Perspective with Ryan Bridge: Aren't children allowed their own political views?

So the teacher's union is warning about a rising tide of extremism in our schools.

I've read the story - what's the actual problem? That's what I'm trying to figure out here today.

Apparently, some kids say they're 'Trump Boys' - i.e. like a majority of Americans, a few kids here support the Republican party or MAGA movement.

The other problem apparently is some school girls saying they want to be trad-wives, or traditional wives - to have children and stay at home to raise them.

Now, that's about as much detail as I could get from this particular story. And the moral of this was - the Government needs to take action on this, according to the unions.

Here's the problem - children are allowed to have political views and societal views of their own and teachers are not there to police politics.

Your job is apolitical, and we need to encourage critical thinking, not legislate against it.

There will be people who read that story and think: here we go again with the brainwashing thing. Your job is education, not indoctrination.

The reality is, not all girls will go on to be Reserve Bank Governors and not all boys will grow up to Reserve Bank Governors, either.

Not all boys will grow up to marry women… hello! 

Everyone's different, that's my point.

But you can’t embrace kids changing genders with gay abandon then demand state intervention when a girl says she wants to get married and have kids.

I'm no conservative. Far from it. But I do hear a lot from parents who've lost faith in the education system, or at least some teachers within it.

If a girl wants to grow up to be a mum, is that radical? Or is that her choice? And if a kid wants to support Donald Trump, is that radical, or is that a choice?

Should they be branded an extremist for holding those views, or should those views be used as a springboard for a healthy debate about society?

Could this not be an opportunity to introduce and encourage critical thinking in young people?

Obviously, if there are specific misogynistic comments being made, then they should be dealt with through a disciplinary process.

But the problem with today's story is that they don't appear to be any examples of that actually happening.

I do not agree with the views these kids hold, but does that mean they shouldn't be able to hold them?

LISTEN ABOVE

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
The teachers' unions warning about a rising tide of extremism
in our schools. Read the story. What's the actual problem?
That's what I'm trying to figure out today. Apparently some
kids say the Trump boys, I like a majority of Americans.
Presumably a few kids here support the Republican Party or
the Mega Movement. The other problem apparently some schoolgirls say

(00:20):
they want to be traad wives, which means traditional wives.
I have children, stay at home and raise them. Now,
that's about as much detail as I could glean from
this particular story that was in the news today and
is doing the rounds on social media, and the moral
of the story was from the unions. The government needs
to take action on this. Here's the problem. Children are

(00:42):
allowed to have political views, they are allowed to have
societal views. Teachers are not there to police politics. Your
job is apolitical, and we need to encourage critical thinking,
not legislate against it. There will be people who read
that story and think, here we go again with the
brainwashing thing. You know, your job is education, not indoctrination.

(01:04):
The reality is not all girls will go on to
be the Reserve Bank governor, nor will all boys. Not
all boys will grow up to marry women. Hello, everyone's different,
is my point. But you can't embrace kids changing genders
and then demand state and divention when a girl says
she wants to get married and have kids. I'm no conservative,

(01:28):
far from it, but I do hear from a lot
of parents who've kind of feel like they've lost faith
in the education system, or at least some teachers within it.
If a girl wants to grow up to be a mum,
is that radical or is that choice? If a kid
wants to support Donald Trump? Is that radical? Or is

(01:49):
that choice? Should they be branded an extremist for holding
those views or should those views be used as a
springboard for a healthy debate about society. Could this not
be an opportunity to introduce and encourage some critical thinking
in our young people. For more from Heather Duplessy Allen Drive,

(02:10):
listen live to news talks. It'd be from four pm weekdays,
or follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.