Perspective with Heather du Plessis-Allan: Who knows what World Rugby can do?

Well it's fair to say World Rugby's copping it today, even more so than yesterday.

This is following the death of Shane Christie, the former Highlander who had the headaches and the memory loss and all those other symptoms that were consistent with CTE from too many head knocks.

A former Wales #8 with early onset dementia, Alex Popham, has gone straight to World Rugby and the All Blacks' Twitter accounts and told them they've got blood on their hands. 

And our very own Scotty Stevenson has written a piece saying it's time to stop spending money on PR - this is obviously for rugby - and start spending money on helping the former players with these symptoms.

Absolutely. I mean, there is no doubt that World Rugby could be doing more, right?

The stand down period for a professional rugby player for a suspected concussion is - what do you think?

12 days. That's ridiculous. 

In boxing, it's 30 days. And if they actually lose consciousness and they know they've lost consciousness, it could be anywhere from 6 months up that they're forced to stand down.

I think we've all seen pretty gnarly cases of head knocks recently or players talking about migraines over the summer period, only for them to be back on the field when they, if you were being careful, should not be back on the field.

And who knows what World Rugby will be forced to do once these lawsuits are successful.

But here's the thing - our ability to keep blaming the rugby bosses is going to run out, if it hasn't already. No player in 2025 can blame World Rugby if they end up with these symptoms in years to come.

No one playing rugby in 2025 doesn't know that if you take repeated knocks to the head, you are opening yourself up to future problems. We know that.

In fact, we already knew it when Shane Christie was playing professionally, even if we didn't know it as widely as we do today.

It is terrible that this may be the thing that has happened to him and it is terrible that it is undoubtedly happening to rugby players playing today, but personal responsibility is now very much in play here.

LISTEN ABOVE

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Well, it's fair to say World rugby's copping it today
a even more so than yesterday. This is following the
death of Shane Christy, the former Highlander who had the
headaches and the memory loss and all those other symptoms
that were consistent with CTE from too many head knocks.
A former Wales number eight with early on set dementia,
Alex Popham, has gone straight to World Rugby and the
All Blacks as Twitter accounts and told them they've got

(00:20):
blood on their hands, and our very own Scotti Stevenson
has written a piece saying it's time to stop spending
money on PR. This is obviously for rugby, time to
stop spending money on PR and start spending money on
helping the former players with these symptoms. Absolutely, I mean,
there is no doubt that World Rugby could be doing
more right. The standdown period for a professional rugby player
for a suspected concussion is, what do you think, twelve

(00:41):
days It's that's ridiculous, twelve days, twelve days In boxing,
it's thirty days. And if they actually lose consciousness and
they know they've lost consciousness, it could be anywhere from
six months up that they're forced to stand down. I
think we've all seen pretty gnarly cases of head knocks recently,
or players talking about morains over the summer period, only
for them to be back on the field when they,

(01:03):
if you were being careful, should not be back on
the field. And who knows what World Rugby will be
forced to do once these lawsuits are successful. But here's
the thing. Our ability to keep blaming that the rugby
bosses is going to run out if it hasn't already.
No player in twenty twenty five can blame World Rugby
if they end up with these symptoms in years to come.
No one playing rugby in twenty twenty five doesn't know

(01:23):
that if you take repeated knocks to the head, you
are opening yourself up to future problems. We know that.
In fact, we already knew it when Shane Christy was
playing professionally, even if we didn't know it as widely
as we do today. It is terrible that this may
be the thing that has happened to him. It is
terrible that it is undoubtedly happening to rugby players playing today.
But personal responsibility is now very much in play. Here

(01:46):
for more from Heather Duplessy Allen Drive. Listen live to
news talks it'd be from four pm weekdays, or follow
the podcast on iHeartRadio