Mike's Minute: Is being Trump-like still good for politics?

For a while there being a tough guy was good for your credibility. 

Look at Victor Orban, Javier Milei and Nayib Bukele. They all revelled, and succeeded, at the polls with their macho, Trump-esque persona. 

The world was moving away from "Me Too" and progressivism. There has been a very distinct move to conservatism, especially in parts of Europe. 

Being like Trump was, more often than not, good for your political aspirations. 

Peter Dutton had a touch of that, but sadly in the length of an Australian campaign it's all changed. The more he has looked like Trump, talked about Trump, and promised policy that sounded like Trump, the worse it has got. 

Chances are by Saturday night, he will be a loser. 

In the meantime, in Canada, who are voting now, the reason Mark Carney is in the lead is twofold. 

1) The bloke who ran the place before him was a progressive sap and was a victim of the movement against the left. But he also had been there a decade, and his clock had run out. 

2) His replacement has made much ground in the new-found vein of political success of looking not at all like Trump, but being tough enough to stand up to him. 

Mark Carney will most likely win today and if he does, the fortunes of his Liberal Party will be one for the ages. 

The same anger, frustration and impatience that led Trump to victory over a hapless socialist, should have played out the same way —and was going to play out the same way— north of the border. 

Yet in the space of a couple of months, the entire scenario has been tipped on its head. 

Looking like Trump, like Pierre Poilievre and the Conservatives do, is no longer currency. It's bad news. 

They have tried desperately to direct the campaign towards the issues that had Canadians so upset for the past ten years; cost of living, cost of housing, and jobs. 

But the tariffs and Trump and his insults have fired them up and off into a new direction, which is hating on America. Carney and the Liberals have seen it, grabbed it and run with it. 

The last polls have a 3%-ish point gap to them. The Liberals have come back from 20 points down, it's astonishing. 

Let's do the counting. But if they win, what's it say about the distaste for Trump? What's it say about a single-issue campaign? 

And will there have ever been a bigger victory snatched from the jaws of defeat? 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
To tell you what. For a while there, being a
tough guy was good for the old cred, wasn't it.
Victor Orbarr, mister Malay, mister p Carly all reveled and
succeeded at the polls and their macho Trump esque persona.
The world was moving away from me too and progressivism
that had been a very distinct move to conservatism, especially
in parts of Europe. Being like Trump was more often
than not good for your political aspirations. Peter Dutton had

(00:22):
a touch of that, but sadly, in the length of
an Australian campaign, it's all changed. The Maorreys looked like Trump,
talked like Trump, promise policy that sounded like Trump. The
worse it's got chances are by Saturday night he'll be
a loser. Meantime, in Canada, who were voting as we speak.
The reason mister Carney's in the lead is twofold one.
The bloker ran the place before him, was a progressive
SAP and was the victim of a movement against the left,

(00:45):
but also being there for a decade and his clock
had basically run out but two his replacement has made
much ground in the new found vein of political success,
looking not at all like Trump, but being tough enough
to stand up to him. Mark Carney will most likely
wintered up, and if he does, the fortunes of his
Liberal party will be one for the ages. The same anger, frustration,

(01:05):
and impatience that led Trump to victory over a hapless
socialist should have played out the same way was going
to play out the same way north of the border,
and yet in the space of a couple of months,
the entire scenario has been tipped on its head. Looking
like Trump. Like polyev and the Conservatives do is no
longer currency. It's bad news. They've tried desperately to direct
the campaign towards the issues that had Canadians so upset

(01:28):
for the past ten years, cost of living, cost of housing, jobs,
but the tariffs and Trump and his insults have fired
them up and often to a new direction, hating on America.
Carnie and the Liberals have seen it, grabbed it, run
with it. The last poll had a three ish point
gap to them. They've come back from twenty points down.

(01:50):
It's astonishing. I mean, let's do the counting later today.
But if they win, what's it say about the distaste
for Trump? What's it say about a single issue campaign?
And will there have ever been a bigger victory? Snatched
from the jaws of defeat. For more from the Mic
Asking Breakfast, listen live to News Talks at B from
six am weekdays, or follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.