say - hey, you know what, this is a good system. It's always criticism.

The ERA had a look at NCEA Level 1 last year and they found such big problems with that they recommended getting rid of it.

NZQA last year found only half of year 12 students actually finished 3 full subjects. They didn't even get to do 3 full subjects, but they somehow managed to pass NCEA.

NZCER found that learning was not the focus of school at NCEA level anymore, assessment was.

The OECD two years ago found what we always know is going on lately and our ability to read, write and do maths was slipping. It had now fallen below the OECD average.

The NZQA Insights paper found a huge number of kids got Level 3 because it's easy, but UE, the old equivalent, they couldn't get it because it's not easy. 

Now, none of this is news to us, right? Some of these reports actually date back to 2018, 7 years ago. Yet NCEA hasn't been scrapped until now.

Now, this is brave, because any change this big is brave, but especially, it's brave right now at a time when secondary school teachers are already dealing with a lot.

They have a curriculum refresh on the go. They've got new compulsory exams already now, they've got this. They are busy and they're about to get busier.

And while I feel for them, and I do, our kids are too important and their education is too important to muck around.

LISTEN ABOVE

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Well, jeez, you can't accuse Erica Stamford of mucking around,
can you. NCIA is gone marks out of one hundred
to back grades from A to ear back, needing to
pass full subjects at least in order to get the
qualification is back. Now, how long have we been talking
about the need to do this, about the fact that
NCA is rubbish, that it's being gamed, that it's not
respected by employers, that it's not understood by parents. How

(00:21):
long have we talked about this? And then within eighteen
months of Erica stand for taking over the education portfolio,
the changes are made. This is absolutely, by the way,
the right thing to do. Nowhere, in none of the
assessments of what's happening at NCAA Level one, two or
three do you hear anyone say, hey, you know what,
this is a good system. It's always criticism. The era

(00:42):
I had a look at NCAA Level one last year.
They found such big problems so that they recommended getting
rid of it. The NZQA last year found only half
of year twelve students actually finished three full subjects. They
didn't even get to do three full subjects. Sell somehow
managed to pass the NCA NZCER found that learning was
not the focus of school at NCEEA level more a

(01:04):
level anymore assessment was the OECD two years ago found
what we always know is going on lately, our ability
to read write in maths was slipping at it now
fallen below the OECD average. The NZQA Insights paper found
a huge number of kids got level three because it's easy,
but ue the old equivalent couldn't get it because it's
not easy. Now none of this is news to us

(01:26):
right Some of these reports actually date back to twenty eighteen,
seven years ago, yet NCEEA hasn't been scrapped until now.
Now this is brave because any change this speak is brave.
But especially it's brave right now at a time when
secondary school teachers are already dealing with a lot. They
have a curriculum refresh on the go, they've got new
compulsory exams already now they've got this. They are busy,

(01:47):
and they're about to get busier. And while I feel
for them, and I do, our kids are too important
and their education is too important to muck around. For
more from Heather du Class Allen Drive listen live to
news talks that'd be from four pm weekdays, or follow
the podcast on iHeartRadio