Jenee Tibshraeny: NZ Herald Wellington business editor on the concerns surrounding new KiwiSaver changes

There are fears Finance Minister Nicola Willis is opening a can of worms by potentially allowing young farmers to dip into their KiwiSavers to buy farms.

She explained she was seeking advice from the IRD on the matter, which is yet to be considered by Cabinet.

NZ Herald Wellington business editor Jenee Tibshraeny weighed in on the debate.

LISTEN ABOVE

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Heather Duplicy, Ellen, I Heather. In addition to attracting the
international foreign home buyers, the fifth rules that you've previously discussed,
the FAA rules still outstanding putting foreigners off coming to
New Zealand. Michael, thank you that those rules are the
ones about how long you need to stay in the
country or not stay in the country in order to
avoid certain taxes and stuff. It's all the shambles by
the looks of things. Eighteen past six now there are

(00:21):
fears that Finance Minister Nikola Willis might be opening a
can of worms if she lets young farmers withdraw their
kei we saver funds to buy a farm. Gr Native
Traney is The Herald's Wellington Business editor. Hey, Youna, Hey,
what's the problem?

Speaker 2 (00:35):
Well, you know, if you say that you can dip
into your kei we saver to buy a farm, then
where does it stop. Can you dip into your key
saver to buy a business, or to buy cryptocurrency, or
to buy art or whatever else you think might help
set you up for your retirement? I mean, arguably already
by allowing people to use their Kiwi saver to buy

(00:56):
a house first home, you know, that that is a
controversial thing. But if you start allowing farms, then where
does it stop.

Speaker 1 (01:06):
So could we say, okay, I mean I agree with
the distinction that's being made here because I think when
you start getting into buying herds and flocks and stuff
like that, then it's basically why don't you buy your
first set of tools or your coffee shop or whatever.
But could you say a farm is like a house
because you can live on it.

Speaker 2 (01:23):
Well, I guess you could. But then you'd say, well,
if you want to live on the farm, then you
could use the exemption that exists, which says you can
use your key we sabor to buy your first home.

Speaker 1 (01:34):
So you can't live in that first home. You can't
live in it yet because you're living on somebody else's
farm and working that FuMB Well.

Speaker 2 (01:41):
You know that's true. I mean. The other thing is
like if I have to live in Wellington for my work,
but I want to buy a house in Auckland, then
then that's also a problem. Like if you need to
be here for work but you want to buy your
house there, then you know, then that's a problem. So
that's just how it works under the rules. You know,
I just wonder.

Speaker 1 (01:59):
If that potentially the thing that needs to be eased
up a little bit, that you can live wherever you want,
but your first home, wherever it is, you're able to
use key we say before.

Speaker 2 (02:10):
You know, look, as someone in that generation that has
struggled to get into property, you know, it's it's kind
of galling when they put these rules around things. But
I think the concern is that if you allow people
to buy houses they don't live in, then that's an
investment property. And and you know, do we want to
be encouraging people to use their QB savers for investment

(02:33):
property or do we want to help them use their
KB savers just to put a roof over their heads?
But I think this is the exact sort of debate
you know that would that the first home exemption has created,
but if you extend it, then it just sort of
exacerbates that debate. Now that you know that there might
be good merit and and you know, the farmers would say,

(02:53):
we're actually it's much better for us to invest in
a farm than have our money tied up in the
share market, you know, support American companies. That might be true,
but the issue is here that if you tinker with
Kiwi Save It, which is meant to be a really
stable scheme. You know, it has to be stable because
we're investing it in the long term. If you tinker

(03:15):
with it too much, people stop trusting it, and if
they stop trusting it, they don't want to invest through it.
So I think that's kind of one of the most
compelling arguments that people who don't like this idea have made.

Speaker 1 (03:27):
Yeah, hey, thank you, Jane, I really appreciate it. Janejab traini,
the Herald's Wellington Business editor.

Speaker 2 (03:31):
For more from Heather Duplessy Allen Drive, listen live to
news talks they'd be from four pm weekdays, or follow
the podcast on iHeartRadio